40 Is the New 30 – Part 7 (Patreon)
Content
Everyone in this story is 18+
-------------Chris’s POV------------
The Frozen Four final at the Xcel Energy Center is electric—twenty-thousand-plus bodies packed in, the air thick with beer fumes, hot dogs, and the metallic bite of fresh ice. The lights are blinding, the Jumbotron looping hype reels, the band hammering out fight songs that rattle my ribcage. I’m in front row close enough to hear the players’ blades bite and the goalies’ pads slap when they drop into butterfly.
Nate’s stuck on trauma call again—triple stabbing downtown.
Michigan’s in white road jerseys tonight. Rowan’s #17 is easy to spot—dark-blond hair plastered under the helmet, shoulders filling the sweater like he’s been poured into it. He’s on the top line tonight, right wing, floating between power-play specialist and shutdown minutes. Next to him on the wing is Jake—#4, broad and steady, the kind of defenseman who hits like a truck but skates like he’s on rails. Grayson’s centering the second line—#9, quick hands, quicker mouth—already chirping the other team’s captain every shift change.
I should be rooting clean for Michigan. I went here. I bled maize and blue. But every time Rowan’s line hops the boards my stomach does a traitor flip. Every time Grayson flashes that cocky grin after a clean zone entry I feel a different kind of pride. And Jake—Christ, Jake just looks like trouble in the best way, the way he bumps Rowan’s shoulder after a goal, the way he winks at Grayson across the faceoff dot.
I’m fucked. I’m forty, sitting in an NHL-caliber barn wearing a Wolverines hoodie that smells faintly of Nate’s cedar cologne, and I don’t know who to cheer hardest for because I’ve had all three of them inside me or vice versa in the last months and the guilt is a live wire under my skin.
The game is brutal. Minnesota-Duluth comes out swinging—big bodies, heavy hits, forecheck like a vice. Michigan answers with speed. Grayson roofs one five-hole early in the second to make it 1–0. The building erupts. I’m on my feet screaming before I remember myself.
Then Rowan takes over.
He picks up a loose puck at the blue line, dips his shoulder, explodes through two defenders like they’re pylons, and wires a snapshot from the hash marks that beats the goalie clean over the blocker. 2–0. The student section loses its mind. I catch myself grinning so wide my cheeks hurt, then feel the stab of disloyalty because Nate’s not here and I’m acting like a proud—fuck, what? Boyfriend? Stepdad? Uncle? The word doesn’t exist yet.
Third period. Duluth claws back to 2–2 on a power-play redirect and a greasy wraparound. Overtime looms. The players on the bench look gassed but wired. During a TV timeout I see them huddled near the tunnel—Rowan, Grayson, Jake—helmets tipped back, laughing about something. Jake says something low; Rowan smirks that dangerous smirk I know too well. Grayson throws his head back laughing, then slaps both their asses with his gloves like it’s nothing.
I know something is up. My dick twitches against my thigh.
They win it in OT. Rowan’s the hero. He jumps on a turnover at center ice, burns the D with pure speed, cuts to the middle, and feathers a backhand pass to Grayson streaking down the left wing. Grayson one-times it—hard, accurate—but the goalie gets a piece. Rebound kicks straight to Jake crashing the net. Jake buries the dirty goal with his skate basically, pokes it over the line before the goalie can cover. 3–2. Lamp lights. Siren. Dog pile at center ice.
I’m screaming again, hoarse, hands cupped around my mouth. Rowan finds me in the crowd first—lifts his stick, points right at me, then taps the crest over his heart twice. My throat closes. Grayson and Jake both look up next, grinning like devils.
Post-game, the handshake line drags. I text Nate a clip of the winner, then head down to the family/waiting area outside the locker room. Security knows me by now—Nate’s plus-one, Rowan’s… whatever I am. They wave me through.
The three of them emerge maybe twenty minutes later—hair wet, street clothes, still buzzing. Rowan’s wearing a backward cap and a compression shirt that clings to every ridge of muscle. Grayson’s got a duffel over one shoulder, Jake’s carrying both their sticks like it’s no big deal.
Rowan spots me first. Breaks into that slow, filthy smile that should be illegal.
“See that pass?” he asks, stepping right into my space like we’re alone.
“Saw the whole thing,” I say, voice rougher than I mean. “Filthy. All three of you.”
Grayson slings an arm around Jake’s neck. “We made a little side bet during the second intermission.”
Jake grins. “Winner picks the prize. No vetoes.”
I raise an eyebrow, already knowing I’m in trouble. “And?”
Rowan’s eyes lock on mine, dark and certain. “I won.”
Grayson laughs under his breath. “He fucking did. Clean sweep on points, plus-3, game-winning assist. Row’s untouchable tonight.”
“So what’s the prize?” I ask, even though the heat crawling up my neck already knows the answer’s going to wreck me.
Rowan steps closer—close enough I can smell the soap from the locker-room shower and the faint trace of Gatorade on his breath. “Told them I’d decide later. When we’re private.”
◆◆◆
I booked the suite at the Loews two weeks ago to celebrate. Now the four of us are crammed in the hotel elevator, gear bags bumping shins, the air thick with post-win adrenaline and something darker. Rowan’s shoulder presses mine the whole ride up. Grayson’s knee knocks Jake’s. No one speaks. The ding when we hit the 14th floor feels obscene.
I swipe the keycard. Door clicks. Lights come on low and golden.
Rowan drops his bag first. Kicks off his sneakers. Turns to face me—then all of us—with that same smirk he wore the night he caught me jerking off in Nate’s bed.
“Prize time,” he says, voice low.
Grayson leans against the wall, arms crossed, already half-hard in his sweats. Jake’s watching like he’s waiting for the puck to drop.
Rowan steps right up to me, chest brushing mine, eyes flicking down to my mouth then back up.
“I want all of you,” he says, slow enough the words sink in like teeth. “And Chris…” His hand slides low, cups me through my jeans—firm, unapologetic. My dick jerks hard against his palm. “…I want you to take all of us. One after the other. Right here. Tonight.”
My breath leaves in a punched-out sound.
Grayson lets out a low whistle. Jake’s grin turns feral.
Rowan’s thumb drags over the head of me through the denim—once, twice—then he steps back, already peeling his shirt off over his head, revealing every carved inch I’ve tried so hard to forget.
“Strip,” he tells me, eyes glittering. “We’ve got all night.”
My hands move before my brain catches up.
Rowan's already shirtless, his chest rising steady, every ridge of muscle etched sharp under the golden lamp glow, skin still flushed from the win. Grayson and Jake follow suit—tees yanked off, tossed aside like afterthoughts, revealing torsos built for the ice: Grayson's lean and wiry, abs flexing with each breath; Jake's broader, shoulders rolling as he stretches, that easy grin splitting his face.
They circle me slow, eyes hungry, the carpet soft under my bare feet as I shed my jeans last, stepping out naked, I’m already swelling thick against my thigh from the promise alone. Rowan's hand finds me first—fingers wrapping firm around the base, stroking once, twice, the friction pulling a sharp inhale from my lungs. "Look at you," he says, voice low and teasing, thumb dragging over the sensitive underside. "All ours tonight."
Grayson steps in close on my left, his palm flat against my pec, fingers brushing one nipple until it hardens under the touch. "We've been talking about this since the second period," he adds, breath warm against my ear, nipping the lobe lightly. Jake flanks my right, dropping low already, his mouth hovering near my hip, tongue flicking out to trace the V-line down.
They drop to their knees in unison, like a coordinated shift change, surrounding me. Rowan's lips part first around the head of my shaft, enveloping the swollen tip, his tongue swirling slow circles along the ridge while his hand pumps the lower half in steady rhythm. Grayson leans in from the side, mouth latching onto my balls—sucking one gently, then the other, the suction pulling tight sensations that shoot straight up my spine. Jake's hands spread my thighs wider, his face pressing between my cheeks, tongue probing hot and insistent against the tight ring there, lapping in firm strokes that make my knees buckle slightly.
"Fuck," I breathe, hands threading into their hair—Rowan's damp strands, Grayson's wild mess, Jake's short crop—holding on as they work me over. The room fills with the sounds: wet slurps from Rowan's mouth sliding deeper along my hardness, the soft pops when Grayson releases one nut to lavish the other, Jake's muffled hums vibrating against my ass. Sensations layer, skin prickling where their fingers dig into my thighs, the cool air contrasting the warmth of their breaths.
Grayson's free hand roams up, pinching my other nipple hard enough to draw a hiss from me, then soothing it with his thumb. "You like that, Chris?" he teases, eyes flicking up to mine, that familiar spark there—the one that's always felt like a secret between us, even now, subtle but definitely still there.
Jake pulls back just enough to laugh against my skin. "He's clenching already. Bet he's dying for more." His fingers replace his tongue—two slicked with spit, circling the rim before pressing in slow, the stretch burning sweet as he crooks them, rubbing that inner spot that makes my hips jerk forward, pushing deeper into Rowan's throat.
Rowan gags once, pulls off with a string of saliva connecting us, grinning wicked. "Easy there, champ. We've got plans." He dives back in, taking my cock fully now, nose brushing my trimmed base, while Grayson switches—his mouth joining Rowan's on my shaft, tongues tangling along the length, lapping the veins in messy unison. Jake adds a third finger, scissoring wide, the fullness making my breath hitch ragged.
They keep it up until I'm trembling, thighs quaking, the edge building too fast. "Enough," I rasp, pulling them back by the hair—gentle but firm. "Not yet."
Rowan stands first, wiping his mouth with the back of his hand, eyes dark. "My turn to call it." He nods to the bed—king-sized, sheets crisp white under the low light. "On your back. Legs up."
I comply, heart hammering, lying back against the pillows, knees bending toward my chest. Rowan sheds his sweats, his massive tool springing free—long, thick, foreskin eased back to reveal the flushed head. He lathers himself with lube from the nightstand, then positions between my thighs, the glistening tip nudging my opening. He pushes in steady—the initial give stretching me wide, every inch dragging along inner walls until he's seated deep, hips flush against my ass.
"Goddamn," he breathes, starting slow rolls—long drags out, then snapping back in, the slap of skin echoing. I reach for Grayson, pulling him close; his length bobs near my face, and I envelop the head with my lips, sucking firm while he braces one hand on the headboard. Jake climbs up beside, his hand wrapping my own shaft, pumping in time with Rowan's thrusts.
Rowan speeds up, angling to hit that spot relentlessly, each drive punching air from my lungs. "Take it," he says, grinning down. "You're made for this." Sweat beads on his chest, dripping onto mine as he leans forward, folding me further, the position letting him go deeper. Grayson fucks my mouth shallow, his free hand carding through my hair—gentle, almost tender.
Jake leans down, his mouth engulfing my hardness now, sucking with hollowed cheeks while his fingers tease my balls. The overload hits—Rowan's relentless pounding, Grayson's length sliding over my tongue, Jake's suction pulling me apart. Rowan stiffens first, hips stuttering as he unloads deep inside me, the warmth spreading, filling me in heavy spurts that leak out around his base when he finally pulls free.
"Switch," Rowan pants, rolling off, still catching his breath. Grayson slides down, taking his place—his curved shaft gleaming as he lubes up, then enters me in one smooth glide, the angle hitting different, rubbing new spots that make my back arch. "Always knew you'd feel perfect," he says, voice rough, eyes locking on mine longer than the others, that subtle thread pulling tighter.
He thrusts steady, building pace, while Jake straddles my chest now, feeding his long tool into my mouth—stretching my lips wide as I swallow around him. Rowan kneels beside, his hand joining Jake's on my shaft, both stroking in tandem, the dual grip slick from leftover lube. Grayson's rhythm turns harder, hips snapping with purpose, sweat slicking our stomachs where they slide together.
"You're wrecking me," I manage around Jake's length, the words muffled, drawing a laugh from him.
"That's the point," Jake replies, thrusting gently into the heat of my mouth. Grayson hits his peak soon after—body tensing, then releasing his load inside me with jagged bucks, adding to the mess, the fullness dripping down my thighs.
Jake's last. He flips me onto all fours, ass up, head down against the pillows. His hands spread my cheeks, admiring the view with a low chuckle. "Look at that—already leaking us." He presses in—long, straight, filling the stretched space easily, then starts pounding with brutal efficiency, the bedframe thumping the wall.
Rowan and Grayson position in front: Rowan on his knees, my mouth wrapping his semi-hard length, cleaning the remnants with slow licks; Grayson beneath, his lips enclosing my dangling shaft, sucking upside-down while his hands knead my thighs. Jake's grip bruises my hips, each slam forward jolting me deeper into Rowan's lap, the chain reaction building the heat again.
"Almost," Jake grits out, pace faltering, then he drives home one last time, emptying himself inside with forceful pulses that push the overflow further out. The sensation tips me over—my body clenching around him, spilling into Grayson's waiting mouth in thick ropes he swallows greedily.
We collapse in a heap—limbs tangled, breaths heaving, the sheets sticky and ruined. Laughter bubbles up first from Jake: "Holy shit, we just won the Frozen Four and this."
Rowan smirks, arm slung over my chest. "Prize claimed."
Grayson's hand finds mine under the mess, squeezing once—quiet, unspoken—before he rolls away, grabbing water from the mini-fridge.
The room quiets, city lights flickering through the windows, the weight of what we've done settling like the snow outside. Nate's text from earlier burns in my pocket downstairs. But for now, in this haze, it's just us.
◆◆◆
The room is dark except for the thin blue glow of the city bleeding through the blackout curtains—streetlights on the Mississippi, car headlights slicing across the ceiling in slow arcs. The king bed is a war zone: sheets twisted into ropes, pillows shoved to the floor, the faint metallic scent of sweat and sex still clinging to the air. Bodies are everywhere. Rowan sprawls on his stomach to my left, one arm flung across my waist, face mashed into the mattress, soft snores rumbling against my ribs. Grayson’s curled on my right, leg hooked over mine, his breath steady and warm on my shoulder. Jake’s half off the edge at the foot of the bed, one massive thigh draped over my shin like he’s claiming territory even in sleep.
I’m pinned under the weight of all three, skin sticky where thighs and chests and stomachs pressed together for hours. My body feels heavy, used in the best and worst ways—muscles lax, a dull ache blooming deep inside, thighs tacky with dried lube and everything else they left behind.
Nature calls. I need to pee bad.
I ease out from under them as carefully as I can. Rowan grumbles something incoherent and rolls closer to Grayson; Grayson’s hand slides down to cup Jake’s ass in his sleep like it’s muscle memory. I swing my legs over the side, feet finding cool carpet, and stand. The room tilts for a second—post-game, post-fuck vertigo—then steadies.
Bathroom light is too bright. I flick it off again, leave the door cracked, and drop onto the toilet seat instead of standing. Too tired to aim properly, and honestly, after the way they railed me, standing feels like asking for trouble. I sit, elbows on knees, head bowed, letting the stream start.
Halfway through, I feel it—a slow, heavy slide inside me, warm and thick. A fat glob of cum seeps out, then another, pooling under me before dripping into the bowl with soft, obscene plops. I freeze mid-stream, staring down between my thighs like I can’t believe what I’m seeing.
Jesus.
My forties are turning out to be cursed. Or the best time ever. I’m not sure which.
I laugh once—quiet, breathless, the sound echoing off the tile. It’s not funny, not really, but it’s the only thing my brain can produce right now. Forty years old, newly out, newly divorced, newly in love with a trauma surgeon who’s probably still stitching people back together downtown, and here I am leaking three college hockey players’ loads in a hotel bathroom at three in the morning after they took turns turning me inside out on national-television-winning night.
I finish pissing, wipe, flush. Stand there naked in front of the mirror for a long second. My reflection looks wrecked in the dim hallway light leaking through the crack: hair a disaster, lips swollen, faint red marks on my neck and hips where fingers dug in too hard. Chest rising slow. Eyes tired but bright.
Nate’s face flashes behind my own—crooked half-smirk, tired green eyes after a long shift, the way he kissed me goodbye before the Frozen Four road trip like he knew something was coming but didn’t want to ask.
Guilt hits like cold water.
Not the sharp stab it used to be. More like a slow, heavy weight settling in my sternum. I’ve been dodging it for months—first the reunion, then the breakfast, then the brownstone, then the rink locker room, then that night in Nate’s bed when Rowan walked in on me, then tonight. Every step felt inevitable, like gravity pulling me downhill, but now the hill’s leveled out and I can see how far I’ve fallen.
I can’t keep doing this.
Not to Nate. Not to Rowan. Not to myself.
I splash water on my face, towel off, pad back into the bedroom. The three of them haven’t moved—still tangled, still breathing deep and even. Rowan’s hand has found Grayson’s in his sleep; their fingers are loosely laced. Jake’s snoring softly now, one arm flung wide.
I stand at the foot of the bed for a long minute, watching them. They look young. Happy. Wrecked in the same way I am. Something soft twists in my chest—affection, maybe pride, maybe regret.
I climb back in carefully, sliding under the sheet between Rowan and Grayson. Rowan shifts instinctively, arm draping over me again, face tucking into the crook of my neck. Grayson mumbles something that sounds like my name and presses closer. Jake’s foot finds my calf and stays there.
I lie on my back, staring at the ceiling, one hand resting on Rowan’s forearm, the other brushing Grayson’s hair off his forehead.
When Nate gets home—whenever that is, probably Sunday night after the conference—I must talk to him.
I close my eyes. The ache inside is still there—deep, tender, full—but so is the warmth of the bodies around me.
Cursed. Or the best time ever.
I’ll find out soon enough.