Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Doctor Who Review Viewers' Choice (Cybermen and Dalek Edition)

  • Destiny of the Daleks 43
  • Attack of the Cybermen 40
  • Remembrance of the Daleks 111
  • Silver Nemesis 65
  • 2023-05-05
  • —2023-05-12
  • 259 votes
{'title': "Doctor Who Review Viewers' Choice (Cybermen and Dalek Edition)", 'choices': [{'text': 'Destiny of the Daleks', 'votes': 43}, {'text': 'Attack of the Cybermen', 'votes': 40}, {'text': 'Remembrance of the Daleks', 'votes': 111}, {'text': 'Silver Nemesis', 'votes': 65}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2023, 5, 12, 18, 54, 44, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2023, 5, 5, 18, 35, 20, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 259}

Content

Hey, everybody!So this November is going to mark Doctor Who's 60th anniversary. I kind of dropped the ball on the 50th anniversary, so for this momentous occasion I wanted to do something special. We're taking another break from Secret Origins month (it'll be back next year, promise) to have an entire month of Who reviews - at least two comics, maybe an audio drama... but I also want to do another review of a Classic Who serial!I did a review of Logopolis last year based on Patrons voting and despite the copyright issues with it that forced me to keep reuploading it over and over (I think I'll be better prepared this year), I want to do another one to mark the occasion. I left off Cybermen and Dalek stories from the choice because I felt any that I put on there would dominate the poll, sooo here are the choices!We're focusing on ones that are either liked (but not by me), hated (but not by me), or just universally considered great. The thing they all have in common? Continuity with past adventures - fitting for an anniversary!Destiny of the DaleksThe 4th Doctor and the newly-regenerated Romana accidentally land on Skaro, homeworld of the Daleks, who are currently engaged in a war with a race called the Movellans. However, for some reason the Daleks are now searching the ruins of their old city for something buried deep within... something that would shape Dalek stories for the rest of Classic Who.FEATURES:-Terrible Acting!-Ill-fitting masks made for other actors!-Questions about regeneration that would baffle people obsessed with continuity!-Rocks!Attack of the CybermenWhile the 6th Doctor investigates a distress signal on then-modern day earth, a group of Cybermen are conducting experiments in the London sewers related to time travel - hoping to avert the original disaster that destroyed their homeworld.FEATURES:-Logic in what he says!-Tons and tons of references to past Cybermen stories!-The TARDIS chameleon circuit kinda-sorta working for a while!-Violent hand crushing!Remembrance of the DaleksThe 7th Doctor arrives in 1963 and becomes embroiled in a conflict between two groups of Daleks both vying for an ancient Time Lord device that the Doctor placed on earth ages ago for safe keeping. FEATURES:-Ace beating up a Dalek with a baseball bat!-Creepy little girls with lightning hands!-Plasma balls as advanced Dalek time travel technology!-Unlimited rice pudding!Silver NemesisDoctor Who's 25th anniversary story, wherein the 7th Doctor becomes embroiled in a conflict between Neo-Nazis, a 17th-century sorceress, and the Cybermen as they all attempt to lay claim to a deadly statue of incredible power.FEATURES:-Ace killing Cybermen with a slingshot!-The human condition of madness!-Neo-Nazis getting blasted!-Jazz!Voting will end in one week!

Comments

Haldon Lindstrom

Love Attack of the Cybermen, but continuity jokes are a personal favorite, and the worse the acting, the more fun the commentary.

Jennifer Smith

I know it probably won't win but am immensely curious about your thoughts on Silver Nemesis

Adam Besley

Easy pick here; Remembrance! Loved it since first viewing and hey they brought that back for last regen special.

Sylvan Scott

Silver Nemesis is probably the most nuanced of these stories especially as it stars Sylvester McCoy's "Machiavellian Clown" incarnation of the Doctor. As a friend of mine said while listening to a 7th-Doctor Big Finish Audio, "Oh, right: he's the scary one!"

The New Chaos Theater

Ace is one of my favorite companions so you know what I'm picking

Xidphel

I just want that scene covered.

Shali Wolfy~

What a difficult choice. Killing nazis is always a net positive. But the rest of those are fun options, too.

Nick Lenz

Remembrance of the Daleks is a fun and exciting story. Also it came out the year I was born 1988. So I'm as old as this story. One my favorites it reviewed on the 1st episode of my doctor who review series

Richard Valdez

Remembrance was the first McCoy episode I saw, and it was his first great episode, mainly because of the bad-ass that is Ace.

Samuel D Bennett

I recently binged all of the Seventh Doctors run so I’m genuinely split between Remembrance and Silver. But I gotta go with Silver because watching it again ten years later it was much better than the first time around.

Christy Gallinger

Remembrance! Destiny sounds like a hoot but Seven & Ace in 1963 is brilliant!

X L

Personally I would have had Earthshock instead of Silver Nemesis, partly because it's considered to be of comparable quality to Rememberance, and partly because it gives the Fifth Doctor era an entry, but Nemesis was not a bad choice.

Lewis Lovhaug

Only reason Remembrance is on the list instead of the far worse Revelation is because I realized the three other stories all had a lot of references to past continuity. And then I realized I didn't really want to watch Revelation again in case it won, so I replaced it. More or less: this list was not SUPPOSED to be about the good stuff, it's just Remembrance is that good. XD

James Miles

Looks like we want unlimited rice pudding.

Rebecca R.

Remembrance if only because I wanna see the Dalek getting beaten with the baseball bat!

Bryan

Oh, I was hoping for love and monsters lol

Kian Hartley

Rememberance of the Daleks is some fantastic television also I'd love to see an audio review. Big Finish put so much work into their stuff.

Joshua Paul

I voted for Unlimited rice pudding

Professor Harmless

I'm just going with Silver Nemesis for mad ramblings about The Doctor being called "Doctor Who" on screen.

BisonBlitz

I really like Destiny of the Daleks in a sort of Meta-sense. Because it raises the concept of the Daleks ultimate endpoint. Where they'd be paralyzed by logic, into a stalemate with a true logicbound race. Robot's in this case. Whilst more naturally setting up Davros's next return. In which the Daleks lost due to being biological creatures. And showing that their rash aggression in killing Davros................/////////////////////////////////////////////////While they were barley out of a 'beta state' back in Genesis of the Daleks. Absolutely had consequences. Also makes it convincing that the Daleks would attempt the Time war against the Time lords. They've lost many times against lesser species throughout the classic series. However we do constantly see their evolution. So when Russell T Davis implements the Time War as a soft reboot. It isn't like American TV where the show jumps the Shark to escalate the stakes or to quickly wrap up the show. As in what happened in Voyager's series finale endgame. So the Time war does naturally fit.

BisonBlitz

You could technically put in The Five Doctors for voting. Which has both the Cyberman & Daleks in it. Also the Blu-ray restoration of the classic series's does really rather help make them watchable. Alot less picture noise and less extreme outside vs studio shooting. Which is clearly visible with the 3 Doctors. Again a concept less awkward when compared to some modern stories. Like the Satan pit. Or the weeping angels.

Skemono

I was going to vote for the rocks, but then I saw Neo-Nazis getting blasted was on the list.

Steve Harper

Tough choice here... Destiny is mostly dull, Attack is mostly just bad, Remembrance is fantastic, and I can't watch Nemesis without singing 'Cor blimey, what a big frankfurter' (My friends did a re-dub back in the 90s called 'Copper Nemesis'). Overall, I think Destiny just because the rest require so much explanation to bring your non-Whovian viewers up to date... unless you were to also review The Tenth Planet, maybe as the audio adventure, in which case I'd say Attack because there's so much comedic fodder there.

Steve Harper

Also, Destiny is the only one of these choices with the proper Diamond logo, as being reintroduced for the anniversary.

Andrew Sparling

I started listening to the 'extended' adventures of 7 and Ace from Big Finish, I'm excited to see one of their more memorable adventures

BisonBlitz

If you take away the Cyberman VS Daleks finale from Doctor Who series 2. It ends up being the weekest of the new series. But certainly not the worst. Yet very safe storywise. It's certainly why I don't like Rose Tyler that much. She's exciting to see again. However nothing more can be achieved with her character growth. Unlike Martha.

BisonBlitz

I wish Daleks in Manhattan 'stuck'.

SmillieReacts

Nope if you put Remembrance on a poll it should automatically win, its too good a story!

Mister Midnight

My Doctor Who knowledge/experience is limited so I'm cool with whichever you choose. Most I've seen is The Next Doctor special with David Morrissey (aka The Governor from The Walking Dead; fun fact, when I heard he was cast in that show, I looked him up on Wikipedia and found out about said special, of which I mentioned to some "hardcore fans" of DW, and not only did they proceed to deny said special existed and I was wrong, they threw toilet paper at me, only to retract their statement when they looked it up and found out it was real and I was right), some 4th, the 8th Doctor movie (probably my favorite incarnation), 9th-13th, and the Day of the Doctor special.