Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

For October, y'all are picking FOUR horror movies for us to watch: one from each category. And we're starting with nominations!

You can nominate ONE movie per category:

1. 👻 HAUNTED & UNHOLYGhosts, demons, possessions, hauntings, supernatural fuckery.

2. 🔪 RUN, BITCH, RUN! — SLASHER EDITIONMasked killers, serial killers, slashers, stalkers. Somebody has a weapon and somebody else needs to MOVE.

3. 🏃🏽‍♀️ RUN, BITCH, RUN! — SURVIVAL EDITIONHome invasions, kidnappings, trapped somewhere horrible, being hunted, creature attacks—survive the damn night.

4. 🩸 WILDCARD FROM HELLAnything goes! If there's a horror movie you NEED to see me react to, this is where you fight for it.

THE RULES:• One nomination per category, per person.• Please only nominate movies you know I haven't reacted to. If you nominate something that is on Patreon, none of your picks will be considered.• Give your pick a fighting chance! Try to stick to movies that are fairly well-known, popular within the horror community, or have a solid cult following. Remember, your nomination eventually has to win a community vote, so if you and three people on Letterboxd are the only ones who've heard of it, you might be in trouble. 🤭 • I'll go through the nominations and narrow each category down to a handful of finalists.• Then we'll vote on one category each week throughout October.• The winner of each poll gets a reaction hunni!

HOW TO NOMINATE:Drop your picks in the comments below and number them 1–4 to match the categories above.

For example:

1. [ur movie pick witcho fine ass]2. [ur movie pick witcho cute ass]3. [ur movie pick witcho sexy ass]4. [ur movie pick witcho hawt ass]

You don't HAVE to nominate something for all four categories. If you've only got one or two great picks, submit those!

By the end of October, FOUR movies chosen by the Reelists will make the cut. 🎃

And no, any Conjuring movies I already have planned do not count toward your four. I'm watching those regardless.

Nominations are open until Tuesday, Sept. 29 at 11:59 PM ET! Drop 'em below! 👇🏽

Files

Comments

Yoliciel

3. The People Under the Stairs (1991)

SkyS

2. The wrong Turn

SkyS

2. The house of wax

Laura❤️

1. The Others 2. House of Wax 3. 4. The Ring

Ava

The Shining(1980), The Exorcist(1973), IT(2017), Smile(2022)

Laura❤️

We always have the same taste🤣

SkyS

Truly 🤣🤣🤣♥️♥️

Tionne✨ (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-04 22:00 1. Smile (2022) 2. Halloween (1978) 3. Jeepers Creepers (2001) 4. A Nightmare On Elm Street (1984)
2026-09-27 13:12 1. Smile (2022) 2. Halloween (2018) 3. Jeepers Creepers (2001) 4. A Nightmare On Elm Street (1984)

1. Smile (2022) 2. Halloween (2018) 3. Jeepers Creepers (2001) 4. A Nightmare On Elm Street (1984)

hannahmai

1. Insidious (low-key Insidious 2 but lets start with the first one lol)

Arissa McClellan

1. Paranormal activity 2. Fear street 3.truth or dare (the one with Lucy hale) 4.Smile

hannahmai

3. A Quiet Place

hannahmai

4. Smile 2 (Yes, technically a sequel but 1st one isn't necessary to watch)

Sidney

My fav category 1. Sinister (NOT Sinners lol) 2. Happy Death Day 3. Hush 4. Insidious

Maddie

1. Silent Hill 2. Re/Member (Japanese Film) 3. Ready or Not 4. Blair Witch Project

T

1. Insidious 2. The strangers 3. A quiet place 4. Smile

nice

insidious for sure thats all i want

Eric

1. The Craft 1996 Iconic baddie witches. 2. Sorority Row 2009 Literally a college version of PLL that’s a fun time. 3. The Descent 2005 Trapped, hunted by creatures, make it out alive. 4. Piranha 2010 Spring break bloodbath

cc (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-29 20:00 1. Sinister (murder happened in the home they moved into, husband knew ab it) 2. The wrong turn 3. The strangers (home invasion) 4. Smile 1 & 2
2026-09-27 14:38 1. Sinister 2. The wrong turn 3. The strangers (home invasion) 4. Smile 1 & 2

1. Sinister 2. The wrong turn 3. The strangers (home invasion) 4. Smile 1 & 2

Jasmine Tucker

2. When a stranger calls (2006) ! 🫶🏽

Luis Mondragon (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-29 20:00 1.) insidious 2.) idk 3.) Hush 4.) paranormal activity
2026-09-27 15:26 1.) insidious 2.) idk 3.) Hush 4.) paranormal activity

1.) insidious 2.) idk 3.) Hush 4.) paranormal activity

Denise

1. Paranormal activity 4. Lee cronin's the mummy

italiangirl

1. sinister 2. hellfest 3. ready or not 4. would you rather

Naya ✨

1. Poltergeist 2. Fear Street 3. Jeepers Creepers 4. Smile 2

Gracie

1. Leviticus (2026) 2. X (2022) 3. Bodies Bodies Bodies (2022) 4. Black Swan (2010)

krich

1. (Haunted): The Exorcism of Emily Rose 2. (Slasher): 3. (Survival): Get Out 4. (Wildcard): Orphan

Lakeshia Jackson

Hills Have Eyes3, Wrong Turn 2, Halloween [original], 1, Nightmare on Elm Street 4 Jeepers Keepers

naomi nadia

1. sinister 2. happy death day 3. strangers (2008) 4. the ring

ReRe Robinson

1.Texas Chainsaw Massacre (1974) 2.Sinister 3. Wrong Turn (2003) 4.The Nun

char

1. Smile 2 2. House of Wax 3. Don’t Breathe 4. Evil Dead (2013)

char

i loved lucy in truth or dare!!

Rayven

1. The Strangers(2008) 2. Paranormal Activity(2009) 3. Halloween (2018) 4. House of Wax(2005)

A.Michaaa

1. Ouija: The Origin of Evil (2016) 2. Fear Street (2021)

Sash Sriganesh

Omg for #3 I watched a movie recently called Don’t breathe that was super intense!!!

Mia

1. Evil dead rise (2023) 2. Us (2019) 3. 10 Cloverfield lane (2016) 4. Evil dead rise!! 🩷(2023)

Tamara McCarthy

Ooop he already reacted to Halloween (1978) 😬

Tionne✨

must’ve missed that reaction and didn’t realize

Tamara McCarthy

1. 👻 Dead Silence (2007) 2. 🔪 Child's Play (1988) 3. 🏃🏽‍♀️ When A Stranger Calls (2006) 4. 🩸Saw (2004)

Alexis Synclair (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-30 23:00 1. Insidious 2. Sinister 3. Stay Alive (2006) 4. Jeepers Creepers
2026-09-28 01:21 1. Insidious 2. Sinister 3. Fear Street 4. Jeepers Creepers

1. Insidious 2. Sinister 3. Fear Street 4. Jeepers Creepers

Lease

1. Evil Dead (2013) 2. Happy Death Day (2017) 3. Ready or Not (2019) 4. Talk To Me (2022)

YazUncensoredTV

1. Haunting In Connecticut (2009) 2. Urban Legend (1998) 3. Jeepers Creepers (2001) 4. Cloverfield (2008)

Armani

1. Devil 2. Smile 3. The Menu 4. One Missed Call Sorry if you’ve already watched any of these, I’m still getting thru reactions 🩷

Gracie

Love the menu!

fry

Rocky Horror Picture Show

lilac

2. The Strangers 3. You’re Next (2011) 4. Forbidden fruits (2026)