EP6 | The Neighbour Across The Hall (Patreon)

This fictional story features only adult characters (18+) and portrays consensual interactions throughout

I froze. I didn’t know what to do. I was completely busted, here I was having gone into my neighbour’s flat, and I was spying on him having sex…and he had just seen me. The guy fucking Benjy kept going; he was moaning and grunting as he fucked him hard. Benjy was taking every thrust with his legs spread wide…but he was looking straight at me...with this grin across his face.

I ran, I ran as fast as I could out of his flat and back into mine. I slammed the door behind me. I was panting, panicked, what the fuck had I just done? This was mad. Fuck.

I went to the bedroom and sat on the bed; I didn’t know what to do. I was listening so hard for the door, expecting Benjy to be knocking on it soon, maybe mad and yelling. If someone snuck into my flat and spied on me having sex, I’d be livid. Will he call the police? I need an excuse, I could say I saw the door was open and I was worried, I was being neighbourly by going in to check he was ok. Yes, that will work.

I heard the door, and I sprang up expecting to hear Benjy. But it was Will coming home from work. I went out to greet him, trying to seem as normal as possible. I thought about telling him, but stopped myself. This all started because I’ve been wanking off to Benjy fucking guys in his flat, imagining it being Will fucking him. How do I tell him that? I couldn’t, so I decided not to.

Luckily, Will didn’t notice anything. We chatted about work and our days, and then talked about what we were going to have for dinner. The entire time I was listening for a knock at the door, I was so sure Benjy was going to come over and expose me for what just happened. Will would be shocked; I would be so fucked.

But Benjy didn’t come.

There was no knock at the door.

It had been more than long enough now, he could have easily finished his fuck, got ready and come over. But he hadn’t. I was obviously relieved, but I was also very confused. Why hadn’t he come? I know he had seen me.

Will did notice that I was distracted, he let me ask him if I was ok, and I just said work had been busy and I was thinking about that.

Later, as we sat watching TV, I started thinking about seeing Benjy getting fucked. Looking through the gap in the door at him on the bed, with this guy fucking him. Seeing that ass pumping into him, the strong muscular back covered in sweat, the room smelling of sex, the moans, and Benjy…his face etched in pleasure…legs spread. Then his eyes locked onto mine, that look, that horny, dirty look on his face. It wasn’t a look of surprise; it was a look of triumph, almost, like he had won. Like he knew I would come. Or was that just wishful thinking so I didn’t feel like such a perv. And even after he had seen me, he didn’t stop, he didn’t get the guy to stop fucking him…he just looked at me, with that smug look. And I just stood frozen and watching.

And again, it happened. I thought of it being Will. I thought of looking into the room and seeing Will’s muscular ass, the one I have held onto so many times as he fucked me. And it made me so fucking hard. I imagined Benjy looking at me with that smug look, because he had Will, he had my boyfriend fucking him, loving his hole…and I could only watch.

I couldn’t believe how much it turned me on. I was going crazy with horniness.

I tried to look at Will, who was watching the show we had on TV. He was so handsome. This good-looking man was all mine. He loved me, he was the perfect boyfriend, kind, loyal, a fucking hot body with a big cock, and he loved me so much. And I was so turned on by the idea of Benjy stealing him. Claiming him.

Will turned to look at me.

“You ok?” He asked.

I didn’t answer, I just leaned in and kissed him.

“Mmm, someone horny?” He said, smiling.

I straddled him and kissed him harder. Will moaned into my mouth. I could feel his hard cock in his shorts against my ass. I was so hungry for him, so turned on by the thought of Benjy taking him, that it made me feel this need to be with Will. I felt Will’s hands grab my ass, and he rolled me over so I was now on my back, legs spread on the sofa. We were still kissing deeply, and he was grinding his hard cock into my ass through his shorts.

I pulled down my shorts and underwear and threw them away, so I was now naked from the waist down. Will’s hand reached down, and his finger went to my hole. He rubbed it and teased it. I moaned into the kiss. Will spat on his hand and rubbed that on my hole, then he felt him pull his shorts down and his hard cock sprang free. He didn’t wait he just lined it up and he grunted as the head popped into my tight hole. We were both so horny that there was no foreplay. I just needed Will inside me, needed to feel him deep into me. I was fucking desperate for it, and Will was more than happy to oblige my horniness.

He pushed his hips forward, and his cock slid inside me, stretching me open. I fucking loved it.

“Fuck yes, baby…” I moaned.

“I fucking love that hole, baby”, Will moaned back.

He pushed hard as I held onto his ass and pulled him into me. I felt his balls against my ass; he was fully inside me. It felt incredible, Will’s cock was fucking perfect, it felt so amazing inside me. It was the perfect size and thickness, stretching me open and hitting all the right places.

“Fuck me, fuck me, baby”, I moaned.

He just growled and held me down as he started pumping into me. This was a horny, quick fuck, and I loved it. I just wanted to be fucked; I wanted him to use my hole till he shot. I wanted him to fill me up. Thinking of Will with someone else, even Benjy, made me desperate to have him inside me, to claim him as mine. To see him getting off inside my hole.

But as I looked up at him, saw the pleasure and horniness on his face, I imagined that look as he fucked Benjy. And it drove me fucking wild.

“Fuck baby, I’m already close…” Will said.

“Do it, baby, shoot inside me”, I moaned.

Will was slamming into me. This intense, almost angry look on his face. He was banging hard into my hole….

Then he slammed in and held his cock deep as he yelled out.

“Urghhhh fuckkkkk” he grunted.

I felt his load filling me up. I loved it. I needed it.

My orgasm hit, but as it did, I saw Benjys face looking at me with his legs spread…and I thought of Will shooting into him…

And I shot my load everywhere. It was so fucking intense.

We both came off our orgasms. Will lay on top of me, breathing heavily.

“Don’t know what got you so worked up today but that was fucking hot baby” He said as he breathed into my chest.

“Was just horny for you baby,” I said. Which was true but also a lie. Benjy had got me so worked up.

We snuggled on the sofa a while longer, then went to bed.

-

The next morning, I was feeling a lot better. Benjy hadn’t come over, and I was now sure he was also probably embarrassed by it. I mean, he did leave his door on the latch and then have noisy sex. They were probably so horny they jumped on each other and just forgot to close the door properly. So I am sure he also wanted to forget it all too.

And, although I had said this before this time, I meant it,  no more fantasising over Benjy and Will fucking. I love Will, and he is the most amazing person. I would be insane to ever let anything happen, and I am so confident he would never do it anyway. He loves me, and I love him, and he didn’t want any other guy at all. He only had eyes for me.

I kissed Will goodbye as he headed off to the office, and then I grabbed my last bits, finished my coffee and left the flat not long after him. I was feeling good, happy.

When I came out into the corridor as I turned to lock the door, I heard a noise behind me.

I turned around, and Benjy was standing there, looking hot as always in some very short shorts and a tight t-shirt, his hair all messy, which made him just look even hotter.

“Hey there, Luke. Think you and I need a little chat,” he said, with that smug smile he has.

Shit.

“What do you mean?” I said, trying to play dumb.

“Oh, you know exactly what I mean, you, little pervert. Come over to mine tonight, or I'll tell Will you've been spying on me having sex,” he said.

Then he turned around and went into his flat, closing the door behind him.

I stood there dumbfounded.

This was bad.

Very bad.