EP27 | The Neighbour Across The Hall (Patreon)
Content
This fictional story features only adult characters (18+) and portrays consensual interactions throughout.
WILL'S POV
It really was like something else came over me in those moments. I still can't believe I didn't stop when Luke came into the room. My boyfriend caught me fucking another guy. Quite literally, balls deep inside him, on his bed, and I didn't stop. But it was like I was possessed, possessed by Benjy, and how fucking insane his ass felt.
But also, Luke was rock hard. It was obvious even through his trousers. He was turned on by it. In that moment, part of me knew he kind of liked seeing this, maybe a part of him he was struggling to admit. And I knew it was hurting him, and I should have stopped. But once Benjy pulled my dick deeper in him, my entire body felt the pleasure that his hole gave me… and I knew I wouldn't stop. I couldn’t
So I fucked Benjy in front of Luke. I put all my focus on Benjy at first. If I was going to blow up my entire life, this ass better be worth it. And it was fucking incredible. But then I realised Luke was wanking. He was standing there with tears in his eyes, wanking his cock. He did like it. He was like me, possessed by Benjy's fucking ass. But he was possessed by watching his boyfriend fuck it.
Then I really started pounding Benjy again, giving in, releasing myself from any guilt and just giving into the pure pleasure of fucking him. And after not long, we both heard it. Luke made this stifled little moan, and I looked over to see his cum shooting all over the floor in front of him. He'd crumpled a little bit, and I paused my fucking as I looked over at him. When he looked up at us after finishing, he looked so deflated… and he ran from the room.
Benjy just grabbed my ass again and pulled me into him. Fuck, I wanted to go after Luke so bad, but I also just needed to fucking. I needed to finish this. I needed to fuck Benjy until my load was buried inside him… and I did. He pulled me down, and we kissed deeply as I fucked my cock into him. My orgasm was building. I hate to say it, but I was even more turned on, knowing that Luke had just shot his load over this, and now we were alone to fuck. I had no idea where Luke had gone.
Finally, it hit me like a fucking freight train, and I pumped my load deep into Benjy before collapsing on top of him, as he wrapped his arms around me and kissed my neck softly, as my orgasm subsided. We lay together like that for a while.
When I finally got up and got my clothes together, I felt fucking awful, horrendous. What the fuck was wrong with me? I was the worst person in the fucking world.
“He likes it, you know. He got off over it,” Benjy said, as I walked out of the room.
Now I was done. I couldn't even look at him. I felt so fucking ashamed.
When I got back to the apartment, I presumed Luke would have left; he would be gone. But when I came inside and looked for him, he was in bed, facing away from me. I called out to him, but he didn't answer. I didn't know if he was sleeping or pretending, but I was just so thankful he was still in our home.
I just got into bed, but I didn't really sleep. I was too nervous for what tomorrow would bring. I desperately, desperately didn't want to lose Luke, but he had every right to break up with me after what I had done.
-
When I woke up the next morning, after a fitful night of sleep, Luke was already out of bed. As I came out into the kitchen, he was changed and looked like he was about to leave for work.
“Hey,” I said.
“Hey,” he replied.
Then silence. I didn't know what to say.
“We should talk,” I finally said.
“Later,” he replied.
He picked up his bag and left the apartment.
I felt some level of relief. At least he wanted to talk. At least he hadn't just packed a bag and gone to stay at a friend's. At least he hadn't already broken up with me. And all of those things I would have deserved.
He wanted to talk. That's got to be a good thing, I hoped.
I got changed and went to the office. I was tempted to call in sick, but I felt like I needed to go in, keep my mind busy somehow. Though I barely got any work done, I was so distracted.
I came home early, and I waited for Luke. I was so thankful when he finally came home. Again, I thought he might not bother. When we spoke, I had decided I was going to be honest, tell him everything, tell him about the other times I cheated as well. I didn't want to hold anything back. If we were ever going to make it after the madness that was yesterday, I had to lay everything out on the table. The craziest part was that Luke was scared that I was going to break up with him. After all I'd done, he still wanted to be with me. I loved him so much. I did not deserve him after what I'd done. Not just Benjy, but the times before as well.
I was determined to fix this. I was determined to make this right, to be the boyfriend he deserves.
After talking through everything, we fucked. And as we fucked, he asked about Benjy. I was so confused. I didn't know what to say. Surely he didn't want to hear this… but I could see in his eyes that he did. This dark look came over them, and his cock got even harder as I told him how good Benjy's hole feels. I was completely honest about how much I loved fucking Benjy. Our sex was hungry and desperate. This intense need for each other after both thinking we were about to break up. As I came inside him, I felt so good, so at peace. Yes, I love fucking Benjy, but I love fucking Luke too, and I feel so good after fucking Luke. I feel so relaxed, at peace, so connected with him. That's the sex I love. With Benjy, it's dirty, naughty, kinky, and yes, hot as fuck… but different. And I feel like shit after.
After our sex, Luke shut down again. He was still mad, really mad, I could tell, and I completely understood why. I tried my hardest to be the best boyfriend I could be, to be attentive and caring, and show him how much I loved him. We'd agreed: no more Benjy, no more contact with him at all. And I was happy to do that. I would do anything to make it right with Luke. Not seeing Benjy again was the easiest thing I could do for him. Although the fact that he was our neighbour was going to be tricky. But over the next few days, luckily, we hadn't seen him.
I was gonna do everything in my power to never see Benjy again…
And that lasted until the end of the first week.
He'd been texting me, but I'd just been deleting them, refusing any contact whatsoever. My whole focus was on Luke, making him dinner, cuddling on the sofa, having sex, just trying to feel like a normal loving couple again. I could feel Luke slowly, very slowly, relaxing around me again. It gave me real hope that we might make it. That after this horrible, awful thing that I did, maybe we could come out the other side, an even stronger couple.
But almost to the day, a week after Luke had found me fucking Benjy, he'd gone into work a little bit before me. As I was leaving the apartment, I heard Benjy's door opening. I looked round to see him standing there.
“Hey,” he said.
“I can't talk to you,” I replied.
“I figured. You've not been answering any of my messages,” he said.
“We can't see each other ever again, Benjy. I promised Luke,” I said.
“I know, I get it, but look, could we at least talk at some point? I think I deserve that, after you fucked me and left,” he said.
I felt really bad. It was true the last time I'd fucked him, and then we hadn't spoken since. I was so confused. I wanted to be a good guy, but did I owe Benjy at least a goodbye chat?
“Please, Will, I promise nothing will happen between us,” he said.
He stressed the word us, which I found odd at the time, but I didn't think about.
“I'll come home early. We can chat this afternoon,” I said.
“Great. Come to mine at three,” he said.
I left to go to work.
-
I was trying to see this as a positive thing. If I could talk to Benjy, make him really truly believe nothing was ever going to happen between us again, that this was done, it would help with me and Luke. We could all get back to just being neighbours, forgetting any of this ever happened.
Later, I left the office early and headed home. When I got back, I dropped my bag in our apartment. Luke was still at work; he had told me he had a busy afternoon of meetings. I made my way over to Benjy's and knocked on the door. He opened it and, thankfully, was wearing jeans and a T-shirt. No slutty little boxers or anything to try and tempt me. I was happy about that. Maybe he really was taking this seriously. He invited me in.
“You want something to drink?” He asked.
“No, Benjy, I can't stay long,” I replied.
“I'm sorry it happened the way it did, but Luke was the one who dared me to have sex with you, and you saw how much it turned him on. He's not being honest with you if he's not admitting that he found it hot, that he finds all of this hot, and I know you, Will. I know guys like you. You're not going to be able to settle for one guy. You need more. You're horny, and you shouldn't be held back just because you have a boyfriend,” Benjy said.
I felt shocked by him saying this. I thought I’d come over to say goodbye, to stop all of this, and here he was trying to convince me to keep going.
“Benjy, you’re wrong about me. I promised Luke I wouldn't have sex with you again, and I'm going to keep that promise. We can't do this any more. I love him. He's the person for me,” I said firmly.
“Okay. If that's true, then none of this will be difficult. But I think you need a wake-up call. You promised we wouldn't have sex, and we won't, until you say you want to. You can keep your promise to Luke. We won't have sex,” Benjy said.
“Well, good,” I said.
“But I am right bout you. And it’s time you stopped fighting it,” he said.
“What are you talking about, Benjy?” I said, feeling uneasy.
“Hey, Chris,” Benjy called out.
I turned around to see a guy coming out of Benjy's room. He was wearing a tight black jock and was naked apart from that. His lithe, toned body looked incredible. He was cute, really cute. Short blonde hair and pretty green eyes. He walked directly over to me and smiled up at me.
“This is my friend Chris. He thinks you're really, really hot, and I thought you might like him too. You promised Luke you wouldn't have sex with me, so we won't have sex. But you didn't say anything about Chris,” Benjy said calmly.
Fuck, Benjy is always playing games. He's always up to something. I should have known. I should have never come over here. I was desperately trying to think straight, but my dick was already reacting. Chris turned and showed his ass. This incredibly smooth, plump ass, as he smiled at me.
“Nice to meet you, Will," he said. “You were tight, Benjy; he is hot.”
“Benjy, this is crazy. Stop this,” I said.
“I'm not doing anything. This is all up to you, Will. You can leave right now. The door is straight ahead. But Chris is going to go back into the bedroom, and he's going to be lying on my bed. And if you decide to follow him in, he'll do whatever you want,” Benjy teased.
Chris now stepped towards me, leaned in, and softly kissed my lips.
“We could have a lot of fun,” he said.
Then he turned, and I had to watch that perfect ass walk away from me as he slipped back into the bedroom, turning to look at me and wink as he disappeared around the corner.
I was rock hard. I hated to admit it, but I was rock fucking hard. Benjy knew exactly how to play me. That other side in me, the side that just gets so fucking horny and needs to fuck, that can't think straight, that can't think about the fact that I have a perfect loving boyfriend at home. That part of me was kicking in.
I need to leave.
All I have to do is walk out that door. I looked at Benjy. He was now sitting on the sofa, looking all innocent. I started walking towards the front door. Everything was telling me to walk out that door. You can do it. You can do it, Will. But as I walked past Benjy's bedroom, I couldn't help but look, and there, in the dim light, was Chris. He was lying on the bed, smiling up at me, looking fucking incredible, as his hands glided over his body. He looked so fucking good…
At this point, it wasn't even a conscious decision. My brain was telling me to go towards the door, but my feet led me into the bedroom. Like I was on autopilot.
As I stepped into Benjy’s room, I closed the door behind me.
I looked down at Chris lying on the bed as I started unbuttoning my shirt.