EP27 | Cheating On My Boyfriend With His Hot Friend - Dan's POV (Patreon)

I felt almost calm in the build-up to Saturday, which was weird. After the intensity of seeing Sam fuck Lucas up close, in secret, I think it had released something in me. All the anxiety and stress of not knowing for those few weeks, suspecting Sam was cheating, but not knowing for sure. Then, having it confirmed by Lucas… but still needing to be sure. Only to watch as my boyfriend bred my friend raw in his bed…

And the level of their sex…the intensity… the horniness… how different Sam was with Lucas. Literally like a different person. 

It all made it fully sink in, and now I knew. And I felt strangely calm about that Saturday, and the threesome I had orchestrated. Sam believed I had no idea about him and Lucas, but I knew everything, and Lucas knew I knew. The only person who didn't was Sam. 

I had told Sam that the plan was for him to come over and hang out on Saturday, and that Lucas would join us later. He was just going to hang out with us, but we could also try for a threesome. Actually, we were definitely having the threesome, but I was pretending to Dan that it was only a possibility. See how it goes. I was very much enjoying seeing Sam squirm, how uncomfortable he was. He was obviously worried he would seem too keen, or in the threesome, I would realise how comfortable they are with each other and put two and two together. It almost made me laugh. He deserved to be worried. I liked how uncomfortable and stressed this was all making him.

But really, none of this was about him anymore. I wanted this, I was playing out all my fantasies while I had this opportunity, I had got to see it in secret, and now I wanted to be there, with him knowing, and see him fuck Lucas. 

-

When Sam arrived, I gave him a big kiss. I wanted him to feel like all was ok. I wanted him to think I had no idea, which he did. 

We went to the living room and lay together on the sofa.

“So? Are we doing it?” I said, smiling at him. 

“What do you mean by it?” He replied, pretending he didn’t know exactly what I was talking about. 

“Oh, I think you know,” I said, giggling innocently “, are we gonna have a threesome with Lucas?”

“I think you have to make the call on this one; he’s your friend.” He replied.

I almost laughed. I could see how badly he wanted to do it. For him, it must be a crazy fantasy getting to fuck his boyfriend and his boyfriend's hot friend in a threesome. But he was working so hard to seem like he didn't mind either way. 

“I think it could be kinda hot and fun. Do you want to have sex with him?” I asked.

“I mean, sure. He’s cute. Was a good kisser when we kissed at the party,” He replied, still trying to be as neutral as possible. 

I knew he had been fucking Lucas for weeks. He was a good liar, I’ll give him that.

“That was really hot”, I replied, then I started rubbing his crotch, “it would be kind of kinky for us all to play, see my boyfriend get sucked off by my friend.”

I felt his dick hardening. 

“Yeah? You want that?” He whispered. 

“I do. And it feels like you do too,” I said, still rubbing him, enjoying getting him nice and horny. 

“Fuck, yes. Wanna get my cock ready with your mouth?” He said, eagerly. 

I removed my hand and laughed. 

“Not yet, baby, gotta save that for when Lucas gets here”, I said.

He wasn't getting any more from me until Lucas got here.

“How we gonna do it? Will he be up for it?” He asked, maybe wanting to know my plan. But I wasn't giving that away. I wanted him to be nervous. 

“I have an idea…” I said teasingly.

“Do I get to know?” He asked.

“Not yet, you’ll see”, I said, smiling.

It’s funny how he thinks he is the one who knows the secret, but really it’s Lucas, and I. Sam is just a pawn in all this now, used for our amusement. Mainly my amusement. 

-

I opened some wine, feeling the need for liquid courage, and we spent the afternoon watching movies and hanging out. It was tricky pretending everything was fine when I knew it was anything but. So I drank wine and focused on the films, acting chilled and happy around Sam; I was sure he was buying it. 

Then Lucas texted me just before six. We had agreed that's when he would come, and he was right on time. I didn't show Sam the messages.

LUCAS: Hey, I’m close. You sure you’re still up for this? 

DAN: Yeah. He has no clue. Come over.

When I told Sam that Lucas was close, he looked so scared. Good. 

“You, ok?” I asked, prentind, I had no idea why he would be so scared. 

“Yeah, just nervous, I guess, He replied. 

I bet he was. 

“Don’t worry, I am too. But we can just see how it goes,” he said and gave him a kiss.

I got up and went to get more drinks. I am sure Lucas will need a few drinks too. 

I heard the doorbell ring.

“Oh, he’s here! Can you answer the door?” I yelled from the kitchen. I wanted Sam to be the one to let Luxas in. Let them have a moment alone before things kick off. I knew Sam would be terrified of Lucas saying something. 

I heard Sam go and open the door, then voices. Then I heard them coming into the kitchen. 

As Lucas came in, I went over and gave him a big hug.

‘Hey, you!” I said.

“Heeey!” Lucas yelled back.

We were both so good at this, pretending like everything was normal. I mean, I guess Lucas was, he had been doing that whilefucjing my boyfriend for the last few weeks, I thought dryly. 

I handed Lucas a glass of wine, then gave Sam a fresh one. I picked up my glass and held it out.

“Well, cheers to what I am sure will be a really fun night”, I said, smiling at them both.

We all clinked our glasses. 

“It’s always fun with you, Dan! And you too, Sam,” Lucas said, and he gave Sam a very dirty look. I pretended not to see. 

“Come on, let’s go chill in the living room”, I said as I led the way.

-

We all sat around drinking, and Lucas and I were gossiping about people we knew and sharing stories, like we always did when he hung out. It was fun, lots of laughing. Dan was looking nervous pretty much the whole time. He seemed to relax a bit, but I could tell he was still on edge. I was dragging out this part as I wanted him nice and tipsy…and I wanted to keep him scared for a while longer…

We moved the conversation to previous hook-ups, Lucas’s previous hook-ups. This seemed like a good place to move things along.

“He was so hot!” Lucas said, laughing, as I reminded him when I had to wait in the street while he hooked up with some guy. 

“Yeah, but you just started making out with him!” I said, laughing, “Speaking of making out…you two had a pretty hot kiss at the party.”

I looked directly at Sam.

“Oh, you like that, huh?” Lucas said, teasingly. He knew what I was doing. 

“I did, did you like kissing my bf?” I replied.

Sam looked so nervous…

“He is a very good kisser, I must say”, Lucas said, and he looked at Sam.

“Why don’t we spice up the night a little? Truth or dare?” I said.

I had always planned this, and Lucas knew. We had discussed it all. Sam will be too scared to share any truths, considering how many lies he has told and how many secrets he has with Lucas. And he won't want Lucas to share any secrets either. So this will be a funny way to make him sweat. And he will always pick dare, so I can get him and Lucas to play in front of me for my enjoyment. 

“Yes! Let’s do it!” Lucas yelled.

“Sure, ok yeah”, Sam said. He didn't really have a choice. 

“I get to go first, and I am picking Sam,” I said, taking a large sip of my wine.

“Truth or dare?” I said.

I knew he wouldn't pick the truth. 

“Dare.” He said.

I grinned at Lucas, all going to plan. 

“Hmmm, I dare you to kiss Lucas, with tongues” I said.

Lucas giggled.

“Ok…” He said cautiously.

They both got up and walked over to each other. Sam put his hand out, and I watched as he pulled Lucas in and they kissed. It got very passionate very quickly, I wondered to myself if I didn't know about the fact that they were already fucking if this would have given it away…I think it might. They looked hungry for each other. I was feeling really turned on, and I rubbed my hardening cock as I watched. 

Eventually, they broke the kiss. 

“Hot,” I said, as they looked down at me. 

“My turn,” Dan said.

He went back to his chair, and I could see he was hard. 

“Lucas, truth or dare?” I said.

“Oh, I’m up for a dare”, he said. 

“I dare you to kiss Dan, with tongues”, Sam said, smiling.

I laughed. I think Sam wanted to feel some kind of control again, but Lucas and I have drunkenly kissed loads; it’s no big deal. I went over and grabbed Lucas, kissing him deeply, giving Sam a good show. 

I broke the kiss and looked at Sam. 

“Like that?” I said.

“Fuck yes,” he replied.

“My turn!” Lucas squealed, “Dan, truth or dare?”

“I am going to go truth”, I said.

I knew what Lucas was going to ask; we had planned it. 

“Oooh, ok. Have you thought about Sam and I fucking, and does it turn you on?” Lucas said.

I smiled… exactly as planned.  “I have, and yes, it does. A lot,” I said.

Sam took a big sip of his wine. Things were starting to get really interesting. 

“My go again! Lucas, I am choosing you this time. Truth or dare?” I said.

“You know me, I love a dare!” Lucas replied.

“Hmmm. Ok. I dare you to suck Sam's cock.” I said, looking straight at Dan.

No more fucking around, let's get this party started.

Lucas smiled; a dirty smile. 

“Oh, do you now? Well, is Sam ok with that?” he said, looking at him.

“I mean, a dares a dare, He replied.

It was so clear he had a massive hard-on; there was no point pretending he wasn't gagging for this to happen anymore. And I was ready to see it, with him knowing I was. Up close this time. 

Lucas got up and made his way over to Sa. I sat in the chair next to them. Lucas got on his knees and put his hand on Sam's crotch, feeling his hard cock.

“Someone is already excited”, he whispered.

I watched as Lucas undid the buttons on Sam's jeans, then Sam sat up, and he pulled his jeans down, then his boxers…exposing his hard cock…

Lucas smiled at me.

Sam's cock was so fucking hard, precum was leaking from it. 

Luas took it in his hand, and Sam's breath caught. 

Then Lucas leaned forward and took it in his mouth, and Sam moaned.

Fuck I was so turned on. Seeing this like this, uplose, was so hot. Sam was thinking I had never seen this before…

Sam looked over at me. I was rubbing my cock and watching.

He looked crazed with horniess, Lucas's expert mouth already driving him crazy.

It was all going to plan.