Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Sorry it was late, y'all. It's been a hectic few days. Please forgive your Lodge

Today, the boys talk about a variety of different topics within the realm of history and historiography, and why it's so important to not just understand our history, but where to obtain reputable sources, and how to know when someone isn't using them. The past is incredibly crazy enough as it is, so let's learn about what we really know about it together...

Files

Comments

Grant Lehner

Who be here loring the lodge?

Telemachus2814

We'll let it slide this time, but Nic and a Binder is closer to happening every time you're late.

Aaron Trail

RIP the turnspit dog. :(

Layne Harvey

I be here loring the lodge. And unhinging the history. For the history of everything.

Magnet

Thanks for fixin it!

sam salyers

Thank you guys for the free episodes

Danni Elliott

I thought chihuahuas were slso ratters so they coukd go down into dens and stop rats from eating crops

Darth Triffid, the Emerald Menace

Theres a joke in the Brit-com Red Dwarf about how all fhe milk on the ship has been drunk or gone off except for dogs milk and it lasts forever ... because no bugger drinks it.

The blacksmith

For a collaboration id love to see Nick the fat election and jack mandaville from jacked history and have you go over how terrible Woodrow willson Douglas Macarthur and FDR actually where srip away all the pomp and glamour and show them for the asreholes they where

legendary super shaggy

Honestly I truly want them on Rogan now. That just sounds like it would be so infuriating but so hilarious at the same time

Thomas Jönsson

Question. What do you guys think about Tim Alberino ?

Aaron Trail

Today I learned the Homo Longi is also called the Dragon man... Do you think the Long-guy was also Dragon dem nuts? (No one deserves to be banned for a pun this bad, please show mercy)

Assassin492

Gutsick Gibbon is a great pre-civilization anthropology youtuber, she's getting her doctorate in biological anthropology rn.

Ryan Romani

Hell yea brother I buy patreon for the one month they give a free episode lol

History Unhinged

Well we do two episodes a month so you will indeed get your money’s worth, don’t worry

Crolter

Honestly aside from every episode starting with “This History is Unhinged” the fact that Thornberry basically ends it with talking about being hungry every time without fail is top notch

book dragon 18502

if it wouldn't get you in trouble. id love to here the three of you go though a high school history book, if you need a supsific year 1999, and just narrate it like a history unhinged episode. Pleeeeeeease

MonsterHuntressRoon

Seriously though, about archaeology I have a hard time believing their strict adherence there was nothing in North America ever before a point in time they say things existed.They ignore the very real geological evidence that everything was wiped out by a fiery cataclysm. I hate the rigidity of modern archaeologists with no sense of curiosity at all. I’d be less inclined to listen to a guy spouting about the pyramids being a “National Project” with no founded proof THAT’S the truth.

ForeskinWalker

I wouldn't call myself a historian like you guys are but I would like you to consider "stupid people" who don't try and fight what they think is history as misinformed people. I fall into that category a lot. I trust what you guys are saying but I also believe what we believe is history is written by people were on the winning side. There are a lot of things we have lost is what I'm saying.

Darth Triffid, the Emerald Menace

My students just did a comprehension activity om Richard the third and the Battle of Bosworth and they were FASCINATED by the description of Richard as a bottled spider and my imitation of his body language so they actually paid attention to other parts.

Kyle

What renfaire are you guys going to I might be able to get free tickets for you guys

jack ladwig

Ok, I want a bible episode. Or just a massive religion episode

theri0n.dot.AI

Stak has the core of the point: history needs to be digestible for people to care, especially since our collective attention and memory spans are declining (also relevant to this EP!)

Ivo R

A short history of nearly everything by Bill Bryson is a really fun book about science and the history of the science, including anthropology. I think it would be good for a very casual dip into it! The only thing is that it's a 20 year old book so it's not as up to date to some modern understandings

historianKelly

Good point, Jeff! I am a historian, I have degrees in History, have literally been studying it since I was 5yo, went to college & grad school to be a History professor. What you are talking about is of great importance to historians now - dismantling that narrative of history being told by the "winners" as you point out. I think that's what a lot of the people you mention are getting upset about. They think they know history because they've been taught this narrative all their lives, and historians are saying, wait a minute, there are other ways to look at that story, and people don't like to question tradition. We are trying to get a more full story, get more points of view, get a 360 degree vision of the past. I personally believe that there's no such thing as unimportant history, or unimportant stories. French scholars have been at the forefront of this narrative-busting, and I'll give you an example of some history out of France I'm translating for personal use, it's about the "barbarians" who conquered the Roman Empire. The Goths and Vandals who conquered the Romans were not "barbarians" at all, that's just the cultural hatchet job the Romans did on them that we've bought for 1600 years! So modern scholars are rehabilitating the reputations of the people who toppled a once-vaunted empire. Isn't that fun?! To see the world through a more nuanced lens. I like that you are questioning the narrative! 💜

David Staffen

Poor thornberry trying to get a word in while the other two explode about a guy being dumb. Oof.

Anemone Plenary

Love to hear Aiden trash MMT, Keynes, and grievance studies. Nice little bonus

derp daddy

1:27:30-ish, poor Aiden cant get a word in between Aiden and Steven

Erik Lucas

Based Mattis taking the late exodus date

Aiden Collins

I must say thank you for making this Patreon segment free, I enjoy your videos quite a bit, you’re all hilarious. You should check out gutsick gibbons video on the finds regarding homo longi and about the current leading thoughts on our relation to Neanderthals and Denisovans.

Jordie

Thanks for the free patreon episode, this was a discussion I was invested in.

MrNoFace

You are legends for removing the pay wall for this ep

MrNoFace

1.54.00. Funny as hell.

Kimberly Terrell

Just discovered you guys and although you don’t know me you are now my go to drinking buddies. Did I make it weird? I made it weird. I’ll go back to my corner.

Frank The Longbeard

For someone, who can’t always afford Patreon, this was a treat.