Sexting Saga Part 3- Game Night (Patreon)
Content
All characters are 21+
Sam raised a brow. “Trouble?”
“Yeah,” Dalton said, still smiling. “We need an in person session next time.”
_________
Sam woke to sunlight creeping through the blinds and the faint buzz of a notification on his nightstand. Groggy, he grabbed his phone and blinked blearily at the screen.
Snapchat — Dalton 😈
He opened it.
Dalton’s thick morning wood, pushing up beneath his boxers, tenting them shamelessly. The caption read:
got a lil problem this morning lol
Sam laughed, rubbing his eyes. Guy’s getting bolder by the day. But it was funny. And weirdly…comforting. Normal, almost.
He rolled back his blanket and snapped one of his own—matching angle, matching wood, same kind of sleepy hardness.
same lol
⸻
Work was mostly how it always is. Mundane. Boring. But there was a fresh new level of fun with Dalton that added to the day.
There were a few loaded glances. A few smirks. During lunch, Dalton slid past Sam in the break room and muttered, “Last night was fun.”
Sam just grinned and sipped his coffee like it was nothing.
Later, across the office, Dalton caught his eye and made an exaggerated jerk-off motion under the desk with a raised eyebrow. Sam nearly choked on his water, flipping him off while trying not to laugh. “Idiot,” he mouthed.
Around 4:30, Dalton strolled over to Sam’s desk, casual as ever.
“Beer after work?” he asked. “Couple guys, end of the day, celebrating how productive we weren’t.”
Sam leaned back in his chair. He already knew where this would probably end up. But he also knew he wanted to go.
“Yeah, alright,” he said. “First round’s on you.”
They hit up a local bar near their office…dim lights, good music, lots of pretty women and opportunities.
They flirted. A lot.
Dalton bought drinks for a pair of brunettes at the bar and got a kiss on the cheek from both before they pranced away. Sam danced with a curvy blonde who grabbed his belt loops and pulled him close. By the second chorus of a slow-burning pop remix, Sam was hard in his jeans and letting her grind against it. He pressed his hard bulge into her ass as she danced back on him. They both knew what they were doing, but neither stopped until the song was over and she went back to her friends.
Somewhere around midnight, both Sam & Dalton ended up back at their table, empty-handed and buzzed.
“Well,” Dalton said, slouching in his seat with a lazy grin, “so much for that.”
Sam laughed. “Your game’s rusty.”
Dalton raised a brow. “My game? You were the one dry humping to a Dua Lipa song and still couldn’t seal the deal.”
“Shut up,” Sam muttered, still smiling.
Dalton leaned in a bit. “Come back to mine? We can have one more drink and smash some Mario Kart.”
Sam hesitated for maybe two seconds. He already knew what else might be on the table.
“Yeah,” he said. “Why not.”
⸻
Dalton’s place was the usual for a late 20’s straight guy: messy, lived-in, comfortable. Clothes on the floor. Dishes in the sink. A game controller under the couch.
Sam was halfway through pouring bourbon over ice when Dalton vanished down the hall. When he came back, he was in just his boxer briefs.
“No pants night,” Dalton announced, plopping down on the couch. “You’re welcome to match the vibe.”
Sam snorted. “You serious?”
Dalton gestured at him with his glass. “Come on, man. Get comfortable.”
Sam shrugged, kicked off his shoes, and peeled off his jeans, flopping back beside him in his t-shirt and briefs. “Better?”
Dalton clinked their glasses together. “Much.”
They sipped, the TV glowing with the game menu. Sam took a long pull, letting the bourbon settle in his chest.
Dalton glanced over. “So…you more of a stepmom stuck in the dryer kind of guy or like busty teen bukkake?”
Sam snorted. “We really doing this?”
Dalton shrugged, grinning. “We’re already in our underwear together. Might as well compare notes.”
Sam laughed. “I don’t know…depends on the mood. Big fan of threesomes lately.”
Dalton smirked. “Course you are.”
“You?”
“Lesbian turns bi. Or bored housewife fucks the pool boy kinda deal. Real dramatic shit.”
They both chuckled, warm and loose, legs sprawled, knees occasionally bumping. Somewhere during the conversation, Sam’s hand drifted lazily over the front of his briefs. He didn’t mean to, not at first…but he was chubbing up again, and he could feel the buzz of energy crackling between them like it had the past few nights.
Dalton adjusted himself, clearly half-hard too. He noticed Sam noticing and didn’t stop. Just grinned.
“Talking about porn gets you going, huh?”
Sam looked at him, hand still low. “Apparently.”
Dalton stretched one leg out and casually squeezed himself through the fabric. “Same.”
They didn’t make a move yet. Just stayed there—two dudes on a couch in their underwear, half-hard, drinking, watching the screen scroll idly by.
They both knew where this was heading.
They were on their second drink now. The game was paused, neither of them paying attention.
Dalton took a sip, eyes flicking to Sam. “You ever play Truth or Dare?”
Sam scoffed. “Yeah. In seventh grade.”
Dalton smirked. “So that’s a yes.”
“I’m not twelve, man.”
“Exactly. So let’s play like adults.”
Sam raised a brow. “And what does that mean?”
Dalton leaned back, grin lazy. “Truth or Dare, but with alcohol and adult shit.”
Sam laughed, shaking his head. “Adult shit? You’re ridiculous.”
“You’re scared.”
Sam stared at him. “I’m not scared.”
“Then pick. Truth or Dare.”
Sam sighed and took a long sip. “Truth.”
Dalton barely paused. “What’s your body count?”
Sam blinked. “Jesus, you don’t ease into it, do you?”
“Nope.”
Sam shrugged. “Six if we’re only counting full penetration.”
Dalton whistled. “Damn. Look at you.”
“Alright, your turn.”
“Dare.”
Sam grinned. “Take a shot.”
Dalton rolled his eyes but poured himself a shot and knocked it back like a pro. “Trying to get me drunk so you can take advantage of me Sammy?”
“Shut the hell up. My turn,” Sam said. “Dare.”
Dalton’s eyes gleamed. “Okay. You’ve gotta spend the rest of the game naked.”
Sam froze, halfway through a sip. “That’s a big jump from a shot.”
Dalton smirked. “Oh, I’m sorry. Are you a pussy?”
Sam snorted. “You’re such a dick.”
“Still waiting, bro.”
Sam muttered something under his breath, then stood. He peeled off his shirt, then slowly pushed down his briefs, letting them drop to the floor. He sat back down naked, cock half-hard from the buzz and the attention.
Dalton raised his glass in approval. “Nice.”
“Your turn,” Sam said flatly.
“Dare.”
Sam smirked. “Same thing”
Dalton stood without hesitation and stripped bare, tossing his underwear over the back of the couch before flopping down beside Sam, just as naked. “Now we’re even.”
Sam laughed, but his eyes flicked downward before snapping back to the TV. His cock twitched, and he knew Dalton noticed.
Dalton grinned. “Truth or Dare?”
“Dare.”
Dalton pointed to the TV. “Put on two minutes of porn. Try not to get hard.”
Sam looked down at his semi-hard cock. “Too late for that.”
“Then it’s already a fail.”
Sam chuckled, then pulled up a site on the smart TV. A moaning blonde filled the screen, riding a ripped, tatted guy like her life depended on it.
Dalton let out a low whistle. “Damn. That’s a good pick.”
They both watched in silence for a moment. The sounds from the TV filled the room.
Sam’s cock thickened slowly in his lap. “Alright, your turn.”
“Dare.”
Sam’s voice dropped. “Thirty seconds of jerking. Timer starts…now.”
Dalton grinned, gripped his shaft, and started slow strokes. “This game’s starting to feel like a trap.”
Sam just watched him, mesmerized. “You complaining?”
Dalton moaned quietly. “Not even a little.”
Thirty seconds passed. “Time,” Sam said, his own hand drifting lower now.
They didn’t really declare the next round. The game dissolved between them. The porn was still playing on the screen. Sam grabbed his cock, stroking lazily. Dalton mirrored him, both of them now leaning back into the couch, openly jerking off just feet apart.
Dalton glanced at him, flushed and hard. “So much for Truth or Dare.”
Sam licked his lips. “Yeah. Think we skipped to the final round.”
Dalton’s voice was low and hoarse. “What’s that?”
Sam glanced at the screen, then at Dalton, still stroking. “Dare. Finish together.”
Dalton nodded, fist moving faster now. “Fuck yeah.”
Side by side on the couch, porn echoing through the room, drinks forgotten, dares long behind them—just two guys, fully hard, totally exposed, jerking off like it was the most natural thing in the world.
Sam glanced down, both their hands still working, and couldn’t help but notice the differences now that they were this close.
Dalton’s cock was a little shorter than his, not by a lot, maybe six inches hard, but much thicker, with a pronounced head still half-hidden by his foreskin. Uncut, it moved differently in his hand—slicker, more fluid. Sam watched it twitch each time Dalton stroked down, skin bunching and gliding back over the crown.
Sam’s own was a little longer, closer to seven inches, straight and a little thicker at the base. Cut, the head was exposed and flushed pink, a shade darker than his skin tone. A faint vein curled along the left side, pulsing faintly with each beat of his heart.
Side by side, it was impossible not to compare—Dalton more lean and subtle, Sam thicker and blunt. Different, but both undeniably hard and leaking.
Dalton caught him looking and smirked. “What?” he asked, still stroking.
Sam shrugged, a little breathless. “Just didn’t know we were packing such different models.”
Dalton chuckled, squeezing himself near the base. “European trim,” he said with a wink. “More sensitive, or so I’ve heard.”
Sam grinned, lazily matching his rhythm. “Mine’s the classic American upgrade. Standard issue.”
They both laughed. Then Dalton stood up.
“Hold on,” he muttered, already halfway down the hall.
Sam blinked, confused, cock still in hand. He watched as Dalton’s plump bubble butt bounced with each step and got further away before turning into his room.
Dalton came back carrying something. Small, cylindrical, discreet—but unmistakable.
Sam sat up a little straighter. “Is that what I think it is?”
Dalton grinned and held it up. “The real MVP.”
He sat back down…closer this time. Legs touching.
Sam looked at it, then at him. “You’re just gonna bring that out mid-session?”
Dalton shrugged. “Thought you wanted to try it?”
Sam swallowed, nodding slowly.
Dalton handed it over, their fingers brushing.
Sam turned the toy in his hands, a little nervous but mostly curious. It was soft, heavy, the moisture at the base signifying it was slick already. “Damn, you already lubed it too?”
“That’s not lube. That’s cum. And I guess a little bit of leftover lube too.” Dalton said laughing. He leaned back, watching with interest. “Go on.”
Sam positioned it, heart racing, and pushed in.
His whole body jerked. “Oh shit.”
Dalton laughed, eyes wide. “That good?”
“Dude.” Sam closed his eyes, thrusting gently. “It’s insane. Warm. Tight. Holy fuck. Your cum makes it feel…” He started moaning softly, hips rolling. The couch creaked beneath them.
Dalton watched him with a grin, elbow propped on the back cushion like he was watching a live sex show…which he was.
Sam went at it for another minute, breathing hard—then suddenly pulled out and let the toy rest in his lap.
“Shit,” he panted. “Got too close. Didn’t wanna finish yet.”
Dalton’s brows lifted, amused. “Quitting early?”
Sam smirked, flushed. “Pacing myself.”
But Dalton reached over, casually picked the toy back up, and slid it over Sam’s cock again without asking.
Sam gasped. “Dude—”
Dalton started pumping it. Smooth, steady strokes. Their legs pressed together. Sam’s arm, unsure of what to do, settled across Dalton’s shoulders—part balance, part instinct.
He moaned deeper now, his forehead tipping forward.
Dalton’s voice was low, teasing. “Still wanna pace yourself?”
Sam just breathed through gritted teeth. “Fuck…”
They stayed like that for a few minutes—Dalton stroking the toy over him, Sam holding onto him, hips twitching, mind spinning. The porn faded into background noise compared to the wet, rhythmic sounds between them.
Then Dalton slowed. Pulled the toy off.
“My turn,” he said.
Sam watched, still catching his breath, as Dalton slipped it onto his own cock and started stroking. He let out a sharp breath, his abs tightening as his hips moved.
Then Dalton’s free hand slid over and wrapped around Sam’s cock again, this time without the toy as a barrier.
Sam froze for half a second.
But the touch was firm and confident.
And it felt good.
Really good.
Sam groaned, low in his chest. “You’re stroking my dick bro.”
Dalton didn’t stop. “You complaining?”
Sam bit his lip. “No.”
This was new, and weird, and hot as hell.
Dalton’s strokes slowed, his grip lingering around the base of Sam’s cock like he wasn’t quite ready to let go.
Then, without looking away from Sam, Dalton asked, “You think we could both fit?”
Sam blinked. “In the toy? I don’t know, it’s pretty tight. You think we could?”
Dalton gave a half-smile. “Only one way to find out.”
There was a pause…an electric mix between a joke and a challenge. Sam’s heart thudded against his ribs, but his body moved before he overthought it.
He shifted, lifting one leg over Dalton’s lap, straddling him with a hesitant breath. Their bodies brushed—hips, thighs, cocks already slick and close.
“Dude…” Dalton murmured.
Sam looked down, positioning himself, then met Dalton’s eyes. “Line it up.”
Dalton held the toy steady. Sam guided himself in first, then leaned forward slightly, holding it while Dalton shifted his hips and began to press in.
There was a second of pressure. Warmth. Contact.
Then both of them groaned at once—half from shock, half from the sheer absurd, overwhelming intensity of it.
It didn’t matter that it was snug, or awkward, or that their bodies were pressed so close together.
Dalton’s hands settled on Sam’s hips, gripping tight. Sam braced himself on Dalton’s shoulders. The toy moved slowly between them, their cocks pressed together inside it.
“Jesus,” Sam muttered. “You feel that?”
Dalton’s voice was rough. “Yeah. I fucking feel it.”
Their foreheads touched and they both humped into the plastic pussy holding their cocks together. And for a long, breathless stretch, nothing existed but shared breath and friction and the throb of their cocks.
The toy moved between them, tight and slick and almost too much. Sam’s thighs were burning from holding himself steady, his whole body tense, heart hammering in his chest. Every shift of Dalton’s hips sent a shockwave through him.
They were panting now. Touching everywhere. Sam’s forehead resting against Dalton’s, their cocks pressed together inside that snug sleeve, working in rhythm—slow, grinding friction that made them both leak.
Sam groaned through clenched teeth. “Gonna—fuck, man—”
Dalton’s breath hitched. “Me too—just—don’t stop.”
Their bodies locked. Hips driving forward in sync, sloppy and desperate.
Then their orgasms hit—first Sam, then immediately after, Dalton. Sam’s vision tunneled as the pressure finally snapped and everything washed through him at once—heat, relief, and the terrifying thrill of release next to another guy. With another guy. His cum gushed out, costing the inside of the toy and his friend’s cock.
Dalton was shaking underneath him, holding on just as tight. As soon as he felt Sam’s load, he was shooting just as much, if not more. Their combined loads seeping out the bottom of the pussy, coating their balls in their fluid.
Neither of them spoke, not at first. Just the sound of heavy breathing, the toy still trapped between them, filled now, still warm and sticky.
Sam slowly peeled himself off, collapsing beside Dalton on the couch, spent and dazed. His chest rose and fell like he’d just run a mile.
“Jesus Christ,” he muttered.
Dalton exhaled a laugh, low and a little breathless. “You’re welcome.”
Sam didn’t respond. He just stared at the ceiling, muscles twitching as the high faded.
And then the thoughts started to creep in. What the hell did I just do? Why did I like it that much? Why did I straddled him?
Dalton must’ve noticed the silence, or maybe the tension in his shoulders, because he turned his head and looked at him.
“Hey,” he said quietly. “Don’t start spiraling, bro.”
Sam’s lips parted, but no words came out. His brain was a mess.
Dalton nudged him with a foot. “It was just fun. You and me messing around. No pressure. No weirdness.”
Sam finally glanced over at him. “You really don’t think it’s weird?”
Dalton shrugged. “Only if you make it weird.”
That got a small, dry laugh out of Sam.
They both sat there for a while, cooling off in the dim room with the TV still playing faint moans in the background. Eventually, they cleaned up without speaking much and Sam pulled his clothes back on—underwear, jeans, shirt.
Dalton walked him to the door like it was just another hangout.
Sam lingered on the threshold, one hand on the knob, the other shoved in his pocket.
“You sure we’re good?” he asked.
Dalton gave him a lopsided grin. “We’re solid, man.”
Sam nodded slowly. “Cool. Alright. I’ll…see you tomorrow.”
Dalton saluted him lazily. “Don’t jerk off without me.”
Sam rolled his eyes but couldn’t help the smirk. He stepped out, the night air cool against his skin.
Driving home, the post-nut clarity refused to fade. He gripped the wheel tighter than usual, windows cracked, trying to sort through what just happened. It was just bros messing around, right?
Then why did it feel so much better than any other sexual experience he’d ever had?
And why was he already wondering if—and when—it might happen again?