Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • 362756828.mp4

Missing 1 video, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

Three bayonets and a maybe-German katana? I don't even know :D

Comments

Ekij

Can you 'look' at the tang *without* taking it apart? Do you know anyone with a medical scanner? X-ray or MRI (probably not an ultrasound) pop to mind. There are companies that offer to scan the inside of 'industrial' objects but it's typically rather expensive. (Medical scanners are also typically expensive to use but someone might scan your Katana as part of training or something?)

shift shift

You always brighten my day.

Robert Calhoun

note of minor interest: that might actually be a tachi, instead of a katana. I can't tell from the video, but it looks like the saya (scabbard) might be made to hang from the belt? If so, you've got a tachi.

Shaun Abdelkerim

Reminds me of a very meaningful comment from Prince Talleyrand, Napoleon's foreign minister, “You can do many things with bayonets except sit on them.” That's more a comment on empire-building, nationalism, and geopolitics in general than the literal blades, but I think it still fits.

Cassandra

I like mysteries, but I particularly like mysteries that come with answers, so I hope you find some!

Ann Brookens

Well! 3 bayonets, 2 officers swords, and a mystery katana! This does sound a bit like WWII battlefield swag. And you'll probably have to get them all cleaned up before you'll be able to identify anything.

Alexander

If you want a professional appraisal, then you could make an appointment with one of the conservators at the Royal Armories Museum in Leeds.

Liz Endreson

To my limited understanding, Japanese doesn't do pluralization at all the same way English does, so using katana as the plural of katana is about right. Elsewise, the standard English pluralization gives us katanas, which is also correct.

Scott Ellis

Considering the number of different ways they found to ask me "do you have any metal in your body" when I had my recent MRI, I suspect that an MRI is not the correct thing for a large metal object :D

David M

Yes, Japanese hardly do grammatical pluralization at all, it's all about the context. Therefore, the plural of Katana is Katana, the plural of Ninja is Ninja, the plural of Samurai is Samurai and so forth. Standard English pluralization does work here, I'll admit that - but with quite a bit of stomach ache.

David M

Katana usually had a single fixture for a cord (I'd look up all the Japanese names for these parts, but... naaah) on the scabbard, which seems to be the case here. Also, generally speaking, tachi handles had a tendency to be longer than those on katana.

David M

Turns out I was wrong to think it was a wakizashi due to the short-looking handle, but the blade is fairly long, as we can see here. Still, I'll double down on saying that the handle IS quite short for a katana: when you hold it with both hands, there should be some space between them. Pausing the video at 1:44, it just doesn't look like that... Regarding the task of taking the katana apart: in traditional ones, there is a bamboo pin holding the tang and the handle together. You should be able to separate them easily - however, if it is really from Germany, it may not be assembled traditionally at all :D