Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Files

Mike and Jay Talk About Carolina Caroline

It's Mike and Jay's favorite type of movie to discuss: the little movie that couldn't. Carolina Caroline has a great director and cast, but only opened in a couple hundred theaters and then was put onto streaming just a couple weeks after release. Did it deserve better? Well yeah, that's why Mike and Jay are talking about it. From the director and star of Dinner in America!

Comments

Amanda Drake

I just like looking at these weirdos.

Lawrence Kassab

Why can't you guys just leave this Kyle guy alone. Is he some kind of actor or something!?

Clare J

I saw it at the music box in Chicago with Adam doing a q&a after. Even that showing wasn’t that full. The movie was supposed to be set in 2001

Bob Connally

The release for this movie was so bizarre. I live in Seattle and it only opened in 2 theaters in the area. One was about 25 miles south of Seattle and the other was about 15 miles north. But even weirder than that, at both theaters it only got one showing per day and the times were all over the place. I went to a 9:20 AM showing on a Saturday morning. If I had tried to see it the day before I would have had to have gone at 11 PM. It was gone from both theaters in the area after a week.

Zoran Basic

I never checked but it feels like that all of this reviews that are obsessed with numbers and either saying that the film will financially succeed or fail is maybe because they (magazines, yt reviewers, except you 😉) believe their audience is only people who invest in film companies (buy their stock or short it). Some people today are only motivated by money and not purity of art. This is why there is maybe some disconnect with films that are just art, nobody talks about them because there is nothing to gain or inform people about gaining... except mentioning, oh, it played in theaters and went to stream, so it is elegable for a reword, buy the stock now...

RedLetterMedia

I'm going to try and exercise some self control... Normally I watch a new video the moment it's released, but I think I'll actually WATCH this movie FIRST. Then I'll watch the video tomorrow and see what I was supposed to think about it!

Tim Salmons

Thank you guys for reviewing this one. I got lucky enough to see this on opening weekend and really dug it. It's a shame that it died a terrible death theatrically.

Amanda B.

Did y'all ever see Samara Weaving in Azrael? I liked that one.

Halph Pint

Did I miss something? Why do they continuously shit on Shelby Oaks lol? Mike hasnt even seen it and its still gets brought up multiple times...Im not a big Stuckman fan, but jeeesh 😂

Juan Calvo

The ultimate goal of these videos is to record an audio commentary of the Nightmare on Elm Street remake with Kyle Gallner.

DoaghDoaghGo

*sighs* "Captain Trips".......

Manuel Johnen

That poor Supergirl actress is not to be blamed for the disaster that movie turned out to be financially, she didn't even Zegler it up with the press, she just drunkenly said some nothingnesses when they put her in front of an agenda driven reporter on a red carpet... ... ... maybe the studios should sift out those beforehand, 'cause how are you gonna answer that idiocy anyway...? :/

Jeremy _

You guys have said "well streaming must be another revenue stream for them". But, like, is it? I thought the lesson of the past 5 years has been, "There isn't really any way to make money on streaming. Not at subscription prices anyone is willing to pay."

Kurt

I never take your advice, but this time I will and actually try to see this. I get sad when something digital is described as colorful. Sure, digital can be colorful, but it also makes everyone forget how much more colorful things are on film. I'm lucky that I don't live too far from an annual Technicolor festival. I usually can't remember what I was thinking about two seconds ago, but dammit I refuse to forget what film color looks like.

Les Pasnak

Two of RLM’s favourites teaming up in a movie could have been trouble but I paid and rented this movie. Really great film that shows you can take a tale that has been told many times before but you do not care when it is done well. Thank you for letting me know this was out there.

Les Pasnak

Wow. Even looking at the Patreon responses I can see why you guys mock the comments. It was great to see Kyle retweet your post. I’m an old so I have seen all the narratives done so many times before but this movie avoided all of the idiocy. Even something that plagued Breaking Bad and Better Call Saul where the women are suddenly innocent victims despite them being participants just in the prior episode. That’s what I liked about the ending scene. You think she’s about to break but she’s actually just coming to terms with how she has been living the last three months. Also how great was the Kyra Sedgwick scene? Caroline was the interloper on her existing world. So brilliantly done. No tearful Reunion

RedLetterMedia

I was surprised just how straight forward this movie ended up being. I kept expecting it to take a HARD TURN, and suddenly introduce some sort of supernatural angle, or modern technological aspect, or suddenly turn out to really be about aliens. So it was actually refreshing when it just ended up being a 'simple' film about a couple who decided "Fuck It!" and just to go on a crime spree! For instance, I had recently seen Gallner's other movie "Strange Darling", and was expecting there to be a big Plot Twist. And it was going to turn out that Caroline was actually just pretending to be the naive small town girl, and we'd discover that maybe she had a thing about seducing and murdering random travelers.

RedLetterMedia

And hopefully this movie turns some new fans onto JASON ISBELL! His track 'Cover Me Up' was featured throughout the film, and that entire "Southeastern" album is great.

RedLetterMedia

Isn't the 'Business Model' basically that every film is its own LLC? And everyone listed in the credits gets paid up front, So, if a movie only breaks even then the Film Makers all still get paid for their work... I guess the only issue is that it'll be hard to secure funding for ANOTHER movie if the investors are only receiving 'credit' but aren't making acceptable profits.

Tim Kocher

Thanks to your comments on this video, I finally caught up with Dinner in America- what a movie. Love it more and more as I think about it. Can’t wait to see this one