Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Creating My Merch: Realistic or Cartoony?

  • Cartoon style; whimsicle, colorful, fun, light 1
  • Realistic; as close to the original bird as possible 0
  • Combination of styles depending on the theme and bird 10
  • Either one as long as all styles are done similarly by the same artist 2
  • 2019-04-20
  • multiple choice
  • 13 votes
{'title': 'Creating My Merch: Realistic or Cartoony? ', 'choices': [{'text': 'Cartoon style; whimsicle, colorful, fun, light ', 'votes': 1}, {'text': 'Realistic; as close to the original bird as possible', 'votes': 0}, {'text': 'Combination of styles depending on the theme and bird', 'votes': 10}, {'text': 'Either one as long as all styles are done similarly by the same artist ', 'votes': 2}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2019, 4, 20, 16, 16, 31, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': True, 'total_votes': 13}

Content

Would you guys prefer my merchandise line to be realistic looking or cartoon/illustrator based? I am struggling with a design concept as Comet's design tends to lean towards more of a goofy concept, while Morgan's is seriously inspiring. So I'm a little lost in my direction of wanting to go the cartoon-style route, or a more realistic looking bird route that's more exact. 

Which do you guys prefer?

Comments

Ashlyn Barnes

I think that, as long as they have a connecting look (which usually results from being done by the same artist), then the realism/cartoony can come from the bird and quote. I do think, though, that the bird should be recognizable (like Comet should accent Comet's features (tail, expression, coloring) more than just looking like a camelot macaw. Same with Morgan. You want people who know BirdTricks to be able to look at the merch and go "that's Birdtricks!" without necesssrily throwing a logo in their face :)

Tiffany Frehley

..... I like the realistic look the most. ... That pink tank top is gorgeous. ... But on black or navy, not too girly for a man. ... Hugs Jamie. :)