EP23 | The Neighbour Across The Hall (Patreon)

This fictional story features only adult characters (18+) and portrays consensual interactions throughout.

I stood there, looking down at my boyfriend, who was naked and on top of Benjy. His cock buried deep inside him.

I was hard; they looked so fucking hot together, and as much as I tried, I couldn’t help but be turned on by the sight of them.

“I’m so sorry, Luke,” Will said, just a moment before. And he sounded like he meant it. But now he had resumed fucking Benjy. 

Benjy was moaning, in pure pleasure from my boyfriend’s cock as it slammed into him. And Will looked possessed; his whole focus was on Benjy again. He wouldn’t look at me; he was fixed on Benjy and slamming his cock into his ass. Every moan of his felt like a stab to my heart.

I had burst in and caught my boyfriend cheating. Confronted him at last. And after a moment of shock…he had just said sorry and continued fucking Benjy. Benjy had told him to look at my clearly hard cock in my trousers, and that had given away that some part of me found this hot. But he should still have stopped. I was begging him to stop.

But he didn’t. He kept fucking Benjy, right in front of me. Their grunts and moans filled the room.

I couldn't breathe. I felt a tear running down my face, and I wiped it away.

Will was really grinding his ass down into Benjy; it tensed as he slid his cock deep with every thrust. My boyfriend looked so fucking hot.

He had won, Benjy. He had said he could get my boyfriend to cheat, and I hadn’t believed him, but he had done it. This is my fault; I dared Benjy to do it. And now Will was balls-deep inside him, fucking him. I should have known he couldn’t resist a guy like Benjy; he was so fucking hot.

I was still standing there, no idea what to do now. I wanted to run but I couldn’t tear my eyes away from the scene in front of me.

Benjy glanced over to me and smiled, his wicked smile. Then he reached up and pulled Will in for a kiss. Will kept fucking him as he and Benjy started making out. Kissing deeply as they fucked.

And I was still hard as rock.

Just as much as I was aware of the tears in my eyes I was also aware of how hard my cock was throbbing. It almost seemed like the more hurt I was, the more deeply I felt this betrayed, the harder I got.

Will continued fucking Benjy in front of me.

My hand went to my cock. No, Luke, don’t do it. Don’t give them the satisfaction that this turns you on, that you are too weak to stop yourself. Even as your boyfriend fucks another guy in front of you.

But my hand gripped my hard cock through my trousers, and I had to stifle a moan. Will and Benjy were ignoring me; it was like I wasn’t even there.

I felt my hand unzipping my trousers; it was as if it had a mind of its own. I can’t do this! But I was doing it, and then my cock sprang free. Hard as rock. Throbbing at the sight of my boyfriend cheating on me with our hot neighbour.

My hand wrapped around my cock, and this time I did moan. I couldn’t help it. I felt another tear fall down my cheek as I started stroking my cock, watching my boyfriend cheat on me.

I must be crazy, but just as Will had given in…I felt myself give in.

I started wanking my cock as my boyfriend fucked Benjy in front of me. I should be yelling, screaming, pulling him off Benjy, but instead I found myself so fucking turned on and wanking my cock as I watched my boyfriend have an intense fuck with our neighbour. They were still kissing; Will was so hungry for him, and his cock was still slamming in and out of Benjy’s tight hole.

But then Benjy pulled away, and he saw me, and he laughed. He grabbed Will’s head and turned it so Will was now looking straight at me…seeing me wanking my cock as I cried. But Will didn’t laugh; he looked pained, sad almost, and he just turned back and put all his focus back on Benjy.

He didn’t stop fucking him once, not for a second. Benjy still looked at me for a little bit longer, watching me wank as Will fucked him…but then he too eventually looked away. All his focus back on Will, my boyfriend.

Will had risen up now and grabbed Benjy’s ankles, spreading them wide as he fucked him hard.

“Fuck baby, your cock is so good!” Benjy moaned.

Will just grunted in reply.

“You love my ass, don’t you?” Benjy pushed.

“Yes. I love it. It feels so fucking good…” Will moaned.

More tears filled my eyes as I kept wanking my cock. It hurt so much to hear this, but my cock was leaking precum as quickly as my eyes were leaking tears. I wanked furiously, completely hypnotised by them fucking. Wanting to see every detail, every sound, the smells of their sex. I was fucking drunk on it.

Does this mean Will and I are over? Have I lost him? I don’t know in this moment; I was lost to the horniness…so deep into this now, my mind was all a blur…

I had to slow down my wanking in case I shot my load too quickly. It was truly crazy how fucked up and horny this was for me. Before Benjy, I had never thought for a second of my perfect loyal boyfriend fucking another guy, but now here I was watching him fuck Benjy.

It kept hitting me. He was cheating on me; I told him to stop, and he didn’t. I told him to stop fucking Benjy, and he didn’t.

But I just kept wanking.

Will had leaned down again and was kissing Benjy; I could see their tongues in each other’s mouths. They were both moaning.

“Fuck Will, I love it, I fucking love it…” Benjy moaned.

“I love your ass, so fucking good, Benjy,” Will moaned back.

Fuck, it was all too much. My orgasm hit me so fucking hard, and I felt my cock twitching as I shot all over the floor in front of me. It was so intense my knees buckled, and I moaned.

The moment I had finished, I felt so ashamed. I was holding my cock as the last cum dripped out; the floor in front of me was covered in my load, the load I had shot while watching my boyfriend cheat. Benjy looked at me, and so did Will. And for the first time since I had walked in, he paused his fucking…

I didn't know what to do. I felt tears coming, so I just turned and ran out of the room.

In the corridor of Benjy’s apartment, I stopped, leaned against the wall, and my face fell into my hands. This is so fucked up.

But Will had stopped; maybe, just maybe, he was going to come to his senses and come after me. There was silence; I held my breath…

Then I heard the bed creak and Benjy moan.

Will had started fucking him again. They were continuing their fuck. I slid down to the ground and sat on the floor. I stayed there, listening as my boyfriend kept fucking Benjy. Their moans were even louder now.

“Fuck! Fuck yes, Will!” Benjy screamed.

“God damn, that fucking ass is so good!” Will moaned back.

“I want that load, breed my ass!” Benjy moaned.

“You’re getting all of my cum…” Will grunted back.

The banging was so loud now, the headboard smashing against the wall as my boyfriend fucked Benjy so fucking hard. They were moaning and grunting and screaming as they fucked. Will was definitely not holding back.

I just sat listening; it was like I was torturing myself, but I had to hear it all. It was too hard to watch; now I had cum. But I could feel the growing feeling of horniness coming again, fuck.

I was sure Will was close now; he was fucking Benjy so hard, and they were both sounding like they were about to cum. Then Will screamed, and I heard the banging stop…

“Yes, yes baby, fill me with your load!” Benjy moaned.

The sounds of Will cumming went on for so long; he must have shot so much in Benjy. Finally, though, it stopped and went quiet.

I got up and went back to the door. I looked in and saw Will lying naked on top of Benjy, who still had his legs spread, and his arms wrapped around Will. They both had their eyes closed, coming off the intense orgasms.

I looked at them a second longer, then I turned and walked away and left Benjy’s apartment. I went back to our apartment and got changed, then I got in the shower. I cleaned myself and then went to bed.

I felt numb. I had no idea what to do. SO much had happened, and in this moment I had no idea what it meant for Will and me, so I just went to bed. Not long after, I heard Will come in. He came into the bedroom, but I was lying facing away from him.

“Luke?” he said, softly.

I didn’t answer, just pretended I was asleep. He left the room, and then I did fall asleep.

-

The next morning I woke up early; Will was asleep next to me. I got up and showered and changed, made a coffee and then was leaving for the office when Will came out of the bedroom.

“Hey,” he said.

“Hey, I replied.

There was a silence between us, neither knowing what to say.

“We should talk,” he said eventually.

“Later,” I replied.

Then I picked up my bag and left the apartment.

We had so much to say, so much to talk about, but I wasn’t ready yet. I was still getting over what happened yesterday, let alone the madness of the last few weeks with Benjy. And I was scared too. Did Will want to break up with me? Did I want to break up with him? Why did I get off over him cheating on me? Does that make what he did ok? No, I really don’t think so.

I just had too much going on in my head. So I just went to work and tried to forget it all.

I knew I had to come to him tonight, and we would need to talk.

But for now, I just needed time to think.