SCRIPTS! (Patreon)
Content
OK, two things. First, I've turned on "community contributions" for my channel. Sadly, I am not fluent in any language besides English and can't properly write subtitles in Spanish, French or anything else. If you want to, you can now submit them.
Second, here are the latest scripts:
PARASOCIAL RELATIONSHIPS AND FAMILIAR STRANGERS
AUDIO 1
In the film Frank, Jon meets up the titular character, a musician with a papier-mâché mask that he wears – at all times – over his head. Jon joins Frank's band, and after a while, he begins uploading the recording sessions to Twitter and YouTube, exploding their popularity and getting them invited to South by Southwest. After a series of misadventures, Frank loses the mask, has a nervous breakdown and is coaxed back into reality by Jon and his band mates. The unusual relationship between performer and audience is the DNA of the film. The audience doesn't really know Frank, exacerbated by the fact that nobody really knows Frank, hidden under his mask. So. Once, someone went into my comments section and made some comments that I thought were a bit too personal – the details, I can't remember because I read dozens of comments every day – so I told the commenter that we are complete strangers and maybe that was not appropriate. After some back and forth, he said that I was not a stranger to him, and that because he watched my show, he knew me.
This was not only wrong but disturbing to me as someone who values their privacy – the idea that he knew me on a personal level or even knew me AT ALL because he subscribed to my channel. He thought that since he knew things about me, that was somehow equal to knowing...me, that we had a relationship beyond viewer and performer. But I am...a stranger. I'm just, a familiar stranger. Stanley Milgram coined this term in his 1972 paper The Familiar Stranger: An Aspect of Urban Anonymity. Milgram and his students conducted a little experiment. His students took photographs of people waiting at railway stations during their morning commute. A week after taking the pictures, the students went to the same spot, distributed the photographs and asked everyone to label anyone they recognized or to whom they had spoken. The average commuter claimed to recognize 4 individuals who they had NEVER spoken to compared to the 1.5 individuals on average with whom they HAD conversed. Milgram thought this might have something to do with what the commuters thought of those strangers. Commuters noted that they imagined what kinds of lives familiar strangers led and what kinds of jobs they held. Sometimes these fantasies are more fulfilling and therefore more memorable than cruel reality, which is often disappointing.
AUDIO 2
Milgram called these “fantasy relationships” with “familiar strangers” but Milgram's study existed long before the advent of YouTube, 24 hour celebrity news, etc. These days, this is more commonly called a parasocial relationship. Chris Rojek, author of Presumed Intimacy, defined is thusly: “This is a concept with more powerful emotional implications for the conventional senses of social responsibility and reciprocity than Milgram’s concept of familiar strangers. It refers to relationships of presumed intimacy between media figures and network spectators.” Basically, it's a mostly one-sided relationship in which an audience believes they “know” the performer. Frank's fans don't really know him – they literally can't, he wears a mask and conceals his identity – but they get a sense of who he is and fantasize about what he's really like, and this fantasy can be very powerful. Let's go back to the YouTuber who thought he knew me because he subscribed to my channel. In addition to this being obviously wrong because watching that person through their YouTube channel does not mean you know that person, it's wrong because you aren't actually watching...that person.
You're watching the version of that person that that person wants to present or is comfortable presenting either for marketing reasons or simply to protect their own mental health, like it is with me. Nothing is uploaded unless it's what the YouTuber wants their audience to see. Even people who claim that their channel is just a completely unfiltered version of themselves and that's the appeal, well, they aren't being truthful with their audience or themselves. Everything is edited and presented in the best possible way. This does not necessarily mean that the personality is performing as a completely separate character or that the performance is a lie or dishonest but it does mean that the personality is presenting a “curated” version of who they are. Frank reveals a little of himself every time he sings a song or makes a public appearance whether he wants to or not. In a sense, he's not being “fake” – but Frank is also not made of papier-mâché, and Frank intentionally does not reveal much about himself to others – and even less to his audience.
AUDIO 3
I may seem like I'm revealing more of myself than Frank because I am showing my face, but this is also a curated version of myself. Everything I'm saying, I'm reading from a script right now. The clothes I'm wearing were chosen to present the version of myself I'm comfortable showing. This is a curated version of who I am that I am comfortable uploading to YouTube. Even live streams that show the YouTuber without a safety net only shows that YouTuber's life...as a YouTuber. That slice of their life that they have decided will be online. Now, you might say that this is true even in more meaningful relationships. People “code switch” and perform a different version of themselves for different people. Nobody is a mind-reader, which means nobody actually knows the “real you.” if such a thing even exists. But a parasocial relationship differs greatly from this due to the balance in the relationship. Your genuine friendships, your co-equal relationships both have an intimacy that cannot exist in parasocial relationships and also contain...balance. A parasocial relationship, on the other hand, well, maybe “one-way” is not accurate. I read all the comments, emails and messages for example.
So, maybe “one-way” is wrong. Maybe “unbalanced” is more accurate. The scales are tilted. This makes me feel...phony sometimes? I'm not trying to make the case that “parasocial relationship = bad” because that's a little reductive. My interactions with my audience ranges from extremely positive and wholesome to people calling for my suicide. All the time. It's difficult for YouTubers to talk about this because no matter how obvious all of this is and how reasonable this may seem, you know, that parasocial relationships are not friendships, some people become upset upon hearing this or use this as an excuse to attack the person, uh, saying “You don't care about your fans!” as a response. The only reason this is a response is because of said parasocial relationships. When you go to the supermarket and the cashier is just doing their job, you don't yell “You don't really care about your customers!” if they don't bend the rules and accept your outdated coupons. But because of the presumed intimacy of the “relationship” between online personalities and their fans – or REAL celebrities and their fans – the “You don't care about your fans!” outburst somehow seems more reasonable and that the idea that a celebrity or YouTuber just doing their job is a betrayal.
AUDIO 4
I can't even count the number of times people have been upset with me when I say that this is my job because...they want it to be so much more than that. Some people on the receiving end of a parasocial relationship – meaning the people being watched – are more comfortable with it than, say, Frank, who has a nervous breakdown in the third act of the film, or even more comfortable with it than myself. On the more intimate side of things, some people on the receiving end of the parasocial relationship play up the fact that their audience calls them pet names – not nicknames – but intimate pet names like “daddy” or “mommy,” and that is their choice. No judgment. But for me, this kind of intimacy with strangers is not OK. Even relatively harmless messages like this do not make me feel good or attractive. No amount of “Take a compliment!” replies will make this feel good to me because even though I actively discourage this kind of thing, it makes me feel like I'm accidentally manipulating people into liking me and giving me one-way attention that I cannot reciprocate, and it's especially troubling when it's the kind of attention I don't want, namely romantic or sexual.
I'm doing this episode in front of the camera for, I think, the first time ever – not counting collaborations – for a reason. This still isn't really me, or if it is me, it's only the smallest part of me. The part that is OK to be shared. YouTube only presents the perception of authenticity. The artifice still exists, even among slice of life vloggers who present a lot of their day to day. You might think that because you can see my face this time that this is a more authentic look into myself, but it's not. I'm still only presenting a curated version of myself, and I'm reading all of this off a script. Even the ums and uhs that I've said are in the script, and so is this confession. I'm reading it right now. Everything I'm saying right now is true...but it's also behind a mask of performance. Something can be true – not a lie – but also a performance. And this seeming contradiction is...a lot. The other reason it's difficult for YouTubers to talk about our inherent inauthenticity is because YouTubers who portray themselves as 100% real but literally can't be...take offense to this demonstrable fact and don't appreciate anyone pulling back the curtain because they depend on the presumed intimacy of their channels.
AUDIO 5
This isn't a callout, I'm complicit in this too whether I want to be or not. It's unavoidable. So, like, guilty. I hope I haven't upset anyone with this video. I don't have all the answers to this stuff, and a lot of different YouTubers have wildly different takes on this, I've noticed, but this is what it feels like...for me. At the end of Frank, he is without his mask, and he sings, and he's happier for it, one assumes. He can be real – or at least as real as possible – to his friends, but can he be more than a familiar stranger to his audience if they don't really know him?
GREEN BOOK
AUDIO 1
[And the winner is] How did this happen? How did Green Book, one of the weakest entries to this year's Academy Award race for Best Picture, take the top prize? At a ceremony where numerous women and people of color won awards and where Black Panther broke new ground, the Oscar for Best Picture went to a hollow but comforting fantasy about how all that we need to do to end racism is to awkwardly talk to each other about race and fried chicken. The Academy tried to inoculate us from criticizing Green Book in this way by spotlighting a bonafide civil rights hero earlier in the evening, perhaps signaling to us the eventual winner and how we must behave when the bomb drops at the climax of the show. And there has been a lot of criticism, both surrounding the film and the people involved in making it. In September of last year, Viggo Mortenson, the actor who plays the magically transformed not racist Tony, used the n-word in a Q&A session. In November, the family of Dr. Don Shirley denounced the film, calling it a “symphony of lies.” One of his relatives, Carol Shirley Kimble, said:
“...once again a depiction of a white man’s version of a black man’s life. ... To depict him and take away from him and make the story about a hero of a white man for this incredibly accomplished black man is insulting, at best.” Mahershala Ali later apologized to the family. When Green Book won three Golden Globes, the optics of a majority white group talking about the importance of the film amidst these controversies were too much to bear. Then director Peter Farrelly was excoriated for sexual misconduct, and screenwriter Nick Vallelonga, real life son of Mortenson's character, was outed as Islamaphobic. In February, Green Book producer Charles B. Wessler was revealed to have sent angry, insulting emails to journalists who criticized his film. And after all this, Green Book still walks away with the Oscar for Best Picture, easily the worst decision since Crash. Even divorced from these controversies and the fact that Green Book is another in a long line of white savior movies designed to exonerate white people from feeling too bad about racism and that traffics in the false narrative of racism being a thing of the past, it's also a passable film at best. Good acting but a largely recycled plot that even though loosely based on a true story feels like it strikes all the notes we have heard before.
AUDIO 2
Green Book is a “racial reconciliation fantasy” – a term I am borrowing from writer Wesley Morris. A racial reconciliation fantasy is movie that teaches falsehoods about the causes of racism and solutions to racism. Racial conciliation fantasies generally star a white protagonist who overcomes either their own racism or the racism of others through simplified means that reassure white audiences that they are not racist. Green Book is the story of Tony, a racist who throws away his own glasses if black men drink from them. Facing unemployment, he takes a job playing driver and bodyguard to Dr. Don Shirley, a famous pianist. Along the way, Tony teaches Don how to be black and also overcomes his more overt racist tendencies through the power of friendship. We used to call this “Oscar bait” – movies that are made with the studio hoping to pick up awards and micro-managing production to tick a few necessary Oscar boxes. These movies are generally released in November or December to keep them fresh in the minds of Academy voters who start to make their picks shortly thereafter. Nobody releases their Oscar hopeful in January. But Oscar bait is sometimes...good. This is more like...prestige schlock.
The problem with the subject of race broached in Green Book is as follows: while the film obviously takes the bold stance of saying “racism is bad,” it does this while committing all the usual sins of a film of this sort: centering the film on the perspective of a white man, propagating the myth that racism is individual instead of institutional, providing a wildly racist caricature to tell the white audience that they themselves cannot be racist, showing a simple fantasy of racial harmony, showing that we have come a long way, which suggests racism is a thing of the past, displaying the white character as the hero who saves the black character thereby removing the agency and overall importance of the black character and infantilizing them, displaying racism as something that equally affects the majority and minority rather than something that obviously disproportionately affects the minority, and minimizing the struggle as mere misunderstanding or ignorance rather than systemic injustice. These are all the big hits, and somehow, Green Book, in its magnificence, may have hit all of them. Now, you might be wondering...why does this matter? It's just a movie, you might say. Who cares that the Academy spotlighted this film, you might argue.
AUDIO 3
Consider this: outside of the Academy, the proliferation of movies like Green Book undoubtedly misinform the predominantly white American audience. Sociologist Matthew W. Hughley wrote: “Due to the racially segregated character of the United States, many within its borders spend little time interacting with people of different racial or ethnic groups. This point is particularly true for whites. Eighty-six percent of suburban whites live in a community where the black population is less than 1 percent. ...Whites are most likely to be segregated than any other group. As a result, popular films about race and racism offer people, especially whites, narratives for experiences they may not have in real life. In fact, in the absence of lived experience, films are often understood as 'authentic' reflections of 'real life.' … The expansive reach of movies makes them a particularly important site for examining popular constructions of race relations in U.S. society. … It is important, therefore, to critically engage cinematic representations of race in order to chart the contours of the strategic rhetoric that supports (and draws support) from such representations.”
Media does not force us to do things, but it does inform our worldview, especially if we are otherwise unfamiliar with the experiences of people with whom we do not often interact. Quick personal aside here: In my experience, black people in America already know this stuff because they live it in a way that I never will, but when speaking about it on social media with white people, many tend to...not? So, I'm not trying to talk over black people with this video. They obviously already know, and I'm not interested in positioning myself as the white savior. Rather, I'm trying to speak to other white people about this, and over the course of this video, I'll be signal boosting black voices who have spoken about this trend and about this movie specifically. Being an ally does not mean having “white guilt” – it means knowing the difference between guilt and responsibility. With that being said, let's go through the aforementioned big hits. [The perspective of a white man] Racial reconciliation movies about interracial friendships are not about systemic injustice but about the journey of one person, usually a man, to become less overtly racist. He can still be casually racist – just not the kind of racist who won't sell a black man a suit or refuses to dine in the same room as a black man or who demands a black man must use an outhouse.
AUDIO 4
Tony stops being a racist only by the low standards of the film that portray racism only as codified by segregation-era law. He makes an exception for someone amazing and then concludes that he will be less overtly racist in front of his friends and ask them not to use slurs in reference to his one black friend. This is Tony's story. This is not the biopic of Dr. Don Shirley. Don doesn't even show up until 15 minutes into the movie, and we spend a lot more time with Tony than with Don. Because of these factors and how the narratives are framed, racial reconciliation fantasies do not focus on black liberation as much as they focus on white redemption. Why do these movies do this? What does this say about the intended audience of these movies? In the book The Devil Finds Work, James Baldwin wrote of this phenomenon. On the subject of an earlier film, The Defiant Ones, he wrote: “They get to the train, the black man jumps on, but the white boy can’t make it, and the black man jumps off the train, it is hard, indeed, to say why. Well. He jumps off the train in order to reassure white people, to make them know that they are not hated; that, though they have made human errors, they have done nothing for which to be hated.”
Racial reconciliation fantasy movies exist for that reason, for that audience. [The myth that racism is individual, not institutional] [3:15] Tony “changes” by the end of the film. The implication is that all we need to do to end racism in America is have a black friend. That's an oversimplification of the film's message, I admit, but it's not far off from the myth that many white people propagate: racism is not institutional, meaning baked into the system. It's the product of bad apples and can be taught away. Look. Racism is more than throwing away your cups. It's also found in housing discrimination, mortgage lending, rates of policing and rates of incarceration. Whenever I mention that racism is systemic, the same people pop out and say “Name one way it is!” and then I name a handful like the ones I just said, and they say “That's not the system! That's individuals!” except that patterns of behavior, especially codified by either the state or as common business practice, is not individual or unique. White people want to believe that we have nothing to do with these more systemic problems, but not recognizing these problems is itself a problem.
AUDIO 5
[Racist caricature to reassure white audiences] [2:00] In racial reconciliation fantasy movies, the racist characters do not perform microaggressions. They do not work in Congress to enact legislation that will disproportionately affect black families but not contain language to that affect, thereby providing plausible deniability. No. The racists in these movies have to be so monstrously racist or so obviously racist that white audiences can watch the movies and think “Well, that's not me. I'm not a racist. Because THAT'S a racist. And I don't do that. Anyway, MAGA.” Perhaps because of media like this or the news media that focuses on the worst of all racists, it's easy for white audiences to envision racism as merely the product of men wearing sheets and lighting crosses on fire. Pretending that only restaurant owners enforcing segregation are the “real racists” is just a way of lying to ourselves. [Simple fantasy of racial harmony] [5:00] Green Book, like so many other films that preceded it, tries to sell the audience on the idea that racial harmony is only a matter of getting to know each other and acknowledging flaws “on both sides” rather than acknowledging the disproportionate power in society. Green Book tries to have it both ways.
It shows obvious cases of overt racism like Don being unable to try on a suit in a store, but it also portrays Don as being in need of a good kick in the pants for his high-falutin' ways. He's being “too smart” and needs to act “more black.” Green Book gives us the worn out view of racism: both-sides-ism. The film tells us that Tony needs to stop referring to black people using racial slurs, BUT Don needs to stop being so uptight. Tony needs to expand his worldview, but Don is acting too...smart. Green Book shows us these things and tells us these things, but it also gives the impression that they are equal flaws. That being uptight is a mere personality flaw akin to or on the same level as being a racist. [Racism is mostly over today] [1:30] You have heard the rallying cry of the “I'm not racist, but...” drunk uncle or co-worker who loves poking the bear.
AUDIO 6
“Obama was president. That means racism is over.” or “The laws changed, that means discrimination doesn't happen.” First of all, it's rather telling that one black president out of forty-five is considered an egalitarian equation. Second, the laws changing certainly helped, but a law existing does not universally prevent people from breaking it or universally lead to a conviction following an accusation. Murder is illegal, but people are still get murdered every day. Laws against discrimination are helpful and good, but they don't universally end the crime. Furthermore, even when a law does not explicitly mention race, it can still be enacted or enforced with racial prejudice. There are many laws that continue to enable discrimination and racism. The harsh drug laws of the 1980s’ War on Drugs have resulted in the mass incarceration of men of color through prison sentences and felony convictions. People of color are statistically more likely receive longer sentences that whites for the exact same crime. These laws are used to justify the same kind of discrimination allowed legally under Jim Crow, such as housing discrimination, job discrimination, and the inability to vote. The relationship between legislation and racism is often interrelated. In the film, Don is locked up when Tony strikes a police officer.
Don did not do anything illegal, but he suffers for the actions of his white employee. This would almost be solid commentary on the injustice that people of color face under the guise of “law and order” except for a few problems. This takes place in the early 60's, and when Don is released from jail after making a call to Robert Kennedy, an acquaintance of his, Don says that the Kennedys are going to change America for black people. Indeed, improvements on the books have been made, but the implication for the audience is that these interactions between people of color and the police are either a thing of the past or that if a police officer is out of line, men like Don will be protected under the law. Often is the case that this is not true. Unarmed black men are outright killed by the police on a regular basis, and these officers, more often than not, are not convicted of any wrongdoing. In fact, they often don't even lose their jobs over the incident. Green Book pays lip service to the fact that people of color are discriminated against by the police in this scene, but white audiences are reassured that the racist cop is an outlier.
AUDIO 7
We see the kindest, sweetest police officer arguing for the rights of Don, and then later when Don and Tony are pulled over again, the film “subverts” the audience's expectations and shows the officer being kindly and helpful. Whether or not most police officers are racist is irrelevant. The point is that the film wants its white audience to generally see the police as no real threat to black people and to reassure that audience that they are not complicit in racism and neither are the police. Spike Lee's Blackkklansman was also nominated for Best Picture, and while it also has some #NotAllCops stuff in it that is, let's say, unfortunate, Lee does not tie racism solely with the past. The narrative takes place in the past, but the epilogue to the film reminds us that racism – even the most overt and dangerous form – still exists now and is being hand-waved and obfuscated by those in power by saying there are good people on “all sides.” Blackkklansman's epilogue is daring. Green Book's epilogue is that Tony and Don remained friends, a “fact” which is disputed by Don's real life brother. Racism solved. [The white hero who saves the black character] [0:45] White people in these films are often portrayed as the real heroes, robbing any societal gains or achievements of their own and giving them to the white characters. It creates a sense of black helplessness and white necessity.
Rather than go on about the infantilization of black people in Green Book myself, I will defer to Wesley Morris on The New York Times: “By this point, you might have heard about the fried chicken scene in “Green Book.” It comes early in their road trip. Tony is shocked to discover that Don has never had fried chicken. He also appears never to have seen anybody eat fried chicken, either. (“What do we do about the bones?”) So, with all the greasy alacrity and exuberant crassness that Mortensen can conjure, Tony demonstrates how to eat it while driving. As comedy, it’s masterful — there’s tension, irony and, when the car stops and reverses to retrieve some litter, a punch line that brings down the house. But the comedy works only if the black, classical-pop fusion pianist is from outer space (and not in a Sun-Ra sort of way). You’re meant to laugh because how could this racist be better at being black than this black man who’s supposed to be better than him?”
AUDIO 8
Shirley’s real-life family has objected to this, claiming that the real Dr. Don Shirley was not isolated from black people, not confused about his blackness and certainly not willing to reduce blackness to fried chicken. Don Shirley was involved in the civil rights movement and attended the march on Selma, for God's sakes. [The myth of the equality of racism] [3:33] There is a scene in Green Book in which Tony and Don argue about which one of them is “blacker” than the other. This results in one of the more famous scenes of the film in which Don becomes upset, feeling that Tony might be right. This scene traffics in the myth of the egalitarian nature of racism; that Don and Tony's experiences are far more similar than different, that Tony suffers as much or more than Don, and that Don can be just as racist as Tony. Don can be just as “prejudiced” against white people as Tony can be against black people, but black people do not hold the same systemic power in America to do much with that prejudice whereas white people do.
Anyone can be prejudiced against anyone, that is true, but only those with power can turn that prejudice into a weapon. [Minimizing the struggle as ignorance rather than systemic injustice] [4:46] Tony is portrayed as ignorant throughout much of the movie, and by becoming mildly more worldly, he becomes less racist. Education is helpful, yes. I am, for example, trying to educate right now. But we can't blame racism on ignorance alone, as if this is all by some clueless accident, because this denies all the ways that racism and racist policies are perpetuated by the educated and all the ways racism and racist policies are perpetuated intentionally. The maxim “Don't label something malice if it can be attributed to ignorance” is not universal – otherwise every malicious act could be labeled an uneducated mistake. [blank] So. Back to the question: how did Green Book win Best Picture? When I first saw the movie, and every time I tell this story is sounds like a “that didn't happen” post on Reddit, but sighs when I saw the movie, I was the only relatively young person there. The entire theater was packed with elderly white people. Wall to wall old and white. I'm guessing they were bused in from a nursing home. I doubt that Green Book appeals exclusively to the old and white. There was probably some coordinated effort for them all to be there at that screening and not just happenstance.
AUDIO 9
But it got me thinking about who this movie might appeal to. The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences has a membership that is currently 84% white and 69% men. This is actually way more diverse than it was only a few years ago. The #OscarsSoWhite hashtag finally got the Academy to broaden their invitations. But still, that's not much better, right? A few years ago, the median age for an Academy voter was 62. It's doubtful that this has changed dramatically since then, as age has not been one of the diversity drives. Old white moderate liberals love movies like Green Book, Driving Miss Daisy and all the other racial reconciliation fantasies – all the prestige schlock. They tell the mostly white audience that racism is not of them – it is of other white people. Combined with the fact that the Academy typically votes “safe” -- this gave Green Book the nod.
I don't have proof of this – only conjecture based on who these films are made for and the demographic makeup of the Academy. The votes are secret. I know. But...the old white vote is still the biggest vote, and all the other votes were scattered among mostly better films. Don't think Green Book getting Best Picture is evidence of its worth. It's only evidence of who this movie was really made for. This is only...a theory...but no matter why it happened, it shouldn't have happened. Because we should be over movies like this by now. We know they are bullshit. We know they are white fantasies.
THANOS WAS WRONG
AUDIO 1
In Avengers: Infinity War, the universe is threatened by Thanos, a gigantic purple alien whose stated goal is the wipe out half of the population of all known existence. One by one, he collects the infinity stones. With all six in his gauntlet, he can snap his fingers and achieve his goal. The Avengers fail to stop Thanos, resulting in the aforementioned catastrophic loss of life. In the comic books, Thanos wants to wipe out half the population to impress Death, a woman he loves but has no interest in him. Basically, he's the universe's most powerful incel. But in the film, his motivation is different. Thanos snaps his fingers to perform his grisly task because he believe it's a “mercy” – the universe, he claims, only has so many resources and far too many people. In doing so, he says, he will actually save the universe. Thanos is...wrong. He's wrong. He's wrong for a lot of reasons but not only the reasons stated in YouTube videos and fandom articles filled with Marvel Comics lore and talk of plot holes. He's wrong because his arithmetic is wrong and because he is blaming resource drain on the people instead of the real source of the problem – capitalism.
Oh yeah. It's one of those videos. Because of the way our discourse and politics inform popular culture and how popular culture informs our discourse and politics, the subject of overpopulation has once again returned to media. Not only because of Infinity War, this topic becomes popular once a generation, but with the most successful movie in the world having overpopulation as its subject, the reintroduction of overpopulation in serious news articles written by serious people was inevitable. Also, with the return of fascist ideology as an semi-acceptable talking point – so long as we call it something else – we now have the perfect incubator for the rebirth of this wrong-headed idea. Right-wing buzz words like “overpopulation” often contain conversations using Thanos as their example to explain eugenics, racism and capitalism. As this has become part of the discourse now, I will also use Thanos as my example to more explicitly oppose the very same. Thanos is wrong. There is enough food – more than enough, in fact. We just don't allocate it properly under our current economic system. There is enough space – more than enough, in fact. There is enough energy.
AUDIO 2
We just don't utilize renewable energy sources because they are not as profitable as non-renewable energy sources under our current economic system. The problem...is capitalism. Not those of us living under capitalism, the vast majority of us in the middle to lower classes, meaning the people who do not benefit from capitalism. But first, some necessary background on overpopulation and eugenics. [I. Eugenics and Overpopulation Overview] In 1798, Thomas Robert Malthus wrote “An Essay on the Principle of Population” in which he laid out his theory about overpopulation. To summarize, he believed that eventually there would be more people than the world could feed. His solution was to find a way to prevent population growth by killing the poor. “Instead of recommending cleanliness to the poor, we should encourage contrary habits. In our towns we should make the streets narrower, crowd more people into the houses, and court the return of the plague. In the country we should build our villages near stagnant pools, and particularly encourage settlements in all marshy and unwholesome situations. But above all, we should reprobate specific remedies for ravaging diseases: and those benevolent, but much mistaken men, who have thought they were doing a service to mankind by projecting schemes for the total extirpation of particular disorders.”
Malthus was the Thanos of his day, and he justified his proposals much in the same way. Malthus was wrong because he did not foresee that food production would drastically increase in the coming centuries, but we'll get into dunking on him later. For now...did you notice something about that quote? I mean, besides that it advocated reintroducing the bubonic plague? He didn't say kill...some people. He said kill...the poor. Much as it is today, the poor in the 18th century were blamed for their own poverty, and the upper class believed that helping the poor would decrease the overall quality life, which really only means the quality of life for said upper class. This made capitalism under the industrial revolution a conflict for survival. Work hard, gain property, gain wealth and maybe you won't be part of the next culling of the filthy poors. [clip] Although Malthus did not use the word, what he was advocating is a form of eugenics, a series of beliefs and practices with the stated goal of improving the “genetic quality” of the human population and the secondary goal of excluding groups judged to be inferior. Most commonly, these groups are the poor, the non-white and anyone who the eugenicists claim should not be part of what they view as their perfect human population.
AUDIO 3
Eugenicists wished to raise the rate of population among people who they believed had “desirable traits” and lower the rate of population among people who they believed had “undesirable” traits. This was instituted through forced sterilization and marriage restrictions – and later, much worse. Who decides who is desirable? Well, those with power, and under capitalism that means those with means and the ability to influence politics with said means. Eugenics as a more popular theory rose to prominence in the western world partially as a response to labor questioning their place in the capitalist system. Eugenics sought to create scientific justification for the status quo – “the way things are” – through quackery like judging human beings based on skull shape. These “sciences” were used as justification for imperialism, the highest stage of capitalism, by claiming that races who the Europeans wanted to colonize and enslave were “inferior” anyway, and that nature itself granted permission for this endeavor. Eugenics was huge in America and not only as theory but as practice. Throughout the first six decades of the 20th century, hundreds of thousands of Americans were not permitted to continue their families by reproducing.
This is a map of sterilization in America in 1935, which seems like this is ancient history, but the Federal Sterilization Regulations that curtailed much of this wasn't instituted until 1978, and even now, it's not always consistently enforced. Thanos' method of population control might seem more “fair” than that of real world eugenicists – he claims that his finger snap will kill half the population at random rather than focus on the poor – but he is still employing the upper class' use of eugenics by sparing someone: himself. Thanos is asked what he will do after his mission is complete, and he remarks that he will watch the sun set on a “grateful” universe. This implies that he has no intention of adding himself to those who may be randomly killed with his de-population. If he knows he will be spared, then he never intended to make himself eligible for this culling. And indeed, we see that at the end of the movie. Those who enact eugenics always see themselves as those who are “worthy” of being spared and “necessary” for the future. Eugenics fell out of favor for a while due to Adolf Hitler employing it on a massive scale, and modern eugenicists cite this as the only drawback of eugenics.
AUDIO 4
Hitler, the eugenicists claim, tried to make the master race the “wrong” way, while still believing in a master race themselves. But...no. Murdering the poor and forcibly sterilizing so-called “undesirable” people was always bad, actually, and the Nazis' adoption of eugenics was not a bug in the system but a feature and the inevitable end goal of a belief that some people are more “worthy” of life than others. In The Population Myth, Social theorist and political philosopher Murray Bookchin wrote: “...by reducing us to studies of line graphs, bar graphs, and statistical tables, the neo-Malthusians literally freeze reality as it is. Their numerical extrapolations do not construct any reality that is new; they mere extend, statistic by statistic, what is basically old and given. … We are taught to accept society, behavior, and values as they are, not as they should be or even could be. This procedure places us under the tyranny of the status quo and divests us of any ability to think about radically changing the world. I have encountered very few books or articles written by neo-Malthusians that question whether we should live under any kind of money economy at all, any statist system of society, or be guided by profit oriented behavior.
There are books and articles aplenty that explain 'how to' become a 'morally responsible' banker, entrepreneur, landowner, 'developer,' or, for all I know, arms merchant. But whether the whole system called capitalism (forgive me!), be it corporate in the west or bureaucratic in the east, must be abandoned if we are to achieve an ecological society is rarely discussed.” OK. So...let's discuss it. [II. Food] Food is brought up explicitly in the film, and that is as good a place to start as any. Remember Malthus, that great big piece of sh*t? His projections about population growth and food production were wrong. Technological advances has made the rate of food production explode – far more than the explosion of population. Not only is enough food produced that the whole world could be fed, but enough food is produced that the whole world could have a lot left over. So, why are so many people starving? It's not because of a surplus population if food production far exceeds the population. Malthus talked of mathematics justifying his beliefs. Well, the real math does not lie.
AUDIO 5
People continue to be hungry because of the economic system that does not distribute food based on need but based on whether or not people have “earned” the food under said system – a system, by the way, they did not choose but are forced to live under. Governments are paying farmers to cut back their harvests, as we have run out of storage space. Under capitalism, this is preferable to having an excess amount of food and simply giving it to people in need. Companies that make an excess of food generally dispose of it rather than giving it away too because the cost of giving it away is greater than the cost of disposing of it. Under capitalism, a system that prioritizes private property and profit over quality of life, this is preferable. A couple years ago, this grew to the point that the world had a third more rice and wheat in storage than it was expected to consume, sell or turn into fuel. The combined world surplus of wheat, corn, rice and soya recently passed 670 million tons. To put another way, that's enough to feed all of China for a year – just on the surplus food. The excess food that nobody uses. Governments sometimes send aid to countries suffering from a drought or food shortage, partially because of the earned relations and influence this gives the “giving” country over the “receiving” country.
But corporations are not incentivized to do this even though they are hoarding all the food and disposing of it. In Avengers: Infinity War, Thanos claims that his planet doomed itself by not following his population culling. For the sake of argument, let's pretend Titan had a similar society, economy and problems as Earth. Thanos could have solved the problem by instituting a radical economic change. Presumably, nobody did. The people of Titan could foresee their own end, but those in power could not even imagine giving up a hierarchical economic society. This is what Mark Fisher calls “capitalist realism” – the idea that not only is capitalism the only viable political and economic system but it is also now impossible even to imagine a coherent alternative to it due to its prevalence. Even in the face of catastrophe that could be solved by finding an alternative or going around capitalism, we do not even consider it. Arguments for wasting food rather than improving the quality of life of others are supported by the hierarchical model and even philosophy of capitalism. “The poor didn't 'earn' that food.” “It's their own fault that they're starving.” “That's just how the system works.” “This is the natural order.”
AUDIO 6
Defending starvation as natural or acceptable because of capitalist concepts is entirely common if capitalists believe in hierarchies that benefit themselves over others. Overpopulation is not the source of world hunger if the amount of food far exceeds the population. There is a distribution problem and a problem of a system that decides who “deserves” food. [III. Energy] Considering the vastness of space and the sci-fi technology in the MCU, finding energy sources probably does not have the same challenges as on Earth. But in either case, problems arising from energy are not caused by overpopulation. The argument goes that so many people are causing global warming. If we had less people, the modern eugenicists argue, we would have less change to the climate. After all, so many people drive cars. This ignores a few key details. Over 70% of global emissions are created by 100 companies. Your individual contribution to climate change – your “lifestyle consumption emissions” – are marginal. Even among these limited emissions, it is not most of us – the poor and middle classes – who are to blame. The top 10% richest people in the world account for nearly half of lifestyle consumption emissions.
Energy companies have known about global warming for a long time but have actively tried to obfuscate their role by hiring right-wing think tanks to create false studies and by buying politicians to side with them against anything that might hinder their profits. Believers in overpopulation would still argue that these companies would not have to produce as much coal and oil if not for the growing population, but that still puts the onus on the consumer and not the producer of the product and the problem. Coal is the biggest issue, both as a cause of emissions but also because it is significantly more profitable than wind power and solar power. The means of production are owned by the very few, which means very few people have decided that this is what our planet is going to be and this is what consequences our planet will have. Capitalism provides no incentive for millionaires and billionaires to give up their industries or restructure their industries around much safer but less profitable energy sources. As much as popular media has demonized nuclear power, the truth is that it causes far less harm to our atmosphere than coal.
AUDIO 7
Although mining and refining uranium ore do require large amounts of energy, nuclear reactors themselves do not produce air pollution or carbon dioxide while operating. However, nuclear power is currently less profitable than coal, which has made it less prevalent. The key thing is understand here is that the cause of global warming is not overpopulation. It's a prioritization of profit over quality of life – or even life itself. Corporations are not incentivized to save the world under the capitalism. They are incentivized only to make money. [IV. Space] This is, perhaps, the most laughable of all the overpopulation arguments, so I won't take much time on it. In Avengers: Infinity War, interstellar travel is commonplace, and gigantic space station cities can be built in the void of space itself. So, Thanos isn't worried about there simply not being enough “room” for more people in the infinite grandeur of outer space, but here on Earth, that is somehow an argument. “Where are we gonna put all these people?” they ask. See, they ask this as if we're all presently stacked on top of each other or if there isn't a lot of open space left. Well, to that, I answer, have you ever heard of Wyoming? You would be surprised how much nothing there is.
95% of world's population is concentrated on just 10% of world's land surface. There is so much open space to build more cities should the circumstances arise. If we lived at the density that people live in Manhattan, the entire global population could fit in New Zealand. Now maybe you live in Alaska, a place that has a density so low and so spread, that if everyone on Earth lived that way, we would need 108 Earths to fit us all. And maybe, as an Alaskan, these figures scare you because you don't want to live anywhere with a dense population. Well, fair enough, but is that enough of a reason to believe in culling the world population? So there isn't a line at the coffee shop? [CONCLUSION] Hierarchies are usually defined by people who believe they are high up on that hierarchy. “Genetic superiority” books were generally written by people who believed they were among the superior race. “Overpopulation” believers are usually people who think that they themselves should not be among those removed or among those whose people or race or class should not be removed. And capitalism is enforced by those with the most wealth.
AUDIO 8
Hierarchies are self-serving, not serving the quality of life of all. Belief in “overpopulation” also only aims to serve those who believe they themselves are the “worthy” race or class who must continue to exist. This belief is also self-serving while under the guise of “helping” the world at large. Nearly all discourse on overpopulation places the blame on the poor or on non-white countries even though the poor don't have much to do with these problems, and the entire continent of Africa contributes only about 3% of the world's greenhouse gas emissions, by far the least in both absolute and per capita terms. The overpopulation discourse from books on the subject all the way up to Thanos memes serve as an excuse to ignore the root causes of poverty, starvation, climate change, etc. The rich telling us why some people are poor is like a salesman telling you why their product is the best available: they have a vested interest in presenting it that way. Capitalist apologists can look at the fact that there is more than enough food but some people are starving, more than enough space but people are homeless, and more than enough sources of cleaner energy but people are facing global warming, and still say that capitalism is not the problem.
They claim things like only “crony capitalism” is toxic or that if we just make a couple small changes to the system, it will somehow have radical results. But disparity is its very dogma – not an unintended side effect or anomaly. There is no...version of the system we are using right now that can solve our problems. It cannot be reformed if capitalism is rapidly creating more and more disparity. The idea that incredible suffering can be removed simply be tweaking the system or putting it through mild reforms is a neoliberal fantasy. Capitalists created the aforementioned circumstances in the world but also wish that you will address these circumstances only within the confines of capitalism itself. Capitalism wants you to fight fire with fire instead of looking for some water. Philosopher Fredric Jameson once remarked that it's now easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of capitalism. Thanos, after gaining the power of all six infinity stones, has the power to perform this radical change. He can create a post-scarcity universe in which everyone is fed, every planet has clean energy and so forth. But he can't imagine that. He can't imagine such a universe. It's easier for him to imagine the end of all things than the end of the system in which we currently exist.
ALL YOUR EYES WIDE SHUT THEORIES ARE WRONG
AUDIO 1
Stanley Kubrick was a director. He was not a god. He was not superhuman. And he was not privy to secret information about a massive new world order conspiracy. He was a man, and the deification of both himself and his movies lead some people down a strange and even dangerous path. Belief in far-out conspiracy theories and prevalence of these theories have their origins in both our inherent evolutionary wiring and the influence of media and culture. Our brains recognize “patterns” to allow us to survive and to impose structure on our world. This evolutionary trait was extremely helpful for the survival of our earliest ancestors. A rustle in the bushes? That often means a predator or a member of an opposing tribe is nearby. Time to either square up or ruuun. Recognizing patterns is incredibly important, but our brains are not perfect. This pattern recognition can overreact, which causes us to see patterns where they don't exist, such as seeing a shape in the clouds or a face in the moon. Human beings see faces more than anything else. These are random anomalies, but our pattern recognition tricks us into seeing something familiar and intentional in the randomness of nature.
We connect the dots from A to Z. It's called “associative learning” – our method of making sense of the world through response and stimulus – and its byproduct is called “patternicity” – finding meaningful patterns in meaningless noise. It's not only humans, though. Non-human animals do this too. Humans are simply able to convey these false meanings to others and spread these ideas of false patterns better. Noticing a pattern where it does not exist can lead people to believe in conspiracy theories. In fact, studies show a correlation between an individual's need for structure and a tendency to believe in conspiracy theories. Bear in mind, these are scientific studies and not simple pattern recognition. There are other evolutionary and even social elements to this. We are social animals and our status in our society is more important than being factually correct. We compare our actions to those of people around us and tend to change them to better fit in. This means that if belief in a false pattern is popular, we might tend to “believe” this pattern without question. Through our social groups, we are exposed to specifics ideas, and eventually – whether factual or not – these ideas become ingrained in our worldview.
AUDIO 2
It's called “social proof” – we view a behavior as more correct in a given situation to the degree that we see others performing it. This means we are more likely to believe something if said by our social groups than studies and data that debunks it. Social proof has us overlook real evidence. Now, combine all these psychological and social aspects of pattern recognition with a world in which we are deluged with information, and you have the perfect delivery method for the proliferation of conspiracy theories. People connecting their politics with conspiracy theories helps spread these theories because of an inherent loyalty to our group. If a social conservative is saying this to me, and I'm a social conservative, then this only loosely related conspiracy theory must also be true! So, how does all this intersect with Stanley Kubrick? On July 20th, 1969, NASA successfully sent human beings to the moon. Not long after, conspiracy theorists began to speculate that this was a massive hoax. They claimed that the American flag fluttered in the wind, but there is no wind on the moon. In reality, the flag just moved as it was planted.
The unusual shadows can be explained by the use of wide-angle lenses, and the so-called mysterious cameraman was actually a mounted camera on the side of the lunar module. You would think this would be enough to dispel this nonsense, but the theory is more intriguing than the truth – even though the truth, man walking on the moon, really should be intriguing enough. In 1980, Stanley Kubrick was roped into this conspiracy by – of all people – Flat-Earthers. In an issue of Science Digest, released two months after the debut of Kubrick's The Shining, Charles K. Johnson, the President of the International Flat Earth Research Society, helped popularize the theory that Kubrick was the director of the fake moon landing. Johnson claimed that we can't orbit a “flat Earth” The sun and the moon, using Johnson's model, are only about 32 miles in diameter. Johnson's beliefs were grounded in his Christianity, and he suggests that the idea that Earth is a globe was designed to force secularism and anti-Christianity onto the world. Johnson named Arthur C. Clarke, co-writer of 2001: A Space Odyssey, as the writer of the so-called fake moon landing, which eventually led to people believing that the other man associated with the film, Stanley Kubrick, was its director.
AUDIO 3
Over time, due to his connection with this nonsense conspiracy theory, Kubrick became a favorite among people with these far-out beliefs, assigning more conspiracy theories to Kubrick's other films – from The Shining all the way to his final film, Eyes Wide Shut. Debunking conspiracy theories runs into the problem of people remembering the conspiracy, which is intriguing, more than the facts, which are often disappointing. People who try to debunk Alex Jones often run into the problem of spreading the theory more than debunking it, creating a net negative to their cause. This is because Alex Jones debunkers are not Alex Jones fans, and if said fans see this debunking, they will not accept it regardless of the facts therein. Because we are social animals, in order to be a successful debunker, you have to also prove that you are part of the group, a secret handshake of sorts that will allow those listening to take YOU more seriously than facts. Good news in that front because, apparently, Kubrick fans somehow consider me to be one of their go-to video essayists. The Kubrick Reddit only has a few links, and one of them, for some reason, is to my YouTube channel. And I am a Kubrick fan.
2001: A Space Odyssey, A Clockwork Orange, The Shining and Eyes Wide Shut are among my favorite movies of all time. I hope that's good enough that you will take what I'm saying to heart. [FADE] About four years ago, I released a video about Eyes Wide Shut, an admittedly bog standard analysis of the film during a time when the premise of my channel was still evolving and in flux. I've also done other videos about other Kubrick films, some of them made with the intention of debunking conspiracy theories and some with the intention of simply discussing movies I like. Back then, Renegade Cut was still political and philosophical, but not every video was so overtly political and/or philosophical. Years later, I still get comments under these videos, and even though 2001, The Shining and A Clockwork Orange are more popular entries in Kubrick's filmography, the wildest and most tinfoil-hatted comments would always appear under my video for Eyes Wide Shut. After a while, I started screen capping the comments before (usually) deleting them because I don't want to be party to spreading misinformation. My channel, my rules.
AUDIO 4
After years of taking screenshots, it's now finally time to address and debunk these conspiracy theories – and again – I'm a Kubrick fan, so you can't discount what I say as some “interloper” or “outsider” doing harm to your ideas. First up: “Kubrick exposed the satanic elite and you are speaking about gender roles. Shameful!” After replying, this commenter then said that the film has a lot of references to Satanism and Freemasonry. Now, whether or not the film has references to Satanism or the Freemasons is not relevant or interesting to me. That might be true, but what is not true is how Kubrick “exposed” the “Satanic elite Freemasons” because Satanism, as a religion, holds little sway over the world as an extreme minority religion and because Freemasons do not secretly rule the world. If you believe Kubrick meant to reference Satan, that's fine, but if you think that because Kubrick referenced Satan, this is a clue that Satan genuinely does hold sway over world's governments, that's something different entirely. It's also wrong. Hysteria about the presence of Satan has existed for a long time. One such account dates back to the 14th century when stories of ritualistic child abuse by the Knights Templar were spoken in hushed tones.
In the 15th century in what is now Switzerland, locals began accusing people in their community of entering a pact with the Devil. Coerced confessions spread around, natural occurrences were blamed on curses and hundreds of accused “witches” were killed over the course of several years. In modern history, the Manson family in the 1960's gave way to a new fear of “the occult” and same year as the Manson murders, Anton LaVey published The Satanic Bible, plagiarized by several sources and recounted the words of other philosophers, including but not limited to Ayn Rand. 1972 saw the release of Satan Seller, an autobiography about ritualistic sex orgies that was eventually discredited and revealed to be fraudulent. Combine all this with the rise of the Christian right and popular works of fantasy, and suddenly people started to fear “the Devil” again. This gave rise to the “Satanic Panic” of the 70's and 80's. The roots of such panics are generally anxieties about social change or potential loss of power. Such worries are then projected on “folk devils” who embody that stress. These can be marginalized people, but such folk devils can also be made up of fantasy beings like, well, the actual Devil.
AUDIO 5
This continues to this day, as movements like Qanon spread conspiracy theories about the Democratic Party's secret Satanic pedophile ring and how Robert Mueller is actually Trump's right-hand man in taking them down. Belief in this, more than anything, is the result of the “anxiety” among Trump supporters and the frenzy they are whipped into by their glorious leader. There have been ritualized crimes in America, but such crimes are not evidence of a Satanic “elite” – especially considering the rarity of said crimes. Conspiracy theorists see the occasional crime related to ritual torture and claim that there is a pattern that must go all the way to the top of society. Because if you believe murders are supernatural, why wouldn't said supernatural forces influence the top people...but there is no real evidence of that. Only supposition that is predicated on pre-existing belief in the Devil and the human failing of seeing patterns that are not there. And what about the Freemasons? Well, they're not diabolical at all, either figuratively or literally. The Freemasons are the world's oldest fraternal society, pioneers in the idea of universal brotherhood and equality.
Conspiracy theorists say that the Freemasons founded America and secretly control it to this day for some nefarious purpose. This is mostly untrue. Leading up to the American Revolution, some values like electing your leaders and having a constitution were part of Freemasonry, but whether or not you can attribute that directly to Masons is a little hazy because those ideas were also part of the Enlightenment, and were growing in the world at large. It is true that many of the signers of the Constitution were Masons, but that alone is not proof of some Masonic leader ordering its people to infiltrate the government. It had more to do with the fact that Masonry contained a kind of “socialite” membership and the people who signed the Constitution were also of that class. The pattern that conspiracy theorists see here is “Some politicians were Masons” extrapolated into “Freemasons run our country.” Conspiracy theories don't come from nothing. Instead, they come from...almost nothing, and that tiny bit of information is presented as conclusive evidence. A lot of rich white guys were Masons, and a handful of those rich white guys became prominent politicians.
AUDIO 6
Here's another Eyes Wide Shut comment: “And about the world not being run by Satanists, explain to me why John Podesta spoke about sacrificing a chicken.” Alright, I will. In 2016, rumors connected Hillary Clinton and her presidential campaign chairman John Podesta to an alleged satanic ritual known as “spirit cooking.” You can thank Wikileaks for this one. Paul Joseph Watson, one of the Alex Jones crew and soy merchant, pushed this into the conservosphere. Hillary Clinton was found to have NOT sent or received this email. So, what is spirit cooking anyway? Is it a tool of Satan? Not. Even. Close. “Spirit Cooking” was an art project Marina Abramovic created in 1996. Although Abramovic’s cookbook does reference recipes containing breast milk, her home cooking events don’t actually feature these items. The aforementioned dinner was a reward for people who donated to her Kickstarter campaign in 2014. Tony Podesta, John's brother, has been a fan of Abramovic’s since the 1990s and was invited to attend the dinner. John Podesta did not attend. But you can see how conspiracy theorists mistakenly saw this as a pattern, right?
Tony Podesta is John Podesta's brother, and John Podesta knows Hillary Clinton, and Hillary Clinton was married to Bill Clinton, and Bill Clinton was President, so in some seven degrees of Kevin Bacon kind of way, Bill Clinton was invited to the “spirit cooking” dinner! Which was actually just a regular dinner, and spirit cooking has nothing to do with Satanism. It just has the word “spirit” in it. Conspiracy theories take form in the minds of people seeing patterns where they don't exist, but they are broadcast by those who intentionally wish to spread misinformation about their enemies. This next batch of comments traffic in antisemitism. The first references the Rothschild family conspiracy theory, which has antisemitic roots, and the second is even more overt antisemitism. Some Kubrick conspiracy theorists believe that Eyes Wide Shut was a warning about THE JEWS. Accusing Jews of being master conspirators is ancient. Since early Christianity, Jews have been associated with plots to control the world, despite relatively small numbers and influence. In the Middle Ages, whenever a Christian child disappeared or was found dead, Jews were often scapegoated.
AUDIO 7
They were accused of using their blood for Passover even though the ritual requirements for Passover were most definitely not...that. Skipping ahead a few centuries, in 1919, Erich Ludendorff, one of Germany’s top military leaders, announced that Jews were one of several groups responsible for the nation’s defeat in the first world war. By 1922, he focused almost entirely on Jews as the enemy of the German people, citing the Protocols of the Elders of Zion, a document supposedly containing the minutes of a secret meeting of Jewish leaders held at the turn of the 20th century. At that supposed meeting, the “Elders” allegedly plotted to take over the world. In reality, the Protocols document is a forgery. Russian secret police wrote it in the early 1900's to incite hatred against Jews. The document and other conspiracy theories became central to the worldview of Adolf Hitler. And finally, the big one: that Kubrick learned about the Illuminati and that he was murdered shortly after completing principle photography but before Eyes Wide Shut was released. In order for this to make a lick of sense, you would first have to believe the Illuminati exists, and they...don't? At least not the way you think. In the 18th century, there was a Bavarian group called the Illuminati.
They did...exist...but they didn't control the world. They were just a bunch of intellectuals, and the group was infiltrated and broken up in 1785. In the 20th century, there have been a great number of different conspiracy theories all using the name “Illuminati” – everything from reptilians to the Masons (again) to the Jews (again) to Satanists (AGAIN). I feel like I'm repeating myself, so let's skip to how this relates to Stanley Kubrick. The famous director died in 1999 at age 70 of a heart attack. It's a common way to go, considering his age and health. There is no evidence whatsoever that THE ILLUMINATI murdered him for “getting too close” to the truth. The mistaken pattern here for conspiracy theorists is that Kubrick died shortly after completing work on a movie about a secret society – so maybe the “real” secret society killed him! There is nothing to actually support this – it's just another case of finding a pattern out of a few loose details and expanding on it until it's fascinating and intriguing enough. You know what? Sometimes old, out of shape men die in their sleep at age seventy. It doesn't require reptilians or sorcery.
AUDIO 8
If the reptile world order or whatever existed – it doesn't – but if it existed, why would they even allow Eyes Wide Shut to be released at all? Couldn't they prevent that? Aren't they the New World Order, the all-powerful secret society that controls the world? What, are they in deep with Hollywood and wanted to make some money off of it? But aren't they also the super rich? Don't they have more money than God? Why would they risk exposure for nothing? See, not only is all of this horseshit, but when you allow yourself to believe in any of it, because it does not add up, you have to invent even more implausible conspiracy theories to fill in the holes and correct the inconsistencies, which can never end because the new theories to fill up the holes are also preposterous. It's a never-ending cycle in which their only answer is “Well, you can't prove it DOESN'T exist.” Proving a negative is unnecessary and even impossible. It doesn't mean anything. It's a logical fallacy. It's vapor. Kubrick conspiracy theorists don't want to believe the simplest explanations, that Stanley Kubrick was just a man. A good director with a keen eye for detail that came from being a photographer, a bit of a jerk by most accounts, and someone who died of natural causes at an advanced age.
It's unsatisfying to people who deify him, who make him out to be a film GOD who never did anything by accident. Kubrick conspiracy theorists – and conspiracy theorists in general – don't want to accept the randomness and chaos of the universe. Everything must be a structure, a plan, a pattern, or else nothing makes sense. It's a understandable desire, but it's also unhelpful at best and at worst, it's genuinely and disastrously damaging to our understanding of the world. It's too easy to dismiss conspiracy theorists as “loony” and either laugh or ignore, especially when they're responsible for harassment and sometimes even death. These conspiracy theories are not just about a movie, they are reflective of broader worldviews containing bigotry and ignorance that get people killed. In a time when we are inundated with “alternative facts” and outright lies, truth has become a precious commodity. It's exciting to learn about conspiracy theories. It's fun – until it's not fun. Then it's dangerous. Letting go of intriguing lies is a small price to pay for trying to make the world a little bit better.
THE LITTLE MERMAID
AUDIO 1
The Little Mermaid, the first film of the Disney renaissance, has long been the subject of both incredible praise and scathing social critique. Said critique generally goes thusly: In the film, Ariel's enchanted life under the sea is interrupted when she sets eyes upon a human. She gives up her entire life to be with him, quite literally erasing her identity and somehow lives happily ever after with a man she just met. The concern with this is that young girls who watch The Little Mermaid will internalize this and that the film reinforces negative, pre-existing values in society as they relate to gender roles and women's aspirations. This take is similar to those of other Disney renaissance movies. Beauty and the Beast is derided for normalizing Stockholm Syndrome or that The Lion King is secretly racist because the hyenas – the antagonists – are played by minority actors Whoopi Goldberg and Cheech Marin. In the case of Beauty and the Beast, what happens between Belle and Beast is not technically Stockholm Syndrome, and I would not even call Beauty and the Beast representative of abusive relationships considering the relationship only occurs after Beast corrects his behavior.
The narrative of the film does not back up this erroneous claim. The Lion King has some unfortunate framing of the poor and the well-to-do, which is a topic for another video, but the racism claim falls apart when you consider that the other hyena is played by Jim Cummings, and other minority actors like James Earl Jones and the late Robert Guillaume perform some of the “good guy” characters. So it is with The Little Mermaid, a film sometimes lambasted for telling young girls to give up your lives for a husband...but that's not actually what happens in the movie. First of all, Ariel is not giving up a rich and fulfilling life under the sea because she does not find her life under the sea rich and fulfilling. We are introduced to Ariel by her absence. She neglects attending a concert for her father in order to search for surface world objects in a ship. She has a whole collection of surface world nicknacks and baubbles. In fact, by the time we meet Ariel, she has collected a grand total of twenty thingamabobs, far more thingamabobs than one ever practically requires. Ariel is profoundly unsatisfied with her life in the undersea kingdom of Atlantica, as evidenced by her song in which she explicitly states just that.
AUDIO 2
She wants to be where the people are, [cough], wants to see, wants to see them dan-cin'. The idea that Ariel is giving up an otherwise satisfying life for a man is invalidated by the very fact that she does not have a satisfying life to begin with. But...that could still send the message that life itself for women is unsatisfying without a man. This complicates matters, right? Except...that's also not actually what happens in the narrative. Meeting Prince Eric is not the catalyst for Ariel seeking out Ursula, the sea witch. For one thing, she already wanted to live on land, and for another, that's not what happens in the scenes immediately prior to Ariel searching for Ursula. The catalyst to Ariel finally summoning up her courage to leave home and join the surface world is her father destroying her collection. King Triton rejects Ariel's obsession with the surface world, and this upsets her so much that she decides to take matters into her own hands. Obviously, Prince Eric is part of why she wants to live on the surface world, but her desire to live there pre-dates her meeting Eric. Meeting Eric and her father being extremely hard on her were simply last straws.
Furthermore, Ariel does not go to see Ursula with the intention of becoming human. That was an idea put into her head by Ursula. When Ursula suggests it, Ariel is surprised and initially hesitant. The film does not characterize Ursula has having a “good” idea. Her deal is Faustian. She's a stand-in for the Devil himself. The events of the film itself contradict the claim that the film endorses marriage to a man over a woman's independence. [sighs] HOWEVER, this is a film for children, and children don't always have an eye for details. It's completely reasonable to think that children might watch this movie and internalize a message that – while not actually there – is pretty close to being there. The fact that the movie does not explicitly endorse marriage over independence is not the strongest argument. Movies contain unintentional messaging, usually born of prevailing, unquestionable societal standards. The Little Mermaid definitely traffics in “love conquers all,” which is not exactly accurate, at best, and maybe even dangerous at worst. Some beliefs in a society are so commonplace that they become background radiation. In recent years, Disney has clumsily tried to course correct as it relates to this particular theme.
AUDIO 3
Frozen has a lot to say about love and when it's real and when it's not and the importance of not rushing into things. So much, in fact, that the film explicitly says this multiple times – practically right to the audience – in hopes of both sending the “right” message and also playing off its own history. Disney's attempt to re-contextualize itself is the stuff of marketing and defensiveness more than genuine introspection. The Little Mermaid tried to give young girls a more positive and active role model than, say, Snow White and Sleeping Beauty, who are more passive characters in their own stories. Ariel sings that she is a “bright young woman,” takes matters into her own hands to get what she wants, and forces her father to realize that she is capable of making decisions and running her own life. Sebastian and King Triton speak of this toward the end of the film, solidifying this is an intentional message of the story. Ariel will not be fooled into living a life she does not want, even if sung in a rousing number featuring the Duke of Soul. Ariel consistently stand up to her father and does not deter from chasing her dreams. The Little Mermaid is also the first Disney film in which the princess does the rescuing.
Ursula tells Ariel that she must choose between Prince Eric and having a relationship with King Triton, but Ariel defies these expectations, marries Eric and wins over her father. Prince Eric is brought up as evidence against The Little Mermaid as a “pretty” but empty man who Ariel loves inexplicably. While Eric does not get a lot of screen time or character development, everything we learn about Eric shows that he's a good choice for Ariel and that he respects her. The film does not pin down when the events take place, but the narrative is clearly from at least a century ago, and Eric is a relatively modern and sensitive man. He finds displays of himself as a warrior to be distasteful, he's a flautist, he's good with animals, he has a good sense of humor, and never tries to pressure Ariel into the relationship or into anything physical, and when he discovers she has a disability, he treats her with sympathy but never patronizes her. Eric never refers to her disability as a negative while he courts Ariel. Declaring The Little Mermaid a “feminist” movie or an “anti-feminist” movie is reductive. A movie is not feminist or anti-feminist as if a score card can neatly declare either of those things. Rather, The Little Mermaid can be viewed quite well under a feminist reading. There is some good stuff in The Little Mermaid. It's not hard to find.