Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Files

mighty nein ep 5 pat.mp4

Shared with Dropbox

Comments

Kenju Storm

No yeah I agree with you on Caleb. I understand he went through manipulation and such, but for it to be enough that you unquestioningly murder your parents? Burn them to death slowly? It's hard for me to empathize with that. I don't vibe with the side of the fandom that's all "oh you poor baby" over this. They had some balls doing it this way because he wasn't tricked into doing this and they didn't give him an ultimatum like "oh if you don't kill your parents, then this terrible thing is going to happen.". Nope none of that. They just had Trent tell Caleb to kill his own parents because they're rebels and he did it without putting up a fight. He should take accountability for that but this is definitely the more interesting route to go.

James Theriault

I fully agree “ I was following orders” is not an acceptable excuse especially when Caleb wasn’t given an ultimatum or put under any kind of duress. Story wise though I love that choice because it really differentiates The Mighty Nein from LOVM by changing the setting to be more morally grey.

Cephandrius

You are definitely right about Caleb yes its brainwashing and he was groomed as a child soldier but nobody hates Caleb more than himself. There is no real excuse for his actions and he knows it too.

demonic-myst

what he summoned was a familair a fey spirit that can shapeshift it takles the form of his cat to comfort him

demonic-myst

usy for more power vulstruker arelike secret police they arested and executed anyone who betrayed the empire

demonic-myst

in the campaign he brainwashed the three with magic to believe theire parents were traitors so no they not real traitors itd a poweer play he is a sociopath trying make them see him as a father figur so they will allways be loyal they were 17 when they burned the house down

Louie_91-Z28

Wtf? how brainwashed must one be to do something like this? This takes it to a different level. There's no excuse, I don't even understand how one could defend this.

Reese esponge

Everyone has their own opinion id if you don't like it what someone has to say who cares it's just a tv show.

IAmABacon

My view of Caleb's choice is that he was brainwashed for years and years, being told how important it is to work for the empire. He didn't grow up with access to the internet and other perspectives like us. He was just a lil farmboy that likely knew nothing about psychology, as he'd have no tv shows/films/news/psychologists to tell him about it. I personally also think I'd resist brainwashing like that, but I seen a lot of information about that, which Caleb never had access to. When we see him go to his parents, we do not see the journey there, so we can't say that he didn't ask questions. My assumption is that he built it up in his head that they were evil traitors and detached himself from them mentally; but then it really kicks in what he's done to people he loves and he breaks down. Im not necessarily "defending him", as what he did was severely messed up; but I think saying everyone should have the "question everything" philosophy is just unreasonable, as you need prior knowledge that people will be willing to manipulate you.

IAmABacon

This might come into play in the series, so this is a potential spoiler that you shouldn't be sharing until after the series once we know if it's been changed