Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 749456596.mp4

Downloads

Content

Hey friends! This episode was obviously big for Star Trek, but it was big for television too. There's also an interesting writing lesson in here when you think about who is the protagonist, and who is not. Enjoy!

Files

Comments

Tyler Santomaso

Totally a random thought, but with the right haircut, you could be a Jonathan Frakes look-alike 😋

Netro

Yup, can't unsee it now.

RobF228

I've always felt that this is the episode when TNG finally broke out & became GREAT!

Omar Acevedo

Totally agree! So many memorable shots let alone moments.

Teresa (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-24 22:00 Speaking of continuity, with this video I can't stick to my course of action and restrain from a verbose comment, I'll save it for the next one 😅 My husband and I can be divided on episodic vs serialised shows. He leans more towards the latter, probably for the same reasons you've touched here. As for me, the serialised nature of the modern shows in the franchise prevents me from really enjoying them. I understand that character development isn't easily achieved within an episodic framework, and that some topics need more time to be fully explored. On the other hand, modern authors seem to be able to handle a story spanning several hours only by linking it tightly to an imminent global catastrophe. In the long run it's kinda boring and limiting. I have the same issue with manga: I decidedly preferred Rumiko Takahashi's Ranma ½ and Urusei Yatsura to her Inuyasha. And I think it's the same reason that often prevents me from appreciating the third and subsequent seasons of a show. However, I'd say that Piller brought TNG to the sweet spot between the two, since I love the entire instalment. This may be the right time to ask you if you can recommend any books on ST. Any suggestions? I'm intrigued by "The Ultimate Star Trek and Philosophy: The Search for Socrates". Have you read anything similar?
2026-09-22 07:46 Speaking of continuity, with this video I can't stick to my course of action and restrain from a verbose comment, I'll save it for the next one 😅 My husband and I can be divided on episodic vs serialised shows. He leans more towards the latter, probably for the same reasons you've touched here. As for me, the serialised nature of the modern shows in the franchise prevents me from really enjoying them. I understand that character development isn't easily achieved within an episodic framework, and that some topics need more time to be fully explored. On the other hand, modern authors seem to be able to handle a story spanning several hours only by linking it tightly to an imminent global catastrophe. In the long run it's kinda boring and limiting. I have the same issue with manga: I decidedly preferred Rumiko Takahashi's Ranma ½ and Urusei Yatsura to her Inuyasha. And I think it's the same reason that often prevents me from appreciating the third and subsequent seasons of a show. However, I'd say that Piller brought TNG to the sweet spot between the two, since I love the entire instalment. This might be the right time to ask you if you can recommend any books on ST. Any suggestions? I'm intrigued by "The Ultimate Star Trek and Philosophy: The Search for Socrates". Have you read anything similar?

Speaking of continuity, with this video I can't stick to my course of action and restrain from a verbose comment, I'll save it for the next one 😅 My husband and I can be divided on episodic vs serialised shows. He leans more towards the latter, probably for the same reasons you've touched here. As for me, the serialised nature of the modern shows in the franchise prevents me from really enjoying them. I understand that character development isn't easily achieved within an episodic framework, and that some topics need more time to be fully explored. On the other hand, modern authors seem to be able to handle a story spanning several hours only by linking it tightly to an imminent global catastrophe. In the long run it's kinda boring and limiting. I have the same issue with manga: I decidedly preferred Rumiko Takahashi's Ranma ½ and Urusei Yatsura to her Inuyasha. And I think it's the same reason that often prevents me from appreciating the third and subsequent seasons of a show. However, I'd say that Piller brought TNG to the sweet spot between the two, since I love the entire instalment. This might be the right time to ask you if you can recommend any books on ST. Any suggestions? I'm intrigued by "The Ultimate Star Trek and Philosophy: The Search for Socrates". Have you read anything similar?

Teresa

For what it's worth: loved it.

The Art Of Storytelling

Definitely some give and take in both approaches to TV. And yeah, I know what you mean about some shows just using the serialized format to "milk" the show and string along the audience forever. That's why, ironically, I often want my favourite shows to end sooner. Like Severance for example - I hope it ends after Season 3. As for books about ST, the only one I have is the episode guide I featured in this video, which is more of a reference book – not really a page turner. I haven't read that philosophy one you mentioned, but sounds like maybe I should. Would definitely fit my channel!

The Art Of Storytelling

Thanks for sharing. Very interesting read, and well written. I agree with pretty much everything you have in there. I like what you write about Star Trek having nothing to comment on today, simply because of how the culture has changed. There's definitely a lot of truth there. It's actually hard to even IMAGINE where Star Trek could go because of this. I also like what you write about the holograms and stuff being overdone, and the magic of TNG's futurism being gone. That's a huge hurdle for the franchise ever being good again. I've thought about making a video on this subject, but I haven't been able to bring myself to actually WATCH the new Star Treks lol. I can just tell at a glance that they are abysmal. And there's already enough videos on YouTube crapping on them. It's really sad. Not sure if you watched Red Letter Media's recent video about the fate of Star Trek. They had some similar thoughts. I was hopeful that Star Trek Legacy (was that the name?) would take off? But for whatever reason, leadership was not interested. I don't understand it lol. In any case, thanks for sharing this article with the community.

San Francisco Human

Thank you for the kind words! Please feel free to use/adapt any of these ideas yourself; no need to credit anything more than your Patreon community. :) I did watch that RLM video, but, for all the reasons I wrote, I can't share their conviction that even a relatively modest TNG-style series could still work, though I do agree it would have the best shot. As for a "Legacy" series, I found Picard S3 to be a witless and joyless slog, so I definitely wouldn't want any tonally similar stories branching off from there. (They brought Shelby back just to have her cheerlead the obviously idiotic idea of a fleet of remote-controlled ships?!) There were two 2010s series I did get a fair amount of classic Trek vibes from: Marvel's Agents of SHIELD and The Last Ship. Neither had much in the way of moral quandaries or social commentary, but they were about dedicated professionals who took their jobs seriously, and the science, even when fantastical, was depicted with respect. (There was a first season episode of The Last Ship that was entirely about doing an experimental vaccine trial, for instance, and it was no laughing matter.) I'm not aware of any similarly classic-feeling series from the past few years, except for maybe The Pitt, which I haven't yet seen, but sounds as though it has more old-school Trek spirit than the new official stuff.

Tjerk

Not a trekkie, but I wish modern streaming would implement a feature where you could watch a series like it was aired in the olden days. So you had time to wait and marinate between episodes.

Shad

Oh man. Another banger! Your TNG episodes tend to be really good. I think it’s because you love the show so much. I didn’t realize that the American pronunciation of “futile” was “few-dal” - I’d always assumed it was “few-tile”. I guess I learned that word from TNG! And your gagging at the American pronunciation - chef’s kiss. 100% agree.

Sendrius Telt

Been a fan of yours for a while, but this one brought me to Patreon. I was 9 when this episode originally came out. I’ll never forget it. As the only sci-fi fan in my household, I had an entire world to myself that summer.

Teresa

My guess is he was gagging at the sound of the entire phrase rather than the American pronunciation of the word itself. Canadians have more of an American pronunciation, don't they?

Cyn Virtue

I recommend to you Wil Wheaton's Memories of the Future - his POV as a teen working on the show, which he was going to extend to all of his work on Star Trek but never did more than that one volume. Memories of the Future is very funny, although also rather bittersweet after I learned what his family life was actually like.

Cyn Virtue

I’d be interested to hear your thoughts (eventually) on the storytelling impact of the old paradigm of having a show like ST:ToS with 79 episodes over 3 years (hitting the syndication requirements of the time) vs. these days when shows deliver 8 episodes every two years (i.e. Rings of Power in ‘22, ‘24, and soon ‘26.)

The Art Of Storytelling

I guess the tradeoff in quality is quantity? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ I agree that's an interesting subject