Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi, everyone. Here are the scripts to the latest episodes. In somewhat related news, the new Renegade Cut episodes will now have proper captions. I mentioned all the other soft reboot changes in a previous post, but this is one I was able to put together recently. It wasn't as hard as I suspected.

Another bit of news: for those at the $30 tier, the first of the behind the scenes videos will be coming this spring. I'm hoping to do them seasonally. 

Anyway, here are the latest scripts. Some of them are noticeably different from the finished product. For example, the Archetypes/Breakfast Club video originally had a whole section on Suicide Squad before I cut it.

Archetypes & Stereotypes - The Breakfast Club

 AUDIO 1
 The 1985 film Breakfast Club opens with narration from Brian. He says “You see us as you want to see us, in the simplest terms with the most convenient definitions. You see us as a brain, an athlete, a basket case, a princess and a criminal.” Over the course of the film, Brian, Andrew, Allison, Claire and John get to know each other, share their lives together, trade war stories and become friends. They, too, initially saw each other as the labels that others applied to them. Brian is a brain. A nerd who gets good grades, rarely misbehaves, is unpopular and romantically inept. But he is also vulnerable and completely prepared to rebel in the most shocking way. Andrew is an athlete, a jock, but he actually hates being on the wrestling team and only does it due to the insistence of his father. He has bullied someone, but he deeply regrets this. Allison is a “basket case” but her behavior can be seen as rooted in the neglect of her parents who ignore her. Claire is a princess but is willing to defy the assistant principal and even date a criminal. And John is that criminal, but he is also loyal to his friends and willing to take the hit when it looks like the group will be caught and punished.
 The members of the eponymous breakfast club are “archetypes” but not completely “stereotyped.” That is the point of the film even if those words are not used. So, what's the difference? “Archetype” as a term has been around for centuries. It means the original version from which copies are made. The original pattern. When creating literary characters, an archetype is the model from which the character is created. From the starting point of an archetype, the writer builds an individual character. Archetypes need not only be characters but situations and settings, usually to symbolize something greater than itself. Situational archetypes include the battle between good and evil, the journey and so forth. The Breakfast Club's situational archetype is arguably The Initiation. This is generally some form of growth into adult life, new maturity or new awareness. Archetypal settings include The Ocean or The River, which both symbolize life, The Island, which symbolizes isolation, and so on. The Breakfast Club's archetypal setting is The Small Town, a place where everyone both knows and judges each other. It symbolizes some form of intolerance.   
 AUDIO 2
 The character archetypes in the film are outright said in the opening narration and repeated in the closing narration. But these modern, high school labels are actually forms of older archetypes. John is the Bully, someone who is included in the story to intimidate others. Claire is the damsel in distress, included for the hero to rescue her. Andrew is that archetypal hero: physically strong and popular. Allison is the Outcast, the wanderer. Brian is the dreamer, unsatisfied with his life. But in order to connect with these characters and make both the situation and setting engaging and “real,” all archetypes must deviate from the original to subvert the expectations of the audience. The situational archetype is the initiation, but where it diverts is the young people initiate each other rather than be initiated by an adult figure. The adult figure gives them a task to complete – an essay about who they think they are – but it is in the rejection of this essay that they grow. The setting is the small town where everyone is judged, but we witness very few characters in the film and we are trapped in one corner of this town rather than explore it. And each character deviates from their archetype.   
 Stereotypes are different. A stereotyped character takes a general type of person and oversimplifies their qualities into predictable or clichéd types. An archetypal character can contain various “stereotypes.” One could argue that if an archetypal character contains too many of these stereotypes or if the archetype rarely deviates in any meaningful way, then the character becomes a living, breathing stereotype. Feel free to say “It's more complicated than that, and the terms 'archetype' and 'stereotype' actually have a lot of overlap!” in the comments as if I don't know. Both archetype and stereotype draw from a “type” of person, the difference is that archetype will use the original version, the “template” as a starting point, and stereotype uses it as the end point. Brian is a nerd and contains stereotypical nerd qualities: he is a member of the physics club [academic], he's shy [shy], he's a virgin [not sexually active], etc. But it is in his deviations from his archetype [gets high, rebels w/ gun]that we come to identify with, sympathize with and accept Brian as a character and person instead of a series of stereotypes fitting neatly into a blank archetype.   
 AUDIO 3
 When Brian writes his essay, he more or less says the same thing except he is referring to how we view real people instead of how to write good characters. Assistant Principal Vernon sees the teenagers as stereotypes rather than fleshed-out people. He berates John for being a garden variety, stereotypical criminal who won't amount to anything because he has seen John's “type” before over the course of his career in education. John is not a person to Vernon, he is a type. Vernon sees Andrew as an athlete, a jock. We know this because we John takes the screw out of the door, Vernon enlists Andrew to help keep the door open. Assistant Principal Vernon sees Andrew the way others see him: a strong body. Athletes are given “hero” status in high schools, and because of that, Vernon expects more than Andrew and is willing to enlist him to help him with the door. He is strong. He is part of the school community. He will help. He's a “good guy.” John is a “bad guy.” Vernon accepts Brian more than he accepts John because Brian is a good student and therefore a “good guy” to Vernon, but Vernon speaks to Brian with no respect because he, too, has being [title] “brainwashed,” as the movie puts it, into believing Brian is not worthy of being loved, being popular.   
 He's a brain. Vernon says almost nothing to Allison throughout the course of the film. She is ignored by Vernon the same way she is ignored by her parents and ignored by the school. Vernon sees the teenagers' stereotypes as the end point of who they are rather than their archetypes as the beginning point to explaining the greater details of who they are. Again, that is the point of the movie – that we see people, not characters in a movie but real people in real life – as templates comprised primarily or even exclusively of stereotypes. Movies use a lot of shorthand with characters due to a combination of its runtime – about two hours – and what it perceives about the movie's intended audience. The more time we spend with a character, the greater the opportunity for that character to show us who they really are, deviate from the archetype, shatter stereotypes and become more than a simple copy of an original. When movies present characters as more stereotype than person or use harmful, negative stereotypes about a group of people, that can reinforce pre-existing ideas in the minds of the audience about that group of people, especially if that audience has limited, real life interactions with said group.
 
 AUDIO 4
 Let's break from The Breakfast Club and look at a film that has been accused of reinforcing these stereotypes: Suicide Squad. El Diablo has committed himself to pacifism following his outburst and murder of his own family. This plays into stereotypes about Latino men as inherently violence against women and owning “fiery” temperament. “A Latin temper” is an uncomfortable phrase and is commonly used to describe Latino men. The deviation from this stereotype is the fact that he wants to be a pacifist, but throughout the film, he gives up on this and his violence is seen as a net positive for the squad. Katana's appearance and honorable revenge backstory are presented with no complexity besides what is given to us from caricatured racial stereotypes. That's not to say The Breakfast Club is somehow unproblematic in this regard. It does not even attempt anything resembling diversity. Also, the ending in which Allison is made “acceptable” to Andrew paddles against current in terms of the themes the film is seemingly trying to address.   
 But purely based on how it deals with stereotypes, one film clearly tried to say something about it, and the other film played it up for laughs and used uncomfortably reductive shorthand. Archetypal characters usually have a flaw to overcome, and sometimes who they become after this character arc is how they deviate from the archetype, but characters who are nothing but a barrel of stereotypes usually have to overcome an unrelated flaw while maintaining their tired or even harmful stereotypes. Audiences expect readily identifiable traits so that characters can be understood quickly within the span of a two hour film, and the limitations of the medium force certain unrealistic character archetypes and stereotypes on us. For example, a human being is many things. A devout Catholic who is also a sinner. An introvert who longs for human contact. A sexual being who is uncomfortable with their own sexuality. A professional in an advanced field who is down to earth. An emotional mess who mocks the “irrationality” of others, and so forth. In a real person, this would not be considered “inconsistent,” as these traits exist within all of us. But if a character in a movie is written this way, it feels different. If the inconsistency is what they must overcome or it is highlighted by the film, it's fine, but if it's not, it feels unsatisfying and even confusing.   
 AUDIO 5
 The medium insists upon characters that fit archetypes not only because of the ease in which to write these characters but because we insist upon. Works of fiction are not designed to have one-to-one fiction to real world realism. They are designed to tell stories and make symbolic points and things like that, and that's fine, but we need be aware of what we're seeing when we're seeing it so that we don't confuse archetypal characters with how walking, talking human beings are or confuse stereotypes depicted in films with the manner in which groups actually behave. Un-learning these stereotypes actually takes time and effort. It's not something that people simply “grow out of” – if anything, it becomes more difficult to un-learn these stereotypes as we get older, more set in our ways and more likely to dismiss nuanced views of groups as products of “naïve” younger people. This shorthand is necessary for fiction. It is unnecessary for real life.   
 

BIG TROUBLE IN LITTLE CHINA

 AUDIO 1
 So, there's this episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation called The Outcast. The Enterprise encounters an alien species that has no gender. Their species rejects anything gender-conforming or sexual as a perversion. Riker falls in love with one who secretly identifies as female and has sexual feelings for Riker, but she is captured by the authorities of her species who use a science fiction “conversion therapy” on her to brainwash her. Riker is sad, the end. This episode was made in 1992 and was intended as an allegory for the oppression of gay people. The episode received a lot of praise and condemnation – but not only criticism from anti-gay groups, condemnation from the gay community. Obviously, the episode is intended to preach tolerance, but it also has a few bugs in the system. For one, it conflates sexuality and gender identity, which are actually two different things. For another, for an episode about being gay, the romance is between a man and a woman. Jonathan Frakes has said he would have referred the actor playing his love interest to be a man, but producer Rick Berman was not on board with this. Also, an explicit reference to “sexual orientation” was removed from the script.   
 Also also, the episode comes out against conversion therapy, which is good, but it also suggests conversion therapy works, which it most certainly does not. For 1992, this was considered progressive, and hey – you tried – but this leap into gay allegory didn't quite stick the landing. The point is that it's possible for something to be Woke AF, especially for the time it was made and also have noticeable problematic elements that tarnish what would otherwise be a solid piece of media. So, what does all this have to do with Big Trouble in Little China? OK, well, BTILT is 1986 film with a screenplay that was originally by Gary Goldman and David Z. Weinstein as a western before it was entirely re-written by W.D. Richter. You might know Ritcher as the screenwriter of the highly political remake of Invasion of the Body Snatchers and the director of The Adventures of Buckaroo Banzai Across the 8th Dimension, a film that both is a sci-fi movie and a commentary on sci-fi itself. Big Trouble was directed by John “I Have Things to Say” Carpenter. Keep these creators in mind when we stumble through the socio-political commentary and genre-referencing narrative of Big Trouble in Little China.       
 AUDIO 2
 Depending on how you witnessed the movie, the protagonist of the film is either Jack Burton due to him being the point of view character, fish out of the water to whom the plot is explained and owner of the most screen time or Wang Chi the character who has the most at stake from the beginning of the film and is significantly more competent than Jack at actually getting shit done. Jack is portrayed as a buffoon – a criticism of the muscle-headed and almost always white action hero of the time who stuck his nose in where it didn't belong and saved the locals with the power of, well, being cast as the hero. Jack can't do anything right. He boasts about how great he is and never really backs it up, he is the least competent among his crew and he has no idea what's going on at any given time. Jack is...America. A naïve but powerful entity that butts into internal matters in other cultures. Jack does the least amount of work and hogs all the credit. This is a common reading of the film, and based on both the screenwriter and director, it's probably at least partially intentional. Jack is an oaf. He has one redeeming quality – his reflexes.   
 This is planted early in the film and paid off toward the end when he catches a knife and kills David Lo Pan, the chief antagonist of the film. Bear in mind that immediate prior to this [10 seconds ago], Jack missed his first attempt and only managed to get the job done due to being able to call a cosmic mulligan. Afterward, he boasts about his reflexes to his love interest like Lego Batman. [First Try!] So, that's pretty self-reflective for 1986, right? The only white man in the movie pretends to be the hero all the while the text of the film tells the audience that he most certainly is not and that the people who actually know about their own culture know how to deal with their cultural-specific problem. [You tried] You tried. But, it's not that simple. Orientalism is a way of depicting people of Asian origin that exaggerates and distorts differences of Asian people and culture as compared to that of Europe and United States. It generally involves seeing Asian cultures as exotic, primitive and dangerous. There are other uses of this term used in art and history, but the focus here is on the version of orientalism that reduces people of “the East” to cultural signifiers and stereotypes for the consumption of audiences in “the West.”   
 AUDIO 3
 The context of Big Trouble in Little China is different from a lot of these “exotic and dangerous” type films – especially considering Big Trouble cast actual actors of Asian heritage and NOT white men in yellowface like in many other films -- but the superficial cultural signifiers are still there. Way back in 1986, Sharon Ching of the Los Angeles Times wrote “Chinese for Affirmative Action and other members of Asian media groups say it is unlikely that a white man would come into an Asian community to save the day. They also say that director John Carpenter's comedy adventure, which had mediocre box office figures its first five days ... is racist and will encourage anti-Asian prejudices among young moviegoers.” Henry Der, at the time Executive Director for San Francisco's Chinese for Affirmative Action said “That's one thing we have to remember--it's a white script written for a white audience . . . the movie is still a white man's product." Critics were similarly unkind to this aspect of the film. Roger Ebert famously wrote of the film:   
 “This movie is straight out of the era of Charlie Chan and Fu Manchu, with no apologies and all of the usual stereotypes. ... 'Big Trouble in Little China' is just one more example of the way every American ethnic group has been fodder for Hollywood's mill.” Some have argued that the film's presentation of a trivial and caricatured vision of Asian culture from the perspective of Jack Burton might imply that this curated form of racism only exists for Americans who are fascinating by the hyperbolic and untrue version of Asian culture. But on the other other hand, is that how it's going to come across to the audience? And are we giving intent too much credit here? Isn't it more significant how it's going to be witnessed and internalized by the audience? The perspective of “Maybe that's the point!” feels defensive and uncritical, even dismissive of orientalism and the historical portrayals of people of Asian descent in American films. Ethnic groups are not monolithic, and individuals within said groups can differ wildly in opinion, meaning that while some Asian-Americans despised the film, some have defended it.   
 AUDIO 4
 I love Big Trouble in Little China. It's one of my favorite childhood films, but it would be kind of arrogant of me to dismiss the actual concerns of the groups that are portrayed in the film by saying “Oh, you just don't get it!” Big Trouble in Little China is infinitely more self-aware of its tropes than the average action film, and because of this, a solid argument can be made that it's not as problematic as its contemporaries or similar movies that contain some of the same DNA. But that alone can't be enough to dismiss actual, equally legitimate criticism about its caricatured portrayal of Chinese culture. My point...is that it can be both. Positive and negative elements in a movie are not mutually exclusive. If Bram Stoker's Dracula can have a really good acting performance and a really bad acting performance than Big Trouble in Little China can have a socially aware element and a socially oblivious element. The Outcast can be both a step forward in representation and also a step that stumbles and lands on its face. And Big Trouble in Little China can be both better than its analogues in terms of representation and also not nearly good enough.
 A movie with problematic elements doesn't necessarily need to be thrown in the garbage, and I'm not interested in “canceling” John Carpenter, but said problematic elements should be addressed so that further progress can be made. Ignoring something doesn't make it better. It never has. And I recognize that I'm not the best person to make this particular argument. My white ass doesn't know better than the people actually affected by this, but I hope that by being a decent ally and signal-boosting this concern, I have done my small part. And if not, well, I tried. 


WHISPER OF THE HEART

 AUDIO 1
 Back in June of last year, rapper and living meme Kanye West told The New York Times that he was learning how to not be on his medication for bipolar disorder. At the time, he claimed that he had only taken his medication once in the previous week. In October, during a meeting with Donald Trump of all people, West apparently told the President that his bipolar must be some kind of misdiagnosis and that his erratic, self-destructive behavior that landed him in the hospital with a psychiatric hold in 2016 was nothing to be concerned about. West is promoting one of mental health's most frequent and dangerous myths: that suffering is necessary for great art and that great artists are creative geniuses with mental illness – and that these illnesses should go untreated so that the public can have the most raw of the artist's creative output. Esmé Weijun Wang, a with schizoaffective disorder has said of this myth “It may be true that mental illness has given me insights with which to work, creatively speaking, but it’s also made me too sick to use that creativity. The voice in my head that says ‘Die, die, die’ is not a voice that encourages putting together a short story.”   
 I think that's what I like the most about Whisper of the Heart, a 1995 film directed by Yoshikumi Kondo and written by Hayao Miyazaki. It's about a teenage girl named Shizuku who loves to read and write. She shared her creative works with her friends, meets a boy named Seiji, becomes both envious of and enamored with Seiji's artistic talent with the violin, and eventually decides to become a writer. She works hard on her high school entrance exams so that she can get into a good school, learn more about writing and become better at her eventual profession. It's a movie about having passion for your art and trying to go about it in the best way possible to improve upon your work, accept constructive criticism, learn more and develop your talent. That's how most art...happens. It's sometimes the product of trauma, but it's more often the product of hard work, imagination, education and uses life experiences – both bad AND good – to develop art that feels real and meaningful due to the passion and learned skills of the artist. The idea that art comes from pain has ancient origins, but in modern times, the myth has been propagated by coverage of celebrities and by portrayals in popular media.
 AUDIO 2
 History is full of creative people who also battled their own personal demons. Sylvia Plath died by suicide, putting her head in a gas oven, strangely predicted a month prior by her only novel, The Bell Jar. Virginia Wolf drowned herself. There are endless other examples. [The Phantom Thread] Perhaps because of this and because of the image of the tortured artist is so captivating for audiences, [Loving Vincent] Movies and television often portray the “tortured, creative genius” character – a spectacular artist with a mental disorder that “helps” them create provocative art. [clip of Joker] The tortured, creative genius who lashes out, behaves erratically and has wild mood swings all in the name of passion has become a tired trope in popular media. This image, whether produced in the real world or in fiction, has created the myth that pain is a necessary ingredient for art. We love Amy Winehouse and Kurt Cobain, and we say that their pain produced their greatest work. And that if they died young, it was somehow worth it for the enjoyment of others, as if celebrating a kind of human sacrifice, a morbid ceremony in which the only result is a song.
 The scientific data surrounding all of this “creative genius with a mental disorder” stuff is mixed, at best. There is research suggesting that people with bipolar disorder, as well as the healthy siblings of people with bipolar disorder or schizophrenia often have creative occupations. But other experts say that results showing a link between creativity and mental illness are unconvincing. Such experts point to small sample sizes and a dependence on self-reported biographical data from the subjects. Even research with large sample sizes is often criticized for failing to set up objective measures of what we consider “creativity.” Dr. Lloyd Sederer, a medical director of New York State Mental Health, explained "There are plenty of geniuses who are not mentally ill, and there are plenty of mentally ill people who aren't geniuses. … Sometimes you have the two combined. When you have geniuses who have such prominence, like Philip Seymour Hoffman or Robin Williams or John Nash, they make you think that this is more common than it is. One in four people annually in this country has a mental illness that impairs their function. That's pretty common. The illness is pervasive. Genius is much more rare."  
  AUDIO 3  
  Let's remove the word “genius” from the mix. Most people who work in the creative fields are good at what they do NOT because of some curse from birth that plagues their minds and forces them into the dark recesses of their souls. Artists generally become good at what they do through good instruction and hard work – like anything else. Shizuku is a writer. She writes lyrics and stories. She gets criticism – some constructive and some not – and later in the film, she submits some of her work to an old man who tells her that she has potential but needs refinement. That's how artists get better. That's how anyone gets better at anything. Shizuku has problems in her life, but they are mostly external and the result of growing up – not some dark, internal suffering. When an artist is good at what they do, they are deified in the media, labeled “genius” – doubly so if they die young. This creates some circuitous logic. People think “Well, pain is what makes good art. And this artist who died young was obviously in great pain. So, their art, too, must be great. Therefore, this dead artist must be a genius, and the more they suffer, the better art they will give us!” Yikes.  
 OK. Let's focus on garden variety people in creative occupations who may or may not have mental disorders. See, there still exists a few other problems with the research and the perception of the tortured artist. One is that anxiety, depression and suicidal ideation may not be linked with a subject's creativity but could be the result of working in the stressful environment of a creative field. Working in a creative environment can affect mental health and lead to the spreading of the tortured, creative genius image. The creative sectors are riddled with poor conditions, high-pressured environments, long hours and low wages. In Whisper of the Heart, this is referenced when Shizuku and her father have a heart to heart about the young girl wanting to focus on her writing. The father says that choosing this path will be more difficult than others. In addition to all the other problems mentioned, Shizuku will face unstable employment and a lack of respect among professionals with careers not in the creative fields. Her mother is initially not very encouraging of her decision. But more than that, people in creative fields will often be told to “Get a real job!” even if said job pays the bills more than the person shouting the insult.    
  AUDIO 4  
 They will be told that art isn't real and that the artist should only make art for free and that artists should not be paid. Imagine if that were true. Imagine if every piece of art you love, say, your favorite movie, was made by volunteers. You can't, can you? Because the movie would not exist. The challenge of the creative fields can cause anxiety – it is not anxiety that steers people toward art. The truth is that the vast majority of your favorite television shows and movies were not created by creative geniuses standing on the precipice of the abyss. It was not pain, suffering and suicidal ideation that created Star Wars and The Lord of the Rings. Most of everything you love was made NOT from someone while slumped in a corner having a panic attack. It was made through incredible effort. Most of everything you love was not made because of pain but because of desire. In Whisper of the Heart, Shizuku has a great passion for reading and writing. She loves books, and it is her love of books that makes her want to be a writer herself. An interest in the profession has made her want to join the profession. It's entirely organic. It's not the result of the so-called curse of creativity or a mental illness.    
 Also, if we are being real here, sometimes people join creative fields because they learn they have a good mind for it, and they just need to pay the bills. Labor is not always emotional. Sometimes it's just labor. … SO. In December, Kanye West said that he was off his medication for the past six months. According to his tweets, he believes this is in service to making new music. Among people who deal with mental-health issues, it’s mostly people who experience mania who complain that their medication robs them of their creativity. This people in creative fields who also have bipolar disorder at particular risk for quitting medication. During mania, the disorder creates a natural high, and those in creative fields spend hours working on their projects, but productivity alone does not necessarily create anything, well, good. But during mania, this euphoria tricks the mind into believing the creative output must be amazing. This leads people with bipolar disorder to believe this is their superpower, as West himself as explicitly said. Those around creative people with mental disorders often enable this behavior, and that leads to a lot of high-profile celebrity deaths. I'm glad that there is media out there to informs people about the joys of the creative process, but it is surrounded by dangerous nonsense and myths that quite literally get people killed. More Whisper of the Heart, less...everything else, please. 


MO' BETTER BLUES


 AUDIO 1
 Aww, nooooo. Alright, so, this is how my show used to work. Episodes would happen by paid request. You pay, you request a movie, and then I fulfill the request in the order in which they are received. I don't do that anymore, I closed requests late last year, but I still have a couple left in my backlog. So, by coincidence, my schedule has me doing a video essay on Mo' Better Blues, a Spike Lee joint, mere days after Spike Lee won his Oscar for best adapted screenplay but was then noticeably upset by the victory for racism-movie-for-white-people Green Book. He walked OUT of the Oscars and deservedly so. Media got on his case for it, but fuck, if Spike Lee wants to walk out of the Oscars after the announcement of the worst Best Picture since Crash – another racism-movie-for-white people – then he can. I stand with Spike Lee on this, and I feel extra special shitty that by happenstance alone, I have to talk about the movie in which he mostly infamously trafficked in hurtful, wrong-headed messaging: Mo' Better Blues. I feel like I'm going to catch heat for this, especially this week, but this is my job and I have to suck it up.
 But yeah, Mo' Better Blues is not the height of Spike Lee's work, and it's not just because the film is kind of a drag but because of the Jewish caricatures used in the film that landed him in hot water with the Anti-Defamation League. When you look at Spike Lee's movies, you can see how thoughtful he is as it relates to racial dynamics. Do the Right Thing gave a sincere glimpse into racial tensions in America, School Daze showed us clashing attitudes in black communities, Chi-raq is an unflinching look at urban gang wars. And his consistent thoughtfulness is what makes his portrayal of the Flatbush brothers that much more uncomfortable. Because Spike Lee is NOT some ignorant, privileged individual who never pays much mind to portrayals of marginalized people on screen. In fact, Mo Better Blues itself is a reaction to seeing movies about jazz musicians' tragic lives made by white people and not doing them justice. That's NOT to say his films should somehow be held to a higher standard, that would be unfair, but that doesn't make the fact that it's Spike Lee doing this any less shocking. It would be like if Tom Hanks robbed a liquor store.   
 AUDIO 2
 He shouldn't be held to a higher standard as anyone else, but it would also be really fucking weird if that story started trending on Twitter. The Flatbush brothers are presented as crooked, conniving, Jewish stereotypes. The high-pitched whine in the way they speak, their odd gestures, their cruel, selfish, almost diabolical greed paint the picture of the propagandist's view of Jews. Lee was hit by the Anti-Defamation League for this wildly offensive caricature, and he didn't help his case by brushing it off in interviews, once trafficking in the “Jews secretly have more power than you think” conspiracy theory by saying that his movies can't be anti-semetic because “the Jews” would not allow his picture to be made in Hollywood. Yikes. The phrase "Jews control Hollywood" is the favored anti-Semitic refrain from everyone from the Henry Ford-owned Dearborn Independent back in the 1920's to modern day dog whistles from conservative politicians and pundits about “Hollywood values” poisoning “Christian values” in America. Yeah, OK. I see what you did there. The Anti-Defamation League website quoted a 1995 article by Steven G. Kellman, a professor at the University of Texas in San Antonio, who wrote:    
 "Boosters and anti-Semites agree: Jews have been prominent and predominant in all phases of the business: production, distribution and exhibition. … Though individual Jews control Hollywood, Jewishness does not." The problem with the line about “Jews controlling Hollywood” is that it's not about statistics because, yes, there are a lot of Jewish executives in Hollywood compared to the relatively small percentage of Jewish Americans in general. The problem with the line about “Jews controlling Hollywood” is that it is never said benignly. It's an accusation, as if the high percentage of Jews in studio positions in Hollywood is a scary “problem” rather than a bit of trivia. It is said in conspiratorial, hushed tones and often accompanied by more overt propaganda meant to make Americans who are not Jewish afraid of a Jewish threat. Nobody says “Jews control Hollywood. Isn't that neat? Why, back in the early 20th century...” and then go off about the history of Hollywood and how influential Jews were in creating the motion picture industry we all love today.   
 AUDIO 3
 No. It's always either said as a bludgeon or, at best, said as a bad joke. And this kind of thing is never said about institutions and industries in America that are dominated by Christians. When Congress, which is predominantly Protestant, fails to pass a spending bill, nobody says “Well, the Protestants sure did screw up again.” because the spending bill is unrelated to the religions of the Representatives. When the automobile industry recalls one of their models due to it being unsafe, nobody scoffs and calls it the “gentile car industry.” Portraying Jewish businessmen as greedy to the point of being inhuman feeds into the idea that the entertainment industry is someone “worse off” because it has a Jewish percentage higher than one would expect. The phrase "Jews control Hollywood" is considered dangerous in a world where most Americans still view so-called “Hollywood values” with suspicion. Spike Lee did NOT say that Jews secretly run the world or show that octopus drawing that anti-semites like to use, but by brushing up against the related suspicion of Jews who have media influence in America, it helps further that along more than it hinders.    
  In Lee's defense, I think he actually knows that – he certainly has more firsthand experience with overt prejudice than I do – but as I've noted in other videos, directors can get pretty defensive in their interviews. I'm willing to chalk this up to that, and if you can't sense my discomfort, I really don't want to be the arbiter of justice as it pertains to Spike Lee. But this...happened and I don't think anyone likes the idea of ignoring it either. [sighs] I am tired. 


JAMES BOND EXAMINED


 INTRODUCTION
 AUDIO 1
 Did you know that James Bond was named after an ornithologist? No, really. Novelist and naval intelligence officer Ian Fleming named the most famous fictional secret agent after a scientist in a book he kept handy. Fleming once said of Bond “I wanted the simplest, dullest, plainest-sounding name I could find, 'James Bond' was much better than something more interesting, like 'Peregrine Carruthers'. Exotic things would happen to and around him, but he would be a neutral figure—an anonymous, blunt instrument wielded by a government department." It's just a bit of trivia I learned while researching James Bond and watching every canonical film from beginning to end. I am very tired. Of the origins of his personality, Fleming once remarked that Bond was a composite of all the secret agents and commando types he met during his naval service in World War II. It is perhaps because of this composite and this tabula rasa of a personality that Fleming instilled upon 007 that the character can be seen as a vestigial arm of the United Kingdom. By the creator's own admission, he is less man than tool.
 If Bond is a blunt instrument to be used by queen and country with no discernible personality of his own, then it stands to reason that he is intended to have goals, politics and values that are extensions of the United Kingdom as well. Not necessarily its people but its government. If Bond is what he was intended to be, then examining the ways in which he is portrayed as it relates to politics – both social and governmental -- is not only acceptable but necessary in understanding what we, the audience, are actually witnessing on screen. So, if Bond is a blunt instrument for the UK, then what is he assaulting? I hope, throughout the course of this video essay, that I can answer that question AND make it clear what Bond has come to represent. Let's begin.   
 I. James Bond the Imperialist
 AUDIO 1
 Imperialism is the practice of extending the power and reach of a nation through invasion, and acquisition of territory through economic influence. A nation's power is increased this way through military intervention, occupation, a coup to remove someone unfriendly to the nation's interests, espionage, sabotage and any other overt use of power to expand the economy and territory – to become not only a nation but an empire. Imperialism is not only practice, it is policy. It won't necessarily be written into a nation's constitution as the public standard operating procedure, but it is policy in the sense that it is frequently employed and justified through nationalism, patriotism and sometimes through concealment of the more subtle actions like espionage and coups. A western power conquering territory and claiming it as a moral good is an example of both imperialism and propaganda justifying imperialism. Colonialism is a related policy of controlling this new territory, often from afar, and snatching power from the indigenous people, making them either second class citizens or removing citizenry outright in favor of enslavement.    
 If James Bond is what his creator explicitly said he is and the movies implicitly show him to be, then he is a figure whose purposes are to protect the practice of imperialism for as long as possible during the waning days of the British Empire and to safeguard capitalism in the face of a looming communist threat. World War II effectively left the UK bankrupt. The British Empire was crumbling under the weight of its smaller wallet and anti-colonial revolutions that it simply did not have the funds to fight. People were fighting back, and they were broke. The United States supported the United Kingdom with their imperialist ambitions for a while if it meant ruffling the feathers of communists states, but ultimately, the UK disengaged from many its colonies over the course of the mid to late 20th century. It wasn't until the 1997 handover ceremony in which the UK gave up Hong Kong to China that the Empire had finally and truly ended.    
  AUDIO 2  
 Throughout this decrease in international power and influence, there was Bond: boldly fighting communists, terrorists and racist caricatures of people who the UK had previously colonized and subjugated. In You Only Live Twice, Bond disguises himself in yellowface. It's all too easy to dismiss outrage over this racial insensitivity as “hoping to be offended.” Well, “offense” all on its own isn't the problem. Why it bothers people and what it is conveying and influencing both matter. So, let's talk about that. All on its own, yellowface reflects an ethnocentric perception of East Asians rather than the authentic depictions of their culture. Yellowface is reductive and portrays East Asians as broad caricatures. These images infect popular consciousness and influence the way we think about people, even to the point of thinking about them not as people at all but as the caricature. But it's especially troublesome when you consider the United Kingdom's history in Asia, more specifically in China.    The British market loved their tea and silk but did not have enough silver to trade with the Qing Empire. Instead, they bartered with opium that the British took from India.    
 The Qing government in China and British markets began to clash in what became known as the Opium Wars, which I assure you is not as cool as it sounds. The increase in opium in China from 1790 to 1832 created a generation of addicts, and the wars themselves cost of the lives of thousands upon thousands of people. The result of this was British control of aforementioned Hong Kong. So, a movie about a British agent in yellowface has an added level of cringe to it. Live and Let Die takes place partly in the Caribbean. British colonial efforts in the Caribbean included but was not limited to exploiting the islands for sugar. The plantation system and the slave trade led to regular slave resistance in many Caribbean islands throughout the colonial era. In the film, MI6 agents are killed in a Caribbean nation, prompting the involvement of James Bond. The film of course depicts these killings as despicable rather than referencing the fact that these agents were conducting espionage on a sovereign nation. Such a nation would have good reason to believe that MI6 is either plotting a coup or plotting to destabilize a power that does not share its economic interests because that is the consistent track record of the UK and its ally, the US.    
  
  AUDIO 3  
 The less said about James Bond infiltrating India in Octopussy, the better. [pause] Actually, you know what? That's kind of a cop-out. Let's talk about India. The British crown ruled India from 1858 to 1947. Although, prior to that, The British East India controlled the nation for about a century. By 1890 about 6,000 British officials ruled 250 million Indians. [1:28:00] In 1919, when peaceful protesters defied a government order and demonstrated against British colonial rule, they were blocked inside the walled Jallianwala Gardens and fired upon by Gurkha soldiers. Under the orders of Brigadier Reginald Dyer, the soldiers kept firing until they ran out of ammunition, killing as many as a thousand protesters and injuring another thousand within about 10 minutes. Dyer was praised as a hero by the British public [you tried] who raised 26,000 pounds for him as a thank you for killing so many Indians. Kind of like a GoFundMe for a massacre. What a great man. Depending on who you ask, between 12 and 29 million Indians died of starvation while it was under the control of the British Empire, as millions of tons of wheat were taken from India and sent to Britain.    
 In 1943 alone, up to four million Bengalis starved to death when good ol' Winston Churchill diverted food to British soldiers and countries such as Greece while a deadly famine swept through Bengal. Of the famine in 1943, Churchill exclaimed “I hate Indians. They are a beastly people with a beastly religion. The famine was their own fault for breeding like rabbits. … Let the Viceroy sit on the back of a giant elephant and trample Gandhi into the dirt.” In 1947, with the British Empire losing India, Cyril Radcliffe was tasked with drawing the border between India and the newly created state of Pakistan over the course of a single lunch. That is not a joke. Radcliffe split the subcontinent along religious lines – India for the Hindus and Pakistan for the Muslims. This uprooted over 10 million people. This meant that Hindus in Pakistan and Muslims in India were forced to escape their homes. Radcliffe's parting gift to India was to create an incredibly violent and dangerous situation. Some estimates suggest up to one million people lost their lives in sectarian killings. To this day, many British citizens see their oppression of India as a net positive for Indians.    
  AUDIO 4  
 Shashi Tharoor, author of Inglorious Empire, finds the argument that modernisation could not have taken place in India without British imperialism to be galling. In response to the claim by Niall Ferguson that the empire laid the foundations for eventual success in a future globalised world, Tharoor rightly countered with this: “Ferguson also suggests that, in the long run, the victims of British imperialism will prove to have been its beneficiaries, since the Empire laid the foundations for their eventual success in tomorrow’s globalized world. But human beings do not live in the long run; they live, and suffer, in the here and now, and the process of colonial rule in India meant economic exploitation and ruin to millions, the destruction of thriving industries, the systematic denial of opportunities to compete, the elimination of indigenous institutions of governance, the transformation of lifestyles and patterns of living that had flourished since time immemorial, and the obliteration of the most precious possessions of the colonized, their identities and their self-respect.” James Bond's forays into other countries without their permission to perform covert operations with an iron-clad license to kill makes for a potentially exciting premise.    
 But also a solid portrayal of imperialism shown in a very personal way – with one agent – rather than how it is generally employed: with massive armies and intelligence operations involving many people. Bond becomes a kind of avatar for imperialism. It's important to note that Bond's actions are rarely if ever seen as questionable to the audience. They are aspirational. When we see these depictions, we have to ask ourselves: Who or what is the target, and who is creating this portrayal? These movies are not critical of British imperialism. These are uncritical action movies in which imperialism is a fun romp. It doesn't hold a mirror up to society if the target is the victim. It trivializes the victim. I know from experience discussing this in the past, when these concepts are brought to light, someone always says “Well, what about movies made in those very countries? Don't they often depict the English and Americans badly?” Yeah, maybe. Bollywood probably depicts the British unfavorably at times. But to claim this is the same is a false equivalency.
 AUDIO 5
 People of color depicting those who have historically colonized and enslaved them is not the same as a UK film depicting the people who they colonized and enslaved. It might look similar on the surface but only if you completely ignore context and history. If someone violently attacks you and you have to employ violence as a means of self-defense to save your life, you and your attacker are both technically being violent, but your self-defense is more justified than the violence of the aggressor. Only a Sith deals in absolutes, and context is for Kings. People who wish to dismiss these issues always call it people “being offended.” The problem with Bond as the avatar of imperialism isn't simple “offense.” The problem is what it projects as “good” and “civilized” and what it projects as “bad” and [Churchill] “beastly.”   
 
 II. James Bond the Anti-Intellectual   
 AUDIO 1
 The United States and the United Kingdom are noticeably different in parliamentary composition, laws about firearm ownership, healthcare and other aspects that make up the lives of citizens in differing nations, but the US and UK share similar cultural attitudes as they relate to the bones of their national identities: capitalism and imperialism being among the most obvious and demonstrable but also attitudes as they relate to gender roles, traditionalism, nationalism and reactionary perspectives as they relate to immigration, terrorism and other boogeymen of the west. Many of the cultural similarities between the US and the UK are embodied in James Bond, a figure who is both inherently British and containing qualities, attitudes, attributes and worldviews beloved by and/or espoused by Americans. Because of this, Bond is not seen as “foreign” in America because without the accent or the references to serving MI6, the paradoxical world famous secret agent is as welcomed in American pop culture as he is in his country of origin. One quality of Bond that is perhaps even more American than British is that of anti-intellectualism.
 Anti-intellectualism is a variety of ideas and attitudes that have points of convergence. For one, it's a hostility and explicit mistrust of anyone of anything perceived as intellectual for fear that it or they are out of touch with common concerns or have nefarious intentions. Anti-intellectualism positions itself as a populist movement, generally right-wing, and seeks to damage or discredit academia and scientific research for its own goals. Populism, at its core, is a style of rhetoric that positions two powers in the public discourse: the people and the elites. However, populism as a right-wing tactic ignores the actual people vs. elites – meaning the poor and the rich respectively –  and cobbles together “the elites” as bookworm socialists, tenured professors, and really anyone who lives in major cities. [“New York City?!”] If you have ever heard American politicians tell rural voters that people from New York City and Washington DC are out of touch with “real America” – you have heard what is essentially populist rhetoric.   
 AUDIO 2
 These mistakenly labeled elites – the bookish twenty-something earning $10 an hour and reading Marx at a Starbucks or the professor with the audacity to teach African-American studies -- don't actually wield greater societal power than the politicians who condemn them or the billionaires who supply said politicians' coffers, but in framing them as if they do, the targets of this rhetoric – voters – might believe it just enough to support said rhetoric and the other goals of the populist, right-wing politician. In short, anti-intellectual rhetoric does not frame being “smart” or “correct” as bad or dangerous. Rather it frames so-called intellectuals as peddlers of false ideas and actually not “smart” or “correct” and that the genuinely correct people are whoever the politician wants as their voting block. It's an attractive idea, to be told that you are more correct and smart than the people who society says are the most educated. And that's how anti-intellectualism intersects with populism. At its most extreme, anti-intellectualism is utilized in totalitarian governments, such as fascist Italy and Germany. Benito Mussolini praised men “of action” – fascism is intertwined with a kind of chauvinism and cult of strength.   
 Intellectuals, in contrast, are portrayed as weak. The diminishment and mockery of education has the intended side-effect of keeping the populace uneducated and also unwilling to confront those in power for fear their perceived unacceptance of this status quo will be viewed as born of reading too much and knowing too much. [Simpsons: Let's make litter out of these literati!] This is shown in microcosm in the battle of wits and antagonistic relationship between James Bond – man of action – and Q, the quartermaster, inventor and top nerd of MI6. Q, a title and not a name, is head of Q Branch. Some version of Q has appeared in every Bond film, with a few exceptions like Live and Let Die and the first two Daniel Craig Bond films, Casino Royale and Quantum of Solace, perhaps as an attempt to distance the rebooted franchise from the gadgetry, light sci-fi elements and camp that had become targets of mockery in the Austin Powers movies. [Sharks with frickin' laser beams.] Despite both serving MI6 and with no real reason to have any personal animus toward one another, Q sees Bond as a nuisance more than anything else.   
 AUDIO 3
 Conversely, Bond figuratively rolls his eyes at Q's inventions while still benefiting from them, all the while taking jabs at Q himself. Q's personal distaste for Bond is referenced as being protective of his nerdy inventions, which Bond often damages or outright destroys in the course of saving the world. Bond is largely unsympathetic and cooly dismisses Q's concerns with his trademark smugness and alpha male sense of superiority over the impotent bookworm archetype that is Q. Bond himself is intelligent and well-traveled, but his intelligence never broaches the barrier of “nerd-dom.” His abilities are practical – for example, his knowledge of other languages helps him assassinate representatives of powers unfriendly to his country. Either that or to seduce women. Bond is far from an oaf, but his intelligence is always displayed as the “right” way to be smart for those who traffic in anti-intellectualism. His cunning is sometimes showcased more as street smarts, particularly in the Daniel Craig Bond era. Bond went to university, but his education has gone into service of his country and by extension values like nationalism and imperialism.   
 He didn't become an “artist” or a “professor” or a “scientist” or any of the other professions for whom anti-intellectuals show such disdain. Bond may have studied at Cambridge, but he would be damned if he ever took courses in “gender studies.” Bond is smart in the way that Q is not: Bond is cool and uses practical knowledge to achieve practical goals, the way that the anti-intellectual chooses to see himself.  These ideas certainly do not come from James Bond, it's merely representative of these ideas. Although the popularity of media like this has done nothing to curtail it. Anti-intellectualism as public policy and popular thought was furthered in the United States and the United Kingdom not by the fascists that the two nations helped defeat in World War II but by their own internal cultures and reaction to the Cold War, a recurring backdrop in the Bond films.    
  AUDIO 4  
 Intellectualism began to be synonymous in the McCarthy era with “communism” – all these intellectuals reading Marx in university and questioning the capitalist and imperialist dogmas of the west. In Ian Fleming’s early novels, Bond was explicitly a weapon to be used against the Communists. In the films, Bond more often faced off against SPECTRE, but during the Cold War, the imaginations of the audience would undoubtedly replace SPECTRE with the Soviet Union. There are other more explicit Cold War references in the film series. In the decade prior to the earliest Bond films of the 1960's, anti-intellectualism was given the stamp of approval by celebrity figures and politicians.  In 1954, President Eisenhower said “I heard a definition of an intellectual that I thought was very interesting: a man who takes more words than are necessary to tell more than he knows.” Oh, Ike's got jokes. According to Richard Hofstadter, author of Anti-Intellectualism in American Life, “The right-wing crusade of the 1950's was full of heated rhetoric about 'Havard professors, twisted-thinking intellectuals...in the State Department'; those who are 'burdened with Phi Beta Kappa keys and academic honors' … those who try to fight Communism 'with kid gloves in perfumed drawing rooms'”
 Much of this anti-intellectualism is Amero-centric, but the United States and the United Kingdom don't simply share certain cultural attitudes: they share media. British theaters are flooded with American films. The James Bond films may be partly the property of EON Films, a British film production company, but they are generally co-produced by MGM, an American media company, and distributed by the likes of 20th Century Fox (among others) over the years. The US and UK also trade in politics. The policies of both Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher in the 1980's, for example, are seen as complementary. James Bond is a product of the 1950's – his first fictional adventures appearing in novels from that era: the decade of the rise of anti-intellectualism as popular convention. By the 1962, Dr. No, the first Bond film, was a smash.    
  AUDIO 5  
   In Goldeneye, Bond expresses his opinion of the new M in anti-intellectual terms, claiming his instincts are greater than her research, analysis and calculations: [clip of “bean counter, the thought had occurred to me.”] The audience is meant to side with Bond here, reinforcing his anti-intellectual dogwhistles as correct. Framing is critical, and the Bond films do not frame 007's bravado as a negative. Depiction does not equal endorsement, of course, but the films are framed for Bond to be right, for M to be wrong or at least less right, and for the audience to sympathize with Bond and therefore his implied worldview. Let this be perfectly clear: this does not mean that Bond is an anti-intellectual because he, well, travels, and stays in shape or even because shoots people for queen and country. Bond being a “man of action” merely makes him attractive to those with pre-existing anti-intellectual views pre-dating Bond. The character need not openly declare “I am an anti-intellectual” whilst winking at the camera. But that's because he never needs to in order for his role as the avatar of this worldview to be clear to the audience. Bond merely needs to exist as Bond in order to be the hero of the anti-intellectual.    
  He doesn't think, he acts, and when he does think, it's about sex or something acceptable to adopters of this worldview like effective ways to ward off bad guys – especially communists or entities that audiences would liken to communism due to not knowing enough about communism. He's never portrayed as unintelligent. He's portrayed as “above” intelligence, wryly smirking as the know-it-all who rebukes know-it-alls. He's suave and well-dressed, which means he does NOT fit the “salt of the Earth” type that anti-intellectualism positions as being correct, but his attitudes are more in line with the worldview and rhetoric than not, particularly as it relates to gender roles. Anti-intellectuals simply cannot resist mocking “gender studies” in universities and decrying feminism, socialism and anti-imperialism as being owned by “the elites” even though its opposites, meaning capitalism and imperialism, are utilized by the actual “elites”: governments with far-reaching military powers. This is what makes Bond an anti-intellectual hero. The politics that he, and by extension the films, express to the audience. Let's be clear about one more thing: the fact that Bond is attractive to people with this worldview does not mean he is exclusively attractive to people with this worldview. One can be opposed to the rise of anti-intellectualism and enjoy Bond films, but clearly this character has a certain demographic appeal. Oh, and leave Q alone. He gave you an invisible car, dude.   
 III. James Bond the Misogynist   
 AUDIO 1
 In Dr. No, James Bond breaks an unarmed woman's bones. In Goldfinger, he sacrifices this woman and then sexually assaults a lesbian before making her enjoy it through the power of his boner. In the novel, this is even more explicit, as Bond's rape of the lesbian is considered “corrective.” by Bond. In Thunderball, Bond tries to force himself on a woman, and then later convinces a woman to have sex with him or else she will be fired. The new James Bond assaults this woman in On Her Majesty's Secret Service. In Diamonds Are Forever, Bond takes off this woman's clothes and strangles her. In Live and Let Die, Bond uses a woman's religious beliefs to con her into sex. The Man with the Golden Gun features Bond assaulting another woman. Then we have The Living Daylights in which Bond strips a woman to distract someone else. In Skyfall, Bond learns a woman was sold into sex slavery when she was a child, which means she was repeatedly abused and raped her whole life and then makes a pass at her. And on and on and on. I assure you, that is the abridged version. One movie features objectification of women in the most literal sense of that word. The point is that when I say James Bond is a misogynist in this section, and I will a lot, I'm not talking about patting a woman on the keister or being a little insensitive in a way that is shameful but in keeping with the time it was made.   
 [zoom] It's far, far worse than that. Did I mention the corrective rape was set to romantic music? [clip] [title] I need a shower [/title] So, yeah, James Bond is a big gross creep beyond the limits of even what was considered misogynist in the 1960's. But what does all this mean in the context of broader ideas about gender roles pre-dating the Bonds that undoubtedly influenced said films? People often mistakenly define “misogyny” in simplest terms: a fear or hatred of women. The dictionary backs this up. Complex social systems, societal organizing, historically-codified behavior and systemic oppression all wrapped up in an emotion, a feeling. But this ignores said systems and the learned behavior that becomes the background radiation of life. Kate Manne, author of Down Girl: The Logic of Misogyny, defines the term more accurately: “There’s a tendency to define misogyny as this deep hatred in the heart, harbored by men towards girls and women. I define misogyny as social systems or environments where women face hostility and hatred because they’re women in a man's world — a historical patriarchy.” By mistakenly defining misogyny merely as a hatred of women, it opens up a bad faith counter-argument in favor of the misogynist.  
  AUDIO 2  
  “I can't be a misogynist,” he might say. “I love women!” This means that because the man who has been accused of misogynist behavior dates women, is married to a woman, has daughters or has a good relationship with his mother, he cannot be a misogynist. If misogyny only means hatred of women and the man associates with women either romantically or within the confines of his immediate family, then that man has his very own “get out of jail free” card when accusations are levied against him. It's the “I have a black friend” of misogynist defensiveness. Men who sometimes date black women can still be racist because racism is not about simple love and hate nor is it about sexual desire. It's about control over women as a social system, particularly when women are in what men consider to be “men's spaces,” which is really just any position of authority or even agency. Comparatively, men who date women are not somehow excused from being accused of misogyny. Heterosexuality has never been a tonic to cure misogyny. If it were, the dominant sexuality on Earth would have prevented misogyny from existing since the beginning of the species. As it obviously has not, this defense is bunk, and if this defense is bunk, then it stands to reason that misogyny is more than “hating” women.    
 In real life, misogynists are rarely as brazen as the fictional James Bond. This is because misogynists generally believe they are in the moral right by preserving a status quo that feels correct to them. They want to be socially and morally correct, and by enforcing misogyny as status quo, they can achieve this. A lot of misogynistic behavior is directed toward women who violate patriarchal norms and expectations or who aren't serving male interests in the ways in which they are expected. [Peterson] Misogynists rarely admit to their misogyny because the invisible hierarchies that govern our social behavior are unquestioned by those benefit from them. They believe if the hierarchy has been violated, women are being morally objectionable or have the incorrect attitude. If women have been cast as “subordinates” or “support” for men over the centuries, then this hostility toward their own agency comes from the alarm of being “usurped” or “neglected.” From the aforementioned book, Kate Manne gives this schematic illustration: “Imagine a person in a restaurant who expects not only to be treated deferentially— the customer always being right— but also to be served the food he ordered attentively, and with a smile.   
 AUDIO 3
 He expects to be made to feel cared for and special, as well as to have his meal brought to him (a somewhat vulnerable position, as well as a powerful one, for him to be in). Imagine now that this customer comes to be disappointed— his server is not serving him, though she is waiting on other tables. Or perhaps she appears to be lounging around lazily or just doing her own thing, inexplicably ignoring him. Worse, she might appear to be expecting service from him, in a baffling role reversal. Either way, she is not behaving in the manner to which he is accustomed in such settings. It is easy to imagine this person becoming confused, then resentful.” James Bond offers a power fantasy to heterosexual men, not only in terms of the obvious power of his fighting prowess and high-tech gadgets but a fantasy of “power” over women. The Bond girls are subservient to him. He treats them and mistreats them as he pleases. Now you might counter with examples of strong women in Bond films, but even “strong” women with minds of their own eventually fall to his charms.   
 In fact, it is in these strong women that the Bond films rebuke the agency of women the most. Their dalliances outside of gender norms are either punished by Bond or shown to be, in the end, less important than serving Bond sexually. It's important to note that these women – except in earlier cases – are shown to consent to Bond's sexual advances, but that is where the fantasy comes in. None of these characters are real. This isn't a documentary. The exchange between them is the fantasy of heterosexual men – all women wanting them – but also the ideology of misogyny being laid bare, a fantasy of worldview. In the end, all women want to be with Bond, and in the minds of misogynists, dominated by Bond. Even the “strong” women, especially the strong women. The only women Bond does not bed are Ms. Moneypenny, who is obsessed with Bond, and the Dame Judie Dench version of M, who the audience will undoubtedly view as too old for Bond. All other women are “entitled” to Bond. If a man has a sense of entitlement to women, he will be prone to hold women to false obligations. Please excuse my brief but necessary aside.   
 AUDIO 4
 Saying “Maybe it's satire!” in response to problematic content is not helpful when something is easily identifiable as sincere and not satire. When the films poke playful fun at Bond, that is not satire. At worst, it's a roast – jokes directed at a person or idea that do more to praise the person or idea and hand wave the faults instead of outright condemn. Satire criticizes. Satire condemns. Satire is opposed to something – it is not sympathetic to it.  For example, Most Wes Anderson movies are [title] NOT SATIRES of white people's problems because the films ultimately sympathize with those problems even if the films also playfully mock the characters in service of comedy. This is especially true if their character arcs and growth have nothing to do with what actually makes them problematic instead of what the director believes makes them problematic. Monty Python's Life of Brian is a satire of, as the troupe themselves admitted, “closed systems of thought” – the example in the film being absolute devotion to dogma above else, both religious or political. Life of Brian condemns. Bond films support. Bond films making jokes about the secret agent's promiscuity is not condemnation.   
 Even Die Another Day, the most self-referential of all Bond films, is at best a roast and not satire. Satire requires intent, a target and explicit criticism or condemnation. James Bond films do not satirize Bond's attitudes. Ian Flemming did not write his Bond novels as satirizing his own much-treasured naval service, and the producers of the James Bond films did not create over twenty films spanning over half a century to make you denounce saving the world and getting the girl. James Bond in film has always been portrayed as aspirational. The phrase “Maybe it's satire!” in response to problematic content in media is almost always in bad faith, a hand grenade thrown into the conversation with the intent of scattering the interlocuters in hopes of never having to think critically about said problematic content in media they enjoy. It's a cowardly move, and we have to be braver than that. There is a mild amount of self-reflection in Goldeneye, released in 1995, a full 33 years after the first Bond film, Dr. No, and 40 years from the first novel. M remarks on Bond's sexism in a blunt manner. His sexism, more cheerfully called “womanizing” back in the day, was only jokingly referenced by his superiors in previous films, often with a hint of envy. [re-entry]
 AUDIO 5
 However, this scene does not re-contextualize Bond because it's not biting enough. M is portrayed as cold and unfeeling, [text: stand-in for critics of Bond] like the anti-intellectual perception of the film series' real life critics, and Bond does not accept this criticism. Bond does not become a “satire” of earlier Bond from Goldeneye and going forward. Instead, this scene is a playful “roast” of Bond by the filmmakers – pointing out lovable flaws in the service of making the character or behavior endearing. The mild self-referential nature of later Bonds do little to re-contextualize earlier behavior because the filmmakers choose instead to ignore it or laugh harmlessly at it. Your favorite problematic content cannot be hand-waved as “satire” every time you don't want to acknowledge what it is actually communicating. End of brief but necessary aside. Does that about cover it? Well, an analysis of the text won't be enough for some people and want arguments from authority – the worst kind. So, OK. Do you know who else thinks James Bond is a misogynist? James Bond. Daniel Craig, whose comfort with the role has had peaks and valleys, once said “But let's not forget that he's actually a misogynist.    
 A lot of women are drawn to him chiefly because he embodies a certain kind of danger and never sticks around for too long.” But even the most recent Bond film, SPECTRE, starring the most self-aware Bond actor of them all, has traces of this. Bond's powers of seduction – his display of dominance of a woman – helps him further his cause. Depiction does not always equal endorsement, but James Bond's misogyny is generally framed that way for an audience all too eager to see their pre-existing beliefs re-affirmed by media. Bond is a misogynist because of the text of the film, and his misogyny is portrayed as either correct, laudable, aspirational or at least whimsical more often than it is framed as wrong.   
 
 CONCLUSION
 AUDIO 1
 So, for those in the back, James Bond is both a product of his time but also an unnatural extension of the values of those times that have either ended or should have ended. He is a blunt instrument, an empty vessel in which to inhabit the values, history and interests of the United Kingdom government. He is a misogynist, a low-key abuser and as an agent of the UK, he is also an agent who tacitly promotes imperialism. Bond is fictional, so the blame for this is not on him. Bond does not exist, he has no agency. What we are witnessing when we're watching a movie is not the ideas of fictional characters but of the culture than created them and the culture that endorses them. Bond was not only the fantasy of men who wished to be him and the women who presumably wished to be with him: he was the fantasy of a United Kingdom that still held the world at the edge of a sword. He is the reassertion of the dominant and aggressive gender role that had ever so slightly been chipped away by modern, progressive society in the west.   
 He is the sometimes smirking, sometimes sneering face of the “real man of action” that spits in the face of the intelligentsia. In conclusion, I will let M herself give my opinion on the Bond character and films, only when she says it in Goldeneye it is framed as cold or wrong, I would say it with conviction: [Sexist dinosaur, relic] Sounds about right. 

Comments

No comments found for this post.