Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Chapter Forty-Eight - Bandit Camping

Bit iffy on this one? I don't want to say why because that poisons the responses, and sometimes a chapter I'm iffy on turns out to be fine. Ah, just let me know what you think?

***

Some people might, wrongfully, accuse Cricket of being unobservant.

Cricket would like to beat those people over the head with an oversized mallet. 

She was exceptionally very observant! The thing was, she mostly observed things that mattered to her. Like pretty ladies.

Right now, she was observing two, patiently eyeing them both as they handled the situation.

Lucky was taking her first real bit of dangerous combat well. She had certainly fought a few monsters here and there as they travelled, but those fights had been relatively quick things, with Rosario standing nearby. Really, they were about as safe as a fight against a monster could be. Tame, almost.

This had been a lot more frantic. 

Cricket had sweated a little too. If she were caught out in this ambush on her own she would... well, she’d be dead. That bolt at the start had been flying straight towards her pretty little button nose, with enough speed behind it that it would have turned her into one of those zombies.

Could she fight nearly ten zombies on her own? Maybe. Having them distracted by Lucky had helped a lot. She could have, she suspected. She could definitely have run.

Could she had done it with [Bandits] firing bolts into her back? That she was less sure about.

In any case, it was over now. The bodies were lit up, and the remaining, living bandits were being trussed up with expert ease by Lucky.

Cricket knew what had to be done with them. They were too far from any city to bring them back alive. 

But... Rosario had acted rather strangely after she killed that one. The elven woman was more... different? Reserved? Stoic? Yes, that might be the one. More stoic. 

Cricket didn’t like that. She liked it when pretty ladies were smiling and laughing and happy. Oh, sure, a smouldering glare or two would spin her waterwheel but this was different. 

Had Rosario never killed anyone? No, that was impossible. Hundreds of years old, with three titles, and the reputation of a Great General. There was no way.

But maybe she had changed? There was a very long blank in Rosario’s past, between the time of the Demon Lord--long before Cricket was born--and now. Maybe the woman had changed in that time? Become more of a pacifist? 

“Now what, boss?” Cricket asked. 

That snapped Rosario out of it, at least for the moment.

Cricket would sneak into her tent and give her lots of hugs and whatever later, to distract her from her woes. Truly, she was the best bug.

“Let’s distribute the loot first,” Rosario said. When one of the bandits complained that it was their stuff, Rosario glared, and once again the world seemed to still, the air growing warm and thick, though it was nowhere near as bad as it had been.

Was that Rosario’s killing intent earlier? Spooky! Cricket wondered if there were other sorts of intents that the elven lady could use...

“Once we’ve gone through it, we can see about finding their camp. Something about this feels a little strange. Is banditry common in these parts?” Rosario asked.

“Bandits are common wherever the guards don’t act against it,” Cricket replied with a shrug. “This area had a long, dangerous, unguarded road. It wouldn’t surprise me at all to discover that there are people trying to make a profit from it.”

Rosario frowned some more. “I don’t like that.”

“Lawful people rarely like lawless things,” Cricket said. Then she sighed theatrically. “Oh, where oh where is the pretty lawful paladin who will sweep me off mine feet and tie me to a wall and punish me for all of my many, many sins?”

“Okay,” Rosario said. “We’re going to continue, and possibly find these bandit’s camp.”

Cricket straightened herself, taking the moment more seriously. “And then what?” she asked. “Dearest Rose, I thought you were in a hurry. We’re more than a day’s walk from the city, and further still from our destination. Whatever shall we do with this lot?”

“We’ll bring them with us,” Rosario said.

The loot was fun to kick around and look at, but it wasn’t anything that interested them too much. Cricket pocketed the spare knives. None were balanced for throwing, and they felt and looked rather cheap, but sometimes she needed a cheap but sharp hunk of metal to throw around. 

Lucky picked up a velvet and leather jerkin. It was a little too large on her frame, but the sleeveless coat did fit. It was not much when it came to protection, but it was better than nothing, and being sleeveless, it wouldn’t interfere with her swordsmanship. 

“We’ll tailor that on the road,” Rosario said. “It looks like it has straps for adjustments already.”

“Thank you,” Lucky said.

There was a bit of coin. The bandits mostly had bronze bits, but there were a few silver crows. Interestingly, most were from Aerie. Cricket didn’t mention it. It could be nothing.

They left much of the loot behind. Someone would stumble upon it and find themselves lucky, but they didn’t have the room or inclination to carry so much stuff so far.

The bandits had a camp.

That much was obvious, they had to sleep somewhere, and it probably wouldn’t be so close to a bunch of wild zombies. Cricket expected the camp to be, at most, a small palisade tucked in next to a bit of cover, with a couple of tents.

Instead, the snivelling bandits they were leading at swordpoint brought them around a slight bend in the gorge and into the woods off to one side.

The camp was nestled there, behind a stand of trees and bushes thick enough to conceal it from the road. Stones had been shifted and moved and piled up to form an enclosing wall behind which a palisade had been erected.

The camp had a dozen tents, some only big enough for one, others were more like small pavilion tents. 

More concerning was the fact that there were three proper, stone buildings and the walls of the gorge were dug into at the rear, giving the camp more room and creating a small cave for storage.

There were no guards on duty, but there were several bandits wandering around, looking like busy little bees. 

“This is a whole operation,” Lucky said. “Um, what is it you said in our lessons, about armies needing logistics?”

“Armies live on their bellies,” Rosario said. “And this is almost an army. I count...” Her adorable elf ears twitched. “Seventeen people in this camp. Counting with the four we fought, that’s twenty-one members.”

“A dozen tents and three buildings,” Cricket said. “They could house a lot more.”

Rosario hummed, then grabbed the [Highwayman] by the collar. “How many are you?” she asked.

“I’m not telling you s-shit, hag!”

The man screamed as he was launched over the walls of the camp and came down, crashing through a small handcart in the middle of it.

“Cricket,” Rosario said.

“Yes, your non-hagishness?” Cricket asked. She had to refrain from giggling at the gimlet-eye look Rosario gave her.

“I’m going to clear this camp. Stay here with these two. Lucky, you as well. I know that this could be precious experience for you, but let’s not push it.”

“Yes, ma’am,” Lucky said.

They sat back and watched as Rosario did her thing. The woman was holding back. She landed in the camp, swiped her sword, and took off the rooftops of all three buildings as well as the topmost section of every tent.

That turned things rather chaotic as bandits had to deal with her and the fact that their buildings were falling apart.

Lucky gasped, and it wasn’t because Rosario was showing off... probably. It was certainly doing something for Cricket, seeing the elf cut apart entire buildings with casual ease. No, the gasp was because someone stomped out of one of the ruins. A man, tall, covered in muscles, and wearing armour that was several tiers better than what the other bandits wore. 

[Hidden]

The Dirty Hand

[Bandit Lord] - level 8

A Titled? 

The presence of someone like that, just out here in the middle of nowhere, was impossibly strange. A titled bandit on top of that...

The man roared, then launched a punch toward Rosario.

And then there were several parts of him flying away.

Ah, yes, right. 

Cricket licked her lips. That man was a little baby Titled. Her elf was a big-name proper Titled.

And to think that just a week or so ago, Cricket wouldn’t have believed there to be any real difference. Titled were at the top. How could she even dare to imagine that not all of them were built of the same stuff. Some of them were built of stuff like long shapely elf ears and legs and...

The camp took all of three minutes to clear, then Rosario was there, casually kicking some of the bandits out towards the centre.

“Cricket, Lucky, it’s safe,” she called out while wiping the end of her sword clean with a cloth. She had a... look on her face.

Cricket and Lucky entered the camp properly, pushing their injured prisoners ahead.

Things moved surprisingly fast from there. They checked on the rooms and buildings of the camp, discovering plenty of stolen goods, crates, bags, but not very much that they could do anything with.

Then it came time to decide what to do. 

Cricket had a simple solution, but first, she insisted that they loot what they could. Which meant grabbing loose coins mostly, and emptying the coffers they found in the Titled’s roofless office. There was, concerningly, a good bit of paperwork there which Rosario took with her. 

“I’ll send a signal to the Adventurer’s Guild,” Cricket said with a nod. “You two head on out.”

“We could stay with you,” Lucky said.

“No. Shoo shoo. Let big sister Cricket take care of everything... Actually, no, don’t call me that, it’s weird. Especially with the things I intend to do.”

Rosario stared at her, then at the bandits trussed up and partially bandaged in a rough line in the centre of the camp.

“Are you... certain?” she asked.

“Yep! Don’t worry, Cricket has it handled!”

She waited until they were gone, then another five minutes.

And then Cricket removed one of her sharpest knives from her inventory.

She didn’t know why Rosario couldn’t take care of things, but that was fine. She’d do it, with a joke. She stepped up behind the first of the bandits, grabbing him by the shoulder. “Say... what do sea monsters eat for dinner?” she asked.

The man said something, but his mouth was muffled over.

“Fish and ships!” Cricket said. 

She cut.

She moved on to the next. It was hard to deliver a joke when the man was screaming and squirming so much, but she did what she had to do. Maybe the humour wouldn’t reach them, but the best way to go out was as a punchline, wasn’t it?

Whatever Rosario had going on was fine. Cricket could look past it, and do that part for her. That was what good friends were for, wasn’t it?

***

Files

Comments

ArchetypeOfCuriosity

Didn’t expect that. Maybe it’s the fact that to our sensibilities Criquet is acting like a psychopath? Though in most settings like this it is quite normal to not make more job for the guards…

Taitenator

This chapter is a little jarring but it’s in a good way - pulling back the “genre” of the situation for a peek at the Reality of this world

ThisIsMyFateNow

Honestly, Cricket chapters are some of my favorites. I love her outlook on things and the fact that she probably thinks the fact that Rose is a legendary Great General only makes her more desirable lol. As far as feeling iffy, I wouldn't worry too much. It's was a great chapter and we get to see a side of Cricket that is a lot more cold and calculating than we might have expected.

xcc wolf

I guess once she was done, all that was left were Crickets.

Bitty45

I think it's that Cricket doesn't seem bothered at all about killing bandits. Any normal person wouldn't feel great about it, even if normalized. I mean, we could just have Cricket not care about that sort of thing. I do like characters with psychopathic tendencies, as long as the story treats it in a mature way, and not like 'Oh, she's secretly a monster!'

Max Malekzadeh

Yeah, the end this chapter is fucking dark and all but it also feels necessary. Like, there's not really anything else to do witha bunch of bandits that would be too risky to transport all the way to somewhere else just for someone else to kill them. I like that Rosario knows what has to happen but doesn't just immediately become ok with killing people herself. It's a much more realistic take on what someone from our society would likely go through rather than when they just automatically accept killing like it's nothing.

Adam

TFTC IMO chapter is good. Gives character depth

Cyrus McEnnis

Mmmm, I see what you mean. I don't know that I'd worry too much about it, although the joking while commiting banditicide is perhaps a step too far. Clowns have a certain duality to them. Sad and happy in equal measure. If we take The Joker as perhaps the most famous fictional clown, you can draw some parallels about how Cricket is acting. That's not necessarily a good thing - Mr. J is hardly a bastion of behaviour to be emulated! But, well, Cricket is a performer. A pragmatic, horny, performer. And it is in no way out of keeping for her to proactively retaliate against some bandits so that what is a small problem today doesn't become a gigantic headache tomorrow. I just dunno that she'd crack jokes while doing so. I'd think she'd be more likely to perform in a different way - do a sad soliloquy perhaps. "Alas, poor unwashed and unloved bandit, I know you not. And now I know you less." sort of deal.

Bad Dog

Absolutely awesome chapter. This is what I was hoping to see. Rosario could not bring herself to do what needed to be done but she did not stand in the way of someone who could. My respect for her character has gone up quite a bit. Cricket lived up to my expectations that underneath the clown mask lives a strong pragmatic person that has the empathy and balls to recognize that Rosario needed help and would not ask for it. Instead she stepped up and shielded her from a grim duty without calling attention to it. This showed that Cricket has real character depth beyond the surface mask she wears every day. Bravo!

Bitty45

In that case, Cricket would be trying to tie herself to Rosario, not just because it would be really fun, but also because she's ridiculously powerful, and having strong friends is a certain kind of power. Cricket also happens to be logical and smart. She's quick to catch onto things, all while playing the fool.

Emmi

This went about as expected, honestly, and doing it in Cricket’s POV I think works in favor of the tone. Rosario understandably hasn’t adjusted to how things work here

Ivy

Oh gods I love introspective cricket. What a good faithful bug. Was not expecting this level of morbid out of this story at all but it might just mean I get more invested hahaha. Lucky is bound to figure out Rosario soon though...

Mattwandcow

I think this *could* be in character but it's not quite been foreshadowed enough. I would not have described Cricket as being willing to do the hard and dirty thing. I think her reasoning makes sense, but maybe adding some bits when she's talked about backstory, some dark parts of that not quite rebel group or something. That might help make this more congruous

Bitty45

If Lucky spotted the titled, then saw Rosario cut through them like butter... that's probably not high tier 3 behaviour.

Michael Zinkstein

I really love the Artwork of Cricket and how she handles stuff. From our modern view it might be excessive what she does, but that are our modern views of it. In Medieval times, in some regions if you set a house on fire you where sentenced to death. If it was by accident it was an „easy“ death, but doing it on purpose and you would be tortured to death. That is just how far their moral and ethical values differ from ours. Also thanks for the chapter.

JordyTheBear

my only real problem with the chapter is that we dont see Rosario's perspective, which i assume will come next/later. Otherwise i agree with other people, i love Cricket's perspective

mechajlaw

I like it, gives Cricket a lot more depth. I don't think she should go full murder clown though.

Bitty45

If Cricket is this smart though, I wonder why she kept getting herself put into the stocks, back when we met her? She clearly would know that she'd get put in there...

Joel Tone

Cricket taking care of business for Rosario. Killing them in cold blood is jarring but what are tge options? Thanks for the chapter

Hannah Anthony

Yeah, the end of the chapter *definitely* is a bit of a swerve tone wise. It's a good swerve, and feels right for Cricket (a murderous jester does in fact need to kill people). It's unexpected, but the more I sit on it the more it makes sense and it doesn't feel out of character at all. I could believe before this chapter that she'd be willing to kill 20 captured bandits without blinking.

Ivy

"Lucky gasped" oh she noticed.

gostsamo

> “Armies live on their bellies,” Rosario said. "armies are like snakes, move on their bellies" might be the quote Rosario is looking for. making Cricket into the psycho assassin type would work if you retcon her lackluster attitude and low level from the beginning. being low-level on a common job speak for no experience in the real cutthroat business, so deciding to go through a police lineup and care not about witnesses is rather new for her. joking during the proceedings goes against that. overall though, a second layer for her is better than what we had so far.

Nathaniel Cloud

I definitely agree that the guards had to die. I lean more towards Cricket's mentality than Rosario's, ironically. If there's anything that makes me pause, it's the disrespect Cricket has while going about it? But even that is not major; it fits for her character, she is often irreverent at times others find it uncalled for, and could be a sign of either trying to keep her own morale, or get own hatred for bandits. Combined with the history of her role getting framed for a bandit murder they didn't cause... Yeah, I can see it.

astralFitz

Ah, so Cricket's going to be their lady's spymistress, good to know; after all, who suspects the literally capering disaster lesbian to be the knife in the shadows >:3c

Temaki

I would say the big issue is the disconnect. Being able to kill people, nevermind a dozen of them in cold blood, without being quite shaken up about it is a very rare trait. And it doesn't make for particularly pleasant people. So the way Cricket gors about it, with little to no discomfort or self-justification, feels off.

BWH

Cricket is, without a doubt, the best bug. She will be a soft landing for our Faithful Maid until Rosie gets her bearings in this new world. She'll make an excellent Great General too. 🦗💖

Manlor

Clowns are always bloodthirsty. That's part of the job description I think.

Rezkel

Hmm well if you want some random thoughts about the chapter.... I am not some one who thinks an isekaied character should immediately throw away their values from their former world just because the new one is harsher. That said there are pragmatic solutions to these kinds of issues, Rosario could have taken Cricket and Lucky to the nearest town farly quickly and brought a law enforcement group back to the bandit camp and stayed out of the rest of it. Having chosen not to do that she should have comitted to the actions that were needed. I am glad that Cricket realized what was going on and helped, though maybe she should have first tryed to talk to Rosario before making assumptions. The jokes at the end kind of made the whole thing a lot more horrifying, made Bug into a right serial killer there.

Blaid Tds

I would like to see Lucky's reaction to Rose casually bodying a Titled. If the building beheading was enough to illecit a response, bro going down should cause serious questions.

Levi

The sentance for banditry is death, and the only good bandit is a dead bandit etc. The chapter works

TroubleFait

It kinds of hints at a difference in culture between us and this world. But as for what it says about this world and how it works…

Simon

LOL what a horrible way to die. Dad jokes and puns? Now THAT'S dark

TroubleFait

And yet even then, not everyone killed people. We might be hasty in thinking they were so different from us.

TroubleFait

Her cracking jokes doesn't work really well from an entertainment standpoint, but I think that's good. Cricket is not so used to killing captives that she has a well-rounded routine for it. Instead, she might be cracking jokes as a way to ground herself in something she's familiar with. She's not doing it to entertain but to calm herself.

Simon

Also, too many comments in here talking about how dark this is. I support the summary execution! They'd be executed anyway so why should Rosario help the local rulers make a farce of a trial out of it? To appease the population and reassert authority? Who cares about them, they let it get bad enough for a titled to come out! Transporting then would be a waste of food and energy, and invites a violent escape that could kill Lucky. Nah, screw that. Take the sword to em

TroubleFait

People can be smart and dumb at the same time. They can have extreme skill in specific domains, and be clueless in others. Even in one discipline.

Narf

Except for when getting publicly shamed is someone's kink, of course. We're supportive like that.

Tricimir *

I was actually sorta expecting Rose to do something absurd like teleport them all back to town or something. Culture differences or not, this does raise the question of just how our little bug has gotten so comfortable with killing.

Trillion

I would perhaps tweak the end to insinuate/make it obvious what happens, but not clearly state it. Incorporate the last two lines & "but the best way to go out was as a punchline, wasn’t it?" though, theyre good lines.

Alloni Kramer

I like the contrast between Cricket's perspective of the world and Rose's. It shows pretty well that Cricket may act like the comic relief a lot of the time, but really she sees the world in a different way than the normal Earth-human one, which can lead into what we would consider to be darker behaviors.

Lord Nesh

I agree with a lot of other people in the comments. I think this was a good chapter. It's okay to delve into dark topics. I also think it was handled really well, and was a good way to set the tone for story as something serious. There's generally two ways to handle isekai. You can either gloss over the fact that a civilian is transported into a brutal setting without warning, or you confront it. I prefer the latter.

Narf

Whether the last bit is a problem or not depends a bit on how you want to portray Cricket's character. For starters, I entirely agree that letting the bandits go wasn't an option, not for career criminals and serial murderers. Taking them with them also wasn't really an option on a multi-day march with only Rose being able to supervise the captives. So far I think it's generally agreeable no matter what. The thing that some people may mind is not the what, it's the how of Cricket's action. And I don't mean the way of execution, that one is mercifully quick. I mean how Cricket handles it. Because with how careless she acts about it and even cracks bad jokes, that comes across as either quite the psychopath - even for a violent world, one can see the necessity and still not be so "whatever" about it. Unless Cricket has been hiding levels in other less savoury jobs she simply is not hardened a veteran enough to have grown this jaded about killing people. Maybe it's a racial trait for insect people to just care way less about killing people, maybe it's just her personality. Or it may be a coping mechanism, a front that she's putting up to be able to deal with what she's doing. Either way this needs to be adressed in some way. Not immediatly, not necessarily directly, but whyever she's able to kill this easily needs to be part of Cricket's story and personality in the future. This cannot be a once-and-done event, I think. Just like Rose's aversion to killing needs to be addressed at some point.

MushedOut

I actually, really, really love this chapter. I was kinda worried about how Cricket would be handled when the novelty of her comedy wore off, but this is a very interesting direction. Seeing her perspective after only seeing how others react to her for so long is so great. I for one love our semi(?) psychopathic bug.

Arcanemagus

I did find it a bit interesting that during the heat of combat Rosario didn't have any issues, it was only the "cleanup" afterwards that Cricket had to help with.

wayy

I really like this chapter a lot

Genebeep (LadyLinq)

That's pretty disturbing, and I Really think Cricket and Rosario should have a discussion about why Rosario doesn't like killing, but I do think that was the only feasible option.

MushedOut

Also note Rosario's advice on how to level. Cricket's getting that little extra bit of exp in.

FOG DRAGON

After reading the chapter and some of the other comments I will say this chapter is pretty good stays with the tone of the story but shows the darker side of it, and I’m going with the head cannon cricket is joking to ground herself as some of the other comments have said instead of her just being a psychopath

Total Absolutism

It's understandable. She's so strong that killing them comes accidentally. But once they give up, or are defeated, that's hard. Far too many isekai protagonists become fine with murder way too quickly.

Bad Dog

I’m not sure I would categorize Cricket as going too far with the joking. My take on it was that she is using the joking as a mask and a distraction from something she doesn’t want to look too close at. In my opinion this is just her coping mechanism, not some sadistic reaction like the Jokers.

Total Absolutism

I don't read it as psychopathic so much as the ppragmatism one would expect from a worldly individual in this kind of setting. She knows that dragging the bandits with them isn't feasible. She knows they have killed innocent people. She knows they will just get put to death even if they take them back. And I think her joking about it actually shows that she isn't comfortable with it really because she needs to use her preferred coping mechanism.

Nyx

I think Cricket has just been through that hard of a life to reach this point. She's ladies and fun and games because she chooses to be... pragmatic about killing because she hasn't had any other choice.

Bad Dog

Yes, in my opinion Cricket is the smartest person in that entire group. She just doesn’t show it unless it is absolutely necessary.

Chris Paddon

A little cold reality in amoungst all of the cute fantasy is good. It is like salt on food. Cricket is an interesting creature. A mix of lewd horny bug, and the sort of cold pragmatism and casual disregard for life that makes her dangerous. Rosario choosing not to kill, and thinking that leaving the bandits hobbled and unable to defend themselves isn't just a slower way of killing them shows the disconnect between her past as a gamer, and the current reality of her relationship with this world.

ts25679

I think I made my position on bandits quite clear last chapter. They murdered whole families. Animals and monsters do that; and once they target sapient beings they become an intolerable threat. They chose to abandon their humanity, so they should be put down like rabid animals.

Bad Dog

Yes, in my opinion Cricket is the smartest person in that entire group. She just doesn’t show it unless it is absolutely necessary. I wonder if by book 3 the name of the story is going to crchange to

Jesus

This chapter made me rethink what this story's tone is going to be. Its going to be innocent OP MC in a cynical world living by their standards because they're just that strong but not changing how the the rest of the cast see life because talk-no-jutsu isn't a thing and they're ultimately a stranger in a strange land with no real stakes in whatever happens. The tourist Isekai story archetype, a bit like what I remember Diana from Past the Redline is.

RekoOne

It exists two kinds of stories. Stories you think about. And stories you just have to relax the critical part of the brain when reading. This story is someone from an modern world that chooses to go all in on being a maid and taking a side in a conflict between nobels. So more a relaxing the brain kind of a story. So I recommend that they just let the bandits run away. Because the darker, maybe more realistic, choice of killing 20 prisoners, do not fit in the relaxed tone of the story.

Bad Dog

You need to think about the kind of world they are living in. Are you aware that not that long ago people would bring children to public executions? Hangings used to be done in public as late as the late 1800s. It was considered to be character building. People in our ultra-civilized world have lost touch with how ruthless people used to be to anyone that was considered a criminal.

Cyrus McEnnis

I don't disagree, but that could be indicated by something displaying that lack of comfort. Say, for example, her voice cracking as she says the punchline.

Cass Fleming

yeah credit to Cricket and she is 100% right for this. also heavy respect for recognizing that Rose wasnt up for this and the baby swordsman was absolutely not ready and taking the heavy duty for herself. banditry isnt all or nothing, but there are lines. you can negotiate with desperate people and even some fools trying to get a bit of coin and supplies off a merchant. you cannot negotiate with people willing to kill children to bolster their traps, and who practice absolute lethality. this is ironically why historically most pirates operated more along the lines of racketeering and negotiation, because its more profitable, safer, and when it goes wrong has less severe consequences even. when you start burning ships and slaughtering crews your career gets a lot shorter and a lot harder. but yeah tangent aside, they crossed a line, and leaving them alive would do far more harm than good. really like that the story went there, and i like the way you balAnced it, Ros isnt ready for it, which is fair, its an ugly thing, but Cricket knew better. too often stories forget what mercy costs in matters of slavers, slaughterers, and rapists, especially when mercy bruises their egos

TortyMorty

Yeah, dark ending... but hell, life is not always shiny roses.

TortyMorty

Cricket has her own way of dealing with things. Doesn't make her less of a goofball.

Michael Zinkstein

We are all humans, so we all bleed red if cut. I am not saying they were all murderers on a killing spree. I say they have different views on certain things. Torture was a legal practice to get evidence. Today we frown upon such methods. We have advanced methods like fingerprints. Things they didn’t have then. Knowledge can change your view. That not only works for a person but over generations for a whole country. Had to repost it cause of Patreon and mobile device shenanigans.

Mary Pardo

Scary Cricket! Bugs are a lot more pragmatic, I guess, even bugs not ruled by hive thinking.

Goa

The way the others left Cricket alone was very strange. I don't remember sending a signal to the Adventurer’s Guild being a thing, or that it needs privacy. Also, what does Rosario expect will happen if the bandits are brought to a city? In most cultures, the punishment for banditry is death.

Joseph (T3mmie)

I feel like you didn't take the grim situation too far. If you went into too much detail it would have bothered me but it doesn't feel too out of line at least imo.

White Neko Knight

The slow break down of Rosario's gaming logic into something more realistic is good character development.

Temaki

Public hangings, yes, with all the justifications and dehumanisation that went with them. But if you go back even as far as the crusades, the people who executed others with blades tended to get very messed up. Heck, a lot of hangmen (despite the fact that, as can be shown, killing with a lever is way less damaging than killing with a blade) had alcohol problems.

Alanna Fry

As someone who has seen some combat. Its really easy to pull the trigger in the moment when you're not thinking. When you have time to think is when that shit hits you

MushedOut

I'm pretty sure the implication is that Rosario knew what Cricket was about to do

BWH

"Why should I apologize for the monster I have become? No one ever apologized for making me this way." ~Nitya Prakash, Little Lucknow

BWH

Rosie knew exactly what Cricket was going to do when they walked away. I suspect that they are both going to have to talk it out later, but good on them both for knowing what needed to be done and more on Cricket for knowing that Rosie couldn't do it herself.

OshiFantasy

I liked the chapter! If I was pressed for constructive criticism, I'd say on the whole it felt a little dry when cricket wasn't being cricket. That said, I dont know how you'd solve that without leaning deeper into the dark nature of the chapter so its also fine if it's a bit light on the immersion during the horrible moments.

Dragof2

I love it! This doesn't break the tone of the story, and for an adventurer killing bandits, even captives, is not crazy. Others disagree, but in general I dislike characters in medieval settings having sensibilities that are too modern, it makes the setting feel fake. For most of history human life was valued far lower than it is now. Cricket isn't over the moon about killing, but she is too seasoned for it to bother her that much.

Rezkel

I think this chapter strikes a good balance, it doesn't just randomly kill people nor does it let the truely deserving go unpunished. Too many authors have killing as the go to solution to all problems, while others will let true monsters get off scott free after the MC has a cathartic verbal/physical beat down leaving the person to continue to purpetuate their crimes on the innocent after recovering.

C E

A nice reminder that Rose is actually a monster compared to 99% of people in this world I would be somewhat surprised if Rose didn't hear what Cricket was up to here though, the question really is if she will say anything about it

HikinBear

Well said! 👍👍

J Harrow

I think it’s a great chapter, cricket mvp 🫡

Cass Fleming

exactly. considering moral weight adds texture and depth to stories no matter the tone, hyperviolence or nonviolence without consideration can be equally empty. feel that last bit about stories pulling their punches at the last minute heavily, its so annoying. esp in high power stories where the character might be one of the only people who can do anything about it. comes of overly simplistic or neglected moral consideration ignoring that inaction is itself a choice.

Nowa

That girl is a keeper! I'm happy to see Cricket showing no mercy, to stand in for Rosario until she sort herself considering the world they're in.

Nowa

True, if you live a modern setting, there are some leeway for modern Earth sensibilities.

Nowa

I argue you need to kill the prison and royal guards as those lot are not your standard people due to who they're guarding and dangerous people should be killed to stop them from going after you again.

Nowa

The how over Cricket actions easily explain by what she learned when journeying by herself, during the circus troupe and afterwards until Rosario arrival.

kindlyshrewmidgeon

Maybe more background on how cricket lost her troupe would be helpful. Like at least one flashback. Something to show how she’s accepted that death sometimes needs to happen, and *she’ll be the one to carry that burden*, but not so jarring that it paints this further as terrible thing has made her into anJoker-like/psychopath. As is this feels like she’s almost mercy killing them, and I think that’s exactly the right tone. She’ll carry the weight, do the deed because she can, and send the bandits off as easily as she can, for herself as much as them.

Bramble

Okay so the joking as she executes them is interesting, to me it seems like she’s kind of just forcefully disassociating herself to get what needs to be done, done. And while we know Cricket has been through some shit, that’s still a hell of a switch-up from the flirty, jokey, somewhat lazy Jester we’ve come to know. But it also makes me think Cricket uses her Jester-y-ness (definitely a word, I’m sure) the same way Rosario uses her Maidly-ness to just deal with certain situations.

Menthewarp

I look forward to how Rosario covers for her own behavior.

Dane Stobbe

"little baby Titled" Haha! Yes! So glad someone said it! Fits so well coming from Cricket, too. re:iffy on the chapter (I wonder if I got a different read on that than other people?) The first half felt a little off to me. I think mostly because Cricket isn't being as campy?- surreal?- as characteristically *Cricket* as she usually is. It sets up well for the darker tone, but she's maybe playing it a bit too straight (*only the comedy duo definition). I think you could lighten up some of the early dialogue to break up her explanations a bit. A couple suggestions to those points (pulled out quick, didn't go over the whole thing so might not be the best examples): “Now what, boss?” could be “Now what, General?” -she was just thinking about Rose's past, so it's a slip up, but she can also cover for it by pointing out that Lucky is a Soldier and Rosario is much stronger than just a Sgt or Captain. “Bandits are common wherever..." -this explanation feels a bit too direct for Cricket. Surely she'd throw in a joke as part of it? -and the paladin joke afterwards feels really forced. Like she's annoyed that she *has to* make the joke, rather than pleased that she *gets to*. If she is feeling annoyed (maybe at Rose's reluctance to be an executioner?) she could snap off a harsh one liner in response to something. Eg: ...people trying to make a profit from it.” Rosario frowned some more. “I don’t like that.” Cricket chirped, "I don't like that they shot at me!" Rosario's ears twitched and she looked away. Cricket was surprised she didn't point out that that bandit was dead, she had already been avenged by her sword-maid in shining leathers. She continued, "Good natured folk rarely *like* seeing crime around them. I've never met a guard that won't raise a fuss at the slightest jest, or a paladin that won't stick their nose in somebody's business." She saw Lucky out of the corner of her eye, the horse girl's face was stern and she nodded in agreement while looking to Rosario. Ah- was it an act for Lucky? The girl didn't know Rose's dark past like Cricket did. "Hmm," she hummed and smirked at the elf's back. "Not that I'd complain about a pretty lady paladin- or any pretty lady with a sword and a sense of right and wrong, sticking her nose in my business." Rosario's posture stiffened, and her ears twitched faster, which just made Cricket smile wider. > okay that suggestion is longer than initially intended, haha. Feels pretty in character and very fun tho! If it starts feeling too light and cheerful before the dark turn, could always have Cricket bring up a story from her troupe days. Or just point out that these bandits *were* using undead children.

CavemanDan

Well it's to be expected in the world our Mr Birb built. Having an unsliced neck as a bandit is a privilege not a right and Cricket reminded them of that. Sure. A bit dark but it fits, after all who's going to put the bandits on trial or even apprehend them. Knifey slicey and it's done \o/ simple as

NoNane09

My read on Rosario is that she dislikes killing in general but especially dislikes killing an opponent who has surrendered (war crimes are bad, actually). On the flip side, Cricket's perspective (to me at least) is that their options are to let them go (right back to banditry) or kill them (because they don't have the tools needed to transport them back), and only one of those options keeps them from killing more innocents. Cricket's been in a traveling circus, she's probably been down a ton of roads like this and seen this happen a few other times.

tr13ze

Thanks for the chapter😁

Maurin

Personally, the trope of the lighthearted and funny character that turns into a stone cold monster the second their friend need them to be is one of my favorite. Plus, Cricket understanding that Rosa is more vulnerable than she appears is necessary for their future relationship in my opinion. I love it when the "weaker" character feels the need to protect the stronger one .

Aldous Russell

Thanks! "these bandit’s camp" should be "bandits' ".

SSS

The ending feels a little weird, the killing was already shocking, but then joking while doing it felt worse. Now I've read others' thoughs and personally I didn't think it was done as a coping mechanism, but because thats part of her class and that's what makes it more messed up. Since a jester jokes and she does it even when killing. Those were my thoughts. The only other thing I found slightly weird was Cricket arriving at all the correct conclusions so "quickly"(we don't now for certain how much time passed), especially about why Rosario was behaving weirdly. Although she did mess up at the end, but again only slightly. Since Cricket does have a lot of information to help her and from what little we've seen is really good at reading people.

steamrick

If Cricket doesn't watch out, she's going to get 'horror clown' offered on her next rank-up. Or worse, 'The Joker'. I quite liked the last part of the chapter. A look behind the curtain, a reminder that despite Rosario still thinking about things in game terms, it's a vicious world.

Rezkel

While i am certainly a person that believes that the excuse of "I was just following orders" doesn't absolve a person of any of the atrocities they commit, i do think there is a difference between an enemy guard and a bandit that is killing families and using their corpses as undead attack dogs. The guards didn't seem to be torturing the guy or anything, they were just watching over him and making sure he couldn't escape, cruel by modern standards certainly but fairly benign by in this world's setting. Killing when you really don't have to when you are clearly the superior person and the others "crime" is that they work for the wrong side seems needlessly edgy and a waste of resources, cause todays enemy could be tomarrows comrad after a good conquering.

Squirrel

Oh, yes, I second that! Such additions could make this moment feel like a culmination of such hints, rather than a sudden reveal. Sounds like a great way to add depth to a final draft

Squirrel

That might be the quote she is referencing, but people frequently paraphrase quotes, especially when they no longer have access to the source material. Heck, I am more familiar with her version than the apparent original you bring up. What she says here fits

gostsamo

oh, I'm just pedant, and the og quote has an interesting punchline lacking from the popular version that I wish more people can appreciate.

Squirrel

I like the chapter well enough, but I do think it shifts the story in a way that needs follow through to be satisfying. Does this hurt Cricket? Do they have honest conversations later? Are there more dark scenes to come? I figure that the other options for handling this were 1- Rosario kills all of them. This option is similar in concept but is strictly less good character writing than the approach you took 2- Rosario uses her OP nature to enable them to safely transport the bandits to an authority who will give them trials and justice. I have no idea why most commenters seem to think this is impossible, since Rosario is an archmage on top of everything else, it seems quite possible she can think of something. Teddy Roosevelt managed something similar, and he was just a mortal badass. The real issues I see with this approach are- In world: that this government is corrupt and this operation seems to be government sponsored to boot. If this is what the characters are thinking, definitely bring it up later. Meta-wise: it would probably be best to avoid making Rosario too much like Broccoli or Carrot. 3- We never encounter such evil folk. If this part changes the tone in a way you don't want, it could be cut I suppose

Marnie

It's giving a different vibe to 'sending a signal to the Adventurer's Guild' than I expected. You may want to foreshadowing Cricket's choice a bit more. Maybe when Rosario says "we'll bring them with us" Rosario can look frustrated? Something early to show taking the bandits with them isn't her preference. Before they leave Cricket should say what her plan is for meeting back up with them.

Marnie

Do we think Rosario understood Cricket's intent? If so, stared is carrying a lot of weight in "Rosario stared at her, then at the bandits". Maybe Rosario could stare assessingly?

Cass Fleming

yeah, and i can see a world where she knows more about local politics and it makes sense to kill the guards over what they might do to the rebellion, but theres a big moral difference between the two. some of the guards were cruel iirc, some werent, ultimately she was there for the king who didnt care, so why would she. more to ethical point though, not killing powerful titled guards is mostly a self-problem. the major risk from her perspective is continued pursuit, so while certainly a little dangerous, leaving focused foes isnt a Problem, bc as you say things can change. not killing organized brutal bandits like that is a Problem, because the risk isnt something you accept for yourself, its something you are accepting for uncountable innocents.

Aleah Cat

Oh. So Cricket has a War Nurse Kurumi vibe going on. Damnnnnn. If you don’t get the reference, go try Magical Girl Spec Ops Asuka. That story kinda opens on the villains mailing the MC’s parents to her in chopped up pieces, so yeah. Kurumi’s thing was… if Asuka couldn’t handle the tough stuff like torture, she’d do it. To protect her precious heroine’s mind.

Zorgdub

I wouldn't say that Rosario doesn't have any issue in the heat of combat. Even then she's making an effort to spare their lives.

Zorgdub

I really like the contrast of Cricket's upbeat and jolly attitude with the grimness of the situation and her actions. Although I think it's a bit weird that we don't get any reaction from Lucky when she sees Rosario effortlessly destroy a Titled when she's supposed to be just a peak tier 3. I know Cricket isn't going to pay too much attention to that but we should at least get something. Or maybe the beginning of the chapter hints at the fact that Cricket is not really observant and completely missed it, which is unsatisfying but would make sense.

NeoJungleLover

Pausing a fight for emotional moment is a anime thing not a real life thing. Anyway good intentions from cricket ig all tho I struggle to see anything impossible about moving bunch of rough men with prepared camp and supplies to a city a day’s way by walk. Noting easy or convenient sure, but definitely an option. In the grand scheme it doesn’t matter yes but it clearly matters to Rose and ultimately she is the driving force.