Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Question about Pre-Supported Minis

  • I Want Pre Supported Files for Resin Printing 510
  • I Want Pre Supported Files for FDM Printing 93
  • I Would Pay More for Pre Supported Files 121
  • I Would NOT pay more for Pre Supported Files. 395
  • I Like Supporting My Own Files 206
  • 2020-04-03
  • 1325 votes
{'title': 'Question about Pre-Supported Minis', 'choices': [{'text': 'I Want Pre Supported Files for Resin Printing', 'votes': 510}, {'text': 'I Want Pre Supported Files for FDM Printing', 'votes': 93}, {'text': 'I Would Pay More for Pre Supported Files ', 'votes': 121}, {'text': 'I Would NOT pay more for Pre Supported Files. ', 'votes': 395}, {'text': 'I Like Supporting My Own Files', 'votes': 206}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2020, 4, 3, 0, 45, 46, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 1325}

Content

Hey guys, lately I've been getting requests and questions about pre-supporting our models. 

As some of you may remember, we did this in the past, over a year ago. And most users were not even using them. That's why we stopped. 

It does represent extra work and it's not our area of expertise, so we're thinking very carefully about how to implement this step to our workflow while providing great quality on supported files. 

Times have changed and a lot of new supporters have joined. So we're all ears and would like to know your opinions about this topic. 

I'll add some options to the poll, please select the ones that are true for you. 


If you want to add anything else, please comment on it in this post. As always, I'll try to go through all the comments and respond. 

Thanks!

Comments

StarlightFoundry

If done can they be in their own separate folder away from the group folder so the download won't be huge?

Tom Boucher

I'm probably a weird one. I wouldn't mind getting supported files, as they'd speed up my ability to print things, but honestly it's kind of zen for me to do the support stuff so paying extra for them wouldn't be something I'd be overly excited about enough to pay more.

Jefferson Thacker

So I appreciate pre supported models when I can get them but I cant justify paying more for them. That money could go to another creator or artist and I can make my own supports easily enough.

Hayden Robertson

Would it be possible to add a couple supportless models each month as an option?

Painbow

The thing I'm the biggest fan of is supportless minis. I would pay extra for a tier that added on a handful of support free models each month!

Cast n Play

Yes, they would separate for the current archive folder.

Cast n Play

That's a valid point. Thanks, Jefferson.

Cast n Play

That is a great idea, Hayden! I'll speak to the team more about this.

Cast n Play

Yep, that's exactly what we used to do back in the day.

Mike Smith

If you move to supported files, I would hope that you offer an option both ways. For those of us who don't want built in supports, it is very frustrating.

BearlyKnownPrints

I love pre supported minis, I even wrote to you guys way back when to thank you for doing it, as it was great help. However, I personally would not like to increase the price for super premium supports. I think what you guys used to do was great, just send a copy of the supported minis as you printed them for your testing. That way is work that you already do, and are just sharing a benefit with the patreons.

Cast n Play

Thanks for the feedback, Painbow! That probably seems like the way to do it.

GM Numbat

As someone who doesn't actually own a printer yet, I really must abstain at this time. I suspect I would really value supports once I am able to start printing.

Cast n Play

Absolutely. This would be just an option, not a change from the current plan.

Chuck Beckmann

I understand it’s time consuming, as I spend hours supporting models myself. I pay extra for artisan guild pre supported files and to be honest...I print and paint more of their modes than anyone’s, because I can throw them right on the printer and I don’t have to sit around supporting models one by one for hours. I think if the price is right to justify whoever does the files for you, it’s completely worth it!

Cast n Play

Thank you for the honest feedback! The truth is, I personally don't mind over supporting things since I'm very patient when removing them. But I know for sure the way I support my minis would not be what most people expect.

Cast n Play

Thanks for the honest feedback and insight, Chuck!

BearlyKnownPrints

I'm the same way, I would rather spend a few minutes removing supports than have a fail print, as I usually print several things at the same time. Like I said, would love them but they don't have to be this super amazing Youtube standard supports. Just knowing that they'll print fine is good enough, At least for me.

Marti3P

I support my own files, I'll download them if they are there but I'd not pay extra for it, that being said I'd drop out if it meant an increase of a current tier, if its a new one then it wouldn't effect me. :-)

Sam Kay

I would appreciate pre-supported files, but I've come to the conclusion that if I want to print something, I can support it myself.

Tom Frisby

I think pre-supported minis is going to be the future standard. More and more artists are going to it. As for price, Cast N' Play's patreon is already a little higher than many other artists, so consider that in your decision.

Joshua Garner

Hey, I love pre supported files as much as the next guy, but you do what works for you. Most of us love your files pre supported or not, so just make sure it's something you can handle before you commit to it.

Nicholas

So it seems in general that the patreon 3d files market is slowly moving towards supported files. I see you guys are recognizing this and bringing the topic back up in response, which is smart. I'm on 8 patreons and 4 of them offer either most or fully supported files. Without naming names, I'm on one very large one that started charging +$8 for supported files. I pay that, but begrudgingly because I don't think it is a reasonable price given how much money that represents across their potential base. And it doesn't take that much work to support the files--especially if the person can take advantage of the better autosupport algorithms like prusa's to get a head start (why do people still need to do all the chitu supports 100% manually one at a time?). One person only has to do it once. It's not like sculpting--a ton of work! Yet the price is almost as much as the models. Another patreon offered it free of charge as a nice surprise. Blown away with that and very generous of them. Although obviously that represents more work from them--I think it is smart because it is a huge value-add without having to crank out more creative content. If I was deciding between them and another--it would break a tie for me. Some people might not use the files--but I'm not sure why (either a file prints cleanly or it does not--no need to reinvent the wheel and it is not a fun task). I don't think it is unreasonable to charge, however, so I think these two scenarios above represent the two extremes. Obviously any pricing and time commitments are a business decision for you guys to make. Couple last things from reading comments - Supportless - please don't. Resin printers you still need to tilt back the model and add supports to reduce suction and open up vent holes on the base, as you guys know. Supportless models just reduces the creativity in the sculpts and leads to boring sculpts. Things should always be designed to be reasonably printable, of course. Community driven models - I think consistency is too important. I don't just want supported files... I want supported files from someone I trust to do a consistent, predictable (and smart) support job on the files. Otherwise I'd do it myself and that defeats the point. Thanks for listening to the community guys!

James Green

Another artist has a seperate tier of support for presupported models. You could consider that as an option?

Scott Frega

I like adding my own supports. Everytime I get presupported models, they end up either cracking or leaving issues on the model.

VigoTheButch

I generally hit delete on a lot of the presupported files I get when I load them up in Chitubox and look critically at their placement. Artisan Guild did a good move getting Greg who is probably the best in the game so I would trust those ones. Some people don't care a ton about their print quality as long as it is close and doesn't fail, hence why autosupports are so popular. I take a lot of pride in my print quality and if I feel like a Patreon is giving me fewer minis for my money because they are spending time supporting files I am unlikely to use, then that decreases the value of the monthly pledge for me.

Captain Feathersword

If you're test printing anyway, I think it makes sense to just release your own tested and proven files. But I'd definitely rather see the Cast n Play team focus on making excellent models rather than faffing about with supports just for release. Also, you have an excellent community behind you. If any of your supporters have printed models, allow them to submit models to you for inclusion in the release folder? If you wanted to incentivize this a little, offer gumroad coupons for models that they don't have or the such? Instead of I creasing your workload, create a community incentive? Maybe a bonus model every month if the community can provide a complete set of pre-supported and test printed models every month? I think that it's one thing to release supported models, and another thing to make sure that they're proven to print. I love another of my patreons because they test print all of their work and release their own supported files. But, they're only releasing 2-3 models/month 🙂

Caesar Rahardjo

I am fine wth the presupported files, though i don't have any printer yet. I just do not agree with xtra tier for supported files but if you guys think it needed an extra tier, i am fine with that too. As long as making the presupported files do not disturb your productivity. As of now, some creator are making extra tier for making presupported files while some others do not and included it on their service which is a good thing i guess

Cast n Play

Thanks for the feedback and consideration, Joshua. Much appreciated!

Cast n Play

Thanks for taking the time to write this. It really helps a lot! I appreciate the feedback!

Cast n Play

yes, it would not affect current plans. It would only be an option,.

Cast n Play

That's the reason why I'm hesitant about this. I would like to put something out that is tested before delivered to make sure it is great.

Cast n Play

It would not be auto supports, that's for sure. And the reason why I am asking this is that I know this is not our specialty. We would have to bring someone who is committed to pre supporting and testing our models to make sure we're putting out a great product and not sacrificing the sculpt's quality.

Cast n Play

That makes a lot of sense. Thanks for the honest feedback, Atlas.

Cast n Play

That's a good point. We don't have enough time to test print everything before releasing it. We test 1 or 2 poses per character, otherwise, we wouldn't be able to finish the sculpts. If we decide to do pre supported minis, I'd definitely try to find a way of doing the complete release an not just a couple of models every month.

Cast n Play

Thanks for the honest feedback, Caesar.

Nicholas

Curious who the one is that is doing 2-3 models and supporting them if you want to share? Large detailed prints?

Zachary Chenoweth

I think it's important for each person to learn their printer to be able to make supports specific to their hardware and that most pre-supported files don't work as expected because of hardware restrictions. I enjoy all the content Cast N Play puts out and would hate to see their time put into supports versus the great files they make each month.

Captain Feathersword

Cast n Play, I absolutely agree, your volume release is spectacular and I'd hate to imagine the additional workload of supporting every model. I'd, hate to see you take on too much personally. Nicholas, the other patreon is Mini Flayer. His last release was two poses of Gnomish Artificer and a Giant Spider Mech for him to ride around on!

Lisa Kellogg

I would like presupported for certain models for example I had a really hard time supporting the wagon from he witch hunter set. I own a prusa mk3 and a anycubic photon I use the photon for mini's but I like the prusa for terrain my first attempt at the wagon I used prusa sli3er supports I could not get them off the model so I tried oriented the model differently and I still could not get the supports off so I put the model into chitubox slicer converted it it an stl and then put it through prusa slic3r without supports it sort of worked but I was not totally pleased with the results I would really like to know what you all did to print this model since I was not able to get good results with supports. as for minis I don't really care that much I am capable of supporting them using chitubox and my result are pretty good I will use a presupported model as well saves me the trouble but it is not necessary.

Robert Mitchell

I have read all the post and AG has been brought up several times, They did not change the price of the their normal tier setup, they only added 2 new tiers for the supported mini, one for non merchants and one for merchants. They did not force anyone to upgrade their monthly cost. Simply added a new tier at a higher cost if you wanted the minis supported. I love presupported minis if done right. I work a lot and it frees up my time when i am home. I also own a business where time it money and the time it saves me is greatly valued. This month you have about 24 minis, it would take me atleast 12 hrs to support all that. So I am willing to come off a few bucks to have that luxury. You will not make everyone happy, and most that complain about it look at the maximum possible amount of money you could make off it and use that as an excuse on why it should be free. Charge a price that you feel is fair, if that is the route you take. Paying someone to support and test print each is a lot of work and cost in material.

Joris Kelderman

If the Patreon you talk about is the patreon I think you mean, then sure. But they have a team of two, who make a lot of content for $10. They had to hire a 3rd guy who doesn't use the auto support algorithm, you can see this in the way he places his supports. $8 is almost double the amount, which I agree, is quite a bit. But it is worth it. Now you just load everything onto your buildplate and you're ready to go. It's so much easier and I print a lot more now, because of this. I do not have time to place support myself, especially with mini's I don't really need, like PC's I do myself. Cast 'n Play have a huge load of content for just the $13, which I think is great value as well, there's a lot of files so at least a $5 extra for supported models doesn't even make that much difference to me. The time I save on supporting the models I want to print is definitely worth it. Cheaper is always better, because we are all humans and not everyone has a great income that they can use on this hobby. But it's all a matter of it being worth the money. And yes. I agree on supportless. Don't do it. It'll limit the character poses, which would be really bad.

Edric Ivan

I'm on AG, Titanforge and CastnPlay. I love all three. I have so much printing backlog because of supports. I really take my time to place them to get maximum detail. I print to be able to paint them, what's happening now is I focus on presupported minis, or just one from each month if unsupported, because that's all the time I have. IMO the additional fee for pre supported minis is more than justified. I spend 40-60 minutes per mini for a detailed one. That alone is worth more than the 8 USD charged by AG. Of course if it's free that would be even better. Either way the supports have to be done right. I think I see where this is going, free or charged i'm looking forward to it!! I can finally get all the minis on my painting table!

TabletopTerrainUK

I don't mind supportless models, there was a recent Kickstarter that showed what could be achieved with posing that was great. Evan Carothers consistently has really good supportless models and RocketPig, while not all, has some good dynamic models. They don't need to be tilted with vent holes etc unless you're hollowing. I print 50mm based models solid without issues regularly. If the thought is put into it, supportless models can look great!

MadMike

Wow, the amount of comments here is incredible...also, some completely overboard. Whoever needs 20 to 40 minutes to support ONE miniature has not done their math. I will not pay extra for supports, I will continue do my own - Greg is great, but not the only one who's good with supports ;) He's just the one face in public that happily assists the noobs out there, those that will listen. My main concern, something MANY here miss: you have different printers, different resins, different settings and temperatures etc. Even Gregs supports may fail on one or the other machine because of the above. I do not want to rely on that. I use my own, heavies for core points, medium to small to finer details. And my sales speak highly of my quality. So - no. Will not pay extra and I'd suggest you do not add it. You got tons of supporters already ;) Let them learn the ropes.

MadMike

40 to 60 for supports on ONE mini? Uhm, then you're doing something wrong. Get your support settings right in ChiTuBox and it takes MAX 10 minutes for a highly detailed one like from Manuel Boris, but never ever AG or TF.

TabletopTerrainUK

I begrudgingly paid the extra for AG to see what the big deal was. For a test, I printed my own supported models (painstakingly tuned chitu autosupports with maybe 2 or three manual) and a presupported bunch. It took me about 30 seconds to support my version, and maybe 30 seconds longer to pull them all off. With the latest AG models, I printed the pre supported ones and had a bunch of failures, I printed my own supported ones and they're all fine. With CnP, the most difficult thing I find is that a lot of the models have very thin and fragile parts. I can't count how many kenku legs I've snapped by accident, or how many fairy king crowns I've broken testing supports etc. I'd much rather have slightly more robust / thicker models than supports! I'd say if you want to do it, have a separate tier for it, then people can test it out and change if they don't like it :)

Edric Ivan

I think if people are willing to pay the CastnPlay crew are more than entitled for the extra $$$. I love their sculpts and I'm willing to give them more $$$. Of course different strokes, a different tier should solve that. It wouldn't affect people who don't think it's worth it. If 10 minutes per mini is gonna be my efficiency with more practice I look forward to that. But this isn't a business for me, it's a hobby that I love but don't have much time for. So my learning curve will be delayed. In the meantime Presupported minis would be a godsend.

Dan Stewart

I think massively what is needed here is more education on supporting models well, If its something that is going to take a very long time every month to pre support and you lose time on creating models it really doesnt make sense to me to see that happen. I believe what might be a very good solution is either creating a great detailed guide on the most sort after supported files which looks like its supports for resin printing. This could be a series of videos released as a helpful guide, dos and donts of resin supports, popular support programs like chitubox tutorials. I believe this would be alot easier to manage and would create a unique patreon experience that shows how to get the best out of your creations for users. Really hope the best for you as your work is always a massive excitement for me every month ! Another idea I had was to possibly trial some patreons to send you their best stl supported files for resin printing and get patreons to test print and find the best supported model

Donna Crawford

Personally I would be wary of anything that would add time to your work and could result in a reduction of the number of these fantastic models in each monthly pack. They're such amazing collections I wouldn't want to change a thing.

Piotr Sajewicz

Pre supported files are real value for merchants only to be honest. If someone just want to click, print, sale. Otherwise it's taking the big part of hobby away. If you're unable to setup your own support maybe printing is not for you? Your models are more challenging than many others but also gives fabulous results. I would definitely like to see you focusing on models and timely, huge releases like now instead of dealing with such a fiddly task as pre supporting models. Not every printer works the same way neither does resin, scaling will not always do the job properly. I've seen people complaining so much about pre supported stuff on other patreons. Also mind you'll be tied to positioning of the pre supported file - not much to play around and squeezing more on built plate even greedy for time merchants can lose time effectively not being able to fit as much at once.

Renaud BODOT

Currently I have an issue with the files from your Patreon as they are significantly harder to support than let say Forge mini. I think that’s due to the fact Cast and Play lack experience in printing. Having to your own supporting job would make you learn about better design of the mini

jay shires

The be fair, the first models I'm putting up on market are the models I can get tested the fastest. I currently have something like 300 or 400 files to support and test print right now. That means artist who are doing pre-supports only require a test print to make sure everything is cool and once confirmed then I switch to merch tier. Those who do not offer pre-supports require a lot more time which means I hold on merchant until I can start testing their models.

Nick Adams

I like pre-supported files for resin printing, and I like them to be in the Greg K / AG style. My biggest concern is a flawless model after removing supports, to either have zero pitting or have it be well hidden. To me that has made the AG tier very worthwhile, it's priced about right, and it doesn't take away from their team's modeling efforts and quality. I have multiple different kinds of resin printers and the AG pre-supported files work great as long as the resin/printer settings are dialed in. If you have enough interest to make a tier for it, and someone to do it that does a great job like Greg or the many other people out there that can support as well as him, I would definitely back it. I would not be interested in getting pre-supported models for free, if it means taking away any time/ resources from you all as modelers.

HAChaos

Yep, I used Gregs settings when I first started off and they worked very well. But when I changed to a different resin the slight change made the small supports no longer viable, had to change them up. Though they are great when they work, no all pre supported items will work for everyone.

Almega

I think presupported files are valuable but not as valuable as the sculpt, you should spend your time on the amazing sculpts, but maybe there's a way for the community you have to share their supported files. i can think of two ways to do this that leave you in control. those of us who are good at supports could share them with you to be put in an additional folder on the sets before the month ends. alternatively if there's a member who is really good, maybe have them make supports for a higher price and you split the money with them and can still focus on sculpts.

Robert Mitchell

I have found if you know your machine and its setting you can fine tune those setting for presupported models, It might take a test print or 2 but once you have that setting for that creators supports then it is a simple switch of profile in you slicer. In the long run it saves time. But to each their own. Have a different tier for supported models if people want them, again no one is forced to purchase the presupported tiers that way

Mark Cauley

I think you should be able to purchase a pre-supported month a-la-carte without having to change tiers. I would consider paying for pre-supported as an addon, but not on a recurring monthly basis. Maybe a month here or there depending on the complexity and texture of the sculpts.

Sara DeWitt

I am inclined to agree here. I have printed out multiple fairy only to lose an antennae removing a support, because they are so delicate. Don't get me wrong, your models are beautiful and wonderfully balanced, but there are more than a few that have very thin parts that require supports to print, and you risk breaking in the removal of said supports.

ThatGuyOverThere

Also, you might get a lot more supporters to join if supported versions where just part of the general release pack. I think this is only viable if you're printing your own work, and have gone through the hassle of support placement already, and then why not share that out? I do like the idea of encouraging supporters to be able to upload supported versions for this community, just not sure how that would work, seems like a lot of folder and rights management.

Joshua Cauble

Considering I only have FDM and there is no chance of a resin printer any time in the near future I don't really see the point for myself. I can see if you are a resin printer though that it would be nice.

Jason DeGonia

the problem with pre supoorted minis for me, is what software they use to support and save. another patreon saves with chitubox file, and my slicer is use wont convert those files. so i prefer to do my own supports so i dont have to mess with zip files and changing them around or figuring out how to make them work with my printer or slicer!

PheonixKnight

I can and have supported lots of my models but it takes time away from me painting my massive stack of them. If i can print six models in four to five hours that gives me less than an hour to paint each model. If i have to support them thats about another five to ten minutes per model that i could be using to prime and base coat what i have printed.

Cast n Play

Atlas, you're not being screwed AT ALL, nor being forced to change tiers. You have been getting all of our sculpts for $1 a month since the very beginning and things will stay that way, not planning on ever-changing that for early patrons. (That has always been the promise) $1 for over 50 models every single month is not punishing you. At all. Please understand that for $4 we can not provide ALL the models + ALL of the pre-supported files. I understand that is what you want, but that's not the offer. And you're not being forced to give up your tier. I usually don't respond to this kind of comment but now it just feels like you're trying to complain and manipulate just to get people mad over this, even after we discussed this privately. You're ignoring the fact that the original price and models you were promised and models have been delivered every single month since you joined. Nothing has changed for your tier and you're acting as if we're taking something away from you. I really hope you can understand this.

Sergio Andre Gentil

Share your resin or FDM support files, settings, and a pic, That is what Mini Monster Mayhem is doing.

Ryan

The problem is you are looking at this new tier wrong. CnP isn't saying that they think all the cost in time and labor is worth $3 more to everyone's subscription, they are saying that to cover costs it will cost $16 per month. That just happens to be $3 more for the plebs (like me) who didn't get to support right away. The fact is you are getting a, frankly, absurd deal with 50 models for $1 a month. Now I agree with you that the pre-supported models tier is a bit steep (I think that about every one I've seen from various Patrons like AG) and thus I will not be upping my subscription. But CnP have every right to charge what they believe is fair for the labor and time that goes into it and it appears they believe that price is $16 a month (not +$3 from your subscription). Be considerate of the people who have saved you $12 a month every month and respect their decision. If you don't like it (like me) then don't pay for it. If, like you said, your budget doesn't allow for $16 dollars a month then $13 dollars would be either too much as well or cutting it close, so take into consideration the benefits you receive each month for backing early and let CnP make their own business decisions and let the community vote with their wallets. I'm all for public discourse for things like this, but the fact you messaged them privately, got an answer you didn't like, and then came here to try to get others to complain about it too is pretty messed up considering the benefits you receive each month. Edit: spelling and formatting.

Dungeon of Fitz

I'm with Atlas there. It's not, that it's not worth the 16$ a month, it really is. But for me patreon was always something else than a selling platform, of course it is, but it was more of a supporting platform for me. I'm also one of the first supporters who had the luck to get into the 1$ tier and even if all of those patreons would stop supporting, who cares? Those numbers are of no interest at a patron-count Cast n Play already has. If the day-one supporters want to be up to date with what cast n play offers they have to pay 15 times more as they where before and not 0.25 times more. It's not about the money, as I already said the price is more than reasonable, it's about the appreciation of the people who where supporting cast n play from the beginning. I don't want to complain, and I am staying at my supporting level I currently am, I just want to explain why the early supporters don't feel appreciated for supporting you since the beginning. This patreon is a business and getting people from cheap tiers into more expensive tiers, with offers like that, got part of it. I understand that, I accept that, but I do not like it.

Dungeon of Fitz

And I do not want to get people mad about that, business is business.

Lawrence

I mean...I'm new here and I happily paid 16$ for pre-supported minis and all the fixins.... so... Keep up the good work, thanks for supporting the hobby, and can't wait to get these guys printed!

Umbralwolf94

you know, I voted that I wouldn't pay more for presupported.. i'm willing to pay the $3 extra honestly. I was expecting a jump like some other patreons that would nearly double the pledge. that said, $3 more for everything pre supported? take my money

Paul Denoncour

I recently added an Anycubic Photon to my 6 Ender 3 pro's. Supports are wrecking me, and I'm about to give it up. I've looked for pre-supported files, there aren't many. Going to give them a go today. Thanks! :)

Cast n Play

Let me know how it went :) Feel free to join our Discord if you need any help getting perfect prints. Feel free to tag AlexZaragoza, Yeesic or Velkhan