Not My Brother – Part 5 - Finale (Patreon)
Content
Everyone in this story is 18+
The car was full. Claustrophobic full. Thomas’s idea of “packing light” apparently meant four coolers, two fold-out chairs, and a chainsaw for reasons no one questioned. When it came time to leave, the only spot left in the back of the van was a single seat that faced the side door instead of the front. Mom looked at the mess and said the words that sealed my fate.
“Axel, honey, you’ll have to sit with Peyton. You’re the lightest.”
I froze. Peyton didn’t. Just smirked and shifted over, making room like it was no big deal.
I climbed in and ended up pressed against him on the sideways-facing seat, the two of us half-hidden from the front by the angle and a scratchy blanket that smelled like tent and woodsmoke. My thigh was basically in his lap. Of course he was already half-hard. I tried to ignore it.
Peyton made a quiet sound that was definitely not innocent.
“Comfy?”
“No,” I whispered.
I still didn’t move. I had to act, so I threw a blanket over us and no one thought twice about it. It was scratchy and smelled like tent and woodsmoke. Mom handed me a bag of trail mix. Thomas backed out of the campsite. And Peyton’s hands settled on my waist like they belonged there.
At first it was subtle. Then progressively firmer. He adjusted me slightly on his lap and I felt him, fully hard now, pressing up against me through both layers of fabric. I tried to wiggle for space. He didn’t give me any. Instead he shifted his hips and suddenly I was sitting directly on the thick shape of him.
“Stop it,” I hissed under my breath.
“Not doing anything,” he answered, voice perfectly casual.
He was lying. I felt him push up just enough that the head of his cock pressed against the thin material of my very flimsy and way too short shorts. My hole clenched like crazy. Then real pressure. Under the blanket he tugged the waistband of my shorts aside. Skin met skin. I felt him spit into his palm, then the slick head of him lining up against my ass. I tried to lift myself off him.
“You’re insane,” I whispered.
“Still not doing anything,” he said, hands tightening on my hips.
He pressed up. My body betrayed me completely. He slipped inside in one slow, careful push, filling me inch by inch while the car rolled over the gravel road. I exhaled sharp and stunned, forced to stay perfectly still as he settled deep.
We were connected again with our parents two feet away.
I sat rigid, heart hammering against my ribs. Every little bump in the road shifted him deeper. I clenched around him without meaning to and felt him twitch in response. I bit the inside of my cheek hard enough to taste blood and tried to keep my breathing even.
His breath ghosted over the back of my shoulder. “Still mad at me?”
“Shut up,” I muttered.
He flexed inside me just once. My jaw locked.
We couldn’t move much. The car did most of the work, tiny shifts and slow rolls that kept him grinding against that spot that made my vision blur. It was sick. Completely deranged. I was already leaking around him and getting harder by the second, trapped under the blanket with nowhere to go.
Then his hand slid around my waist and down, wrapping around my hard-on. His thumb dragged over the head in slow, precise circles while his hips made the smallest movements beneath me. I gripped the seat in front of me so hard my knuckles went white. Mom laughed at something Thomas said. I wanted the ground to open up and swallow the entire car.
He kept stroking me in time with those tiny thrusts. I bucked once without meaning to and tried to play it off like I was just adjusting how I sat. It didn’t work. The pressure built too fast, too sharp, and I came quiet and shaking, cumming over his fist while I stayed perfectly still on the outside.
I was still trying to catch my breath when he adjusted his grip on my hips, tilted me a fraction, and pushed even deeper.
“No,” I whispered. “Don’t.”
But he did. He held me there, fully buried, while the car bumped along the highway and my mom turned around to offer me a protein bar. I didn’t answer. I just sat there with Peyton’s cock buried in my ass, face burning, brain completely fried, trying not to make a single sound.
He came a minute later, deep and hard. I felt every pulse of it. He bit the back of my shoulder to keep quiet, breath hot against my neck.
When he finally slipped out it was a mess. I didn’t look down. I just stayed on his lap the rest of the ride home, sticky and full and completely ruined, staring out the window while the countryside blurred past.
We didn’t talk. But I couldn’t stop thinking the same thing over and over:
Peyton was going to be my stepbrother.
God help me.