Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

rockstar showdown

Files

Comments

Lily Rose

yall let these damn incels bully yall into removing ATLA from the line up? who cares if it’s not well liked? i still would’ve like to see your reaction to a show YOU STARTED

Alex Omega

Honestly, I'm not a fan of this version of Bard's Lament compared to the original. The original Bard's Lament, if they had done it right, should have been the Season 3 finale, especially if they did it the same way. Scanlan and Kaylie left the group after he revealed his anger toward them and all of the emotion he held back. This season could have more moments of the group exploring how they treated Scanlan in the past, like in the original sprinkle throughout this season until their reunion. I'm probably the only one who feels this way because I have watched Critical Role since the very first episode on Geek & Sundry.

Mervyn Larrier

Incels? Girl please stop. They didn't even like it much

I'Zanay Rogers

Ahhhhhh!!! This was the BEST episode EVER!! I absolutely LOVE musicals!! Now it's time to watch y'all react to it lolll.

Mervyn Larrier

Like, incels because barely anyone likes the absolute butchery they performed on every last aspect of a beloved series? That makes people incels? Please. Grow up.

Lily Rose

and they should’ve been able to react to the entire thing and make that opinion for themselves… not take the word of you online incels. despite it being “hated” it’s still a trending topic and it wouldn’t have hurt for them to keep it in the line up as a reaction.. especially since they already started it!

Princess Sakura

I don't think you know what an "incel" is

Kermit

It was out of their control. Scanlan's VA was recovering from throat cancer, that's why he abruptly appears just in this episode. The alternative would have been sprinkling in flashbacks of him being silent...which would be weird

Izak

huh? incels? it was removed cause the show is ass

Izak

only gets better from here :)

Lily Rose

@izak yet roshi said it was a great first episode until you incels got in their ear telling them otherwise..

Sam

Loved this episode, glad you guys did too. Scan Man will return, so it's going to be ok

Izak

The bard's lament happened a bit differently in the campaign. It was something that was supposed to happen end of season 3 but they just felt it wouldn't make sense and would be kind of bad to end the season with it if they didn't get a 4th and 5th but it's such big scanlan moment and some of Sam's best work that they had to find a way to include it. The original was also a lot more angry but here it makes sense they changed the emotions to make it more that he was sad. https://youtu.be/N0_Z_qHzS_g?si=TxIT5nWe_P13DGZy Here is the original, there's no spoilers for anything beyond ep 8 in this video but some funny context is that Sam did this, and then he immediately came back with Tary and the cast were so (lovingly) annoyed lmao. Also super funny that Sam had Scanlan's mother killed by a goblin for his backstory and then in campaign 2 ( the mighty nein) he plays a goblin Also 1st 10 minutes of this for the cast reaction to Sam coming back as Tary in the same episode, can watch more, idk if there's spoilers beyond the 1st 11 minutes tho but it's too funny. https://youtu.be/l2Am0zqRJEc?si=xcLnVsM5W8a4GxhD

RedSunCrusher!!!

Actually in their latest stream both Sheera and Roshi enjoy the live action Avatar more than the live action One Piece so I would way they definitely like the show.

Narluga

Scanlan is just fat Elvis XD

Izak

do u know what incel means??? and I didn't say anything to them about the show, i'm just saying it's ass

Adrian Locke

YEAH the reference to Obsession Roshi? 😭😭😭😭

Lily Rose

@izak who cares if it’s “ass”.. a lot of shit they watch is ass… do they ever stop watching it? no. the 2nd season is literally better than the 1st so if they were going to quit they should’ve stopped a quarter into season 1

Bria A.

I've also watched the entire campaign and I actually really appreciate the adaptation for what it is. It makes arguably some more sense as a cohesive TV narrative.

Tbdovan

You do understand they'd never want to do a show that's poorly viewed up on their patreon where 99% of the comments are negative

Tbdovan

This is how Invincible needs to lock in atleast 5 minutes of each episode with the animation.

Kris Barnes

Yes Lupa! Pick of Destiny is a great movie

Lily Rose

@tb the comments shouldn’t have been negative in the first place, it was never that serious.. especially when they themselves were enjoying it

Samuela Shannon

They literally said they really liked the first episode. Yes, they were bullied into not watching the rest of it.

Cleven Anthony

Your definitely not wrong here. It’s not the first time the comments have harassed them into doing something and personally I think they should shut it out. Listening to them robbed the ppl who was interested of being able to see it & for what ? In favor of shows they like. Yall should be ashamed putting down shows other ppl like just cause yall like something else. We’re all subbed and should be able to enjoy what we wanna see regardless if it fits with everyone or not

Sekraan

@RedSuncrusher!!! I mean, the first season of the LA ATLA wasn't bad. The second season is pretty much unwatchable. @Samuela Shannon - you are being dramatic. No one was bullying the trio. People expressed how crap the new season was and they responded to their audience's feedback.

RedSunCrusher!!!

@Sekraan I do agree with you that season 2 sucks that I can definitely agree with. But I do feel bad for the trio because they did like the show I see both sides of the parties. The patrons and the creator's whatever the outcome it's a lose lose situation for either parties depending on what show/movie it is the only good thing that came out of them dropping LA ATLA was Mr. Robot. But I hope that they might come back to watch it or at least watch it on their own time.

PJ Rivera

Dang I can hear the difference in Sam Riegels(Scanlan’s) voice I hope he can recover fully from throat cancer

PJ Rivera

To be fair sam riegel aka scanlan had throat cancer and was recovering so this is the best he could do I’d rather he stay in and recover for a while than hurt himself doing a ton of voice work.

Jonathan Hart

That show was fucking ass. No one wanted to see ts

Jason Marbach

I thought ep 7 was my favorite of the season…then I watched this all-timer. Top 3 or 4 episode of the whole series, for me

Mervyn Larrier

You know this is how they make money, right? Roshi has on many occasions said they work for us and they're not gonna waste their time watching anything we aren't enjoying. Idk if you're new here, but they have forced themselves to continue series that we enjoy but they don't, unless it was really bad. This is how it works here. We're not having a philosophical debate on it. And if you're going to be that rude to them and your fellow patrons because you dislike that, go whine elsewhere

NovaVortex

Lupa calling White haired bro Slash was crazy 🤣

lackingnames

@Kermit What? That has nothing to do with what they said. Scanlan was absent back in the campaign as well, long before the cancer. Him recovering had nothing to do with the ending of last season, nor the diminished version of it we got in this ep. They didn't do it last season because they didnt know if there would be a Season 4. Which imo is a bad reason to just completely change the source material, and then try to shove in a mediocre watered down version of that ending into this episode.

sol jam

I really like when music battle are done well

N

EQUESTRIA GIRLS RAINBOW ROCKS

Hybrid10Prime

Wow, that bard fight was awesome!

HIM

Wow, lol 😆 I just realized how funny it was when Taryon says, "Well, I'm gonna find a spare closet to mope in" just after kissing Pike.

HIM

TS 18:50 es ist Vünter Slaush 🎩🪓🎸

Ayanda Mpofu

I'm just glad we got to see Scanlan again 😁.

Clinton the Bingethinker

Pike’s “I could be a dad” line is funny to me cause her voice actor played Ellie in TLOU games, and Bella Ramsey’s Ellie said “I’m gonna be a dad?” Idk my brain made that connection right away when I heard that line lol

Zuri Young

Bro, the crunching in my ear, I can’t 😖. Love the reaction otherwise

Krohv

Go take your meds femcel

Eric

I love that they got Tom Cardy to play the Dark Bard, that was awesome

Jamaal Ellison

Alright this episode might be my favorite.