Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

In this episode, Winters writes a report detailing the unexpectedly fierce German resistance they encountered. He's also haunted by his conscience after shooting a young SS soldier.

Please note: because of copyright, full-length reactions are watchalongs, so you'll need your own copy to sync up with us! You can find the episodes on Netflix, HBO Max, and other streaming services.

Files

Band of Brothers Episode 5 (Crossroads) Patreon Full-length Reaction

Join us for our Band of Brothers watchalong. Exclusively for our amazing Patrons — thank you for supporting Totally Whatever! Because of copyright, full-length reactions are watch-alongs, so you'll need your own copy to sync up with us!

Comments

Magnus Lagerborg

You guys are in for a treat next episode! It has a unique perspective! Thanks for this reaction!

Ian Forbes

The opening sequence is all from the show. For real footage and photos, the “We Stand Alone Together” documentary will provide. Others surely know better but the lack of resources for Easy heading into Bastogne is to my understanding due to the need to rush into the situation as Hitler’s attack on Bastogne was a complete surprise to the Allies. Operations like Overlord and Market Garden were meticulously planned for and thus the soldiers were more fully prepared/supplied. And totally understand that certain actors can take you out of the immersion but as I’m sure you both know, that’s the product of seeing the show 24 years after it aired. At the time, very few of the actors were known at all (Schwimmer was the biggest name then). But now we know Damien Lewis, Ron Livingston, Michael Fassbender, James McAvoy, Simon Pegg, etc, etc. … this is one of those projects that cast on ability and similarity to the real-life counterparts rather than “are they an A-lister” and so over the decades that followed, so many of these actors have gone on to further deserve the recognition they have now. Keep up the great reactions!

Phil Stubblefield

Excellent reaction as always, my friends! Just to clarify a few things about the battle at the crossroads: Winters obviously didn't know how many troops they'd be facing until he and Easy reached the top of the dike. They began firing on the Germans with small arms and two machine guns, but soon more Germans came into view, presumably from the ferry landing mentioned earlier. Seeing the strength of the opposition, Winters called in an artillery strike. We see him with the radio handset yelling: Easy Beaver to Easy Minor. Reinforce Easy at Phase One Yellow. Plus one, strike three. Fire concentration Charlie. Drop 200, left 100. Repeat: [...]. Krauts in the open, fire for effect, over. I certainly don't understand all of the jargon, but he's requesting a specific amount of artillery fire at a specific map coordinate. He ends with "fire for effect," which generally means to forgo any preliminary shots needed to establish aim (because he's already given them fairly exact coordinates) and instead to immediately deliver the full barrage. Within 10 to 15 seconds, shells begin to burst in and among the Germans in the field. Shortly thereafter, Winters orders a soldier named Boyle to "Get up there where you can spot the fall of those rounds!" In other words, verify that the shells are indeed landing in the requested target area so that Winters can inform the artillery battalion whether any adjustments are required. As Boyle runs out onto the top of dike, other shells burst near him, wounding him and knocking him down. Someone else yells, "Incoming rogues!" assuming that these are American shells that have fallen short of the target. But Winters soon yells, "It's German artillery!" After the battle, another lieutenant (Peacock?) tells Nixon that "they hit us with their 88s, zeroed in on this crossroad." In other words, the German 88mm cannons had fired back at the Americans, having earlier pre-sighted the crossroad from their emplaced artillery positions. After the battle, Nixon arrives on the scene. (Remember, he's an intelligence officer at this point and thus not expected to take part in combat.) He tells Winters: Well, you're looking at two full companies of SS out there. About 50 dead, probably another 100 wounded. Seven back in the regimental cage [the ones that Liebgott had taken back for interrogation], plus a whole string of 'em up there. That's not bad for Dukeman. I don't think Nix was being callous. Rather, he knew very well how hard his friend Winters tended to take the death of even a single soldier under his command, so he was trying to help Winters balance his rational and emotional sides. BTW, Private David Webster was the wounded soldier who was embarrassed at having yelled "They got me!" He'll refer back to this incident in a future episode, so I just want you to remember what he's talking about. This is the episode when we really begin to see PTSD appear. As you noted in your outro, the scenes of Winters in the Paris metro are so powerful. As the lighting within the train car flashes on and off, his mind keeps substituting images of the young soldier he had killed in place of the young French man in the train. Later, we also see Buck staring blankly at the movie screen, struggling to return to reality as Winters tries to talk to him. At that point, a pair of soldiers interrupt the film to announce that the Germans have broken through in the Ardennes Forest, marking the beginning of a famous historical engagement in and around the Belgian town of Bastogne. You've probably heard of this battle, but I'll leave it unnamed for now to avoid spoilers. Carolyn, during your outro, you said, "I'd like to know why was it so poorly coordinated that they lacked so much in terms of resources here." The Allies had been preparing for a relatively quiet Christmas break, in keeping with common occurrences in previous wars. Several senior officers were out of the area, and some even out of the country. We see Nixon tell Winters that no action is expected until March, giving Easy three months to train the replacement soldiers and officers who had joined after the Holland campaign. Unfortunately, the Germans launched their surprise attack on December 16, 1944, catching the Allies completely by surprise. Sending a paratrooper regiment to hold a defensive position as if they were regular infantry was a drastic move prompted by the desperate situation. As Easy is transported to Belgium by truck, Buck remarks, "I guess that blackout's not in effect. Lutwaffe must be asleep." The Lutwaffe is the German air force, and even when this far behind the front lines, vehicle headlights were usually covered at night to avoid providing targets for enemy aircraft. In reality, the Allies had near complete air superiority at this point in the European campaign. Guarnere says that he misses "those C-47s", the aircraft from which they typically parachuted, implying that jumping out of a plane after a smooth flight is preferable to taking a safer but much bumpier truck ride! BTW, Jimmy Fallon wasn't nearly as famous when Band of Brothers was being filmed. He had been a member of the Saturday Night Live for only a couple of years, and he wouldn't begin hosting The Tonight Show until 2009, nearly a decade later. Thus his portrayal of Lieutenant George Rice wasn't nearly the "famous person cameo" that it appears to be today. One of my favorite quotes from this episode comes after Rice warns Winters that the Germans are about to cut the final road into Bastogne: "We're paratroopers, Lieutenant. We're supposed to be surrounded." As you suspected, the next two episodes are tough. Be prepared.

Totally Whatever

That is a good point, we need to remember that we are watching this 24 years after it aired. What an incredible cast. Thanks again for watching with us!

Totally Whatever

Thank you for all of the extra details, Phil! We really appreciate them as do others, I'm sure. They are helpful to read right before we watch the next episode.

Phil Stubblefield

I have no idea, Brett, but it would shock me if he did. It's one thing to nurture a grudge but another thing altogether to endanger lives by withholding ammunition, food, proper clothing, and so on. I read somewhere that BoB emphasized the issues with Sobol to make a good story; that is, he certainly had faults, but not to the extent portrayed. Perhaps someone more knowledgeable can chime in...

Ben

Nannette and Carolyn, Phil has already started with more details, but if you have a few minutes and want to virtually walk the real battle of the crossroads, then this Battle Guide Channel episode is worth your time. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=el6DrrtluWw There aren't any spoilers in the video, so it is safe to watch. Battle Guide and WW2 Wayfinder are two YT channels that use Google Earth, on-site drone filming, and on-site walking to explain battles. They each use primary sources to research the battles before going to the sites. In this case, Battle Guide used the actual AAR (After Action Report) that you saw Winters typing in this episode among its primary sources to locate and explain the battle in detail. Seeing this site today (it is a few miles from Arnhem) is incredible. While other tourists are going to European beaches or major cities, I spend my time in obscure European villages walking unknown roads. Thankfully, my wife is as much of a history geek as I am. There are a lot of interesting Easter Eggs in this episode which give knods to reality. For example, in the opening scene we see Winters taping up the spoon on his Mk2 hand grenade. GIs often did this as an extra precaution in the event the pin is accidentally removed from the grenade. Taping the spoon prevented it from igniting the fuze and going off accidentally. Jump forward ... after the battle we briefly see Winters near the body of the German he had killed and Lt. Peacock makes a remark about the German being SS. Jump forward a little more, and when Nixon meets up with Winters after the battle, Winters is holding a grenade. While he is talking with Nixon, if you watch, you will see Winters removing tape from the grenade in his hand. Then as Winters goes to leave, we see him playing with the tape. This is an Easter Egg to the real battle. When Winters crested the road in his attack at the crossroads, a German sentry was on the road (depicted in the episode by the German that he shot). As Winters was running up the incline of the road, he threw a grenade at the German. Unfortunately in his excitement, Winters forgot to remove the tape and the grenade did not go off, so Winters shot the sentry. After the battle, he actually did retrieve the grenade as it had not gone off because the spoon was still taped down. Another BRIEF Easter Egg of note occurs during the transport of Easy to Bastogne. We see Easy Co. in the backs of deuce and a halfs and the camera briefly shows the truck driver - a black soldier. This is a knod to the "Red Ball Express". The date of that ride was 16 Decmber 1944. Although the Allies had been in Europe since 6 June, they had not secured a deep water port yet. All of the Western Ally's supplies were still being off-loaded at the Normandy beaches and were being driven 400 miles to the front lines, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. EVERYTHING the Allied Armies needed from fuel and medicine to mail and chewing gum were being hauled overland by US transportation units. Because of the rampant racism in US at the time, Black American soldiers were placed into these supporting units (which were all-Black units except for the officers who were more often white) and kept away from combat roles as a general procedure. Spielberg and Hanks showing a black driver was their way of showing respect to the tireless, back-breaking, thankless and grossly overlooked work that these units did. Make no mistake, Germany was not beaten by "superior Allied equipment and training". What made the US military formitable then, and what still makes the US military the powerhouse that it is today, was America's ability to manufacture and move mindboggling amounts of men and material all over the globe. (I could go into depth here, but I won't bore anyone unless they ask for it, in which case, bring the tequila and have a seat). Since you already watch the next episode, the Battle of the Bulge should not be a spoiler to you. On 16 December 1944, 240,000 - 500,000 German soldiers (depends upon your source as to how many German soldiers were involved, but most sources place the number near 500,000) comprising 30 divisions (generally understrength) suprised the American forces by attacking through the Ardennes Forest in Belgium and launched what was to become the United States Army's largest battle in history. The Allies were caught completely by surprise and units such as the 101st, were rushed to the front so fast that the men generally only had their immediate combat gear. Many didn't even have weapons (but you already know this because you watch the next episode). Two German Armies would push a bulge in the Allied front line in an attempt to split US and British forces and capture bridges over the Meus river. Hitler believed that this would force the Western Allies to negotiations for a ceasefire, which would in turn allow him to move the German army units to the east to battle the advancing Soviets who were already in eastern Germany. By the time the front line was returned to its pre-16 December locations, 24 US divisions (16 infantry and 8 armored - both the 101st in Bastogne and the 82nd Airborne further north in the St. Vith region were considered infantry divisions) would take part, and over 700,000 Allied troops would be involved. Reality Check: When taken as a whole, Bastogne was neither the most brutal of the fighting that the Allies faced, nor was it the main focus. The main German push and concentration of forces ("Kampfgruppe Peiper" - Battle Group Peiper) was in the north in the St. Vith region. The 101st being surrounded in Bastogne, however, made better copy for the Allied newpapers back home, so it received/s a disproportionate focus as a result. Even though I know you have watched the episode already, I will hold off on babbling about it to prevent spoilers. The one point I will make is that the winter of 1944-45 was the coldest winter in over 50 years. The average temperature was 20 degrees F (-7 C), with nighttime temperatures dropping to between 10 to -4 degrees F. While I have spent enough time in the winter cold of Alaska, northern Europe, and Korea (the worst) to know the real meaning of cold, we were fully equipped. Even with good equipment and clothing, the cold in these places was indescribable, and I still lost parts of my feet to frostbite. I cannot imagine how horrible it was for all of the underequipt Allied forces. They have my complete and unwavering respect. As always, it is a sincere pleasure to watch your reactions to this series and go through this journey with you.

Ben

Phil and Brett, the operation was far larger than Sobel. If you want to learn more about Sobel at Normandy, check out WW2 Wayfinder's video, "Band of Brothers MOST HATED at Normandy, 1944 Then and Now" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HAfDxPHwrO0). Nannette and Carolyn - Do not watch this episode until AFTER your BoB journey as it might spoil a few things. However, afterwards definitely watch it.

Ben

Nannette and Carolyn, As you are adding to your new list of movies to watch, add "Das Boot". You are already on a run with WW2 films, so you should add it to your schedule after "A Bridge Too Far" and before you move to the Pacific Theater with "The Pacific". While fictional, "Das Boot" does the best job of any film ever in conveying life aboard a German U-boat (Unterseeboot = submarine). It is a German film. While I find watching it in its original German (with English subtitles) is a different experience than watching it in English, it is still incredibly powerful. As for the Eastern Front, most people suggest, "Enemy at the Gates", which is a must see. But it doesn't hold a candle to Joseph Vilsmaier's 1993, "Stalingrad". This is another German film, but it follows a platoon of German soldiers who are transferred to the Eastern front in August 1942 and find themselves in Stalingrad. It also comes in English, but like "Das Boot" I find it much more powerful in German with English subtitles. Here is the YouTube link to it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VnJJQxZ0hu8 And my favorite film about the German Army on the Eastern Front is Sam Peckinpah's 1977, "Cross of Iron". It is definitely Peckinpah! And since you will eventually need to explore his movies, it is a good place to start. As you become familiar with his storytelling and movie making describing something as "Peckinpah" speaks volumes in one simple word (much like saying something is "Kubrick"). The YouTube link to "Cross of Iron" is [ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5y4ck6EUFrM ].

Phil Stubblefield

Wow, Ben, thank you so much for this fascinating read! And thank your for listing the other YT channels; I've seen animated versions of the Battle of the Bulge on other channels — and I've read what a bastard Peiper was! — but I look forward to learning more from the channels you mentioned. Even so, it hadn't really occurred to me that the actions around Bastogne had been magnified in the media for morale purposes. "Nuts!" indeed... 😉 Your mention of Korea and other places makes it sound as if you may have served in the military. If so, thank you sincerely for your service! 🫡

Totally Whatever

Yes, thank you for all of the information and YT channel suggestions. It a pleasure watching along with you too.

Ben

Phil, yes ... I was an infantry officer (and all the tabs and wings that go along with that) from '83-'94, which was a LONG time ago, in a much different world, in a much younger and less broken body. Back when I was bullet proof. Thank you for the comment, but you don't need to thank me. You were worth it. As for the other YT channels, I am currently planning a trip to Europe next Spring to walk some battlefields. Right now I am deep in the pre-research (reading primary source AARs, going over primary source maps, making battle overlays on my Google Earth account, etc). I have been to Bastogne and visited Patton's grave in Luxembourg (one of my uncles is buried in that cemetary also), but haven't been to Normandy yet. I am still not sure if I want to start exploring Omaha and the airborne AO or if I am going to retrace Kampfgruppa Peiper's line of attack from the German border to Stavelot. One of my former client's grandfather was one of the survivor's of Malmedy, and I had a chance to talk to him on Zoom in the Spring of 2020 before he passed away. That reawakened my interest in operations in the St. Vith area. Unfortunately, my wife has already told me that I will be doing this trip alone as she is headed in the other direction to see our oldest and our grandson. This will mark the second time I have been back to Europe since we got married, and the second time I will be doing it alone. (In fairness, the last trip in March 2022 doesn't really count as I went to Ukraine to help - and for some reason she wasn't very interested in going... puzzling.)

PP82

Alley did indeed survive. in fact, you met him in the interview section in Ep. 4.

Bill Elliott

Wanted to comment, as a follow on to my post about Crimson Tide, when I went through XO school, they showed us the clip from this episode where Winters becomes XO and he has to focus more on overall leadership and admin while Easy Company is still running missions. I had seen the show, so I understood the context, just wanted to point out that that the military thinks so highly of this show that we reference it in training. Keep trucking to 50,000 you two.

Totally Whatever

Wow, that's incredible. It is so good that they reference it during training.