EP25 | The Neighbour Across The Hall (Patreon)
Content
This fictional story features only adult characters (18+) and portrays consensual interactions throughout.
The next few days were weird, to be honest.
We were trying to get back to some level of normality after all that had happened, but it was hard. Sometimes I was so mad at Will, and I would snap at him and get upset. And other times we would be on the sofa after making dinner, and I could almost forget he had cheated on me with Benjy.
Luckily, I had not seen Benjy since I watched Wil fuck him a few days earlier. Every time I left the apartment, I was so worried I would bump into him, but mercifully that hadn’t happened…yet. I mean, it was going to happen sometime. He lived literally across the hall. My boyfriend had picked the closest person possible to cheat on me with, which almost made me laugh, if I wasn’t so angry.
Will was on his best behaviour. Constantly checking in with me, being uber attentive and apologising all the time. I felt like we weren’t properly dealing with it all, really, but I was scared to, in a way. Will had cheated, and it turned out not just with Will, but earlier in our relationship. I knew if we were going to stay together, we had a lot more conversations to go. But I just didn’t want to yet; I wanted to feel normal for a while. And Will was never going to be the one to bring it up; I think he just hoped we could sweep it under the rug.
And then there was the rampant horniness that would hit me out of nowhere. I would be trying to work or just hanging with Will, and suddenly I would have the most vivid flashes of Will and Benjy together… the moans… the banging of the bed… Their naked bodies together… it would be so intense, and my cock would get so hard. Several times at work I had gone to the bathroom and jacked off quickly, shooting massive loads that left me breathless.
After that first fuck when Will and I spoke about him and Benjy, and I had made him talk about it while he fucked me, I had been trying hard to make that not happen again. I was angry at him, and if I brought it up in a horny way every time we fucked then he was basically getting away with it. But I couldn’t stop these intense flashbacks that drove me wild. So far, I dealt with it by wanking a lot, but it made me feel shitty that I was still wanking over the memory of my boyfriend cheating on me.
It finally happened a few days later when I was leaving my flat in the morning. As I locked the door, I heard Benjy's door open. I turned to see him coming out. He saw me and smiled. I turned and practically ran down the corridor. I didn't take the lift in case I had to wait for it and he got in with me. I just went down the stairs. It felt so crazy seeing him, the guy my boyfriend cheated on me with, and the guy I'd also wanked off with over it.
As a few days turned into a week, I started to feel the knot in my chest loosen a little bit. Will and I had been having more conversations. Some of them involved me yelling, and we'd had sex again, but without any mention of Benjy. Just us together. I know we weren't anywhere near out of the woods yet, but I got a small glimmer of hope. Except I had been sneakily coming home a bit earlier some days. I would get back to the apartment and sneak over to Benjy's door and listen. Wanted to see if Will was sneaking over to fuck Benjy, but so far, nothing. Will was always at work, as he said he was.
I hadn't heard any other guys in Benjy's flat either. Seemed like he was maybe taking a break from being fucked, or he was just doing it when I was away.
But Benjy wasn't my focus or concern anymore. Will and I were getting ourselves back on track, and it seemed like Will was really keen on that too.
At least that's what I thought.
It had been two weeks since I'd found Benjy and Will, fucking. Since Will hadn't stopped. Since he'd continued fucking Benjy after I left the room crying, until he'd shot his load inside him. I'd been working hard to stop thinking about it, to stop getting hard over it, and to stop wanking over it, and it felt almost like some normality was coming back into our lives. It was still incredibly awkward that Benjy lived literally across the hall, but I hadn't really seen him apart from that one time, which actually was kind of odd. But I was just happy that I wasn't seeing him that much.
So one day I decided to do something nice for Will, considering how moody and angry I'd been the last couple of weeks, and hopefully moving towards us getting back to a good place. I finished work kind of early for the day and decided to head home, but I thought it'd be nice to head to Will's office on the way. Stop in and say hi. He was out for some work drinks that night, so I wasn't going to see him, so I figured it'd be nice just to say hi for a second. His office was a little out of my way, but again, I wanted to make the effort.
As I got to Will's office, I was walking up to the doors when I saw something that stopped me in my tracks. It was Benjy. He was ahead of me, so luckily he hadn't seen me, and he was walking into Will's office.
What the fuck was he doing here?
This made no sense. Why was Benjy at Will's office? He can only be here because of Will. And it feels crazy that the first time I decided to come by Will's office, I saw Benjy. Was this some crazy stroke of luck or bad luck? Or was Benjy coming to Will's office regularly?
I decided to try and follow him in without being seen.
I went into the reception area of Will's office. It was a large office building with lots of companies in it. Will was up on the sixth floor. But Benjy didn't go to the lifts. He went through the large atrium and headed towards the back where there was a sign saying toilets.
I stayed back, making sure not to be seen, but followed down the corridor and saw Benjy going into the gents' toilets.
I waited outside for a second, not sure what to do, but eventually, I went up to the door and opened it, peering inside. I couldn't see Benjy or Will, so I headed inside. There was a row of doors down a wall; those were the toilets. It’s a fancy office, so the toilets are nice too, and each toilet is its own little room with a toilet and small sink inside. I could see all the doors were open, apart from one… the one at the far end.
My stomach was doing somersaults. I had a sinking suspicion. I knew what was happening, but I was desperately hoping I was wrong.
I walked slowly and quietly down towards the closed door.
As I got there, it was all quiet at first. Maybe it was just Benjy using the bathroom. But why was he at Will's office? Why here? Had he come to talk to Will? Maybe Will was going to tell him to leave him alone. He wanted to do it in private, not to upset me. Maybe. That might be it.
But then I heard it.
The unmistakable sound of kissing and moaning.
I put my ear against the door, and now I could hear it clearly. Benjy was definitely not alone in there… He was making out with somebody. Then it sounded like the kissing stopped, and I heard a zipper, and then a few seconds later, a loud moan, clear as day, and I knew exactly whose it was. It was Will.
“Fuck Benjy,” Will moaned.
I knew for certain that Benjy was sucking Will, my boyfriend's cock, in the toilets at his office. This is so fucking crazy. Just as I thought things were okay, I thought Will was really trying. All they'd done was move the location. Was this the first time? How often had they been meeting up? Who planned this? Again, with so many thoughts in my head.
I looked around the toilet, but there was no one else here. It was quiet, apart from Benjy and Will in the last stall together.
I thought about banging on the door, busting them again, but if it was anything like last time, they might not even open the door, just continue. So I figured this wasn't the place to confront them, and as they had absolutely no idea I was here, I unzipped my trousers and pulled out my hard cock. Fuck it, I thought.
I started wanking my dick here in this toilet at Will's work as I listened to Benjy sucking his cock. Will was moaning. He could tell he was trying to be quiet, but he couldn't help it. Benjy's mouth just felt too good around his dick.
I stroked my dick as I listened to them in the stall together. Will was having his dick sucked. After a few minutes, it went quiet again, and there were some sounds of shuffling, and then another moan, but this one wasn't Will. This was Benjy. I think Will was sliding his cock inside Benjy. He was gonna fuck him in this stall at his work. This is fucking madness.
“Fuck baby, so good…yes…” Benjy moaned.
“Fuck that hole…” Will moaned.
And then they started properly fucking. I was standing just outside the stall, and I could just hear Will slamming his dick into Benjy. Benjy started moaning loudly now.
“Shhh, we need to be quiet,” Will said.
Benjy's moans got quieter, but they were still there. And Will's too. This is crazy. He wanted them to be quiet. I guess because he was worried about getting busted at work for fucking some guy in the toilets. Was even worried about the fact that he could get busted with a guy that wasn't his boyfriend. What if his work colleagues came in and saw them leaving the store together? Do his work colleagues know? Do other people know about this? I don't think so, as he was doing it secretly in this cubicle and telling Benjy to be quiet while he fucked him.
In the silence of this toilet, all I could hear was the slap, slap, slap of Will's hips as he fucked Benjy in the toilet, and their quiet, stifled moans. I was imagining in my head what they were doing. Was Benjy bent over, Will just fucking him, standing up?
I was still wanking my cock. As I heard the moaning starting to get louder and the fucking getting more intense, I thought Will was about to shoot his load inside Benjy.
“Fuck, here it comes,” Will moaned.
“Yes, breed me, baby,” Benjy moaned back.
Hearing that tipped me over the edge. My knees buckled as I shot come all over the floor in front of me. As I listened to Will moaning loudly now as he emptied all of his cum inside Benjy's tight hole.
When I'd come off my orgasm, I quickly grabbed some tissues from the side, wiped up my cum as best I could before chucking it in a bin. I could hear Benjy and Will putting their clothes back together inside the cubicle, so I quickly ran out, made my way back down the corridor and out the front door. I waited across the street, where I was a bit hidden, but I could see. The front of Will's office.
After a few minutes, I saw Benjy come out and head off down the street. There he goes. After being fucked by my boyfriend, his ass full of my boyfriend's come. And I guess Will was just going to go back to work now, carry on as if nothing happened, and come home to me later tonight. When he'd just been fucking Benjy in the toilets at his work.
I felt insane. I really thought he was trying. I really thought we were doing better. But now they've just been even more secret.
What the fuck was I gonna do now?