Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

A little context:
My process is to write what interests me, what tickles my brain or improves my skills in one way or another. My hope is to overlap the Venn diagram of what sells well, what can help me improve as an author, and what I enjoy writing.

And so far, that has worked very well.

I started working on William Oh about two years ago, and I had a great time incorporating new techniques (The living legend, gear-based system,) with older techniques that I've done, and it turned out very well.

But to be honest, the diablo-style looter-shooter has slowly been getting harder and harder to keep up, and I find myself less engaged with keeping the acceleration going. I haven't introduced new techniques, synergies, storylines or situations in a long time and it's starting to weigh on me.

So for the finale, I'm planning on giving Will his own self-built custom-class. Most of you have gathered this. A problem and opportunity is that I don't have a perfect idea of how I want his new Class to play out yet.

This is an opportunity to write a completely different progression system, that might be more entertaining for me to write the final book or two. And if it's entertaining for me to write, then you can bet your ASS it'll be more entertaining for you to read. It's the reason it's one of the three key bubbles on my Venn diagram.

So I would LOVE suggestions for a different style of progression other than Diablo-lite. Drop suggestions for Will's Class and quirks about it's progression in the comments. That's the brainstorming portion.


The consultation portion is this:

I want to write another story that's been brewing in my head for nearly six months now. Usually I let ideas like that simmer and if they fade away and get forgotten, they must not have been that good.

This one keeps popping up.

I want to write a story about a nonhuman paladin.

It covers two of the 3 major things I look for in a new story:

#1: A connection and genuine faith in a higher power is something that I don't really have a firm grasp of, beside writing religious zealots as enemies, but I've read several paladin MC stories where everything comes together and it is outrageously awesome. The way it hypes up the audience gives me goosebumps, and I want to learn how to do that. Studying how to write in this style would cover my (learning new techniques) requirement.

#2: It sounds really fun. I know I would enjoy it.

#3: Not sure if it'd sell well, but I am planning on incorporating other techniques that I know that tend to sell well.

The premise: An evil wizard creates an ugly little homunculus to worship a deity in his stead, giving it just enough of a soul to technically register as a real being, separate from the wizard's misdeeds. He has it pray regularly from its cage and wish for things that are on the surface benign, but indirectly benefit the wizard for hundreds of years.

One day, the church of that deity gets wise to the wizard's prayer fraud and busts into his tower and kills him. The homunculus gets lost in the shuffle and hides in the sewers.

Now this incredibly devout little mutant is wandering the world, righting wrongs and being a badass.

I have an interesting, biological progression system in mind for him that will be a dual-edged sword.

There are more details, but I'm hesitant to mention them publicly before I even start writing.

Whaddya think? Sound like fun? My inspirations for the story are here:

https://www.royalroad.com/fiction/21410/super-minion <---excellent example of powerful nonhuman released into the wild
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/c0kBFqswCX0 <----got me curious about the little one's story.
https://mangakatana.com/manga/saihate-no-paladin.20258 <---- takes being a paladin seriously.
https://mangakatana.com/manga/adventures-of-an-undead-who-became-paladin.26141 <----has the biggest overlap with the idea. nonhuman paladin. successfully delivers the hype.


Let me know what you think about the new idea for a story, and if you have a suggestion for Will's new Class, be sure to label it as such so I can sort them a bit easier.

Comments

Natalie

The premise: An evil wizard creates an ugly little homunculus to worship a deity in his stead, giving it just enough of a soul to technically register as a real being, separate from the wizard's misdeeds. He has it pray regularly from its cage and wish for things that are on the surface benign, but indirectly benefit the wizard for hundreds of years. Someone's been watching YouTube shorts haven't they? :p Edit: finished reading the post. Yes, yes he has and linked the exact same short I was thinking of lol

Bunny Waffles

If you are needing any other literary inspirations for a righteous paladin, then have you read "Penitent" by Seersucker/CB Titus?

Pati

Sounds awesome dude.

FreakShow

I like that idea and look forward to reading more about it. Reminds me of The Iron Teeth: a goblins tale. (Except instead of the Thief class it’s a Paladin)

Natalie

I posted that before I finished reading the post, I edited it to update lol

Bananeeg

I saw that youtube short a while back and loved the idea! So heck yeah to reading a story based on that.

Daedalus

Class feedback: I think it would be a shame to lose the fact Will is so gear-based, so perhaps something incorporating that? Not so much Diablo, more… mad science bodging. Shove a wand of magic missiles and a goblet of overflowing water and turns it into a Gatling gun of magic missiles as each droplet of water becomes a bullet.

Treeman4

I personally like the concept of the nonhuman paladin, remins me of a dnd character ive had on the backburner of a goblinoid who has taken a book on dining etiquette as their code of conduct and are treating it as a guide to chivalrous knighthood. Will's Class: Miasmic Grasp -Focuses on the skills to directly manipulate miasma through his hands and effects -This effect would allow greater control of forming spells on his own outside of system perview, thinking like Oblivion spell crafting and all the jank that entails. -Would allign nicely with Will's legend and description, and he could physically grab the threads of fate affecting him which sounds suitably mythic.

Garrett Therkorn

For what it's worth, the lack of new synergies and techniques has been felt and missed. You're not alone in wishing to shore that up. Will's New Class: The Devourer of Worlds is a very neat idea that I feel would be a great base to start from as a 'blue mage' archetype. Discover a new type of Miasmatic structure, create and store samples of that structure inside his body, replicate and release. The loot is no longer items for Will, but seeing and yoinking new attacks; he might even lose gear slots entirely for the ability to safely store miasma, proving a major difference to his current loot-focused build. New Story: I'd read it. The overwhelming aura and hype of a paladin MC is facing a foe utterly beyond you with the conviction to see it through, regardless of your chances of success. Whether that's the leviathan of a state, a demon lord, or a dragon, conviction + an awareness of your own mortality + the will to go on anyway is hard to beat. The contrast between heroic knight that usually stands here and homunculus-gremlin sounds like great spittake reactions combined with the hype of the genre regardless. I'd stay subscribed for it.

vetro 26

Im always sooo excited to see you wanting to write a new story because it always means Im going have a new favorite book to add to my list.

funktorial

Will as a blue mage makes a lot of sense, I dig it

SkippyARC

The easy answer to the brainstorming would be miasma cultivation. Take all those tropes from Royalroad about breathing mana and chi into your body to make a stronger vessel with a bigger magic resource pool.

Cole Ford

what about something along the lines of being the one to close or end the loop and the class lets him stop miasmatic structures from firing off making him sort of a null type of thing. the trade off is his own stuff also gets turned off so now you gotta fist fight William oh

Gam

For the paladin pitch. Under the light of the world at war by Seras is the only paladin story I’ve read so far and have enjoyed it greatly. As for a system/progression designed around faith… you could go warlock style, or even take it that one meme route where the warlock/faith power are a pyramid scheme which would explain why the homunculus prayers help the wizard… I’m not coming up with anything else that’s “progression-y” off the top of my head but when i do I’ll mention it.

Jacob

I think the paladin idea would be fun and present a challenge for having the character grow in power and have people still trust him. If its biological in nature then you can explore the grafting of monsters parts onto the paladin which makes him stronger which means he can fight weirder monsters and get stronger parts etc etc. The challenge is that the more monstrous he looks the less people are likely to trust him at a glance and tests how long a person can keep their faith when everyone is against them. For Will I think the custom class needs to incorporate the ability which started the breaking of the game. THE MAP. To have a pun name I am calling it The Final Destination. The class is all about mapping and creating abilities the tower did not approve and the more that will does it the more the tower tries to stop him in crazier and crazier ways. Will would be putting a timer on himself to increase his power exponentially before the tower can kill him. It is a bit more wishy washy in what Will could do with his abilities but to get away from the Diablo esc type with stats and combos I think we are past the point for the number stats truly mattering.

Harrison Vanderbyl

Idea for progression system: Mobile game prog system: Spends resources to unlock abilities, then forced to go and attempt to beat the floor, and then hes ripped apart, and either reconstructed back at the begining or sent back in time and can use collected miasma structures to build up his abilities to try make it further. And if he makes it to the next floor he is completely reset, so he has to do it all again on the next floor

Quazzy

wait i love that concept 😭 i do the same thing for story ideas so its rly cool to find that one of my fave authors does too!

Westin Lanser

Idk on the class but having it relate to the Will Special from the beginning of book 1 would be a nice book-end.

Cally JJ

The alternative I thought he was going for was full automated wizard. Every induvidual miasma shape has a special function so instead of looking at class/gear/ability synergies we can fully narrow down on ability synergies.

rwn

Ya I think it could also be a culmination of what he's done so far - miasma storage via Steve's body plus arbitrary note taking via legend, miasma intuition plus replay via the ring of wizardry, and self replicating faefireish structures to take small samples and make them larger (which is also kinda like PCR with miasma)

CrystCrunch

yes please, class revolving around creating and utilising miasmic structures and gear. kinda like what CCWTC could’ve been if the author wasn’t scared to write about the actual premise

Nicolas Symeou

Acts of merit get your prayers heard by more powerful entities, which give different abilities/ but have more demands (which balances out progression)?

Paul Foster

Brainstorming: Wizard - He's been pursuing the goal of being a wizard as defined by Ghoul since Ghoul first introduced the concept to him, it's only fitting. The class would be tied much more closely into direct miasma manipulation and free-form spells, combining everything he's been working on together into a neat package. It also fits with his connection to Ouroboros and the outsiders' connection to miasma. Maybe his new ring inspires him to lean into it? Progression could be tied into generating miasma, boosting free form spells, or even enhancing his ability to modify miasma constructs... maybe even miasma constructs inside of other climbers/beings. Concept: I love this idea and I think it could be super interesting to read. Lots of storytelling area to explore also. Things like: Does the homunculus continue to worship the same deity as it learns and grows? Is there a religious order for his deity and/or how will they interact with the little guy?

Vinohr

If Will is building a new class, it feels like only makes sense that he could take little snips of other classes to keep building his own. Taking inspiration from and stealing parts of the System's designs feels like a great way to make combinations it never allowed or expected

Prinny Knight

Mecha paladin, PRAISE TO THE MACHINE, DUES EX MACHINA!

Tsorov

If you want to dive in the Ouroboros thematic a bit more, maybe make the class have a really small pool of miasma, only that which can be stored in his own body, and make him only use low enrgy techniqes that have to return the miasma to him? Making a cycle of Miasma with Will as the center and the world as his conduit.

McIntosh Ewell

Idea for Will's new Class: System Progenitor / Keystone of Humanity / Insider Outsider Basically it leans into the versatility of his Magery. He has increased sensory powers, especially as they relate to miasma, structures and effects. He's still exceptional at traversing terrainbut now that definition extends far beyond the physical into the conceptual. To pair well with his perception, he has enhanced environment manipulation that lets him create better gear and spells (stored in wands I guess?) Lastly, he finally gains the ability to be in more than one place at a time (maybe tied to his legend in a reverse summoning type situation)

Macronomicon

I don't think i'll use the V-word, but yes, the MC will definitely have a large portion of maneater in him.

Joshua Sparkman

Please I love v word maybe a incubi that be nice

Ed Je

Im honestly so hyped for your homunculus paladin- super minion is in my top three favorite royal road books and i havent been able to find any other books which correctly replicate the vibe. Ill check out ur recs lol. As for progression systems for classes; He could attempt to remove the infinite loop cap on passives by inverting the use of charge and miasma; you need charge to gain and maintain stats that you can freely allocate, and you passively and freely allocate miasma to your various synergistic skills at will instead of using a kit to dictate terms. It becomes a balance of having the infinite loop not blow yourself up while maximizing your stats and effects or limiting your own internal cooldown as you level/ gain xp/miasma.

Ed Je

If it wasnt clear i meant that he should power his skills using infinite loops(instead of charge), and using charge instead for something non-standard or cant be looped. So the cleverness will be finding miasmic structures from kit that loop then powering new skills that can be freely manipulated to maximize loopage to the limits of miasma instead of dictated by the system through kit stats and sourdough.

Abomb1723

That could have a clear path to being a deity as well, and can come from Will being created by a deity.

CentaureHeart

I mean we have all loved Will being able to craft his gear so you could really turn him into the Craftsman or the Forger. And obviously that dude can fix himself and the Tower. And make outrageous gear

Lockwood

If he extrapolates the function of the "Forge of Will" floor effect then him making gear outside of the towers system that he can connect to in more intimate ways is 100% possible. He can already see the structures that support the gear equip function. What stops him from making his homebrewed(homebaked?) class with a more malleable equip function allowing him to widen or narrow gear imput valves. Narrow armor valves, widen accessory valves, swap kit to accommodate. Combo that with some dimensional fold fuckery for fast swap, some creative(previously useless) set creation and having some premade miasma structures he can slot in for gear equivalent boosts. If the miasma is what gives the boost then you could in theory strip away the physical item entirely, no? It just helps give the effect its structure via the conceptual reinforcement of the items understood usage and history.

WarmSoup

I really dig the paladin pitch. My mind immediately went to the idea that the little guy attracts the curiosity of the god that he worships (who wouldn't be intrigued by an unusual artificial soul devoutly worshipping them?) and so the deity pays closer attention/more favour on them than they would otherwise. An unusually attentive god//devotee relationship sounds entertaining to explore, especially if the paladin is naturally a bit ostracised from normal society. I can just imagine this D&D-esque homunculus wandering into a stricken town, drawing the ridicule of the townsfolk (after all, how's this foot tall Wizard's servant going to help any of them?), and then them all being rendered speechless as the little guy calls down the strongest Holy Strike any of them have ever heard of, instantly atomising the terror afflicting them. Then you cut to the internal dialogue and the homunculus is having a nonchalant Will//Loth-esque conversation about something completely different - still debating the merits of the previous town's clergy's cooking, for example. The image already has me cracking up, especially when I imagine it written with your style of humour. Loth's diminutive distant 20,000th cousin spreading the holy wrath of their benevolent god.

whistler

I absolutely loved Saihate no Paladin back when i was keeping up with it! Very glad to see it in your list of inspiration. I also have really enjoyed Penitant which slowly becomes more and more paladin-focused as the story goes on. I’d love to read the journeys of this pitiable pious thing you’ve got cooking up.

a passing Fnord

For writing the paladin and religious character there are some people who are so devout that they approach a sort of zen like approach to life. "What will be will be, it is all part of the world made by the gods, etc." Someone that actually embodies "the strength to change what I can and the wisdom to know what I cannot". An effective Paladin will always push the lever on the "trolley problem" either because they know that not doing it will cause more tragedy in the future, or to save others from having to get blood on their hands to make the world better. Basically the opposite of Batman's approach to justice and morality. Also, depending on how faith and "alignment" and the metaphysical definitions of "good" and "evil" in the setting you can absolutely rules lawyer some insane and fucked up things in the name of punishing evil or enacting a greater good. The "chaotic good barbarian" meme has some good examples of the "creative ways to punish evil" mindset.

whistler

(Suggestion/brainstorm) I can’t remember, has will been offered "miasma is a terrain" yet? In any case I think the new class should lean into the wizardry, without being *exclusively* wizard. I think there need to be some twist or added flavor.

whistler

The ring could become the seed, or center of his class/soul? Would work with Jason’s prophecy.

Senti

Reminding me of super minion is psychic torture I miss it :(

HUAAAANG

Class stuff? You've already got a Forge of Will spell lined up. And faefire. And a housing/shielding spell. Just gotta morph it into a foundry, then manufactorium, then... Basically, he needs access to a miasma type that when paired with faefire has an anti-destructive effect. And the liquid metal seems an excellent medium. It would be fitting to call his class Terminus or some such. Probably pair it with some angry baking kludges that Loth can mock. As to your Paladin: faith makes for poor character. The direct connection refutes any need for faith due to earned/granted knowledge, in which case "faith" can be used as a mask for the truth. The other side of the "faithless" coin is worth exploring.

DrSubterfuge

For what it's worth, the paladin stuff in Penitent doesn't really come together until the second book. The first book is military fantasy through and through, then the rest flip the weight much more toward general fantasy, with the paladin stuff as a major focus. I think the first book is a really good deconstruction of isakais where the person reincarnates as a kid with all their memories intact. It's some fucked up bodysnatching, actually, and every society has a different way to deal with it.

whistler

(Suggestion/brainstorm) His new class’s peak skill could be a summon/transformation mechanic where he can either summon or embody other Wills (or the other guys) from the past or future that specialize in whatever skill he needs. Say he needs an impenetrable defense, he can pop in The Guy Who’s Cheat Skill Is Defense.

whistler

This could also work as a way to keep the theme of summoned ghost-things (i already forgot the proper name).

whistler

(Suggestion/brainstorm) An interesting drawback to this new class could be an inability to properly slot equipment, giving up one source of power for more potent new skills. (It would also serve as excuse for you to drop the diablo/loot thing)

Selkie

Something I thought the story could potentially be building towards was HOW Will 'sacrifices' himself. He works out the entire System stuff, then like the pure spider being (devourer of worlds 2.0, whatever is name is), 'extracts' his class from himself. That extracted 'William Oh' is sacrificed, and he's 'left behind', like his hand is. Then, with a bit of help from Loth (and the temptation of treachery...) Will kick-starts his own class from scratch, and 'rebuilds' his own class entirely from the ground up. He gets to have his cake and eat it too.

雨宿りAma yadori

As someone with a genuine faith in a higher power who tries not to be a zealot (opinions may vary) would you like my thoughts, or would you prefer to keep your research more impersonal?

Natalie

His class becomes a Miasma-vore, he gains power by making a nice hearty Miasma stew, and just going to town on it

whistler

"Terminus" is a sick name. "Genesis" works if we want to emphasise a new beginning. "Pivot" or "Threshold" might be good for words that hint at keeping both of these in balance.

funktorial (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-02 11:00 I was kinda hoping for that xianxia yandere timeloop harem next, because that sounds insane and fun lol, and because I'd like to see your take on cultivation + more relationship drama. Not sure how I feel about the nonhuman paladin. That sounds very tricky to execute well (like, the character has to be both obviously virtuous and also not overly annoying? tricky!). I trust you to write something interesting though. --- I love the sacrifice progression system for abilities so much, so I'd be sad to see that gone for Will's new class. Any chance it sticks around in some form? Some random class ideas: - Double down on "Terrain" and become a full geomancer! Make homefield advantage a core ability and give attacks a damage-type based on the surrounding terrain. Without homefield advantage it probably sucks, because lava attacks aren't very good against lava monsters. - Inspired by Will's new wizard ring, a class that makes all equipment permanently bound to the user, but with opportunities for growth/evolution if you give the equipment a compatible sacrifice. - A scholar class that lets you substitute new information for experience (perhaps inspired by Devourer?). New miasmatic structures, new terrains, new classes, new Legend of William Oh jokes, etc. Every new bit of info pushes you a little further to the next level. Not really a combat class unless you're able to do unstructured magic already. - If you're familiar with Andrew Rowe's universe (he's the magic system goat imo), something like dominion sorcery. Spend stats to temporarily call forth different elemental magic types. Spend strength to make a fireball, spend resilience to make an earth spike, you get the idea. The idea is that it functions like physical exercise, so whatever you spend eventually comes back a little stronger than before but makes you technically weaker in the moment. Could give some variety to Will's magic and a path for increased stats that isn't just better equipment or more levels.
2026-11-01 22:16 I was kinda hoping for that xianxia yandere timeloop harem next, because that sounds insane and fun lol, and because I'd like to see your take on cultivation + more relationship drama. Not sure how I feel about the nonhuman paladin. That sounds very tricky to execute well (like, the character has to be both obviously virtuous and also not overly annoying? tricky!). I trust you to write something interesting though. --- I love the sacrifice progression system for abilities so much, so I'd be sad to see that gone for Will's new class. Any chance it sticks around in some form? Some random class ideas: - Double down on "Terrain" and become a full geomancer! Make homefield advantage a core ability and give attacks a damage-type based on the surrounding terrain. Without homefield advantage it probably sucks, because lava attacks aren't very good against lava monsters. - Inspired by Will's new wizard ring, a class that makes all equipment permanently bound to the user, but with opportunities for growth/evolution if you give the equipment a compatible sacrifice. - A scholar class that lets you substitute new information for experience (perhaps inspired by Devourer?). New miasmatic structures, new terrains, new classes, new Legend of William Oh jokes, etc. Every new bit of info pushes you a little further to the next level. Not really a combat class unless you're able to do unstructured magic already.

I was kinda hoping for that xianxia yandere timeloop harem next, because that sounds insane and fun lol, and because I'd like to see your take on cultivation + more relationship drama. Not sure how I feel about the nonhuman paladin. That sounds very tricky to execute well (like, the character has to be both obviously virtuous and also not overly annoying? tricky!). I trust you to write something interesting though. --- I love the sacrifice progression system for abilities so much, so I'd be sad to see that gone for Will's new class. Any chance it sticks around in some form? Some random class ideas: - Double down on "Terrain" and become a full geomancer! Make homefield advantage a core ability and give attacks a damage-type based on the surrounding terrain. Without homefield advantage it probably sucks, because lava attacks aren't very good against lava monsters. - Inspired by Will's new wizard ring, a class that makes all equipment permanently bound to the user, but with opportunities for growth/evolution if you give the equipment a compatible sacrifice. - A scholar class that lets you substitute new information for experience (perhaps inspired by Devourer?). New miasmatic structures, new terrains, new classes, new Legend of William Oh jokes, etc. Every new bit of info pushes you a little further to the next level. Not really a combat class unless you're able to do unstructured magic already.

Joe ?

Idea for will's progression: I'm not sure about making things more comfortable exactly, but I think the obvious answer is, of course, renowned based progression. The class could be called: The Legend. That makes it the titular Legend of William Oh. First it runs on the impact he's had on his friends, then the people of his stronghold, then all the people still alive in the tower, then it goes back through the timeline, all the little legends that used to start the chapters. Then he breaks his own continuity, all the Legends of all the William Ohs, the Serpents, the Paragons. And that's how he gauge the godlike strength required to pull off all the stuff he has to do. Then he ascends to being the god of legends and heroes. The little guy against great forces, with his talent, hard work, and a lot of luck. The Legend so great, he created himself.

whistler

I feel like "The Bestest Gear Ever" wouldn’t be cool enough unless you go all the way, like forging raw miasma into items that also function as wearable unique skills.

Joe ?

Also Jason naturally rides his coattails to become the minor deity of public relations

Finn

I think a cool idea for his class would for it, like will, to constantly be learning and changing with every encounter. Every new creature or environment that uses miasma differently his class will slowly learn from and become able to better counter or replicate it and similar things

HUAAAANG

In transportation, the end of the line is also the beginning. I was trying to adhere to the industry angle. I suppose a continuation into a two word class name would be something like "Ignition Terminus." Still annoyed I went mechanical when we need bakeries.

Jacob Armstrong

Pathfinder 2e has an archetype called a beastgunner, based on making weapons from the corpses of monsters. An ability that lets Will use sacrifice materials as crafting materials would play on Sourdough in a fun way. Will turning himself into a reality anchor, where monsters that are purely miasma are forced to manifest in a more physical, and therefore more killable, state. Kind of a “drag you down to my level and beat you with experience” approach. Will attempts to grant himself the ability to use unlimited sacrifices and/or purge sacrifices to make way for new ones. The unintended side effect is that the sacrifices cause physical mutations related to the effect of each sacrifice. Will kidnaps the entire pool of butler mind soup from the tower and creates a necromancer build that lets butlers possess monsters. Alternatively he finds a way to drag Castavelle and Ezekiel’s minds into his timeline for the same purpose. Will’s body gains physical and mental stats when he’s full on charge, but loses them as he spends it. Starts fights as a strong physical fighter, but gets weaker as he uses magic.

Jack Thomas-boddy

Will has developed taking inspiration from everything he sees, largely from the tower and system itself. His ring and map already are starting to replicate the system (learning abilities, noting misamic forms and spells etc). What if the new progression made him his own tower? He creates "floors" as he copies and iterates on what he sees. Maybe something similar to the terrain amulet, but more conceptual or self designed? It would let him grant his ideas for improved versions of classes to his companions (meaning they can keep up better) and he could turn defeated beings into gear directly, designing loot like he does with Sourdough.

Fire209

For the class, it'd be interesting if Will took inspiration from the Tower itself. Or maybe the way it folds, at least, Building up to certain thresholds before folding down and incrementing I guess. I'd imagine that as he builds up each layer there's an empowering, but a growing instability, until he crests the wave and crunches it down raising his 'floor' a bit. I don't have much in mind power wise though.

Fire209

As for the other book idea, Yeah that sounds awesome. Super Minion was definitely a book a lot of us missed, so if you're drawing inspiration from its progression I'd love to read that. A paladin is interesting, most of your protagonists have been somewhat self-interested or just broadly interested in protecting the world, so this would be a neat shift.

Macronomicon

My study is less about the real life experience and more about how to write a story about it in a way that hypes up the audience.

Trathnonen

So far the class seems to be mostly revolving around space manipulation. There's an element of time, since he keeps reliving his past lives, and he's an incarnation of the eternal serpent. So his new class could be the Singularity. He shifts and controls space-time, since he's a terrain manipulator, but now that includes changing gravity by curving space time, or trapping areas inside a relativistic slowfield, where the distance they try to cover keeps doubling, keeping them frozen in place, or accelerating objects by doing the opposite, shortening the distances. Think JJK's Gojo limitless technique.

Sylphie

What if Will’s final Class didn’t progress by getting stronger, but by gaining the ability to break increasingly fundamental rules of the System? [Class: The Exception] Instead of levels, Will earns Exceptions: narrowly defined permissions to violate an existing rule, while having stats. Early progression might let him change a single word in an ability description, bypass an activation condition, or transfer a restriction from one ability to another. Later progression could allow him to impose new rules on an entire battlefield, or temporarily rewrite a fundamental System constraint. The catch: every Exception must have a corresponding limitation, and the more fundamental the rule, the more expensive or dangerous it becomes to violate. Here’s the twist I’d especially love: tie Exceptions to Will’s growing legend. Each widely believed story about William Oh could unlock a specific rule he is allowed to break. That creates two entirely different progression paths: engineering increasingly ridiculous combinations, and manipulating the stories people tell about him. It also feels thematically perfect for The Legend of William Oh. Instead of becoming the character with the biggest numbers, Will becomes the guy who wins because he understands the rules better than the people who wrote them. And imagine the final confrontation being resolved not by dealing more damage, but by changing a single word in the victory condition.

Sylphie

For example, his first ability could be: [One Exception] Once per day, you may change a single word in the description of an ability you possess. Imagine changing “Target ONE enemy within sight” to “Target EVERY enemy within sight.” The progression could look something like this: Stage 2: Modify an activation condition. Stage 3: Swap restrictions between two abilities. Stage 4: Create a new rule that applies to everyone in an area, including Will. Stage 5: Temporarily rewrite one fundamental law of the System itself. Obviously, there would need to be limitations, costs, and consequences to prevent this from becoming completely broken (although knowing Will, he’d find a way to break those too). What I love about this concept is that progression would no longer be about bigger numbers, better loot, or increasingly ridiculous damage multipliers. It would be about creativity, loopholes, and exploiting the exact wording of the System. Every fight becomes a puzzle. Readers could actively try to figure out the most ridiculous combinations before Will does. And it feels incredibly fitting for his character. He’s always been at his best when using seemingly insignificant mechanics in ways nobody anticipated. I think this could give you an almost unlimited playground for the kind of clever, absurd, occasionally hilarious problem-solving that made William Oh so much fun to read in the first place. But it could break you, Mac

Sylphie

Instead of gaining XP through killing enemies, Will would progress by discovering and successfully exploiting loopholes in the System, establishing something called Precedents. Every time he demonstrates a previously unknown interpretation or contradiction in the System’s rules, the System is forced to acknowledge it. [New Precedent Established] You have demonstrated that self-inflicted damage does not exclude damage caused by a detached part of your own body. Precedents: 4/7 — Progress toward next Exception. Repeating the same exploit earns no progression. Will must constantly discover genuinely new loopholes. And the System gradually patches previously exploited ones, forcing him to become increasingly creative. I’d also introduce a principle of Consistency: Will can manipulate rules, but consequences don’t simply disappear. Changing “once per day” to “once per second” might compress an entire day’s exhaustion into those few seconds. And for the ultimate progression? Will eventually discovers that the System itself is violating one of its own fundamental rules. He establishes a Precedent against the System itself, earning the authority to overrule it. Just William Oh effectively suing the laws of reality and winning. That feels like a very Will thing to do. :D

Infinate Fail

Since his class has been about traveling, and he has reached the end of the road, this new one would fit really well as one thats more of a guide, to help others follow the path that he paved, like a beacon to follow

雨宿りAma yadori

So like how the paladin in D&D Honour Among Thieves is an unrealistic charicature, but a hoot to watch?

Not You

Two things: first I love the new story idea. Paladin stuff is so fun and your inspirations are very good reference. I love a good non-human character, so I’m all aboard and will buy anything you put out. Second thing for Will, systemancy is fun. I’ll toot my own horn about non-traditional system stuff, and my story on royal road: building a magic system on threat of destruction. Things like using system prompts to adjust people’s power, or even using things like screens or prompts to interfere with people. Can’t wait to see how it plays out. I loved Willam oh for the Diablo style looter builds, and stayed for the cool story, world, fights, and style you bring to your writing. Can’t wait for more of macronomicon!

Ranger Science

Will isn’t just making a new Class. He’s central to making the Tower System in the first place - which means considering *why* there’s even levels, etc in the first place. What’s even the point of having slots every ten levels? Why does sacrifice rarity mean anything? Otherwise; why doesn’t Will just give himself a class of infinite power?

Ranger Science

Will’s actual Class is System Designer. He’s travelled the breadth of the world, now he’s the one making it. Primary abilities have to do with modifying other people’s Classes, and modifying Floors themselves.

houff

So is this basically going to be the tumblr meme about the Catholic homunculus turned into a full length novel? Was that the genesis of the idea?

Cozy Book Corner

I was thinking about the density of the miasma. Thinking that if Will is reborn on the 50th floor then he has the density that pushes his baseline to the perfected human realm and then it becomes a cultivation vessel story. He can already give himself any class ability but that can only take you so far. Eventually you just need to get a bigger bucket to throw it all in

Skipping

One idea for a non human progression system that I really enjoyed before the author dropped the novel was alien evolution system; an unfeeling bio weapon created by a hivemind to kill gods gets disconnected from the hivemind and ends up in a magical world. It has to learn to understand emotions to cultivate magic and gets a system esque aspect from a shard of the splintered hive mind left behind before the disconnect. It’s pretty different from your initial idea but the inhuman perspective and discovery of emotions by an unfeeling being was a fun read, not to mention mixing biological evolution with magic for two different progression paths.

SV

For brainstorming: There are already so many great suggestions, but I might as well throw my ideas at the wall. The map and legend already serves as a kind of spell book, maybe that can be expanded? First thing that comes to mind is vancian prepared spells. Not sure about that since Will can freecast. Adaptability has always been Will's thing, so I imagine the new class should allow him adjust his build on the fly, moving around points between stats. Since he keeps cutting his hand off and the concept of sacrifices. What about for the new class, since it will be disconnected from the tower, he can sacrifice body parts (temporarily until they grow back) for different boons. Due to the disconnect to the tower only his bodyparts count. Sacrificing eye for mental stats for example. To reflect the snake theme, the new class could allow Will to create a layer of 'skin' from miasmic structure that can be shed and changed out. Parts of the shed skin can also have static spells that can be activated when shed. For paladin story: Really like the idea. It is ripe with potential. If you are looking for more inspirations I can recommend looking into Michael and the knight of the cross from the Dresden Files Also it reminds me that I need start on Small Gods.

SkippyARC

This would also serve the idea of Loth "killing" Will as prophesied

whistler

If you watch the linked video you’d see that is an animation for that exact story.

Exrotes

Paladin story s ounds neat, assuming it's a D&D/Pathfinder style world defining the domains of the patron god in advance would be good. As far as Will's custom class goes he should return to his roots and get Gravity/Goat powers again and actually explore the limits of messing with physics like teleporting via Black and White holes.

MFW I See Someone T-Posing

I remember reading about the worship homunculus on Tumblr, very cool concept to look into! I suggest reading about SCP foundation's Tactical Theology hub for the wizard's viewpoint on the matter https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/tactical-theology-hub There's a bunch of articles linked but the overview and history is whats important. Its kinda similar to what Perry Z thought of his gods to be honest

Tokufan178

Class designed to “molt”. Maybe when his body reaches full saturation in the miasma dimension it gives a new chance to be reborn & expands his abilities/ miasma domain. Could also be a physical change along with it turning his body closer to an outsider’s. Embryo would be a nice name. Crafting new abilities and implanting them in himself to control the local miasma like a living homefield amulet.

Ethan B.

I mean for the whole Will's new class system he's been leading up to becoming a wizard so maybe the class just enables him to use the charge he has to make custom spells with some being pre-given like Will's magic missile and the ability to perceive miasma.

Tate Browder

You should read ELLC lowk it has great gods

Kev Gamm

Is there really enough narrative space for another book or two? With how fast the power scaling has been, we are quickly approaching the point where abilities are transcending the capacity for language to describe them. As for the class itself, keep it simple: Wizard, where the class progresses with the number, variety, and understanding of spells created. Beyond this, the implementation really depends upon whether the class can query the greater system or is totally independent, and if Will's current class progress is kept or completely deleted. Concerning the next story, I think rather than a paladin a CLERIC is a far more intriguing idea. Specifically, I'd love to see a story about a kid becoming a cleric for a tiny insignificant god/spirit and growing together in power and importance. Small Gods is one of my favorite Pratchett books, and I think playing off this idea could be a lot of fun. For inspiration, see Cat's relationship with Sve Noc in The Practical Guide to Evil or Jin Rou & Tianlan in Beware of Chicken. This could also be an opportunity to run a more obfuscated power system- that's not to say 'soft', but with the stats hidden behind the curtain.

unmellow the gamer

Oh my god super minion mention. Really wish that would come back. As for ideas. I love ar'kendryst and something along the lines of the end game power system would be cool. Having to decide on who he is and what he stands for, a system that rewards you with power for sticking to your beleifs, and powers more being about giving what he is trying to accomplish through trial and error rather then just finding the right resource. Could even pair well with the other cultivation suggestion. Just call this a "day"

unmellow the gamer

I too missed industrial strength magic and live absent this.

Melody Haren Anderson

My thought is he becomes almost somewhere between a fae, a jinn, and a god. By granting power, it creates a feedback. But he's unlike gods because he can safely be among humans. He becomes an architect that enables others to weave their own fate. Allowing all to transcend the need for the tower.

Sands

For your new story you should check out paladin of the forsaken lands by Jollybane if you haven’t read it yet. He’s been able to do some fun things. He’s also got another story called remnant knight. Both stories might give you some ideas of how you could do the paladin part

Leph

Class suggestion: why stop at a custom class? Have him make his own personal custom system! It sounds like he's gonna have a great view of the major parts of the system on floor 50, and it seems unlikely that the original system would take very kindly to a class that it did not design itself. As for what that might mean, quirk-wise: -The custom system is intelligent, and really snarky. -The custom system is stored entirely within his body to protect it from volatile miasma effects, so instead of sacrificing things to the Tower, he now has to straight-up eat them so that his system can get at them. -Custom stats. Entirely new ones, optimized versions of existing ones or both. -No infinite loop protection. As a side effect, Will becomes a god. Seems like a fitting finale to the story. -Instead of being granted "experience" by his system, it will automatically take in the ambient miasma and turn it into Stats. Will has to hold still for this, though. -No ability limit, but Will has to make all of his own abilities. And that's all I thought of. (Sorry if this looks really scuffed on PC, I don't think I did the formatting right)

Anon_Anon

For the final class, maybe something that delves more deeply into the idea of using myths/sentient beings' emotions for power? It's been lightly touched upon with Jason's Relic Seed ability as well as with how set items being created when a lot of sentient creatures die at once but it would be fun to see how Will could weaponize his own legend.

AG

Could have it that he levels by improving his efficiency and effectiveness so can cast the same spells for less and eventually improve them into better more powerful versions

AG

I like the theme

Frosty Potatos

Super Minion... Man I miss it. I hope the author the best. New story sounds great. Maybe have a little boon from the god he prays to. Maybe an angel on his shoulder type thing with advice that helps everyone at a cost to him. Oh! And it would be funny if an evil God/Devil also likes him because he was technically defrauding the good god and grants a boon/ little demon on his shoulder with advice that helps him at a cost to others. As for William Oh, I just want to see him uno reverse Holdna and Daddy Ouroboros into a gift for Loth or something. His class could be "William Oh", or "The Legend". And work less gear based and more soft magic based. Or even just the funny route. Like a certain magical index. There's a bad guy makes whatever he believes real regardless of if it's harmful to himself.. could go, William Oh once beat a God, by making it believe it was weaker than him. It was Right!

AG

That would be rather interesting and potentially solve the issue of miasma sickness

Selkie

On the paladin note, would be happy to discuss! I wrote a paladin character at one point, and I could send you Valkyrie's Dawn (Paladin MC short story)

dragonsFire

I absolutely love the idea for the new book, my favorite character in all the web novels I'm reading atm (Vi from Deuterium Prayers) is also very much a paladin. Her connection with her gods is incredibly well done and both she and her pantheon are very entertaining. From your story concept, I like the idea that rather than the church of this god going after the wizard, the god themself takes notice that they're being scammed therefore takes an unusual imterest in the MC but can't bring themself to kill the poor creature. Then they step in to orchestrate the escape through a comedy of luck and errors

Roeland

I have followed you on and off since wake of the ravager and your greatest strength has always been (to me) turning standard tropes/mechanisms on their head and making me think. As long as you keep working that into your stories to some extent then you got me hooked.

Roeland

Its been great :)

Aloysius

NPCs (Spells, Swords, Stealth Book 1) by Drew Hayes has an interesting take on the god to worship, where there is a god of Minions that tries to protect the minions of the world. The wizard probably had it pray to a popular and powerful god initially but when the homunculus is by itself it could lose the initial target god? That then hopefully a god closer to home picks him up afterwards. Or maybe that is the end goal for the homunculus minion to become... Genuine faith in a power that you know has your better interest at heart can make you let go of the wheel at times, so to say. I can imagine an exasperated god trying to protect the little guy while also being limited in the ways it can help beyond what the little guy got himself or deserved from a divine-to-mortal-karma standpoint.

Aloysius

I would imagine Will's class to just be... Will. A real class that truly resembles the person would just be a soul wouldn't it? If you want to have Will's class show itself to be a different progression system, maybe let the class be a Soul that everyone then starts with and protects them from the miasma but not have any abilities yet. However, their Souls are constantly in touch with the miasma around them and can filter abilities in the air that respond with their Souls until it can click into a Skill. This Skill grows as they grow and Experience more (miasma), but if they develop new personality tendencies or goals, a new ability can grow simultaneously. Additionally, with something akin to a soul- or familiarbond, you can connect to items, creatures, divinity or other beings (all with souls) to both learn from them and borrow their ability through them, although they also grow (although an unfair bond diminishes the growth for both parties with the lesser side in the affair being most impacted)

Adam Roundfield

I like the Paladin idea and you have a good record of ideas I like so if the idea is sticky for you then it is probably good for me. The custom class idea that popped into my brain is: Original Sin as in the recognition of how an organism is both separate from and a part of its environment, abstracted out into building custom ontological frameworks to modify both the organism and environment in intentional ways but requiring some sort of "audit trail" to maintain the causal integrity of both. Implementation is always the trickiest part...

Lizard Brain

I think it might be super baller to have Will's class as-close-to or entirely loaded up within his phantom hands somehow. They already have a method for storing miasmatic structures (abilities + spells) as well as boosting them to absurd degrees. Him making more phantom hands than two would also be fun to see, and you might be able to wrap up the functionality of both the hands and the eyes into one Eidolon to give those a bit more juice

Lizard Brain

Thinking about it more, his hand was his first ability, it'd kinda wrap things up nicely if it was his "last" / first of the new class

Plot Twist

New class idea for will where he fashions his own armor and weapons out of the monsters he slays like monster hunter for resistance and abilities. I cant remember how large the hand storage was but he should have some valuable stuff still like a bit of living metal and other such "monster" parts that might pop out when he "dies"

BlackCat

Will’s new class: I kind of thought you were headed into the ‘reverse engineer’ territory where he creates these crazy powerful relics but then just pulls the pattern out into a spell for his ring so if he gets stripped of his class by the tower, he can imprint those spells using the tattoo method he saw those warring tribes do way back on the (twenty?) somethingth floor. But that’s too easy, the thing that I loved so much about jeb in the stitched worlds was that he lost everything (first time I read it I was SO mad!!) and even though he was down for a bit, he pulled himself back up the hard way - AND he went counter to his first build. Maybe this time Will has to lean hard into one specific type of miasma structure bc the others are too complex or unstable? Maybe Ghoul shares more of his backstory and that gives Will a glimpse into what is running the tower (like if there’s a known vulnerability with the code version or encryption/signing they used for sysadmin access to the controls or something). Maybe his ‘jack of all trades’ needs to become a master of one and that is becoming a ‘weaver’ like the devourer of knowledge? That could be cool if he has to have a training montage about weaving dense miasma into real physical constructs 🤔 Idk, I just finished reading the ‘John dies at the end’ series and picked up the newest one today so I’m in an eldritch comedy mindset 😅

Mahadma

holy shit the paladin story idea is awesome!

Mrfacemanlol

New story: You should go on royal road and read a story called “a real human being” it’s a frieren fanfic with the best representation of a religious character I have seen in years and the premise of the story is kind of similar to your own idea

Ashen-Shugar

It must be good, the series ended I take it?

Ashen-Shugar

The naming system and synergy sets, I get it, haven't played Diablo in Forever