Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

So Blizzard is getting sued again (seems to be their new hobby), this time by a father who is upset that his child bought a bunch of Hearthstone card packs and can't refund them after getting garbage.Polygon reported on it here, but the gist is this: Dad gives his daughter access to a device connected to his credit card, and over the course of three years, she buys $300 worth of Hearthstone booster packs. He eventually wises up, and upon realizing that a) she didn't get any good cards and b) can't refund the purchases, decides to sue Blizzard because they didn't properly educate his child on the shittiness of random-draw card packs.There's a lot of angles to this thing. I am a parent, and I know as well as anyone, being a parent is hard. Especially in this day and age. There are so many things you have to watch out for, dangers you have to be aware of and educate your kids on... it isn't easy. I try my best not to be too critical of other people's parenting; we all have our own approaches, and we all make mistakes.I can understand not realizing that you connected your credit card to an app your kid is using. I can understand not being aware a game includes lootbox-esque purchases (and I can get on board with the idea that those mechanics shouldn't be marketed to kids).But the moment a parent decides that those two mistakes are no longer their mistakes, but the responsibility of a massive corporation that requires litigation to remedy... I don't know. At that point I have a hard time finding the angle to that I can agree on.

Files

Comments

Frederic Barthelemy

I think it's fair to expect government to restrict "random", paid, loot-boxes in the gaming industry for games particularly targeted directly at children. This is a simple extension of the gambling laws, and I generally believe forcing the industry to avoid preying on people is probably good. As a player, I'd also love if there was a labeling standard on paid lootboxes they had a "tell me more" icon that gives you a listing of the odds. Net result of the current industry choices is regular frustrated players/customers/payers and plenty of people don't come back (or the reverse are gambling-addicted). Definitely struggle to sympathize with the father based on his lawsuit, however. No refund on losing lotto tickets is a pretty normal expectation.

Ctrl+Alt+Del

A Marvel mobile app I played for a short while had the odds of obtaining each item in a random pack, so I've seen it in practice. I think it should be info available, but I'm skeptical that we cn expect a kid to read and understand it if they are not even aware that they're spending money on these things/that it's an irreversible action.

Frederic Barthelemy

I know that iOS, and I believe that Android both have ways to configure the CC-connected device such that purchases have to be approved by the account owner. Now I know this experience might be difficult for a less tech person to set up, or that there are good reasons why he doesn't. But to me, if you're trusting the child with a credit-card transaction of a certain size, then you're trusting them, and suing the merchant after the fact is probably poor-form. If he wouldn't have been offended if the drops were better quality, then it particularly smells.

Ctrl+Alt+Del

Yeah, no app purchases can be made on our boys' tablets without entering an auth password, which they don't have. Nothing is set up to allow them purchasing power without our consent, but we've also explained to them how these apps work, and that the robux or whatever cosmetic nonsense costs real money. They understand the correlation. But while we stay on top of that sort of thing, I get how a parent could miss it, or not realize their kid can charge things until it's already been done. But I feel at that point you just say "whoops, my mistake, let me fix this going forward" not "this is the company's fault."

Thomas

If the father complained after a few weeks or month or so, I could be understanding. Letting it go for three years cannot be just ignorance.

Kaedys

Worth noting, even if the probabilities were listed, the entire *reason* the Gambler's Fallacy works is because people are *really* bad at processing percentage chances of things occurring. Most people are rather heavily inclined to *over-estimate* the probability of events they want and *under-estimate* the probability of events they do not want. Even in cases where the math is fairly simple and the prize is in the same currency as the purchase, people don't cognate it properly. See, for example, scratch tickets. I'm not sure if they're under the same "must return at least 51% of revenue as prizes" rules as most lottos are, but even if they are, that means that your expected return on _any_ ticket ~half of what you spent on it. And yet you still see people walk into corner stores and buy scratch tickets *in reams* and sit there and scratch off each one in turn. So really, I'm not convinced that putting the percentages on there will help much, except insofar as it helps to hold the company a bit accountable and force them not to put utterly ridiculous percentages on it for rare high-demand items. I'm *absolutely* behind not letting loot boxes be marketed towards kids, though. They're even more susceptible to the gambler's fallacy, due to an as-yet-immature reward center of their brain, impaired risk analysis, and a lack of awareness of the "value" of money due to not actually being in the labor force. There's a *lot* of evidence that people don't really achieve their developmental plateau of addiction processing until their mid 20's or so. That all said, as Tim said, if you hand a kid a device connected to your credit card, and do not engage with the nearly ubiquitous parental controls around it (I know all major phones have such capacity, and I also know that Battle.net accounts can have controls applied within those accounts as well), especially if you also don't bother to monitor what the heck they're doing with it, you deserve every dime of loss that comes from that stupidity, imo.

Kaedys

Eh, intentional ignorance. You've be surprised at how many people 1) don't bother to monitor their kids' activities, especially in the digital space, unless something reaches out and slaps them about it, and 2) don't bother to track their bank account/credit card register and transactions that are occurring. I find it very believable that someone could just straight up not notices the transactions, and not bother looking for them or checking their kids' activities, for 3+ years. Doesn't make it not *their fault*, though. Even if the company published the probabilities, very few kids have the capacity for understanding those probabilities *and* the understanding of money actually having value (and a proper understanding of "how much" that value is) for it to make a difference. Hell, many *adults* lack the capacity to properly process that information. This is just another "something bad happened, and I need someone else to blame for it so I don't have to take responsibility for my own laziness/stupidity/inattention".

Alain Baum

I like Tim's version of "surprised Pikachu face". 😄