DCEU Film & Culture Analysis Update and some scripts (Patreon)
Content
My 300th episode will be dropping later this month. I'm hoping to have a live stream on YouTube to hype it up. The likely time for this is Saturday the 22nd in the early afternoon. Keep an eye on my Twitter for updates.
And now, loads of scripts! Some are a bit different from the versions on my channel because some things were cut during editing or recording.
LET THERE BE LIGHT
AUDIO 1
Let There Be Light is a movie directed by and starring Kevin Sorbo, co-starring Kevin Sorbo's wife, Kevin Sorbo's children and featuring Kevin Sorbo's far-right Christian conservative worldview made manifest in a series of hollow argument and logical fallacies. Sorbo plays Dr. Sol Harkens, an author who the film calls the world's most famous atheist -- a vague reference to Dr. Richard Dawkins but also a strawman for atheism in general. In the beginning of the film, he debates a creationist and has the university student audience in the palm of his hand. He takes almost sexual pleasure in humiliating the creationist with his brand of acerbic wit and loud, bombastic arguments. Harkens “wins” the debate – not so much because he disproved God but because his argument was more appealing to the audience. He tells his audience what he wants to hear. For the socially conservative Christian demographic of THIS film, the scene is confirmation of what they suspect about atheism. It is appealing to young people because it lacks responsibility. The “real truth” is under attack by liberal authors and professors.
Let There Be Light is a didactic film. It is proselytizing rather than genuinely informing. The film does not shy away from this. It explicitly says so. [Proselytizing] There is a lot to cover with how much Let There Be Light gets wrong, but maybe the best place to start is how to propagates popular myths about atheism. When spiritual matters come up on my show, it is never my intention to convince viewers of something so grandiose – that there is or is not a God. That's not my job. I try to approach a spiritual matter in a film with the same reverence that the author gives it or its intended audience would give it. I make rare exceptions like this – such as with indefensible beliefs like prosperity gospel or premillennial dispensationalism. So, bear in mind that when I deconstruct this film's fallacious arguments about atheism, I am not trying to promote atheism or attack theism so much as I am trying to explain why many common theistic arguments against atheists themselves are not logically defensible. It's a distinction that I trust my audience is reasonable enough to see. Let's begin.
[Rap 1]
AUDIO 2
[TITLE CARD]
[MYTH #1: ATHEISTS ARE IMMORAL] The first thing we learn about Dr. Sol Harkens is that he is immoral. He is condescending to his debate adversary, he advocates a life creed that is essentially “Party on!” [Party on, Wayne] He drinks while he drives, he is not a very present father, he surrounds himself with ne'er-do-wells, he is prideful and obsessed with himself and so on. Many theists believe that there is no such thing as a good atheist. After all, how could anyone have morality without God? This question is asked by theists who believe that our sense of morality comes from God or is dictated by God. For theists, this is perfectly fine to live life in that belief, but upon trying to convince atheists that they are inherently immoral due to their lack of belief in God, we come across a circular argument. A logical fallacy. The circular argument restates the argument rather than attempting to prove it. For example, in the statement, “Dr. Harkens is a good communicator because he speaks so well,” we get a circular argument. The conclusion that Harkens is a "good communicator" and the evidence used to prove it "he speaks so well" are essentially the same idea.
Specific evidence such as his ability to use comedy to reach his audience, his use of uncomplicated language to neatly break down complex problems, or illustrating his points with personal, meaningful stories would all be evidence to prove the hypothesis that Harkens is a good communicator. In the case of theists proving that atheism is inherently immoral, we run into a similar circular argument. Some variant of “Atheism is immoral because belief in God is moral.” but the second part of that statement only restates the first part. It does not provide evidence for why atheism is immoral. Theists could attempt to argue that atheists are immoral by providing anecdotal evidence – a bad encounter with an atheist like Harkens. If someone bumped into Harkens at a party and had an uncomfortable moment with the world's most famous atheist, one could make the leap that atheists in general behave this way. He's a jerk, he's insensitive, irresponsible and a sloppy drunk. However, a personal experience or an isolated example is not a sound argument or compelling evidence. A singular witness to, say, a singular crime could be credible enough evidence that the crime was committed, but broad declarative statements about an entire worldview or group of people requires more than one's personal experiences.
AUDIO 3
Another logical fallacy related to proving atheism is immoral is “begging the question.” This is similar to a circular argument. The person trying to prove something assumes the truth of what they are trying to prove. The conclusion is stated by the premise. If one needs to initially believe the premise in order to believe the conclusion, then one has not established anything. One cannot establish something by assuming it. Theists use their holy texts as evidence that belief in God is moral and non-belief is immoral, but this relies on the belief that said texts are true, and that's where begging the question comes in. Example: “Everything in the Bible is true. It says so right in the Bible.” You will only find this argument convincing if you already believe the Bible is true, which is both the premise and the conclusion. Again, I am not interested in proving or disproving the divinity of the Bible or someone's faith, but this argument is not enough. There is no real data that proves not believing in something itself is immoral because suggesting otherwise is predicated on something that has not be proven. Harkens is a jackass, but that is because Let There Be Light wants to portray him that way. It reinforces what the target audience already believes about atheists.
Back to the narrative. We learn that Dr. Harkens' books are given sensationalist titles like Aborting God, which is just one example of the film's sense of subtlety. Dr. Harkens exclaims that he knows that there is no God because Harkens' son tragically died. Since then, Harkens has devoted his life to proving God does not exist through a series of popular books. The son's death must be fairly recent – the past few years or so – making one wonder what Harkens was doing with his life prior to this. He is some sort of overnight atheist sensation. He parties and gets drunk with his two business representatives, one of whom is coded gay. The character mentions an interest in women, but that is not what “coded” means. He is given effeminate qualities, an over-the-top affectation and becomes the strawman for what socially conservatives believe is the “limp-wristed” liberal movement. Although not explicitly called gay to avoid direct accusations of homophobia, the film delivers a coded homophobic message to the film's target audience. So, let's not be naïve about media literacy and what the film is trying to convey. Dr. Harkens is miserable and still grieving the loss of his son, which brings us to our next myth about atheism.
[Rap 2]
AUDIO 4
[MYTH #2: Atheism Comes from Tragedy] Dr. Harkens became an atheist because of the tragic loss of his son. This is a trope that surpasses the borders of this film. The once faithful man – often someone of the clergy – who has lost his faith and must regain it is a common, perhaps overused character in film. Someone befalls a tragedy or has seen too much horror in the world, but then he receives supernatural evidence to the contrary, and his faith is restored. In reality, faith has not been restored. Evidence has been presented. The former pastor in from Dusk till Dawn has lost his wife, and he is only willing to embrace God again when he is confronted with monsters from Hell. The former pastor from Signs lost HIS wife, and he is only willing to embrace God again when a series of coincidences that allows him to defeat the aliens leads him to believe that everything that happens for a reason. This goes on and on. What these films and Let There Be Light get wrong about faith is that it is not “lost” due to tragedy. It can, perhaps, but the implication of virtually every film, including this one, is that a lack of faith is a failing that must be overcome and that a loss of faith must have had something negative that preceded it.
The other thing movies like this get wrong about faith is how it is recovered. The word “faith” in the spiritual context should not be mistaken for “certainty” – Faith in the spiritual context of the word means strong belief based on spiritual apprehension rather than proof. “Certainty” means unassailable proof exists. In other words, if you are CERTAIN, then one would not REQUIRE faith. Dr. Harkens lost his faith in God, but he does not receive a moment of enlightenment. He receives proof. Certainty and faith – under the spiritual definition -- are mutually exclusive. The nature of faith requires less than certainty. Anyway, the real answer to why some people are atheists is less sensational. On some occasions, they are simply raised without a religion, and atheism comes about naturally. For others, it's different but just as simple. People have the opportunity to adopt a new outlook when confronted with alternative viewpoints. Experiences and education different from that with which they were raised. Based on Pew Research on the matter showing rising secularism and atheism specifically upon someone reaching higher levels of university education, the implication is that the introduction of alternatives allow for differing viewpoints.
AUDIO 5
That does not necessarily mean college equals atheism, of course. It only means that leaving home and no longer following the guidelines of one's parents provides opportunities for new ways of viewing the universe. The increase in secularism in the 21st century may have something to do with information being more readily available due to the Internet. Again, this does not mean that knowledge equals atheism either. It only means knowledge equals confronting previously held beliefs. Some people keep their childhood religion, some people change their religion from one theistic faith to another theistic faith, and some people adopt agnosticism or atheism. I've made dozens of videos explaining what Christians believe. I may as well briefly explain what atheists believe. Atheists think there probably is no God because extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Atheists would say that the counter-argument of “You can't prove God does NOT exist” is another logical fallacy called “Appealing to Ignorance.” Because complete proof that something is false is usually impossible, a lack of proof AGAINST something is not a good reason to conclude that it’s true. A claim puts the burden of proof on those making a claim – not on the person disbelieving it due to lack of evidence.
That is what atheists believe, and it's not as fascinating or sensational as movies like Let There Be Light make it out to be. In the film, Dr. Harkens not only became an atheist due to a tragedy, he also exhibits a related trait that is also a myth related to atheism: he hates God. He seems vindictive. He says, even while extolling atheism, that “God” took his son. Here's the thing. Atheists cannot “hate” God because atheists do not believe God exists. It is self-evident in the definition. If someone hates God as a person – not a concept -- then that person believes in God and is not an atheist. In the film, Dr. Harkens follows the trope. He suffered a tragedy, he experiences the supernatural, and he becomes religious once again. A near death experience allows him to see his departed son, and after some soul-searching, he allows himself to be baptized. He apologizes to his family for this previous atheism the way someone apologizes for being in a bad mood one day because they were “hangry” or something. It's embarrassing. The whole movie is embarrassing. [MYTH #3: Atheists Are Unhappy] This is related to the myth about atheists adopting their worldview due to tragedy. In the film, Dr. Harkens says his life is a party – woo! Drinking the drink they named after me at a party in my honor! -- but then he is actually shown to be deeply unhappy, especially when he is alone.
AUDIO 6
It should be noted that Pew Research has done some polling that some have interpreted as confirmation that religious people are happier than non-religious people, but there is a problem in the methodology. It measured religiosity in large part by how often people attend religious services – not upon which religion they identified. In effect, the research actually measured those that have strong community connections. There is, obvious, a correlation between happiness and one's connection to other human beings. Although, even that is not universal. Atheists have friends and family, just like anyone else. Who knew, right? Atheists with strong connections to their community are as happy as theists with strong connections to their community. Let There Be Light strays from its central claim – “atheists are just bad” – to dip its toes into other socially conservative talking points. Yeah, this is going to get even more uncomfortable, sorry. Every reference to Islam in the film is to Al-Qaeda, ISIS or a singular formerly Muslim woman who converted to Christianity after “escaping” Islam. Let's be clear here and not be naïve. The reduction of Islam purely into ISIS is intentional.
To a movie like Let There Be Light, the only good Muslim is one who converts to Christianity by the end of the film, and all others cannot be trusted. The opening credits even invokes 9/11 and Al-Qaeda. Dr. Harkens wants to set up a Christian phone app and convert everyone to Christianity. So, he goes on Fox News with Sean Hannity, and this exchange happens: [clips] Is it? Is it, Hannity? Because that's actually two logical fallacies in one: The first is the either/or fallacy, in which a conclusion oversimplifies an argument by reducing it to two sides or choices – sometimes irrelevant choices, like in this case. The second is that this argument “Well, what about ISIS?!” is a diversionary tactic or red herring or whataboutism – a method of avoiding an issue by focusing the audience's attention on something else or something worse. Dr. Harkens and Sean Hannity are using their allegedly fair and balanced news program to convert people to Christianity. The loyal adherents of Fox News have virtually no chance of joining ISIS. They are inventing a potential consequence to do something that has nothing to do with the actions of ISIS. There are so many references to ISIS in this movie, and nearly all of them are non sequiturs.
AUDIO 7
ISIS does not actually show up in Let There Be Light. This isn't an action movie or a war movie. They just keep mentioning ISIS as if the only alternative to Christianity is to become an Islamic militant and vice versa. [montage] I could go on. There is this enthusiastic plug for Chick-fil-A – the anti-gay fast food chain – but it's not product placement. Chick-fil-A is not seen in the film. Harkens' wife just casually mentions that her children ONLY want to eat at Chick-fil-A. No money to that godless In and Out Burger. Kevin Sorbo just really, really wanted to sprinkle in as much anti-gay and socially conservative references into his film. Hannity says the word “diversity” like he is spitting out poison. And there's more I could talk about like the COOL PRIEST, MAAAAAN – he was in the mob, but now he found God, but he still talks like a supporting character from The Sopranos – but this has gone on long enough. I hope this has been educational, and I hope, more than anything, that people don't assume the worst about people based on what they check on the “religion” question on the census. People believe the things they believe for a variety of reasons – most of them innocuous. The vast majority of atheists are just regular guys, and the vast majority of Christians would probably hate this awful, cynical, ignorant movie.
THE SHAPE OF WATER
AUDIO 1
[Beauty of Kura] In the 2017 motion picture The Shape of Water, the United States government captures a new species: an amphibian man. Elisa, a mute woman who works at the facility that houses him, falls in love with him and rescues him. Her employer, a man named Strickland, investigates this disappearance until eventually discovering Elisa intends to release the Amphibian Man into the sea. Over the course of the film, we see various ways in which social systems oppress minorities or people with less political power. Ableism in the form of how Elisa is treated due to her disability, racism, of course. Sexism, well, it's the 1960's. So, what do you think? The Amphibian Man is not a direct allegory for any particular oppressed people the way, let's say, “lesser” films clumsily utilize allegory. Instead, the Amphibian Man is more of a grander symbol for the concept of The Other. Director Guillermo del Toro explained it himself.
“...The monster...is a cipher; it’s a symbol. It’s an embodiment of, more than anything else, the ‘otherness;’ … I needed to talk about acceptance and love in a very urgent way. I feel it as an immigrant that has been received by this country, but I still feel there is sort of the demonization of ‘the other’ very present. I needed to talk about the beauty of ‘the other.’” What Guillermo del Toro is touching on here is the sociological concept of The Other. The idea of ‘otherness’ is central to sociological analysis of how majority and minority identities are constructed. This is because the representation of different groups within any given society is controlled by groups that have greater political power than the other. In the setting of the film, for example, white people construct the identities of racial minorities by representing them through stereotypes and superficial observations. When Strickland meets Zelda, the cleaning woman mentions that she is an only child. Strickland insensitively remarks that this is unusual for “her people.”
AUDIO 2
A minute or so later, Strickland mentions the appearance of God and says that He probably looks more like Strickland than like Zelda. So, in everything from social matters to religion, Strickland is constructing the representation of another people. Later in the film, the diner employee tells an African-American couple that they are not allowed to sit down at the counter. “Othering” has obvious discriminatory aspects that permeate through social interaction and even the law, but there is a psychological component to it as well. Social identities reflect the way individuals and groups internalize their established social categories within their societies, such as their cultural identities, class identities, gender identities, sexual identities and so forth. These social categories shape our ideas about who we think we are, how we want to be seen by others, and the groups with which we belong. One of the major contributing factors to ending racial segregation in America was proving that this othering had a severe negative psychological effect on children.
Social identities are creating through ongoing social interaction with other people and other resulting self-reflection about who we think we are according to these interactions. This is sometimes called the “looking glass self.” Social identities are produced through agreement and disagreement with other people, and we adjust our behavior and self-reflection based on these interactions. When Strickland invades Zelda's home to discover the location of the Amphibian Man, her husband, Brewster, briefly objects before almost immediately backing down and allowing Strickland to manhandle his wife. He also gives up the location of Elisa and the Amphibian Man. This interaction is terrifying to watch, and as an audience, we might wonder why Brewster does not defend his wife. However, bear in mind that his previous interactions with white men and the discrimination he faces might have persuaded him that this is not a fight he could win. That even if he pummels Strickland and throws him out of his home, he and Zelda might face consequences for that action.
AUDIO 3
His social identity is the result of his disagreements with other people, and his unwillingness to get involved is a result of his self-reflection of who he is, and what he can and cannot do. After the incident, Zelda tells Brewster that he could never understand what it is like to be her, the implication being that Brewster is not willing to understand what it is like to be a woman. Socialization shapes our ideas about what it means to be a “man” or a “woman.” and the unequal relationship between these two identities. Strickland sexually harasses Elisa at work. We could say that he does this because he is a bad person, and maybe he is, but he is “permitted” to do this because many societies establish certain privileges in men. If Elisa complained, there is a strong chance that the accusation would be dismissed as quickly as SHE would be dismissed with her job. 20th century philosopher Simone de Beauvoir once said “Thus humanity is male and man defines woman not in herself but as relation to him. … She is defined and differentiated with reference to man and not he with reference to her. … He is the subject, he is the absolute – she is the other.”
Strickland says that Elisa's inability to speak sexually arouses him, and when he has sex with his wife, he places his hand over her mouth so that she cannot speak. He enjoys the ability to shape the social identity of the other. His references to the Biblical Delilah is his way of expressing his feelings about female cunning and betrayal. It's his way of reminding Zelda, a black woman, that she is the other. [Angels] There are different ways of “othering” a group of people. The Shape of Water takes place during the Cold War in the 1950's. The American government and the Soviet government do not have any specific use for the Amphibian Man outside of a brief and preposterous discussion about the likelihood of his biology helping the space race. The American general explicitly says that if the Soviets want it, then America wants. If the Soviets want it, they can't have it because the Soviets must be up to no good. His sole basis for reasoning is that there are Soviets. The Shape of Water shows not only a tolerance for “the other” but also a love. Unlike in, say, Beauty and the Beast, the Amphibian Man does not need to transform into a human to receive a happy ending.
AUDIO 4
Movies generally present us with clear heroes and villains. In the film, Strickland is the villain. He is the true “monster” of The Shape of Water. Movies, and perhaps stories in general, reinforce an individualistic worldview, the idea that society is made up of individuals making independent choices and that your lot in life is primarily a result of your own actions – irrelevant to the actions of the billions of other people on Earth. The individualistic model of the world posits that people do what they are and that injustice and oppression are the result of the isolated actions of a fringe group of “bad people.” like Strickland. But the truth is that the social systems that individuals create become more powerful than the individual. As individual people, we are always participating in these social systems. A family is a social system. A workplace is a social system. When we meet someone and either introduce ourselves or shake hands, we are participating in a social system. When we interact with our employers, we are participating in a social system. And when we treat people a certain way based on their social identity, we are also participating in a social system. It is so inescapable that it has become ubiquitous and therefore invisible.
We choose not to see it and choose to see only the individual. In a sense, the villain of The Shape of Water is not Strickland. Rather, it is the institutions and systems that affect the characters. The villain is racism, sexism, homophobia, etc. Strickland exhibits most of these traits. He is the representative of these systems and functions as the voice of the institution of “othering” people – because a film is told through individuals rather than invisible systems of oppression. To the credit of The Shape of Water, Strickland's motivations are related to his being in a system – in this case, the government military and intelligence sectors. He complains to the general in individualistic terms. Strickland says that he has proven himself time and time again. However, the system does not care about that because it is bigger than the individual, and upon realizing that, he ramps up his villainy. Strickland is portrayed as the villain, of course, and the audience is meant to root against him, but when many are confronted with facts about “othering” minorities in this way in real life on a larger and less intimate scale, some are quick to dismiss the concept, become defensive, miss the point and talk about personal responsibility instead or choose the path of least resistance: ignoring it as someone else's problem.
AUDIO 5
That is how social systems and individuals interact. Individuals are not completely powerless. They can choose to walk away from the path of least resistance and actively fight systemic oppression, despite the pressure from the social systems to conform. [I Promise You] The Shape of Water shows us an example of this. When Elisa turns on the television, she and Giles see the 1950's civil rights movement and suppression of these protests by the police. Giles, frustrated, demands that Elisa turn it off. He can't stomach watching it and instead prefers watching Bojangles, an African-American performer, not a protester. Giles, who is gay man living in the 1950's, must be careful about his interactions with other people. His flirtation with the diner employee ends badly, but it could have gone much worse for him if the employee had decided to become violent. However, his sexuality is something he can hide and therefore has the small luxury of not engaging. Zelda, in contrast, must take into account who is speaking to in every situation in her life to protect herself from sexism and more violent forms of bigotry due to her race.
Giles tries to make this someone else's problem – magnified and exemplified by Elisa's request to help the Amphibian Man, which he also rejects. He eventually finds that he cannot take it anymore, seeing the diner employee reject him and then shoo away African-Americans, watching his career go nowhere. He realizes that hiding in the system and ignoring the problem is no way to live, and he helps Elisa rescue the Amphibian Man. He even fights Strickland. It's easy to pretend sociological systems of oppression and “othering” does not exist. Sometimes they benefit us, and we instinctively side with things that benefit us. Also because we would prefer to think of ourselves as individuals instead of existing within complex social systems that we do not entirely control. And also because such systems are invisible until we witness them happening to ourselves.
THE COUNSELOR
AUDIO 1
You would think I would like The Counselor. You would think, at a glance, that I would at least appreciate the film and believe that this might be the perfect subject matter for this show. The screenplay was written by Cormac McCarthy, the highly philosophical author was gave us No Country for Old Men. It was directed by Ridley Scott, the man behind highly philosophical films like Blade Runner. And the film itself is mired knee-deep in its own navel-gazing self-reflection. I don't like The Counselor, but before getting into why, let's tackle what the film is pontificating about in the first place. In The Counselor, the titular character who has no other name or designation, buys a diamond ring for his soon-to-be-wife Laura. He is on top of the world, not only because of this but because he is arranging a lucrative criminal endeavor with his criminal client. A series of events that seem like coincidences but are actually masterminded by someone else put the counselor and Laura in danger. The cartel has Laura killed via snuff film, the counselor's associate is also gruesomely murdered, and the counselor himself lives out whatever is left of his life in exile.
In the film, we essentially are meant to understand the ennui that comes from realizing your life has been determined by other forces. This does not necessarily mean forces like fate or God. Causal Determinism is the idea that every event is necessitated by antecedent events and conditions together with the laws of nature. It is connected to both philosophy and the study of physical sciences. People generally believe in some level determinism and some level of free will – the Counselor decided to get involved with criminals. It was his “decision.” Free will. Actions were set in motion because of it: determinism. But here's the thing. You can't really logically believe in both. An action is free only if the agent could have done otherwise. Free actions require options. Determinism does not allow for options. Every action is determined by the one preceding it. Wind blowing creates a branch swaying, due to physical laws. Causal Determinists would say that human beings are no different, despite our complexity. We only “think” we are making free decisions.
AUDIO 2
The Counselor may believe he made the decision to get involved with the criminal world, but everything that happened to him in his life created his personality, brain chemistry and everything else that went into that so-called decision. And every so-called decision he made prior to that that helped form the person he became who made the final decision was ALSO created by everything that happened to him THEN. Believers in free will say that everything the Counselor did was because of his own independent thoughts, but determinists would say that nothing is that independent. The Counselor does not exist in a vacuum. Those who believe in free will try to avoid all this by saying there is a difference between “event causation” – the branch being blown by the wind – and “agent causation” – people making decisions. The problem with that is that human beings are still governed by the same physical laws and systems that govern everything else. We are NOT so special that we are exceptions, and as rational thinkers, there is no real reason to believe we are. In the film, the counselor meets with a jeweler who explains that when the diamond is first cut, the rest of its flaws will emerge.
The beginning of someone's life is the same way. Someone is born and the natural laws of the world determine what is going to happen, and when the person makes decision, this is also due to natural laws. We are trapped in a series of causes and effects. We simply are not smart enough to calculate the whole of the universe all at once, so we perceive everything as choice when it is not. But just because we cannot narrow down the exact causes of an action does NOT mean they were not caused by something. Throughout the film, different characters say more or less the same thing to the counselor but using different metaphors and allegory...and...it gets tiresome. In a sense, The Counselor is a “message movie” in that nearly all of the movie is tell, not show – the opposite of film, but perhaps this conversely makes it an anti-message film. It discards what it believes is the saccharine moralizing of countless message movies and instead serves nihilism. I “get it” – I “get” what The Counselor is saying but “getting it” does not always mean appreciating it or respecting it. The film's sexual politics are a little troublesome. Laura is decapitated. She loses her head after an opening scene in which she receives oral sex – “gets head” – in a dark joke that might be film's most clever and most uncomfortable revelation.
AUDIO 3
Her genitalia is worshiped by the Counselor as innocent whereas Malika's is portrayed as ugly – not sexy but “gynecological” according to her boyfriend, Reiner. She has sex with was car windshield at one point. Reiner's fear of women might be framed as a character flaw for these purposefully flawed character, but his fears turn out to be correct when his girlfriend is shown to be the secret villain who has masterminded the evil scheme that results in so many deaths. Every woman in the film is either a seductress or an angel whose head is ripped off. Speaking of which, Westray says his only weakness is women, and he is seduced in order to have in offshore accounts stolen, leading to HIS decapitation. Whatever Cormac McCarthy is trying to say about women is...not good. Then again, he never writes women outside of superfluous characters, which might be itself telling. But the issue of the sexual politics isn't even the film's greatest sin. The problem with the film and its philosophical underpinnings is that the film feels so inconsequential that we do not believe in the cosmic laws that it purports.
Like a university philosophy professor giving a lecture with mustard on his tie and wearing no pants, the lesson lacks a certain credibility. Even if the arguments the film delivers are valid, everything around the arguments is not strong enough to contain its weight. Some of the picture is bogged down by Cormac McCarthy's noted inability to write women. His tales are generally caged inside in the traditionally masculine. The innocent Laura has no personality to speak of. She is there to be in danger – an object that the Counselor must love in order for the film to have a point. Their romantic relationship is explored only superficially. When she is assaulted and captured, we do not feel much for her – at this point only sharing about three scenes with other characters, most of them forgettable. Malkina is revealed to be the closest the film has to an antagonist, but this twist is telegraphed from the beginning. What's more, she is such a cartoonish figure that her complete lack of gravity makes it difficult for us to care when she reveals herself the villain.
AUDIO 4
And as for Scott, he can only do so much with material that is almost exclusively two people talking in a room together for two thirds of the film – all of them having mildly philosophical conversations. There is a difference between discussing philosophy in fiction and non-fiction. I deal in discussing philosophical in non-fiction. I don't write stories. In a story, the narrative is the lecture. We determine what the film is trying to say by watching everything unspool. In The Counselor, we watch a series of lectures. We may as well audit a class instead of listen to two hours and seventeen minutes of Michael Fassbender's middling American accent. In a sense, Scott has not adapted the screenplay to film because the film still feels like a reading of a screenplay rather than something that has calcified into a finished movie. When I was watching this, I thought “What is even going on in this movie?” but that's not because it was hard to follow or because it was too “deep.” It's because its world and characters lack credibility so much that my brain did not always register it as a finished movie. Scott eventually remembers that motion pictures generally contain motion and delivers a few sparse action scenes in the third act, but at the point, we are long past caring about the hollow characters and the more ambitious philosophy that is unfortunately not supported by the movie itself.
AMADEUS
AUDIO 1
In the 1984 film Amadeus, Antonio Salieri tells his life story to a priest. As a youth, Salieri prayed to God for musical talent. In return, he gave God his chastity and his eternal gratitude. Many years later, now as court composer, he meets Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, a young man considered far more talented than himself but not bearing any of Salieri's faithfulness or piety. Salieri grows envious of Mozart and angry with God. Why would God bless Mozart, who behaves boorishly, with greater talent? Salieri eventually rebels against both God and Mozart, planning to make a mockery of both of them. In disguise, Salieri commissions Mozart to compose a requiem. Salieri plots to kill Mozart once the piece is finished, then premiere it at Mozart's own funeral, claiming the work as his own. In doing this, he will use Mozart's blessing of musical talent as his own to rise above Mozart and humiliate God himself. This plan largely fails. Mozart dies before the requiem is completed, and Salieri spends the rest of his days in obscurity. Amadeus is a great movie, and it also presents a great opportunity to ask this question: How much control does God have in our lives?
Now, for non-theists, this can be answered by rejecting the premise of the question that God first exists. But for theists, this is a significant question and one that comes up a lot in our example: Amadeus. This question relate to metaphysical freedom. The concept of metaphysical freedom is related to last week's episode – the concept that free will requires alternate possibilities. In order to freely choose to do some action X, it must be possible to not do action X. If there is only one action you can take, then you cannot act freely. You would have no choice. This is sometimes called libertarian intuition – completely unrelated to political libertarianism. Rather than looking at this from the standpoint of hard determinism related to the observable sciences, Amadeus brushes up against freedom from a metaphysical and theological perspective. [Omniscience] Salieri faithfully believes in God, specifically the Christian God. When he was young, he prayed to God for the talent to create music and the opportunity to advance in that career. He claimed that he wanted to use music to praise the name of God. Salieri's Christian faith posits that God is all-knowing – omniscient.
AUDIO 2
God knows everything that there ever was and ever will be. That means if God knows everything, God knows the future, a concept called omnitemporalism. The future is known to God. If it were not, then God would not know everything and would not meet most criteria of what people, particularly Christians, believe God to be. Salieri, like a good Christian, believes that God has some influence on his life, but he also probably believes in his own free will – a gift from God. Many Christians and other theists believe in their own free will because it explains their ungodly actions and because it solves – at least for them – the theological problem of evil. It's not God who is bad. It's just that humans are bad, and God gives them options. Free will. Salieri believes Mozart is vulgar and immoral. He condemns Mozart for his human failings – at least first. Free will seems to be required for moral responsibility. If we were given no other option but action X and action X is immoral, are we at fault? If Christians believed God did not give them free will, how would they label anything a sin? If human beings had no free will, wouldn't all of humankind's sins be the sins of God instead?
How could God punish someone for their sins if NOT performing the sin was impossible? What reward could one receive for doing good when NOT doing the good deed was impossible? Free will is not only believed by theists to be a gift from God but also necessary to believe in any kind of moral responsibility, which itself is a tenant of their faith. However, this line of thinking runs into a serious problem when confronted with omnitemporalism. If God knows everything that will happen, then our choices are already made. Bear in mind that this is NOT the same as saying predestination is incompatible with free will. Foreknowledge only. How does this work? Well, let's say Salieri needs to decide between being a friend to Mozart or being his enemy. Suppose God already knew that Salieri was going to see Mozart as his enemy and plot against him. God is all-knowing and knows the future. Is it possible for Salieri to do other than what God knew he was going to do? If he answer is no, then Salieri does not have an option and therefore is not truly free. If the answer is yes, then God is not all-knowing and is easily outsmarted by a human being. Therefore, he is not God.
AUDIO 3
Only one option ever exists: The one God believes will happen. We see this in the film when Salieri tries to outmanuever God through his ploy to have Mozart's divinely-inspired music claimed for himself. It does not work because God is God and cannot be outmanuevered. Towards the end of Amadeus, having finished his confession to the priest, Salieri asks how a merciful God could destroy Mozart, someone Salieri believed to be simply beloved by God, while keeping a mediocrity like Salieri from both sharing in that glory and remaining alive to live in obscurity. As he is pushed down the hall in a wheelchair, Salieri declares himself “the patron saint of mediocrities” and absolves the other patients of their inadequacies. Salieri believes everything that happens to him must be by God's design, and if he outlived Mozart, that, too, must have been God's will. By this logic, Salieri has no free will. God foresaw everything AND forced everything into being. Everything that Salieri tried to do to avoid his fate of mediocrity was also foreseen by God. If God is omniscient, then we run into omnitemporalism.
And if someone knows the future, then our actions are definitely going to happen a certain way, and if they are, we have no choice. Salieri was always going to do everything he did, and his attempts to subvert this were also part of his path to ending up where he did. There are a number of common solutions to the problem of foreknowledge and freedom compatibility, but they generally fall short. For example, some suggest that freedom and foreknowledge are compatible because, by having foreknowledge, God is not actively using his power to completely force you to make a certain decision. However, the problem of foreknowledge and freedom compatibility is not a problem of action but of consequences. The suggestion that God has foreknowledge logically entails that you do not have alternate possibilities – remember, something besides X? – and if you don’t have alternate possibilities, you are not free. In Amadeus, we see Salieri pray to God many times, asking for guidance and for clarity on why Mozart was chosen to be more talented and to be the vessel of God's music. Those who are skeptical of the existence of God sometimes ask “What is the point of prayer? If God knows what you are going to do, it is already fixed!”
AUDIO 4
And that has a certain kind of logic, but really, if God already knows what you are going to do, you could say that about any activity. Another attempt to counter the problem of foreknowledge is called the backtracking counterfactual objection. It suggests that even if God does have foreknowledge, it is still within your power to act otherwise because, if you were to act otherwise, then God would just have had a different belief about the future than he did. In other words, if Salieri were to act differently, God would have believed differently than he had. Unfortunately, this still runs into the problem that God can’t have believed differently than he did. The fact that God believed as he did is already a fact, already written in the past. God believing differently than he did is no longer possible, which means Salieri acting otherwise to what God believed is no longer possible. Backtracking counterexamples do not solve the problem. God can know what the future holds only if it already exists, which means our future is already set. God’s complete foreknowledge is incompatible with free will because it entails a temporal ontology – the aforementioned omnitemporalism. Another solution is to reduce the powers of God.
You ever heard that antiquated argument about God making a rock that even he cannot lift? It's supposed to prove God is not omnipotent, and since God can only be omnipotent, there is no God. I don't find that a convincing argument whether from a perspective of theism or atheism. God is said to be able to do anything, but that only means he can do anything that is possible. He cannot do something that is impossible like make a square circle. That's just wordplay. It's a joke more than an argument. In that same area, God can only know everything that is possible to know, and the future may be impossible to know. So, does God control our lives? To theists who really think about, maybe complete control simply due to foreknowledge. Maybe simply by virtue of existing. To Salieri, it's unclear. He seems to believe in some kind of middle ground in which God blesses certain people but somehow exists a-temporally and does not know the future or Salieri's clever scheme. Does anyone? Throughout the film, Salieri never needs to be convinced of the existence of God. Even when he comes to believe that God rewards someone of supposedly bad moral standing like Mozart and ignores someone of supposedly good moral standing like himself, he never questions the existence of God – only his alleged omnibenevolence. What he really should have thought about was God's omniscience. It might have saved himself a lot of trouble.
HOT FUZZ
AUDIO 1
In the 2007 film Hot Fuzz, London police officer Nicolas Angel is transferred to the village of Sandford. There, he is partnered with Danny Butterman, son of Inspector Frank Butterman. A series of strange accidents -- all resulting in the gruesome deaths of the locals. Nicolas believes these deaths are connected and are no accidents, a theory pushed back by the rest of the police. After initially coming up short in his investigation, Nicolas discovers a secret cabal made up of the Neighborhood Watch Alliance who have been quietly murdering people in town for what they believe is the “greater good” of Sandford. Every year, the village is judged to be the best and wins an award for being the top village in terms of quality of life. The cabal believes that in order to maintain this status, those who do not fit in with their perception of what Sandford must be – need to die. Nicolas and Danny fight back against the cabal – guns a'blazin' – and restore normalcy to the village. In this film, we witness a conflict between two normative ethics theories.
These are systems that serve to articulate and advocate an ethical code or to provide justifiable and reliable principles to determine what is moral behavior. Throughout the film, townspeople use the term “the greater good” – a term which is also used in the ethical philosophy of utilitarianism. In concept, utilitarianism is the belief that society should attempt to maximize “good.” The morally right action is always the one that produces the most good. This theory is a branch of the normative ethics theory of consequentialism, meaning the right action is understood in terms of the consequences it produces rather than its good intentions. Utilitarianism specifically is more about the scope of the consequences. A utilitarian view is that we should maximize the OVERALL good for society. Not just one's own personal well-being. As much good as possible. Lots of good. Good, good, good, good, good, good, good. And that sounds rather incontrovertible, right? Superficially, utilitarianism sounds like a no-brainer. Of course we should work towards maximizing good in society. What is the alternative? Maximizing bad? MINIMIZING good?
AUDIO 2
But if utilitarianism – or ethics philosophy in general – were that simple and obvious, we would all be living in some kind of utopia right now instead of our waking nightmare hellscape where every news story is worse than the one that preceded it. But utilitarianism, like most any approach to normative ethics in philosophy, has some problems and Hot Fuzz illustrates some of them quite well. Early consequentialists defined “good” as pleasure or happiness. A kind of proto-utilitarianism called “hedonism” was developed by ancient philosopher Epicurus. He believed that one could determine the rightness of an action based on whether said action brought pleasure or pain to the person performing that action. “We must exercise ourselves in the things which bring happiness, since, if that be present, we have everything, and, if that be absent, all our actions are directed toward attaining it.” When the cabal of the neighborhood watch and others in Hot Fuzz plot the murders of townspeople because doing so will relieve their pain caused by the objectionable townspeople and increase their pleasure, they are performing the most selfish form of hedonism.
Actions that serve to maximize good purely for oneself fall into the realm of egoism. Epicurus would strongly disagree with these actions based on his writings about what it means to have a full and pleasurable life, but not everyone reads the fine print in your normative ethics theory. Utilitarianism, an outgrowth of this, aims to serve the greatest utility for society. Not the individual. 19th century philosopher John Stuart Mill once said “The creed which accepts as the foundation of morals, Utility, or the Greatest-Happiness Principle, holds that actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness, wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness. By happiness is intended pleasure, and the absence of pain; by unhappiness, pain, and the privation of pleasure.” Utilitarianism is opposed to egoist philosophy, citing the fact that while hedonism is ancient, utilitarianism is comparatively modern, and they are not one in the same. And that is true. However, their comparative nature can create misuse of hedonism under the banner of utilitarianism, and any good utilitarian may have to agree with this because they believe that the intent of something is far less important than its consequences.
AUDIO 3
But what is “good” to a strict utilitarian? Epicurus said “pleasure,” yes, but a more agreeable and less selfish way of stating that is...happiness. We all want happiness, right? Look at this guy eating ice cream. Now that's happiness. See, happiness is something that can be called an intrinsic good because it is good in and of itself. A counter to this is that utilitarianism reduces the subtleties of life to calculation of animal-like pleasures with no concern for how these pleasures are produced. Someone once said that because of this, utilitarianism is a doctrine only worthy of swine. Now, utilitarians would disagree and remind us that utilitarianism is not about maximizing only personal pleasure but maximizing personal pleasure for everyone. For...society. Utilitarianism, in concept, is not egoism. And society claims to operate this way, but as we see in Hot Fuzz, it doesn't work out quite that way in practice – and remember – how it works in practice is important to utilitarian thought. The cabal believes what it is doing is for the “greater good” of Sandford. These murders, they believe, keep the crime rate down and keep Sandford as the famous “best village” – which helps their image and therefore helps commerce.
But this is a falsehood. As Nicolas explains in one scene, these murders made out to look like accidents keep the public crime rate down but only because the murders are never documented as such. Nicolas says that the murders are still happening, and these so-called “accidents” are no less gruesome and tragic if they had been thought of as murders in the first place. Consequences. Not intent. Utilitarianism justifies moral wrongs for the greater good, but this also means that utilitarianism can ignore justice. A classic example of this criticism was given by H. J. McCloskey. If framing an innocent person for a crime that would reduce further riots and pain that looking for the real guilty person would incur, utilitarian theory would suggest that this would be the morally correct choice as although an innocent man will suffer, for a greater number of people less pain will be caused, creating a calculation of more pleasure overall. In other words, if the sole aim of utilitarian theory is to maximize pleasure and reduce pain for the greater number, justice can and will be ignored.
AUDIO 4
To use the film as an example, the cabal killing Nicolas would cause great pain for the police officer – only one man -- but it would cause great pleasure for the cabal. If they did not kill Nicolas, they would all be arrested and spend their lives in prison. This could be calculated as a net loss in pleasure and net gain in pain – and thereby justified under utilitarianism. A common criticism of utilitarianism is that it would justify slavery – as long as the overall happiness gained by the many beneficiaries of slavery was calculated as far greater than the unhappiness of the slaves. Many thought slavery was morally wrong, but they argued that the effort dismantling it would cause too problems, particularly financially. Famous utilitarian Jeremy Benthem strongly denied this to be true, but history proves the consequences of this line of thinking. The town of Sandford in Hot Fuzz functions as a kind of microcosm for a utilitarian society with all the trappings of one. The hooded figures claim to only be looking out for the greater good, but their decisions are terribly...human...meaning flawed.
There is an impracticality towards calculating the utility – or overall goodness – in real time, not to mention predictive calculations. Plus, do you really trust this guy to calculate what is best for everyone? Look at this guy. Anyway, there is a lot of historical precedent for dangerous utilitarian “greater good” policies in action, such as early American support for eugenics and forced sterilization and Japanese internment camps during World War II. These are the more hyperbolic examples, but everything from any policy that devalues people to serve what the ruling party believes is best for the majority is an example of utilitarian philosophy in action. The secret society in Sandford has a particular disdain for Irish travelers or Romani. The cabal believes that their inclusion in their village is a net loss for people in general, and under utilitarian standards, the mild discomfort and inconvenience of the wider local population takes priority over people who are in desperate need of help. In short, the challenge of applying utilitarianism into the real world is that for someone to take on the principle of “greatest happiness for the greatest number” every action an individual performs requires one to behave impartially.
AUDIO 5
This sounds sensible except that people are often not capable or willing to do that, making calls for the “greater good” a smokescreen to do something...less good. So, if Hot Fuzz – within the text of the film – rejects utilitarianism, what is it endorsing instead? Well, one could argue that it is propping up Kantianism instead. That is to say, ethics as proposed by 18th century philosopher Immanuel Kant. Unlike utilitarian philosophers, Kant believed that certain actions such as murder, theft and even lying were absolutely prohibited. Kantians ask themselves if they can rationally will that everyone act as they propose to act. If the answer is no, then they must not perform the action. They ask if their actions respect the goals of human beings rather than merely using them for their own purposes. Once again, if the answer is no, then they must not perform the action. Nicolas Angel is our Kantian hero in the film. He explicitly says that he knows the difference between right and wrong. He always follows a strict code. He cannot disobey this code.
As his ex-girlfriend says, he cannot turn it off. The film frames Nicholas as right and the neighborhood watch alliance as wrong, because in this case, their wrongness is rather plain to see, but that does not mean that Kantian ethics are infallible. Kantians believe that they must follow their code – their “laws” – even in cases where following said code would bring about more unhappiness and even harm than the alternative. Believing in the code more than the consequences can lead to harsh rule in society. One character, for example, calls Nicolas a fascist. Normative systems of ethics are challenging because they must account for the totality of existence – every conceivable possibility – and be applied by imperfect humans. Kantian ethics are particularly challenging due to their black and white nature – but that is a topic for another episode.
LIFE OF BRIAN
AUDIO 1
In the 1979 film Monty Python's Life of Brian, the eponymous and reluctant hero is born next door to Jesus Christ. As an adult, his primary concerns are the Roman occupation and getting laid. He joins the Judean People's Front [clip] Sorry, the People's Front of Judea. After some run-ins with the Romans, he blends in with a crowd by briefly pretending to be a prophet. When he leaves, people mistakenly believe he is the real thing, the coming Messiah and savior of the Jewish people. He tells his accidental apostles that they shouldn't follow anyone so blindly and that they need to think for themselves. After another encounter with the Romans, Brian is sentenced to be executed by crucifixion. The People's Front of Judea and his new girlfriend offer exactly squat in terms of help, and Brian hangs on the crucifix as the film ends. The satirical film comes into contact with theology, its relationship with philosophy and closed systems of thought, commonly and sometimes derisively called dogma.
But what is theology and how is it related to philosophy? Well, originally, “philosophy” simply meant the love of wisdom. Philosophy is the search for truth through reason. Philosophy is not belief but “justified belief.” Theology, the study of God, and philosophy are two different disciplines, but there has been a lot of historical overlap between them. In India, philosophy was discussed within the context of Hindu beliefs, for example. Since philosophy is the love of wisdom, one could argue that any form of knowledge could be classified as philosophy, but over time, greater understanding of different disciplines like physics and biology changed this perception. Anyway, the biggest difference between the discipline of philosophy and the discipline of theology is belief. Theology starts from a position of absolute certainty. A few critical facts about God are more or less taken for granted – his omnipotence, omniscience, etc. – and theologians and then tasked with analyzing and explaining the consequences of these supposed facts. In the film, there is scene in which a man is accused of blasphemy by speaking the name of God.
AUDIO 2
His defense is that he does not believe it is particularly disrespectful to say that his meal with good enough for the likes of God. People reject this. Everyone in the crowd begins their judgment of this man already under the position that God exists and that certain critical facts about him are already known. The accused does not argue that God may not exist and therefore uttering his name is no real crime. Theologians may use philosophical arguments and methods, but they are applying them to a set of presuppositions about God. This is not an accusation – only a definition – one held and popularized by Saint Thomas Aquinas. According to the Thomistic model, philosophy and theology are completely distinct because theology takes as its starting point the divine revelations contained in the Bible. The accused man is dancing around a reasoned argument: If God is omnipotent, as theologians broadly agree, he is unable to be injured by anything, including words. If God is omniscient, as theologians also broadly agree, he knows that the accused meant no offense.
So, the accused could use reasoned arguments to defend himself, but all his arguments would come from a presupposition that God definitely exists and that God has prerequisite properties. Philosophy, in contrast, begins from a position of skepticism even if it finishes at a position of certainty. That means that a philosopher could be either an atheist or a theist, but a philosopher tries to reason these arguments carefully rather than argue that theism is concluded and largely unquestionable. Brian, although proud of his Jewish religious heritage, is also a skeptic. He says people need to figure things out for themselves. Brian is an unwilling, reluctant philosopher – not a theologian as his accidental disciples believe. A theologian can be considered a philosopher as well, but not all philosophers are theologians. Theology is not a branch of philosophy so much as it is something that overlaps with philosophy. Life of Brian makes this important distinction. The men who claim to be prophets are theologians – even the boring prophet who talks about losing hammers – whereas Brian, who briefly imitates one to avoid the Roman guards, is not.
[clip]
AUDIO 3
Philosophy attempts to discover the truth from a position of skepticism whereas theology has a pattern of reaffirming or reinforcing dogma. And that's what he see in Life of Brian. The emergence of a new dogma based on almost nothing. Sometimes used exclusively as a pejorative, dogma is an official system of principles or tenets of a religion or church. Theology does not necessarily create dogma since the same theological arguments can be used to explain God in different religions, but theological conclusions are used as evidence towards justifying dogma – no matter what that dogma actually is. When I say that the word dogma is used pejoratively, that is because the word is applied to unceasing belief based on no evidence and not willing to engage rationally. Adhering to dogma means accepting that the dogma is true. Much like theology, believing in the dogma of a theistic religion is belief that begins with the conclusion. During an interview with the Monty Python troop in 1979, they professed that Life of Brian was a condemnation of “closed systems of thought.”
Example: After Brian escapes from the Romans, he is followed by a group of people who mistakenly believe he is the Messiah based on the fact that he does not finish his statement and therefore is mysterious to them. When he tells them he is not the Messiah, they claim that only the true Messiah would deny this. That is where dogma comes in. In the early stages of their new religion, Brian's unlikely followers build their faith out of whole cloth. They recover a gourd that he briefly owned but did not want, proclaim that it is a holy artifact and begin to assign greater meaning and significance to it. Upon finding his shoe, a schism emerges among the new followers. They are instantly dedicated to the emerging dogma of the religion of Brian. They are so eager to believe in Brian as the Messiah that they immediately begin fashioning the tennents of their faith – the dogma of their new faith. This exaggeration is supposed to be funny, and it is, but their closed system of thought is not unlike real world dogma.
[I've followed a few]
AUDIO 4
Dogmatic belief – meaning belief that cannot be changed or challenged – is the opposite of the aim of philosophy. This is because philosophy is an inherently social activity that thrives on the collision of viewpoints. Beliefs that cannot be altered are a philosophical and intellectual dead end. 5th century Athenian philosopher Socrates, if Plato is to be believed, wandered the marketplace haranguing passerbys in his now celebrated and eponymous style. In philosophy, those discussing and debating are called “interlocutors” – not prophets. Some early Christian thinkers like Tertullian believed that any intrusion of secular philosophy into theology was both blasphemous and wrong. This means that even if some theological claims defied reason, the believer should not waver. Other early Christian thinkers like St. Augustine of Hippo – who could be called both a theologian and philosopher, argued that secular philosophy complemented theology but only when such philosophy was grounded in a commitment to the Christian faith. Remember, theology begins with the conclusion.
In the film, Brian speaks out against belief for the sake of belief. He tells his throngs of followers that they need to think for themselves and not follow such an unwavering dogma, though the does not use that word. His followers accept this...kind of...but they take this anti-dogmatic statement as dogmatic itself and parrot it rather than live it. Everything in Brian's life is dictated by dogmatic thought – and not only religious dogma either. Dogmatic thought is not only an aspect of organized religion. It can sometimes exceed those borders. When he and his mother attend a stoning and Brian asks why she must wear a disguise, the mother says because it is written. When he joins the People's Front of Judea – not to be confused with the Judean People's Front -- he finds that they are more concerned with the rules of their organization rather than action that might advance their goals. The various revolutionary groups split with one another over minor disagreements in the dogmas of their respective groups, even though they are so similar that two groups come up with the same kidnapping plot on the same night. Belief requires debate. It must be tested. Otherwise there is no real cause for it to be believed.