Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

*FREEING HEADPHONE WARNINGS*

This episode kept going in any direction except the one I expected! Asa finally confronts her isolation head on and finds an unlikely person to ask the question: Is it okay to stand out? To NOT stand out? And the answer is quite inspiring, indeed!

LINK TO REACTION: https://pixeldrain.com/l/wrY9uR9J

Thank you for watching with me and for all the support!

Files

Romania Black - Journal With Witch: Episode 11 Reaction! SET FREE?!

LINK TO REACTION: https://pixeldrain.com/l/wrY9uR9J **FREEING HEADPHONE WARNINGS** This episode kept going in any direction except the one I expected! Asa finally confronts her isolation head on and finds an unlikely person to ask the question: Is it okay to stand out? To NOT stand out? And the answer is quite inspiring, indeed! Thank you for watching with me and for all the support! #romaniablack #journalwithwitch #jww Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/RomaniaBlack My Anime: https://myanimelist.net/profile/RomaniaBlack Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/RomaniaBlack You can mail me a letter or anything (except food, please) at this address: Romania Black PO Box 768 Harrisburg, IL 62946 USA

Comments

domdodom

this was such a chill episode, thanks for the reaction 🥰🙂

Alexandra Q

I really like this episode, there are some reaally cool moments in here. Something that occurred to me as I was watching your reaction is how Asa maybe left her journal open at the beginning because with her mom she wasn't allowed/didn't feel like she could her own thoughts and opinions. We've seen how Minori, in a missguided want to set her daughter for success, was very controllig of Asa's actions; like when she chose choir club for her daughter, and basically telling her that "mother-knows-best". Makio, on the other hand, has encouraged her from the beginning to have her own thoughts and make her own choices - we even see it in this episode with Makio's refusal to give easy answers to Asa and telling her to think harder. So I think the journal represents that journey for Asa; open for a mother that offered her input all the time and needed to know everything, where she felt she couldn't make the right choice herself and needed her mother for everything; shut for an aunt that allows her the freedom to have her own thoughts and to wrestle with her emotions herself. And I do love the way that Makio makes Asa think. How she, unwittingly at points as with the words Asa has been researching, broadens Asa mind. It's really neat to see. Especially when you think how Asa has helped Makio process her own emotions a little bit better, and being a bit of a better communicator. They've both helped each other grow by virtue of cohabitation. Which is also what Juno was talking about in the previous episode, and how they have both left an imprint in each others' lives already. Then we have the wonderful discussion about "types" and how we so easily fall into these labels for ourselves. I hope that Asa can continue to be bolstered into finding and being exactly who she is. And I love how her singing, as randomly perfect as it is, can be the beginning of her shaking off the labels her parents, in this case her father, put on her. Finally, after so many episodes, we get a better view at the dad, and I like that you called him depressed, because that is exactly the impression I get from him. He said that he would stay with Minori not for her, because he didn't want to be a husband - or at least a husband to her - but because he wanted to be a father to their baby... and then we see him doing the barest minimum if at that, and lookind absolutely miserable on top. My first instinct is to be mad at him for failling spectacularly at being there for Asa and caring, but thinking over the life that he took on being not what he wanted to do in life I can see him being depressed and deeply frustrated with his life. Not that I excuse him for being a neglectful parent, because Asa isn't at fault of the bad decisions both her parents took that made them so unhappy; even if I do understand that Japanese culture puts so much pressure over families and individuals and how they should act and be. I love that Kasamichi shows his favoritism over Makio bluntly and bought her the biggest box of chocolate. Clearly, Makio likes chocolate because she ends up eating Asa's last piece.

Sunspots

Loved the reaction and discussion! Another amazing episode with us getting to see some of the lives of the people who surround Asa. 🥰 Various things I loved: Yuto being a sweet boy asking about Chiyo and then trying to learn about the situation 🥰 Glad that that boy from the baseball team stood up for himself, yes! Knowing Yumi is someone who makes people chocolates, that’s so sweet 🥰 That “Natsume” scene! Knew you’d love it 🤣 Makio’s friend Motsu being kind and encouraging Asa My absolute favourite moment is the scene where Makio says to “Give them hell!” Just beautiful! 🥹 We all deserve a Makio in our life. That kind of encouragement, I feel, is so good for Asa to hear in general but also specifically in that moment. And maybe Makio truly does believe it when she says that Asa would have come to join the band-club regardless of anything – but I personally don’t know whether that is true. If Asa had still been around her parents? I don’t think so. So I think this is another example of Makio carefully choosing how to build Asa’s confidence and experience with making choices, and Makio does it by directly denying taking ‘credit’ for something that quite clearly happened because she created the environment where Asa felt able to make that choice for herself. Whether Makio truly believes it or made this small choice, it was exactly the right thing for that moment! 🥰 Looking forward to the next episode! 💙

Romania Black

A very cool episode, indeed, and I wasn't expecting the routes it took! Thank you for the comment!

Romania Black

Thank you so much for the comment and kind words!! Yessss, so much happening “around” Asa this week! I love Yuto in this episode! I’m rooting for him! And YES, glad that baseball ace stood up for himself! Seeing Yumi have a chocolate “industry” going on was great – and YES, hahaha, although, the Natsume scene just made me miss the anime even more! T_T And Motsu was such an MVP – sometimes you need that “third party” to give advice when someone won’t listen to the person nearest, and Motsu did just what was needed to reach Asa, finally. GIVE THEM HELL - I love that part so much as well, with them in the desert! Makio is such a good aunt! And I agree 100% with all you say about choice in that part of the episode! Thank you for the comment and so looking forward to it as well!

Romania Black

This episode did have so many good moments! From the discussion, I completely agree with your notes about the journal, and I love that connection to Minori vs. Makio for it being open and shut - nice! But yes, Makio gets Asa to THINK, which is so wonderful! She’s just an awesome aunt in all this. And the whole TYPE conversation, yes! I definitely feel the dad just doesn’t WANT to be there, but feels obliged. I do feel that he should take accountability for not wanting to be there, and all that goes with THAT, but I do feel for him being depressed in the situation. And then there’s the cultural expectations on top of that, so yeah, just an all around “quiet MESS.” And seriously, Kasamichi fools NO ONE, giving Makio the most chocolate. :3 What a sweetie! Thank you for the comment!