Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 717704434.mp4

Downloads

Content

Files

Comments

Blue’sLeftNut

Don’t forget bout the 30 episodes you promised big bro 😅😅😅🫱

지원

hell yeahhhh let's go

지원

tiger is my goat

LAW

Fishman Island is criminally overhated simply because its themes are much more political and less dynamic than standard arcs. The real battle isn't about defeating a strong villain but a clash against the ideology of hatred and how racism is passed down through generations. But because Oda trades shonen villain hype for sociological depth, a lot of people overlook what makes it so special. (Also Oda does Sanji kinda dirty this arc)

Jason

Have you seen the comments about fan letter? You are able to watch it now and it is genuinely a 10/10 I don't want to say anything about it because that would be a spoiler but I would really recommend checking the ep out

MoPierre

50:28 normi nogans?👨🏽‍🦼💀

Akagami

Shusui is one of Zoros coolest swords fr always cool seeing it. One of only two Black Blades, the other being Dracule Mihawks blade Yoru. I always wondered if Mihawk thought anything of it while he was training Zoro.

Akagami

There's fasho no redeeming the World Government as an Organization. They have gotta go for their crimes. Monkey D Dragon and his Revolutionary army gotta lock in ong.

Akagami

1:07:00 True but that's cuz Garp probably believes reforming the system from within saves more lives than abandoning it altogether. Think about the countless lives of ordinary citizens, who otherwise wouldve been dead, that were saved by Vice Admiral Garp Hero of the Navy.

Zarathos Daimaoh

Not necessarily. Speaking for myself, I do dislike the arc, but the lore, the flashback, themes of racism, and the landscape are its strong parts, and, to a lesser degree, the demo of the crew's abilities post-timeskip is also nice. It's just that some stuff—like the pacing (obviously so much worse with Toei's original treatment of the arc), a few plot choices, and my "hatred" of some characters (like Hordy and Shirahoshi)—overpowers the rest and sours it. And nothing can control that; no amount of rationalization and deep diving into it will. Understanding characters, plot elements, and their concepts and themes does not automatically negate feelings of annoyance and issues with them. It's just that nobody will ever convince me that you can't have all the good parts of the arc while also having better elements. Finally, its place on the timeline does not help. It's the great return of the Straw Hats after massive, grandiose arcs, and it takes place in a setting we've dreamed of for years, yet it's underwhelming. And let's not forget that it's also a big follow-up to events from past favorite arcs involving beloved characters. People would lose their shit too if Elbaf turned out to be a mid arc when it happens.

Zarathos Daimaoh

Yeah, while it's obvious the WG labels any form of rebellion and illegal actions as "Piracy" or worthy of being wanted... being an actual pirate is still an ideology. If you just want to see the world and help people, you don't need to become a pirate; you could even become a Marine (or merchant, adventurer, etc.). Unfortunately, you can also become a Marine if you want an excuse to belittle people and be corrupt. You would usually only become a pirate if you have a chip on your shoulder or are very ambitious and don't really care if you hurt people in the process. , While they are the positive outliers and anomalies among pirates, Luffy and the people we follow, like his crew, WB, etc., do share those traits. And even then, let's not forget that while obviously provoked into it, even Luffy unleashed the deadliest of criminals onto the world because he was only focused on his own goal. Asking why Garp would uphold the Marine system is like asking why "good" politicians or good cops uphold capitalism or police departments , instead of burning down the whole system and "establishment" . Garp isn't so naive as to believe the Marines in general are absolutely pure and righteous; it's why he chose not to be promoted to admiral so he wouldn't have to be a direct lapdog to the worst people. Whenever Garp preaches about the Marines, he's talking about the good of the Marines—people like Koby, Smoker, Tashigi, as-yet-unseen characters, and many of his other subordinates. I'd wager that if not for Garp and a few other like-minded people, the Marines would be even worse than they already are. And it's not like they are pure evil; they still help plenty of people, and because the story of One Piece is viewed from the pirate side, it's easy to forget that the vast majority of pirates in One Piece are downright atrocious criminals. Garp values justice and sees Marines as necessary for protecting the world, even if he resents the World Government’s actions. To him, being a Marine is about fighting crime (pirates) for the greater good, even if it means tolerating the corrupt system he serves. Getting people like him completely out, is basically like completely defunding and suppressing a police system that you'd still need. Or saying "what the point of a good cop in a Cartel infested country ?"

Dreamknight942

Can we be real about Arlong though? He is a bum. Beating on a child who was a slave herself, when he was never even a slave, he hasn’t experienced half her hardship. There’s nothing really to understand about his actions, he is bitter and wants a reason to hurt others. Tiger was a true goat. He wanted to keep the good message of unity despite his experiences with humans. And Jinbei and others who are passing down his will.

Akagami

1:43:37 Had me dying bruh 🙏😭😭 Yes tho seriously do not take anything Johnny and Yosaku had to say seriously. Those niggas were cool but they were clueless, uninformed and in their own lil East Blue bubble. Niggas had practically 0 knowledge about what the grandline was like unreliable ahh mfs.

Dreamknight942

Agree it’s definitely overhated. It has so many strong moments that outweigh the weaker ones.

Zarathos Daimaoh

Sure, but he had one tiny redeeming feature. ultimately, in his twisted ways, he cared about his people, and beyond his immediate friends/family, his community. Which is in part why he took on the fish men’s hurt as his own and ran wild with it. Still a bum, still a villain, but there is a root at least. And he was a cool villain overall, with some decent plotting skills. He just emulated and became the very oppressors he hated.

Dreamknight942

Oh absolutely he was a great villain, obviously cared about his crew. I just don’t vibe with the revisionist history some people have with Arlong. But I agree with what you said 😊

LAW

I guess we just disagree. For me, the good heavily outweighs the bad. You’re definitely right about the annoying aspects (Sanji, the pacing, and the Shirahoshi antics). But Hordy is actually an amazing character for what he represents. He isn’t supposed to be a charismatic, likable villain like Doflamingo or Aokiji. He epitomizes inherited, hollow racism: he never experienced discrimination himself, yet he developed a hatred far more extreme than Arlong or Fisher Tiger who were actually affected by discrimination. That's his whole schtick, and it's a fascinating concept that happens irl too. Add in the MLK vs. Malcolm X dichotomy of Otohime and Fisher Tiger, especially Tiger wrestling with a hatred for humans he knows isn't justified but still can't shake off, and the writing really shines. That's why I think it's still a great arc. IMO, it fits perfectly right after the timeskip. The Straw Hats get to flex their new strengths (as u said) while exploring a sociologically deep topic on an island of friends. It was never going to be a massive hype-fest like Egghead right out of the gate. Honestly, I’d be absolutely fine if Elbaf turned out to be a more chill arc too, but that’s just me ig.

King Tut

I agree I think thats the point tiger probably didn't want to continue after so much that was happening and probably knew if he was revived he would become more like along which would hurt Fishman in the long run. Thats how I took the scene but I understand everything have there own interpretations great reaction can't wait ti see more

Dennisjmv

VanderP445 16:34 😭😭😭😭

Mystique

Love Fisher Tigers flash back with Koala, I remember crying when she screamed!!😭😭😭I never understand why people dislike this arc. I bet it’s the same people who would skip Skypiea, and say Thriller Bark is boring 🙄🙄.

Mystique

Also, I don’t see it as Fisher Tiger giving up. I’m pretty sure years ago, when discrimination really bad, white patients won’t accept medical attention from a black doctor/nurse regardless if it cost them their life. They could suffer from internal bleeding but since it’s a black Dr/nurse assigned to them, they refuse to accept their help. Fisher Tiger suffered and witnessed all the horrible things humans have done, human blood was there to keep him alive but he can’t accept it. That’s how I interpreted it tbh 😅😅😅

Zarathos Daimaoh

Oh, it's fine that we disagree—not pointing fingers—but I do have a bit of a pet peeve of sorts about people making assumptions about someone disliking specific arcs. Many people do understand the plots, symbolism, themes, concepts, and why things and characters are the way they are (or at least what they attempted to be or convey), even if they feel the execution was unsuccessful. That doesn't mean they automatically have to enjoy them, or that if they didn't, it went over their heads. It was especially ridiculous with some Davy Back Fight enjoyers and their infamous rebuttals, which are basically akin to 'Well, if you don't like it, you must not like comedy' or 'Not everything has to be hype moments and action'—which was never the point or the issue. Finally, at the very least, anyone honest can agree that a so-called 'bad' One Piece arc is still pretty good by most standards, even with the filler episodes and arc.

Brandon Debrosse

King Neptune isn't saying anything just because he doesn't necessarily agree with her (which I think is a valid assumption because if he did he'd most definitely be with her). And tbh that's fair, just because his wife thinks one way doesn't mean he has to advocate for it as well yk

LAW

That is true, and I'm not tryna point fingers either. But calling it a flat-out "bad" arc is just false IMO. We can debate whether or not someone enjoys the concept of Fishman Island, but when judging the arc on its own merits and what it actually tries to achieve, it succeeds very well. I never said anyone has to enjoy it, as you said, it's totally fine to agree to disagree. My main point was just that the general discourse around this arc lacks substance. And that's not pointing fingers, that's just a fact. Most people just boil it down to "bad pacing + bad characters = bad arc." For example, I brought up thematic reasons for why Hordy is a great villain but when you look at why the broader fandom thinks Fishman Island is bad, the criticisms are usually just poor. A common complaint I read is "Hordy was a bad villain because he was weak." That completely misses the point of his character and shows that the person complaining probably just cares a lot more about battle hype. I'm not saying this is you, I'm sure you have really solid reasons for saying it's bad. But my original comment wasn't aimed at you, it was about the general consensus of Fishman Island being a "bad" arc, when most of the criticism I see shows a total misunderstanding of what the arc was even going for.

Brandon Debrosse

Well to play devil's advocate, imagine Arlong's crew respected him just like Luffy's crew does. I mean He was the Arlong pirates for YEARS. Even if they (specifcally Hachi) agreed with Jimbei's ideals or whatever, more, I can see why they'd still follow Arlong, that's their captain

Brandon Debrosse

Yosaku was right btw, I don't remember the exact wording but it was something along the lines of Jimbei exchanged being a warlord for Arlong, it was just the other way from what you guys were thinking

Brandon Debrosse

Y'all I just watched the next reaction, I was wrong on why he wasn't saying anything LOL

nelly c

Yes they seen it but they said they aren’t going to watch it yet and and wait till later and I agree I don’t think it makes sense to watch it so quickly imo it is better as a slow burn and a nostalgic reminder of how far we’ve come from back then than to watch it immediately

Semi-addict-gamer

14:20 totally missed what Luffy said 😭😭😭

diri

I really like the fishman island flashback arc. on my first watch I was so annoyed with otohime bc she felt like just an actionless liberal LOL up until she actually says what she wants and means when she gets drunk -- how the fishmen keeping themselves separate does protect them more but also is another way for humans to have power over them. and how ultimately she and tiger had the same goal when it comes to making sure that the children dont grow up with inherited biases. girl you should lead with that next time though lollll loving the binge I hope yall had fun with it!

EyesLikeLiquidFire

True, but the option to become a Marine is not always realistic either and people need to acknowledge that too. Take Ace for example, he could have become a Marine, but it also would have messed up an already depressed and angry kid. The idea that Garp would tell him the truth and expect him to put on the uniform and eat that? "Oh, your mom basically killed herself because the institution I work for terrorized her entire island and murdered people as they searched for you and her. Now join that same institution where you may be asked to do it to someone else." That is absolutely bonkers and it would have ended badly the moment Ace received a similar order. There are evil pirates out there, but we also know there are angry people out there who have been on that side of marine justice through no fault of their own. Spouses and orphaned children (like a young, angry Ace) left behind after the hunt for Roger's child. Escaped slaves like Koala, Fisher Tiger and Aladdin. People who assist escaped slaves. Traveling from an island that isn't part of the World Government. Robin, just Robin. Those can all get you labeled as an outlaw and that is just existing. And of course, if you are poor and happen to live on an island like Luffy's where the nobles decide to eradicate you or tax you into oblivion. If you escape those things, then piracy or the revolutionaries (also criminals) are your main options. Even the title of adventurer is not realistic because exploration brings knowledge and the government doesn’t want that either. Without government backing like Nolan had, or operating a merchant business, people don't really have a reason to be on the sea at all. The entire planet is a dictatorship where they want to keep people oblivious, separated and propagandized like crazy. Even the islands that aren’t apart of the World Government aren’t free of them. So, while there are other options for people who want to leave their island, those options are actually very limited, especially for anyone who is exposed to the truth about the marines and the WG.

TheDouble BB

48:00 welcome to one piece kiddos where things that don't makes sense.....make sense