Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Files

Mystery Men - re:Visit

Mystery Men is a 1999 comedy with a big budget and an all-star cast that flopped hard. But to kids that grew up watching it repeatedly on home video, it is looked back on fondly now. It is of course perfectly fine if you are one of those former children that looks back on this movie with warn fuzzy memories, but Mike and Jay didn't grow up with it or even watch it again since it's theatrical release and are now here to splash some cold water on your face and tell you why it sucks.

Comments

Screen Time!

What a coincidence I just bought this on Blu Ray

Brian Bridges

I don't need a compass to tell me which way the wind shines.

Emma Dawn

I saw this movie in theatres when it came out but I was nine years old so I was very confused. The part where captain amazing gets fried up genuinely terrified me, I couldn't sleep after, but I was with a cool older Gen X family friend and didn't want to seem lame so I didn't say anything. I wanted her to think I liked cool movies like MYSTERY MEN. lmfao, lol

Rick Drake

As if the day couldn't get worse.

Eric

Such a seriously underrated movie

Steven Simmons

I love this movie. In a recent rewatch I caught something: I was a little taken off guard when one of the members of the parole board (maybe two) had a medal with a hammer and sickle on it. I've seen this movie at least 6 or 7 times and never noticed this tiny, confusing detail. I googled it to see if there was some weird "the USSR won the cold war" backstory (I know its based on characters from the Flaming Carrot comics but I've never read them). I doubt that's the case but its bugging the heck out of me now :D . In the original comics there were Communist bad guys but there's a scene in the diner where Mr Furious pays with a Chinese cash coin...so I don't know if this is just an anachronistic choice or something meant to make Mr Furious look even weirder? just a fun detail...when I posted to Reddit no one knew anything about that detail so its stuck in my mind.

Manuel Johnen

I had a colonoscopy that was actually rather nice... they knock you out real good...

Notation

I watched this again recently. I still think it's really funny. I love this movie. I acknowledge its weaknesses, but I like it anyway.

Manuel Johnen

The only good movie in 1999 was "American Beauty", everything else was shit...

Sara Iyer

LOVE THIS MOVIE AND CANNOT WAIT TO WATCH THIS

Sara Iyer

I was definitely too young to see this when I first did, but rewatched it just a few months ago and I’m now the right age

Nutshell Brainery

Twice a year at least since it came out. That's how often my wife and I enjoy this gem of a little film.

Zoran Basic

Release the Mike cut (of Space Cop)

Kellic

A good pick, but I still waiting on the guys to do Big Trouble in Little China

Zoran Basic

Come to think of it you guys should re:view Corneto Trilogy 🙂

Kellic

Umm no. The Matrix, The Mummy, The Iron Giant, Galaxy Quest, Fight Club, Dogma, bicentennial man, Austin powers, Arlington road,. And depending on your taste Blair Witch project all came out in '99

arojay

If I remember correctly from the DVD commentary, the superhero tryout scene was largely unscripted. It was literally just a casting call for random people to show up at a house with their own absurd, homemade characters and costumes.

Notation

I think Mike wants it to be too cynical though. It's a feel-good movie.

Manuel Johnen

Okay, "The Mummy" is good, too...

Marvin Falz

I still stand by my opinion that Space Cop is better than even its creators like to admit, but I also like Oranges: Revenge of the Eggplant, so I guess that immediately disqualifies me. But some day I'm going to smile in a camera and talk about The Recovered, get about 20 views, and maybe even a like, as I am able to see all the great aspects in RLM productions but I am also a compulsive comedian, a clown, someone nobody takes seriously, even when everybody takes him seriously. Being a Red Letter Media fan is complex. But funny and engaging. And Red Letter Media are apparently filmmakers who are not filmmakers. Jay (Bauman) even says that it's never worth it. Mike stares, Rich falls down. Everybody laughs. Curtain. Bow. How's your day?

Andrea Johnson

I totally forgot Wes Studi was in this movie.

Ja Dav

Lots of songs have vastly outperformed the film they were in. It's the You Light Up My Life syndrome.

Chad Allen

Never forget when I had a superhero costume party when I was 4 and my uncle showed up as the Shoveler

Spookylush

You know good comedy when just the sight of a scene makes you laugh, so I really enjoyed this and now am rewatching Austin Powers for 100th time. Thanks guys!

Elaine Skowronski

Release the Rich re:Visit, he has a heart, I bet he gets it!

Amanda B.

Glad y'all are getting your colonoscopies.

Sara Iyer

Yes! All their criticisms are totally valid, but it sounded like Mike wanted a different movie altogether.

Sara Iyer

Although I did disagree with their watermelon shoes re-edit. I like the slow awkward version that’s in the movie.

Notation

Yeah, they're right about the prosthetic arm but they're wrong about the watermelon shoes joke. Also, it's funny that they keep talking about how they only thought one or two things were funny, but then as they're talking about the movie, they keep remembering more jokes!

Renus Dewberry

Two days before this dropped, I scheduled my first colonoscopy for early morning to get it over with. God bless these prescient hack frauds.

Juan Calvo

I'm curious now about a RLM analysis of Zoolander, which may be a case where the fancier style of filmmaking actually makes that material funny... There are clips of Ben Stiller playing his character, doing the same stuff he does in the movies, but he's being filmed in a drier/more realistic stuff and I find it less funny.

Alexander Birtles

Looks like the director was going for Gilliam, but you need to be Gilliam to pull that off.

TheSingingBush

That there Mike Shamallamas has a good point

Pac Man

Unpopular opinion, I'm with Mike and Jay on this one. I was the perfect audience for this kind of movie. It was one of the first DVDs I ever bought. I just assumed I would like it, based on the trailer. I just...didn't. Everything felt off, especially the way Greg Kinnear just dies. It felt like it was trying to be every kind of superhero movie that had been done, while failing at all of them. The worst offender being failure to be funny. Except for Janeane Garofalo. She can do no wrong.

Dion Turner

I know you have trauma, but the new Resident Evil is not the worst movie.

Tommy McMaster

Really hope you end up talking about resident evil. Just for your thoughts. I’d recommend it but parts didn’t really work for me but it was a fun movie either way

Matt Arnold

I dont know how we missed a Onslaught/Resident Evil, double-bill, Half in the Bag. I feel like Onslaught is underrated, Resident Evil is overratred, and I need those opinions reinforced by flyover alcoholics.

andrew

Your editing intuition never ceases to amaze me.

andrew

Your idea for a comedic roll call of super heroes was expertly done in Harvey Birdman: Attorney at Law episode 2.