Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 573359072.mp4

Downloads

Content

A closer look at the dramatic technique in the first act of Peter Jackson's adaptation of Fellowship Of The Ring.

Files

Comments

Philip DeArmitt

I really appreciate that you have turned yourself into a character for the patreon bits.

Cyn Virtue

Andrew, if you haven't visited NZ to see some of the filming locations, I encourage you to put it on your goal list. I went about three years ago, and it was a great way to not only see the movie locations, but also learn a lot about the country itself.

The Art Of Storytelling

Oh believe me, it's on my bucket list of things to do. My parents have been twice, including visiting Hobbiton, and they tell me it's amazing.

The Art Of Storytelling

Lol I have this awesome Gandalf costume that I got for Halloween a few years ago and I've been getting a lot of mileage out of it.

Cyn Virtue

Oh, good! I figured it probably was, but I'd rather be the twelfth time you've heard it than risk it not ever being said.

E Kelly

Returning here after the announcement of Shadows of the Past, where Peter Jackson and Stephen Colbert are pitching to insert a “lost act” into Fellowship. And…I’m just not sure it needs it. Removing the 6 chapters of Frodo’s journey from the books was a narrative decision that served the film incredibly well. The sense of urgency it created was the driving force of it. The 17 year gap, the barrow wights, even Tom Bombadil himself (who I believe to be the most unfilmable character in literature) detract from that urgency. Growing up, I was too exciting to see my favorite books come to life to view the films with any criticism, but likewise, I was too young to extend any criticism to my favorite books. Looking back now, at the weapon of mass destruction contained in that envelope, the URGENCY Jackson and co. injected into the narrative was the correct instinct.

The Art Of Storytelling

Yeah I was just reading about this Colbert thing. Still processing how I feel about it. Think it's worthy of a video? Not sure what I would say beyond "I have doubts, but I hope I'm proven wrong". But also as you point out, there's probably a good reason why that section of fellowship didn't get included in the film.

E Kelly

I think you’re better positioned than most to put out a nuanced take on the announcement. I’ve seen mostly negative, and some overly optimistic. Maybe you could talk about how you’d approach such a writing assignment what pitfalls you’d foresee, and how’d you’d avoid them? Tolkien’s own thoughts about why he wouldn’t write a sequel inform my own thoughts on this. But mostly, I just wonder what narrative purpose does this project serve? Their pitch is to write a sequel that then reflects back to a lost act in Fellowship. But does fellowship need another act inserted into it, or along side it? I’m not sure. I know Colbert is a life long Tolkien lover and has the deepest respect for the source material. He’s spoken for years about the 6 missing chapters and how he wished they were in the films. I’m sure this is coming from a place of love, but I’m not sure that’s enough. Maybe we’ll be pleasantly surprised.

The Art Of Storytelling

If I had a take, basically you just said it. The problem is that characters in a story need to change, and if we're going to see the hobbits' journey from the Shire to Bree in more detail, the question will be "why"? Because each Hobbit has his own arc in the trilogy - for example, Merry and Pippin end up being brave warriors. So when this Colbert movie ends, they STILL need to be the same Hobbits who left the Shire basically. Anyway, yes I agree - I'm excited to see new interpretations of Tolkien, but I feel like this is not the way.