Update and some scripts! (Patreon)
Content
For any new patrons, you are entitled to access to the scripts from previous episodes. Some scripts (most, really) are different from what ended up in the video. Lines get cut for time. So, they are the most complete forms of the episodes.
That aside, here is the latest batch:
SON OF SAUL
AUDIO 1
Son of Saul is a 2015 film directed by Lazlo Nemes. Saul Auslander is a prisoner in Auschwitz, the infamous Nazi concentration camp. He discovers a young boy has died and convinces the doctor to allow him to take the body. Saul searches all over the camp for a rabbi who can perform the Kaddish and help give the boy a proper burial. Saul tells others that the boy is his son, but nobody he tells is convinced of this. Saul and a few others escape from the camp under the pretense of coming to bury the boy. They are eventually discovered, and the gunshots that ring out suggest that nobody survives.
The Holocaust differs from other historical genocides – Rwanda, Cambodia, Armenia – because a genocide is generally confined to a particular country or region. Armenians living elsewhere on the continent could potentially be safe, but the Holocaust was a plan to target and eliminate Jews all over the world. First in Europe and then elsewhere as Nazi Germany planned its expansion. This means that while the plan was enacted by Nazi Germany, most nearby countries have their own histories. Saul is a Hungarian Jew lead by Germans to occupied Poland. We picture the millions of Jews and others killed exclusively in these camps, but in reality, many were simply killed outright – where they lived – which makes the total number killed in the genocide difficult to calculate. The loss of humanity numbers in the millions, but the loss of “our humanity” – in the abstract – cannot be measured.
AUDIO 2
Throughout the film, Saul searches for a rabbi to perform the Kaddish. The film does not explicitly tell us what this means, assuming the audience will know the Kaddish as either ubiquitous enough to understand the basics or ascertain – in context – that it is a prayer for the dead. In actuality, the Kaddish is a kind of hymn of praise, and the burial Kaddish is a version for this specific purpose. When followers of the Jewish faith say that they are “saying Kaddish” – it often refers to burial rites. When Saul finds someone who he believes knows the Kaddish, he begins to bury the boy, but the man is revealed to be a fraud. He does not know the Kaddish save for the first line or two. Over the course of the film, Saul is subjugated because he is a Jew. The Nazis mock his religion, his culture. They dance around him singing a false version of a song and nearly force him to dance to it before tiring of the scene. So, when Saul races back and forth across the concentration camp attempting to find someone who will help bury the boy and perform the Kaddish, we can begin to understand why. His faith has been used against him.
The Nazis have challenged and mocked his culture. In burying the boy properly and reciting the Kaddish, Saul will be preserving his faith. The purpose of the Kaddish is not simply to mourn the dead but to praise God in spite of their loss. To tell God that the Jewish people still believe and remain faithful even in the face of death. Part of the Kaddish is the response: “May His great name be blessed for ever, and to all eternity.” The Holocaust is often called “Shoah” among Jews. This is because “holocaust” comes from a Greek translation – holokauston – of a Hebrew word “olah” – meaning a burnt offering to God. Obviously, Jews might find the association of the word offensive, and so the alternate version, Shoah is sometimes used. “Shoah” translates in English as “calamity” or “catastrophe.” Not sacrifice. Michael Berenbaum, director of the Sigi Ziering Center for the Study of the Holocaust and Ethics at the American Jewish University once said “I wouldn't want to know the God who sacrificed these people.”
AUDIO 3
Coming to terms with the Shoah from the perspective of faith can be challenging. Not since the temple in Jerusalem was destroyed in 70 AD by the Romans has the faith of the Jews been so tested. Philosophy among Jewish thinkers post-Word War II followed a number of competing theories and paths – trying to discovery why this happened from the perspective of their faith. Philosopher and educator Richard Rubenstein, in his book After Auschwitz, claimed that from the perspective of the Jewish faith and the history of the Jewish faith, there exists only two possibilities for why the Shoah occurred: either as punishment or as a mystery. He argued that since he could not conceive of a God who, after choosing the Jews as his people and forming a covenant with them, allowed for the Shoah to occur, then the Jewish concept of God cannot exist. This concept of God, he argued, is dead. Jews could no longer claim that an omnipotent, omnibenevolent God works in favor of the Jewish people.
Of this, he once wrote “No people has less reason to believe in abstract moral principles, human virtue, or international institutions than do the Jews. … The death of God as a cultural fact is real and all embracing.” The fact that the film, Son of Saul, revolves around finding someone for the Kaddish tells us a lot about what it is trying to convey is a grander scene. Saul is not merely searching for someone to say a few words. He is searching for faith, for hope. He is searching for what the Kaddish is about – understanding loss in the Jewish community while still being God's chosen people. Saul would probably reject Rubenstein's assertion or at least wish to reject the assertion, that the previous Jewish concept of God is now dead. Rubenstein pictured a couple scenarios and hypotheticals. If God were alive, Rubenstein argued, he would not have allowed the Shoah to occur. Or if God were alive and allowed the Shoah, then the covenant between God and the Jewish people had been broken. In either case, the Jewish CONCEPT of God – whether God ever existed or not – is dead.
AUDIO 4
Jewish philosopher and theologian Arthur Cohen had a differing view. For Jews, suffering was part of their history, but this new suffering – the Shoah – was different and represented an altogether new challenge. A new version of evil with no moral to the story. A break from past events. Perhaps because of this, he also claimed God's role in the Shoah was and is ambiguous. “God and the life of God exist neither in conjunction with or disjunction from the historical, but rather in continuous community and nexus. God is neither a function nor a cause of the historical nor wholly other and indifferent to the historical. … If we begin to see God less like an interferer (when it accords with our needs) and more as an immensity whose reality is our preconfiguration...we shall have won a sense of God whom we may love and honor, but whom we no longer fear and from whom we no longer demand.” Though, this lack of intervention, this “silence” as Cohen once put it, may not be comforting to men like Saul. He attempts to alleviate the silence of God. To make a rabbi speak. Throughout the film, Saul tries to have this boy buried. He tells others that the boy is his son, but others question the validity of this.
The boy is probably not directly related to Saul, but his obfuscation is only a lie to others. To Saul, the boy is family because he is a Jew. He is family because he is suffering in the same way that he is. He is family because his true parents – whoever they are – are not there to bury him. Not there to speak Kaddish. When the audience asks whether or not Saul is the boy's father, that is not the mystery of the film. Post-World War II Jewish theology may sound dire or perhaps just revolutionary, but not all Jewish philosophers and theologians believed in upending the faith or declaring the death of God. Abraham Joshua Heschel once said “In a world where God is denied . . . violence applauded, in a world where God is left without allies—is it meaningful for man to court-martial Him?” Heschel compared this questioning of God following a disaster to that of Job, who famously never received a satisfactory answer. Heschel believed these affronts to his God were gibberish, even if they were articulated well.
AUDIO 5
This hope and this attempt to attach oneself to one's faith in the face of the Shoah is written into the film. The director himself has confirmed this. He said that his movie shows hope – not hope of survival but the hope of the inner voice that might exist, when everything, including God and religion, is gone. In the film, we don't see the classic, movie arc or act structure or even familiar cinematography. There is a momentum to everything that differs from these structures. Classical storytelling inside Auschwitz does not work because there cannot be a happy ending. There can be no ending, really, just a series of endings. One death, after another, and with the Nazis giving no special recognition or burial rites to the dead, and with the prisoners not able to mourn their losses, there can be no closure in a narrative. Not a narrative that is genuine, anyway. Hannah Arendt, a Jewish political theorist who escaped Nazi Germany, famously wrote Eichman in Jerusalem.
Adolph Eichman was one of the architects of the holocaust, perhaps its chief bureaucrat. Trying to understand the Shoah outside of the religious point of view, Arendt famously called Eichman's inability to think for himself, reliance on stock phrases and cliches, and strict adherence to conformity as The Banality of Evil. This phrase has since taken on a life of itself, and we see this bureaucracy, this casual brutality, this machine-like evil, this banality in Son of Saul. Prisoners are forced to shovel ashes of people they once knew. Removing blood from the floor is mere janitorial work. A chore, like washing the dishes. Prisoners are marked in the same way that documents are stamped. Everyone is...inanimate. Arendt was NOT making the claim the genocide was unremarkable because of this – some have mistaken her words over the years. … The way the action is shot in the film, according to the director, is meant to show the limitations of life there. The lack of information. Nobody could know or see very much, and the cinematography conveyed this. There is another benefit to this, though. The holocaust seems so far away, so distant, as if it happened in another world. Son of Saul braces us to the action. It makes us watch everything up close. That way, it can never feel distant. It is happening...right now, in front of our eyes.
SOUTHLAND TALES
AUDIO 1
Southland Tales is a 2006 film written and directed by Richard Kelly. Boxer Santaros, an actor, has amnesia. In his vulnerable state, he becomes part of a plan by revolutionaries to bring down the Republican party. In this alternate history 2008, America suffered a nuclear disaster in Texas a few years prior and is currently waging World War III against a coalition of enemies. Because of this heightened state of fear, the Republican party has endorsed and implemented the USIDent program, an all-powerful surveillance system for America. Throughout the film, characters slowly become aware of the coming apocalypse. The narrator often recites “This is the way the world ends.” Though the film never cites its source, this is perhaps the most famous line from T.S. Eliot's The Hollow Men, written following World War I.
The characters are somehow guided along their paths, occasionally given prophetic information, receive epiphanies about themselves and stumble through portents of doom both spiritual and natural. When Boxer is told that he traveled back through time and met his past self, one version of himself – seeing himself for his own eyes – committed suicide. Boxer replies with some bravado, declaring himself a “pimp” and that “pimps don't commit suicide.” This bit of humor is not without some depth. I have discussed personal identity in previous episodes, but this time travel encounter provides some new insight. The question of personal identity is this: What does being the person that you are consist of? It's a broad question, but it's an important one because the correct answer to it determines what types of changes a person can undergo without ceasing to exist.
AUDIO 2
Philosophers like Plato, Descartes and indeed, many of the world's religions solve personal identity through the soul. You are unique because your soul is unique. But if Boxer met another Boxer in a different time, would that not be evidence that unique personhood does not exist? We discover late in the film that Ronald Taverner and Roland Taverner are not twins but the same person – one of them has time traveled. A time traveler is not a clone or twin – a time traveling Ronald has just as much claim as being Ronald as the other he met. The old Ronald from Friday travels back in time to talk with his younger self on Monday. Are there two Ronalds or just one Ronald on Monday? Is there one person or two? Whatever you answer is, why? Your answer might tell you a lot about what you believe about personal identity. If there are two Ronalds, then one might argue for a physical explanation for identity, and if one argues that there still exists only one Ronald, then one might argue for a spiritual explanation for identity. Or maybe the opposite is true! From an outside observer on Monday, if someone were to witness this, Ronald might have two bodies and therefore be two people, but as we look back on our lives, there are versions of ourselves throughout history. Different...bodies...just existing at different times, presently unable to interact.
If time is not destroyed when we pass by it and continues to exist enough for us to travel back to it, then we ALWAYS have duplicate bodies – existing. Ronald always has more than one Ronald, at least from one perspective. Time in philosophy, not quantum physics, has three forms: eternalism, possibilism and presentism. Presentism posits that only the “now” exists. No future or past. The character Krysta Now embodies this philosophy. She insists, during this scene, that what matters is now, not any other time. Possibilism posits that both the present and past exist – much in the way that characters speak of recent history and what they are doing in the present as a consequence of the past. Eternalism posits that time is a fourth dimension, as real as space. All times – past, present and future – are actual physical times that exist at all times in the same way points in space always exist. One is not more real than the other. The universe is a spacetime “block.” A physicist typically views the universe much in the same way that an eternalist philosopher would, and indeed, Southland Tales views the universe that way too.
AUDIO 3
Prophecies of the future suggest that the future is something tangible and not theoretical, and the scientists in the film refer to time as the fourth dimension, as an eternalist would. When Boxer travels back in time to meet himself, his personhood is explained away in the film as “sharing the same soul.” So, from the philosophical standpoint of Southland Tales, Boxer is always one person and time is eternal. Even when Ronald holds hands with Ronald and talks to himself, there is only one Ronald. However, there is a third option in existentialist thought. What if instead of there two Ronalds or only one Ronald, there is no Ronald? 18th century Scottish philosopher David Hume helped popularize the idea that there exists no real “you” over time. None of “you” persists, whether you are existing in a fixed time or meeting yourself in a bizarre science fiction scenario. To Hume and other philosophers, the solution to whether you are your memories or your body or your soul is that you are not any of those things.
From his book A Treatise on Human Nature, he once wrote “If any impression gives rise to the idea of self, that impression must continue invariably the same, thro' the whole course of our lives; since self is suppos'd to exist after that manner. But there is no impression constant and invariable. Pain and pleasure, grief and joy, passions and sensations succeed each other, and never all exist at the same time. It cannot, therefore, be from any of these impressions, or from any other, that the idea of self is deriv'd; and consequently there is no such idea.” It's perhaps best explained this way: This is a circle, and inside this circle is everything that you consider you. Impressions, emotions, stimuli, and more private things like your memories, your name and your beliefs, and lots of other things. OK, but now imagine that all of the things inside the circle exist, but the circle does not. What you consider yourself, according to Hume, is just these floating ideas and concepts. What we call the “self” is short-hand for what's in the circle because it's the quickest way to explain a “person” but there is no circle to keep it together. No self.
AUDIO 4
Hume argued that our concept of self is caused by our natural inclination of attributing unified existence to any collection of associated parts. Facing something that shatters your view of the universe of your view of yourself can cause existential ennui, and the scientists claim that this was why one version of Boxer committed suicide. Because faced with something that disproves what he always believed about himself was too much. Ronald, still haunted by the things he saw and did in the Iraq War, is face to face with himself, and he does not like what he sees. For this, he wants to kill himself. Suicide is brought up several times in the film. This lonely woman demands sex with Boxer and threatens to commit suicide if she does not get what she wants. This frequent reoccurrence in the film shows us the complexities of modernity. The world moves so fast and is so enormous that its crushing weight can make it challenging to find happiness. Conversely, this enormity superficially appears to provide so many opportunities for happiness that if one cannot find it, one blames oneself for this. Because if a world with such wonders cannot provide for meaning and joy, then people will turn that introspection on themselves.
Southland Tales shows the modern world, particularly America, as a blur of consumer entertainment and obedience to authority, enough to cripple individual identity. Celebrities are figures in their own cults of personality. Krysta Now has her own perfume, talk show, movie and energy drink, all with her name and/or face on them. We, the audience, laugh along at the black comedy of this, but it's really no more dissimilar to celebrity worship and celebrity brands in 2017. In the film, we see an America transformed by a nuclear disaster in Texas and the onset of World War III. One of the countries against America is shown as Syria. In 2006 when the film premiered, America in the real world was not involved in a military conflict in Syria, but a few short years later, we are. The film also predicted the extension and reauthorization of the Patriot Act, which allowed greater flexibility in government surveillance. In 2015, parts of the act expired, but the expired sections were applied into a new law called the USA Freedom Act, which extends until 2019. If everyone is watching, identity is not what it once was. If everyone is watching, everything becomes performative. Are we behaving because we are being watched or are we behaving because we are good?
AUDIO 5
These are modern issues, but introspection about ourselves and our own happiness is actually not a new concept. Ancient philosopher Hegesias of Cyrne once said “Complete happiness cannot possibly exist; for that the body is full of many sensations, and that the mind sympathizes with the body, and is troubled when that is troubled, and also that fortune prevents many things which we cherished in anticipation; so that for all these reasons, perfect happiness eludes our grasp.” He was one of the earliest philosophers to actually make a case in favor suicide, declaring that happiness is impossible to achieve. If modernity can be a cause of such feelings, perhaps modern philosophy can also be the cure. 20th century author and philosopher Albert Camus considered suicide the fundamental issue for moral philosophy. When faced with a universe that does not contain order or meaning, some claim that life may not be worth living. However, meaning and order, to Camus, were not prerequisites for existence. He believed that the only courageous and morally valid response to an absurd universe is to continue living, famously stating that suicide is not an option.
And for the characters in Southland Tales, it is not. Boxer discovers that the body he sees is of himself but that he did not commit suicide. Whatever else he may or may not remember about himself following his amnesia, he knows that is not in his character. He dies at the end, but this is not so much suicide as it is sacrifice – a less than subtle reference to himself as a Christ figure as his tattoo of Jesus bleeds through his shirt. Ronald, holding hands with himself, considers suicide but is talked out of it. He forgives himself for what he did because nobody else could. In this unique position of being able to talk to himself, he finds peace. Does the world truly end as the film concludes? If it did, Ronald would not be so intent on saving himself. There is a reason this cataclysm is happening on election night. The “world” does not end. The old world does, much as how Eliot's The Hollow Men was about how the world changed following the war. As the film closes, his eyes turn two different colors. It only happens for a few frames, but the implication seems to be that one Ronald with two working eyes has merged his double with a missing eye. He is one person. He is not two. He is a real person, and he is strong. Ronald does not let go. The world is not stronger than himself.
THE COOK, THE THIEF, HIS WIFE AND HER LOVER
AUDIO 1
The Cook, The Thief, His Wife & Her Lover is a 1989 film written and directed by Peter Greenaway. English gangster Albert Spica has taken over a French restaurant. He gorges himself on food while his wife, Georgina, suffers through his abuse and neglect. Georgina has an affair with a bookkeeper named Michael. Albert philosophizes – poorly – about how food relates to the human condition. He does this in between brutalizing both the staff and patrons. Albert eventually discovers this and has Michael killed. Georgina, the cook and the staff of the restaurant conspire against Albert and force the gangster to eat the corpse of Michael. As he does, Georgina murders him. What does Albert Spica want besides, superficially, food? There is this scene in Key Largo, a classic 1948 film directed by John Houston and starring Humphrey Bogart. Frank McCloud confronts notorious gangster Johnny Rocco. McCloud says he knows what men like Rocco want. Rocco, driven more by his passions and instincts than introspection, stumbles over his words when he tries to guess. McCloud says that what Rocco wants...is MORE, and the gangster enthusiastically agrees.
McCloud says that Rocco will never get enough. Then McCloud says that what HE wants, instead, is a world with no Johnny Rocco. More than anything else, Albert Spica wants...MORE. He wants to consume. His physical appetite reflects, rather, his desire for more from his life. He has so much that he has paradoxically become empty. He is wealthy enough that his life is now post-scarcity. He does not need anything, and when you do not need anything, you might suddenly WANT other things. This is a trait among and common accusation about the upper class. When all of your needs are met, and you have nothing left to struggle for, this complacency causes someone to invent other things that they need. Desire becomes gluttony, and gluttony grows into decadence and then vulgarity. If the rich and powerful have everything, why are they not happy? Why, having both security and access to the world's great pleasures, can they still be miserable? 17th century philosopher Blaise Pascal famously had a theory about this. When someone is no longer busy, they are alone with their thoughts and are forced to face the truth about their own existence – and sometimes that truth can be horrifying.
AUDIO 2
Of this, he has said “The only thing that consoles us for our miseries is diversion. And yet it is the greatest of our miseries. … I have discovered that all the unhappiness of men arises from one single fact, that they cannot stay quietly in their own chamber. A man who has enough to live on, if he knew how to stay with pleasure at home, would not leave it to go to sea or to besiege a town.” Albert Spica has no true struggle in his life, but rather than trying to be happy with what he has, he seeks distractions: women, enterprise and especially food. There are almost no scenes in the film in which Albert is alone. He is constantly surrounded by her underlings. When his wife disappears to go the restroom, he chases after her. Albert cannot allow himself to be alone. There is a more socio-political reading of the film too. This film was released in 1989 during the waning years of the Margaret Thatcher administration in the United Kingdom. Peter Greenaway, the director, is British. Thatcherism removed some of the government's economic regulations and a focus on controlling inflation rather than controlling unemployment.
Albert feels almost like a gangster version of a Thatcherite as well as the strong-arm, anti-intellectual politics that were becoming in vogue. Albert positions himself as an upper crust socialite but actually has trouble reading the French menu in his own restaurant and generally behaves in a careless, boorish manner. He admonishes Michael on multiple occasions for his audacity to bring a book into the restaurant. Albert represents this anti-intellectualism by stating that more people will read the graffiti in the bathroom than will ever read books. Spica considers his recognition of this to be its own intellectualism, the fact that he believes he has discovered what people “really want” is greater than what people could actually use. It's a kind of fool's intellectualism in which actual education and enlightenment are degraded under the mistaken belief that it is not intellectual after all. Men like Albert decry actual intellectual pursuits and position themselves as smarter than the well-educated in the same breath. It's embarrassing but so common.
AUDIO 3
The painting in the background of the dining room scenes is A Banquet of the Officers of St. George Civil Guard Company, created in 1616 by Dutch artist Frans Hals. The dignity of the officers gathered together contrast the vulgar party of Spica and his toadies. But to Spica, they are the same because he does not understand the difference between having power and having class. Albert claims to be an artist himself, not being self-aware enough to know how laughable that is. He is vulgar and violent and never questions the morality of his actions. Of course, he surrounds himself with so many distractions that he obviously has never allowed himself any real introspection. People are as consumable as food to him. In the beginning of the film, he mocks an Asian person saying that he never cared for Chinese “food.” In another scene, he refers to “quality” in his food and in another scene, refers to “quality” in his associates much in the same way, the connection suggesting that he sees them much in the same way.
The 1980's UK politics allegory may have been intentional or it may have been subconscious, but the politics of the film become far more overt when Albert denounces Michael's interest in The French Revolution that abolished the monarchy – Albert hates France's right to self-govern and instead eats their food. Albert references and praises the eating habits of Napoleon, Hitler, Mussolini and, perhaps controversially in the same company, Winston Churchill. Food is a kind of weapon in the film – Spica force feeds books to Michael, for example. The food of the poor and the food of the rich show their priorities. The food of the poor is affordable and the food of the rich is a status symbol more than anything else. When Georgina forces Albert to make good on his word and eat the body of Michael, the gangster's eyes are bigger than his stomach. He has finally had enough. He can no longer have...MORE.
ESCAPE FROM NEW YORK
AUDIO 1
Escape from New York is a 1981 film directed by John Carpenter and written by Carpenter and Nick Castle. In the future, the island of Manhattan has been transformed into a massive prison. Escape is nearly impossible due to a massive wall, a bridge with explosives and round-the-clock surveillance and helicopters as lethal guards. On the way to a peace summit between the United States and the Soviet Union, the President's plane, Air Force One, is hijacked by anti-imperialist revolutionaries. The President crashes into the city-wide prison and is taken hostage in exchange for release and amnesty of all prisoners. Snake Plissken, a former Special Forces soldier and current convict, is tasked with retrieving the President. If he is unable to do so within 24 hours, Plissken will be killed by micro-explosives injected into his body. If he is successful, he will be pardoned. After a long and bloody mission, Plissken recovers the President from the defacto ruler and gang leader of New York – The Duke. Following the rescue, the President attempts to give a speech to the peace summit, but this is sabotaged by Plissken who feels betrayed by the country he once served.
Escape from New York is a distinctly American film, not just because it was predominantly made by and starring Americans like so many other Hollywood films but because it setting, themes, politics and atmosphere were of the American zeitgeist of the 1980's. And yet, much of the film's predictions extend beyond the decade and some of them even came true. In the beginning of this 1981 film, the audience is told that in what was then the “future” of 1988, crime rises by 400%. This is the premise of the film and an explanation for all events that take place in the narrative. This did not happen in the real world 1988, but this hyperbolic projection of the near future was grounded in the statistics of the day. Some history might be necessary. In the 60's, 70's and especially the 80's, crime in major cities rose. Part of the this was because of a process now commonly called “White Flight” – white middle class families left the cities for the newly created suburbs, some of which were either legally or illegally whites only. Over the course of several decades, white families left and took the money with them, and without money, there is poverty. A common byproduct of poverty is crime.
[clip of “racist policies”]
AUDIO 2
Early in the film, the revolutionary who hijacks Air Force One claims that America will no longer be subjected to the racist policies of the government, and indeed, the real world government was complicit in the increase in “white flight” and subsequent increase in crime in the cities. The Federal Housing Administration justified housing segregation or “redlining” by claiming that if minorities, particularly Africa-Americans, bought homes in the suburbs or even near the suburbs, property values would decline. In reality, the opposite was true. When African-Americans even TRIED to buy homes in all-white suburbs, property values actually ROSE because they were more willing to pay MORE for properties than whites because their housing supply was severely limited. When Hauk forces Plissken to rescue the President under the threat of death, this might seem like a far-out, hyperbolic sci-fi scenario. Something to demonize the prison system by showing something truly barbaric. “Hauk would never get away with that,” we might say in our incredulity. The rights of convicted prisoners in the United States have constitutional limitations. The 13th Amendment to the Constitution abolished slavery in the country, but it has a very specific loophole. A condition.
Slavery is still legal among convicted prisoners. That is why forced labor for either no pay or little pay is legal while convicts serve their sentences. It is why chain gangs could exist. It is why corporations contract modern prisons for lower-than-minimum-wage labor among its prisoners. The only thing outlandish about the prison system in what was then the “future” of the 90's in Escape from New York is that the prison is strictly administered exclusively by the government and not by private enterprise. In the film, we are given a lot of technical data about how the city-wide prison functions. Manhattan itself – the setting of the film – is the most densely populated borough of New York City. In the real world, it has a population of about 1.6 million. If we estimate the population of the fictional Manhattan of the film is similar, we might guess that number would be rather high for a nation's entire prison population...but we would be wrong. According to the US Bureau of Justice Statistics in the REAL WORLD – not the movie -- roughly 2 million Americans are prisoners. America only has 5% of the world's population, but it has 25% of the world's prisoners.
AUDIO 3
Escape from New York depicts a future in which the police and the military are one in the same – or at the very least, the police force has become militarized. According to the opening narration, The United States Police Force is “like an army.” This frightening vision of the future is not too dissimilar to images of the police in America today. Police wear helmets and masks, carry assault rifles and ride in mine-resistant armored vehicles. Federal programs have provided military equipment to local police – regardless of whether or not it is necessary to perform their jobs – and definitely regardless of whether or not the police officers have military experience. In other words, the capacity to use said military equipment safely and effectively. It is, frankly, jarring how much this movie got right about the future. Militarization of the police does not make the population safer. It erodes confidence in the police force, making it difficult for citizens to approach the police following a crime, and it exacerbates delicate, sensitive situations like protests.
In the film, the imprisonment of convicts in Manhattan is portrayed as a result of the increase in crime, but the militarized, imperialist, racist government of the future does not consider that its own policies have created the situation. It is the cause, not the solution. Escape from New York challenges the social politics of earlier action films like Dirty Harry and Death Wish that portray anyone charged with a crime as a raving punk or vermin to be exterminated. Snake Plissken, conversely, is the criminal who can save us all. We don't know a lot about why Plissken was convicted. He was apparently involved in an armed robbery of the Federal Reserve, a crime in which Brain left twisting in the wind. Why did Plissken do this after a stellar career serving his country? Well, what reasonable assumptions can we make about the world he lives in? If crime rose 400%, one could rationally surmise that poverty was also on the rise preceding this. His pay following his discharge from the military may not have been enough to sustain himself or his loved ones. He may have been suffering from mental or physical ailments common among veterans. Unfortunately, such ailments sometimes go untreated, even by a culture that practically fetishizes the military.
AUDIO 4
Also, if he was robbing from a tyrannical, authortarian government that does not provide for its people, how immoral was this robbery? And what about New York City itself? Why, of all the major cities in America, is it the setting of this film? Well, that may require some history as well. In the 1970's, the decade prior to the debut of this film, there was widespread corruption in the NYPD, and the New York subway system had a crime rate higher than any other mass transit system in the world. With the city on the brink of bankruptcy in 1975, President Ford refused to bail out the city, comparing it to an “insidious disease.” Lack of funds breeds corruption, and corruption breeds inefficiency. In the film, this fall from grace and desperation due to no outside help is represented by The Statue of Liberty, once a beacon that welcomed those yearning to breathe free and now a processing center for inmates. The narration in the film says that the city-wide prison follows a simple rule: once you go in, you don't come out. This is an enhanced version of real world mandatory minimums and mandatory sentences. Guidelines for harsher punishments – even at times for non-violent drug charges – with less recourse than one would hope.
In America – the real world America anyway – the violent crime per capita has actually largely decreased since the 90's. This is a chart from the World Bank because people often do not believe this important statistic, probably due to the sensationalist news and when compared to the rise in prison population. Violent crime is way down and prison population is way up because of a lot of factors like mandatory minimums and the mass incarceration of non-violent drug offenders. Characters in the film are representatives of attitudes rather than fleshed-out men and women with complex backstories. Snake is missing an eye. He lost something in the war – but what he lost may have been more emotional, psychological and spiritual than just physical. The President of the United States has no name. He is the face America's harsh judgment and false moral superiority. With Air Force One under attack, the President escapes in his pod, leaving everyone else on board to die. He says to people he knows are about to die for him “God save me and watch over you all.” Helpless under pressure, willing to fire on a minority only when he is safe enough to do so, and disingenuous in the face of suffering that is not his own.
[clip]
AUDIO 5
The Duke has no name either. He is, perhaps, a villain, but he still has more fight in him than the feckless president. The Cabbie has no name. This appears to be a pattern. He simply is the spirit of New York. Optimistic in the face of disaster. He is the only character who genuinely smiles without any menace throughout the film. Originally a scene was filmed that would have given Plissken a little more depth. He was going to have to choose between saving himself and saving one of his friends. However, there is a scene that shows there is more to Plissken than his defiance and his attitude. When Plissken is frequently mistreated by Hauk – treated like a weapon more than a man – he whispers to himself, saying “A little human compassion.” More than the violence and the suspense, that is Escape from New York. If there is a line that ties everything together in the film, it's that one.
Plissken's actions at the end might be difficult to understand. The cassette tape that he retrieves and secretly destroys contains information that could help American either end the war or win the war. Based on the fact that it is data on nuclear weapons, one assumes that the “peace summit” is a charade. America will only sue for peace under the threat of the Soviet Union's total annihilation. For this, and for the actions of the President, Plissken takes this power away from America. Maybe, before America can grow in strength and become the world's only remaining superpower, it must change so that it handles its new power responsibly. Or maybe, to Plissken, America is irredeemable and does not deserve its victory.
KINGDOM OF HEAVEN
AUDIO 1
Kingdom of Heaven is a 2005 film directed by Ridley Scott. In 1184, a French blacksmith, Balian, is visited by a man who claims to be his father. When the father dies, Balian inherits his title of Baron of Ibelin and travels to Jerusalem. During this time, there is an uneasy peace among the factions who wish to control the city. The Knights Templar, wishing to reignite the conflict between the Christians and the Muslims, attack a caravan. In response, Saladin, the first sultan of Egypt and Syria, sieges the city. Balian surrenders, and he and his lover leave the holy land to live a more peaceful life elsewhere. There are a lot of historical inaccuracies here, especially about the protagonist. Balian of Ibelin was not born in France but in – not surprisingly – Ibelin. He was not the illegitimate son of Godfrey but actually the legitimate son of Barisan of Ibelin. He did not have a relationship with Sibylla, princess of Jerusalem. He was married to Maria Comnena.
In fact, that was a course of conflict between himself and Saladin. Balian asked Saladin for safe passage to Jerusalem to retrieve Maria under the condition that Balian not take up arms against Saladin and not stay in the city for more than a day. Balian broke the agreement. But this is history, not art, and the film is more interested in philosophy and religion than being a history book. Throughout the film, Christians and Muslims come into conflict with one another. When attempting to either justify their actions or rally their forces, they both shout “God wills it!” – placing the rightness of their actions under the rationalization of what is called Divine Command Theory. This is the view that morality is dependent upon God and that humanity's moral obligations consist of obedience to the commands and whims of God. When charging into battle, the knights say “God wills it!” and under Divine Command Theory, that is enough because this ethical outlook includes the claim that the morally right action is always the one that God requires or commands.
AUDIO 2
For many theists, this makes perfect sense due to their concept of God. To many theists, particularly those in the Abrahamic faiths, God is omnipotent, omniscient and omnibenevolent. So, if God says to do something, he knows best. If God says not to do something, well, you better not. The Book of Job famously grants God the right be unquestioned even when he seems that he is not portioning out justice the way one would expect him to do this, and that the act of questioning him itself is both wrong and foolish. 16th century French theologian John Calvin once wrote “The will of God is the supreme rule of righteousness, so that everything he wills must be held to be righteous by the mere fact of his willing it. Therefore, when it is asked why the Lord did so, we must answer: because he pleased.” In addition to believing that Divine Command Theory is simply factually true, there are also pragmatic benefits to believing God is always morally right.
Some argue that we must believe God exists and that his commands are correct because the requirements of morality are too much for us to bear. Faith can be a shortcut to peace of mind. Another advantage is that is provides an objective metaphysical foundation for morality. In other words, if one is determined to discover objective moral truths, said truths work well within a theistic framework. However, these advantages, while appealing, are perhaps better classified as conveniences. Life might be easier to navigate under Divine Command Theory, but these advantages say nothing of whether or not it is true; only convenient. In this scene, the Knights Templar and more moderate authority figures debate whether or not they should wage another crusade against Saladin and the Muslims. King Baldwin and Tiberius argue that there is no good reason to do this and try to use logic to dissuade the Knights from urging violent conflict. Tiberius argues, whether God wants them to fight or not, it is a battle they may not win.
AUDIO 3
Someone shouts that this is blasphemy. Under Divine Command Theory, The Knights Templar feel a sense of certainty about their actions. Not only related to the outcome of the battle, which they end up losing, by the way, but about the moral rightness of their actions. God, they believe, commands them to kill the Muslims, and if God wills it, then it must be morally right. To argue against this proposition, to the Knights, is blasphemous. Divide Command Theory follows different paths, though, and not just in differing religions. A strong version of the theory includes the claim that moral statements are defined by theological statements. In other words, x = moral obligation and x = God's will because x is the same thing in the first part and second part. Moral obligation = God's will. A supposedly weaker version of Divine Command Theory is that x = moral obligation and y = God's commands, meaning that morality and God are independent, and that morality was not an arbitrary system created by God but simply that he is the most informed being in the universe as to what our moral obligations should be.
And that brings us arguments against Divine Command Theory. “Does God command this particular action because it is morally right, or is it morally right because God commands it?” This is often called The Euthyphro Dilemma, named after a character in the writings of Plato. Both parts of the question might sound similar, but they are remarkably different. It is difference between whether God KNOWS what is right and wrong or God CREATES right and wrong. If God commands an action – like, say, wage war – because it is morally right, this means that God is brilliant enough to KNOW what is the right course of action. In other words, right and wrong exist outside of the creation of God, but he is qualified to both understand and explain rightness and wrongness to humans. This presents a problem for theists because if rightness and wrongness exist outside of God, then God did not create everything in the universe, and if God is not absolute in all things, he might be wrong or we could figure it out ourselves, thereby complicating Divine Command Theory.
AUDIO 4
On the other side of the coin, if God commands the knights to kill the Muslims, and because God said it, this alone makes it morally right, then morality is arbitrary. When the Knights Templar and their supporters decide to prepare for battle against Saladin and his army, they are not only defending Divine Command Theory but actually responding to the Euthyphro dilemma. Imagine if God commanded you to murder others. If one believes that God's will alone CREATES right and wrong, then you would feel obligated to do so without any reservations. If your response is incredulity – “God would never ask me to do that because it's wrong!” you exclaim – then you would have to admit that morality exists outside of the whims of God. In either case, Divine Command Theory becomes problematic. Believers in Divine Command Theory in general do not want to believe that cruelty could be as morally right as kindness. The Knights in the film do not seem to have this reservation, but most theists do. The Knights Templar are trying to decide if God, brilliant enough to know what is the right course of action, is commanding them to kill Muslims, or if God is commanding them to kill Muslims, thus making it morally right simply because it is the will of God.
Since they do not have any moral justification outside of “God wills it!” then one would argue that the knights agree with the version of the Euthyphro Dilemma that this phrase is enough. By their logic, and this response to the dilemma, God does not command us to be good. He just...commands us. The biggest problem with Divine Command Theory is foundational. It presupposes the existence of God. It does not begin with attempting to prove the likelihood of God. Rather, it starts with the absolute belief. Over the course of the film, characters make a lot of assumptions about the will of God. One character declares that Italy has been made rich, just as God intended. Is this a reference to the Roman Empire which had, let's say, a complicated relationship with the Jews and early Christians? A glorification of the Holy Roman Empire, perhaps? Also, why would Christians believe wealth is a sign from God? Jesus Christ would probably disagree with any connection between the rich and the morally good. In the beginning of the film, a priest assumes God has condemned a woman to Hell because she has committed suicide. The Bible has a lot of references to suicide, but it’s important to note that nowhere in the Bible does it indicate that the act of suicide is an unforgivable sin.
AUDIO 5
We could argue that these characters are simply ignorant, but Divine Command Theory rests upon a lot of assumptions to begin with. In order to believe in it, one must first assume exceptional claims about the universe. The strongest argument against Divine Command Theory is not the word problems and examples from before. It's that basing all ethical decisions on something that has been historically challenging to prove definitively means that everything related to Divine Command Theory is built on very shaky ground. The knights from the 12th century could have benefited from 20th century philosopher Robert Merrihew Adams who created a modified form of the divine command theory. To Adams, if something is wrong, then God did not command it. “If God were really to command us to make cruelty our goal, then he would not have the character of loving us, and I would say it would not be wrong to disobey him.” But Adams was not rebelling against God. He was and is a man of faith. He simply meant that if God commanded cruelty, then he would not be a loving God or God at all, in which case, he would not have to be obeyed, but God does not command cruelty, so such commands could not be from God.
So, if the Knights believe they must kill Muslims, and killing Muslims is wrong, then God did not command them to kill Muslims. It's the divine command theory in reverse, which presumes less and forces more critical thinking about both God and morality. It should also be noted that Divine Command Theory is not just a philosophical position but also can be used as flimsy justification for unrelated goals. The film depicts a time between the second and third crusades. Modern scholars understand that while religious authorities pushed for these wars, more terrestrial concerns were just as responsible. The Knights Templar, for example, became so wealthy during the Crusaders that they effectively became the bankers of Europe. In other words, the crusades were about land and wealth more than anything, but they occurred with such fanaticism and attracted so many belligerents because the crusades were justified under the theory of divine command. But this was not anything new and still exists today. Worldly matters that have nothing to do with God, in order to gain popularity and support, are re-framed as holy.
RED DAWN
AUDIO 1
Red Dawn is a 1984 film directed by John Milius as well as co-written by Milius and Kevin Reynolds. In an alternate 1980's, the Soviet Union and Cuba invade America. A group of teenagers flee the town and live in the woods as they prepare to become a resistance movement. In the end, the teenagers are victorious over the communists, and the United States military recaptures the rest of the country. It's a well-remembered but perhaps not well-regarded film that was very much of its time. It's also propaganda. It's necessary to define propaganda because it's word, like “art,” that is so far-reaching that it becomes nebulous in definition. Propaganda in its broadest definition is the spreading of ideas, information, or rumor for the purpose of helping or injuring an institution, a cause, or a person. [-Merriam-Webster] With this definition, we immediately run into a problem because this could cover everything from a political attack to advertising to completely truthful information that the creator hopes will further an important and/or personal goal. So, for our purposes today only, “propaganda” refers to the derogatory usage, that being misleading information through some form of media to covertly further a nation or a potentially dangerous worldview that is valued by a nation.
This is the more “everyday” usage of the negative side of the word “propaganda.” With this in mind, I do not think it is controversial to call Red Dawn propaganda – even if one believes in the general message of the film. NOT propaganda created by the state but propaganda created by private citizens. Generally speaking, the difference between propaganda like...a provably false tweet with an abhorrent political message...and propaganda that is created by the state is size and scale. And because of this, state-endorsed and state-created propaganda is usually what people think of when that word is used. However, there is another entity, at least in America, that has incredible size and scale – the magnitude and the money to spread or reinforce a worldview, and that is the motion picture industry. I am not demonizing Hollywood. It's a tool that can be used for the benefit or detriment of society. The point is that Red Dawn had the reach to be propaganda on a larger scale than a political pamphlet.
AUDIO 2
So, what aspects of the film serve right-wing goals? The opening text of the film says that NATO has disbanded and that America must fight communism alone. This is a popular isolationist, nationalist prediction: the idea that globalism – a united world based on common interest – will fail. In the parking lot of the school, we see a National Rifle Association bumper sticker. John Milius was on the board of the NRA. After the invasion, the teenagers band together in the woods. Daryl, the student council president, is depicted as a weak-willed intellectual who eventually is put in a situation in which he must betray his friends. Jed, a jock, is depicted as both morally and factually correct in all things. The far right – both fascism and right-wing American politics – historically decries intellectualism in favor of what it perceives as traditional values and “strong men” like Jed. Red Dawn props up hyper-masculine traits that the far right believes correct: multiple times in the film, men are admonished for showing emotion or crying.
“Don't cry!” is a common refrain in the film. “Turn it into something else!” Jed demands, suggesting that emotions are only good for violent anger and revenge. Indeed, “Avenge me!” is one of the most famous lines from the film. The Soviet Union is portrayed in almost Orwellian terms, creating re-education camps for civilians. Other Americans who are unwilling to join the cause of communism are executed while singing “America the Beautiful,” establishing their sacrifice as patriotic and the Soviet soldiers as monstrous. Red Dawn spouts nationalism as justification for any action, including unlawful execution at the hands of the Wolverines.
[we live here]
AUDIO 3
Propaganda requires an antagonist, like in any story. These World War II-era American propaganda posters, for example, tell a complete story. The Nazis and other Axis Powers are the villains and the Americans are the heroes. Conversely, the infamous 1935 Leni REEF-EN-SCHTAHL film Triumph of the Will has even more time to portray the Nazi Party as the hero and “degenerates” as the villains, even though some of the more inflammatory politics of the party are intentionally absent in the film. People...resist the idea that media informs their worldviews. They don't want Red Dawn to be right-wing propaganda SO MUCH that there are fan theories and bad sub-reddit posts about how the film might be a misunderstood left-wing satire about nationalism in the same way that Starship Troopers was mistakenly believed to be pro-fascism instead of anti-fascism by some critics during its release. I'm very sorry, but in addition to the text of the film itself not supporting this fanciful interpretation, John Milius himself has been explicitly clear about his intentions in interviews over the years – not to mention his highly public politics. He hated the peace movement and once claimed that he was blacklisted in Hollywood by the 90's for his conservative politics.
In reality, he was extremely difficult to work with and was known to point his guns at studio executives. Anything that could be interpreted as anti-war in the film, perhaps written by the co-writer Kevin Reynolds, was taken out by Milius. One actor, Powers Boothe, said that Milius removed the anti-war aspect of his character and other more humanizing qualities of other characters. Anyway, while authorial intention is not everything, one the key reasons for why Red Dawn can be comfortably called propaganda instead of just “misguided” is because of its intentions. But Red Dawn, regardless of how one interprets it or misinterprets it, is violent right-wing propaganda because it was made with those politics and those INTENTIONS. Red Dawn is beloved among conservative audiences. The National Review, a conservative magazines that loves putting Ayn Rand on its cover, named it as one of the best conservative movies of all time. The real world United States military operation to capture Saddam Hussein was named Operation Red Dawn. Its targets were given code names Wolverine 1 and Wolverine 2. Milius was apparently thrilled about this. The film's lasting impression was to inflame the nationalistic, militaristic qualities of Americans.
AUDIO 4
Red Dawn is what it seems to be. There's a saying. When someone shows you who they are, believe them the first time. … It is critically important to be suspicious of any message contained in propaganda, even if – on the whole – you might lean towards its worldview. For example, if one is a right-leaning American Republican, they should still find it in their best interest to still be suspicious of Red Dawn because its messaging is manipulative enough that it allows for someone who – in broad strokes – could agree with its patriotic sentiment to also accept new, radicalizing opinions. As an illustration, imagine someone who is intensely patriotic about America but has no established opinion on the war effort. Red Dawn and propaganda takes that pre-existing patriotism and feeds new information to the viewer that suggests that patriots are also pro-war. This does not happen as consciously as one would think, and because of this, it is difficult to track and subsequently the effects of the propaganda are easy to dismiss by the purveyors of said propaganda or the converted people for whom already share its inherent message and politics. The allure of propaganda for some is that it can reinforce and build up pre-existing beliefs. Defenders of the propaganda have multiple tactics.
First, they use events that take place in the movie to justify other events that take place within the same movie. It usually goes like this. I mention that the Wolverines execute one of their own for treason, a legal right they do not possess because they are not a legal entity, which makes it murder. Worse, it is child murder because Daryl is a high school student. It is framed as something that was difficult to do but needed to be done and justified. I say that this is a terrible political and moral message to deliver to an audience because it reinforces the rationalization of violence and, worse, revenge. Someone defending this will say “Of course they had to kill Daryl! He committed treason!” But here's the thing. Daryl didn't commit treason because Daryl does not exist. We are not seeing people on the screen. We are seeing decisions made by filmmakers. The filmmakers decided he must commit treason so that they Wolverines can be seen in a positive light to the target audience of the film and to justify murder. This terrible scene did not happen because Daryl committed treason. It happened because the filmmakers wanted it to happen. I'm not heartbroken that Daryl was executed because Daryl does not exist. Rather, I'm concerned that the filmmakers decided to make it happen and to frame it in the film and for the audience as morally justified.
AUDIO 5
This is a common bad argument when questioning the decisions of film and other media, but it is especially important when dissecting media with a message so overt and so negative that it can safely be labeled as propaganda. In the film, the first assault by the Soviets on American soil is a school, and their first victims are a friendly teacher and some children. This is not because the invaders are evil because the invaders do not exist. It is because the filmmakers knew this would upset the audience and immediately cast the antagonists as the scum of the Earth. Nothing happens in the narrative unless it is chosen by the creators for reasons of audience manipulation. Nothing exists in a fictional world EXCEPT the idea that it represents. Second, defenders of Red Dawn or other questionable films could and do claim [title] “It's only a movie.” in hopes of either sweeping the conversation under the rug so that the person objecting to it will cease OR in hopes of not having to think about it themselves and relieving themselves of any guilt or lingering questions about whether or not the existence of a film like Red Dawn is worth the negative consequences. Nothing is just an...anything because nothing exists in a vacuum. Red Dawn was not gifted to us by a muse. It is born out of the dangerous politics of its time AND the dangerous politics of its creator.
As a side note, I have seen people question the politics of Red Dawn while still claiming the film is otherwise a quality motion picture – wracked in conflict about whether or not something objectionable but entertaining qualifies as “good art.” That's an understandable internal conflict, but if I can just put on my critic hat here for a moment, this movie is terribly bland for something so violent. John Milius at his best was a fine script doctor and co-writer when working in tandem with more talented people. His directorial efforts are mostly forgotten save for Conan the Barbarian and Red Dawn, the latter for all the wrong reasons. Red Dawn is worth targeting as a piece of propaganda as I am trying to do today, but it is not worth the moral conundrum of whether or not it is ethical to enjoy...because it is not that enjoyable. Every shot is basic, which makes sense for someone more akin to writing and not being on the set, and the acting is poor, even by Swayzian standards. So...relax. It's OK to abandon your love for a movie once you realize its intentions, and it's easy to stop caring about something that was never particularly good in the first place.
[avenge me]
AUDIO 6
Red Dawn is special in how overt and obvious it is as a piece of John Milius's political propaganda, but American films with nationalistic overtones and themes about obedience to the state are extremely common. Americans do not always see them that way because America as the hero is the default for an American film, and nationalism disguised as patriotism is the background radiation of the American action genre. The universality in Hollywood pictures of American heroes and particularly the American military as the default has an “othering” effect on people who are not American. Movies are not great at making us do anything, but they do inform and shape our worldviews. It's something that happens to us on an unconscious level. To a non-American, it is plain to see, but for Americans, it is so normalized that we don't always notice it. I recently watched The Great Wall, a Chinese-American co-production. When the trailer was released, there was concern that this would be a “white savior” film, but considering it was co-produced by China with the biggest audience being the Chinese people, that concern may have been flawed. In reality, it's a nationalistic Chinese film in which the predominantly Chinese cast is portrayed as nearly superhuman in its defense of its country, and its enemies are literally de-humanized by being monsters instead of depicting, for example, The Mongols.
Its Chinese distributor is China Film Group, which is a state-owned film studio. China has also created a state-owned nationalistic action series called Wolf Warrior that is taking the country by storm. It's so easy to see from the outside. … Propaganda relies on the public being ignorant. The best thing we can do to limit its effects is recognize it for what it is.