Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I'm sure you're getting a similar post from everyone you support on Patreon today, so I'll be short.

If you don't know what's going on, Jason Scott summed it up really well:

https://www.patreon.com/posts/15763662

I am always grateful for your support, and for now, I will continue on here. Moving to another service (like Liberapay) is always possible in the future, even the near future, but I don't honestly know what the trade-offs are yet, and hey, maybe Patreon will reverse course quickly. We all have a few weeks of wiggle room to make a decision here.

If you have to cancel your pledge--for financial or moral reasons--I completely understand. I appreciate your money, but honestly? The only feedback that Patreon will find meaningful is watching their revenue evaporate. And you know me: I love a good protest.

Comments

flesk

I don't mind paying a little extra, but I'd want that money to go the creators I support instead of into the pockets of Patreon, which already has a reputation for shady business practices. Liberapay looks like a great alternative.

tuxayo

> I'd want that money to go the creators I support instead of into the pockets of Patreon I wouldn't mind if it would pay the workers at Patreon. But it's more likely that it will pay the investors to get toward the ridiculously high return on investment expected by venture capital.

Timothy Arceri

BountySource isn't much better on fees 10%. I believe Librapay only passes on the processing fees, they support hosting etc via their own donation page.

Timothy Arceri

Sorry I'm out. Let us know if you start a Liberapay page. You could switch to that over time (or just keep both). I already didn't have much love for Patreon and things generally only get worse after moves like this.

Mayeul Cantan

Liberapay sounds great, especially as it is a nonprofit.

QuadChroma

How could anyone think that adding that PER PLEDGE would be viewed as anything but naked greed? They're making a single CC charge to my card - yet making me pay the transaction fees X times over? :-( This is really going to make me check all my lower pledges especially and trim some of them out.

Rémi Verschelde

I'm also not fond of the direction taken by Patreon on this, especially with their move to process all pledges individually with a flat fee on each of them (and in the future, even at different times in the month). I've moved my patronage of GamingOnLinux to Liberapay, and I'd be really glad to do the same for you if you open an account there (until then, I'll keep supporting your here tho'). Patreon still has great features in terms of visibility and communicating with your community, so I'd advise that you keep your Patreon account at any rate, but it can't hurt to offer a FOSS and non-profit alternative.

Kaz Redclaw

If you have a Paypal address, I can just donate on that. I'm working out a spreadsheet now. Would you rather have less frequent payments that are larger so paypal takes a smaller cut?

Kaz Redclaw

That's the even worse thing about it. They're not charging a single time to your card anymore. They're going to hit you multiple times per month on your bank statement to the point where you can't even tell how much is going to Patreon anymore.

Josh 'Cheeseness' Bush

I'm also feeling pretty uncomfortable with these proposed changes and doubly uncomfortable with how little lead time we've been given to embrace and/or make other arrangements (I didn't even get a notification from Patreon - the first I heard about it was when a supporter asked me if I was going to be moving to an alternative platform!). I definitely want to continue supporting you, though. Jason's post is solid, but doesn't address Patreon's recent update to their blog post, which claims that the changes are to pave way for up-front charging collected on the monthly anniversary of supporters individual pledges. Given that up-front charging is only one of three possible payment methods that creators can choose from, messing with the fee structure and by extension the creator/supporter relationship for creators who are *not* using up-front charging feels super inappropriate.

QuadChroma

That's...Profoundly Stupid[TM]. That might make me just cancel all but one or two pledges.

tuxayo

> BountySource isn't much better on fees 10%. I think the percentage shouldn't be the only factor. Here are some explanations about that 10% fee: <a href="https://salt.bountysource.com/teams/bountysource" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://salt.bountysource.com/teams/bountysource</a> «What about that 10% fee, doesn’t that cover costs?» I still think that 10% are too much. It seems that they can't yet make large scale savings on the mentioned expenses. So these 10% aren't greed as the devs can't even be compensated for their work. There is no capital/investors taking a cut. Which is why I think Boutysource it better that Patreon. And it's libre/open source. Which means if they go wrong, someone can create a copy of the platform with a different legal entity. Which could already happen now if someone knows how to cut down these 10%.

Rémi Verschelde

Yeah, I actually got a notification from Patreon one day before they notified patrons and initially thought "it's not too bad", without thinking too much about the huge impact on very small pledges. But then when I read that blog post, and worse, its update, I was really disappointed. What they describe in the update as their Holy Grail is the last thing I want as a patron. If I support 10 creators, I don't want to be charged ten times a month with each time various kind of transaction fees packed on top of my small donation. I love that on Liberapay I can transfer 150€ to my wallet in one go and support all creators I want from this lump sum. Regarding the three supported payment methods, they're clear in the log post that in the future they want to get rid of the non-upfront ones to keep only their subscription-like model... too bad for us who don't want money ASAP...

tuxayo

So, I sadly canceled my pledge. Thanks for your encouragement to reduce the guilt. I'm eager to support you on another platform.

tuxayo

For anyone interested (and for me to be corrected of the mistakes that I wrote), here is the feedback that I left when canceling the pledge: Patreon's investors seem to be taking a too high cut. That's what you get with venture capital, unfair cut from the capital. Forget about the creators, Patreon is legally bound to feed a much a possible the investors, no matter if it hurts the creators. So that's why I'm leaving. It just happen too much, the business model of venture capital is just toxic and ruins good ideas. To the person reading this: Thanks for your work, if you have the skills and profession which allows you to choose your job, please find another one whose business/funding model won't ruin the value. Your time is precious, be picky with what you do 40hr a week your whole life. That's what will remain of you on this world. Don't waste it, there are so many great things to do :)