Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi, everyone! A few quick updates and a deluge of scripts today. I will be attending VidCon next month. I'm not a guest, only an attendee. If you are going and you want to say hi, just let me know on Twitter. I'm also attending ConBravo, but I will actually be a guest there. I'll be hosting panels and autograph sessions. If you're thinking of going to a convention this summer that won't be too expensive, that's the one. 

The Saturday Night Live project is moving along. Thinking of calling it Saturday Neoliberalism with the thumbnail highlighting the S-N-L of the title. Oh, so clever, right? I finished watching every damn episode that I needed to watch. Some of the script is already written, but I will be spending most of the summer hunkering down and finish writing it. I announced it in early 2019 and said it would be done in "about a year." So, expect it some time in the first quarter of 2020. 

And now, the scripts to the recent episodes. Some are a bit different from the video versions.

STAR TREK

 AUDIO 1
 Two years ago, when a trailer dropped for Star Trek: Discovery, we finally got a look at what the first Trek show in over a decade would be: a stylized, intense, grittier-than-usual, space-faring adventure with a cinematic feel common to the era of Peak TV and, of course, being Star Trek, it had a diverse cast. The reaction from the darkest edges of the political far right was that of outrage and immediate condemnation. For all of the right's talk of left-wing “snowflakes” being offended at the slightest infraction, nobody launches into frothing, hateful convulsions like a right-winger whose pet obsession is the myth of “white genocide.” It's a paranoid conspiracy theory among the far right that denounces immigration and racial integration as tools to eliminate white people. It's also – apparently – been appropriated for discourse about popular media having diverse casts as a means of eliminating white people, particularly white men, from representation in media. The right spewed their venom again when the first episode debuted. The Klingons spoke of keeping their species pure and fighting against the comparatively “diverse” Federation.   
 Star Trek has always commented on the times, and the Klingons' desire to “remain pure” is a reflection on the rise of white supremacy and far right politics that have ramped up under the Trump administration. This is not idle speculation. One of the executive producers said that Trump's 2016 campaign was “front and center” in their minds when developing the series, and Jason Isaacs, who played Captain Lorca, went even further, adding "We're living in monstrous times, let's not dance around it. Hideous, divisive times, when all sorts of stuff we thought was long buried is coming to the surface, and being encouraged by the most powerful people on the planet. We're living in disgusting times." That's not say to no one on the left can be racist or sexist – that would be absurd. Of course an individual who is aligned with political left could be either of those things, but the ideology of the left is anti-racist and anti-sexist whereas the ideology of the right couches its racism and sexism in code words and dog whistles like “traditional values” and “law and order” – but is still nonetheless racist and sexist. Those espousing these racist and sexist beliefs in reaction to Star Trek: Discovery used the terminology of the right in more explicit terms.   
 AUDIO 2
 Modern canards like diversity or feminism as a “cancer” and other fear-mongering, hyperbolic verbiage that appeals to the aggressive, the angry and almost always from white men who can't see past their own entitlement. When one is accustomed to privilege, equality can feel like oppression. The backlash was immense, prompting Discovery actor Jason Isaacs to tell racist Star Trek fans that they can go fuck themselves. Right-wing Star Trek fans were angry that Trek had been “taken away from them” by the “radical left” or the “SJW's” or whoever their boogeyman is this week. And everyone else...kinda laughed? Because Star Trek has always been diverse, at least by the standards of its time. It's always been steeped in left-wing talking points and ideology. Everyone balked at this and said that these right-wingers, these Trump supporters, these, well, flat-out racists could not be “real” Star Trek fans. Because how could Star Trek appeal to the political right in the first place? [blank] No, seriously, we need to answer that, and the answer might be surprising. What people consider “the left” can be fluid, especially over time, but generally speaking, the left supports social and economic equality and is often in opposition to hierarchies that create disparities contrary to these goals.
 “The Left” should not be confused with “liberalism,” which is a fairly centrist political position in most of the world. In America, liberalism is considered the left only because it is in opposition to conservatism, which is to its political right. Liberalism is more progressive than conservatism, but liberalism still supports capitalism. Both the narrative and philosophy of Star Trek do not support capitalism, which is why it is often considered a show for leftists. Star Trek is always a little vague as to how the economy of the future works. This is deliberate because the intricacies of economics do not make for exciting television and because with so many writers over so many decades, keeping track of such things would be a headache. Also, not everyone involved in Star Trek over its history has had the same politics as Gene Roddenberry. Producer Rick Berman once said "What Gene wanted me to do was basically carry the ball for him, and to try to maintain his vision. He saw that I had respect for his vision--not because it's my vision. I don't believe the 24th Century is going to be like Gene Roddenberry believed it to be, that people will be free from poverty and greed. But if you're going to write and produce for 'Star Trek,' you've got to buy into that."  
 AUDIO 3
 Earth is free from poverty because it rejected the current economic system: capitalism. What was put in its place? All we can do is guess based on the evidence, and since Trek is fictional and we're not excavating a real society, no actual conclusion can be reached because no actual conclusion was ever written. You can't treat fiction the way you would the real world. However, we also can't discuss why Trek appeals to leftists without examining its economic system in as much detail as we can, so here are some semi-reasonable guesses based on hundreds of episodes of Star Trek and its movies. The Federation economy decouples labor from reward. This concept frightens capitalists and capitalist apologists because they believe that without the coupling of labor and reward, people will stop working and society will suddenly grind to a halt and that capitalism, which is a scarcity-based system, is still preferable to the incredible scarcity this would create. However, with the rise of automation, the potential for a post-scarcity society may be possible. We already have a surplus of food, for example, we simply do not distribute it to the whole world.   
 It's not a matter of scarcity, it's a matter of organization. In the future, a small number of humans or other aliens living among humans could produce all the food, energy and other requirements. Some people would choose to do this, and some people would choose other things. This might seem utopian – Star Trek is often labeled this, sometimes as a bludgeon – but this does not exactly seem like simple wishful thinking given our current trends. In Star Trek, these advances are helped along by visiting aliens – the Vulcans – but the real world humanity could realistically become self-sufficient in such a way that capitalism and even labor as we know it need not exist. That's not to say that this will happen, only that it could happen, and Star Trek shows us a future in which it does happen. Star Trek shows people to suddenly be absolutely in love with their humanity and more willing to lend a helping hand than in the real world present. People call Trek's vision of how humanity behaves to be utopian and a daydream as well, but the removal of hierarchical systems like capitalism would change the way we see each other: no longer in competition.   
 AUDIO 4
 The removal of economic competition among ourselves would remove alienation, the estrangement of people from their own lives due to living under stratified social and economic classes. The elimination of our alienation under capitalism could have the side-effect of greater harmony related to gender and race. This is because those classifications are often coupled with labor and economy. Imagine never having to worry about money – never having “economic anxiety” that is so often coupled with racism. Nobody could say “They're coming from another country to take our jobs!” because labor as we know it would not exist, thus reducing the “othering” of different people. The Federation, a coalition of various species, works because these species are not competing with each other. Gender relations are often strained due to labor and economy as well. People still argue about the “gender gap” in wages, and “women in the workforce” as a boogeyman phrase even today. Sexual harassment in the workplace that goes unnoticed because women are sometimes too afraid of losing their jobs to speak up, causing men to not realize how prevalent sexual harassment actually is. In a society where nobody needs to worry about losing their job, harassment would be better enforced and reduced.   
 Eliminating competition will not eliminate all racism, sexism, homophobia, transphobia, etc., but as Sisko once said about actually caring about people, it would be a start. Bigotry has not completely been eliminated in Star Trek. Captain Kirk admonishes one of his men about his prejudice in the original series episode, Balance of Terror. In the Next Generation episode The Drumhead, Captain Picard defends one of his men who is on trial at least in part due to his having Romulan ancestry. Worf is occasionally sexist, such as in the episode The Outcast, and so on. But progress has been made, and a lot of that is due to completely changing the economic system, thus eliminating our most alienating hierarchy. In the TNG episode, The Neutral Zone, Captain Picard tells someone from the past "People are no longer obsessed with the accumulation of 'things.' We have eliminated hunger, want, the need for possessions." How this is done is not explained in great detail, but based on how our future might actually unfold, we can guess that it has something to do with the loss of capitalism as the primary economic system on Earth.   
 AUDIO 5
 Star Trek does not, however, portray a society in which there is no private property. Joseph Sisko owns a restaurant, the Picard family owns a vineyard, Starfleet officers have personal items in their quarters, etc. At this point, we enter a guessing game – mere speculation – on how the Federation functions economically. In Star Trek: First Contact, Picard tells Lily Sloan that there is no money in the future. In Star Trek IV, a time traveling Kirk tells Spock that the people of the 20th century are still using money, suggesting that the Federation does not. In various episodes, Starfleet officers “pay” their bills with Federation credits. Based on the fact that there is no economic hierarchy, one assumes that everyone receives the same amount of credits at the same intervals, but this is never explicitly stated. Also, based on the fact that there is no poverty, one assumes that everyone receives Federation credits regardless of employment status. There are many ways this system is contradicted over the course of the series and movies. There is a “Bolian Bank” even though the Bolians are members of the Federation, for example. The Federation also trades with other governments, which means that Federation “credits,” whatever they are, must have some worth to people outside the Federation.   
 The Ferengi primarily use latinum as their currency, but Quark routinely accepts Federation credits from Starfleet officers. [Firstborn] The fact that the details are not explained does not invalidate a future that Star Trek proposes. It's more a matter of narrative convenience and different writers. Some writers will present a future that is deeply regressive, and some writers will have Rom quote Karl Marx. [clip] Star Trek more explicitly rejects capitalism through its introduction of the Ferengi as antagonists in The Next Generation and various other anti-capitalist and anti-disparity statements throughout the franchise. Regardless of what we call the economic system of the Federation, it is definitely something to the left of what we have now and therefore appealing to leftists. Sci-fi futures more often than not still showcase capitalism as its economy, an inescapable economic system even in the distant future. There are a lot of other aspects to Trek that appeal to leftists as well. Trek was “woke” before “woke” became a punchline. The Original Series attempted to tackle racism during the civil rights era, perhaps clumsily but nobody ever said Trek needed to be subtle.   
 AUDIO 6
 [The Measure of a Man] So many episodes across all series are like this. [Stigma] Trek attacks social issues with the bluntness of a hammer, everything from racism to homophobia to the AIDS epidemic. In addition, Trek weaved its vision of the future through its casts. Trek always had diverse casts. Admittedly, having two non-white characters in the main cast is not incredible by today's standards, but it was a landmark for its time. More women and people of color continued into The Next Generation and beyond. TNG even had a disabled character, albeit played by someone without that disability. It took a long time – too long, in fact – before Trek introduced characters who were explicitly gay, although you could argue that Jadzia Dax is the “future space alien” version of bisexual or pansexual, not to mention the fact that she has been multiple genders. Whining about diversity in Star Trek is not new. People whined when the commanding officer of Deep Space Nine was black and his first officer was a woman. People whined when Captain Janeway was announced as the lead character of Voyager, the first officer was revealed to be a Native American and when Tuvok was revealed to be a black Vulcan.   
 For all of Star Trek's leftist ideology, it has also attracted right-wingers and reactionaries among its fanbase. What could be so appealing about Star Trek to these people? Well, part of that could simply be that Star Trek is so ubiquitous that everyone has seen some of it and also that it's so well-made (sometimes) that people love it across political lines. But there is something more here. Something that might directly appeal to the political right. Starfleet is often euphemistically called the “exploratory wing” of the United Federation of Planets or the “trade organization” or a number of other cop-outs to what it is: the military. That's not to say that it's only military. It escorts ambassadors on diplomatic missions, it negotiates with other planets, it does...a lot for the Federation. But it is also the military. When the Borg strikes, the Federation sends Starfleet to fight its war. Ditto for the Dominion and every other conflict that the Federation finds itself in. Starfleet is many things, but one of those things is the military. Anti-war fans of Star Trek don't always want to acknowledge this, but the text of the series and films are right there. They even have naval ranks and often speak in terms of military hierarchies.
 AUDIO 7
 Star Trek tries to paint Starfleet as inherently benevolent and therefore not what we would call a “military,” except for all the times when it functions as a military and even outright is called just that. [The Most Toys] In the 2009 Star Trek movie, Captain Pike called it a “peacekeeping and humanitarian armada” instead of the word “military,” but no matter how hard Star Trek tries to call Starfleet something else, it is what it is. If one wishes to call Starfleet a different term while still acknowledging that Starfleet fights the Federation's wars, then such a term is a matter of semantics only and therefore unhelpful in classifying what Starfleet actually does. One political position common the right is that of having a strong national military force to both “defend” its borders but also as a means of interventionism. Protecting the nation's “interests,” often meaning wealth. In Star Trek, the Federation may not care about wealth, but that's a detail that the right would probably ignore or not care about when presented with this awesome, galaxy-sized military force. Starfleet is not only a powerful military due to its size but also due to how it functions and how much power it has consolidated under its banner.   
 In the real world, intelligence agencies within a country are sometimes divided into military and civilian. America, for example, has the Military Intelligence Corps, which is a branch of the United States Army. America has also the Central Intelligence Agency, which is a civilian organization. The CIA has performed a great number of paramilitary operations over the years, but there is still some separation of power here. In the United Kingdom, “MI” technically stands for "Military Intelligence,” but MI5 is actually a civilian intelligence agency. Not a wing of the armed forces. That's MI6. Again, a separation of powers. Starfleet, among other things, is the military for the Federation, but it is also the intelligence organization for the Federation. Starfleet Intelligence is the only intelligence organization for the Federation. There is no official civilian intelligence agency. Section 31 is officially part of Starfleet Intelligence in Discovery but a rogue organization in other series. It's never both official and civilian. It's always one or the other. This means that Starfleet has untold autonomy that goes beyond even the wildest dreams of the most hawkish military fetishist.   
 AUDIO 8
 But that's not all. Leftist ideology seeks to reduce hierarchies and to create something resembling a horizontal leadership. In Star Trek, the Federation's government may be more left-wing in its economy and tolerance of other people, but it is more right-wing in its structure. The legislature of the Federation called the Federation Council is unicameral, not bicameral like in America, and it only seems to contain a few dozen representatives. That's a few dozen people dictating law for over one hundred and fifty worlds and trillions of people. The Federation President is democratically elected but is also given powers beyond that of most representative republics. The Federation President serves as both the head of state and head of government, chief executive officer, the individual who determines most of the Federation's foreign policy and economy in a moneyless system somehow, and most importantly, serves as supreme commander of the Federation's military force: Starfleet. And if the Federation President has final say in Starfleet, then said President is also head of Intelligence for much of the galaxy. Starfleet has consolidated both military and intelligence powers, and the President presides over all of it.   
 There is a Federation Supreme Court, but it is rarely shown to act against the wishes of the president or legislature. This does not mean that Gene Roddenberry and later Rick Berman intended to show a psuedo-authoritarian space organization as the best possible outcome for Earth. Starfleet and the Federation are what they are for narrative convenience. A series about people living in peace on Earth is not exciting, so Star Trek is about Starfleet. And since the shows are about Starfleet, it is presented as doing a bit of everything. Yet, it's possible that this focus on an all-powerful military being the best arbiters of justice throughout the cosmos may be at least one reason why so many right-wingers love this otherwise left-leaning sci-fi franchise. You could argue that Starfleet is benevolent, and it mostly is, but that is how the right always sees its military no matter what it does: as a force for good. That's why Starfleet is appealing to them. It's the fictional justification for their real world military. This does not, however, invalidate Star Trek as a leftist narrative. In addition to everything already mentioned, Star Trek is explicitly anti-fascist, as evidenced by so many episodes in which Starfleet fights the Nazis or stand-ins for Nazi ideology. It is also anti-interventionist, as evidenced by the admittedly inconsistent prime directive. Star Trek does not provide a blueprint for how we achieve its future because there are no Vulcans coming to save us. We have to figure that out for ourselves.   

TRANSPHOBIA

 AUDIO 1
 Transphobia is the umbrella term for negative attitudes and feelings for transgender people, skepticism of transgender identities, and resentment or fear of the existence of transgender people changing the manner in which many societies have traditionally viewed gender. Transphobia has been seen everywhere from legislation to limit transgender people's access to public spaces, casual transphobia and transmisogyny in social circles, and negative representations of transgender people in popular media. Transgender people in film and television are often portrayed as deceivers, villains, killers, less than human or the subject of mockery. Criticizing media portrayals of marginalized people often summons defensiveness among those in the majority. “Well, we don't complain when straight white guys are bashed in movies!” First of all, this is untrue. Straight, cis white men have become noticeably upset simply when there are not enough straight, cis white men in a film or television show, even though straight white guys are the most common group in all popular media in the western world. Whiteness in white majority countries is impervious to marginalization due to their numbers. Heterosexuality is impervious to marginalization the world over for the same reason. Ditto for cisgender people.
 A negative representation of a straight white man in media cannot harm the standing of straight white men, particularly in white majority countries. Conversely, marginalized groups are obviously in a more vulnerable position in society. Second of all, and perhaps more on topic, it's different because portrayals of transgender characters are so rare, and when trans characters are portrayed, their characterizations are either profoundly negatively or at least inaccurate. In 2002, GLAAD began cataloging trans portrayals in media. Ten years later, they revealed their findings. In movies and television shows with a transgender character, these characters were cast in a "victim" role at least 40% of the time. Transgender characters were cast as killers or villains in at least 21% of the catalogued episodes and storylines. The most common profession transgender characters were depicted as having was that of sex workers. Anti-transgender slurs, language and dialogue was present in at least 61% of the catalogued episodes and storylines. 54% of trans characters were depicted as completely negative representations, and only 12% were depicted fairly and accurately. This is not “outrage” at a handful of poor choices in representations. This is a trend, and it has been going on for a long time.   
 [I. PORTRAYALS AS DECEIVERS]
 AUDIO 2
 Transgender characters, particularly transgender women, have a history of being portrayed as deceivers. Their identities are plot twists and empty jokes for the cisgender audience. Oftentimes, the revelation of a character as trans causes the cis character who was attracted to her to become uncontrollably sick. In Ace Ventura: Pet Detective, Jim Carrey's titular character kisses Lois Einhorn. Later in the film, Ventura makes the startling discovery that Lois is a trans woman, vomits in the toilet and cries in the bathtub in a scene that is meant to summon the image of someone who is attempting to become clean after being sexually assaulted. Ventura was not assaulted, their physical interaction was consensual, but the film portrays the way many cisgender people think of trans people, that their very existence is deceptive and that any sexual or romantic interaction is the product of that deception. Toward the end of the film, Ventura humiliates Einhorn by revealing she has had top surgery but not bottom surgery, which is not unusual among transgender people. One does not have to have surgery in order to be trans, and many transgender people use hormones only for a variety of reasons, one being cost.
 Ventura does not refer to Lois as a transgender woman. He misgenders her as a “man.” More than that, Lois becomes an object of ridicule, a little less human in the eyes of both Ventura and his colleagues, who also become physically sickened by a trans woman. This plot twist is common in comedies. The Naked Gun 33 1/3: The Final Insult contains a similar revelation with a similar reaction from Leslie Nielsen's iconic comedy character Frank Drebin. An episode of Family Guy follows this almost beat for beat. This also true of Soapdish, Dude Where's My Car, Crocodile Dundee and various others. [The Cleveland Show] The Crying Game portrays its trans character more sympathetically than most, but it still contains the trend of a cis man becoming ill and being “deceived.” These films and television shows generally conflate trans women with gay men – not only a matter of poor terminology but a matter of complete misunderstanding about trans identities. The reactions from presumably cisgender and straight men are meant to be comical, but it nonetheless taps into a prevalent societal attitude that depicts trans women as inherently deceptive. Ace Ventura and many of the other examples are from years ago, but this attitude persists in the real world, as evidenced by a common slur which identifies them by this alleged characteristic.   
 AUDIO 3
 It should be noted, however, that this characterization of trans people has appeared in media this decade, such as in the aforementioned Family Guy episode and The Hangover: Part II. The popular misconception of trans people as “deceivers” both on and off the screen has consequences beyond someone comically throwing up in a toilet. Trans people, more often trans women and even more often trans women of color, are subject to physical abuse or even murder when their so-called “deception” is uncovered. In July of 2008, 18-year-old Angie Zapata met 31 year old Allen Andrade. They spent three days together, during which they had at least one sexual encounter. When Andrade discovered that Zapata was transgender, he viciously beat her with a fire extinguisher. Upon his arrest, Andrade said he thought he had “killed it.” During the trial, Andrade's defense attorney claimed that Zapata “smiling” at Andrade was too “provocative” and that smiling was justification and a proper explanation for the murder. He was convicted of first degree murder. There are countless other examples. Worse still, others who have committed similar crimes have avoided the sentence that Andrade received.   
 This abuse and murder of trans people is often legally defended under what is commonly called the “trans panic” defense. This is a legal strategy which asks the jury to find that the victim's gender identity is to blame for the defendant's violent reaction or even murder. The defendant claims that the victim's gender identity either explains or excuses their loss of self-control. When defendants are fully or partially acquitted under this legal tactic, the courts send the message that trans lives matter less and that trans identities are inherently deceptive. The defendant often alleges that a sexual attraction or interaction triggered a nervous breakdown, a “gay panic” which was debunked by the American Psychiatric Association in 1952. Defendants claim that even a flirtation was “provocative” enough to warrant violence, which stigmatizes behavior which, on its own, is not illegal or harmful, but is considered “provocative” when it comes from a trans person. Defendants claim a kind of “self-defense” even when not attacked. According to the LGBT Bar, this defense has been used to acquit dozens of murderers.    
  AUDIO 4  
  Such a defense does not always work, but the fact that it is even partially effective shows a pattern of bias against transgender people in the legal system. Outside of the legal system and in social circles, transphobic people have justified these attacks as “fighting back” against trans people and that sex with a trans person who has not disclosed their life story is somehow tantamount to rape. Not only is this not legally defined as such, but it is also logically unsound and showcases a kind of social inequality because cis people are not held under the same scrutiny for their sexual encounters. Cis people are not expected to disclose their sexual history, physical history or anything else related to their body, past, previous sexual encounters, etc. It is deeply dehumanizing to think that it is the right of cisgender people to judge when transgender people are “allowed” to be sexually active. Trans people do not have to walk around with signs around their necks and warning labels across their bodies in order for cis people to judge them to be acceptable for sexual activity. More importantly, the argument that trans people would be safe if they would disclose their gender identity and past immediately falls apart when trans women are sometimes attacked and killed even without engaging with the cis man.    
 A trans woman named Islan Nettles was murdered simply for walking down the street near cis men. It is not sexual intercourse that makes cis men murder trans women. It is their very identity, which is mistakenly believed to be inherently deceptive and therefore “fair game” for violence and retribution. This common denominator in all of this violence is not deception among trans people but a desire among cisgender heterosexual men to protect their own status and the status of cis heteronormativity in society. It's not retaliation for deception. It's retaliation for mere existence. A recent episode of Jack Ryan features a character with a black eye mocked by his peers, claiming that a transgender sex worker must have done it. In addition to the episode carelessly using a transphobic slur, it reinforced the idea that transgender people are the aggressors whereas legal history and statistics show that not to be the case. At best, scenes like this are unhelpful, and at worst, they propagate dangerous, pre-existing attitudes about transgender people. [II. PORTRAYALS AS MONSTERS] In Psycho, Norman Bates has been metaphorically castrated by his mother, the result of which is a feminine man who takes on feminine traits.    
  AUDIO 5  
  That, combined with Norman dressing in women's clothes at the end, is meant to frighten the audience by his “otherness.” Norman is not explicitly identified by the word transgender and probably would not be called that, but the intention of his characterization is to create that “panic” among the audience. Norman's psychotic break and crossdressing are blurred together. Norman is not a serial killer who happens to be queer. He is a serial killer whose queerness is part of why the audience is meant to fear him. This is a film from 1960, but films made decades later follow similar paths. The Silence of the Lambs features a transgender character called Buffalo Bill. She is also not a serial killer who happens to be transgender but instead a serial killer whose violent actions are related to her murders. She kills overweight women in hopes of making a “woman suit” to complete her transition. Hannibal Lecter claims that Buffalo Bill is not actually transgender and all characters misgender Bill throughout the film, but this does not in any way lessen the characterization of anyting outside of cisnormativity as dangerous or insane.    
  If anything, it plays with the misconception that many cisgender people have of trans people: that trans people are merely “confused” and have misidentified and mislabeled themselves. In the television series CSI, Paul Millander, a trans man, is a serial killer and arch-enemy of Gil Grissom. He appears several times throughout the series. Nip/Tuck featured a psychopathic trans woman depicted as a baby-kidnapping sexual predator who have sex with her own son. There are many other examples, such as Aunt Martha in Sometimes Aunt Martha Does Awful Things, Angela Baker in the Sleepaway Camp series, Bobbi in Dressed to Kill and so forth. The portrayal of Buffalo Bill is particularly insidious because it plays into a talking point that is often used against transgender people: that their existence is a threat to cis women and that their rights must be limited to protect cis women. This erroneous statement is usually made by cis men who are using cis women as pawns in their transphobia. These are usually the same men who are suspicious of women's claims of sexual assault and skeptical about women's modern concerns like wage gaps and harassment in the workplace.  
  AUDIO 6  
 Yet, some who demonize transgender people are cis women – radical feminists who exclude trans women from womanhood and sometimes label trans men as confused or lost. The truth is that transgender people are far more likely to be victims of violence than to cause violence. According to statistics tracking by the Human Rights Campaign, the murder of transgender people – often for reasons related to transphobia – has been on the rise for the past several years. In addition to this violence, discrimination at the intersection of gender identity and race lead to significant barriers to both employment and housing. The consequences of this discrimination pushes many transgender people into underground economies to survive, including sex work, and into circumstances where they may be more likely to face violence. The proliferation of the “transgender serial killer” character in film and television has given a completely false impression of the lives of trans people. These characterizations are actually the reverse of what life often is for trans people in real life. Director Lilly Wachowski once said of this:  
 “Though we have come a long way since Silence of the Lambs, we continue to be demonized and vilified in the media where attack ads portray us as potential predators to keep us from even using the goddamn bathroom. We are not predators, we are prey.” [III. RECENT PORTRAYALS] In the past decade, movies like The Hangover Part II with shock trans revelations became a little more rare. The changing of the times did not allow transphobia to be expressed so overtly as contemptible or depraved, but social inequality does not diminish greatly over time. It only finds new forms. People find new uses for it, new expressions of it. Racism against black people in America took the public face of slavery, and then it took the public face of Jim Crow, and then it took the public face of mass incarceration and forced labor; more “socially acceptable” forms of racism and slavery that still allowed businesses to exploit and profit from racism. Comparatively, when studios and screenwriters became aware of mildly changing attitudes about transgender people, transphobia had to take a new form. The shift away from trans characters as monsters and deceivers left a void to be filled.   
 AUDIO 7
 One method of keeping transphobia in films is by co-opting queerness. Zoolander 2 is the sequel to a movie in which the primary joke is that these men display characteristics that are traditionally associated – perhaps unfairly -- to women. Zoolander 2 features a character named All, a non-binary or androgynous character. No actual term is explicitly given. When Hansel and Derek meet All, Hansel asks if All has a hot dog or a bun and then clarifies, “Do you have a wiener or a vaginer?” Defenders of this characterization would say that the movie mocks Hansel for being out of touch, but All is far more the subject of mockery than Hansel. The movie jokes that All is marrying “hermself,” treating non-binary people as an absurdity. Deadpool gives its license to mock the LGBT community partly because it presents the titular character as part of the community. Director Tim Miller and Ryan Reynolds describe the character as pansexual. Yet, there is no actual same-gender romance or sex in the film, and the movie version of Deadpool is pansexual because the creators of the movie say so and there are hints of this in the comics, not because he is depicted that way in the film.
 It's the “Dumbledoor was gay” cop-out that is revealed by the author but not in the text. Deadpool's soulmate is a cis woman, Vanessa. This sorta kinda characterization of Deadpool as queer allows for a mild, threadbare defense of the movie's overtly transphobic comments. One of the villains of the movie is Angel Dust played by Gina Carano. Upon meeting Angel Dust, Deadpool says “Aren't you a little strong for a lady? I'm calling wang.” By presenting these characters as part of the LGBT community, movies give themselves permission to make transphobic jokes and to play with the audience's transphobia. Another modern reinvention of transphobia in popular media is that of being trans as body horror for cis people. In The Skin We Live In, a young man is forcibly transformed into a woman using the procedure that was commonly and sometimes pejoratively called a “sex change,” but is now more commonly called gender confirmation surgery. The newly reassigned person is then held captive and raped by the surgeon. The Assignment – formerly called (Re)Assignment – a professional killer is captured and forcibly given the surgery to become, well, Michelle Rodriguez.
 AUDIO 8
 The Skin We Live In and The Assignment are not about actual transgender women – they are about cisgender men who are physically violated. Worse still, the character in The Assignment who does the violating is portrayed as a champion for transgender rights, making a mockery of the long and still ongoing struggle. [IV. CONCLUSION] These characterizations would not stand out as much if there were greater positive representation of transgender people in popular media, but when the vast majority of trans characters are portrayed as either negatively or as problematic, these portrayals become dominant. Defensiveness about this issue often comes in the form of hyperbole that exaggerates the concern: “What? So, EVERY depiction of [insert marginalized group] needs to be positive?!” No, because that might be impossible, but a little sensitivity toward the very real consequences of said depictions might be warranted. Furthermore, in this case, these depictions are not outliers. They are the norm. When transgender characters are more frequently portrayed as villainous, disgusting, victims, aggressors, clowns and body horrors than not, then there is an unmistakable trend in how this group is depicted.    
  These examples are not cherry picked. They are the most common and most famous depictions of trans people. More sympathetic depictions generally come from so-called “art house” films like A Fantastic Woman and Tangerine but are not presented for mainstream audiences and therefore have limited impact. The Danish Girl is an outlier – a movie made for a mainstream audience that also depict transgender people as sympathetic protagonists and not monsters, but this movie and other movies like it also feature cisgender actors portraying trans characters. The trans community often cites this as furthering the misgendering of trans people and the misconception that trans people are only cis people in costumes. Finding a film or show with a transgender character that also has that character prominent in the story and not in a small role, portrayed by a trans actor and within a film or show that is designed for a mainstream audience and not the “art house” crowd is a challenge. Transparent cast a cis actor for its lead. Rise was canceled after one season and that show's transgender character only had a small role.  
  AUDIO 9  
 Then again, there's Sense8, which was on Netflix but canceled after two seasons, Orange Is the New Black, certainly, and definitely Pose, which is on FX. Those are the exceptions. Not the rule. Not every trans character needs to meet this criteria. That's not the point. The fact that so few depictions of trans people can meet that criteria in the first place proves that there is an irrefutable trend that has been going on for decades. It would be ignorant to say there has been no progress – shows like Pose did not exist in the 1980's – but the shifting media portrayals often given rise to new damaging and dehumanizing media portrayals. Trans men are even more excluded from media than trans women. This mirrors the exclusion of trans men in the discourse about transgender people in general, even though trans men, one would assume, make up roughly half of trans people. Society feels less “threatened” by trans men because patriarchal society views men as a kind of default. If trans men can't be mocked as easily as trans women, then they are less likely to be represented in popular media because popular media so frequently mocks trans people. That is not to say that trans men somehow have it easy.
 They are still subject to the same anti-trans legislation and the same potential for rejection by their families. Trans men being “erased” allows them to be more hidden from certain harms, but it also forces them to be misunderstood due to this erasure and lack of representation. This video suffers because of so few examples of trans men in media, which makes it challenging to discuss this representation. Boys Don't Cry was a long time ago. Popular media does not force people to behave a certain way, but it does inform and shape our worldview. If media consistently portrays trans people as monsters or objects of mockery, it infects that worldview. This is especially among viewers whose only exposure to transgender people are these negative, dehumanizing portrayals. The best we can do is call out these portrayals. When one form on transphobia in media is mostly erased due to public outcry and media watchdog groups, a new one attempts to replace it. It's...whack-a-mole. But the alternative is worse: letting the transphobes win and allowing their misrepresentations to go unchecked, leaving no chance for progress. 


WILL GOD FORGIVE US?

 AUDIO 1
 In the film First Reformed, Reverend Ernst Toller befriends an environmental activist. When the activist commits suicide, Toller begins to learn more and more about global warming – what we now call “climate change” due to the George W. Bush administration hoping to soften the issue and mislead the public. Toller learns of the relationship between the local megachurch and an industrialist who is harming the environment. Joel Jeffers, the pastor at the megachurch, tries to dismiss these concerns, but Toller is convinced that God wants mankind to protect the environment and that the relationship of money and religion is doing harm to God's creation. The film has themes of forgiveness, doubt, all manner of things, but it's also a fine narrative representation of how money and religion mix to further our environmental catastrophe. Denial of anthropogenic climate change – meaning climate change that is man-made – is not a uniquely American problem, but the percent of deniers in America dwarf that of most other regions on Earth. When polled, 77% of the population of Latin America said they believe and understand that climate change is harming them. European countries range from 88% to 97% of people feeling that it's happening and similar ranges are present for agreeing that climate change is caused by human activity. There is a gap between “developing” countries and countries that are already considered developed.   
 For example, in still developing Asian and Pacific countries, only 31% believe climate change to be a threat, but in developed countries in that region, the number is 74%. In many still-developing African countries, that percentage is also low. But America is unique in its denial of climate change because it has fewer excuses. It is not a developing country, it is fully developed by international standards. It has an education system that can inform the public, it has a powerful media that can do that too, and it has the wealth to combat climate change if need be. Yet, only 45% of Americans believe climate change is a very serious problem. Furthermore, America has the third highest percentage of climate change deniers, behind only Indonesia and Saudi Arabia. But why? Why America? What is unique to America as it relates to climate change? The answers appear to be a perfect storm of a large percentage of socially conservative Christians, the energy industry's relationship with the fiscally conservative Republican Party, and the Republican Party's relationship with conservative Christianity. An ouroboros. A snake that eats itself. But it wasn't always this way, and it didn't have to be this way.
 AUDIO 2
 [PART I. CHRISTIAN STEWARDSHIP] In the book of Genesis, chapter 1, verse 26, it was written “Then God said, 'Let us make mankind in our image, in our likeness, so that they may rule over the fish in the sea and the birds in the sky, over the livestock and all the wild animals, and over all the creatures that move along the ground.'” Upon reading this, one may have the mistaken impression that the Holy Bible commands mankind to have authority over Earth and that whatever it chooses to do with the Earth is right in the eyes of God. This, however, ignores the very next chapter. In chapter 2, verse 15, it was written “And the Lord God took the man, and put him into the garden of Eden to dress it and to keep it.” According to the Holy Bible, God wants mankind to “tend the garden,” to look after the Earth. Only God owns and rules the Earth. The planet is never given to mankind in terms of ownership but instead is “given” Earth as a task to complete for God. In the Book of Job, God said “Who has a claim against me that I must pay? Everything under heaven belongs to me.” Tending the Earth and protecting it is commonly called “stewardship,” the belief in Christianity that human beings do not own the world but instead are responsible for the world and that they must take care of it while living in it.    
 This is also referred to as “Creation Care” among some Christians. God wants human beings to be his collaborators in the work of creation, redemption and sanctification. God does not do everything for us, and in turn, Christians are commanded to perform acts for God. Church leaders often call for Christians of various denominations to practice stewardship. Pope Paul VI, in his Octogesima Adveniens letter, stressed the importance of preserving the environment. John Paul II had similar concerns, Pope Benedict XVI installed solar panels in the Vatican and Pope Francis has called the exploitation of Earth “our sin.” Francis has been explicit that climate change is both real and mostly the result of human activity. The politics of these varying popes differ greatly – Benedict is conservative even by papal standards – but stewardship is a command by God Himself and is a concept that can transcend politics. Stewardship is also interdenominational. Lutheran synods – meaning assemblies of clergymen – have declared the need for stewardship. The same is true of the Episcopal Church. In other respects, the Lutherans and Episcopalians are political opposed, as Lutherans in America are more likely to be conservative Republicans and Episcopalians more likely to be Democrats.    
  AUDIO 3  
 But stewardship is a commonality. If stewardship is so important in Christianity, how is opposition to stewardship communicated to Christians by American politicians, and why do so many Christians buy into it? In 2017, the United States withdrew from the Paris Agreement on climate change. President Donald Trump believed this would be better for business and the businessmen who back him, but other Republicans couched their opposition to the Paris Agreement in their Christianity and the Christianity of their constituents. Representative Tim Walberg said “As a Christian, I believe that there is a creator in God who is much bigger than us. … And I’m confident that, if there’s a real problem, He can take care of it.” Representative Walberg's statement does not hold up well to scrutiny, even among devout Christians. Dismissing a man-made problem like climate change with a statement such as “God will sort it out” means that all concerns can be dismissed with that. Walberg does not propose ignoring any other problem. He recently wrote an op-ed about the opioid crisis, introduced a bill to change healthcare options for small businesses, and so forth.    
 Why is the answer to all other terrestrial matters action on the part of humanity and the answer to climate change “God will sort it out”? There is a reason why so many of his constituents accepted this answer, and there is a separate reason why he said it in the first place. A self-serving political message needs an audience that will accept this message for their own reasons. Let's focus on the acceptance of this answer among Christians first. [PART II. Christian Anthropocentrism] Anthropocentrism is the philosophical viewpoint that human beings are the most significant entities in the world and that humans are both separate from and superior to nature. Taken to its extreme, anthropocentrism is a viewpoint that can also contend that anything that is not human in the world does not matter and that all resources are justifiably ours to exploit. Christian Anthropocentrism takes this further by saying that human beings are the most significant entities in the universe and that we are both separate from and superior to nature due to decree by God. Christian Anthropocentrism sometimes comes into conflict with Christian Stewardship because even if Christians believe in some level of stewardship, they also believe that whatever they chose for the environment must be for the best if our stewardship is God's mandate.  
  AUDIO 4  
 Anyone with an even passing understanding of the Holy Bible might find this ludicrous, considering that shortly after Adam was made steward of the Garden of Eden, he and Eve made their infamous mistake. Christian Anthropocentrists tend to ignore that and instead focus on Pslam 115, verse 6: The heavens are the Lord's heavens, but the earth he has given to human beings.” Again, other books, chapters and verses clarify that humans do not “own” the Earth, but to Christian anthropocentrists, this is close enough. Bear in mind that anthropocentrism in and of itself is not inherently “bad” but that it can lead Christians down a path that may be dangerous for our planet. It's possible to value the environment without discarding anthropocentrism. Sometimes called prudential or enlightened anthropocentrism, this view holds that humans do have ethical obligations toward the environment because they can be justified in terms of obligations toward other humans. Environmental impact does not only hurt the birds and the trees. It hurts human beings – the people who Christian anthropocentrists believe are the most significant entities.    
  Political scientists and public policy experts have reported that American Christians, as a whole, have lower levels of environmental concern than non-Christians: Jews, people of other faiths, nonbelievers, etc. The higher the level of religious commitment – meaning self-reports of importance, frequency of religious service attendance, and frequency of prayer, the lower the level of environmental concern.    Christians have read roughly the same Bible and have come to radically different conclusions. The two groups that are least concerned about climate change are white Evangelicals and white Catholics – two groups that heavily vote Republican. This is not a coincidence. More on that later. Remember that study that showed only 45% of Americans consider climate change a very serious problem? This study shows similar but slightly different numbers due to the question's phrasing: 50% of Americans either very concerned or somewhat concerned. That number is pulled down significantly by these two groups at the bottom. According to a paper by the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, this environmental backlash include conservatives suspicions that “stewardship,” improperly understood, resembles neo-pagan nature worship and might even lead to anticapitalist sentiments.    
  AUDIO 5  
  The backlash was furthered along by a reinvigorated belief in the “end times” and that stewardship is pointless as we near the end of the world. Hal Lindsey furthered America's apocalyptic expectations with his 1970 book The Late Great Planet Earth, and Tim LaHaye and Jerry B. Jenkins exploded this into popular culture 25 years later with the Left Behind book series and later movies. Within this mindset, catastrophic climate change does not effectively compete for concern with the coming cosmic drama. A recent study confirms that expectation of an imminent apocalypse among conservative American Christians is directly tied to decreased environmental concern. In fact, with many end times believers assuming that they will be among those saved by God, there is not only a lack of concern but even – for some – an anticipation of the end of the world. [PART III. FOLLOWING THE MONEY] We know why Christian Americans are willing to deny climate change. But why do Republican politicians, whether Christian or not, engage in this denial? Some may genuinely believe that the end times are coming that this is all part of God's plan, but for many politicians, the answer is more terrestrial and less supernatural: money  
 The oil industry, the coal industry, all energy industries that play some part in climate change have known for a long time that global warming is anthropogenic – man-made. Major fossil fuel companies have known for decades that their products—oil, natural gas, and coal—cause global warming. Their own scientists told them so more than 30 years ago. In response, they concluded that they must deceive shareholders, politicians and the public in order to maintain their billion dollar companies. This is no longer speculation. Their tactics were made public through a series of investigations, lawsuits, leaks and disclosures through Freedom of Information Act requests. As early as 1977, representatives from fossil fuel companies attended congressional hearings in which carbon emissions were discussed. By 1981, at least one company – Exxon – was already considering the implications of what their company was doing. By 1988, James Hansen, a leading NASA climate scientist, testified before Congress that they now had irrefutable data confirming that industrial activities were causing a steady increase in average global temperature.  
  AUDIO 6  
  By the early 90's, industries ramped up their projects to position climate change as a theory rather than a fact. If you can call it a “theory,” then the public doesn't have to accept it. Climate change denial is not just a percentage of misinformed Americans, it's a network of think tanks and front groups, paid for by right-wing organizations and powerful industries to provide just enough dissent within the scientific community to create doubt in the public. If there is doubt in the public, then the politicians that these industries bought can safely vote against environmental protection. The overwhelming consensus among climate scientists is that global warming is at least partially man-made. Much of the dissent, however small it may be, comes from these right-wing think tanks and front groups funded either by fossil fuel industries or groups affiliated with them. In order to give the false impression of a genuine scientific debate, these think tanks say that the jury is still out on climate change. This is trumpeted by right-wing media like Fox News and accepted by those Americans who predominantly watch Fox News as their primary information source.  
 This creates the impression that climate change denial is as legitimate as the climate change reality for the millions of Americans who consume this media. The fossil fuel industries create groups with names like Americans for Prosperity: a front group posing as concerned citizens performing grassroots protests but is actually funded by the infamous oil barons, the Koch brothers. Koch Family Foundations have spent over 127 million dollars directly financing 92 groups that have attacked climate change science and policy solutions, from 1997-2017. Fossil fuel industries donate to the campaigns of politicians they believe are friendly to said industries, and these politicians then parrot these talking points. More than $2 billion was spent on lobbying climate change legislation in the United States from 2000 to 2016, with the fossil fuel industry, transportation companies, and utilities outspending environmental groups and the renewable energy industry 10 to 1. It's not that conservative Christians in America are climate change deniers by happenstance or that this belief in entirely informed by their faith. Their prediction of a supernatural end time is given precedent over science, and any potential fear of climate change is removed by the lies of bought politicians.   
 AUDIO 7
 Any pre-existing mistrust of climate science due to their faith would not have such an impact if not for the powerful industries and politicians who tap into these beliefs and tell these lies. That's not to say that all these politicians are aware that they are telling lies. It's entirely possible that they are simply incurious enough to not have a strong opinion, but what is in their heart does not change the falseness of climate change denial. Some Christian groups and churches, realizing that their flock is among those most likely to get suckered in by climate change denial for all the aforementioned reasons, have tried to mitigate this damage. Unfortunately, success has been limited. In a way, this isn't anything new. Politicians in America have relied on Christianity to push their agendas for a long time, and the clergy have pushed the politics of the right in a kind of unspoken handshake agreement. During the Cold War, evangelicals who believed in the second coming of Jesus Christ argued that God wouldn't allow mankind to destroy itself in a nuclear war. The aforementioned Tim LaHaye, co-author of Left Behind, wrote in 1972 that the world might be destroyed in a nuclear war, but if it did happen, God would be behind it, and God is always right.    
 In fact, socially conservative evangelicals during the Cold War saw disarmament as a greater threat than proliferation. Jerry Falwell coined the phrase “Peace through strength” in the 80's. The difference between then and now is that the political and religious right both have more powerful infrastructures to peddle climate change denial. The right-wing billionaire propaganda apparatus is more powerful now than during the post-World War II era, at least partly due to the rise of the Internet, and the religious right now has megachurches instead of holding their “revivals” in tents. The connection between the political right and the religious right is stronger and more dangerous than ever before. Even when they don't work together directly, their views align in such a way that they benefit one another anyway. [PART IV: CONCLUSION] [1:06:49]There is a part in First Reformed in which Reverend Toller makes a sign that says “Will God forgive us?” The global climate is projected to continue to change over this century. It's only a matter of how much at this point.    
  AUDIO 8  
 They are still things we can do to mitigate the damage, but some of this is happening already. The amount of climate change beyond the next few decades depends primarily on the amount of heat-trapping gases emitted globally, and how sensitive the Earth’s climate is to those emissions. Precipitation has increased over the past hundred years, as have droughts and heat waves. Hurricanes and becoming stronger, more intense and therefore deadlier. Hurricane-associated storm intensity and rainfall rates are projected to increase as the climate continues to warm. The sea level is rising and will continue to rise by one to four feet throughout this century. America is particularly at risk. In the northeast, heat waves, heavy downpours and sea level rise pose challenges to infrastructure, agriculture, fisheries and ecosystems. In the southeast, sea level rise poses widespread and continuing threats to the region’s economy, environment and habitability of areas near the coast. People will lose their homes and some will lose their lives. Extreme heat will affect health, energy, agriculture and will cause a decrease in water availability. In the midwest, forestry, transportation, air and water quality, and more will be affected. Climate change will also exacerbate a range of risks to the Great Lakes.
 In the northwest, threats include sea level rise, erosion, inundation, risks to infrastructure, increasing wildfire, insect outbreaks and tree diseases. In the southwest, increased heat, drought, increased wildfires, declining water supplies, reduced agricultural yields, and flooding and erosion in coastal areas. Some of this has already begun, and some is yet to come. Due to our low reaction to this, some of this is inevitable, but not all of it is. There is still time to mitigate some of the damage and keep the planet mostly habitable. At the end of First Reformed, Reverend Toller is lost and ready for oblivion, but he is saved at the last moment. It's not too late.
 

WWE


AUDIO 1


The United States of America and the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia have had a close relationship for the better part of a century. Despite the noticeable differences in government – the US being a secular constitutional republic and Saudi Arabia being a far-right theocratic monarchy -- the two nations bonded over a mutual disdain for socialism and a mutual love of weapons and oil. Saudi Arabia has the oil, and America needs the oil. America has the weapons, and Saudi Arabia needs the weapons. America needs oil for transportation, and Saudi Arabia needs weapons to perform airstrikes in Yemen that kill civilians. In 2017, Saudi Arabia bought $110 billion worth of arms from America with the expectation that they will buy another $350 billion in arms from America over the next ten years. For reasons like this – as well as their ongoing human rights abuses – The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia has a terrible reputation the world over. Not its people but its rulers: The Saudi Royal Family. Recently, the royals had an idea. “What if,” they thought “we could improve our international reputation with some superficial, insignificant reforms and publicly ally ourselves with a powerful American company? But what company could we find that has absolutely no shame?”

 

[I. THE DEAL] World Wrestling Entertainment is existed in one form or another since 1952. Vince McMahon, seen here with his tongue in the mouth of one of his wrestlers, has been chairman since 1980. He took a family business and made it an international sensation. Through a series of broken promises and steroid scandals, McMahon amassed an empire that is now the leading brand in professional wrestling across the world. Although publicly traded, WWE remains a “family business” in key way: members of his family, including his children and son-in-law, help run WWE to this day. The House of Saud is the ruling family in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. More commonly called the Saudi Royal Family, the head of the House of Saud is King of Saudi Arabia. The King serves both head of state and monarch of the Kingdom. The King holds almost absolute political power, but the King sometimes appoints someone else to be the public face of the kingdom or to do the legwork because I guess being a king with no real accountability gets hard sometimes. Right now, that man is Crown Prince Muhammad bin Salman. Human rights under the Saudi Royal Family are considered among the worst in the world by almost any metric.


AUDIO 2


Saudi Arabia performs public executions by beheading and can be performed for any number of offenses, many of which would not be considered capital crimes in most of the world. A Saudi citizen can be publicly executed for repeated drug use, heresy or apostasy, adultery, witchcraft and more. I guess they got a real witch problem over there. Earlier this year, Saudi Arabia carried out a mass execution of thirty-seven prisoners, mostly due to confessions that were made under torture. Women are given status similar to that of children in Saudi Arabia and comprise only 5% of the workforce, the smallest in the world. The public practice of any religion besides Islam is strictly prohibited. The press is actively censored by the Saudi government. Peaceful protest can get you locked up for 15 years. Homosexuality is illegal and punishable by either imprisonment or even execution. 


Doctors are banned from giving hormone replacement to transgender people and honestly, the list just goes on and on. Bear in mind that none of this is a condemnation of the Saudi people. They're the victims, not the oppressors, and a lot of them are trying to fight back. The problem is the government. Not the people. The deal between WWE and the Saudi Royal Family is for WWE to do huge shows in Saudi Arabia and help them with propaganda for the family while they're there. Unlike the vast majority of WWE shows, their events in Saudi Arabia are funded by the government, controlled by the Saudi Royal Family. Normally when WWE wants to tour somewhere, they pay some fees, do some paperwork, make a deal with the arena about profits and who gets what, and then all of the sudden, Monday Night Raw is live from Tampa, Florida or London, England or wherever WWE wants to hock its merchandise. In this case, Saudi Arabia handles everything. WWE just needs to show up and rassle. Now you might be thinking “So what about Saudi Arabia? Why is it strange that WWE is doing shows in Saudi Arabia? They do shows in other countries with less than stellar reputations all the time, and America is an imperialist nightmare.” And all that's true. 


AUDIO 3


In fact, this isn't even the first time WWE has toured Saudi Arabia. But WWE's events everywhere else are not paid for exclusively by the government or paid to be propaganda. When WWE tours the UK, their events are not paid for by the Queen, and WWE is under no obligation to endorse the UK government or make a stand on Brexit. They're just there to put on a wrestling show. Frankly, WWE usually has their heels mock the city or country they're in for some cheap heat. The precise terms of the deal are unknown only to those who have signed it and those who have access to it, but since WWE is a publicly traded company, they make quarterly reports on their earnings. Some of the details have been sussed out while other details remain under lock and key. One thing we do know for sure is that WWE's money from Saudi Arabia is stacked higher than that of Wrestlemania. The gate alone for Wrestlemania this year was around $16 million, but that's chump change compared to the Saudi Arabia deal. 


There have been conflicting reports on just how lucrative this deal is for WWE, but by the most trusted accounts, this will make the company at least $45 million per year on the deal. That may be an estimate because WWE's earnings in Saudi Arabia are listed as “Other” in their financial reports. Let's say this conservative estimate is correct and that WWE stands to make 45 million per year. The deal lasts for ten years. WWE stands to make, at least, $450 million dollars over the course of their deal with the Saudi Royal Family. That's nearly half a billion dollars into the WWE coffers. Maybe with that much cheddar, they can start giving their wrestlers health insurance. (They won't.) This is a ridiculous amount of money for two shows per year, especially considering how little is actually grossed for Saudi Arabia. Media outlets have reported that their first show only made the Saudis $250,000, and the second made a similar amount. The Saudi Royal Family is losing a tremendous amount of money on this contract. There is absolutely no way for them to earn a profit from it. For WWE, it's a sweetheart deal. For the Saudi Royal Family, it seems like a bad investment...except they aren't trying to make money off WWE directly. They have other plans in mind.


AUDIO 4


When WWE tours in Chicago, their presence helps the city's economy, and of course WWE makes a tidy sum from the tickets and any merch they sell. That's the arrangement. They aren't summoned there on the behest of the Mayor of Chicago and paid $45 million just to show up. There would be no return on that investment. So, why is this happening in Saudi Arabia? What do the Saudi Royals want from their association with WWE? Saudi Arabia practically gave their tickets away. They had no intention of making money from this. Their objective was not to make money from their alliance with WWE. The deal to have WWE put on shows for them and their people is part of a “charm offensive” to the west. To understand this, you gotta understand the Saudi Royal Family. [II. Charm Offensive: 27.4] In April of 2016, Crown Prince Mohammad bin Salman unveiled his plan for the future: Vision 2030. While the plan was lauded as a modern solution to the monarchy’s heavy reliance on oil, it simply does not involve significant social reform. Instead, it has provided the Saudi Royal Family with a strategic way to distract international attention away from massive human rights abuses that the country commits to this day. 


It's almost entirely a financial plan. Not a social progress plan. Among his goals are “reforms” for the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, such as allowing women to drive. Saudi Arabia was the last nation on Earth that criminalized women driving. When they decriminalized it, the international media ate it up. What a reformer! Women drivers! How progressive. What's next? Freedom of religion? No, literally no chance of that. Well, maybe decriminalizing homosexuality. No, that's still on the books as punishable by prison or execution. But still. Women can now put their hands on a steering wheel without going to prison. Much progress. So equality. But that didn't matter to the media. The Crown Prince got what he wanted: positive press for his country and the Saudi Royal Family. Reputation means a lot. PR means a lot. For example, when the Saudi royals recently had a journalist murdered, it caused an international stir resulting in several nations in the European Union to suspend their weapon sales to the kingdom. The Saudi Royal Family wants the Kingdom to have more influence in world politics, and you can either earn a better reputation or you can buy one. 


AUDIO 5


The closest thing to a real reform is the Crown Prince saying he will stamp out corruption in the government, but guess what, buttercup? You're the government! And you and your family do ALL the crimes! What the Saudi Royal Family means when they say they will end corruption is that they will end corruption outside their family. They want all the corruption for themselves. This parallels Donald Trump's claim of “draining the swamp” and then presiding over an administration that itself is corrupt. 


How many scandals have their been? Are they daily now? The Crown Prince gives up nothing, gains everything and everyone calls him a selfless and earnest reformer because it makes for an appealing narrative in mass media. The reforms are not “bad” – women being able to drive is good – but the reforms won't go much further than that. Saudi Arabia is an ultraconservative theocracy, and that won't change outside of a revolution. Bottom of the barrel reforms are not indicative of significant reforms any time soon, if ever, and so far, that has been confirmed. Executions have gone up since the Crown Prince's Vision 2030 plan. The interventionist war in Yemen has intensified under the Crown Prince. The war in Yemen is so bloody and such a disaster that even longtime ally the United States tried to pull support for it in Congress until the bill in was vetoed by the President.


AUDIO 6


Donald Trump loves the Saudi Royal Family. They are peas in a pod. Saudi Arabia has become more dangerous to its people and to its neighbors. The “reforms” related to entertainment are superficial. It's a veneer, a thin veil and nothing more. So, where does WWE come in? World Wrestling Entertainment is the Saudi Royal Family's proof to the world that they are a “modern” kingdom. In addition to this alliance looking good for the Saudis, WWE is paid to perform propaganda for the Saudi Royal Family during their WWE Network specials in Saudi Arabia. That's what the Saudi Royal Family paid for. They didn't pay for wrestling. They paid for propaganda. WWE understands reclaiming your legacy after a history of misdeeds and scandal. In recent years, WWE has had their own charm offensive: charity work. That hasn't changed the fact that they mistreat their wrestlers, don't provide healthcare, prop up murderous regimes and support a President who literally puts children in cages, but hey. You know what? Shut up. Ignore all that, and Be a Star. Be a Star, everyone. WWE has an anti-bullying campaign in spite of the fact that it infamously has created an atmosphere of bullying among its talent. 


Chief Brand Officer Stephanie McMahon, seen here falling into a pool of mud, has admitted publicly that WWE's charities are there for show, to help the image of the company, and because it's just good business. Frankly, the McMahons and the Saudi Royal Family are a match made in Heaven. [III. PROPAGANDA Legend Has It 0:20] When it is said that WWE performs propaganda for the Saudi Royal Family, this does not mean that WWE simply has wrestling shows in Saudi Arabia. When detractors of this deal say it's propaganda, they mean it's propaganda. During the first show under this deal called Greatest Royal Rumble, announcers, commentators and wrestlers touted Saudi Arabia as a “progressive” country thanks to the Crown Prince. Corey Graves talked up the Prince's Vision 2030 plan and said that Saudi Arabia is committed to “diversity.” [zoom] That is...a lie? Yeah, it's a lie. It is literally illegal to be anything but a Muslim in Saudi Arabia. It is literally illegal to anything but a heterosexual in Saudi Arabia. 


AUDIO 7


Multiple times during the show, Michael Cole, the voice of WWE, gave shout-outs to the Saudi Royal Family in attendance. You know, the group that signs off on all the executions and extrajudicial killings? The Saudi Royal Family can be seen in almost every shot because they occupy the entire front rows. They seem barely interested in the show and mostly talk amongst themselves and walk around, obstructing the view of the people behind. Just milling around, being dicks. Just being...mean, salty dicks? There was also an entire section of the show dedicated to WWE Hall of Famers like Jerry “The King” Lawler and Booker T thanking the Saudi Royal Family and completely ignoring everything they stand for. In addition, there was a video package touting Vision 2030 and the amazing reform of women not being imprisoned anymore for driving a car. Quite literally the last country on planet Earth that permitted women to drive cars, and they want a cookie for it. Right before the Rumble portion of the evening, Michael Cole reiterated that Jeddha, the city where the event took place, is so “progressive.” [sighs] Listen, I'm not applying the word “progressive” under American standards because America is complicit in a lot of this. I'm not applying European standards or “western” standards, especially since that term has some racist implications.


I'm not applying the word “progressive” here in any way except to say that the Saudi Royal Family has made Saudi Arabia one of the most ultraconservative nations on Earth by anything resembling an objective criteria and calling it “progressive” in any way, shape or form is fully enriched, weapons grade bullshit. It is conservative not only by world standards but also by regional standards. Women are required by law to limit their interaction with men unless they are family. There are separate entrances for women and men in buildings, offices, banks and universities. Unlawful “mixing” leads to criminal charges for men and women but women will always have to face the harsher punishment. Women can't go anywhere without their male guardian's permission or conduct business without a man present. 


AUDIO 8


Speaking out about this or about anything else that the Saudi Royal Family does is also illegal and punishable by death. As I am writing this, Saudi Arabia has just sentenced three moderate scholars to be executed for the crime of campaigning for a better country. There is no “progressive” city in Saudi Arabia while the Royal Family is in power, and claiming that there is because the Saudi Royal Family paid you to say it participating in propaganda. During the Greatest Royal Rumble, there were no matches for women. This is prohibited in the country. Even though WWE has made strides in their women's division over the past several years, they were barred from the event. Women fans of WWE were permitted to attend the show but only with man as a chaperone. Sami Zayn, who is of Syrian descent, was also barred from attending the show. The Saudi Royal Family doesn't like Syria, and even though Zayn is actually Canadian and just has Syrian roots, that's still too Syrian for the Royal Family. During the show, WWE played an advertisement featuring some of their women wrestlers, and the Saudi Royal Family was furious. 


According to those who were there, the audience – the citizens – were apparently fine with this, but again, the government is not the citizenry. The Saudi Arabia General Sports Authority made a statement later on apologizing for showing “indecent” women in their wrestling gear and basically threw WWE under the bus. And what did WWE do after being mistreated like that? They said “Thank you, sir. May I have another?!” [IV. CROWN JEWEL CONTROVERSY Close Your Eyes 0:24] On October 2nd, 2018, Jamal Khashoggi, a journalist and critic of Saudi Arabia, entered the Saudi Arabian consulate in Istanbul to obtain documents related to his marriage. He never walked out. Over time, it was revealed that Khashoggi had been assassinated, almost certainly under orders by the Saudi government. Saudi Arabia kept changing its story. First they denied he had been killed, then he had been killed in a fist fight, then by accident during interrogation, until finally the Saudi Arabian attorney general said it was a premeditated murder but absolved the Royal Family of any guilt. Of course. Shortly thereafter, a CIA investigation concluded that Crown Prince Mohammad bin Salman ordered the assassination.


AUDIO 9


This put WWE in a public relations nightmare. Should they go ahead with Crown Jewel, their next show in Saudi Arabia? Should they cancel and deal with the fallout of their contract? WWE claimed it would “investigate” the issue, but that's corporate speak for “we're not going to do anything.” It's the same thing they said when one of their doctors recently admitted, under oath, that he had a sexual relationship with one of the wrestlers under his care. It's the same thing they said when reports of Randy Orton's sexual misconduct surfaced. They didn't investigate but two things: jack and shit, because if they did investigate and came up with something, they wouldn't have plausible deniability anymore. They didn't want to find anything because it would be easier and better for them not to. 

Generally speaking, WWE fans were not happy with the wrestling company's foray into Saudi Arabia and their blatant propaganda for the regime, but once word about the murder of the journalist began to spread, fans at live events began to audibly boo every reference to Crown Jewel. Even the Undertaker – a fan favorite for decades – was on the receiving end of this reaction when he promoted his match in Saudi Arabia. 


American politicians, both Democrats and Republicans, condemned Saudi Arabia and some were even concerned about WWE doing the show. Some speculated that the State Department might put pressure on WWE not to go. But with Trump in the Oval Office, it never seemed likely that WWE would be asked to stay home. WWE and Trump go back a long time. Trump hosted two Wrestlemania events in Trump Plaza. Trump is in the WWE Hall of Fame, the WWE did fundraising for the Trump 2016 campaign. Even Linda McMahon, seen here next to Karate Eric Bischoff, was head of the Trump administration's Small Business Bureau for about two years. There is no way Trump's State Department [photo] would tell the McMahon family not to make their blood money. In the end, WWE decided not only to do the show but to continue to do their twice yearly shows for the Saudi Royal Family. Nobody has a copy of the contract between WWE and Saudi Arabia except for WWE and Saudi Arabia. 


AUDIO 10


That means we don't know for sure what the penalty for backing out of a show or a deal will cost WWE. But probably a lot. They may even have to go to court over it or settle out of court for a lot of money. Nobody knows exactly how it would shake out. But here's the thing. I don't...care? According to Forbes, Vince McMahon is worth three billion dollars. If he lost two thirds of his worth overnight, he would still be a billionaire. I don't have any sympathy for a billionaire who might lose millions of dollars on a deal or go to court and lose millions more. Vince McMahon will never be broke. He's seventy three years old, set for the rest of his life and he's probably happy with all of his success. There is no other explanation for why he walks that way. UFC, following the murder of Jamal Khashoggi, severed its ties with the Saudi Arabia. Endeavor, the parent company of UFC, returned a $400 million investment to the Saudis. They gave it up. All of it. I also don't have any sympathy for Vince McMahon here because he may not have known that the Saudi Royal Family was going to dismember and murder someone and have it be international news, but he definitely knew who they were before he signed the deal. He knew what they were about, and he signed on anyway.


The killing of Jamal Khashoggi is nowhere near the first death at the hands of the Saudi Royals. It's just among the most high profile in recent years. Numerous American businesses expressed concern or made a show of outrage over the Saudi Royal Family's involvement in the murder of Khashoggi, but nearly all of them are still doing business with the Saudi government, including WWE. Only two men refused to work the Crown Jewel show: John Cena and Daniel Bryan because they are very good boys, and we're all better off for having them in our lives. It's understandable why others were afraid of requesting the night off, though. WWE is infamously vindictive and most wrestlers would probably end up losing their spot for staging a protest. Cena and Bryan are basically untouchable at this point and so well-respected that punishing them would cause more problems than solve. Chief Operations Officer Paul “Triple H” Levesque, seen here having sex with a dead body, followed WWE's talking points precisely. He said that the company's presence will make Saudi Arabia a better country, but he is too smart to really believe that. 


AUDIO 11


The Saudi Royal Family is using WWE to increase their influence on the world stage. WWE is not using the Saudis to change Saudi Arabia. They just want their blood money, and it's extremely naive to think otherwise. WWE can't make Saudi Arabia a progressive or even moderate country because Saudi Arabia is a hundred times more powerful than WWE. Also, WWE is not financially incentivized to do this either because if the Saudi Royal Family gives up its power, it won't be able to make all the decisions like giving an American wrestling company untold millions to put on glorified house shows. Speaking of which, Crown Jewel happened. They brought back Hulk Hogan. Look at him. All racist and made of leather. They had a World Cup that only featured wrestlers from America, so whatever. Shane McMahon, seen here getting his penis electrocuted by a monster, was given the World Cup and declared the Best Wrestler in the World.


Their next Saudi Arabia show, Super Showdown, is being billed as a show that “will be as good or exceed Wrestlemania.” That's definitely something the Saudis insisted WWE say. WWE has never before thrown Wrestlemania under the bus or treated Wrestlemania as anything but the biggest show of the year. The Saudi Royal Family has so much power over WWE right now. It's embarrassing. WWE wants to keep the cash rolling, and they will do and say whatever it takes to make that happen.

This is a ten year deal between WWE and the Saudi Royal Family. We're only about a year in. We have a long way to go before it's over. 


AQUAMAN


AUDIO 1


Aquaman is the story of Arthur, the son of the Queen of Atlantis and a surface-dweller who is the one true King. Orm hates the surface-dwellers, and this puts him into conflict with Arthur, and they fight, and this movie sucks. Aquaman is the perfect example of political neutrality: a stance in popular films in which contemporary issues are mentioned, even briefly commented upon but largely without any hard stance, radical commentary or conviction – and sometimes even without intent. This is sometimes done to bolster a weak, flaccid plot and sometimes simply as an unavoidable byproduct of a movie in which any systems of power and influence are depicted. Aquaman ever so briefly mentions environmental concerns but only in passing and never with conviction. Orm says he must save Atlantis from the surface world, and one of his reasons is that of ocean pollution. In the end, Aquaman saves the surface world from Orm but leaves the status quo of corporations and politicians ruining the planet intact. All references to environmentalism vanish once Aquaman convinces Mera that surface world = good because flowers, and the audience is not meant to question Aquaman leaving the oceans and surface world to be more slowly destroyed by said corporations and politicians.


Environmentalism is not a great “theme” for the film because the film does not want you to think about environmentalism or even care about environmentalism. It's a hastily thrown together justification for Orm to hate the surface world and not even his real reason. He wants power. Environmentalism is a red herring, which actually does more to embolden the right-wing talking point of climate change being a hoax. Aquaman traffics in “suburban environmentalism,” the kind of white liberal “Maybe we should recycle” mentality that does not directly address how climate change is the man-made result of corporate greed. If you blinked and missed this environmental message, you can be forgiven because it's so opaque that it may as well be a ghost. Orm is a nationalist, and as nationalism is often coupled with racism, he believes the surface-dwellers must be eradicated to preserve the “sanctity” and “purity” of his own people, but the film never doubles down on this parallel. Orm's nationalism and racism is born out of a generic lust for power than can be seen in every boiler-plate, garden variety supervillain and Disney film antagonist. 


AUDIO 2


He is not a character with an agenda so much as a standard movie obstacle for our big lug who is too cool to have meaningful politics, ideology or ideas. Aquaman, the character not the movie, is the “I don't care about politics” Planet Fitness lunkhead to whom the audience is meant to sympathize because an activist character in a film with confused politics wouldn't fit. The reason that Aquaman's politics seem “confused” is because the creators involved in making the film didn't give two thirds of a s**t about a message and merely used some razor thin politics as background noise for this jumbled mash-up of shark monsters and fish men. The reason that Aquaman's thin politics are barely noticeable is because the film spends so much time overloading the senses of the audience with a waking nightmare of uncanny, far too shiny special effects. And finally, the reason nobody cares about what Aquaman has to say about our world is because the movie isn't very good, and critics are more likely to extrapolate meaning from significant works of art than from garbage. With respect to the think piece writers, Aquaman feels less a film designed to comment on contemporary issues and more a film that follows a psuedo-Shakespearean concept mixed with Arthurian myth and a “bro” action-adventure movie.


Some movies are structured so well that you can find and assign other structures to it whether those structures exist intentionally or not. John Wick has been described as modern mythology by some and as a condemnation of hierarchies, particularly capitalism, by others. The world building in the John Wick trilogy is enough that audiences and critics can assign meaning and see parallels to how our real world society works within the fictional secret society in the film series. The John Wick movies reveal the intricacies of the world mostly through visuals, allowing the information to wash over the audience in a way that feels satisfying. Aquaman's mythology and world building spills out in intermittent bursts of exposition, introducing us to various kingdoms seemingly at random intervals and providing us with visuals do not reveal their world so much as reveal the CG budget. 


[50:39]


AUDIO 3


The camera is a dizzying, wide awake bad drug trip. It spins during action sequences, signifying intensity, but also spins during sad moments, quiet moments and loud moments, signifying nothing. The camera does not present the audience with information. It tells the audience...watch me spin. There is no rhyme or reason to this. The nauseating zooming, upside down shots and random slow motion within action sequences present no weight or impact to the action. The overabundance and over-reliance on CG gives us a world that feels uncanny, never allowing the audience to be properly absorbed in the story or to feel grounded. The eye does not follow the action. The human eye sees nearby objects clearer depending on distance. This lines up neatly with how focus works in film. Some objects are in focus, some objects are out of focus, and sometimes the focus changes from one shot to another and sometimes within the same shot, called focus pulling. I have (rightly) mocked the "Granny's Peach Tea" scene in Batman v. Superman, but I recently re-watched it for comparison, and it employs standard but adequate changes in focus to emphasize the jar, emphasize the Senator, to emphasize Superman watching and with the people out of focus, etc.


This is not groundbreaking. It's time-tested, well-understood filmmaking. It's how movies and our eyes work. Shots that are all CG sometimes feel unpleasant to watch because everything feels unnaturally in focus. Aquaman even employs a floating, CG effect as its camera to switch from one perspective to another instead of changing focus to show distance and emphasis. Visuals in Aquaman are bright enough to pop but so flat that they can't. Aquaman is crowded with visual information, and none of it feel significant because the camera never gives anything emphasis or pins down a particular visual as shorthand for an emotion. Its wishy-washiness provides nothing tactile, and its distance provides no urgency. The images pulverize the film, the length makes the entire experience exhausting and the gormless protagonist doesn't talk like an action star but more like a tween who just learned the most impotent cuss words. It has mild charms and deviates from some of the drudgery of earlier DC outings, both of which explain its mixed reviews rather than full-on dunking by critics, but it still falls short. Aquaman, the movie all on its own – divorced from its jumbled, mishandled themes – is still too weak to support said razor-thin themes and house-of-cards, false grandiosity. In other words, it's not good enough to allow us to extrapolate any meaning from a meaningless film. Aquaman sucks, and now everyone can stop asking me why. I'm sure this will go over very well. 


AMERICAN GILEAD


AUDIO 1


Complex topics sometimes require shorthand to quickly communicate information and one's own stance within the topic. It is extremely common, for example, within a discussion about growing concerns over the authority of the police, authority of domestic espionage and the power of propaganda to reference George Orwell's 1984. In 1984, a totalitarian superstate has achieved supreme authority over its citizenry. The novel has become a symbol more than a story. Even those who have never read it know the basic premise enough to use it in conversation as shorthand for the complexities of a “surveillance state.” When referencing 1984,this is not meant to be one-to-one. Nobody is saying that America is now an exact duplicate of the hyperbolic fictional superstate Oceania. Only that saying “1984” or saying “Orwellian” conjures up an image and a basic idea, perhaps even a warning that if we all agree the totalitarian superstate in the novel is “bad” then we should steer clear of anything that even loosely resembles its values. People misunderstand the meaning of the reference sometimes, responding “Oh, don't be so dramatic!” but this is a response to something that is not being said or a way to dismiss the reference and prop up the surveillance state as “good.”


Another similar exchange of symbols and shorthand coupled with dismissals has begun to take form, this time connected to The Handmaid's Tale, originally a novel but popularized by the critically acclaimed television series. The story is that of a totalitarian state that strips women of their rights and subjects many of them to child-bearing enslavement. The show was in development for years but premiered, by happenstance, a few months after the inauguration of Donald Trump. A casually anti-choice president, and an infamously anti-choice vice president gave cover to a growing erosion of reproductive rights that suddenly started to disappear at a far faster rate. Women began attending protests in handmaid uniforms seen on the show as a shorthand for anyone watching the protest about their feelings on losing their hard-won, constitutional rights. The Handmaid's Tale is now more valuable as a symbol than a weekly television series. Much like references to 1984, the reference to The Handmaid's Tale is not a declaration that the fiction has sprung off the page and that women are literally enslaved. 


AUDIO 2


It's only shorthand in the same manner used for 1984, to conjure up an image, basic idea, and a warning that if we agree that the society in The Handmaid's Tale is something not to aspire to, we should also be able to agree universally that this real world and milder version is also something to avoid. But of course, when the alarm bells are rung, everyone wants to close their ears. Everyone from Twitter randos to verified journalists said not to worry too much and that referencing a television show was too sensational. Nearly every fear that women had – and indeed many men had – that the current administration would bring about terrible consequences for women and for marginalized people has come true. Everyone said “Calm down” and then Trump named two new Supreme Court justices – serving for life. Now the court was stacked with those who might overturn Roe v. Wade. Everyone said “You're being too emotional” and then anti-choice legislators began not only testing the waters like before but diving in head-first. It doesn't matter if you think dressing up like a handmaid exaggerates the subject. That's not the point. 


The point is this: the fact that women are making this reference at all should tell you how serious they are and how seriously we all should take this. So...how did we get here? [S01E03 2:20] [I – THE OLD WAY: TRICKERY, SKIRTING THE CONSTITUTION] American views on abortion have a lot of gray area, it's not as simple as the pro-choice, pro-life binary would have one believe. The circumstances in which one requests an abortion is a major sticking point for some Americans, but by and large, the vast majority of Americans believe abortion should be legal under many circumstances. Only 18% of Americans believe abortion should simply be outlawed. Gallup has been has tracking American opinion on reproductive rights for a long time, and this 18% is actually down from 22% in 1976. Belief that women should have no autonomy with regards to abortion has historically had a downward trend. It is such a minority opinion that even some otherwise conservative Republicans have adopted some form of a pro-choice position. Yet, in spite of this overwhelming majority in favor of maintaining some option open, anti-abortion organizations and lobbyists continue to push the issue and present the false notion that America is roughly split down the middle on the subject. 


AUDIO 3


This is because sometimes polls phrase the issue as a binary, meaning questions like “Would you rather call yourself pro-choice or pro-life?” but even respondents who believe abortion should be legal under many circumstances sometimes identify as pro-life due to their personal beliefs but recognize that their personal beliefs need not be the beliefs of all, particularly when said beliefs are based more in religion than anything else. Asked as a binary and as self-identification, it's about even. Asked with some level of nuance and reason, the vast majority of Americans don't believe abortion should actually be outlawed. Anti-abortion activists and lobbyists use the more misleading poll figure to make their case.  

State legislatures have enacted new laws that have to lead to the shutdown of dozens of clinics throughout the United States. The old way of doing this was through trickery and obfuscation – to tell the public that anti-abortion measures were enacted to “protect” women and various other lies. To skirt around Roe v. Wade, the landmark Supreme Court decision in favor of reproductive rights, they cite Planned Parenthood v. Casey, a different SCOTUS ruling that allowed individual states to place some restrictions on abortion so long as it did not outright ban the practice or create an “undue burden” on those seeking an abortion. 


However, states interpreted this the way they wanted, meaning what is “undue” is vague and a matter of opinion and that laws could be created that would limit access to abortion so much that it could be nearly banned in practice, if not on paper. Here are some examples: states like Oklahoma, Kansas, Louisiana, Utah, North Dakota, Mississippi and more have passed laws that force abortion clinics to have admitting privileges in local hospitals. This all seems harmless at a glance until you realize that many hospitals will not grant these privileges to abortion clinics, either for political, financial or religious reasons. The law says that your abortion clinic is fine if a hospital endorses it, but hospitals are under no obligation to endorse it, therefore forcing it to close. Lawmakers are aware of this, it's not some unintended side effect. It is the intent of the law. That's where the trickery and obfuscation comes in. Lawmakers can't outright ban abortion clinics in their state, and if they openly declare that is their intent, they lose plausible deniability should the case go to a higher court. 


AUDIO 4


So, they create a system in which it's next to impossible for abortion clinics to meet requirements. They then claim that this is done for the “safety” of women, as if that were their real goal. Many other medical facilities are not subject to this requirement. It is specific for abortion clinics because lawmakers knew that hospitals might be hesitant to align themselves with the clinics. These laws might seem like political suicide for politicians considering the national numbers in favor of keeping abortion legal at least in many cases, but national numbers are not state numbers and national numbers are also not party numbers. In deep red Mississippi, for example, the population that wants abortion illegal is higher than the national average, and the amount of Republicans who want abortion illegal is also higher than the national average. So, if you're a Republican politician in Mississippi, it may be beneficial to you to not only be anti-choice but virulently anti-choice to secure re-election. Republican politicians can trot out these laws that shut down abortion clinics but don't technically ban abortion on paper to appease those in their constituency who might identify as pro-life but believe in some exceptions such as rape, incest or the safety of the mother.


They can tell these comparatively more reasonable voters that they don't want to ban abortion in case you ever need one. They claim to only shut down the “bad” abortion clinics, and enough voters who are ignorant to the complexities of the law eat it up. Another tactic of trickery and obfuscation comes in the form of laws that force doctors who perform abortions to give misleading information or even outright lie to their patients about the risks of an abortion. In some states, doctors are also forced to show the patient an ultrasound of the fetus whether they want to or not. Politicians claim these measures are meant to protect women and give them the appropriate information. But since the information is false, the real intention is to either trick someone into not having an abortion after all or at least shaming the woman [shame scene] before the procedure. Another tactic of trickery comes in the form of “pregnancy crisis centers” which are set up by anti-abortion groups to appear like abortion clinics. These centers give misleading advice or flat-out lie to the patients. 


AUDIO 5


Now, let's look at a specific case. In order to shut down abortion clinics in Texas, a law was passed that force clinics have the same building codes as hospitals, which almost sounds logical until you realize that the needs of clinics and hospitals are quite different and have different regulations and standards for a reason. The building housing an abortion clinic is obviously much smaller than a hospital and requires less than a hospital because the vast majority of abortions are actually non-surgical procedures. Anti-abortion lobbyists and lawmakers know all this but created the laws because they knew this would immediately shut down clinics that were too small, had too narrow hallways, or could not renovate their entire building to meet these unnecessary new requirements within the short deadline given. Years later, this was taken all the way to the Supreme Court. In a 5 – 3 decision, provisions in Texas' law were struck down as placing an “undue burden” cited in Planned Parenthood v. Casey. This is how it used to work. States governments, activist groups and so-called crisis centers would engage in trickery to severely limit reproductive rights while still being forced to keep abortion on the books.


States would get very far, shut down various clinics but were never able to ban abortion completely or convince the Supreme Court to side with them all the time. But that may be about to change. [II – TRUMP, CHANGING ATTITUDES AND THE SUPREME COURT] Every generation has had its own social and legal apparatus constructed to dehumanize women. Justifications over centuries can be found in religious faith, medical ethics, anxiety over the growing autonomy of women, financial gain such as in medical professionals hope to stamp out the non-medical community's ability to profit for women's reproductive health and much more. None of these mesh together well and none explain why when the justifications and excuses change, the legislation remains the same. Writer and essayist Eleanor Penny once said “Where a reason is needed for criminalizing abortions, a reason will be found.” It should be noted that while the crusade against abortion in America is absolutely designed to target cisgender women, they are not the only Americans who need abortions. Trans men have a uterus and in some cases require an abortion.


AUDIO 6


So, how have attitudes “changed” within the past few years? During the 2016 Donald Trump campaign, the would-be president was rightly humiliated when video surfaced showing him to speak about women not having a choice in whether or not they they should have intimate contact with him. That is the most polite way I can say what he said without actually saying it. [clip] This created a dilemma. Under any other circumstances, this would be universally condemned and the politician in question would see his career fall apart before his eyes. However, these were unusual circumstances. First, with the revelation so close to the election, there was no way to make a change to the ticket. Second, this fit in nicely with Trump's cult of personality. He was a misogynist who rallied against the forces of “political correctness,” and his cultists accepted his explanation that this was merely the way men talked to each other, that is was “locker room” talk.


This did not seem out of character for him. [clips] And that's just the way he talks, there are also a lot of sexual assault and rape accusations, Google is your friend. His supporters loved this about him because it gave them tacit permission to behave this way as well, especially with regards to treatment of women. The Overton window had shifted. When Trump was elected, this emboldened his most sexist and racist supporters. Arguments against their behavior were met with declarations that “Trump won” and that alone was justification for their behavior. Remember: justifications for dehumanizing women change, but the result remains the same. Trump and Vice President Mike Pence are really the perfect pair for the anti-choice movement, as the former is the standard misogynist who deep down sees women being inferior as some kind of psuedo-science “biotruth” and therefore all the justification he needs to treat them as he sees fit, and the latter is a far right Christian whose faith is all the justification HE needs to treat women as vessels designed for procreation. Both attitudes inform the worldview of the anti-choice movement. Trump selected Neil Gorsuch for the vacant seat on the Supreme Court.


AUDIO 7


This was to be filled in the previous administration, but Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell refused to do this because he has no shame. Gorsuch has shown clear signs to the Republican Party and to Trump supporters that he may oppose women's reproductive rights. In 2018, the Supreme Court voted against hearing cases to deny Medicaid funding to Planned Parenthood, but Gorsuch and other conservative justices dissented with this decision, hoping to hear the case and potentially make a ruling in favor of the states limiting access and funding to abortion. In 2019, Gorsuch sided with three other conservative justices in one of the aforementioned cases that required doctors performing abortions to have admitting privileges in hospitals. When Anthony Kennedy unexpectedly retired, Trump selected Brett Kavanaugh as his replacement. Kavanaugh was credibly accused of sexual assault by psychology professor Christine Blasey Ford. Such an accusation is sometimes enough to torpedo a career, but in the age of Trump, her accusation was met with not only skepticism but accusations against her credibility in return. 


Common accusations against women who come forward with sexual assault and rape accusations include the misogynist cry that women only say this to become famous and for the thrill of taking down a powerful man. In reality, Christine Blasey Ford had her life upended, as she has been forced to move four times due to death threats and harassment. She has also had to hired security for herself for the indefinite future. Her testimony against Kavanaugh was corroborated by therapy session notes, polygraph test results and other pieces of evidence. Kavanaugh's testimony was belligerent, hostile, insulting, and most notably of all, Trumpian. The window had shifted, and behaving like Trump was a surefire way to win over his supporters and keep oneself in the good graces of Trump himself. Before 2017, Senate rules required a supermajority to cut off debate on Supreme Court nominations. That meant that even if a president's party held the Senate, presidents generally chose nominees that would attract little controversy. However, when faced with a possible filibuster for Gorsuch due to the stolen seat, Republicans eliminated the filibuster for Supreme Court nominees. Now only a majority was needed. If Kavanaugh had been selected during any other administration, Democrats could have filibustered, and that would have been the end of him.


AUDIO 8


But in the Trump era, that was no longer an option. Kavanaugh was narrowly confirmed, and that was that. Kavanaugh joined with Gorsuch and other conservatives justices in the aforementioned case about abortion clinic requirements. In the past, divided party control and ideological drift among some justices made it challenging to solidify a reliably conservative Supreme Court, but with a Republican president, a Republican Senate, new rules that only required a majority to stamp out a filibuster, and with two seats to fill Trump, was finally able to stack the court well in the favor of his party's interests. Before Kavanaugh, Justice Kennedy, though a Republican, was considered a swing vote on some issues. That swing vote has been lost. [III – THE NEW WAY] With some headway made during the old way of chipping at abortion rights, meaning tricks and lies, and with an anti-feminist, anti-woman, anti-choice backlash in the air, AND with the Supreme Court now stacked with conservatives, the anti-abortion activists had what they wanted. A syzygy – a cosmic alignment of everything required to overturn Roe v. Wade. But how to get it in front of the Supreme Court so that the justices revisit Roe v. Wade?


The tactic appears to be to create laws so restrictive and skirting right up to the edge of constitutionality that they will eventually make it way to the Supreme Court where a decision by the most conservative court in 50 years might overturn abortion rights. Supreme Court decisions that had their origins in local matters have a history of making sweeping changes across the country. For example, this is how marriage equality was legalized across America. With the planets aligned, anti-abortion groups and politicians are purposefully trying for the strictest laws possible either because they know they have cover in both the Oval Office and the courts or because they are hoping to make an even bigger splash that will effectively overturn Roe v. Wade. Here are some examples of these restrictive new laws: an Alabama law has made performing an abortion a felony. The only exception is when the life of the mother is endangered by the pregnancy. Georgia's “heartbeat” law bans abortions as early as six weeks into pregnancy, often before someone knows they are pregnant, and even if they do learn shortly before the deadline, they have little time to prepare and even find an abortion clinic that's still open in the deep south. 


AUDIO 9


Kentucky, Mississippi, Ohio and Missouri have passed similar laws, albeit with different language and deadlines. Louisiana and South Carolina are both trying for the same as of this writing, and Alaska may go even further with a ban that has no exceptions whatsoever. The Supreme Court might hear one of these cases or perhaps an earlier case – June Medical v. Gee -- that has been making its way through the system. This could happen as early as June 2020. Even if some of the Supreme Court's Republicans would prefer to put off this question until after the election a few months later, anti-abortion state lawmakers and lower court judges are forcing their hands. Many of the lawmakers behind the most extreme laws in Georgia and Alabama have been explicit that the whole purpose of their new laws is to make the Supreme Court take up one of them and subsequently overrule Roe v. Wade. The old way of eroding reproductive rights was tricks and lies. The new way, now that the deck is stacked in their favor, is to push the boundaries so far that the Supreme Court has no choice but to take a look and potentially overturn almost half a century of legal rights. The Supreme Court knows it's coming.


It's why Justice Thomas recently wheeled out the old and tired argument that abortion is eugenics because one of the Planned Parenthood founders admittedly had just the worst take sometimes. He knows it's coming, and he's priming the pump. People are understandably angry and worried. They are protesting in the streets, they are wearing handmaid outfits to make a point and they are doing whatever they can to sway public opinion enough to either convince the states to reverse course or to convince the justices to preserve their rights should the case come before them. America doesn't have to become an exact duplicate of the fictional Gilead for it to be a more dangerous place. We won't see a second civil war. All it will take is a few men who have proven not to be friends to women in this country. Justice Kennedy's record on reproductive rights was mixed, at best, but there is every indication that his replacement, Brett Kavanaugh, is a hardline conservative. Trump had long vowed to appoint justices who would reverse Roe. Kennedy had been a swing vote in years past. Those days are gone. Things could get even worse if, say, 86 year old Ruth Bader Ginsburg doesn't live through this president's administration. Even if reproductive rights are somehow enshrined and protected once again by a surprise swing vote by Chief Justice Roberts or someone, the window of public discourse among politicians may have been damaged beyond repair. And finally, for everyone who said not to worry and that people were being too dramatic, you were wrong.


BURNING KING'S LANDING


AUDIO 1


In the final season of Game of Thrones, Daenerys Targaryen burned the city of King's Landing, the capital of the Seven Kingdoms of Westeros. Her advisers, Tyrion Lannister and Varys, counseled against this due to incredible amount of civilian casualties this would incur. Daenerys' actions were shocking to the audience of the popular television series, as it effectively transformed her into the villain of the series immediately prior to the finale. Nobody could justify her actions – until they tried. Cries of “Daenerys Did Nothing Wrong” followed bizarre think pieces. It shouldn't be surprising that some in the American media tried to find a cold, pragmatic justification to defend the wanton destruction of King's Landing and the annihilation of its civilian population – most of which probably had no love for its ruler, Cersei Lannister. Because conflating civilians with the troubling governments that rule over them has become commonplace; a truly indefensible mix-up between the governments that oppress their people and the people who are oppressed by their governments. [PART I: THE WAR ON TERROR] Fans of the series had different reasons for why they disapproved of Daenerys effectively becoming the last-minute villain.


For some, it seemed out of character considering she spent several seasons as something of a human rights hero. For others, it ruined a feminist icon. But even for those who saw Daenerys' behavior as the culmination of a character arc that had been built up over several series, the general feeling about what she did was clear: deliberately targeting civilians in King's Landing was wrong and unable to be defended. The audience for Game of Thrones spreads out across the world, but it has a huge portion of its fanbase in the United States. Support for firebombing civilians has a complicated history. Saturation bombing of civilians during World War II killed, by one estimate, 750,000 civilians, which is several times the number who died in the nuclear bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. The firebombings had widespread public support in the United States. Whether or not American support bombing civilians in modern times depends on how the question is asked.


AUDIO 2


A recent survey by the International Studies Association found that the vast majority of Americans agree that it's wrong to attack civilian populations. Less than 10% disagreed with that blanket statement. However, another recent survey by Stanford and Dartmouth asked the question differently and received a remarkably different answer. Survey respondents were told to imagine a war with Iran and whether they might agree to a saturation bombing of a populated Iranian city—likely to kill 100,000 civilians—in order to save the lives of 20,000 U.S. troops. When put this way, two-thirds of respondents leaned toward a strike against a civilian city. The authors concluded that “the U.S. public’s support for the principle of noncombatant immunity is shallow and easily overcome by the pressures of war.” In other words, most Americans who answered the survey implied that the lives of American troops are worth significantly more than civilian lives in Iran. At least five times more more valuable than Iranian civilians. Not long after 9/11, Afghanistan was under attack. The United States and the United Kingdom claimed the bombing was justified because the Afghans did not turn over terrorism suspects.


However, the bombings and subsequent invasion did not only take the lives of those who were allegedly hiding terrorists but also the lives of anyone who simply happened to live in Afghanistan. The response “Well, they should have turned over Osama bin Laden...” can always be countered with this: Who is “they”? Because the civilians killed in the bombing of Afghanistan were not hiding Osama bin Laden. They were just...families. People who happened to live in the country. “They” were not hiding anyone. Even if one believes the United States had a right to invade a country over a disagreement on extradition, which is historically unprecedented and was widely condemned all on its own, the civilians who died had no choice in these decisions. It is incomprehensible to condemn the subjects for the actions of the Queen. In 2002, the United States announced a new National Security Strategy asserting its authority to maintain global hegemony permanently. In 2003, the US, the UK and others in a coalition invaded Iraq under the pretense that the Middle Eastern country was hiding weapons of mass destruction. Countless more civilians killed.


AUDIO 3


The War on Terror persisted through the George W. Bush administration and the Barack Obama administration, adding more and more countries to bomb and more civilian lives lost amid questionable excuses for these military interventions. Obama declared the war on terror over in 2013 but actually escalated it under a different branding. It's not over. How many people have been killed in the War on Terror? Brown University's Costs of War Project just last year released a new estimate of the total death toll from American wars in three countries: Iraq, Afghanistan and Pakistan. At least 480,000 people have been directly killed by violence over the course of these conflicts, and more than 244,000 of them were civilians. This means that contrary to the popular misconception that civilian casualties are limited in war, civilian casualties in the War on Terror outnumber military casualties. More civilians die in war than the people who either chose to fight or are conscripted to fight. In addition to those killed by direct acts of violence, the number of indirect deaths – those resulting from disease, displacement and loss of critical infrastructure – is believed to be several times higher, running well into the millions. This sounds catastrophically high, but the truth is that this report only scratches the surface.


It does not take into account other conflicts in the War on Terror, such as in Libya, Yemen, Somalia and Syria, where the United States has conducted military operations in the past several years. Daphne Eviatar, director of the Security with Human Rights program at Amnesty International said of this: 

“The major challenge in tracking the full costs of these wars is that the U.S. military doesn’t even meaningfully investigate civilian death tolls. Generally, they know it’s not good to have civilian casualties, but their focus is mainly on fighting, and there is little pressure to make protecting civilians a key priority. Meanwhile, the U.S. public simply doesn’t see deaths in other countries. They don’t see civilians being killed in Iraq or Afghanistan. With everything going on in the United States at the moment, the fact that we’re even at war has largely fallen off the radar.” If Americans, the British and other people whose countries participate in civilian bombings were so shocked and dismayed by the fictional city of King's Landing burning, why is the real world bombing of the Middle East barely on the news anymore? Why do so many of us...not care? Or at least not care enough for it to be a major political talking point in elections anymore? 


AUDIO 4


People tend to turn away from disasters such as these. They turn away because the casualties challenge their strongly held perception that their country is a force for good. In the face of shocking civilian casualties, disease and massive displacement caused by war, people are much more likely to become indifferent than they are to protest. Facing hard questions about the people who represent them is an incredible burden, and oftentimes it's easier to blame the victims for causing their own suffering. During the Vietnam War, the institution of the draft and its unpopularity forced the public to maintain some awareness about the war. But the creation of an all-volunteer military has made the conflicts much easier to ignore. As public attention has waned and the media has largely move on, it has become easier for the US government to obscure what it's doing. According to the BBC, At the beginning of the twentieth century only 10%-15% of those who died in war were civilians. In World War II, more than 50% of those who died were civilians. By the end of the century, over 75% of those killed in war were civilians. These increases have a lot to do with how warfare has changed with the proliferation of air combat. 


In modern times, reporting on civilian deaths has become more rare. In March of 2019, President Donald Trump signed an executive order revoking the requirement that American intelligence officials publicly report the number of civilians killed in drone strikes and other attacks on allegedly terrorist targets outside of war zones. The administration previously ignored a deadline almost an entire year prior for annual accounting of civilian casualties. Civilian casualties present a distinct ethical quandary. In season one, Tyrion Lannister kills someone for the first time. This is done in self-defense. In season two, Tyrion commands the Battle of Blackwater and repels an armed invasion. In season four, Tyrion strangles an unarmed woman to death. One of these incidents is not like the others. Everyone Tyrion killed had the same rights to be alive as the others, but the incident with Shae was “avoidable” in a way that the others were not. That doesn't make the suffering of Tyrion's other victims any less great or the victims any less worthy of their lives, but it does make the Shae incident contextually distinct from the others – not to mention legally distinct and perhaps, to some, morally distinct. 


AUDIO 5


A soldier in the service of Stannis Baratheon is no less dead than Shae, but the hypothetical soldier posed an immediate and mortal threat to other soldier. Shae did not. Soldiers pose immediate lethal threats to opposing soldiers. Civilians do not pose an immediate lethal threat, and their deaths are not as easily explained away. Furthermore, even if we were to conclude that civilian deaths and military deaths are not ethically distinct, the widespread existence of civilian deaths prove there is a far greater cost to war than people generally acknowledge. Maybe all this civilian talk isn't the main point, though. Ideally, no one should be killed in these conflicts because these conflicts should not exist. They only exist to support the financial interests of those committing the bombings and drone strikes. [PART II: America Only Has Interests] Between 1948 to 1991, the United States engaged in forty-six military interventions. Between the much shorter time period of 1992 and 2017, that number increased fourfold to 188. The increase in military interventions is the result of United States' struggle to impose its order 

on foreign nations to secure its financial interests.


The interests that have long kept the United States involved in the Middle East are fairly clear. Following World War II, American strategists resolved that the United States must prevent any nation not allied with the US from dominating any region of “economic significance.” The Middle East, with its vast oil reserves, fits that description. The US never got most of its oil from Middle Eastern sources, but its political and economic allies did. President Truman's Secretary of Defense, James Forrestal, once said “The Marshall Plan for Europe could not succeed without access to the Middle East oil.” Oil was and is traded on a global market, which means that a disruption of price or supply in one region would cause disruption on a far larger scale. Presently, the US is again becoming a net energy exporter and a swing producer in the global oil market, but so long as the countries of the Middle East sit atop huge energy reserves that confer great wealth on whoever controls it, the strategic importance of the Middle East remains. Time and time again, whenever a conflict arises that has the potential to disrupt oil prices, the US and its allies intervene with their combined military forces.


AUDIO 6


The US is allied with Saudi Arabia for this purpose. If Saudi Arabia wants to drop bombs on Yemen, then the US will assist in this to keep in Saudi Arabia's good graces and maintain its access to oil. This is nothing new. President Eisenhower's own National Security Council outlined America's presence in the Middle East and military interventionism as necessary for controlling resources in the region. Said council described the US explicitly as “opposing political or economic progress” in the Middle East. In public, the US instead presents its military interventionism as “spreading democracy,” but US foreign policy has generally been to install leaders and governments in foreign nations that better suit its financial interests – even deposed democratically elected leaders and sometimes installing authoritarian leaders. In the late 1940's, the United States financially backed the Christian Democrats in Italian elections because their opposition was not friendly to capitalism. They forged documents to discredit the leaders of the Italian Communist Party. In 1952, the CIA enacted Project FF, a coup d'etat of the Egyptian government and installed someone friendlier to American interests. 


In 1953, both the US and the UK assisted in the coup d'etat of the democratically elected Iranian Prime Minister Mohammad Mosaddegh. They new authoritarian government heavily relied on the US. In the 50's, the United States helped overthrow governments or was otherwise involved in regime change in Guatemala, Laos, Indonesia, Lebanon and Iraq. In the 60's, the US helped assassinate the first democratically elected leader of the Congo and went to the enact regime change in the Dominican Republic, Brazil, Iraq again. In the 70's, Bolivia, somehow Iraq again, and various others, in the 80's, El Salvador, Poland and others, and so on and so forth up until the modern face of forced regime change: the war on terror. America's foreign coups have more often than not placed undemocratic and/or dangerous regimes in place. Dangerous to their own people and dangerous to their neighbors but friendly enough to America. In the August 1 (2002) issue of the Far Eastern Economic Review, the internationally recognized regional specialist Ahmed Rashid wrote that in Pakistan, “there is growing anger that U.S. support is allowing (Musharraf’s) military regime to delay the promise of democracy.”


AUDIO 7


9/11 provided an opportunity and pretext to finally implement long-standing plans to have greater access to Iraq's oil reserves, a central component of the Persian Gulf resources that the State Department, in 1945, described as a “stupendous source of strategic power, and one of the greatest material prizes in world history.” America and its allies are demonstrably not spreading democracy – any marginal progress in the region is both accidental and incidental. America is there to consolidate its control over the region's resources, particularly oil. These wars are a matter of interests, not democracy. Following 9/11, America could engage in these wars for resources more freely than before. [Ned Stark] It's the classic strategy of diverting mass discontent into nationalism through fear of external enemies. Criticism of these conflicts were dismissed as “treason” and “un-American” during a time of American crisis. In additions to consolidating resources in foreign territory, these conflicts are also good for the more hawkish party's election results. For the congressional elections that followed 9/11, the strategy has diverted attention from the economy to war, and this continued into the next presidential election.


These wars are not fought for democracy because American military interventionism, coups and state-sponsored terrorism rarely if ever supports political or economic progress in the Middle East – by design. In the early days of the War on Terror, President George W. Bush claimed that the events of 9/11 occurred because certain people “hate our freedoms.” If he was referring specifically to Al-Qaeda, this is not only overly simplistic but outright false. Al-Qaeda was not shy about revealing its motives. The heinous attacks of September 11th were largely a response to western presence in Somalia, American support of Israel, American presence in Saudi Arabia, sanctions against Iraq and other international affairs and foreign policy. If Bush was referring to civilians living in the Middle East, or if his supporters interpreted it that way, it is doubly false. What civilians in the Middle East hate is western foreign policy and interventionism that denies them the freedoms to which they, too, aspire. Again, this is nothing new. In 1958, President Eisenhower described America's interests and justification for potential intervention in the Middle East as “the campaign of hatred against us not by the governments but by the people.”


AUDIO 8


It's important to recognize that when America labels terrorist organizations and rogue states as “evil doers” and other simplistic terms, it does not acknowledge its own war crimes and its own support of terrorism. [White Walkers] By framing the conflict as a battle between good and evil, catastrophes such as the widespread deaths of civilians can be justified by the media and public as necessary for the destruction of said “evil,” [King's Landing] even if those who die in the conflict have nothing to do with the “evil-doers.” [Drogon] Because if America and its allies are “good,” then any actions it takes to stomp out “evil” are also “good.” The language of the conflict becomes its politics. In the Yemeni Civil War, for example, assigning “good” and “evil” to the various belligerents is irrelevant to the civilians who will suffer the most from foreign intervention.  America's state-sponsored terrorism covers a lot of ground. In the 1960's, after the failed Bay of Pigs invasion, President Kennedy launched a campaign to bring “the terrors of the earth” to Cuba. There were more than 800 documented incidents resulting in more than 3,000 deaths and 2,000 injuries. 


America joined South Africa in providing crucial support for Jonas Savimbi's terrorist Unita army in Angola. Washington continued to support terrorism even after Savimbi had been defeated in a carefully monitored free election. These are only two examples among countless. In modern times, America's actions in the Middle East – whether called “terrorism” in the media or not – have the same results: civilian deaths and unrest in the region. Noam Chomsky once wrote “It's only terrorism if they do it to us. When we do much worse to them, it's not terrorism.” By falsely attributing motivations for terrorism against America, the state can claim moral high ground, and by falsely attributing America's own motivations for their own armed conflicts, they can achieve the same goal. [Sept] It's “evil” when others do it. It's “good” when we do it. [PART III: PEOPLE DON'T LIVE IN THE LONG RUN] Proponents of interventionism ignore the human cost and cite hyperbolic examples to shut down arguments, such as noting that it was ultimately beneficial that the world intervened against Nazi Germany, but the Third Reich actually did pose an immediate danger to the entire world – whereas most US military interventions have flimsier reasoning, often do far more harm than good and even exaggerate the threat: see Saddam Hussein and his phantom WMD's.


AUDIO 9


Whether or not philosophers can decide if there is such a thing as a “just war” is irrelevant. What's relevant is that the vast majority of US military interventions, war crimes, assassinations, coup-d'etats and civilian bombings were done and are still being done for its own economic interests -- not for lofty goals like, say, liberating France from the Nazis. The fact that Hitler...existed...is not comforting to families digging through the rubble of a school bus. In the final episode of Game of Thrones, Daenerys tells Jon Snow that now that she and her army has conquered King's Landing, she will send out her forces across the land and even beyond Westeros. Her war will never end until she is satisfied that the world is the way she wants it to be, and since the world can never be exactly how one wants it to be, the proposed war will last forever. Indeed, the war on terror shows no signs of ever stopping. The world will always have terrorism, which means that a war on a concept that can't ever truly be eradicated can never be won. The public accepts that the wars are exclusively about “terrorism” and not consolidating economic interests abroad because it's easier to understand and because confronting what a government does in our name is too frightening.  


Some Middle East scholars speculated that 9/11 was a strategy by Al-Qaeda to provoke America and its allies into a war that will have the byproduct of radicalizing Muslims. Osama bin Laden hoped that western retaliation would unite the faithful against America and its allies. Al-Qaeda knew that America would retaliate and subsequently kill civilians, which would radicalize Muslims against America and could lead to greater recruitment to Al-Qaeda. And that is literally exactly what happened. Terrorist organizations draw support and recruits from resentment and anger against the enemies of the organizations; in this case, America and its coalition forces. Michael Scheuer, senior intelligence analyst in charge of tracking Osama bin Laden from 1996, wrote in his 2004 book Imperial Hubris “there is nothing bin Laden could have hoped for more than the American invasion and occupation of

Iraq, [which is] Osama bin Laden’s gift from America.” There is a great deal of evidence from studies made during the War on Terror that the western coalition's invasions and subsequent civilian casualties have caused a swell of recruitment into terrorist organizations.  


AUDIO 10


A paper published by the National Bureau of Economic Research has found “strong evidence for a revenge effect” when examining civilian casualties caused by US-led military action in Afghanistan. The research found that when units killed civilians, this “increases the number of willing combatants, leading to an increase in insurgent attacks.” According to their model, for every civilian killed, “an additional 0.03 attacks per 1,000 population in the next 6-week period.” This means that in a district of 83,000 people, two civilian casualties leads to six additional insurgent attacks in the following six weeks. This is only one study. Nearly every study on the subject shows similar results, especially as it relates to drones. Strong evidence has begun to suggest that terrorists use US drone strikes as a recruitment tool. 


Supporters of drone strikes as US foreign policy ignore the wider socio-political impact and indirect costs when evaluating their effectiveness – let alone the ethics of inevitable civilian casualties in the first place. The claim from US of “We're doing this FOR you, not AGAINST you” is hard to accept when your family has just been killed in a drone strike. Those who have lost loved ones can't be expected to swallow the argument that these deaths were for some greater good. Shashi Tharoor once said “...human beings don't live in the long run; they live and suffer in the here and now...” We wouldn't just accept terrorist attacks and bombings of our own people, and we can't expect that of civilians in other countries. The idea that other nations should be grateful for US military intervention is arrogant, and the idea that the US only wants what's best for other nations is ignorant. The state wants us not to care. They want us think of ourselves as more important and more worthy of life than the civilians they are killing. They want us to be ignorant. They want us to not have a say in what they're doing because if we do, we might disagree. We might call them on it. We might reignite the anti-war movement or even create anti-war candidates. Business has been good for them, and they want it to be business as usual.


Comments

Simia Canis

Patreon makes content like this quite unwieldy. In regards to your SNL project, please consider a mention of The West Wing and 30 Rock as extensions of the same ideological bent.