EP20 | Falling For The Hot Straight Gym Bro (Patreon)

This fictional story features only adult characters (18+) and portrays consensual interactions throughout.

I had stayed the night with Bryce, but I had to be up early the next day, so we didn’t have sex in the morning. I had woken in the night, and he was cuddling me. I had fallen back asleep, so happy and content. Also, after he had fucked me in the showers and then on the sofa, my ass needed a break.

I left his place feeling more confused than ever. I had accepted that Bryce was straight and that we would never actually be together, never be boyfriends. But the way he acted with me when we were together felt way more than friends. It even felt more than friends with benefits. I had been with guys in the past who I just fucked. Neither of us wanted to date, but we liked having sex. But with Bryce, we had started as friends and become really good friends before we started fucking. And we weren’t supposed to start fucking. It had been for his girlfriend, so he was better at anal before they tried it. But then we had just kind of kept going because the sex was mind-blowing. So now the fact that I cared about him so much as a person, and that we had incredible sex together, made it all very confusing. And to add to all this, the real truth that I hadn’t told Bryce and never would tell him was that I had been in love with him since before we first spoke. I had been in love with him since I first saw him at the gym. He was easily the most beautiful man I had ever seen.

I knew eventually I was going to get hurt, really badly. Because Bryce was straight, and he just liked fucking me because it felt good, and he was a typical guy who chased the good feelings. But I didn’t care, I would deal with that when it came. For now, I will take every second of Bryce I can, and I will take as much of his cock as he will give me. Soon it’ll stop, so until then I'm going to enjoy all of it.

Getting up that morning, though it already felt as if it were about to change, I knew it was time to meet the new girlfriend; we couldn't keep putting it off. And as soon as I did, I knew everything would be different.

-

Over the next few days, Bryce and I were texting as normal, just friendly stuff. I was happy there was no awkwardness after we had fucked again. Bryce had originally suggested I was going to meet his girlfriend on Wednesday, but he hadn't messaged about it or mentioned it again, so I wasn’t going to push it.

Then he texted to ask if I was free on Friday night. I felt so nervous reading it, knowing it was time.

CHARLIE: Yep, I’m free Friday.

BRYCE: Awesome. I’m having a house party, and Sarah will be there, so you can meet her!

Fuck, here we go. It was an interesting thought that I was no longer meeting her alone, but now as part of a house party. I was relieved, as having other people there would make it less intense.

CHARLIE: Great! Can’t wait x

That was a total lie. I was happy to keep waiting, or even never meet her, so I could pretend she didn’t exist and that Bryce and I could keep fucking regularly. But he was my friend, so I was going to be nice.

BRYCE: Come over for 7! x

So now I am off to a house party on Friday, where I am going to meet Bryce’s new girlfriend… great.

-

On Friday, I was so nervous about what to wear. I didn’t want it to look like I had made an effort, but I also wanted to look good. I had this dark, fitted shirt that I knew would show off my body, so I decided to go for it. It was casual enough that it didn't seem like I had tried too hard. I was kind of fascinated to know what Bryce’s girlfriend would be like. I had an idea in my head. I was guessing she was very fit, a gym-goer, and probably pretty. Bryce was a seriously good-looking guy, so I was sure the girlfriend would be hot too.

I arrived a little after seven, hoping there would already be a few people there. I had brought wine and snacks, hoping that was the right thing to bring. It had been a long time since I had been to a house party. Bryce’s place wasn’t huge, so I wondered how busy it would be.

I boxed, and the door was open, so I headed up. I knocked on the door and could already hear people chatting and music. I was happy to hear the party had already started. A few moments later, Bryce opened the door.

“Charlie!” he yelled, a big smile on his face.

He pulled me into a tight hug, and I melted as I always do when I’m near him.

“Hey,” I replied, hugging him back.

“So glad you made it. Come in. I’ll introduce you to everyone,” Bryce said, bringing me inside.

I followed him into his flat, and as we entered the living room, I saw it was already busy. There were groups of people standing around drinking, and others gathered around the sofa. I couldn’t help thinking about the last time I was here, when Bryce fucked me on the sofa. I remembered being naked, on top of him as I rode him, both of us moaning…

“Sarah, this is Charlie!” Bryce said as he approached a very attractive woman.

Shit, stop thinking about Bryce fucking me. She smiled and opened her arms to hug me; everyone liked hugging around here.

“Charlie, hey! I have heard so much about you!” she said as we hugged.

“Hi, it’s so nice to meet you,” I replied.

I was very curious as to exactly what she had heard about me. I doubted it was that I had been sucking Bryce’s cock regularly for a while now, and more recently, we had been fucking a lot. Bryce came and stood next to her. They looked good together, a very good-looking couple. Sarah was a little shorter than me. As expected, she had a very fit body and clearly went to the gym a lot. She had long, dark brown hair and dark eyes. She gave off a very open, friendly vibe; it annoyed me that I instantly liked her. I could see why Bryce liked her, for sure.

We chatted for a while as Bryce brought me over a drink. It was sweet how much he clearly wanted us to get on; it made me realise how much he cared about me. We were really good friends; this gorgeous man from my gym had actually become a good friend. Yes, I had stronger feelings for him, but I should feel lucky to have him as my friend. He was such a great guy.

Sarah worked as a PA at a law firm; she liked her job, but her main focus was her fitness. She used to compete in bodybuilding competitions, but now she just focuses on keeping fit. That’s how Bryce and she met and what they first bonded over. We talked about how Bryce trains me and how we both think he should move to being a full-time trainer, which was his dream. I quickly relaxed with Sarah, forgot about how she had Bryce the way I wished I had him, and couldn’t help but feel happy for both of them. Bryce came over and held Sarah's hand as we talked. He seemed so into her, and they looked so good together; it was cute to see.

After a while, I got chatting to other people. The party got even busier, and people got more drunk. I chatted to some other guys who go to the same gym, and then I got chatting to some people who were Sarah’s friends. One was a guy called Adam, who was really attractive. I was pretty sure he was gay, and he was being flirty with me. It felt nice to get some attention. I was also a bit tipsy at this point, having drunk a lot to calm my nerves. 

While we were talking, Bryce arrived.

“Hey, you ok?” he asked, looking concerned about me.

“Yeah, all good,” I replied.

“Sarah likes you. I knew she would,” he said. I think he was a little drunk.

“Oh, good, I really like her, Bryce. She’s great,” I said, honestly. “This is Adam, her friend.”

“Oh yeah, we met, hey, Adam,” Bryce said, seeming a bit short with him.

“Hey, Bryce, fun party. And you have very good-looking friends,” Adam said, looking at me.

I blushed. I couldn’t help it. I wasn’t used to compliments.

“Yeah, I do,” Bryce said, also looking at me. “Charlie is the best. You’d better look after him,” Bryce said, giving my arm a squeeze. It looked like Bryce was going to say something else, but then two guys came over, laughing, and pulled him away, telling him he had to come see something.

“He cares about you,” Adam said.

“Yeah, he’s a really sweet guy,” I replied.

“Also, I meant it. I think you’re hot,” Adam said.

I wasn’t sure what to say. I really wasn’t used to people being so direct.

“Urgh, thanks. You too,” I said, smiling.

“Wanna go get another drink, maybe chat somewhere quieter?” he said, smiling.

“Sure,” I replied.

He took my hand and led me through the crowd towards the kitchen.

The best way to get over someone was to move on to someone else; maybe Adam could be that someone else. He is hot and clearly into me.

As we walked away, I saw Bryce looking over at us as Adam led me by the hand. I couldn’t read his face, but he looked unhappy. Then Sarah pulled him in for a kiss, and we disappeared around the corner.

I was drunk and horny, and Adam seemed the perfect person to have fun with. Most importantly, he was actually gay.

The ideal guy to help me forget Bryce.