Updates and scripts! (Patreon)
Content
So. I reached the next Patreon goal. Expect the SNL/Neoliberalism mega-video to debut in about a year.
Also, thank you to my $10+ patrons who voted in the first poll. The results are in, and yes, I will be subjecting myself to making an episode on The Last Jedi before the year is out.
That bit of housecleaning out of the way, here are the scripts to the most recent videos. The DCEU scripts have A LOT of material that was cut in editing. If you notice some extra content, that is why.
DCEU 3
[A TROUBLED PRODUCTION]
AUDIO 1
Welcome back. If you have never seen Suicide Squad, let's get the synopsis out of the way. Amanda Waller, a high-up government agent, sets up Task Force X: a group of criminals assembled to fight metahumans. One member of Task Force X, Enchantress, goes rogue and joins her villainous brother, and the rest of the task force must stop them. Suicide Squad's development is a far more fascinating and engaging story than Suicide Squad itself. One day, I hope there is a Heart of Darkness style documentary with the actual cast and crew that recounts how everything went wrong from their own perspectives. Presently, such a project is not forthcoming because people who work on doomed productions generally need to preserve their jobs in Hollywood going forward. I'll get into this more later in the video, but the cast – when doing press junkets – is almost certainly either instructed what they can and cannot say or at the very least have the common sense to have a general idea about what they can and cannot say. David Ayer, the writer and director of the film who famously had the edit snatched away from him told the press that the finished theatrical version really is “his cut” even though we all know that to be false. Even the home video version with a few added scenes is apparently not what he envisioned as the editing duties for Suicide Squad were taken over by another company at the eleventh hour. But I'm getting ahead of myself.
David Ayer wrote the screenplay to Suicide Squad in about six weeks. It approximately the time it takes for your eggs to bad, Ayer pumped out Suicide Squad. Now, a long scripting and re-writing process does not always create a good story. See: The Book of Henry, which went through multiple drafts over the course of nearly twenty years, and it's godawful – and not because the director botched the screenwriter's vision or something. There is a lot of blame to go around, but the story is not salveagable, perhaps not even in the hands of a more emotionally aware director. But six weeks to create a story involving a multitude of established DC Comics characters, some more famous than others, and pushed out the door into production is a dangerously short amount of time. It's a challenge, and maybe David Ayer considered the challenge part of the thrill of it all, but that doesn't change the fact that this needed re-writes and the notes-taking process from producers and script doctors. Accomplished writers themselves openly mock this process – if you have ever seen that episode of The Simpsons about producers giving the writers notes about Poochie the Dog, that's their dig at this.
AUDIO 2
Patton Oswalt does a whole routine about how maddening he finds the producer note-taking malarky, but the truth is that it's probably for the best in some cases, especially with so much on the line. A movie is not the handiwork of one person. It is a massive undertaking with hundreds of moving parts and a ridiculous amount of money involved, and David Ayer should not have been trusted to have his screenplay ready to go in a month and a half. This lack of planning shows up again and again in the production of DCEU movies, and one would think that by the third one – Suicide Squad – they would know not to rush into things, take their time and make it as polished as possible before day one of shooting. It's not Ayer's fault that he was rushed, though. According to the Hollywood Reporter, one source involved in the film said that once the studio dated the movie, pushing back the release was not an option. "It's not just that you've told the public the movie is coming, you've made huge deals around the world with huge branding partners, with merchandise partners. It's a really big deal to move a tentpole date."
It's not that Ayer double dog dared himself to write a movie in six weeks. It's that the timetable was mandated by those more powerful than himself. Ayer was said to have shot over 200 hours worth of footage on the set and hoped to “find the movie in editing.” Again, Ayer isn't talking. He needs to protect his career to make Bright 2, but many have speculated that the frenetic pace is more an issue of editing. There is probably a lot more shot in the prison, for example, that tells us about the characters and possibly would have allowed us to empathize with them, but what we got INSTEAD was a series of brief music videos. Of course, if we spent even more time in the prison, that would increase the run time and drag the film, and we already spend nearly half the movie there before the action begins. So, it's not just the editing because Ayer's vision – on the page – would not work well either. But maybe, some speculate, it would have at least worked better than what we got in the theaters. And how DID we got that theatrical cut? The first trailer for Suicide Squad was made by Trailer Park, a production house that does exactly what the name implies.
AUDIO 3
Later, a different trailer made by a company named Aspect debuted to rave reviews. Yes, reviews...of a trailer. This is the famous Bohemian Rhapsody trailer that got everyone's hopes up about this movie. It's hard not to be enthusiastic about a movie set to Queen. [mamma mia let me go] Trailer Park, the company that did the earlier trailer, was contacted by Warner Bros and tasked with creating a cut of the film that resembled the trailer made by Aspect. I hope that answers some questions, but it also raises some. Why wasn't Aspect hired to do an Aspect-style movie? Also, why was a trailer company hired to cut the film in the first place? And finally, why was Warner Bros insistent that the film needed to be “fixed” anyway? What was so wrong about the cut that we have never actually seen? Often is the case that efforts to fix movies ratchets up costs, which drives up expectations at the box office. It's possible that Trailer Park was hired because they are a trailer house and might have been willing to “save” the movie for a lower price than someone else or even another trailer house like Aspect. That's speculation. We simply do not know.
When it comes to saving the movie, in some cases, such as Fantastic Four, this swooping in at the last minute clouds what the public knows about the director's involvement. Studios are careful to claim that the credited director is on the scene and totally in charge, but this is lip service to avoid Director's Guild of America issues. Directors are usually smart enough to play along with the charade, else they cause career problems for themselves, again like in the case with Fantastic Four. Josh Trank did not play along to the studio's satisfaction, to say the least, and it messed up his career for years. Ayer did what he was told. The director – never before creating a special effects heavy big budget juggernaut like this – was hired out of necessity. A lot of directors will not make deals with studios to create movies like this due to the stifling oversight and incredible pressure. Before this, Ayer was known for directing Training Day and a lot of movies that nobody remembers. Another thing out of Ayer's hands was the reaction to Batman v. Superman. The film was lambasted by critics, and Warner Bros got nervous, possibly deciding that Suicide Squad needed to be more [text] “fun” to escape the shadow of the dour Zack Snyder vision of the DCEU.
AUDIO 4
Batman v. Superman, though initially financially successful, was seen as damaging to the brand. People will only go to bad DCEU movies so many times before deciding to stay home, which is what they did for Justice League, but we will get to that later. Warner Bros wanted to rebrand the DCEU as more light-hearted, which explains the shoe-horned comedy bits and kinetic pacing of Suicide Squad. By the time Suicide Squad was ready to premiere, multiple editors had been brought in to salvage it in the eyes of Warner Bros. Although, John Gilroy is the only one who is credited. I want to be clear about something. What David Ayer wrote and shot all on his own was not...good. Suicide Squad is not the victim of a brilliant film lost in post-production. A lot of the movie that is entirely his baby is not the lost remnants of a great picture. It's still bad, but if Ayer had his way entirely, at least the film would have been more...cohesive. Based on what was added, however, it also probably would have been bad in a different way. Slower, less exciting, but still ugly and full of bad decisions. It might have been “better” but it probably would not have been a stellar film based on what we know is all David Ayer.
Warner Bros was put in a situation in which the film Ayer wanted was too grim and unpleasant to be the blockbuster they needed. Based on some leaked information, Ayer's cut may have been around three hours long, which is unacceptable both due to the casual filmgoer's attention span but also due to multiplex marketing. Studios want their films to be of a certain length so that theaters can cram as many showings as possible to reap those financial rewards. A very long movie equals fewer showtimes, and this is a superhero blockbuster. Not Ben-Hur. The studio's decision was to create a version that was so unfocused and frenetic that it would be laughable if it were not so headache-inducing. Damned if you do, damned if you don't, but when money is on the line, the studio will take the reins. So, to recap the order of events: The studio announces Suicide Squad. The studio hires David Ayer. He writes the film in six weeks. It goes into production. The studio is unhappy for various reasons. There are re-edits.
AUDIO 5
Two weeks before two versions were tested, Ayer's next project, Bright, is turned down by Warner Bros. It's eventually bought by Netflix. One version of Suicide Squad was only mildly well-received by test audiences. Due to this, there were reshoots to create a lighter tone. A Frankenstein monster of the Trailer Park cut, the studio-mandated reshoots and Ayer trying to have his way with his own ideas was tested for audiences, and something similar but probably a bit different from what the test audiences saw is what we got in the theaters. And what we got...was a mess.
[LET'S MEET THE SUICIDE SQUAD]
AUDIO 1
In the beginning of the film, Amanda Waller convinces top officials of the United States government to form Task Force X, our titular Suicide Squad. A group of criminals who can be sent into the field to deal with a [text] “Superman level threat.” See, by this point in the DCEU, Superman is currently dead, and without Superman, the world is in danger. Also, Waller says, if the next Superman-level being shows up on Earth and he's a supervillain, the world is toast. And that makes sense, right? They just witnessed Doomsday, and without Superman, maybe the world wouldn't have been able to stop him. So, what are you going to do, Amanda Waller? Contact Batman, Aquaman, Wonder Woman and The Flash – the most powerful superheroes on Earth – to form the Justice League? I mean, we know that YOU KNOW who they are and how to find them because you have files on them that you give to Batman at the end of the film? NOPE. The premise of the film is that in the face of a global threat that could endanger the world, she enlists Captain Boomerang.
Remember: Superman-level threat. The movie's premise: We need Captain Boomerang. The premise of this movie is built on the shakiest of ground. A foundation that cannot stand. Almost nobody Waller enlists for her suicide squad is up to the task of facing someone even remotely like Superman. Deadshot can shoot real good. So can a thousand trained snipers that are already in your employ via the United States military. Deadshot is not a supernaturally good shot or has a superpower that makes it impossible for him to make mistakes in the field. He's just a really good sniper. His inclusion in the face of better alternatives is both unessential and dangerous to the mission due to his demeanor. Harley Quinn. She has a baseball bat. Killer Croc has regressive atavism. Not powers. Slipknot...is the MAN WHO CAN CLIMB ANYTHING. [laughs] What? OK, so he has a grappling hook that anyone in the army could be trained to use. And Captain Boomerang. … He has boomerangs. Amanda Waller tries to convince the officials, but really, the audience, that these people are essential. She remarks that Captain Boomerang fought a metahuman, The Flash, and lived to tell about it. No. That is not what happened.
AUDIO 2
The Flash pushed him over and DOES NOT KILL. The only people Waller enlists for Task Force X who are worth a good goddamn are Enchantress and El Diablo. The former is a monster who she cannot control, and the latter has fire powers but doesn't want to use them. Flagg, a soldier working for Waller, tells her that this recruitment makes no sense, and Waller says he's on a need to know basis. OK, so maybe Waller is foreshadowing the real reason her plan makes no sense superficially but there is some secret that strengthens the premise. Nope! She has no secret plan that does this. It's a hand-wave. Someone writing the script realized that this movie is built on a faulty premise and added this line to tell the audience not to worry about it because it's all part of a greater scheme – one that is not addressed later in the film. [Austin Powers line] There is no twist that subverts the audience's expectations and delivers a big reveal as to why Captain Boomerang was absolutely necessary for this team. It's just a garbage line. Most nitpicks about films aren't particularly interesting to me because so long as it doesn't ruin the movie or make the events of the film impossible, who cares? But Suicide Squad's very PREMISE is faulty.
See, if something doesn't make a whole lot of sense somewhere in the middle of the film – like an uncharacteristic action taken in service to furthering the plot but making a character look stupid – then, OK, that's a shame that happened, but it's forgivable. Sometimes a writer is backed into a corner, and instead of rearranging and re-writing the entire screenplay, something's just gotta be contrived and awkward for a second. It doesn't excuse it, but it does explain it. However, the creation of Task Force X and why it must exist is the PREMISE of the entire movie, and if the PREMISE has no structural foundation, then everything that happens in every scene, every line, doesn't make sense. Now, if you are the kind of viewer who stares blankly at the screen and watches movies the same way you watch a kaliedoscope, this might not bother you, but audiences are generally intelligent enough to know something is up, and it affects their engagement with the narrative. And again, the movie goes out of its way to let you know that Waller knows everything about the team that will eventually become the Justice League – [Justice League vs. Superman scene] a group of people who could face a Superman-level threat.
AUDIO 3
She opts not to because she thinks, I guess, that she could control Task Force X better, but they are crazy and dangerous, and she absolutely cannot control them, especially the most powerful one. Everyone on this team is a liability to the goal they are meant to achieve. So, what the f*** are you talking about, movie? This is where we come into the problem of things happening in such a way that it takes us out of the film. Amanda Waller doesn't form Task Force X because she thinks it will save the world. She does it because Warner Bros wanted a Suicide Squad movie. There is no in-universe explanation. Amanda Waller doesn't pass on forming the Justice League because she thinks Task Force X is more her style. She does it because Warner Bros wanted a Justice League movie. If the only explanation for something happening within the narrative is an answer that exists well outside the narrative and in the real world, you're doing it wrong. Now, I'm always hesitant to say “Well, here's how I would do it instead!” because it's generally better to dissect the problems a film has with what is on screen rather than create scenarios surrounding what could be on screen instead. You critique the movie you got.
But in this case, with the premise itself in tatters and with the DCEU tribalists undoubtedly thinking that we needed a Suicide Squad movie and Justice League movie, so they HAD to do that, I feel like getting into some possible alternatives that could have maintained these films but had them make more sense. First, skip the Waller and Batman meeting. Make it seem like Waller does not have intelligence on the Justice League. Only Batman does. Or maybe make it clear that Waller has heard of them but has no idea how to reach out to them because, unlike Task Force X, they are not in prison cells. Don't reveal that she knows Bruce Wayne is Batman. This scenarios solves the question of why she doesn't actually form a group of ACTUALLY incredible beings by removing the question altogether. She doesn't know Aquaman from a ham sandwich, and that's that. Next, make Task Force X less about stopping the next Superman and more about running black ops in public. If the government is caught doing something unseemly, they have the public to answer to. If Task Force X does it, the government can disavow. That is more or less the premise of the comic books.
AUDIO 4
Either write a movie in which nearly all the group is made up of super-powered beings or keep the characters intact and make the movie about stopping a threat that even Captain Boomerang can handle: The Joker. In an interview, David Ayer has admitted that he should have made The Joker the central antagonist and not the extended cameo that we got. The Joker being the antagonist would make for a more compelling story for one thing, and for another, it explains why Amanda Waller would risk Harley Quinn – who is psychotic – being part of the team. She knows the Joker. She can get close to him. That lets us have Quinn, who the studio clearly wanted to be the standout character based on the fact that she is getting her own spinoff movie, and it lets Suicide Squad and Justice League happen with no gaping plot holes related to the very premise of the story. Sure, there are a lot of other things in the movie that don't make a lick of sense. When Griggs gives Harley Quinn the phone to contact the Joker, he does it in PLAIN VIEW of EVERYONE, including the soldiers who are tasked with making sure things like this don't happen on the mission. It's right here. He does it right in front of everyone.
When the Joker shows up to rescue Harley, Flag can't seem to blow up her head with his head explosion app. He could just shoot her, but he doesn't. That's not the big problem, though. This is: Eventually, Waller enlists Deadshot to kill her because the explosion app is on the fritz. If they are safe, why doesn't everyone in Task Force X take that opportunity to kill Flagg and Waller and destroy the phone? They're free. Only moments ago, they tried to escape, but Waller showed them the phone thing, and that was the only reason they backed off. With the threat no longer there, why are they still cooperating? I'm certain that upon hearing this, the film's defenders and those who love playing devil's advocate will come up with some reason for these things to have happened the way they did. [Maybe all the soldiers are on the Joker's payroll too!] [Maybe all the soldiers were all distracted by a pigeon at that exact moment!] [Maybe Waller's reason for the Suicide Squad will be revealed in Suicide Squad 2!] [Maybe Waller approached Aquaman and he turned her down!]
AUDIO 5
Look, if the film doesn't address why these things happened, any explanation of how the soldiers didn't see Griggs working with Harley Quinn and all the other holes sounds like fan fiction rather than engaging with the text of the film itself. The movie is the movie. It is THE TEXT. An explanation that exists far outside the realm of the text is more head canon than it is legitimate. And about the whole “Just wait until Suicide Squad 2” argument, that's bunk. Yes, a cinematic universe sometimes leaves some unanswered questions because that is the nature of the beast. Batman v. Superman did not explain what The Flash meant during the dream sequence. It also did not give us many details about who Aquaman is, but these are teases for upcoming films: not THE PREMISE for THIS FILM. This film, all on its own, needed to fit together, and it just doesn't.
[BLUE] FILM CRITICISM AND POPULAR MYTHS
AUDIO 1
I do not fit the traditionally definition of a film critic. Generally speaking, a film critic is someone who reviews recent releases whereas I am a video essayist who does something else entirely. If you have never watched my show, I mostly discuss films as they relate to philosophy and politics or philosophy and politics as they relate to film. So, I do “film criticism” from time to time, but I am not a “film critic.” Confusing? Yes. True? Probably. Yet, I am still witness to a lot of these arguments. Film criticism has existed since early on in the medium of film as an extension of art criticism. A film critic has two major functions. The first is obvious: to guide potential theater-goers about whether or not to spend their time and money on a movie this weekend. Nobody should have to see Collateral Beauty without a warning. But that is more like the immediate effect of film criticism. Really, a film critic guides readers not about what to see but about how to think about what they are seeing. Traditional critics generally have a deep knowledge of cinema and its history, a pre-requisite to doing that second form of criticism: teaching how to think about film. Briefly explaining whether something is good or bad is simple enough, but educating readers about why creates a deeper understanding of the media.
There is this mistaken belief that critics and movie fans are at odds with one another, which is actually a misunderstanding of the film criticism profession. Film critics think about your point of view as an audience. When a film critic trashes a movie you love, it's not because the critic wanted it to the terrible or wanted you to feel terrible about liking it. It's because the film critic is professionally obligated to consider aspects that you have dismissed or never considered in the first place. Dismissing a film critic's opinion – usually expert opinion – purely on the basis because it does not coincide with your own does both film criticism and yourself a disservice. Those who dismiss popular consensus among film critics usually have a few tactics. [Film Critics Don't Really Know Movies!] The first is some variant on attacking the critics themselves rather than examining what they said in any detail. It's an ad hominem argument or logical fallacy, which is itself disqualifying from reasonable arguments, but let's go over it anyway. Film critics generally have either a degree in film, a degree in something related to writing or literature, or at the very least – if they are well-known enough for you to be reading their reviews – they probably have the experience of doing this a long time.
AUDIO 2
They do, in fact, know what they are talking about. That is not to say that we must always agree with film critics. In fact, because film critics are individuals and not a Borg hive mind, [Locutus saying “The Snowman sucked”] one film critic can adamantly disagree with another. However, it is simply – I'm sorry – a wee bit ignorant to claim that most film critics simply do not understand film. It is literally their job to understand film and convey that understanding to their readers and potentially movie-goers. They're not all good. [Example of ] My Lord, they are NOT all good, but dismissing film criticism in general comes from a place of not understanding that academic film studies and subsequent film criticism comes from the groundwork of university education. Not all film critics are created equal. Some guy with a blog is probably not as educated as the guy who works for a major publication because they generally hire the best. What makes a good film critic? Well, that's debatable, of course, but I would say the best critics have little interest in writing plot synopses and instead dissect the movie's cultural relevance as much as its structural framework.
Another argument used to dismiss film criticism is that [Film Critics Are Failed Filmmakers!] It's reminiscent of the old and demonstrably false adage about teachers: “Those who can't do, teach.” Defensive fans who wish to dismiss legitimate criticism sometimes use a similar adage for film critics, suggesting they all wanted to be directors but somehow washed out of Hollywood. Teachers are rarely teachers by accident. Countries and states vary, but generally speaking, if someone wants to be a teacher, they have to get a degree in elementary education for younger students or a degree in a specific subject to teach older students. In addition, they have to go through certification, which takes years and because of this is usually done concurrently with their university education. Teaching is a choice and one that takes years to get into. Nobody becomes a teacher by accident or through failure. They become teachers through hard work. This is similarly true of film critics. While there might be a handful who wanted to break into Hollywood but settled for something else, film critics usually get their jobs through educating themselves in the subject, getting a degree or low-level experience and then applying for a major position.
AUDIO 3
It's like any other job, really. There is this kind of mistaken perception about critics – that they must be these bitter old fogeys – which oddly enough has been propagated through film itself. [Birdman: What does it take for someone to want to be a critic?] Filmmakers have a love-hate relationship with film critics, and because of this [Godzilla/Ebert], they are often portrayed badly or even satirically in popular media. [The Lady in the Water] And since most people aren't friends with a bunch of professional film critics, this media mistakenly informs people of what film critics are and what they are like. It's nonsense. The old “Those who can't do” line doesn't even entirely work here. A lot of filmmakers would make terrible critics because a lot of filmmakers are not also writers. About the love part of that love-hate relationship, director Francis Ford Coppola gets it, once saying “For me, the role of the critic is to teach me how I can make the next one better.” Another argument is [Film Critics Just Try to Look Smart!] I get this one from time to time. Basically, this is the idea that if you read a review of a movie you liked and the critic told you something about it that you didn’t notice, or had not even considered, then they must have over analyzed the movie.
There are a lot of movie fans out there for whom “It's just a movie!” is their foundational argument. Rather than confront the possibility that media informs culture and that itself is informed BY culture, some fans prefer to think of a movie existing purely in a vacuum and having no ability to touch anything else in society. That way they will not have to be critical of the media they love or consider anything significant or challenging. Another argument is [Film Critics Love to Hate Movies!] Film critics are generally film lovers, partly due to their film school education or, if they did not attend film school, the evidence that they are film lovers is that they have chosen a job in which they watch movies all the time. It's so...obvious [laughs] that film critics love film. They are largely passionate about the medium, its structure and mechanics, and its history. They want every film they see to be good as much as you do. They don't go into a theater hoping to not have a good time, especially when their job entails watching so many movies. Nobody walks into their job hoping to have a bad day. Film critics, due to the nature of their job, need to have certain standards, and because the average film goer might have different standards, there is a habit of misunderstanding a critic's standards as being OVERLY critical.
AUDIO 4
And if how you gauge a film's worth is different, that's fine, but bear in mind that a film critic, by the necessity of the job, can't just write “Well, that wasn't too bad.” and call it a day. For some fans, a movie need only be as entertaining or emotionally resonant as one requires to distract oneself for 90 minutes on a Saturday. “It doesn't have to be a good!” might be the worst critical argument ever. Would you say that about ANYTHING else? A car doesn't need to function well? Food doesn't need to taste good or be healthy? It doesn't work as a functioning argument. Now, how do these myths about film critics help create a defensive atmosphere among the DCEU tribalists? Well, these myths and bad arguments are trotted out whenever someone wants to dismiss the popular critical consensus that DCEU movies are really, really bad. You can insert any of these broad arguments into this specific fandom. Remember this one? [Film Critics Don't Really Know Movies!] Well, the tribalists point to the noticeable difference between the critic score and audience score on Rotten Tomatoes of some DCEU films. Although, keep in mind that while the actual film critics who are part of the algorithm are known, the audience score comes from what in statistics is called an unscientific sample.
We don't know who upvoted Suicide Squad to a healthy 60%, but it's probably the people who love Suicide Squad and not a generous, broad sample of movie fans. DCEU's tribalists claim that most of Internet hates the DCEU movies AND that most of the Internet gave it a positive rating on Rotten Tomatoes. This is a contradiction. It can't be both. Either their beloved film is under fire, or it's not.
[FOR THE FANS: A FALSE NARRATIVE]
AUDIO 1
It has become a popular mantra among Hollywood directors and producers to say that a bad movie was never meant to succeed with film critics. From their perspective, it makes sense to say this in interviews. I mean, a big budget studio film can cost upwards of 200 million dollars, and that's not even counting the marketing budget. Getting ahead of the narrative is probably just good public relations. It's bogus nonsense, sure, but it's just good business. Actors get in on this too. Dwayne Johnson said of the critically panned Baywatch “Oh boy, critics had their venom & knives ready. Fans LOVE the movie. Huge positive scores. Big disconnect w/ critics & people.” First of all, critics aren't people? That's...a lot to unpack. Second, general audiences did not embrace Baywatch either. It flopped. When director Alex Kurtzman defended The Mummy by saying that critics didn't understand it but the fans loved it, not only was it disingenuous but demonstrably false because it also bombed at the box office and those who saw it thought it was garbage. But this is about the DCEU, so I'll leave the failed Dark Universe alone RIP. Amy Adams, the actor who plays Lois Lane in the DCEU films, embraced the “for the fans” narrative:
“I know that Zack doesn’t make the movies, and none of us are making the movies for the critics, so to speak, you can’t go into it from that perspective. So, I know we really hope the fans like it, and so far the reaction’s been really positive on that front.” By claiming that superhero movies need not be embraced by professionals who can tell the difference between good and bad, she comes close to suggesting that these movies and quality movies are opposites. This does a disservice to actual good superhero movies and limits the sub-genre as something that need never bother escaping its alleged “low art” designation. I'm not upset with Adams for saying this, though, for reasons I'll get into shortly. The “we did it for the fans” narrative is a massive eye-roll. The narrative of giving “the fans what they want” is not respect for the fans – it's flattery. Real storytellers don't go out of their way to give the audience exactly what they wanted and therefore expected. Real storytellers give people what they never knew they needed until they had it. “Give the fans what they want” is not a creative strategy, it's a marketing strategy, and we all need to learn the difference. If I wanted to watch a movie that gave me exactly what I expected, the movie itself would become superfluous.
AUDIO 2
But more important than any of that – my belief in what makes good art aside – it's...a lie. When a studio executive lies, it's like when a politician lies – we know they are full of it, but we understand they are only trying to protect their job or their investment. If it ended there, it would barely register, but this narrative has begun to infect movie fans and therefore the discourse around movies and movie criticism. I guess that frightening old adage is right. If you tell a lie enough, no matter how obviously false, enough people will eventually believe it. The hope is that fans will parrot this phrase amongst themselves, broadcast it on social media and have it become their mantra. That way they can feel good about the movie they liked, continue to see further sequels and feel as if they are rebels against the elitist powerhouse of THE CRITICS. And you know what? A lot of “FANS” fell for it. This has been the rallying cry of studios for a while, but it really came to a head with Suicide Squad when the director and the cast, all in lockstep with one another, said the same thing in interviews.
David Ayer, director of Suicide Squad, said of the backlash “I made the movie for real people who live in the real world. I made the movie for people who actually love movies and go and see movies. The movie's a lot of fun and the fans are really going to enjoy it." The implication is that critics, who have devoted their lives to movies, don't love movies. This is an actual talking point in The Discourse, and for reasons previously indicated, it's hogwash. In this case, it's also a smokescreen to hide a flawed movie from criticism. Now, when studios retroactively say that they made the movie “for the fans,” they're not referring to their intention to make the film as generic and broad as possible to appeal to the masses. That would be an admission of guilt that they would not make in public, especially as a defense of their bad movie or as a means of placating their audience. More on this later. No, when studios say that they made the movie “for the fans,” they are referring to the die-hards who bought tickets weeks in advance – their unshakeable audience that will always show up to the theater, who buy the t-shirts, the action figures, the merch. The hyperconsumers.
AUDIO 3
When Suicide Squad was absolutely savaged by critics, the cast and crew knew what what they had to say. Jay Hernandez, the actor who played El Diablo said “Obviously, we worked hard and tried to give the fans what they wanted." Joel Kinnaman, the actor who played Rick Flagg said “What matters is what the fans think.” Cara Delevigne, the actor who played Enchantress said of critics “You know, I just don’t think they like superhero movies.” That is provably false. Even a cursory glance at the Rotten Tomatoes scores of most MCU movies, most X-Men movies, DC's The Dark Knight trilogy and so many more disprove that outright. It's not the critics' fault that your movie is bad. Margot Robbie, the actor who played Harley Quinn said “Critical acclaim is really nice, but we made it for the fans. If the fans like it, then we did our job.” Fans, eh? Fans. Now, this might be genuinely what these actors think, but in all likelihood, based on how coached press appearances are and how uniform everyone was in their reference to the fans, this is almost certainly what they are told to say.
Let's be clear. Studios, directors and actors on a critically panned film claiming that this movie is “for the fans” is what in politics or public relations they would call “spin.” It's a form of mild propaganda achieved through offering a biased and often false interpretation of an event or reaction to something – in this case, critical reaction to a film. It relies on altering the presentation of the facts. When studios respond to a negative reaction to their movie, they spin this by claiming that they didn't make this movie for the critics or even the casual movie-goers who might turn their nose up at their schlock. They made this...for the fans. Let's make something clear here. By “fans” they (and I) do not refer to the the casual movie-goers who contributed to the box office of Suicide Squad because it was a big tent pole event but thought the movie was garbage. By “fans” they (and I) mean the tribalists, even if they won't use that word. The narrative the studio is delivering is if the hardcore fans of the intellectual property liked it, then the movie did its job. The spin – the alteration of the facts -- is that the studio pretends that this was the plan all along. It's the equivalent of someone tripping on the sidewalk, landing face first, then getting up and saying “Meant to do it!” The most significant problem with this defense is that it is so obviously untrue, but tribalists eat it up.
AUDIO 4
It furthers the cause of tribalism because it creates a false narrative that the studio has a personal connection with its fans, that it is some kind of “mother” figure that loves its children, its fans, its defenders. The studio is telling the truth about one thing. They didn't make Suicide Squad for the critics, but they also didn't make it for the DCEU's biggest fans who bought the Harley Quinn t-shirt at Hot Topic before the movie debuted. No, any movie with a studio-sized budget is made for MASS APPEAL. Every decision is made as an answer to this question “Will this make people come see this movie?” The idea that movies are made primarily for the people who are already planning to see the movie is deeply naïve. Hardcore fans, the tribalists, are going to buy their tickets no matter what. Producers are constantly interjecting themselves into the creative end of the process, telling filmmakers to do this and not to do that due to the possibility of alienating a demographic, the possibility upsetting parents who might otherwise bring their multiple children and therefore multiple tickets, the possibility of not targeting a key demographic and market, et cetera. Big budget movies like those seen in the DCEU are not built by fans for fans. They are built by massive corporations who want to use the intellectual property they have purchased to make more money on the investment of purchasing or licensing said property. The director and others might be enthusiastic about the project but they are still under the thumb of other people who make the final decisions.
And after production is seemingly completed, a rough version of the film is sent into test screenings. A test screening is a preview screening of a movie before its release in order to gauge audience reaction and determine what, if anything, needs to be changed. The preview audiences are not chosen among hardcore fans of the property. They are selected from a cross-section of the population, giving the studio representatives of particular classes of people. During or after the screening, this cross-section of people are asked to complete a questionnaire or provide feedback. Often, the test screenings have the studio conclude that expensive re-shoots need to be made or at least certain scenes need to go back into editing. All your favorite movies went through test screenings and many of your favorite movies were different during said screening than they were once they hit the theaters. If there is one thing test screen audiences hate, it's down endings. 28 Days Later, The Descent, I Am Legend, E.T. The Extra Terrestrial, First Blood and many more previously had the main or titular characters die. Movies that challenge the audience are generally not liked by test screeners.
AUDIO 5
Occasionally, a compromise can be reached. Test screen audiences hated the downer ending of Seven, and under pressure, David Fincher added an ending narrative spoken by Morgan Freeman that is half hopeful and half nihilistic. However, compromises like that are not always reached. Sometimes completely new endings that botch the movie are shot because a handful of people said so, and this handful of people represents the studio's best guess at [text] MASS APPEAL. That's their goal. Mass appeal. Not catering to people who are going to see it no matter what. So, if you were ever wondering why Hollywood movies have “Hollywood endings,” some of the blame must be placed on the average schmuck. NOT the hardcores of the product. NOT tribalists. NOT “the fans” that the studio claims is its only demographic after all the other demographics hard pass on buying a ticket. Movies are made with mass appeal in mind. That's why the test screen audiences are cross-sections of the population. If anything, the “fans” get the least amount of focus when marketing the movie because they were going to be there on opening night anyway. Production, test screenings and marketing of a film is all about trying to convince people who are NOT big movie fans to see the movie. No, seriously, the average person only goes to the theaters about five times a year.
And that's not an exaggeration either. This was a study from a couple years back. If anything, it's less now because Netflix gets bigger with every passing day. The average person is rarely coaxed into leaving the comfort of their own home to venture to the local multiplex, but the studio NEEDS those non-movie fans to see their movie in order to make a bigger profit. You may find that absurd because, if you are watching a huge mini-series on YouTube about the DCEU, you probably watch lots of movies. But you, apparently, are not the average movie-goer. Movies, on the other hand, are catered to that unattainable average person. If they are only going to visit the theater about five times each year, THIS movie, the studio demands, must be one of those five, and so the studio does everything in their power to make sure this has the most mass appeal as humanly possible. Every decision is geared towards this one end goal. Superhero movies are not made to please everyone who reads the comic books and hangs Batman posters on their walls. They are made for everyone. That isn't some egalitarian comment, though. I mean they are made to be as broad as possible.
AUDIO 6
This is even more true nowadays than in decades past. Big budget movies must be so accessible and so simple that they can be understood and beloved across cultural divides because the foreign market of a 200 million dollar Hollywood movie is now more important than the domestic market. Whether or not a movie hits in China is everything. China has four times the population of the United States. Big budget movies are commonly Chinese-American co-productions so that Hollywood can get its foot in the door with their next big budget movie and make a ridiculous amount of money overseas. It's why Transformers 4 had a lot of its story take place there. It's why Independence Day 2 talked up China so much. It's not just as simple as mentioning the country's name in a positive light, though. Studios try to make movies as action-heavy and effects-heavy as possible now because explosions and fight scenes are universal and translate perfectly across borders. Dialogue does not. Movies like Justice League contain a bunch of action set pieces, which is probably why that movie was the highest grossing DCEU film in China. Man of Steel, a more, let's say, contemplative film, did far worse in China.
Movies are made for mass appeal, not only among Americans but for audiences worldwide. Every decision is only reached after someone determines that it translates well and will play well in foreign markets. Comedy is something that does not translate well, and because of this, comedies don't make it big internationally. Comedy is dialogue-heavy, and some things are lost in translation. There is less and less faith in the comedy genre these days, and God help you if you decide to make a BIG BUDGET comedy film. It probably won't even play in China, and due to this, it won't be seen as a financial success. The idea that the DCEU movies are made primarily for people who collect comic books or people who will get all the Easter eggs they put in for the heck of it or even people who are just really enthusiastic about the franchise is patently false. So, tl:dr – movies are not made with a narrow target audience in mind, they are made for international mass appeal, and the decisions are made by studio producers and random test screeners who represent entire demographics and who have no emotional stakes in what they are seeing because that makes them “good” test screeners. Suicide Squad was not made “for the fans.” It was made for China.
[THIS MOVIE SUCKS, AND HERE'S WHY]
AUDIO 1
A lot of the success of a film comes down to its shape. How the screenplay and the finished product after post-production builds to each plot point, holds tension, releases it, and surprises the audience even while delivering a familiar structure. And that structure is generally divided into acts, and nearly all blockbuster movies that hope to hold the attention and money of the audience is divided into three. It was good enough for Aristotle, and it should be good enough for Suicide Squad. This film does have a structure, and you can use three-act structure as theory to see where everything fits, but Suicide Squad's three-act structure doesn't do what said structure is meant to do; the aforementioned tensions and releases, proper rising action, et cetera. The setup, confrontation and resolution are awkwardly placed, and because of this, Suicide Squad is unpleasant to watch. Even if you don't know about the three act structure, you have seen enough movies to understand it subconsciously. You knew something was off about this film's pacing even if you didn't go to film school. There has been a recent thinkpiece article backlash against the three act structure in recent years, but this mostly amounts to misunderstanding about what it is.
Most movies having three acts does not make most movies the same. It's only the lattice upon which to hang the narrative. The movie Raiders of the Lost Ark is said to have a near-perfect three act structure, but so does 12 Angry Men. These movies are nothing alike except in their ability to have good rising action, releases of tension and other hallmarks of the structure. Raiders of the Lost Ark is an action-adventure movie that takes place all over the world. 12 Angry Men is a stage adaptation that has no action, only dialogue, and it takes place in one room. To explain the details of the three act structure, how it works on other movies and is used poorly in Suicide Squad, I'll use a famous example: Die Hard. Act I is the setup. John McClane, a New York City cop, arrives in Los Angeles to meet with his estranged wife. We learn a lot about McClane quickly and without much dialogue. His signs of disgust and disinterest in LA and his brief interactions with an annoying passenger and a comparatively talkative limousine driver reveal a lot about his character. The movie also reveals smaller details and foreshadowing through implication.
AUDIO 2
McClane mentions how he hates flying, suggesting a fear of heights. The passenger tells him to take off his shoes to relieve stress. Later in the movie, McClane will be forced to the top of a building, and his lack of shoes will actually be something that increases his stress. The reveal that McClane is a police officer happens because the passenger noticed his gun. Not much is made of it at the time. When McClane mentions in passing that he has never been in a limo before, we learn he is a working class kind of guy. All this character and foreshadowing is revealed without a big exposition dump in the beginning. Die Hard shows more than it tells, which it what you want in a visual medium. The inciting incident of the film is the events of the Christmas party. McClane arrives and argues with his wife while Hans Gruber and his men show up. Now let's compare this to Act I of Suicide Squad. For the first three minutes of the film, we are introduced to the two characters on Task Force X who get the most screen time and backstory: Deadshot and Harley Quinn. We see them in what the film shows us to be their natural habitat: a prison.
Now, you would think that after that, the plot would begin to unspool, but you would be wrong! Because then, we spend another SEVENTEEN MINUTES introducing supporting characters through a series of comical dossiers – INCLUDING Deadshot and Harley again -- two characters who we already met. We get a bunch of music videos from Rick James and Kanye West but no Meatloaf. Then, nearly twenty minutes into the film – after a scene with Amanda Waller trying to sell her colleagues and the audience on who Task Force X will be and why it exists, she introduces said characters and mission AGAIN to the Pentagon. Finally, she also introduces Enchantress to the military officers, even though we – the audience – already know who she is, her conflict, her relationship with Colonel Flagg and her role in the team. But it's still not over. Right after this, Waller, Flagg and Enchantress visit the prison we are introduced to these characters AGAIN. Each of these sections of the first act, the initial three minutes, the overly long, pace-destroying dossier montage scenes, then the Pentagon scene, and then the following prison scene all convey the same thing over and over again rather than providing new information.
AUDIO 3
In a good movie, each moment pushes the story forward. Everything that happens has consequences relating to the next scene or a couple scenes later. This causality allows us to engage with what is happening because it gives everything weight. A scene is meant to convey information to the audience. Who are these people? What can they do? But we already knew that. Exposition should be over by now, but it will not stop. If this poor structure were used in Die Hard, John McClane would fly to LA, get in the limo, fly to LA again, get in the limo, and then fly to LA again before showing up to Nakatomi Plaza. “Welcome to the party, pal, indeed.” Act II of Die Hard has McClane fighting Gruber's men. Each time he defeats one of the criminals and hinders Gruber's plan, it pushes the plot forward. Gruber becomes more and more frustrated with McClane's interference, and while this happens, the danger simultaneously ramps up with each encounter. All the actions have consequences. McClane is winning, seemingly, but he is more and more banged up, bloody and worn down as the film progresses. Will McClane die hard or will Gruber die hard? Who will die the hardest?
The tension allows for character engagement and empathy, and the movie also shows the consequences of each action. In Suicide Squad, the inciting incident of Incubus possessing the subway passengers and Enchantress escaping. The former is a tense enough scene, but the latter happens off-screen. [“She bolted!”] We learn about it via walkie talkie. Bad inciting incident. It gets worse, though, After the inciting incident, we still haven't been introduced to the entire team. We meet Slipknot [clip] the man who can climb anything, and Katana. Some of the action scenes that follow have consequences either in terms of the plot progressing or the characters progressing. The encounter with the deformed creatures tells us that Deadshot will not, in fact, cut and run on his teammates as Flagg incorrectly predicted. This is a good scene and a good character moment. Most of Act II is not like this, though. There are a lot of flashbacks and cuts to what the Joker is doing, which turns out to be almost completely meaningless to the central plot. Some encounters and moments do not have consequences. They are moments that do not push the action forward.
AUDIO 4
Well into Die Hard, we get more features of the three act structure and a solid screenplay. Here's an example. Setup and payoff. Remember the no shoes on the airplane thing? Hans Gruber orders his men to shoot all the glass. McClane's feet are completely messed up. Suicide Squad sets things up but does not pay them off. When Flagg questions the sanity of Waller's plan, there is this moment between them that makes the audience think there will be a payoff – an explanation about why Waller chose Task Force X as opposed to recruiting the Justice League or using Flagg's highly effective team, but this foreshadowing is never resolved. It foreshadows something that does not exist. It sets up something that is never paid off. Die Hard ends with John McClane reconnecting with his wife, and Sgt. Powell getting over his fear of drawing a firearm. Character arc is complete.
Suicide Squad ends with the task force right back where they started but with a cappuccino machine. Deadshot does go through a proper character arc due to his willingness to save Harley Quinn and become a better person, but the ending feels flat because there weren't many gains for these characters. Also because the ending sets up another movie, giving the audience the impression that all those Joker scenes really were meaningless as they relate to THIS movie. And that is why Suicide Squad sucks. It is edited in a blender and came from a screenplay that was probably too rushed to begin with. There are a few good ideas in the movie and some scenes really do work, but the script needed a few more drafts, and the edit needed to be tighter or at least less chaotic. Critics pretty much savaged Suicide Squad, but they didn't have to wait too long for the first good DCEU film...
DCEU 4
[THE STORY UNTIL NOW]
AUDIO 1
The DCEU did not have a strong start – or a strong middle. Man of Steel was a mess of conflicting ideas that needed a few more drafts before day one of production. It was the foundation with a flooded basement. Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice – The Revenge was somehow worse. A whirlwind of bad pacing and Randian bullsh*t that could not figure out why people like Superman in the first place or why Batman, though dark, still needs to be human and, more importantly, humane. And Suicide Squad just sucks. The DCEU brand had already taken a lot of hits to the face and was fast on its way to being a public embarrassment for Warner Bros. Its tribalists would defend it no matter what, but deep down, they also wanted some public recognition. Fans enjoy a product. Tribalists enjoy respect for their product. By attaching themselves to an amorphous product like a cinematic universe, they desired the validation of one movie that nobody could say was a giant, gaping black hole that devoured light. Enter: Wonder Woman. Before the DCEU was even a glimmer in the eyes of Christopher Nolan and Zack Snyder, a potential Wonder Woman movie was always a possibility, but it seemed doomed to remain in development hell.
Movie executives took the wrong lessons from movies like Catwoman, Elektra, and Supergirl – that being that a female-led superhero flick wouldn't sell, ignoring the real lesson that movies that are universally understood as bad don't sell. They saw “woman” as the common denominator rather than the quality of the film. Studios do this all the time. A genre film that wasn't marketed well or wasn't any good is blamed on the genre no longer being popular or shifting trends rather than blaming the poor box office returns on anything that the studio itself did. For example, the uranium-enriched bomb that was Cutthroat Island was scapegoated as a failure of the genre rather than accept that said studio made a heinously bad movie. This excuse was later revealed false due to the critical and commercial success of the first Pirates of the Caribbean movie. Way back in 2010, Warner Bros announced that solo projects for male superheroes like The Flash and Aquaman were in development but not Wonder Woman. Then DC Chief Diane Nelson said that she wanted to make a Wonder Woman movie but such an endeavor is too “tricky” right now. Uh-huh.
AUDIO 2
It wasn't until 2015 before Warner Bros confirmed that the Wonder Woman movie was a go – with director Patty Jenkins at the helm. The production had a few hiccups. Reshoots were required, and by that point, Wonder Woman actress Gal Gadot was five months pregnant. She wore what basically amounted to a green-screen cloth, and her baby bump was CG'ed out in post-production. How they managed this so perfectly and completely botched Henry Cavill's mustache-less face in Justice League remains a mystery. How do you make a fetus seamlessly invisible but an upper-lip look like it was made out of Stretch Armstrong rubber? But generally speaking, production went comparatively well. Batman v. Superman was a mess with required two cuts of the same movie. Ditto for Suicide Squad, among its other aforementioned problems. Justice League had two directors and so many changes in post that the tribalists are still petitioning for a Zack Snyder cut that does not exist. Wonder Woman's production was, like, a regular movie. But there is still a lot to talk about.
[REVIEWS AND CHANGING NARRATIVE]
AUDIO 1
Wonder Woman is the story of Diana. She is the only child on Themiscyra, home of the Amazons. When World War I breaks out and a pilot named Steve crashes near the island, Wonder Woman believes she must both help him on his mission against Germany and possibly even against Ares, the god of war. They gather a group of lovable misfits, beat the Germans at trench warfare, Steve sacrifices himself for the greater good, WW punks out Ares and the world is saved. More importantly, the DCEU is saved. [sarcastic child voice] Hurray. Not only was Wonder Woman a big financial success that surpassed expectations, it was the first DCEU film to be met with anything but groans, torches and pitchforks from critics. All the other movies were rotten. Wonder Woman was fresh. The Rotten Tomatoes percentage doesn't judge its overall worth but its broad appeal, but looking closer, the rating out of ten is a hefty 7.6. Critics appreciated and respected this movie. Wild, enthusiastic reviews came in like the one from Richard Brody from the fancy pants New Yorker:
“Wonder Woman is a superhero movie, and it fulfills the heroic and mythic demands of that genre, but it's also an entry in the genre of wisdom literature that shares hard-won insights and long-pondered paradoxes of the past with a sincere intimacy.” I don't even know what that means, but I do know that it sounds like a positive review with a lot of posh language and grandiose phrasing. So, the New Yorker. Jason Guerrasio of the Business Insider lavished it with praise: “I'm confident Wonder Woman is one of the best superhero movies ever made. I can't wait to get back to the theater and watch it again.” Sean Axmaker of Screen on Demand noted the social issues of the film: “There is great pleasure in the matter-of-fact way Jenkins and Heinberg make points about chauvinism, sexism, and equality through pointed humor and practical examples, and how deftly Diana sweeps aside all attempts by men to dismiss her.” In short, critics not only liked Wonder Woman, not only loved Wonder Woman but saw Wonder Woman as one of the very best examples of the genre and a pivotal moment for both Hollywood and women's depictions in film. Even Marvel movies didn't get THAT kind of adoration.
AUDIO 2
And for the DCEU tribalists, this surprising good news created a problem. As mentioned, in order to deflect criticism that their favored movie franchise had been garbage, the widespread critical dumping of Man of Steel, Batman v. Superman and Suicide Squad was dismissed with conspiracy theories and half-baked ideas. Before, the tribalists tried to make the laughable case that the first three DCEU movies were great and that they only received negative reviews due to the lack of integrity of film critics, most notably the “bribe” conspiracy theory. This popular myth spread all over the Internet and became the go-to in ignoring broad critical consensus that the three DCEU movies were objectively bad. “It's not that Batman v. Superman was a goddamn mess,” they say, “it's that Disney is paying off critics with their deep, deep pockets.” First of all, that's obviously defensiveness masked as intellectual skepticism. And second, it could no longer be used as a proper defense. With the emergence of Wonder Woman as a critical darling, the narrative among tribalists – even in their own bubble – could no longer be believed by even the most tinfoil-hatted among them.
If DCEU movies were obviously good but were hammered by critics only because of a secret cabal of nefarious critics and massive payouts, how can the tribalist conspiracy theorists explain that? It's not as if Disney suddenly ran out of money. If anything, their coffers were even more filled in 2017 than they were at the start of the DCEU. It's not as if they just forgot to perform their EVIL plan. It's not as if, these devilish critics with no morals all collectively saw their hearts grow three sizes like the freaking Grinch and gave good reviews to Wonder Woman in spite of these phantom payouts. Let's be clear here. I imagine a lot of the DCEU faithful who use this excuse don't actually believe it. The excuse is an example of tribalism. They know it's not true, but the tribe is under attack, and lies are fair game. But with a shiny new DCEU movie with an excellent critical rating in our midst, the lie is even harder to believe now than it was before – and before – it was still bullshit. Another false claim fell apart. The idea that critics, people whose entire professional centers around knowing their movies, simply did not understand DCEU movies, and that's why the three previous entries got bad reviews.
AUDIO 3
Except now that Wonder Woman's reviews are out, that can't be true either. It was never true, duh, but now it can't even be swallowed by the most gullible in the fandom. Another false claim had yet another hole in it – the idea that critics didn't like most superhero movies because they saw them as infantile. That was never true because previous DC entries like The Dark Knight trilogy got rave reviews, and a lot of Marvel and X-Men movies received similar praise. But now that the modern DCEU had a critical winner, the argument, like a boat that already had a few holes in it, was now completely sunk. Some DCEU fans – not tribalists – were enthusiastic both about Wonder Woman and its reviews, proclaiming it by far the best of the lot and hopefully a sign of things to come. No more messes like Suicide Squad. NOW, they thought, DC finally got its act together and they could enjoy the DCEU less as a guilty pleasure and more as a legitimate quality movie experience. But tribalists are not like that. They changed the narrative. They moved the goal posts. They claimed that the critical success of Wonder Woman legitimizes previous DCEU entries rather than view Wonder Woman as a smash all on its own.
Some tribalists might remark that if only the critics went back and rewatched Man of Steel and the rest with new eyes after liking Wonder Woman, they might change their tune completely. That is...quite a fantasy. I made previous videos about the DCEU, and one comment I remember quite well. Someone said that critics only bashed Man of Steel, Batman v. Superman and Suicide Squad because it was the “in” thing to do. That critics were somehow the real tribalists. It's an old politics move. Discover your greatest weakness and claim your opponent actually has that weakness instead. The problem with that is that film critics write their reviews independently of one another. They're not all in a room collaborating. Generally, they work for competing newspapers, magazines and websites. I think, maybe, the existence of Rotten Tomatoes as this monolith has warped the perception among some people to the point they think of “film critics” as more or less existing under one roof. Not true at all. A side argument among tribalists is that Man of Steel soured critics on all future DCEU movies, which can't be true because Man of Steel actually got higher marks than subsequent entries Batman v. Superman, Suicide Squad and Justice League.
AUDIO 4
Also, again, Wonder Woman removes this already weak argument. The conspiracy theory persists. DCEU tribalists, due to what tribalism expects of them, are more likely to profess that critics just weren't paid off this time or that Disney didn't have the heart to bash a female-led superhero movie than to simply believe the obvious truth: Wonder Woman was good and the others were bad. They are using the inversion of the old Sherlock Holmes quote. The conspiracy theories, however unlikely, must be more likely that the DCEU being mostly full of bad movies. The trouble with tribalism is that evidence will never be enough because tribalists see a duty to their tribe rather than an obligation to people outside their tribe who see things differently and desire the truth.
[THE NON-TROVERSY]
AUDIO 1
Justice League dropped on November 17, 2017, and in the days leading up to its release, everyone was wondering where the reviews were. The closer the reviews are to the release, the worse the movie tends to be. Studios mandate a review embargo of right before the release day if they expect bad reviews because everyone who buys advance tickets will have already made their purchases by then. Movies that the studio expects will have good reviews have a much earlier embargo because these reviews may drive UP advance ticket sales. Justice League reviews started pouring in, but Rotten Tomatoes made what seemed to be, at the time, an unusual decision to not calculate the weighted totals for everyone and instead delay the score until their new web series See It/Skip It. Rotten Tomatoes waited more than 24 hours to post a rotten critics' percentage, breaking with tradition of posting right after a studio-imposed ban. See, according to The Washington Post, Warner Bros owns a 30% share of Rotten Tomatoes, leading fans and critics alike to speculate that this even greater delay was manufactured to protect a bad movie at the box office. With a budget approaching $300 million, Justice League is among the most expensive movies ever made.
That means Warner Bros had a lot riding on it. Now, I have doubts about this being a massive conspiracy by Warner Bros and Rotten Tomatoes to protect Justice League. I respect journalists enough to give them the benefit of the doubt, and Rotten Tomatoes in an autonomous “news” organization that does not have to cater to a minority stakeholder. Yes, 70% of Rotten Tomatoes is owned by Comcast, which owns Fandango – a ticket seller – but by that logic, Rotten Tomatoes would try to protect a lot more movies to help sell their tickets. It doesn't entirely add up to call this a conspiracy. The score was probably delayed for other money-grubbing others internal to Rotten Tomatoes itself: that being that they wanted everyone to watch their new web series with the score reveal. And it worked! I watched it. I've never watched it AGAIN, but still, they hooked me but good. But regardless of why the delayed score happened, it created even more animus in the discourse. It was probably a case of Rotten Tomatoes wanting to hype their new, really bad web series.
AUDIO 2
See It/Skip It launched two weeks prior, and probably nobody gave a damn about it until it was used as a platform to give people something they wanted: the Justice League score. Here's the thing. Delaying the score was the standard for See It/Skip It. The premiere episode was about A Bad Moms Christmas, which meant the movie's score was not released until that episode aired. It was delayed too. Nobody noticed or cared because it was A Bad Moms Christmas. Then, as expected, Rotten Tomatoes picked Justice League for See It/Skip It to bring more eyeballs to its show, and everyone lost their marbles. DCEU tribalists went on the defensive – their natural posture – and had to be in the unenviable and unnatural position of being the voice of reason. The delayed score reveal probably was not a case of a studio influencing media. It was a case of media raking in its own money its own way. Neither case is altruistic, but the simpler answer is almost certainly the correct one. But, here is where tribalism comes in. DCEU tribalists had been making the case that film critics were corrupt for years, or at least lacking the integrity to give DCEU movies the good scores they “rightfully” deserve.
In order to defend Warner Bros and subsequently the DCEU from accusations of review tampering, they had to either concede that the film critics and news media had integrity after all and that this controversy is manufactured nonsense – which it was – or engage in some kind of double-think in which the critics and media did have integrity but also did not have integrity and was secretly plotting the downfall of the DCEU. They appeared to have chosen the latter because that's how tribalism works. The narrative of the bought movie reviewers has never gone away in the social media discourse of the DCEU tribalists in spite of the fact that they had a real “come to Jesus” moment in which they were on the other side of the tinfoil hat conspiracy theory game. The idea that Rotten Tomatoes had a new web series which reveals a Tomatometer score every week and that week’s score was obviously going to be Justice League because it was the big release was too complicated. Conspiracies are more fun, and that was that. The MCU tribalists had a field day too.
AUDIO 3
This was evidence that not only were the DCEU movies far worse than Marvel movies but that Warner Bros was shady as hell. This non-troversy made Warner Bros and therefore the DCEU look pathetic, even though the story was bogus. The phony story seemed to be made legitimate in the coming days when Justice League was released as a complete mess. It fueled the conspiracy theory that Warner Bros would do ANYTHING to draw attention away from the inevitable bad reviews of this overblown, unwatchable turd. The conspiracy theory poisoned the discourse even further and the MCU and DCEU tribalists entrenched themselves in their camps deeper than ever.
[JUSTICE LEAGUE IS PRETTY BAD, RIGHT?]
AUDIO 1
As of this writing, there are five DCEU movies: Man of Steel, Batman v. Superman, Suicide Squad, Wonder Woman and Justice League. At the time I am editing this, Aquaman and Shazam have not yet been released. So, Justice League is not the worst DCEU film. The crown probably goes to Suicide Squad. It's not even the second worst DCEU film. It's vying for third worst in contest between itself and Man of Steel over which movie had the most wasted potential. I want to start with the Superman CG mustache debacle – not because it's the worst crime of the film. It's not. It's of minor importance, but it is so emblematic of the lack of foresight, planning and vision that bogs down a lot of other aspects of Justice League. Henry Cavill is a handsome man. Hollywood recognizes this because he keeps getting work in spite of the fact that he is, at best, a passable actor. Watch him in any movie and watch how little his emotions change. [clips] So, the best Cavill attribute – his dashing good looks – are the only thing that needs to be protected in this film, and somehow, Justice League screwed that up.
In the opening scene, a couple off-camera children catch him after a big hero moment and ask him questions. After filling some time with nonsense, one of them asks what Superman loves best about Earth? He looks off into the distance but gives no answer. The audience, presumably having seen Man of Steel and Batman v. Superman, is meant to think he is thinking of Lois Lane, and later in this movie, that is made abundantly clear even if the audience had not seen those films. It would have been one of the best parts of the movie, but any significance or emotion or meaning in that pregnant pause is ruined when the audience looks at Superman's face because the area where, oh I don't know, a mustache would be in colored differently than the rest of his face and Superman's chiseled visage looks just...off somehow. We see this happen over and over and over again in the film. The reason? Well, Cavill was called in for reshoots and Warner Bros, a studio that does not think ahead when it comes to the DCEU, now had a more hirsuit Superman to deal with.
AUDIO 2
Cavill grew a mustache for Mission Impossible: Fallout, perhaps a studio-mandated change in appearance to differentiate himself from his more iconic character portrayal. Paramount Pictures refused to let Cavill shave it off in a move that was one part contract requirement and one part power play. Warner Bros instead decided to shoot Cavill with his mustache and then use the miracle of modern visual effects to digitally shave it off. The end result is better than one might think but still glaringly obvious and in one case, monstrous and frightening. Again, this shouldn't have been a big deal. It's only a big deal to the Internet because it is VERY meme-worthy, but it is also emblematic of how poorly Warner Bros plans out the DCEU. … A movie can live and die with its antagonist. A good antagonist need to be a threat but also needs to have an intriguing motivation, a prior relationship with the protagonist or a personality that lets them stand out and not seem only like an obstacle for the protagonist to overcome. Preferably more than one of these traits.
We need to care about the protagonist, sure, but we also need to have a reason for us to care about the protagonist defeating the antagonist. This is especially important in superhero movies and other action movies because the protagonist generally must physically defeat the antagonist, making their climax that much more significant and having greater weight for the audience. Avengers has a great villain: Loki. He has personality like whoa and a relationship with Thor. Avengers: Age of Ultron is not a great movie, but it does have a memorable villain. He has a robust personality, a motivation and a connection with the Avengers. Honestly, he is one of the only good parts about that movie. Justice League has...Steppenwolf. He is never referenced in previous movies outside of an image of him that everyone forgot, has no personal connection to the Justice Leaguers prior to the events of the film, has no personality and his motivation and philosophy is non-existence. He just, you know, likes to conquer and thinks power is cool. He's a threat, sure, but that is all he is.
AUDIO 3
The strange thing about this is that the DCEU movies previously had a good track record for villains. MCU villains are usually forgettable. Man of Steel had Zod. We get a lot of time with Zod in the prologue to set up who he is and why he does the things that he does. We learn of a connection between himself and Superman's father. Lex Luthor in Batman v. Superman is not without his flaws, but he is definitely a memorable villain. His motivation is all over the place, but he has personality and he stands out, at least. Ares from Wonder Woman is not the best villain or anything, but the sleight of hand and character reveal both work. Also, his motivation is thematically important because Wonder Woman's journey is about whether or not the world of men deserve to be saved. Ares thinks they are not worthy. Wonder Woman, over the course of the film, goes back and forth on this and then concludes that Ares is wrong and that the world needs saving, not destroying and starting over. Again, not the best antagonist but his role fits neatly into the themes of the film. Ares works. Steppenwolf does not. Also, he's a CG image that never looks real. A waxy, shiny cartoon that never fools the audience into thinking he's there.
Some of the elements of Justice League don't work as they relate to other films in the DCEU. Normally how a movie works in relation to another movie isn't all that important, but when you have a cinematic universe whose whole appeal is fitting together, it's noticeable and awkward. In the beginning of Justice League, the world is in chaos. Crime all over the globe is on the rise, there are new terrorist factions and a general feeling of despair – and this is all blamed on the death of Superman. The Man of Steel is dead, and hoped died with him. Except...what? To the people of Earth, Superman had been around for, like, two years or so. He's not...a constant. The Earth has existed for millions of years prior to Superman, and it will continue post-Superman. The death of one hero who the public barely had time to get to know does not cause the end of the world. Now, with the arrival of Steppenwolf, the world does seem to need them some Superman, but the people don't know that when they start losing their minds and joining reactionary terrorist organizations.
AUDIO 4
Wonder Woman's whole arc in the film is that she needs to finally get over Steve Trevor, but in her origin story, we learn that this happened about a century age during World War I and that she knew Steve for, like, a few days and they never consummated their relationship. They danced once, I think? I'm sorry, but I refuse to believe that Diana is still hung up on this guy that she knew a hundred years over who had been in her life about as long as it takes to watch The Twilight Zone marathon. And don't tell me now it's been retconned that she may have also seen him in 1984 because that may or may not be the plot of Wonder Woman 2 because that wasn't even an idea when they wrote the script to Justice League. Within the context of this film, it makes no sense and for the writers – not knowing about this upcoming retcon – to write this, it was a mistake. See, much like the world in chaos thing, Justice League tries to make everything have so much more gravity than one would think, and because of this, it comes across and fake and disingenuous.
That makes it difficult to become invested in these characters and this plot or give a damn about their arcs and motivations and everything that makes an audience engage with the movie. The dialogue is cheesy, the Flash is obnoxious, Aquaman is too try-hard in order to get rid of the Superfriend stink, Cyborg is a mopey emo guy because we needed to quickly establish his conflict because Warner Bros didn't want to give him a solo movie before Justice League. Also, this is an action movie, right? Why is so much of this movie planning? Why are multiple action scenes so unimportant to the central conflict? By that I mean the flashback action scene and the Superman vs. Everyone scene. There are, I think, two action scenes relevant to the central conflict in this action movie with a central conflict that has allegedly (but not really) been built up over the course of several movies. The first is the rescue scene against Steppenwolf and the second in the bright red extended action sequence with Steppenwolf. 1 hour and 32 minutes into the film, it stops being a mess of exposition and becomes an aesthetically displeasing bright red tinted generic CG action movie, and the bright red action scene is killing my goddamn eyeballs.
AUDIO 5
How can this movie be so bad at color grading? In the trailer, it wasn't this bad, but then someone must have said “REDDER! WE MUST MAKE THIS AS BAD AS POSSIBLE!” And don't tell me that it was necessary to reference Crisis on Infinite Earths because I don't care about your nerd shit. sighs I have other concerns, but it's more nitpicky, really. Like, how is Clark going to explain coming back from the dead? They buried him. Also, how will he explain coming back from the dead at the same time as Superman? Why is Lois Lane the only thing that can make Superman stop being The Incredible Hulk? Shouldn't Superman be able to be brought back to being not a monster due to his good nature? Isn't that...the point...of Superman? That he loves everyone? But only Amy Adams and bath tub sex can get Superman back to normal? I could go on...and I will! You know how in the MCU, they took like, a million movies setting up the Infinity Stones as things we are supposed to care about because if they all combine they form Captain Planet or something?
Well, in Justice League, their version is the Mother Boxes and they are set up over the course of about five minutes, and the audience is meant to instantly give a damn. Why does this movie think Batman and Wonder Woman have sexual chemistry? Also, why anything? This movie is bad. And if you're a DCEU tribalist, you might be thinking, well, it would have been better if Warner Bros released the Snyder Cut. Well, guess what, butter cup? That does not exist.
[THE SNYDER CUT DOES NOT EXIST]
AUDIO 1
Tribalism creates sainted figures in its communities. If the object of tribalism is an institution or a belief system, then the people who are responsible for its creation or management become figures who are beyond reproach. It is by their hands that the purity of the institution or belief system was made and any mistakes they might have made are either happy accidents or a move in 4D chess that outsiders or members of an opposing tribe do not understand. If there is one figure in the production of the DCEU that has certainly achieved that status, it is Zack Snyder, director of Man of Steel, Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice and Justice League, executive producer of Suicide Squad and the upcoming Aquaman, and even the owner of a producer credit and story credit in Wonder Woman. He will also have a producer credit in the Wonder Woman sequel. The idea that he has somehow been banished from the DCEU is demonstrably false, but this martyr narrative among the DC faithful helps elevate his status even further, requiring the tribalists to go into full apologist mode when discussing both Justice League and his stepping down from the project – except that is not even what really happened.
To say that Justice League had a challenging shoot would be an understatement. Filming began in April of 2016. During filming, rewrites from then DCEU honcho Geoff Johns caused conflict between himself and screenwriter Chris Terrio. Kyle Buchanan of Vulture wrote of this: “...Geoff Johns rewrote so much of JUSTICE LEAGUE when Zack Snyder was still directing that Chris Terrio would complain, ‘Maybe *try* using some of my pages?’ WB was allegedly so unsatisfied with how the Johns/Snyder version was shaping up that they convened a footage summit for *other* writers including Joss Whedon, Allan Heinberg, Seth Grahame-Smith, and Andrea Berloff to offer feedback. Then they hired Whedon.” During post-production of Justice League, Zack Snyder suffered a family tragedy. The DCEU faithful believe that this is the sole reason why Zack Snyder was not available for reshoots. This was the official line of Warner Bros, after all. However, over time and after more journalists looked into it, the truth appears to be that Warner Bros wanted rewrites and reshoots even before Snyder's departure.
AUDIO 2
Some have speculated that Warner Bros wanted Whedon to take over reshoots even before Snyder's tragedy, but rumors about this are fuzzy and can't be substantiated as of this writing. We may never know, but it is unimportant as it relates to the erroneous belief in a Snyder Cut. Whedon's rewrites went into action during the reshoots. Snyder was not cut out, though. He actually supervised the Whedon's reshoots. So, why do DCEU tribalists use the ReleasetheSnyderCut hashtag? Why do they think there is a mythical Snyder Cut in the first place? Well, a lot of it comes down to misunderstanding how the editing process works and Warner Bros's post-production timeline for Justice League. People who worked on the film told the Wall Street Journal that Snyder assembled a rough cut after principal photography, but he never intended for it to be released. What people who don't understand post-production heard was “There is a secret Snyder cut!” What people who do understand post-production heard was that Snyder built a rough cut – something just above an assembly cut but before a first cut.
Often when a movie is in production, the film's editor is already cutting together some of the footage being shot. But since the director is busy with the film, they may not be involved in putting these scenes together this early in the process. Once a film wraps, the director often works with the editor – for months, really – to make the movie whole. Many times, the first step is watch the assembly cut. It's the rough version of the movie that was put together by the editor during production. It's basically everything that was shot. This version cannot be released. It's not an extended version or an “ultimate edition” like the home release of Batman v. Superman. An assembly cut is only the building blocks to what the movie will be, and in the case of a movie that still needs reshoots, it's even less than that. It doesn't look like a real movie yet. In fact, an assembly cut doesn't have the visual effects yet. So, it's unwatchable for an audience. The assembly cut to Black Panther was over four hours long, but when news leaked about that, the average fan not in the know thought that meant that we were either getting the biggest superhero movie ever or that there are hours of great deleted scenes. Neither was true.
AUDIO 3
It's just the assembly cut. After the assembly cut is worked on for a while, a “first cut” appears. For example, Rian Johnson revealed that the first workable cut of The Last Jedi was well over three hours long. That's a watchable cut but still nowhere near a finished product. A first cut is not actually ready to be seen or released. It's just not a complete mess of scenes anymore. A first cut is just another rough draft. Denis Villenueve's first cut of Blade Runner 2049 was four hours long. A first cut is not done. They are all these extraneous scenes that don't fit together or contradict one another or are redundant or add nothing to the story except runtime. So, when news from the Wall Street Journal broke about their being a rough draft that Snyder had worked on, tribalists thought that was confirmation enough that the movie was done and ready, Snyder had made it, and that it had been wrested away from his grasp for reshoots to create an entirely different film. The truth is that Snyder was working on the assembly cut or creating a rough idea for a first cut. By that point, rewrites and reshoots were already planned, which means even his first cut would have been a first cut for a version of a movie that will soon no longer exist.
There is no Snyder cut because he did not create anything even resembling a finished product. He couldn't have during that time in post-production. DCEU tribalists believe that there's a pure version of Justice League locked up in a vault by Warner Bros to hide their shame after hiring Joss Whedon for reshoots. A “Release the Snyder Cut” campaign covered social media. Reddit, Twitter, Tumblr, Facebook, YouTube – anywhere where hashtags live. If you go on Twitter – right now – and check the #ReleasetheSnyderCut hashtag, you will see a lot of desperate grasping at straws, misinformation, apologetics and the standard tribalism that has haunted the DCEU fandom since its early days. [Show examples, get cameos.] Snyder himself has confirmed that his rough cut was never meant to be viewed by the public, probably because rough cuts, first cuts, assembly cuts – all those cuts – are barely watchable. They are half-baked. But that hasn't stopped the tribalists, and it has infected reasonable discourse on the film. Warner Bros and Snyder's representatives both confirmed that there exists no Snyder cut and that no alternative cuts of Justice League will be released.
AUDIO 4
Tribalism insists that anything counter to the narrative of the tribe is an attack, which is why the Wall Street Journal article to disproved the alleged Snyder Cut was met with fierce resistance rather than as confirmation that fans can move on. The movement has created a kind of double-think for DCEU tribalists: does this mean you do think Justice League is bad? In order to demand for a better cut of a film, one must first admit the original cut was unsatisfactory in some way. But in doing this, they betray their tribe. That means that blame must be placed on someone else – outsider Joss Whedon and Warner Bros – and someone sainted by their tribe – Zack Snyder – must be elevated as martyr. In short, there is no Snyder cut. There never was. Based on the time between the end of principle photography and reshoots when Snyder was working on the assembly cut with his editors, at best, there was an unwatchable mess of a rough cut with no visual effects done – made incoherent by the fact that the film still had lengthy and expensive reshoots to do. Assembly cuts and first cuts are missing lots of pieces and entire scenes are blank or utilize placeholders with concept art instead of special effects.
In a movie like Justice League, every other shot needed some kind of visual effect or touch-up or color grading. Snyder's alleged “rough cut” at its best could be no more than something mildly above an unwatchable rough cut but below a still mostly unwatchable first cut. There is no finished product that Snyder himself put together. By his own admission, he has never even seen the movie. Snyder has no intention of creating his own finished cut, and even if he did, Warner Bros has no intention of re-releasing the film. Even if Warner Bros wanted to make a new and finished cut based on what they thought Snyder might have wanted, which they definitely do not, it would still require reshoots – now years after principle photography began – because the script was in such a state of flux that Snyder was forced to shoot what he thought the studio might want on any given day and hope to – as they say – find the movie in editing. This would count untold millions of dollars – practically the cost of another big budget film because they would have to coax the cast back into costume years after release, for God's sake, to make that happen. That is UNHEARD OF – not to mention the fact that Ben Affleck has moved on a big way. But that is literally the only way that a so-called Snyder cut could ever be released because such a cut presently does not exist. And since that option is impossible, the prospect of this Snyder cut is impossible too.
[HOW THE STUDIOS SEE THE CONSUMER – YOU]
AUDIO 1
I love Star Wars. I love Star Trek. I love a great many pieces of media, and I especially love the franchises that house this media. The cinematic universes, the shared continuity, all that. And obviously, I am not alone. Fan culture has grown from being the stuff of “nerds” to being, well, culture. Our connection through the Internet and anonymity allowed for people to engage with nerdy, geeky, dorky stuff without fear of judgment. Now everyone is out of the geek closet, and I own an Ewok plush novelty of my very own. People have begun to identify with these fandoms as part of their identity. When I think of my friends and I am asked to describe them, I will mention a few personality traits but also what they are into. “Oh, she's a Disney fan. Princesses, musical films, the whole shebang.” “Oh, him? Yeah, he can't get enough computer games, and he collects comic books.” The reason someone loves something from Star Wars or Marvel of the DCEU might come from inside that person, but the reason the studio made that thing that you love or allowed that thing that you love to exist is because the studio studies you. All the time. It's called market research.
It's a study of the consumer, and if you didn't know, that's us. That's...you. Market research informs companies – in this case, studios – what consumers want. The DCEU may have its own subculture full of casual fans, tribalists and everything in between, and that fan culture may be moderated by the fans themselves, but it only exists in the first place because of market research leading to conclusions about what you might enjoy and, more importantly, what you might buy. And each new DCEU movie is at least in part the result of further market research. One key player in market research for studios is Market Picture Group, which was acquired by C4 in 2014. Market Picture Groups provides research in audience test screenings, advertising screenings, audience tracking and exit polling and online community tracking. That last one is key because even though the tribalists are in the minority, they are by far the loudest online, leading to market research on what DC fans what potentially skewed by research done on the Internet. Also, test screenings are part of market research. I discussed this earlier in the mini-series, but as a quick fresher, test screenings change a lot about the movie.
AUDIO 2
If a small group of people hate the downer ending that makes sense thematically in the film, that ending is history and new happy ending is created. Market Picture Group introduced data analysis that could inform movie script story choices. Basically, market research in movies affects the script writing of the film to the outcome of the film even after primary shooting has concluded. Market research is everywhere. Even the trailers are a product of market research. Movie trailer previews and TV commercial spots are key ways to create buzz for new films. Nielsen's Moviegoing Reported from 2014 ranks movie previews and TV spots as the most popular way American viewers learn about new movies. So, if you have noticed that movie trailers have become really samey – to the point that people can parody the average movie trailer – that is why. Someone did the research and decided that this format of “bwaa” sounds and visual effects at just the right point seem to work. Every decision that studios make is about manipulating us into buying tickets, buying the blu ray, and buying merchandise surrounding the movie.
That is what we are to studios: consumers. It makes tribalism about movie franchises like DCEU that much stranger and that much more uncomfortable to watch because, in effect, it is defensiveness about being manipulated so much that we identify with a product. It is apologetics for the end result of market research. We are not soldiers on the battlefield of fandom, fighting for our chosen cinematic universe. We are consumers buying what we are told. The rage of tribalism is actually favored by studios. The more people rage, the more talk surrounds a movie, and the more talk surrounds a movie, the more people will be aware of it. Tribalism is not some out of control byproduct that the studio did not intend. Intense, undying devotion to a product is what the studio wants. Studios see the manner in which people identify with a product – as a resource to exploit.
AUDIO 3
The end goal is to create a group of consumers who will be loyal enough to reliable purchase their product, recommend the product to others and defend the product from others. In sociological terms, we might call this tribalism, but to capitalists and economists, they are “hyper-consumers.” Hyperconsumerism is the consumption of goods for non-functional purposes and the associated significant pressure to consume those goods exerted by the modern, capitalist society. Hyperconsumerism also shapes one's identity. It makes consumers identify with the product. Studios and other businesses rely on identity to encourage consumption. That's why, throughout this mini-series, I have tried to avoid placing the “blame” on DCEU tribalism on the tribalists themselves. Because the impetus of tribalism or hyperconsumerism is not on the fan or consumer. It is the result of market research and a studio's desire to create an identity surrounding its product. Consumption is inevitable. I need to consume food, for example, and my life would be pretty dull without entertainment.
So, the blame for tribalism is not the exclusive property of the tribalists themselves because this outcome was manufactured, manipulated and intended by the studio. Human beings evolved as communal creatures, and we require groups, families, and yes, tribes, in order to feel whole. Corporations take advantage of this inherent need. We don't always find our tribe at work or at home with our family, but we can find our tribe in a galaxy far, far away. Again, this is not a condemnation of fan culture or of enjoying things. My life would be boring without my movies and my Star Trek – because, oh my God, did you hear Captain Picard is coming back? Sweet. No, I'm saying all this because we were born into this system. We were born into capitalism. We were born into corporations leveraging our enjoyment for their profit. What I'm saying is that we need to be aware of this, at least enough that we recognize when our attitude surrounding our product that we love so much becomes toxic.
AUDIO 4
Someone who buys a ticket to see Batman v. Superman only owns the ticket, but this identification with a product tricks fans into thinking they are the co-owners of the products. And you see it all the time in fandoms. A self-importance placed upon “we the fans” as opposed to the actual owners of the product – the corporation. Because admitting that the corporation owns the product would be admitting to the fans' hyperconsumerism and their own manipulation. There's this scene from West Side Story. A man is berating young people and says “You make this world lousy.” to which the younger person says “WE didn't make it.” We didn't make the world that we were born into, and because of that, maybe the onus should not be on us to change it – but since Warner Bros won't, we have to. We can't continue to behave in the way that tribalism or hyperconsumerism or whatever you want to call it has us behave. We have to change this behavior ourselves. Because the result of this is not just a bad online discourse. It's the constant harassment of both fans and actors involved in the franchises.
It's capitulation to the worst dregs of each fandom, who usually end up having worse ideas than just which movie in the series is the worst. And those bad ideas – racism, sexism and so on – spread with the franchise as a conduit. For example, the toxic elements of the Star Wars' fandom has furthered the visibility of racists and sexists on the Internet. There was a sexist backlash against the first women Doctor in Doctor Who and the first women Ghostbusters in that franchise's latest film. There was a racist backlash in the latest Star Trek series, a franchise known for its diversity. Identifying oneself with a product creates a false sense of ownership of that product – that franchise. These movements never happen under Klan hoods. They are done under the guise of keeping the product “pure” and “traditional” – and when tribalist fans don't notice these are dog whistles, they go along with them. Because to not go along with them would be to out oneself as not an “authentic” fan. Tribalism demands obedience, and if the tribe is spouting racist, sexist garbage, tribalists will adopt those postures.
AUDIO 5
If you catch yourself engaging too deeply in tribalism or hyperconsumerism, remind yourself of this. If you catch your friends or others doing this, be brave and remind THEM of this. Because a lot of fandoms – including the DCEU – are toxic right now, and we need to either make them better or watch them get worse. [FADE IN/OUT] I don't want to write a list of potential changes for Warner Bros to make the upcoming DCEU movies better. If I did, it would be generic advice like allowing more time and hiring the right people and changing the tone and all that. And there are two reasons why. One: they appear to be doing that anyway. Movies have been delayed rather than pushed out faster. Matt Reeves is involved in the DCEU. Shazam looks like it might be fun. And two: my advice would fall on deaf ears anyway. Warner Bros isn't going to watch this. But it is my hope that DCEU fans and even tribalists watch this and change their minds about how they interact with both media and other consumers of media. That's all I want. And the DCEU itself might end up great in the end. I'm looking forward to Shazam, and The Batman could be a landmark film. Oh, you know who would be perfect for the music in that movie?
FEARLESS
AUDIO 1
In the 1993 film Fearless, Max emerges mostly unscathed from a plane crash. This makes him a subject of public interest due to the catastrophe itself and his role as hero in the event. Max spends time trying to ease the pain of a woman named Carla who lost her son in the crash but begins to unravel as his family has trouble adjusting to the new “enlightened” version of himself. Following the plane crash, Max becomes a new man. He previously had a fear of flying, but even immediately after the crash, he is perfectly comfortable getting on another flight to go home. He is no longer afraid of death, and he waxes philosophical about this. Max and Carla go to church, and they ruminate on the existence of God and why people believe or don't believe. This is the most the movie attempts at searching for answers, though. Max broaches the subject about not fearing death but does not actually explain why in even the most rudimentary of ways. With this in mind, I will try to give some basic philosophical context to Max's new outlook on life and his feelings on the fear of death.
Defining death remains a challenging prospect in and of itself without, but with the counterpart of defining life, it becomes even more complex. [The Matrix] Imagine we construct a being that has all the hallmarks of life and psychological attributes one ascribes to a person. Is this being alive? Does this being have a life? Well, what we consider “death” is also ambiguous. This event might be understood in three ways, all defined by The Philosophy of Death by Stephen Luper. First, it might be the ending of the dying process, meaning the loss of the very last trace of life. We might call this the “denouement death.” Second, it might be the point in the dying process when extinction is assured, even if there is still some trace of us. We might call this moment “threshold death.” Third, life ends when the physiological systems of the body have lost the capacity to function as an integrated whole, or when this loss becomes irreversible. We might call this “integration death.” These definitions may seem obtuse when defining – “dead is dead” some might say – but even outside of philosophical circles and in scientific circles – people are considered “clinically dead” or “medically dead” if they lose all blood circulation and breathing but are able to be revived before brain death.
AUDIO 2
In Fearless, Max has a violent allergic reaction to strawberries and stops breathing. He experiences a version of the plane crash events in which he does not survive. Is he “dead” during this time? Until his wife revives him with CPR, is he not alive? Throughout much of the film, Max denies any fear of death, dismissing it as an inevitability and therefore not worth his concern or any form of planning. Max takes the perspective of Socrates. The film does not reference this philosopher, but I will. Socrates believed death was nothing to fear because of the two possibilities he could conceive of: nothingness or an afterlife, neither was undesirable. Nothingness following death is sometimes called Termination Thesis, and something existing past our extinction is sometimes called Dead Survivor Thesis. Socrates claimed that if the former is true, nothing can harm him while dead, and if the latter is true, he can potentially interact with other dead survivors. In some philosophical circles, fearing death is logically excluded by explaining the one can never experience death. One can experience dying but not the state of being dead.
If we conclude that death happens after the irreversible loss of any trace of us – the aforementioned denouement death – then death is never in the same place at the same time as ourselves. We can't feel being dead after we die. In the film, Max remarks that because he faced death on the plane, he himself is dead in a manner of speaking, but this Max does not meet any of the criteria for death. He has never “faced death” because nobody “faces” death. In the termination thesis, death only exists are the conclusion of our existence. Death and life cannot share the same space. Another method of dismissing death as a negative is called The Symmetry Argument: it is irrational to object to death, since we do not object to pre-vital nonexistence, meaning the state of nonexistence that preceded our lives, and the two are alike in all relevant respects, which means any objection to the one would apply to the other. This gives comfort to those who fear death by attempting to explain it away with the simplest of equations, but this basic math does not take into account death as it relates to comparativism.
AUDIO 3
If one sees being alive as a good, then being dead would be bad. Philosophers reminding people not to fear death is fruitless if those people believe in the Harm Thesis. Typically, those who value life accept this thesis, that death is a negative for those who die. Some things and events are intrinsically good or bad for a person, but some things and events are extrinsically good or bad for a subject, meaning because of their contingent effects. They are good or bad by comparison. Regardless of the fact that life and death cannot exist in the same place at the same time, that does not preclude avoiding death and fearing death on the basis of appreciating life. Also, The Symmetry Argument does not take into account that our pre-existence is something that has already passed and therefore cannot be feared as something that is coming. Toward the end of the film, Max enthusiastically declares that he is alive, accepting comparativism and the harm thesis. But would Max want to live forever, if he had that choice? If we lived forever and death did not exist, we might lose the desires with which we identify. Life would lose its novelty and boredom would set in.
The extremely old would have to replace their fundamental desires so often that eventually, the person we once were would functionally no longer exist, which some would argue is tantamount to death. Following the plane crash, Max becomes an almost entirely new person. Before, he was fearful and worrisome. Following the catastrophe, he is seen as nearly unrecognizable even to his loved ones. His former identity has been taken away. From one perspective, that identity died in the plane crash, and this Max is practically a new identity. But would this happen if we were immortal? This view of identity may be short-sighted if the purpose is to portray it as a negative. Many would welcome a transformation. In fact, transformation cannot be considered death unless we also consider our lives a series of deaths. We are psychologically distinct from who we were when we are infants. Furthermore, the argument against immortality is no comfort to mortals who do not live long enough for such an event to occur. Also, this argument is not without flaws. We need not replace our desires, only add to them. The more interests, the less bored we may become.
AUDIO 4
Max's transformation -- his new zest for life – has not made his existence more boring. Max seems to believe it's an improvement. In the end, these arguments about whether or not we should fear death might not convince someone who does or does not fear death because these fears are based in our emotions and desires more than simple calculus. If someone is afraid of heights, flying or both, showing them statistics about the relative safety of air travel may not be enough. Those who fear air travel might move past their phobia through repetition of air travel and showing personal, immediate lack of dire consequences. However, that can never be done with death. You can't “die a lot” to get over a fear of death. Due to this, fear of death is unique and therefore uniquely challenging to overcome.