Putting my toys back in the box (Patreon)
Content
Written by Nathan Ditum
Hello dear and excellent patrons, and welcome to the ninth edition of the esteemed Civilian Observer, newsletter of record pertaining to the world of film and fandom for, well, the last eight months.
For a man now undeniably in his mid-forties, the subject of this month's newsletter is the problematic urtext of modern fandom. The first love, the cruellest heartbreak, the mention-of-your-mother-in-a-therapy-session (or dad, whatever, YOU DON’T KNOW ME). Yeah it’s fucking Star Wars.
You know, I wasn’t ever planning to trace my history with Star Wars on the podcast but you get to a certain age and it just starts happening, sometimes in public. Like this.
Star Wars was my earliest film love. We moved out of London when I was five so my parents could buy a house (fans of my many mentions of the Medway towns - there are dozens of us - this is the move that brought me there). Every weekend we’d drive the short journey back to London to see family, my mum’s mum on Saturdays, my dad’s mum on Sundays. My dad’s mum - Nana to me - had a top-loading VCR and a handful of off-the-air recordings on stickered blank tapes, including Star Wars.
These days you can google the air dates of films like Star Wars, which was shown on ITV for the first time on the 24th of October 1982 (five years after its cinema release, when moviegoing meant something very different). It was shown again in September 1983, then on the 30th of December 1984, and then the 1st of January 1987 and 1988 - a staple of the festive line-up.
It’s strange to think of the scarcity of these showings, just five times across the decade, five opportunities to capture the film on video (it wasn’t available to buy on VHS for years after that original broadcast). My dad’s family were unusually interested in film and theatre, and it’s easy to imagine them scouring the TV Times for listings, being ready to hit record as transmission started. Although it was quite hard to miss - as a sign of how big a deal a premiere like this was, the TV Times did a Star Wars-themed issue, packed with pages of fresh coverage of the half decade-old film, which is hard to imagine in today’s speedy, saturated entertainment culture. In fact you can see on the cover below that this also happened to be the week that Channel 4 launched. There were only three channels in the UK when Star Wars was first transmitted, and, after a post-film evening in the company of Clive James and Melvyn Bragg, the station simply closed down at twenty past midnight, when we should all be in bed anyway. (Also excuse me as I revel in the glamour of a competition giving readers the chance to win one of five Ford Sierras).
Anyway, I digress. My purpose in tracking these air dates down was to see if I could figure out the exact moment the recording that I remember watching every weekend was snatched from the airwaves. I’m guessing, but 1984 or 1987 seem likely - to have a machine in 1982 or 1983 would have been unusually expensive, but theirs was a top-loading unit, which were phased out in the mid-to-late ‘80s. Either way, I watched the film every weekend, having to be dragged away for lunch (“Luke and Leia need their lunch too”), and having the music, emotion, and spectacle of Star Wars imprinted on me before I was old enough to understand anything past the blazing good versus bad of it all. This is the title card they showed at every ad break, an image I’ve not seen for 35 years but that’s familiar to me on a hard to describe, foundational level. 
So that’s where it began. It continued with Star Wars toys (lots has been written about them - they were simply the perfect way to extend the world in perpetuity in the boundless realm of childhood imagination) and, eventually, in The Empire Strikes Back (first shown Christmas Day 1988) and The Return Of The Jedi (first shown Boxing Day 1989). I know these films inside out, but I can’t as easily say when and where I watched them, as by this time already I was leaving that particularly imprintable phase of childhood, and already - at nine, ten years old - recording things myself and watching at home.
From our age of speed and saturation, what’s perhaps most astonishing is how the clamour, attention, and devotion surrounding a fictional world like Star Wars can be sustained for more than a decade by just three films. I write this while wondering how to negotiate my take on what came next - the return of Star Wars in the 1990s (excitement at the special editions, slow burn devastation at the prequels, confoundment at yet more special editioning), the rise of fan culture in the 2000s, the shadow of toxic entitlement, and, most recently and above all, the quick and vast expansion of the Star Wars universe in the streaming era.
Disney’s purchase of Star Wars has led to… loads of fucking Star Wars. It can’t all be perfect. It can’t all be good. The journey of this fan has been a slow letting go - distancing myself, though I understand their pricks of disappointment, from the audience so often at war with the thing they love. Understanding why Star Wars is and was important to me (those weekends at my Nana’s Clapham flat, the clunk of the top loading hinge) and how that won’t ever change, while accepting that I’m going to enjoy some of the rapid and ready supply of new stories in the world, and not others. It’s difficult to know how much of this is a result of me becoming incredibly wise and brilliant, and how much is just growing the fuck up.
So my new approach is to embrace the positive, and pass over the negative. Did I enjoy the Obi Wan series? Not really, but the “You didn’t kill Anakin Skywalker, I did” scene gets inside the Vader character in a complex way that I’m glad exists. Did I like the sequel films? In the end they didn’t really go anywhere, but the surging joy I felt watching Harrison Ford, the young new cast, and hearing John Williams’ Rey’s Theme in The Force Awakens was real and lasting. Did I want to set fire to the elephant kid in Skeleton Crew? Yes I did. And I enjoyed that feeling.
In short, I’ve gotten used to not expecting the world of Star Wars. It doesn’t fucking owe me anything, and so few things in life are perfect. Enjoy the good. Enjoy that we get more of this thing. This is how I felt about Rogue One, too. Some refreshing moral ambiguity - some freshness to the idea of Rebellion - followed up with some extraordinary action, if peppered with clanging digital resurrections (part of a fetishisation of known figures and tokens I struggle with) and a neatness that bordered on smug.
All of which - ALL OF WHICH - is to set the scene for what this newsletter is really about, which is how much I’ve enjoyed Andor. The second season finished recently, released over the course of a month in four batches of three-episode drops. After a three year gap, it followed up a wonderful first season with that rarest of things in the Star Wars universe - an ending, a permanent conclusion for a group of characters and a set of ideas that the show had conjured into being. It also slid, precision tool-like, into its progenitor material in Rogue One, itself built to dock urgently and immediately into the start of 1977’s Star Wars.
I have hundreds and hundreds of things to say about Andor, but also basically two things.
One - I love that a show, any show, has excited and interested me enough to give me the kind of viewing and post-viewing experience I’ve had over the last couple of months. The anticipation of release day. The weekly cycle of conversation and observation. The afterglow, post-conclusion, of fan discussion and postmortem. The quality of these discussions is a testament to Andor’s own quality - not so much about picking holes, posing childish “what ifs”, or pointing in blank recognition at a familiar droid or blaster, but highlighting performances, smartly drawing together parallel or contrasting moments from across the series to explore themes and ideas, revelling and celebrating the depth and quality of the work on display.
On the pod I often say that the kind of criticism I’m interested in reading is the kind that makes a film or show better - an appreciation rather than a takedown, a key to more understanding and enjoyment. Andor’s community is full of this, and I’ve also enjoyed finding it from the eloquent interviews with the production team of the show (Jeff Goldsmith’s Q&A podcast has done a multipart interview series with Andor’s writing team which I inhaled, and would recommend to anyone who enjoyed the series. Start here).
And related to the above, the second thing I have to say is - I love that the Star Wars world has generated a show that is so good, so sensitive and intelligent in a particular way, that it makes the rest of Star Wars better. I don’t think this was the plan - I’m not sure you can plan for that - but it’s the result of a way of working and a quality of execution that elevates and strengthens the ideas in the world itself. A lot (but not all) of this can be summed up by something Tony Gilroy, Andor’s creator and showrunner, told his writing team during production: to “leave more toys in the box than you found when you got there”. Basically, leave Star Wars richer for your contribution than poorer, don’t exploit familiar symbols and characters for cheap wins, create new moments and touchpoints where possible. It’s a line in such sharp contrast, when you consider it, to the general approach of much new Star Wars, and it basically boils down to the simple premise that what you’re making should be worthy of existing because it’s good, not because it’s part of an existing world.
Before I finished Andor, I’d seen Rogue One just the once, at the cinema. I realised during a rewatch of season one (at the end of 2024, after season two was confirmed for a 2025 release) how excited - and nervous - I was to rewatch the film after the show had concluded. Heightening the anticipation was the fact my wife - not a Star Wars fan - had started watching Andor during this second viewing, and was all fucking in. She had no idea what would happen to these characters, how Rogue One fit into the Star Wars world, anything. She was just hooked on some good fucking television. And watching in proximity to her naivety gave a sharpness to both this revisit of season one, and our joint watch of season two. A rewatch of Rogue One, with borrowed fresh eyes from my wife and 24 episodes of extraordinary backstory, became a highly anticipated event, and as far as I’m concerned, it absolutely delivered.
Rogue One wasn’t suddenly a different movie. But it was a better one. Diego Luna’s support character suddenly arrived in every scene with the weight of hours - years - of ambivalence, struggle, and determination. Where Rogue One’s rightful, hopeful protagonist Jin Urso stood uncomplicatedly centre stage in several scenes on a first viewing, now Cassian counterbalanced those scenes with a weary, earned skepticism, carrying the scars of what it took to get the Rebellion this far, and a doomed sense of what kind of effort will get it over the line. It’s the same film - but it’s better.
And the same goes for Star Wars (A New Hope, to all you kids). Community memes poked fun at the grandstanding medal ceremony at the end of the film in light of Andor’s grounded politics. But Andor also includes a precedent - Gold Squadron given the credit for Cassian’s rescue of Mon Mothma - that establishes this kind of PR win as a necessity of winning the wider war. It doesn’t undermine the Force, the idea of heroes, the hope and optimism of George Lucas’ film. It just gives us some more ways of thinking about it. More toys in the box.
A lot of people praising Andor say “we’ve been waiting for this” or “Star Wars is back”, suggesting that there’s a right and wrong way to tell stories in this universe that means so much to so many. I don’t like that way of looking at it. I’m as grateful as anyone that Andor exists, and I think it’s a testament to rigour and excellence in storytelling. But almost every part of the Star Wars world means something to someone - this is just the part that’s made for me. And not me at 5 or 6, gulping down Star Wars for the first time. But me now - 40something, liberal, media literate, TV binging, fandom-adjacent. This isn't the Star Wars, it’s just - right now - my Star Wars. It takes something I love - the raw material of overworked ideas and images - and moulds it into something new, something that sparks and conducts ideas like electricity. And just like magic, it makes me feel like a kid again.
Files
Previews only