Scripts and an announcement! (Patreon)
Content
Hi, everyone. Happy New Year! For my $10 tier patrons, expect your first poll to choose an episode coming very soon. For everyone, here are the scripts to the latest episodes. For new patrons, scripts often contain parts that were cut in editing. They can only be seen here.
ELEVATOR TO THE GALLOWS
AUDIO 1
Florence Carala and Julien Tavernier are having an affair and who plan to kill Florence's husband, Simon, a wealthy arms dealer and Julien's boss. Julien is an ex-Foreign Legion soldier, and using the skills he learned at war, climbs into Simon's office, murders him and sets it up to look like a suicide. It's the perfect crime except he forgot to remove the rope, goes back in and gets stuck in an elevator. Julien's car is stolen by a young couple, a small-time crook named Louis and florist named Véronique. Florence sees the car go past with Véronique leaning out of the window and assumes Julien has ran away with her instead. Louis pretends to be Julien, but this exposed with a German acquaintance, Horst. Louis, feeling threatened, shoots and kills Horst. Julien is mistakenly arrested for the death of Horst, though he is actually guilty in the case of the murder of someone else. Elevator to the Gallows has a lot of mistaken identities and misunderstandings based on these identities, but there is more going on here than farce. Maybe this is nothing, but I can't help but watch the movie from the perspective of the politics and philosophy of the screenwriter: Roger Nimier.
I'll explain. Nimier was a French author who was often associated with the literary right-wing of his country, specifically with a group called the Hussards. You might call it a reactionary group, an assembly of writers who opposed France's slide toward the political left and the emergence of existentialism, a modern philosophy that abandoned previously held traditional beliefs about the self. Existentialism posits that existence precedes essence. A personality or meaning to one's life is not given to us at birth or built over a previous model of purpose. Who we are and our purpose in life are both decided by our surroundings and by ourselves. We have a dizzying amount of freedom, which existentialist philosophers sometimes view as overwhelming. Existence is our being alive. Essence is our purpose and who we are. If existence precedes essence, the “meaning” of our lives is what we make it later on. This flies in the face of traditionally held beliefs about God and predestination. From that perspective, it is the opposite: essence precedes existence. God has put us on Earth for a specific purpose, and He being all-knowing, already knows the outcome.
AUDIO 2
Nimier rejected this idea that we design our own identities and choose the meanings of our lives and wrote a film in which such attempts are shown to be both disastrous and against the social order. Louis creates an identity for himself, not in the way that existentialist philosophers actually believe we do but in a farcical way in which to be mocked. Louis pretends to be Julien, and this lands him in serious trouble with the law. Louis is portrayed as a reckless youth, the kind of youth who had begun to embrace existentialism in France in the post-World War II era. Julien and Veronique, assuming that they will be caught, sent to prison and never see each other again, form a suicide pact. Ennui and angst is feature of existentialism. Existential angst is an overwhelming feeling arising from the experience of human freedom and responsibility. Louis and Veronique, faced with the consequences of that freedom and what it lead to, agree to kill themselves. They fail because, well, the screenwriter perhaps wants us to think that existentialists can't even kill themselves properly. For those who oppose existentialism, one of their weapons is the idea that traditional ways of viewing ourselves gives a kind of “certainty” to who we are and our purpose in life, even if that purpose is impossible to prove.
In the end, Julien and Florence are found out, as newly developed pictures prove their affair and give the police a motive for the murder of Florence's husband. For those who oppose existentialism, we are a static picture. Unchanging. Developed by someone else and with no agency. The “truth” of who we are in laid bare in the final scenes of the film, or at least the truth as the screenwriter sees it. Traditionalists and reactionaries often see and portray modern thinkers this way, unbearably gripped with ennui, but in truth, instead of fearing the inherent meaninglessness of life, existentialists and other modern thinkers embrace it and create their own meaning, sometimes through the betterment of others. Also, even though angst is inevitable, there is also a comforting liberation in knowing that once we are gone, there is nothing we can do to further alter the world in which I have exited. The task we have given ourselves is complete.
AUDIO 3
Existentialism does not posit that life is SUDDENLY without a magical purpose, only that it never had such purpose, and in realizing this, we can begin to hard work of making our lives have newly created meaning that we ourselves create instead of spirits or gods or anything like that. [sigh] So, why does Elevator to the Gallows try to make its point against existentialism and modern, emerging values? Well, because Elevator to the Gallows is a reactionary film. A reactionary movement is a right-wing political push to return to previously held beliefs and values. While garden variety social conservatism aims to keep things the way they are and not change, a reactionary aims to actively turn back the clock and remove changes and progress that are deemed harmful to the previous social order. When a tradition is called into question or some people are granted rights or the world moves forward in one way or another whether in philosophical circles or political circles, reactionary groups form to kneecap anything resembling progress.
One would think the French of all people would be uniformly opposed to anything even resembling fascism after the occupation by Nazi Germany during World War II, but a reactionary movement in France preceded this in the late 19th century under the organization Action Francaise. This movement essentially wanted France to return to monarchism, to erase much of the progress made after the French Revolution. This movement began in the late 19th century but lost some steam around World War II, perhaps due to its reactionary similarities between itself and Nazism. German historian Ernst Nolte claimed that Action francaise was not only fascist but the first fascist party. Fascism itself is inherently reactionary, in that it entails hostility toward the emergence of egalitarianism concepts like socialism and feminism, which prioritizes class or gender rather than nation. The modern form of reactionary politics in my part of the world is the alt-right, part of a neo-reactionary movement popularized on the Internet that ties into white supremacy and modern fascism. In fact, Elevator to the Gallows, though respected, was also criticized for being “fascist” at heart. This is partly due to the German tourist extolling the virtues of his people and dismissing the idea that the Germans wanted war. He is the victim of a fatal gunshot, brought on by Louis mistakenly thinking a cigar was a gun. Germany portrayed as the victim and France (or modernity in general) portrayed as the aggressor. Film critic Raymond Borde called Julien Tavernier the screenwriter's vision of a “reactionary hero.” A good observation. It's important that we can spot reactionaries – in film and in life.
DCEU 2
AUDIO 1
It wasn't long before a sequel to Man of Steel was greenlighted by Warner Bros. In fact, it became official four days BEFORE the worldwide release of Man of Steel. This fact is an indicator of future events: when it comes to the DCEU, Warner Bros always puts the cart before the horse. Man of Steel made a profit at the box office, but considering the massive budget and marketing campaign, the returns were seen as a disappointment. Man of Steel made a whopping $600 million worldwide, but calculating against its production budget and marketing budget combined, Deadline estimated that Warner Bros. Made approximately $42 million in profit from Man of Steel, which is not nothing. That's a lot to you and me, but for Warner Bros., it's the coins in the sofa cushions. They were hoping for a lot more, but with critical reaction being what it was, some moviegoers opted to stay home. I know I did. I waited until it was available for home video before even watching it for the first time. But a profit is a profit, and Warner Bros really thought they had something with Snyder and the potential for a shared cinematic universe a la Marvel Studios.
The plot of Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice goes thusly: Batman is upset with Superman for his role in the destruction of Metropolis. Superman is sad because the world still doesn't trust him. Lex Luthor is plotting to pit Superman against Batman for reasons. He manipulates Batman and Superman into a fight, which Batman kind of wins until Superman says “Martha.” Batman, Superman and Wonder Woman fight Luthor's latest creation: Doomsday, a resurrected and modified General Zod. Superman dies. Doomsday dies. Batman and Wonder Woman are sad. The end. Batman being upset with how Superman handled himself during the Metropolis 9/11 was vindication for DCEU tribalists. Social media was abuzz with “See?! Superman HAD to be careless in Metropolis to set up the next movie where Batman doesn't trust him!” OK, first of all, no fictional character “must” do anything because everything they do will always be mutable by the writers. Second, that is a gross mischaracterization of events. Zack Snyder and company did not even know Batman was going to be in the next DCEU movie. Snyder even admitted it in an interview:
AUDIO 2
“... after Man of Steel finished and we started talking about what would be in the next movie, I started subtly mentioning that it would be cool if he faced Batman...” So, let's get our timeline straight here. Nothing that happened in Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice was purposefully set up in Man of Steel. There was no plan, no direction, no momentum. According to David S. Goyer, some of the Easter eggs in Man of Steel were put there in the hopes of creating sequels, but the idea for Batman fighting Superman was not in the cards, nor was his anger about Metropolis being his motivation in the film. The fact that there is an Easter egg of a Wayne Enterprises logo on a satellite does not mean Batman was being set up in Man of Steel. There is a Booster Gold reference in Man of Steel too. I'm sorry, but the timeline does not lie. The creation of the DCEU did not begin in earnest until the casting for Batman v. Superman, meaning figuring out Batman, Aquaman, The Flash and Wonder Woman. There was no blueprint, and what could only charitably be called a plan, according to Goyer, was scrapped: “In our world, the Man of Steel world, Zack has gone on record saying that we’re implying there are other superheroes in this world. But I don’t know that they’ve come forward yet.
The idea is that Superman is the first one. There might be people helping people, but not in costumes, and that Superman comes forward and announces himself to the world. In him announcing himself, he’s the one that changes things.” Neat. But that's not what happened. Wonder Woman was revealed to be around far earlier than Superman, and Batman had apparently been punching criminals in Gotham City for a decade or so prior to Superman putting on his cape. And they were both “in costumes.” Alfred mentions how long Bruce Wayne has been at this and that he is now too old to die young. So, let's stop pretending the events of Batman v. Superman were purposefully set up in Man of Steel or that the existence of Batman v. Superman and its clarification on some matters changes how bad and ill-formed Man of Steel was. Arguments apologizing for Superman killing someone because it was necessary to set up his character's reluctance to kill Batman in the next movie do not add up because the writers and director did not have this idea set up that far ahead of time. Arguments apologizing for Superman carelessly blowing up Metropolis because it sets up Batman's motivation are equally bunk for the same reason.
AUDIO 3
You can't make Man of Steel a good movie by explaining away aspects of it through a sequel. The movie must stand on its own. Frankly, even with these explanations, it does not actually make Man of Steel make much more sense or make it a quality film. I'm just tired of bad arguments popping up in the discourse, and yeah, that's what these videos are about. The discourse more than the movies. Anyway, with Man of Steel in the rear view, let's open up wide for Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice. [It's cherry] I gave a plot synopsis, but it does not begin to truly explain what is happening in this movie or why.
[NO EMPATHY or WHY SHOULD WE CARE ABOUT SUPERMAN?]
AUDIO 1
Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice is not only a conflict between two be-spandexed superheroes with emblems on their chests and the better part of a century of source material history. It is, on paper, a conflict between two worldviews, two political positions, two complete opposites. Two beings who are diametrically opposed in every conceivable way except their mother's first name. [Why did you say that name?!] That is why the whole “Save Martha” thing is supposed to have emotional resonance. It's a “We're not so different, you and I” sort of moment. I'll get into that more later, I don't want to deviate right now. In the screenplay and therefore in the dialogue, characters reference the fact that Superman and Batman are total opposites. [Lex Luthor “Day vs. Night” speech] Even to the point of cringe-worthy meta in-jokes. [“Nobody wants to see...”] Ha. Ha. Ha. QUESTION MARK? See, on paper, the movie is telling us that Batman and Superman are polar opposites. Batman himself references this when he calls Superman a god and that gods are not brave, men are brave because they have something to risk.
He doesn't say that last part, though. The part about why men are brave and gods are not. The risk thing. That's just what I read between the lines there. The movie could have done a better job with that point, if, in fact, they were even making that point. Anyway, B is night and human and brooding and dark, and S is joyous and optimistic, and so they must V. Except...*is* Superman the opposite of Batman in the movie? Yes, in deeply rudimentary ways like their difference in power levels, but the movie never speculates on who is physically stronger because we already know Superman is. The movie tries to contrast their ideologies and their personalities. But the thing is...their personalities and ideologies are not too different. See, the whole “day vs. Night” “man vs. God” aspect of the film is undermined by the way Superman is framed by the camera, the acting choices and even by the special effects. Traditionally speaking, Batman is portrayed as a brooding figure. [The Lego Movie “no parents song”] His parents were murdered, he stalks the streets of a city with a deeply worrisome crime rate, and his villains are generally insane.
AUDIO 2
Batman is often portrayed as pessimistic or at least...troubled. [Batman TAS] Batman always looks like he's doing his best under difficult circumstances, but those circumstances rarely get any better. [Superman TAS] Superman is traditionally portrayed as the opposite. He flies above the city of tomorrow: Metropolis. He is nigh invulnerable and that may have something to do with the fact that he looks like he's emotionally handling his job better than Batman. [World's Finest TAS] Superman is beloved whereas Batman is feared. Superman sees the best in people whereas Batman is skeptical. In theory, this conflict of worldviews and ideologies makes sense, but the movie does not frame Superman as being particularly different than Batman due to the way film language works. When Superman is Superman and not Clark Kent, he rarely speaks. In fact, even when he's Clark Kent, he is often alone with his thoughts. Superman is shown in montage performing god-like feats of strength, but the Man of Steel is mostly seen in shadow or looking off mournfully in the distance or struggling with something or screaming with burning red eyes like a goddamn demon.
The screenplay tells us one thing, but the visual language tells us another. It creates a dissonance that is uncomfortable to watch and unsatisfying to see it play out. At the risk of incurring a tribalist reaction, when Captain America Civil War set up a conflict between Iron Man and Cap, they explained their worldview differences in such a way that was not only clear but compelling. It was done in such a way that audiences could easily side with either character. In Batman v. Superman, Batman is a brooding sad sack and so is Superman. Their ideologies are thus: Batman thinks Superman is dangerous, Superman thinks Batman is dangerous. It's not opposites. Neither of them are apparently correct based on how the movie frames both Superman's necessity and Batman's necessity towards the end of the story. Their differences and personalities are not pronounced enough. [World's Finest] In every other portrayal of these characters, they are, sure, but in this movie, they are not. A movie cannot rely so heavily on audience foreknowledge of characters to let us all fill in the blanks.
AUDIO 3
The main inspiration for Batman v. Superman is Frank Miller's The Dark Knight Returns. Miller was a big fan of Ayn Rand, a bad author and even worse philosopher. Miller and Rand were both drawn to depictions of heroes who are defined by ethical egoism, the belief that the best course of action is always the one that benefits oneself. Only by pursuing your own self-interest can you achieve happiness and any power or government that gets in your way should be either ignored or destroyed. In The Dark Knight Returns, Batman is this Randian hero, and Superman supposed to be the establishment. That is the ideological conflict. Yet, in Batman v. Superman, both titular characters behave this way. Superman acts unilaterally, he is in conflict with the government, etc. The only difference ideologically between Superman and Batman is that Batman knows what he wants to do and Superman is still struggling with it. Superman's ghost dad tells him that he can save someone, but someone else won't be saved, and that it is best to serve one's own interest. Superman's mother says more or less the same thing. Even when Superman does something selfless in the end, this is AFTER the fight with Batman. AFTER the point when ideological difference could have meant something. In short, Superman and Batman are not different enough for their conflict to mean much at all. It's something completely bungled by a director who also really, really loves Ayn Rand.
Now, this isn't some fanboy cry about why Superman doesn't act enough like “Superman” in this movie. That doesn't mean much to me, and I'm not interested in adding to rage about this film that is purely based on so-called ruined childhoods. It's not a helpful position when discussing the actual merits of a film. This complaint about Superman being too similar to Batman in the movie is structural. It creates an incongruity between what the screenplay is explicitly telling us and what the framing of the camera is telling us. I've heard some people claim that Superman, as a character, does not work in Man of Steel and Batman v. Superman because the world is too dark for Superman, but that ignores contrast between the conflict of the world and character in a narrative. In all Superman stories, he is a light in the darkness. The world is facing a huge challenge, and Superman steps up with a big smile on his face and conquers it. He could have been here too. Instead, he's just another corner of the shadow. He is as bleak as everything else in the film, including but not limited to Batman. But his similarity to The Dark Knight is not the only reason why Superman does not work in the DCEU.
AUDIO 4
In order to understand why Superman does not function well as character with whom the audience can emphasize, we need to first understand how characters work in a screenplay, and since Superman shares top billing with Batman, we will consider him on equal footing here, even though he is in slightly less of the film than his counterpart. When a point of view character or protagonist of a film makes choices, it reveals to the audience things about the character. The choices also affect the plot directly and help the audience empathize with the character. A character has a goal and different choices about how to reach that goal. One path might be more dangerous or one path might be morally questionable. It is in these choices that we learn about the character, and it is also in these choices that the character follows their arc. Pop quiz: Throughout the film, what would you say is Superman's goal? ... It's not to fight Batman because he doesn't even consider Batman a threat to himself until halfway through the fight which is more than two-thirds of the way through the film. The audience might see that as his goal because they read the damn title to the damn movie, but the character, Superman, does not.
Is it to expose Batman through journalism? Maybe – I mean, he does try this – but it seems secondary to his daily concerns. For Batman, facing off against Superman is his goal. For Superman, it's his b-plot and he mostly undertakes it as Clark Kent. Superman has more pushback from Perry White than Batman. Is Superman's goal to prove to the world that he can be trusted? Maybe, but his obstacle is muddied here. Who is opposing him? Sure, Lex Luthor, but Superman doesn't even know that until very late in the movie. If a character doesn't know what his obstacles are or what his goal is, he cannot be written to make choices to overcome said obstacles or to achieve said goals. Because Superman's goal throughout the movie is unclear, his choices become less important, and we learn less about his character. He is an action figure. Not a character. He makes few decisions. He is a passive character. Sure, this is more Batman's movie than Superman's movie, but this passivity was also true in Man of Steel, which WAS Superman's movie! Things happen...around Superman. He is forced into a situation in which he must fight Batman due to the machinations of Lex Luthor. He doesn't DECIDE to fight Batman in the traditional sense. He is in an impossible scenario in which not acting is not an option. Ditto for his fight with Doomsday. Ditto for a lot of Man of Steel.
AUDIO 5
This ALMOST ties into something his mother says about being the world's champion or not, but once Doomsday is created, Superman has no choice. Again, things happen AROUND Superman, and he only acts when he has no choice, making his decision meaingless and therefore not possible for the audience to empathize with him. Superman does not make choices so much as he makes “reactions” -- and here is the difference. Lex Luthor pushes Lois Lane off a building. Superman reacts by saving her. This wasn't a big, monumental choice Superman had to make. He did not have to weigh the rightness or wrongness of this action or consider whether or not this would advance him towards his goal. It would make no sense for Superman to decide not to save Lois Lane because there is no benefit towards letting her die. In the 1978 Superman movie, the protagonist must decide between the wishes of his two fathers. One says that Superman must never interfere with the course of human events, and the other says that Superman has these powers for a reason and absolutely should. It's an internal struggle between the wishes of his two fathers. The film shows us this quite well beforehand.
We see Jor-El say this to a young Superman, and we see Jonathan Kent give his own contradictory advice as well. When faced with the death of Lois Lane, he sees the faces of his fathers in the clouds to remind the audience of their contrasting words of wisdom, and then Superman makes his choice. People make fun of this scene because of the rotation of the Earth scene, but from a storytelling standpoint, it's actually quite good, shows a choice, reveals more about Superman's character and advances the plot. In Batman v. Superman, when Supes needs to save Lois Lane, he just...does. When he needs to save his mother, he makes a choice of SORTS, but this was thrust upon him and had absolutely no build-up, unlike the long build-up of contrasting worldviews in the Christopher Reeve Superman. These reactions reveal very little if anything about his character. The so-called choices Superman makes throughout the movie do not truly affect the plot. Superman chooses to investigate Batman as Clark Kent for the Daily Planet instead of covering sports like Perry White said, but this has zero consequences. These are not two choices with lots of positives and negatives.
AUDIO 6
That's what makes a good choice and helps develop a good character. Nobody expected Superman to to tell Perry White “OK, guy who is no threat to me. I guess I like football more than justice now.” Also, again, there are no consequences to this. When Superman chooses to stand in front of the Batmobile and politely ask Batman to stop Batmanning all over Gotham City, there are no consequences. This is not the action that makes Batman hate Superman. He hated him since Metropolis 9/11. It also is not the catalyst towards Batman's decision to straight up murder Superman. That came in the form of Lex Luthor's manipulations. Nothing Superman does advances the plot or reveals things about his character. He is a passenger in his own journey. Nothing Superman does until the showdown means anything to the plot. A choice in a movie is a decision based on two valid options when faced with an obstacle in an attempt to reach a goal. The only thing in the entire movie that meets this basic criteria for a movie character we're supposed to root for is when after the superhero throwdown, Superman decides to let Batman save Martha Kent instead of saving her himself because even though his mother is his priority, Superman is needed elsewhere, and there are some thing only Superman can do that Batman cannot.
It is, quite possibly, the only major decision that advances the plot and reveals something about Superman's character, but it is handled so poorly and immediately after the terrible “Save Martha!” scene that it goes largely unnoticed by the audience. Superman spends all of three seconds considering his choices, and it feels more like Batman convincing Superman rather than good ol' Kal-El deciding for himself. In fact, it reveals more about Batman than Superman, and it expands upon Batman's character far more than that of Superman. This really needed to be Superman's moment – anything to make him feel like a fleshed-out character and not a manniquin, but the scene is just...so...poorly done. So, if you watched Batman v. Superman and you were wondering why you felt so cold towards the big blue boy scout, this is why. A few screenplay issues and some serious framing problems that make endearing the character to the audience challenging, if not impossible.
[LEX LUTHOR: OUR MAIN CHARACTER AND HIS MOTIVATIONS]
AUDIO 1
Who is the protagonist of Batman v. Superman? Is it Batman or is it Superman? Or is it V? [V for Vendetta] The fact that we can even ask this is a problem in and of itself. A protagonist in a screenplay is our point of view character. The character with whom the audience generally spends the most time and with whom we should empathize. We spend more time with Batman than Superman, but so much of the story revolves around Superman, his place in the world and his complete lack of ability to make decisions. Also, as a follow-up to Man of Steel, one assumes he is as important or more important than anyone else in the film. Yet, things...happen TO Superman more than Superman makes things happen. Batman feels closer to being a protagonist. We spend time with him not only in the bat cave and such but also in his dreams. We follow his journey. I mean, he gets top billing, right? He's the protagonist, but he is a weak protagonist due to how much of the movie is about everything non-Batman. I'm talkin' Superman being a grouchy-puss, Lex Luthor being Max Landis, Lois Lane's investigation and so forth. So, OK, is this an ensemble film like X-Men or...*sighs*...Clue?
In the first X-Men film, we have a lot of good guys characters, but our point of view character is definitely Wolverine. We see things from his perspective for the most part, and when Professor X explains the rules of the world and his school and all that, he is speaking to Wolverine. That's screenwriting 101, really. Our protagonist is our POV. Things that are explained to the protagonist are really being explained to us. Obi-Wan Kenobi doesn't just tell Luke Skywalker about The Force, Darth Vader, the Empire, the Jedi and everything else. Obi-Wan is telling us through Luke because our young padawan is our point of view into this world. In The Last Starfighter when Alex is taken into space, the aliens explain what is going on to him so we that we, too, can figure out what's happening. He's a fish out of water, but so are we – the audience. Yeah, this is pretty basic stuff, but that's the thing. The protagonist isn't just the “main character” – the protagonist is our perspective. In Mad Max: Fury Road, even though this is clearly Furiosa's story and she has way more on the line, Max is the protagonist because we are following his journey and seeing the events unfold largely from his perspective. Furiosa: main character. Max: protagonist. It's rare, but it can happen.
AUDIO 2
The reason I bring all this up is because while Batman is the closest this meandering film has to a protagonist, this doesn't feel entirely like Batman's story. He isn't the driving force behind much of anything that happens. Lex Luthor, the antagonist, makes all the decisions that lead up to Batman vee'ing the heck of Superman. He vees him good! But the most active character in the movie is Luthor. He's setting up the fight. He's manipulating both of him. He's making decisions about kryptonite and Zod. Superman is just along for the ride, and Batman is a pawn until the fight is over. I'm not sure I want to definitively make the argument that Luthor is absolutely the main character of Batman v. Superman, but my point is that a reasonable argument CAN be made that he is the main character. And with this in mind, with the antagonist being even more critical and significant in this film than most any other film with a proper antagonist, what Luthor does and why he does it becomes that much more important to the structure and the plausibility of this film. In other words, because Luthor is so important to this story, if what he does makes no sense, then there is no story. Spoiler alert for the end of this section: What he does makes no sense, so there is no story.
Alright, so Lex Luthor manipulates both Batman and Superman into a fight to the death by sending letters to Batman and convincing Superman that Batman is bad news by hiring men to kill prisoners who Batman brands in jail. That second thing is just guesswork if you only watched the theatrical cut. Only the extended cut makes that clear, which, I'm sorry, is a failing since that's what most people saw. Luthor hurts Superman's public image by making a slaughter in Nairobi appear to be Superman's fault. One of the “terrorists” was actually someone on Luthor's payroll, except for the world to believe this, they would have to believe Superman used a GUN to mow down these men. Even with Superman as a fairly new player in the world, nobody in their right mind would believe the Man of Steel would need to use a gun to kill anyone. Dude can nuke the world with his eyeballs. So, this is already falling apart. Luthor and his wheelchair-bound buddy set off a bomb in the Capitol, which is also meant to make Superman look bad, but nobody would think Superman would use a bomb for the same reason he would not use bullets, and his heroic rescue of the survivors – if anything – helped his public image.
AUDIO 3
This epic costume throwdown would make sense if Luthor had beef with both heroes, but in this movie, Luthor has zero history with both of them. It might also make sense if he was using this to distract them while he performed some big robbery or caper, but that does not happen either. This fight is his endgame, making his goals unclear. As convoluted as all of that is – with so many moving parts that fit together and worked out only by a combination of dumb luck and divine intervention – it doesn't actually explain anything about Luthor's motivation. What was he planning to do and why? Remember, if he's the main character, this needs to make perfect sense. Well, he wanted Superman to fight Batman – to the death – which means he wanted one of the two outcomes. But if he wanted Superman to die, he had the kryptonite, and he could have simply done that himself. Luthor is presumably smart, and a green bullet to the head would have done the trick. So, that's out. Luthor could have wanted Batman to die, but he had no real beef with Batman. So, that's out. OK, so, maybe Luthor did this for philosophical reasons. He references the problem of evil.
If God is all good, he cannot be all powerful or else he would eliminate all evil. If God is all powerful, he cannot be all good because he could, if he wanted, eliminate all evil. It's a conundrum that is thousands of years old. In creating the super fight, either Superman would kill Batman, proving Superman or “God” is not all good, or Batman would kill Superman, proving God is not all-powerful. That's kinda clever...but nobody else knows about this little philosophy experiment. See, this makes thematic sense but not narrative sense. I cannot accept that this is all about Luthor making a point...to himself. Even if I could, because I like me some philosophy, Luthor immediately undermines this possible motivation after the battle is inconclusive by introducing Doomsday, a creature specifically made to kill Superman. He made Doomsday before the fight, which means he wanted this monster to kill Superman regardless of the outcome of the superhero steel cage match. That brings us back to Luthor just wanting to kill Superman, but again, why? OK, maybe because Luthor believes Superman is a threat to the world. Fine. Alright. Except by introducing Doomsday, a dangerous monster who cannot be controlled and whose D&D character alignment is definitely Chaotic Evil, this seems like a lateral move if the plan is to protect the world. And again, he doesn't need Doomsday to kill Superman. He has kryptonite. NONE OF THIS MAKES SENSE.
AUDIO 4
Luthor has no motivation, or at least no clear motivation. He's the only character in the film that really makes anything happen, and there is no solid, concrete sense of why any of this is happening. … Let's talk about misconceptions surrounding plot holes, plot contrivances and criticism of movie plots. Because of everything I mentioned just now, Batman v. Superman has some of the most obvious and embarrassing plot contrivances seen in recent films. There is a difference between the criticism of a plot hole and the criticism of a contrivance – not to mention criticism of minor details – more commonly known as nitpicking. Misunderstanding these distinctions have hurt The Discourse because they have become lost in a sea of bad YouTube videos and ignorant conflation of inconsequential details and true plot holes. So, let's nail down some definitions. A plot hole is an error or gap in the narrative that violates the internal logic of the film, makes the events IMPOSSIBLE and the story untenable. The internal logic of the film is that Krypton exists and Superman is the last son of Krypton. So, as impossible as that is in the real world, having impossible characters in this film does not violate its internal logic.
I mention that because whenever someone mentions a plot contrivance in a film, someone jumps out from their seat of ignorance to say “Oh, you're looking for LOGIC in a movie with aliens and superpowers! Ha!” and then they hiss and slither down a drain pipe. Whether or not Batman v. Superman has plot holes is debatable, but it definitely has plot contrivances, meaning plot points that seem nearly but not entirely impossible within the framework of the film's internal logic. A plot contrivance, which is a lesser problem than a true hole, is a weak, artificial point in the narrative that is created to serve the larger plot or make improbable events happen. All that Luthor plan stuff? Plot contrivances. The idea that it would work out so perfectly for the benefit of Luthor but really the benefit of the screenwriter begs belief, and it makes the audience collectively rolls its eyes. It's just that people keep claiming any minor issue counts as a plot hole. Criticism of plot holes and contrivances is markedly different from nitpicking details that do not change the flow of the story. When I say Luthor's plan is preposterous and therefore, as possibly the main character, the whole movie is preposterous, it is not...nitpicking.
AUDIO 5
Nitpicking is about minor details that have little if anything to do with servicing the main narrative. Luthor's plan? That's the narrative. Luthor himself? That's the main guy. The person who drives the plot. Unfortunately, nitpicking has become confused with legitimate film criticism and legitimate film criticism has become confused with nitpicking. When critics reference these obvious screenwriting errors and contrivances, the DCEU tribalists say that the critics are nitpicking, and when the bad YouTube fanboys talk up the easter eggs of the plot, the same tribalists consider that more legitimate because it comes from the “real fans” who notice such things. It's a Bizarro world of discourse.
[THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ADULT AND MATURE]
AUDIO 1
In a 2016 interview, Deborah Snyder, long-time producer of Zack Snyder's films and also his wife, explained the negative reaction to Man of Steel and Batman v. Superman thusly: “The main thing we learned, I think: People don’t like to see their heroes deconstructed.” The obliviousness of this quote is staggering. The “main thing” was that people didn't want to see heroes deconstructed? That is demonstrably false both in terms of whether that is true in and of itself but also in the broader sense of that being the “main problem” with the DCEU movies. By “deconstructing” superheroes, Deborah Snyder is referring to post-modernism – an attitude towards skepticism and meta-narratives. Deconstruction of fiction is a critique of the relationship between text and meaning. Deconstructing superheroes has been common for superhero fans for quite a while. One of the most celebrated comic books of all time was Watchman, a movie that Zack Snyder also adapted. He must be, you know, aware of it? Everything from The Authority to The Boys deconstruct the concept of popular superheroes.
Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight Trilogy deconstructed the Batman mythos and asked whether or not the world needed a Batman. And if memory serves, those films were incredibly popular at the box office and among critics. Ditto for the first Kick-Ass movie. Watchmen had mixed but mostly positive reviews according to good ol' Rotten Tomatoes, and after the release of Snyder's cut instead of the studio-mandated shortened version, fans and critics looked at it much more favorably. So, if we look at movies in which “deconstruction” is the common denominator, we find that many of them receive broad critical acclaim and excellent box office receipts. This is solid evidence that Deborah Snyder's belief about the problem with the first two DCEU films is bunk. It does not add up at all. There is too much history within both film adaptations and the source material of comic books deconstructing superheroes and being successful. So, now that we are done blaming the audience, we can once again focus on why these movies are garbage.
AUDIO 2
Zack Snyder once said “Yeah, I mean, I think I’m obsessed with tone in the movies. Tone has always been the main thing that I go after with a movie, and I really wanted the tone of the three movies to be different chapters and not be the same note that you strike like, 'Okay, there’s this again.'” Alright, then. Tone is big with him. So, let's talk about that tone and the audience reaction to the tone. As I said in the previous part, the tone of Man of Steel and Batman v. Superman is bleak and unpleasant and a real slog to get through with no real sense of humor. When tribalists defend these movies, its awful and much-maligned tone is used as a positive rather than a negative, and I believe this misconception and misunderstanding of the tone has a lot to do with misunderstanding the difference between [text] “adult” and “mature.” These words are used interchangably – indeed, they are synonyms – but for our purposes today, the distinction I am making is this: When I say that a movie is “adult,” I mean that it is aimed towards adults. It's a rated R movie or it is not meant to be for children. That covers everything from Pulp Fiction to Basic Instinct.
And indeed, the extended cut – what Snyder wanted all along – is rated R. Only the theatrical cut was rated PG-13, and if ever there were such thing as a “hard PG-13,” it is the theatrical cut of Batman v. Superman. Now, when I say a movie is “mature,” I mean that it is for mature audiences, but adult audiences may not necessarily be truly mature. Ditto for a film. Example: If your awful friend tells a racist joke, it is certainly an adult joke and not meant to consumption by children, but it is also not what one would call “mature” because the attitude surrounding the racist joke is childish and undeveloped. A child could tell the same joke or even conceive of the same joke. One defintion of “mature” is “fully-grown and developed.” Back to the tribalists, they tout the grown-up style of Man of Steel and Batman v. Superman as a strength. Man of Steel deals with big, weighty issues about Jesus Christ. Batman v. Superman doubles down on this, and much like your friend from high school who just came back from Bible Camp, simply will not stop talking about God. So, this all seems pretty heavy and adult and mature, right?
AUDIO 3
Except that these films handle these topics with all the grace of the person telling the dirty joke. It's not entirely for kids, but it is not a fully-grown, developed idea. It is not...mature. It is adult, at times, I [dat ass black box] mean Batman v. Superman has nudity and bath tub love scenes and people's heads kerploding, but for all the reasons already stated, it is not mature. The difference in tone between the DCEU and MCU movies is something that tribalists bring up a lot. This is part of that nauseating tribalism. MCU movies have a fair bit of humor in them. Even the most serious MCU films like Captain America: The Winter Solider have some jokes, [Ragnarok] and some have a lot more than others. Because Marvel movies crack a smile and DC movies rarely do, tribalist fans use this as fabricated evidence to draw a comparison, that being Marvel movies are for babies and DC movies must be for graduate students working on their MFA. But since Man of Steel and Batman v. Superman are simply more “adult” and not more “mature,” the argument falls a bit flat. Adult and mature are not the same. Friday the 13th Part VIII: Jason Takes Manhattan is a film for adults. It is not, however, what one might call a “mature” film.
Furthermore, the theatrical ratings of all DCEU have been PG-13, just like MCU movies. Its greater “adultness” is marginal at best, right? The hostility among the tribalists towards humor seems more tribalist than anything. I imagine if you asked the same people about different, non-superhero movies, they would speak lovingly of comedies they enjoy and comedians they admire. The distinction between the grim self-seriousness of the DCEU and comparatively goofy tone of the MCU is a way to draw a line in the sand for reasons of tribalism rather than to provide genuine criticism. As for humor itself, the idea that movies about people dressed in spandex suits should not have humor in them is kind of laughable itself, but the advocacy for having humor in action movies is more a matter of audience engagement. The audience needs a break. If something is...the same thing on screen the whole time...in the same setting or with the exact same tone, it cannot create any ebb and flow. Aladdin is a comedy musical with a goofy-ass genie, but without stakes and quiet moments, we will not care about how it all concludes.
AUDIO 4
A Nightmare on Elm Street is a horror movie, but if every scene had a jump scare, then the scares would lose their bite. Good screenwriters know how to construct a story with a variety of emotions that the audience should have. Humor is humanizing. It's not just there for a quick chuckle. It's an effective way to make an otherwise larger than life figure seem grounded. So, in a movie like Iron Man, the ebb and flow of humor, action and deadly serious moments create a character that the audience roots for with stakes that the audience cares about. In Batman v. Superman, the tone is so grim that the characters don't feel relatable. [Dan Turpin dies] Some people think Superman has a relatability problem, but other adaptations of the character made the Kryptonian quite...human. In Batman v. Superman, we don't get much insight into who he is because he is always brooding and staring off into the distance. He is a grim figure more than a character. Ditto for Batman, which was not as unexpected but is nonetheless unwelcome. And yet, people try desparately to defend this tone.
Batfleck himself said “It was a huge hit movie. More people went to see that than any movie I’ve ever made in my career. It was the biggest hit of my career. And then it had a lot editorial negativity. ... It was interesting, that movie, because it was judged not necessarily on execution so much as on its tone. People seemed to want to have a lighter tone to the movie, and I thought that was interesting because it’s subjective. Tone is not a qualitative thing. It’s subjective, right? Some tones resonate with me that might not with you. And the tone of the movie was really parallel to the Frank Miller book [The Dark Knight Returns], which I liked and thought was great.” At the risk of criticizing an Oscar winning filmmaker here, Ben Affleck is making a mistake, and I don't just mean equating the box office returns and how great this was for his career for the actual quality of the film. He is claiming that critics were harsh on its tone and not the execution of the film, but the TONE is PART of the EXECUTION. The tone, for all the reasons I just mentioned, does not work well. It's not just that it's dark.
AUDIO 5
It's that it is unceasingly dark and provides no shelter from the storm of its grimness. It's a bad screenplay. I should mention that the incredibly rare attempts within Batman v. Superman to have humor fall flat. Jesse Eisenberg's manic performance as Lex Luthor is grating rather than comical. The urine...thing...was disgusting. And Batman saying “I thought she was with you.” is a trailer line that does not work within the narrative of the film. Batman, dude, she is with YOU. And you know that. You were aware of her existence, and Superman was not. [cut music] ... What the f*ck are you talking about? And why do I have to listen to Junkie XL during this scene when [Meatloaf] there are better options out there? So, the urine and the uncomfortable zaniness of Luthor provide no solace from the onslaught of the grimdark. In fact, these jokes are themselves grim and unpleasant. So, the ONE THING that a movie can use to provide shelter from an overly dark tone – comedy -- is ITSELF dark in tone. This. Movie. Sucks.
[RED] HAVE YOU HEARD THE GOOD NEWS?
AUDIO 1
We're going to do some jumping around among multiple movies here because we simply cannot discuss the topic of Superman as a parallel to Jesus Christ without showing how it shows up throughout the DCEU. Superman was originally written with Mosaic features due to his Jewish creators, but his later Christianization is what people have come to understand. Superman, like Jesus, his sent from the heavens by his true father to be raised by an adopted father. In Man of Steel, the unusual birth of Christ is paralleled further, as his mother gives birth to him in a way that is strange for Krypton – it is a natural birth. Superman is both a citizen of Earth and a stranger to its people. He has powers unlike anyone else, and the mere fact of who he is proves to be dangerous. His father tells him that he is Earth's savior. Superman's very blood has a royal lineage – the blood of Christ – and serves as the component of the survival of a species. When questioned about Superman, Peter [text: Pete Ross] denies him. Superman is able to communicate with his father despite being ethereal and not on Earth. The villain's main crime is betrayal. He cannot be trusted. [Church] After careful reflection and prayer, [Hovering above military] Superman agrees to sacrifice himself [Crucifix pose] because that's his mission on Earth.
Superman mentions he is thirty-three years old, the same age as Christ when he died, and so on and so forth. None of this is subtle, but believe or not, that is not the problem. Put in a pin in that. We'll come back to it. Batman v. Superman continues this rather than truly expands upon it. It's just more about humankind's relationship with God. It stumbles through philosophy, broaches subjects but does not have the intelligence to resolve them and references far wiser luminaries and intellectuals with no interest or ability to meet their standards. Lex Luthor refers to Superman as God but also a Devil. This is not a one-to-one allegory because Luthor also calls Doomsday the Devil, and it's just terribly muddled. The DCEU's obsession with referencing religion has nothing to do with reverence and everything to do with pomposity. Luthor's mistrust of God or perhaps disbelief in God is brought up again when he references Prometheus. Luthor's actual theistic beliefs are shockingly vague for a series of films that are otherwise quite blunt. Is Luthor an atheist? A misotheist? This would be an important question to answer, but the film does not bother. Superman is nearly murdered with a spear, a reference to the spear held by Longinus, the Biblical artifact that allegedly pierced the side of Christ to see if he was still alive.
AUDIO 2
The spear comes into play again with Doomsday. In Justice League, Superman is resurrected, thus completing both his arc and the story of Jesus Christ. … When I was younger, I thought that the best way to engage with a topic in a film was to be subtle. This means allusions to Christ but really anything else. I'm not really a film critic, but even I know that the word "subtlety" ends up being part of a film critic's vocabulary, a way to differentiate between great works and lesser works. That was my go-to. Trying to explain what is and is not handled properly to make a good allegory or message film. I still believe that can be important, but I have come to realize that subtlety is a tool – not a goal. A film need not be subtle to make a good point or to be “good” in general. When people talk about Superman as a Christ figure in Man of Steel and Batman v. Superman, they harp on how obvious it is – this scene with the stained-glass window in particular -- as if that is the film's greatest crime. I freely admit to taking issue with this as well back in 2013 when I first saw Man of Steel. We don't accept Superman as the Christ figure in Man of Steel and Batman v. Superman – nor do we accept the latter's onslaught of other spiritual references -- and we cite the lack of subtelty as the primary cause. But something about that does not fully add up.
One of my favorite films is Ashes and Diamonds, a classic 1958 Polish film directed by Anrzej Wajda – a name I have almost certainly butchered. The protagonist is given certain Christ qualities, and it is not always subtle. In the film's most famous scene, an upside down crucifix waves in front of the camera. At least the stained-glass window is in the background and not the foreground. Yet, Ashes and Diamonds is widely considered a great film. So, what is the difference? Klaatu from The Day the Earth Stood Still takes the human surname "Carpenter" and comes from the sky to save humanity. It is not remotely subtle that he is a Christ figure, but people love this aspect of the film as well as the film in general. The Matrix is so explicit about who Neo is meant to represent, but people sure did love this movie. If a complete lack of subtlety does NOT hinder the Christ figure aspect of THESE films, then why does it feel so awful and awkward in Man of Steel? I've come to believe that the Christ figure working or not working for the audience does NOT ALWAYS have to do with Christ figure himself and more to do with the rest of the film. If the rest of the film is good, then we can accept the Christ figure as part of it. If the rest of the film is, well, Man of Steel, then we can't.
AUDIO 3
This is NOT arbitrary, and it's NOT a case of hating a movie and then deciding this one aspect is also bad. Instead, it's a case of earning the Christ figure. When a movie is structurally bad for all the reasons given earlier but casts its protagonist as Jesus Christ, then we feel that this film has not earned this grandiosity. People sometimes misuse the word "pretentious" as meaning "overly fancy" or "too high-brow" or “elitist” but that is not actually true. [text] "Pretentious" simply means affecting greater importance to something that is not. In other words, for our purposes, a dumb film trying and failing to be smart is, by definiton, pretentious. [2001] A good, clever movie with good, clever ideas [The Seventh Seal] is NOT pretentious by very definiution because it has achieved its importance. Man of Steel is a "pretentious" movie because it is something that is of poor quality that the artist clearly believes is more significant than it is. The Christ figure and other spiritual references do not work in the DCEU's three films starring Superman, but it has nothing to do with a lack of subtlety. The Christ figure doesn't work because the three movies in the DCEU that have Superman have greater structural problems UNrelated to their spirituality. I've said this before in other videos, but it bears repeating: A movie with a good message needs to be a good movie first.
When DCEU tribalists use the film's universe's philosophical pomposity as defense of its importance and quality, they are actually unwittingly spotlighting one of the film series' greatest flaws. It's not that people who dislike the DCEU don't “get it” -- it's that they do get it, and what they have, in fact, “gotten” is a series of bad movies that have not earned their Christ allegory. Jesus' appearances in the DCEU films do not elevate the quality. They broadcast how everything AROUND these appearances and references are not strong enough to hold up the DCEU's genuine pretentiousness. Jesus can carry a crucifix, but he cannot carry Man of Steel.
[DEFENDING THE INDEFENSIBLE]
AUDIO 1
Nicholas Winding Refn once said that in all of his movies, there is one scene that is its heart. The one scene that connects everything together, that shows the audience what the movie really is, the movie's point. In Drive, it's when the driver kisses his girlfriend, the lighting changes and he murder-stomps a dude into modern art. In Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice, the scene is undoubtedly and inarguably the “Save Martha!” moment at the climax of the much-anticipated and promised battle between the two superheroes. After a bloody conflict, Batman appears to have won. He cuts Superman across the face – fulfilling the “Do you bleed? You will!” prediction – and then Superman says “Save Martha!” Batman, incredulous, says “Why did you say that name?!” and then Lois Lane appears just in the nick of time to tell Batman that “Martha” is Superman's mother's name. Martha Kent has been kidnapped. Martha is also Batman's deceased mother's name. Batman drops his kryptonite lance, having learned a valuable lesson about something. You know, maybe the real Martha, is the friends we made along the way.
Fans have been quick to mock this scene, and the tribalists are just as quick to defend it. “Save Martha” is the most ridiculous, and frankly, memeable scene in the film, and the fact that it is its emotional climax – its heart – and said with such weight and sincerity makes it that much more ludicrous and mockable. I've thought about this scene, honestly, far too much over the past couple years. I love a big emotional scene. I cry at movies. And not just, you know, tragic film, but, like, Star Wars. I wear my heart of my sleeve, and if you cried during the “Save Martha” scene in Batman v. Superman, I am not going to mock you for that. Get your cry on. It's healthy. However, our emotional reactions to things are different from our intellectual defenses of them, and even though I want to be able to defend this scene, I simply can't. Believe me, I've tried. I've scoured the Internet and found defenses from others. One is that critics and “haters” are fixating on this scene because the rest of the movie “greeeeaaat” and this is the only goofy part of the movie. OK, first of all, I reject the premise that the rest of the movie is great. Second, there are lots of goofy parts in this movie. [It's cherry.]
AUDIO 2
The reason critics and such fixate on “Save Martha” is because it's the aforementioned emotional core of the movie. Another defense of this scene is that this isn't about Batman learning that mild coincidence that he and Superman's mother both have the same first name. It's about recognizing that Superman has parents in general, and that makes the Kryptonian more “human” in Batman's eyes. People love him and not just because he saves others with his superheroes. He has a family. Batman never considered this because he was so focused on building an Iron Man suit and murdering an alien, right? Except IMMEDIATELY before the “Save Martha” thing, Batman says [clip of “Your parents...” show text] This is RIGHT. BEFORE. IT HAPPENS. Batman talks about Superman's parents immediately before “discovering” he has parents. He has considered Superman's familial ties. So, that defense is bonkers. One odd part about this scene is that Superman is saying “Save MARTHA” instead of “Save MY MOTHER.” See, “Save Martha,” narratively, makes no sense to say because Batman cannot conclude who “Martha” is without context. He would need that to, you know, save her?
Structurally, Superman needs to say “Martha” instead of “Mother” in the script because that will trigger Batman's memory of his own mother also named Martha, but Superman logically saying her name instead at this point is a plot contrivance. A defense of him saying this that happened in my own comments section years ago was that someone was actually saying “Martha Kent” but every time Superman tried to say “Kent” it came out “KKKK” because he was being choked. NOPE. Sorry, this defense is disproved simply by watching the movie with the official subtitles on. Superman is not desperately trying to say “Kent.” He is just saying “Martha.” The weird thing about this is that the cast and crew really thinks they nailed it. [Batman v. Superman martha scene explained by filmmakers, “I don't think Batman even realizes...until he realizes he has a mother”] NO! I'm sorry, Martha Kent actress, but Batman talks about Superman's mother right before, and I'm sorry, “other guy?” but that is not enough. The scene is really, really, forced. Another defense is not narrative but thematic. Batman needs this scene to respect the sanctity of all life because everyone has a mother, everyone has people who care about them, and that murdering people – super or otherwise – is wrong.
AUDIO 3
Except Batman's next mission is to “save Martha” by employing lethal methods against a dozen or so henchmen. So, when those who mock the scene say “It looks like Batman only spared Superman because their mothers have the same first name,” it's because that's genuinely what it looks like because the intent of the scene is obscured by lines that immediately preceded it and ruined by its aftermath. Speaking of which, Batman sure does kill a lot of people in this movie, right? This is the next indefensible argument put forth by the tribalists, that Batman doesn't actually kill anyone in the movie. This popped up so many times in my own comments section and certainly elsewhere. Whether or not Batman should kill criminals is topic for another video. I will save that for my worst video. But the idea that Batman simply did not kill anyone in this movie is not logically defensible. [1:01:18] [Intermission music] Here, Batman rams into a car with a driver instead, it spins, he uses a grappling hook and then throws it again. Survival would be miraculous but not impossible, so, fair enough. [1:01:43] But right after, Batman shreds this other vehicle with a driver and a gunner.
It rolls over and then explodes into cinders. Everyone in that vehicle is definitely dead. Whether one believes this is justified or not, Batman definitely killed those people. [1:02:49] Batman then launches his Batmobile which severs both this vehicle and this individual inside. It is not possible that he survived. [1:50:16] Following the Save Martha scene that allegedly restored Batman's belief in the sanctity of life, Batman shoots a few men outside a warehouse. They die horribly in a fireball. [1:52:00] Some of the injuries in this battle are difficult to ascertain or confirm as kills, but these two men definitely die by grenade. [1:55:30] Shortly thereafter, Batman incinerates a couple others with a propane tank. Those who were stabbed or brutalized in other ways might have made it through, however unlikely that may seem, but many of the nameless henchmen are inarguably killed at the hands of Batman. Or bullets and explosions of Batman. It is indefensible that Batman walks away from this film with no blood on his hands. Again, if you believe all these deaths were 100% necessary and unavoidable, that's...troubling but another topic.
AUDIO 4
However, defending indefensible scenes in a symptom of the aforementioned tribalism. Many of the Marvel faithful who point out the obviousness of the deaths in DC movies would be quick to hand-wave them away if they occurred in their chosen films. It's intellectually dishonest. A film must be approached as it exists and not as we would prefer it to exist. When fans don't do this, it poisons the discourse. An honest interpretation of deaths in MCU and DCEU movies is that so many superheroes are pretty OK with killing people. Iron Man wastes men in firey explosions and punch catapaults them in ways that cannot possibly result in non-lethal injuries. The Falcon incinerates people with missiles. And so forth. Superman pushes a man through several walls with such force and such speed that it would be quite literally impossible for him to survive. And Batman's kill count is definitely even higher and even more obvious. Acknowledging the text of the film is the first step towards criticizing and debating it. By willful obfuscation of the text of the film, nothing can ever be said of it – and while that might appear to be the goal of its defenders – willful obfuscation of the text of the film also makes genuine and honest POSITIVE criticism difficult as well.
You can't talk about a movie when the discourse surrounding a movie denies what the movie is. ... When Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice debuted, it received a thrashing from film critics. 27% on Rotten Tomatoes, various “Worst of the year” lists and Ben Affleck memes. [Hello darkness] But to the DCEU tribalists, this was simply a massive conspiracy to discredit their nascent cinematic universe. Because that is what tribalism does to the discourse. Nobody can recognize red flags with rose-colored glasses on. But Man of Steel and Batman v. Superman were just the beginning of this attitude. The entrenchment of this tribalism didn't become so pronounced until it was clear that the DCEU was not improving. A couple false starts? Sure, these things happen. But then came...Suicide Squad and any denial of the downsides of the DC Extended Universe became that much harder to justify.