Kdrama Poll Round 4 after Kill Me Heal Me: Final Two
- 100 Days of Deception 21
- Love in Disguise 46
We're down to the top two from Round 3: 100 Days of Deception and Love in Disguise. Which one do you want us to react to after Kill Me, Heal Me? Pick one.
I want to clear up what I mean when I describe a show as sad. Everyone has a different idea of what counts as sad, and I have no problem with a show having sadness in it. What I struggle with is SLOWNESS, when the story stops moving and we're left sitting in sadness and despair.
I'll keep using the same examples rather than unnecessarily talking bad about more shows. Mr. Sunshine and Tale of the Nine Tailed had plenty of sad moments. People were lonely, being killed, fighting by themselves, or spending decades searching for love. People cried. Depending on how you read those moments, they can be very sad.
But there was still conflict, momentum, and sophisticated dialogue. Your mind was being tickled. In Mr. Sunshine, even when people were depressed or couldn't be with the person they loved, the dialogue gave you something to think about. Someone could be crying on screen, and you'd still be reflecting on what they said.
My issue is when you get three episodes of people crying with very little story movement or stimulating dialogue. You can spend ten whole minutes watching somebody have a breakdown. I understand that emotional response. It reflects how people behave in real life, but realism alone doesn't necessarily make it entertaining TV.
Those scenes take my energy away. I don't connect with those emotions as strongly as some viewers do, and my crew feels the same way. We end up staring at the screen saying, "Aw, that's sad," without feeling engaged or mentally stimulated.
For a hypothetical example, imagine a high school scene with 17-year-old characters sitting around crying. If the scene offers no sophisticated dialogue or anything else to reflect on, what am I supposed to engage with? You know what I mean? The crying itself isn't enough to hold my attention.
This also connects to how a drama finishes. Sometimes a 16-episode show feels like its main plot is already solved by episode 9 or 10, at least as far as the viewer is concerned. Then it spends the remaining episodes dragging out the ending. The story feels over, but we're still watching people cry and talk about their problems because the show has to reach episode 16.
Mr. Sunshine, True Beauty, and plenty of Chinese dramas are positive examples for me. They have sadness, but each episode has enough story that I don't feel like the drama is already over and just dragging things out.
So this often isn't a problem for me during the first 9 or 10 episodes. It becomes a problem near the end, when there seems to be no more story and the show keeps milking those final episodes. That's what I'm opposing: losing the momentum and meaningful dialogue, then stretching the sadness to fill time.