Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I've played a bunch of the demo for 'Probably Stolen,' and if you enjoy the shopkeeping sim genre at all, I cannot recommend it highly enough. Game comes out in late October, and I'm really excited for it.However, aside from all of the great mechanics, fun gameplay loop, lovely pixel graphics, there was one moment in the demo that had me sat back in my chair staring at my screen for five minutes.In the first ten minutes, a security officer (who had up until this point been a regular customer that seemed to be participating in the onboarding tutorial explaining mechanics) presented me with a list of wanted criminals, and said if any of them show up, I should keep them occupied and alert security. And of course, the moment I recognized someone from the poster, I hit my little panic button and the security showed up.As they're hauling this dude away, he's cursing me to hell, I get notified that I've gained reputation with the government (or whatever) and lost reputation with the revolution; which I had no idea about because I hadn't let this guy get a word in edgewise before bringing the po-po down on him.And I'm left sitting there, shook, wondering "Wait, is that who I am? Am I the guy who just narcs because the uniformed thugs told me some story about 'scary criminals'? I didn't even question it?" I didn't think that was who I was, but I had just done it. Bit of a real soul-searchy moment, and a great bit of morally-significant gameplay.But anyway, the game's awesome and you should definitely check out the demo.

Files

Comments

David Symonds

I think you want "fascist" in the last frame, not "facist"

oyeedraw

I had a slightly similar situation in Skyrim ages ago when an NPC came up in my face and demanded which side I was on in the local noble family drama.

Mr Seeker

You remember the old tutorial in Project Zomboid? Just grab a pillow, use it on your loved one, and you can end her suffering...

Blue 5alamander

A government that wants to make everything easy, to eliminate all friction, effort, and mild inconvenience from daily life? Sign me up!

Baleine

If that may put your mind at ease, you should read about the Milgram Experiment (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_experiment). When given instructions by authority, we tend to enforce them without even thinking about what we are doing. It may be concerning, but it is how we are wired. I’m pretty sure the devs knew about this experiment and wanted to play on it (and maybe harvest data about players without having the ethics issues of the Milgram Experiment). There is a lot that could be said, like the fact the protocol of the experiment wasn’t always strictly followed, and a lot of ethics issues. But what is important is that you are not a bad person because you narced some guy (ingame or IRL). It is how we are working when confronted with authorities. Some guys do it differently, but in the majority, we conform with authority (if you think about it, that’s why a social species evolved until now). That’s a good thing you learn about how humans are working.

Marc Steigerwald

Some people just enjoy the taste of boots, i guess...

Maurice Post

You are right, but I guess the question is more that Tim discovered that he himself indeed would blindly follow the authority without asking himself the question about right or wrong?

Klaas Pieter Rook

I hope the reaction in the last frame is standard when playing this game! A lot of people need to ask themselves that question. 😁 One can only hope…

Tyler

I think context matters too, in that study the participants were asked/told to do something obviously morally wrong. Tim doesn’t say here but it sounds like the devs don’t really present that there’s an ongoing revolution or even tension with the government. You only find out after you press the panic button. That’s a far cry from an obvious moral conflict, it’s devs being jerks while pretending to be philosophers.

Ctrl+Alt+Del

I meant people that are prejudiced against faces ;)

Anthony

This might not be the case as much with Probably Stolen, but preconceptions we have as experienced gamers also play a big part in this. Someone seeing Mario for the first time might try to look for a way to talk to a Koopa... experienced gamer? We just press the jump button. When we see an RPG, though, we will look for additional options to resolve a situation and might even plan a build from the start that will allow us to finish the game with as little blood on our hands as possible. So, in part, I guess, the problem is that the games that offer a meaningful choice are rare and it's common for these game to advertise it in big letters. I might have tried just pressing "block" in a turn-based RPG battle a long time ago. After many times it didn't matter, though, I gave up trying.

Baleine

Is it really morally wrong? You wouldn’t signal to the police if you would see a terrorist? That’s the conundrum in these kind of games, as in Papers, please. Which side is good or wrong? That’s ultimately for you to decide which side you choose (and due too our nature, the established order is the "default" side, that’s what Milgram’s experiments demonstrated). Saying that the devs are jerks is obviously wrong, because they just present you a choice, and you have to decide what is a jerk move or not.