Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

On global shortages and their political consequences.

Benjamin Bradlow, assistant professor of sociology and international affairs at Princeton, talks to Alex and Lee about the world-historic impact of the Hormuz Strait closure.

How will shortages – beyond oil and gas – reverberate through global supply chains?

Why are markets so sanguine about all this? Are financial economic elites too insulated from consequences?

Will China be the big beneficiary as more countries turn to importing its tech for renewables?

Do countries want to trade dependency on the Middle East or US for dependency on China?

Would a world of energy autarky be more or less peaceful?

Are "electrostates" a thing?

Links:

The Winners and Losers of the Iran Energy Shock, Benjamin Bradlow, Foreign Affairs

The energy crisis may just be starting, Martin Wolf, FT

Files

Comments

ashley atkinson

Interesting discussion as always, although I did find Ben's arguments around Chinese dependency to be a little nonchalant and contradictory as the episode went on. It is true that nobody controls the wind or the sun, but energy isn't generated by people basking in the sun or being blown around their gardens. It is generated through photovoltaics at local and national level or large wind turbines at the national level. None of this is dug out of the ground. Few states have the ability to manufacture it on technological grounds and even fewer states on economic grounds. As Ben said near the end of the episode, China manufacturers over 80% of PV cells. Well it also manufactures the majority of wind turbines, battery storage, inverters and other hardware and software required to operate them, not to mention control over rare earth's and the supporting and manufacturing equipment to produce these technologies. It's their tech stack. Ben rightly pointed out the problems of dependency on US LNG or on the US order to keep fossil fuel energy flowing. So why turn a blind eye to this dependency? As he said, China is the only real electrostate. In my view, this is significantly worse than fossil fuel dependencies as many countries produce oil and gas and further countries can produce it if they need to. Consequently, supply chains of fossil fuels are more diluted and supply is not dictated by one country. Just look at Russia's sanctioned oil, it is at a discount but still gets through to many markets. Ultimately this new electro dependency is yet another example of supply dependencies due to China's mercantilist model and the asymmetric openness in trade. Western countries are finally waking up to this no matter how hypocritical. But it not just a Western or a China hawk concern, many countries including in the 'Global South' have trade protections in place on Chinese exports in an attempt at protecting their industries. China is not going to bail them out anymore than a western country, it is out for itself just like everybody else.

KM

Off grid solar is 'off grid' there is no way for after-purchase-meddling as the systems are too dumb to communicate online ..

jkjkjkj

Id just like to note that the world does actually have an electrostate (albeit a very small one): Laos, which has decided to wield its immense hydro (and to a lesser degree wind) potential to become a major generator of electricity for continental Southeast Asia (especially Thailand)

Davka Smolah Collective

Man we made this episode months ago, just without getting to write for Foreign Affairs.