Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi, everyone! A few quick updates for you and then the latest scripts.

Someone on Twitter asked when the SNL video is debuting. Like I said in the announcement video, my big projects take about a year from the point I announce. That's the way it was with the Left Behind movie and the DCEU mini-series. The SNL video won't be as long as either, but with my regular weekly videos now about twice as long as usual, the SNL project will take just as long to complete. I announced early in the year. That means that the SNL project will be done early next year at the latest. Scripting continues. I'm not yet sure whether it will be one video or a two-parter. It depends on how huge it becomes.

I've released a couple behind-the-scenes videos for the "high-roller" patrons, and there are a bunch more coming before the year is over. There will also be new polls forthcoming for the $10 tier patrons. 

With that aside, here are the latest scripts. Some are a bit different from what ended up on YouTube. I cut material sometimes.


JOE BIDEN

 AUDIO 1
 This month, the biggest television event of the summer will hit the airwaves. No, not the Game of Thrones finale, that was last month and BAD. Not the season premiere of The Handmaid's Tale, that was weeks ago. It's the stuffed-to-bursting two-night Democratic debates in which two blocks of ten candidates – twenty total – will face off. It's like the G1 Climax of mostly old, mostly white guys. Over the last year or so, Democratic candidates have sprung out of nowhere to introduce themselves to American voters and grab attention for at least a news cycle before another one does the same thing. At the time of this writing, former Vice President Joe Robinette Biden is leading the polls among the overcrowded Democratic candidates for President. When asked about why potential voters side with Biden, reactions often come in the form of “nostalgia” for the previous administration. Biden hitched his wagon to the popular president, and though the vice president does not dictate policy or do much of anything, the “good will” of Barack Obama seems forever tethered to Joe Biden among garden variety Democrats. If you ask these Democrats about Biden's specific policies, they may have a difficult time coming up with an answer because Biden is bereft of ideas.
 The Washington Post recently sent a questionnaire to the veritable ocean of candidates and came back with lots of answers from everyone...except Biden. On many issues such as changes to the electoral college, health care and immigration, Biden was the cheese who stood alone as the single Democrat who had no answer or an unclear answer. In one case, he was among a select few, but he still chickened out of giving a response. Biden's main advantage is name recognition. He's running on nothing. He's hoping you vote for him in the primaries the way Disney hoped you would show up for the new Aladdin movie, because you recognize the brand name, not because you think it'll be any good. It wasn't. Biden does not generate excitement. He generates recognition. Some Biden supporters are in his camp simply because of this false sense of electability. They believe that Biden has the best chance to unseat Donald Trump in 2020. However, history has shown that candidates that don't motivate people to vote because people are unclear about where these candidates stand tend to lose whereas candidates that have a kind of “buzz” about them among their base tend to win. Even people who answer “Joe Biden” in these polls aren't enthuasiastic about Joe Biden. They're just enthusiastic about Not Trump.
 AUDIO 2
 Most Americans do not vote, and it takes a lot to motivate people to go to the polls. Biden does not appear to be that man. Furthermore, early polling rarely tells us how the primaries will shake out. The similarly crowded Republican field last go-around showed Trump at 1% this time last year with Jeb Bush and his sad face as the front-runners. Jeb, too, was polling high due to name recognition – in this case, only last name recognition. Republicans outside of Florida were not overly familiar with his policies, only his lineage. So, one of two things will happen. Either Biden will flame out like Jeb Bush at the hands of a more magnetic candidate, OR the even more crowded Democratic field will eat itself, and Biden's mainstream name recognition and establishment connections will prevail. It's too early to tell. It's also worth noting that Biden being the only way to beat Trump is demonstrably false. If these same people are so trusting of early polling, they may want to look at this other bit of early polling that shows all the major Democratic candidates polling much higher than Trump. Biden has a micrscopic edge here, but again, that's name recognition, and this feature will fade as other candidates become known.
 The debates should fix that and give American voters a better idea about these candidates. His lead against other Democrats is already slipping. Joe Biden would obviously make a better president than Donald Trump because three Muppet babies in a trenchcoat would make a better president than Donald Trump, but considering how well the other Democrats are also faring against Trump in the polls, we don't have to settle for Biden. We don't have to imagine some white dad in a midwest pancake house and how he might vote. No offense to the midwest or pancakes. We can do better. We can choose someone to face the Republican president who is NOT simply a Diet Republican, a Republican Light. The former vice president has an absolutely terrible past and an equally terrible present, both of which suggest that either his campaign will be extremely polarizing and easy to defeat or that an unlikely Biden presidency would maintain a lot of neoliberal, centrist, status quo policies that have ravaged the United States of America for a long time and have impeded progress more than helped it along. Like what, you ask? Well... [RACE] Back in 1975, Biden told the Washington Post “I still walk down the street in the black side of town. Mousey and Chops and all the boys at 13th, and — I can walk in those pool halls, and quite frankly don’t know another white man involved in Delaware politics who can do that kind of thing.”   
 AUDIO 3
 Wow. So equality. Such sensitive. In addition to the inherent cringe factor in trying to earn street cred by referring to men who probably don't exist by outlandish, racially-coded nicknames, there is another problem. This quote was a reaction to accusations of racism. In the same year, Biden became one of the loudest and most bombastic opponents of a de-segregation measure, commonly called busing. It simply meant that some black students would now go to schools that were previously segregated as whites only, and some white students would now go to schools that were previously segregated as blacks only. Prior to this policy, even after the “““official””” end of segregation, schools were still de facto segregated, if not de jure. Before regaling reporters with tales of “Mousey and Chops,” Biden told the press that this de-segregation policy was “the single most devastating issue that could occur to Delaware.” Infamous racist cartoon character Senator Jesse Helms drafted the opposition. On September 17, 1975, when a larger education bill came up for debate, Helms offered an anti-integration, pro-segregation amendment. It would prevent the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare from withholding funding from school districts that refused to integrate.    
 Between lynching fantasies, Helms remarked “This is an amendment to stop the current regiments of faceless, federal bureaucrats from destroying our schools.” He meant white schools. Biden strongly supported Helms, saying “I am sure it comes as a surprise to some of my colleagues … that a senator with a voting record such as mine stands up and supports [the Helms amendment].” and then called integration measures “a bankrupt concept.” Others sided against the team of Helms and Biden because the Helms amendment would effectively destroy any progress made by the 1964 Civil Rights Act; the thing that every civil rights hero of the time was striving for. The Helms amendment did not pass, losing 48 – 43. Biden voted for the amendment. He voted for a policy that would clip the wings of the Civil Rights Act and roll back progress made during the civil rights movement. Biden lost, but he wasn't done. Not ol' Robinette. Biden introduced a similar bill that would still damage the Civil Rights Act but not as much as Helms. This “compromise” pleased liberal senators that had previously opposed the Helms amendment. It still gutted parts of the Civil Rights Act, particularly Title VI, but it managed to pass 50 – 43.    
  AUDIO 4  
  Biden never had a change of heart about this, defending his actions as recently as 2007. One can't claim to know what is in Biden's heart, but we can see the effects his actions have had up until today and not just how his actions affected the nation in the 1970's. According to a report from the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES), much higher percentages of students of color are made to attend high-poverty schools compared to white students. Experts agree that instead of getting better over time, it is actually getting worse. The Supreme Court case of Milliken v. Bradley stated that school districts could legally be segregated as long as it was not intentional. However, this language allows districts a lot of leeway to do this through trickery and loopholes rather than simply advocating for policies that more explicitly state their purpose. This so-called “color blind segregation” comes from zoning ordinances, homeowners associations and predatory lending. Because of racialized poverty, these tactics predominantly affect black students, Hispanic students, Native American students and Pacific Islander students. Basically, students are segregated on an economic basis.  
  45% of black and Hispanic students are made to attend high-poverty schools whereas only 8% of white students attend such schools. [Source: NCES] This is done “legally” because housing developments can be built that have no specific racial requirements but do require two acre lots or homes that must be at least 5,000 square feet. This purposefully excludes the vast majority of people in the country from purchasing such a home, which perpetuates privileges and exclusions in favor of affluent white families, like these people in some stock footage that I find both hilarious and haunting. This puts black families in different school districts and in schools that the government barely funds for...reasons. What Biden did was further advantage white families in the US and further disadvantage black families. White parents are able to choose neighborhoods with highly-funded public schools or private schools whereas black parents usually can't. Biden's law effectively gave white families a choice and took away that choice from black families. Biden once said that “that your black, curly-haired son” doesn't need to be in a class with “my white, straight-haired one” to get an education.    
  AUDIO 5  
 Biden repeatedly invoked Delaware’s history as a slave state to appeal to southern conservatives, once telling a Republican Rotary Club that Delaware only fought with the Union because “we couldn’t figure out how to get to the South.” [Source: The Baltimore Sun] Biden has, in the past, defended his pro-segregation attitudes by exaggerating his civil rights bonafides. Another way to put that is that he lied. He...lied. Biden loved to tell the public that he “participated in sit-ins” at restaurants, except that he later admitted that this was not true, that he absolutely was not an activist and that the full extent of his participation in the civil rights movement was that he worked at a predominantly black swimming pool. No amount of declarations that Biden was “friends” with Barack Obama can remove these particular stains from the former vice president's record. Some of this may have happened in the 70's, but its effects are still being felt today. What's worse, he has never corrected this and has rarely backed down from it. He remained in the Senate for over thirty years after his law passed, and he chose to leave it on the books.  
  Any argument that this was a long time ago is irrelevant because he had over thirty years to change his mind, and he still has not. There has been a rise in racial tension and hate crimes under the Trump administration, and a Biden presidency would do little to cure this because history has shown that he has no such ability or inclination to do so. [WAR ON DRUGS] In 1989, President George H.W. Bush delivered a speech that escalated the disastrous war on drugs. Bush presented his National Drug Control Strategy, calling for harsher punishments and allocated nearly one and a half billion dollars toward drug-related law enforcement. Bush wanted “more prisons, more jails” [Source: Jacobin] all over the country. Biden, still technically a Democrat, believed that a Republican president's war on drugs was not conservative enough. Biden said “Quite frankly, the President's plan is not tough enough... the President's plan does not include enough police officers to catch the violent thugs... or enough prison cells to put them away for a long time.” Biden helped create the cabinet-level “drug czar” position. Biden helped move legislation that anyone caught with an amount of cocaine larger than a quarter was imprisoned for a minimum of five years but potentially more.     
  AUDIO 6  
  Biden pushed “civil asset forfeiture,” which allowed the government to rob anyone that they claimed was dealing drugs. Was it abused? Of course! It always is. He pushed for the Bush administration to sentence more drug dealers to death. Former United Nations Secretary General Kofi Annan once said “Drugs have destroyed many people. But bad governmental policies have destroyed more.” [Source: We Forum] The criminalization of drugs fuels a violent international narcotics trade. The US has spent over a trillion dollars trying to combat the problem with policing for about forty years. It drains the government of funds when we could be using that money on healthcare for all. Zero tolerance policies help prosecute Americans for even microscopic amounts of drugs. A report from the ACLU shows that one man, for example, was prosecuted for an amount of drugs so small that a laboratory couldn't even weigh it. He was sentenced to fifteen years. If these arguments don't tug at your heart strings, perhaps the pragmatic argument will be more helpful. The war on drugs has not worked. Nearly every study into the matter has shown that the extremely costly war on drugs has been almost completely ineffective.    
  In fact, the war on drugs could even be worsening the problem, deterring users from seeking help when they need it. That seems to be the case in the US, where a record number of people died through drug overdoses a few years ago. Drug law reform and focus on treatment has never been on Biden's agenda. He voted for drug laws in 1986 and 1988 which created harsh mandatory minimums for drug possession. Biden not only mimicked conservative Republican ideas about the war on drugs, he went even further, hoping to brand himself as a Democrat who even Republicans would vote for. He does that...a lot. [CRIME] Related to the war on drugs, Biden has been one of the loudest proponents of the mass incarceration movement among his own party. Biden co-authored the 1994 crime bill called the Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act. This 1994 law imposed tougher sentences and increased funding for prisons, largely contributing to the growth of the US prison population from the 1990's through the 2000's. Journalist Radley Balko of the Washington Post once said of this “The martial/incarceral state has had no greater friend in Washington over the last 35 years than Joe Biden.”  
  AUDIO 7  
 The American criminal justice system is highly racialized, and the Biden crime law made things worse. Mass incarceration is predominantly black incarceration. Black Americans are nearly six times as likely to be incarcerated as white people and nearly three times as likely as Hispanics. Conservatives and straight-up racists try to use these haunting statistics against black communities as “evidence” that black people are “criminals,” but The Sentencing Project actually concluded that racial bias and other racist factors were behind as much as 39% of the disparate rates of imprisonment for black Americans.  According to the FBI and the US Census Bureau, black Americans are much more likely to be arrested for drugs than white Americans even though their comparative usage of drugs is nearly identical. According to the US Sentencing Commission, black Americans receive longer sentences than white Americans for the exact same crimes. Not only drug crimes. The 1994 crime bill that Biden so fervently supported made things worse. That was then and this is now, though, right? Well, as recently as 2016, Biden was asked if he was ashamed of the crime bill.  
 He said “Not at all. As a matter of fact, I drafted the bill, if you remember. ...by and large what it really did, it restored American cities.” But did it, Joe? Was the crime bill the cause of the decrease in the crime? Many researchers say no. Although the US makes up about 4% of the world's population, it accounts for a staggering 22% of the world's prison population. The US is out of line not only with its developed peers but also with authoritarian nations. A panel from the National Academy of Sciences concluded in 2012 that higher incarceration rates had, at best, a modest effect on the decline. The panel also found little indication of a deterrent effect, concluding “The incremental deterrent effect of increases in lengthy prison sentences is modest at best. Because recidivism rates decline markedly with age, lengthy prison sentences, unless they specifically target very high-rate or extremely dangerous offenders, are an inefficient approach to preventing crime by incapacitation.” Basically, most offenders reach a point when they age out of criminal behavior, which limits the benefits of “mandatory minimum sentencing.” Lengthy prison sentences are “ineffective as a crime-control measure” in nearly all circumstances.  
  AUDIO 8  
 In fact, a lot of research suggests harsh prison conditions and lengthy sentences make convicts more likely to reoffend. Contributing factors to the drop in crime include greater economic growth in the 90's causing less need for crime to make ends meet, lower unemployment, reproductive rights, lead regulations, pharmacological advances and a host of other smaller progressive changes. There is no one reason why the crime rate dropped, but one thing we do know is that the crime bill's affect on the drop in crime was marginal at best, which means that its negative affects far outweigh its alleged positives. Voters want politicians who are “tough on crime” to this day, even though said voters still think the crime rate was as bad as in the 80's. It's not...Mad Max out there, guys. If nominated by the Democrats, Biden's history with mass incarceration will have the same deleterious effect on his campaign as the “super predator” line had on the Hillary Clinton campaign. This means he will either double down on being tough and crime and enact more of these regressive laws when president or he'll crash and burn on the campaign trial because of it, just like Clinton. Neither possibility is all that appealing. [LIGHTNING ROUND]    
 Alright, let's wrap things up. When Roe v. Wade gave reproductive rights to women in America, Biden exclaimed “I don’t like the Supreme Court decision on abortion. I think it went too far. I don’t think that a woman has the sole right to say what should happen to her body.” He has changed his opinions here and there over the years and is now technically pro-choice, but he still – up until a few days ago – supported the restrictive Hyde amendment. His record on women's reproductive rights is spotty at best, and during a time in which those rights are genuinely under threat by state governors and this goober, Biden's not exactly the best Democrat that the voters can choose to advocate for women. Biden has publicly blamed people in their 20's and 30's for their financial hardships instead of sympathizing with the fact that the older generation ruined the market. Biden is a walking-talking “Millennials killed the ____ industry” click bait think piece, and based on this cold-hearted, shitty take, there is no reason to assume he will do anything to help like raise the minimum wage. Biden presided over the extremely sexist interrogation of Anita Hill, refusing to take responsibility for her treatment for decades until it became politically convenient.    
  AUDIO 9  
  She did not accept his apology, nor should she, because it happened right when he was about to announce his candidacy and was therefore politically motivated and insincere. He is way too comfortable with the Republican Party, probably because he shares way too many of their values, and he personally really likes actual war criminal Dick Cheney. He has a very close relationship with lobbyists, especially financial institutions, even attending retreats with them. If he gains the presidency, he will be about as compromised as many other bought politicians. Biden's policies have been so toxic to the US that I didn't even have to spend too much time in this video talking about how he's kinda creepy and invades people's personal space. I mean, it is creepy, and the fact that he had to be dragged kicking and screaming to make an empty, psuedo-apology that he later backtracked, mocked and violated on the campaign trail only days later is just a whole thing, right? But I don't even need to dive too deep into that in order to explain why a Biden presidency would be worse for the United States than an administration run by someone else in his party.    
  Although, small note on that: a debate between Trump and Biden in which they both call each other perverts might literally kill me. I have a weak stomach. When Trump talked about how big his dick was, I almost threw up my own skeleton. It's also important to note that Joe Biden is only one man.    He didn't do all of this alone, and the racist and capitalist institutions that he helps maintain existed long before himself and will exist without him. I don't mean to pin all of America's woes on Joe Biden or individualize these systemic problems, but the debates and primaries are effectively about how these politicians have individually contributed to the gains and losses for our country. Even if we can't pin all of the woes on an individual, it is necessary to pin DOWN what they believe in and what they will do if elected. I hope I have done this today. Biden's alleged “electability,” literally the only thing anyone says in his favor is an illusion. He has so much riding against him and so much that can and will be used against him should he earn the nomination. He doesn't have more inherent “electability” than the other major Democrats. That's the false narrative that he loves peddling, and the media is happy to quote him verbatim instead of challenging him on that demonstrable falsehood. There are ten thousand other candidates, and we can do better than Joe Biden.   


DAVID THE GNOME

 AUDIO 1
 We are exhausted. The world is much worse than we thought it was, and we already thought it was careening toward disaster. [Lisa Simpson] Sometimes the more we learn, the more unhappy we become because the veil of the world, the illusion is so neatly crafted that we could fool ourselves into thinking that the system works and that we, too, must be in the right if we are part of that system. We listened to our parents, and we grew up, and the world was more or less what they said...so long as we didn't look too closely. So long as we viewed the world with one eye closed and the other only squinting. But then, we learned more and then came a false revelation. If the world is so much worse than we thought, why bother trying to fix it? If it can't get better, don't you want to see how much worse it can get? But there is another option. David the Gnome tried to teach it to us, but we forgot. We sat on the floor of the basement and watched television early in the morning before our parents arose from their crypts. David had a bone to pick with us, he said, because human beings were destroying the world. Ruining the rivers and forests around his home. We were surprised because we didn't know. Ignorance is bliss.
 David tried to teach us something that parents sometimes don't. He tried to teach us empathy. Movies and television mock themselves, showing characters who were raised on TV instead of raised by their parents and how terribly they turned out. But did those who were raised by their parents turn out better? They became trolls. They became monsters. Our parents said things like “Stay out of trouble.” and “Don't talk back to me.” and believed that these were lessons in good behavior. “Stay out of trouble.” doesn't teach empathy. It teaches us to avoid getting caught. The system doesn't treat us equally, though. So, some of us may be abler to avoid getting caught better than others. Marginalized people will be hounded by those who try to catch us for not staying out of trouble. But if we listened to our parents, and thought “Stay out of trouble.” was enough, then we are unconcerned about the plight of others. WE stayed out of trouble. That means WE are good, right? David had to be cautious to avoid those in the forest who would do him harm, but when one of his antagonists lost their child, he stepped up. He helped. He showed his empathy, and he showed us how empathy works.
 AUDIO 2
 “Don't talk back to me.” Does that teach us empathy? It teaches us fear. It teaches us either that we are not as worthy of having ourselves heard as others, or worse still, it teaches us to want to be the one who can tell others what to do. When to speak. When not to speak. When to act. When not to act. If we are taught only that there are those with authority and those without authority, those who are bullies and those are bullied, then we might choose to be bullies. And when called on it, we might say “Get used to it. Life is hard!” That second part is true. Life is hard. So...why make it worse for everyone? We learned the wrong lessons from our parents. “Stay out of trouble” and such. These are survival skills, at best, but they don't teach survival so much as conformity to a system that has no use for empathy. It's designed that way. David always talked about hoping that the children watching would share his point of view. His words. That's what empathy means. Sharing or experiencing someone else's feelings from their point of view. Our parents said “That's just how the world works.” And we believed them instead of questioning this. People shrug at a world that unfairly advantages some and disadvantages others, and those that the world advantage say “That's just how the world works.”
 People who are granted unfair advantages by the system always think that the system is fair, and people who are shown unfair disadvantages by the system know that it's not. How convenient for the unfairly advantaged people that the system just so happens to work for them! If the advantaged people thought about empathy for one second, they would see from the point of view of the disadvantaged. But we were all taught “Stay out of trouble.” as our morality, as our compass, as our guide to life. If we were lucky, parents might have sat us down for THE TALK about the birds and bees, but parents didn't sit us down for THE TALK about empathy. About why we should treat others well. Some tried but couched it only in the authority of God, and by doing so gave us the impression that if our lives fall apart, it is only because we are no longer in His grace. Maybe we should have been raised by David the Gnome instead. He always went out of his way to help others – humans, animals, even trolls. He had such high hopes for us, believed that she would save the world from our parents, but instead we just turned into them. We took their place in the system, and we are making the exact same mistakes.   
 AUDIO 3
 David spoke gently the children who watched, but he also taught hard lessons. He didn't lie to us. He showed us that we live, we love, we suffer and we die, but the fact that life is hard was never an excuse to be unkind. David knew he was about to die since we first met him. He never thought “Why bother?” the way that some say. The way that some look at the world and say “Why bother trying to fix it? Don't you want to see how much worse it can get?” David traveled all over the world to help people – even in his final days. Even his death was about helping people. He and his wife Lisa became trees to offer shade and protection to others. David always expressed his emotions. He didn't bottle them up inside. Nobody ever told him to “suck it up” and he never told that to us either. He wanted us to be emotionally healthy. He told his wife he loved her all the time, he showed affection, he called people “my friend” when greeting them. He confessed to the children watching that his life as a doctor sometimes made him nervous because of the lives that were in his hands. David treated his wife Lisa as his partner and never spoke down to her. When she set out to rescue him, David was pleased as well as proud of her – he never became insecure about the fact that he needed rescuing.
 David tried to teach children that growing up didn't mean growing old and that we could, if we wanted, retain our innocence and our empathy even after becoming old. He was almost 400 years old and he never became bitter and resentful of the younger generation. We didn't live up to his ideals, not by any stretch of the imagination. We grew up believing the lies and half-truths and obfuscations that our parents taught us either directly by their words or indirectly by the greater implications of their words.   … We should have been raised by David the Gnome. He was a far better role model than anyone who wanted that position, who wanted to mold us into smaller versions of themselves. All we can do now is try to break free from the bad lessons that we instilled in us at a young age. To reject the idea that empathy is a weakness.   
 

INDEPENDENCE DAY

 AUDIO 1
 Let's play a game. Try to think of a big budget, Hollywood-made alien invasion movie that does NOT follow most of this pattern: we see the invasion predominantly from an American perspective with only fleeting glances at the rest of the world, the US military is the primary opposition to the aliens, and the US saves the world. District 9 takes place in South Africa, but it's not an alien “invasion” movie. The aliens have been there for years, and exist alongside humans as de-valued immigrants. Attack the Block and The World's End were made in England, and they're not big budget pictures. War of the Worlds is more from the perspective of Tom Cruise's character than the US military, but said military does play prominently in the film. We also stay firmly within the US borders throughout the duration of the narrative and barely notice other nations. Arrival is the greatest outlier because even though it is from the perspective of Americans and the US military, the fact that this is a global effort is central to the plot. Moreover, the scientists are trying to understand the aliens and not wage war on them. The aliens have come in peace. Generally speaking, alien invasion movies made by Hollywood follow the Independence Day model and have long before Independence Day was even a movie.
 Independence Day simply built upon much earlier flying saucer invasions – aliens knocking over landmarks and tourist traps in Washington DC and such. Independence Day is told primarily from the perspectives of the commander in chief of the US military as well as US military forces [welcome to Earth], the wife of the commander in chief and the eventual wife of a military pilot, a Vietnam veteran, US military super secret scientists in Area 51, and one civilian who still participates in a US military operation that saves the world. Indeed, before the US came up with a plan, the rest of the world was a complete afterthought to the narrative. The entire world outside of US borders were apparently standing around with their thumbs up their a**es, waiting for the US to come save them. [It's the Americans...] It's not simply a case of American audiences wanting to see America unilaterally taking on the alien invaders – it's a case of American audiences expecting to see America unilaterally taking on the alien invaders. It's an unquestioned narrative – an assumption of American exceptionalism. [PART I: American Exceptionalism]   
 AUDIO 2
 American exceptionalism is the belief that the United States is not only different from the rest of the world but uniquely positioned to lead the world. Exceptionalism states that the US follows of path of history different from the laws and norms that govern other countries. American exceptionalism is the belief that the US is not only bigger and more powerful than other nations but that it due to its uniqueness, it need not follow said laws and norms. When the US violates the borders of another nation and strikes it with a drone, this is unquestioned among Americans due to American exceptionalism. We are “allowed” to do this. If the same nation struck ours with a drone, they are not “allowed” to do this. Who do they think they are? AMERICA? That's terrorism when they do it. The US allows itself to do this because it sees itself as the standard bearer of liberty, freedom, democracy, “western civilization.” In the 1980's, President Ronald Reagan called the US a “shining city upon a hill.” The concept of exceptionalism became more and more linked to global US military and political hegemony. No matter of how much income inequality and other issues make “exceptionalism” seem hollow, the US can rely on their military to enforce this idea that the US can do as it pleases – by force.   
 American exceptionalism should not be confused with “patriotism,” as patriotism is understood, by definition, to be internal to the people of a nation. Patriotism is the belief or feeling among citizens of a nation that said citizens should support and praise their country. American exceptionalism is the belief that the world should support and praise America and that the world owes a debt to America and that the world should aspire to be more like America. Every nation has patriots, the people who root for the home team. But Patriotism is internal to a nation. American exceptionalism is both internal and contains an expectation that it should be external. President Obama once said maybe other nations might believe they are “exceptional” too, so what's the harm in America's rhetoric about this? No, that's patriotism, not exceptionalism. Patriotism is a feeling whereas exceptionalism is both theory and praxis. The US practices its exceptionalism through its military on the world stage whereas most other nations don't or can't. There is a difference between saying “I love my nation” and saying “My nation has been chosen – perhaps divinely – to lead the world by any means necessary.” US politicians try not to use the words “supremacy” or “superiority” when referring to where they believe the nation is on the global stage because such words have historical negative connotations. Up until recently, US politicians also avoided the word “nationalism,” but the Overton window has moved yet again. [clip]   
 AUDIO 3
 So, politicians use the word “exceptionalism,” as it provides a small amount of cover and deniability. Politicians are careful not to say Americans are superior to other people, only exceptional, even though the word suggests Americans are apart from others. Professing a belief in American exceptionalism is a requirement for all prominent politicians these days. Republicans say it. [clip] Democrats say it. [clip] Virtually everyone says it. President Donald Trump claimed to not like the term “exceptionalism” but did not denounce its meaning. He doubled down on its meaning, preferring the terms “American First” and “Make America Great Again.” instead. They have the same connotations as American exceptionalism, perhaps even worse connotations. Trump couldn't say America was great now because he wanted his cultists to believe that only he could make it great AGAIN. Nonetheless, he was still tapping into the same nationalism, only using more inflammatory rhetoric. Regardless of wording, it is absolutely necessary for politicians in the US to agree with the concept, lest they be denounced. A controversy will swell, their patriotism will be called into question, and they will be labeled “traitor” by Fox News. Those in politics doubtlessly question this behind closed doors but not in public. President Jimmy Carter's National Security Advisor Zbigniew Brzezinski once said:   
 “[American exceptionalism] is a reaction to the inability of people to understand global complexity or important issues like American energy dependency. Therefore, they search for simplistic sources of comfort and clarity. And the people that they are now selecting to be, so to speak, the spokespersons of their anxieties are, in most cases, stunningly ignorant.” When people profess that some group of people is superior, the first question to be asked should always be: is this belief in superiority common to people outside this group? Is this a widely held belief, or is this a belief that the group is inherently “better” held predominantly within the group? White supremacists believe that white people are inherently “better” than many other racial identities, but it is obviously not a widely held belief among black people, among South Asian people, et cetera. It is a cultural belief, a colloquial value that is unquestioned only within the group. Similarly, American exceptionalism is not fact or a universal value, but believers in American exceptionalism practice it as if it were. When America invades another nation and American politicians claim that they will be greeted as liberators, this is an example of two aspects of American exceptionalism.   
 AUDIO 4
 The invasion itself and the belief in how the invasion will be received. The former, the invasion, is a byproduct of the idea that Americans have both the right and duty to invade other nations. The latter, the idea America will be greeted as a liberator, comes from the mistaken belief that American exceptionalism is a universal value instead of what it is: a cultural value almost exclusively among only one group. Americans. [PART II: Today We Celebrate Our Independence Day] During the lead-up to Independence Day's final battle, President Whitmore delivers a rousing speech to the US military, telling them that from now on, July 4th will no longer be only an American holiday but a world holiday. Americans view this as egalitarian and noble. Non-Americans might view this as condescending. Independence Day is a fictionalized account of US military hegemony as altruistic rather than what it is: self-serving. The US has its troops all over the world for economic concerns, not “spreading democracy.” Real life US politicians frame their exceptionalism and subsequent military presence much like the fictional President Whitmore – as a responsibility to the world, but it's not a burden – it's a feature, a positive.
 US military and political hegemony benefits the US over other nations. I made a separate video essay about that recently, you can follow the link here. Consider this a companion piece. Independence Day is how Americans want to see their alleged exceptionalism: a net positive for the world, justified by power and ultimately unique. That brings us to a question: what makes the US so “unique” that it sees itself as being apart from the rest of the world, its laws and its norms? Sticking to the military for a moment longer, one might say that the US has the largest standing army in the world...but it actually doesn't. China has the largest army. Oh, OK. So, second largest, right? No, that's India. Maybe...third largest? Yes. And yet, in spite of this, American exceptionalism persists. Americans don't believe that China and India have the same “right” to break international law and commit war crimes, though. That's only for America. The US military, however, is the most highly-funded armed force in the world. The government, regardless of which party is in power, spends more on its military than any other nation on Earth. In fact, it's not even close.   
 AUDIO 5
 China has the largest standing army, but they don't spend even half as much as the US does on its military. Saudi Arabia, India and France are distant third, fourth and fifth in military spending worldwide. So, what percentage of the US budget is spent on the military? A quarter? A third? Actually, significantly more. Most. MOST of the budget for the entire federal government is spent on what we euphemistically call “defense.” Let's put a pin in that. Hang on. We'll come back to it. Besides the fact that the US spends more on its military than any other nation, how is it unique? What justifies its notion of exceptionalism? The Social Progress Index measures how much nations provide for the social and environmental needs of their citizens. Fifty-four indicators in the areas of basic human needs, foundations of well-being, and opportunity to progress show the relative performance of nations. According to last year's ranking, the US is 24th in providing shelter, 25th in quality of electrical supply, 30th in nutrition and basic medical care, 37th in overall health and wellness, 39th in access to drinking water, 40th in child mortality, 44th in environmental quality, 47th in political rights, 50th in personal safety, 50th in access to basic knowledge.
 61st in secondary school enrollment, 63rd in primary school enrollment, 67th in preventing discrimination and violence against minorities and on and on and on. So. With all of this in mind, what makes the United States of America...exceptional? Only military spending. US justification for its military hegemony is a mobius strip. The US justifies its military operations all over the world...because it has military operations all over the world. It justifies its actions...by its actions. It justifies its existence by its existence. It justifies its wars by its ability to make war. “We're great,” they say, “and that's why we're allowed spread our military all over the world.” And when questioned we're they're great, they say “Because our military is big enough to spread all over the world.” It's double-speak. It's Orwellian. It's circular reasoning. Even if the US were #1 in most of the categories mentioned before, it wouldn't justify all the wars because those are unrelated, but even if having good domestic policies could somehow be justification for a devastating foreign policy, it's a non-starter of a justification because the US demonstrable does not have a superior or exceptional domestic policy to begin with.
 AUDIO 6
 We actually see a bit of that in Independence Day. President Whitmore's domestic policies are under scrutiny and criticism. A political pundit says the people elected a warrior but got a “wimp.” Whitmore's war record is what got him elected, and his military prowess and declaration that the US will save the world is what pumps people up about him. The US as the #1 military force alone justifies his presidency. It's what finally makes him popular. [PART III: EARTH AS AMERICA] How did American exceptionalism become mostly about the military? According to Godfrey Hodgson book The Myth of American Exceptionalism: “Many exceptionalists today, starting with the forty-third president of the United States, base their case on religion. It was the deity, according to them, who singled out the United States for his purposes. Yet the Founders … were hardly conspicuous for their religious belief; deism, among them, was as common as orthodoxy. In recent decades, capitalism has taken its place on the podium as an aspect of American exceptionalism almost equal with democracy. For many, however, throughout the Progressive and New Deal years, capitalism rated very low in their reasons for thinking the United States exceptional.   
 … Empirically the United States has become one of the least equal, indeed probably the very most unequal, of the world’s developed democratic nations in terms of the distribution of both income and wealth. Where once America was exceptional in its contempt for militarism and its suspicion of standing armies …. now the supposedly invincible prowess of American arms is a vital part of the exceptionalist litany.” In short, the concept of American exceptionalism has existed for a long time, but the justification for this exceptionalism has changed. The criteria – the evidence – for why the US should be seen as exceptional changes depending on what the US is presently “good” at doing. American exceptionalism creates a feedback loop for the populace. The US is labeled the best and most important nation on Earth, and when the populace asks for the nation to treat its people better, those who buy into American exceptionalism dismiss this. They ask “How could the US possibly treat us better if we're in the greatest and most important nation on Earth?”
 AUDIO 7
 Criticism becomes “treasonous” unless mixed with a dose of exceptionalism that guarantees said criticism won't be taken seriously. American exceptionalism creates a toxic atmosphere among the populace. Exceptionalism is the pledge we take every day by living in America, it flows through air like background radiation. According to Gallup polling, at the beginning of this decade, 80 percent of Americans polled said that the US is the "greatest country" in the world. Of the 20 wealthy democracies polled, US citizens were the most proud of their nationality and most supportive of attacking other countries. It's a cultural belief that is unquestioned regardless of how many actual questions it raises. It is the “It is known” of the Dothraki, an accepted truth that is not true. It is so unquestioned and feels so natural to Americans and in American media, that Independence Day can be directed by a German and still have it tap into American exceptionalism because directors and studios know what Americans want and more importantly what Americans believe about America. Americans see their nation and particularly their military as the police of the world, but this allows the military to do what it wants, bomb who it wants, take what it wants.   
 And all of this is justified not by the end results, which are often disastrous, but by the “might is right” belief that is the modern form of exceptionalism. The concept of American exceptionalism tricks the population into thinking that the US exerting itself in other nations is generally “good” and is spreading “democracy.” But democracy can't mean military occupation. Democracy can't mean an entire world's political decisions are made in the White House. The US defeating the aliens in Independence Day is the fantasy of exceptionalists – the idea that only the US can protect the Earth, and because of that, a certain amount of leeway and a few war crimes can be handwaved away. When aliens come, they come for America. When aliens come for Earth and the audience is primarily American, the aliens tap into American xenophobia. When aliens come for Earth, Americans see Earth as America. In conclusion, American exceptionalism is actually American “exemptionalism” – it exempts the United States from seeing itself as part of world and instead apart from it or above it. And that kind of attitude – that kind of philosophy – is historically very dangerous.
 

THE OUTRAGE IS ABOUT CONTROL

 AUDIO 1
 In June of this year, Square-Enix began to finally release more information about its long-awaited and much-delayed Final Fantasy VII Remake. Some cheered the re-designed battle system, some booed even attempting to have another go around with such a classic – but there came a third, laughable position. One that seemed like a joke until sadly, inevitably, we realized it was not. Gamers, in this case almost entirely men, lamented that fan favorite character Tifa had ever so slightly smaller breasts than as depicted in the original Final Fantasy. It seemed, at first, like a tempest in a tea pot. A smattering of tweets from disgruntled malcontents, a false controversy, an outrage where there is no outrage. But then more and more gamers began weighing in, more and more began denouncing this mild, barely noticeable change in chest size, and any hope that this would blow over in a day or two was dashed. Gaming YouTube pounced, crying “censorship” and usual candards of “feminists ruining gaming” and the like. YouTube titles like “What are the NPC's saying about Tifa?” and “Tifa CENSORED” and “SJW's Want Tifa's Boobs Smaller” and so forth. This also spread to gaming news websites and think pieces examining every pixel of the virtual breasts.   
 Many major gaming “journalists” spent many an article treating this as if it were news and treating the reaction as legitimate and not the whinging of crybabies. Twitter mocked said crybabies, claiming that they must not be aware that breasts are in no short supply on the Internet and that one need only spend two seconds on Google to find millions of pairs of breasts. “What?” we asked. “Can you no longer masturbate to Tifa?” This was not an isolated incident. Months prior, the cycle was very much the same for the latest Mortal Kombat game in which some of the women fighters wore somewhat more practical fighting gear even though said skin-tight outfits still showcased their attractive bodies. The outfits simply didn't show “enough cleavage” for some longtime fans of Mortal Kombat who still remember Kitana and Milenna's wardrobes from yesteryear and even from more recent iterations. The same outrage occurred when Tomb Raider was rebooted and Lara Croft's ample chest size was not as ridiculously oversized as in some other games in the series. The “wanker” insults lobbed at those who participated in the outrage were funny for a moment until it became clear that this was never solely about breasts.   
 AUDIO 2
 Gamers know that there is a nearly unlimited amount of fully naked breasts and other p*rnography for free on the Internet. Telling them “Don't you know about P*rnHub?” is not helpful because they definitely already know and because that is not the root of this outrage. Simply wanting to see more breasts can't be the root cause due to the aforementioned bounty of p*rnography. We have to look deeper. This problem can never go away, can never even diminish, until the men – and it is mostly men – who participate in the outrage address the roots of this pattern: a fear among those who have more institutional power in society about the possibility of a change in the status quo that they find comforting or even morally correct. [PART 1: INSTITUTIONAL POWER] Disclaimer: Some of this will seem entirely 101 to some, but because this is completely foreign to others, some basic definitions are necessary. Institutional power is the authority wielded by entities such as governments and corporations. It can also be used to describe those who benefit from this authority contrasted with those who do not benefit from this authority. Institutional power exists where authority has been approved by a society and accepted as legitimate.   
 The racial majority of a country, for example, wields institutional power that the racial minorities do not. The power that racism carries depends on how it is embedded in institutions like law enforcement and whether or not racist actions carry with them institutional support – not only through the law but through social governance and social norms that determine “right and wrong” for much of society. Even if racial minorities have advanced in a society on paper, they still typically lack institutional power. When racist actions are committed against them, minorities tend to lack the institutional means to defend themselves. This happens through the law due to racialized poverty making it difficult to defend oneself in court, but it also happens socially because often when a racial minority accuses either action or speech of being racist, they can be shouted down by far more people who will back them up. The rich have more institutional power than the poor irrespective of race and other factors. The rich can donate great sums of money to politicians to keep the laws in their favor, defend themselves effectively should they ever run afoul of the law and so forth.   
 AUDIO 3
 One example that society tends to both understand and believe across political lines in this: wealthy celebrities are rarely punished for their misdeeds. They have the money to defend themselves effectively, but they also have public support. No matter how awful the accusations, the celebrity's fanbase will either assume their innocence and attack those who claim otherwise or forgive them almost immediately, setting the stage for their comeback. No matter what they do, they tend to be able to bounce back from almost any controversy or even crime. They have the institutional support of being rich as well as a society that values celebrities over non-celebrities. Politicians wield an incredible amount of institutional power, particularly when it comes to being able to defend themselves. In some countries, heads of state and heads of government are practically immune from prosecution. Sometimes this is codified in the law and sometimes this is due to an unwillingness by their societies to prosecute. In short, some people in society have more institutional power than others. Sometimes this institutional power is explicitly the law, such as in the case with the President, and sometimes this institutional power is de facto in the law or governed socially.
 Women are significantly more vulnerable to sexual assault due to a society that places less value on the autonomy of women. According to the National Sexual Violence Resource Center, one in 71 men have been raped whereas one in five women have been raped. That means there is approximately a 1.4% chance of a man being raped over the course of his life and a 20% chance of a woman being raped over the course of her life. Expanding to both rape and sexual assault show us more disparity. 91% of victims of rape or sexual assault are women and only 9% of the victims are men. This, of course, does not lessen the pain of sexual assault for male victims, it merely shows a pattern. Laws, on paper at least, make it possible to prosecute the perpetrators of either crime, but as you can see by these statistics, there is more to disparity of how different people are treated than simply what the law says. Disparity of treatment is a consequence of how society views different people not only officially through the law but unofficially by social governance. Negative attitudes about women infect law enforcement and prosecution of these crimes. Women often report that law enforcement does not always take accusations of sexual assault seriously and sometimes dismiss the accusation outright.
 AUDIO 4
 Fear of how law enforcement will treat women who come forward with their assault and societal reinforcement that women must see their bodies as shameful or sexual are two contributing factors to why sexual assault and rape are the least reported crimes. 63% of all sexual assaults are not reported to the police. Another way to put all of this is that women have less institutional power than men. There are other examples related to women and other examples of institutional power for others, but the sexual example is the most relevant for the topic today. Institutional support creates social norms: a broad set of ideals, both explicit and implicit, that dictate behavior in particular situations as well as attitudes about different people and ideas. Social norms become “institutionalized” by a society and these various social norms form a broader status quo: the existing state of affairs, particularly socially and politically. Deviation from a social norm can cause serious consequences to those who do, depending on how widely held the social norm or how strongly believed the social norm. Saying “thank you” is a social norm in many countries, and failure to do so generally results in little more than mild offense or an accusation of rudeness.    
 A social norm is not only tradition to some – it is morally correct. This can have adverse consequences. If the social norm is “Women should take care of running their home and leave running the country up to men.” or “It is much better for everyone involved if the man is the achiever outside the home and women takes care of the home and family.” then these social norms affect the perception of women's value in society and where they exist on a kind of social hierarchy. Being “de-valued” carries serious consequences. If someone is seen as “less than” in a society, and institutional power defends those who see that someone as “less than,” then that someone is vulnerable both legally and socially. People internalize social norms at a young age, which means women appear to internalize social norms like when to have children, what tasks are appropriate for women in the work force, how much society values the work of women, what women are supposed to look like, how women are supposed to behave compared to men, et cetera. Over time, society fights against social norms they see as negative and try to upend the status quo to something comparatively more progressive or egalitarian.   
 AUDIO 5
 When this happens, there is always an effort by those with institutional power to turn back the clock. This attempt at reversal is called reactionary politics. A reactionary is a person or entity which holds institutional power and favors a return to a previous status quo. When gamers say that “feminism has ruined video games” or other outlandish statements that do not actually reflect reality, this is a reactionary movement – not only reactionary as it relates to video games but reactionary because the mild changes in the video game landscape, to them, reflect mild changes in the status quo and a threat to their unequal, institutional power. Social norms can be influenced by a great many factors – and one of those factors is popular media. [PART 2: PORTRAYALS IN MEDIA] Square-Enix is not “woke” because its new Tifa design went from a double D to regular D. It's probably very happy that reactionary gamers have given Final Fantasy even more coverage. It may have even been their goal. I'm not here to defend Square-Enix, only to explain the reactionary politics element of all this. Square-Enix is not your friend, and it has contributed to reinforcing sexual objectification far more than it has fought against it. Objectification theory states that many women are sexually objectified and treated as objects to be valued for use by others. Sexual objectification occurs when a woman's body or body parts are singled out and separated from her as a person and she is viewed primarily as a physical object of sexual desire. Sexual objectification of women contributes to mental health problems that disproportionately affect women like eating disorders.
 This can occur one of two ways. The first is direct and involves experiences of being sexually objectified in public. The second is indirect and involves women's internalization of sexual objectification. Media allows sexual objectification to be broadcast and even played worldwide. All forms of media have sexually objectified women, but video games have proven unique in that gamers are able to more actively participate in the sexual objectification – creating a confluence of both direct and indirect objectification. Video games do not turn an innocent child into a school shooter – this is well understood – but all media influences how we see the world and colors our perceptions of people. Media reinforces pre-existing social norms. Due to gaming's incredible international popularity, it has greater capacity to do this than many other forms of media.   
 AUDIO 6
 The consequences of sexual objectification are well-documented. Internalized objectification can increase women's anxiety about their own physical appearance, reduce opportunities for peak motivational states or flow, diminish awareness of internal bodily sensation such as hunger, sexual arousal and stomach contractions, increase body shame, increase anxiety about physical safety such as fears of sexual assault, which in turn can lead to depression. Video game designers have not done much to course correct as the statistics show, but there has been a mild amount of effort. The problem is that when this mild effort appears, reactionaries become upset and demand a return to the previous status quo. The outrage over the mildest – and I do mean mildest – diminishing of breasts isn't about breasts. There is never going to be a drought of breasts.
 The mild diminishing of breasts, to these reactionaries, is a signal of losing control over the autonomy of women, representative of mild gains in society and mild changes in social norms. These mild gains don't actually threaten to harm anyone but do threaten a traditionalist status quo that some find comforting. Reactionaries believe they are in the moral right by preserving a status quo that feels correct to them. They want to be socially and morally correct, and by enforcing depictions of women – even virtual women -- they can achieve this. A lot of misogynistic behavior is directed toward women who violate social norms and expectations or who aren't serving male interests in the ways in which they are expected by this status quo. If men, for example, believe expectations of a woman are to be attractive to them, then any deviation feels like a violation of what they perceive as the correct, morally upright status quo. If the status quo is violated, even by something as simple as slightly smaller breasts in a video game, this is seen as morally incorrect. Reactionary gamers are not angry that they can't as effectively masturbate to a Final Fantasy character, as comical as that might be.
 AUDIO 7
 The status quo of men having greater roles in the hierarchy has advantaged themselves for a long time. Their anecdotal experience of the status quo is that of it being “correct” because anecdotal experience only tells them how social norms affect themselves. They have been unfairly advantaged, but all they see is “social norm = good for me = good for everyone!” It's all they need to dismiss the experiences of others. Reactionaries don't frame their beliefs this way and instead frame them through a smokescreen of seemingly more reasonable arguments that they either know are false and are therefore arguing in bad faith or mistakenly believe as their true reason for their reactionary politics. One argument they make is that when a character in a video game is a woman or a person of color or not straight, the studio is doing this purely for marketing reasons or political reasons and not for artistic reasons. This ignores the fact that making their character a man or white or straight is also a product of marketing or politics. Reactionaries often display an argument that amounts to this. There is man, and there is political. There is white, and there is political. There is straight, and there is political.   
 This is a product of entrenched belief in the status quo in which white straight men are a default or normal and that any deviation that is chosen is therefore suspicious. Regardless of intention, it's possible for positive, real world consequences to marketing decisions just as it's possible for negative, real world consequences to marketing decisions. The argument that a slight diminishing of breasts and other small changes to the aesthetic of video games are insidious specifically because they are corporate decisions ignores the fact that previous decisions that made the breasts larger were also corporate decisions. At best, it cancels out this argument, and at worst, it reveals that the argument is probably being made in bad faith. Reactionaries who denounce these aesthetic changes purely on the basis that they are based in marketing look the other way when marketing benefits themselves. It's only bad...if it's not for themselves. Defenders of sexual objectification of women in gaming are quick to point to outliers in which men are depicted as sexy, but again, these exceptions only reinforce the pattern.   
 AUDIO 8
 To give you some idea about the unbalanced power dynamic, the closest mirror to this – meaning outrage about a male video game character's body not being allegedly sexy enough – was a joke or meme about Solid Snake's butt no longer being as well-defined on a Nintendo Switch game. There are three key differences here. One: nobody was actually angry but more like performing anger as a joke, one that quickly went away within 48 hours. Two: this joke does not fit a pattern. Even if it were sincere, which it was not, it would be an outlier and thus an isolated incident. And three, it is contextually different because men have historically tried to control women's bodies in a myriad of different ways – particularly in media – whereas women do not have that institutional power in society. There is no institutional power for women controlling men's bodies whereas historically there is institutional power for the opposite. Once again for the people in the back, an exception does not disprove a statistical pattern, and both the context and power dynamics are completely different. [PART 3: Censorship] The other smokescreen argument is a cry of censorship.  
 Censorship is the suppression of an idea or image by a force more powerful than its target. If a company creates a video game character design, a more powerful entity than said company is not manipulating them to do so. There is no cabal of super billion-dollar companies secretly forcing regular billion-dollar companies to treat portrayals of women with respect. The state also is not forcing these portrayals. Any artistic or marketing decision removes from existence some version that would otherwise have existed, but that would also be true if the artists who made these decisions chose to portray women as sex objects. Portraying women as sex objects also removes from existence some version that would otherwise have existed – in this case, women portrayed NOT as sex objects. The argument from censorship falls apart not only because it's conspiratorial and without evidence but also because artistic decisions necessitate exclusions. If I painted a mountain blue, that does not mean I have “censored” purple. If I colored it purple, that does not mean I have censored blue.   
 AUDIO 9
 One might argue that there is still a whiff of censorship if the decision is “political,” but as previously mentioned, it would be just as “political” if the artist chose to portray a woman as a sex object. A social norm is not apolitical simply because it is a social norm. It only feels that way due to your own familiarity with it. Would you like to hear an example of censorship within the video games that more closely aligns with both the definition and spirit of the word? Months ago, a Taiwanese horror game called Devotion was released on Steam before quickly being pulled from sale. Red Candle Games, the developer, was speculated to have done so to remove a poster that mocks Chinese president Xi Jinping. The game never returned. The game's publishers, Indievent amd Winking Entertainment completely abandoned the title and terminated their contracts for console versions of Devotion. The Chinese government revoked Indievent's business license within the country, citing that Indievent violated “relevant laws.” Whether or not this counts as “video game censorship” is open to your interpretation, but this example is much closer to the definition than, say, women wearing more realistic outfits that are functional for combat.
 China intervening in the sale of a game is the suppression of an idea or image by a force more powerful than the entity that is being oppressed. China is a world superpower and Indievent is a somewhat obscure game company. The unbalanced power dynamic is there. A game company designing a woman character has no unbalanced power dynamic because the decisions begin and end within the company. An artist or company making a decision you don't approve of is not inherently censorship no matter how much you disagree with the decision. Bear in mind that censorship does NOT need to be “state censorship” in order to be censorship, but it does need to be mandatory or involve unbalanced power dynamics. This means censorship requires a force or law or entity with more authority or more power than the entity being censored. The example with China and the game company fits that criteria. The example with Tifa does not because nobody with more authority than Square-Enix is making them do this. Furthermore, it is striking that women being portrayed less as sex objects is compared to the design of a secret conspiracy because it exposes reactionaries' true feelings.
 AUDIO 10
 If the issue is not women's bodies, as they claim, but that decisions about women's bodies are being made by a diabolical cabal, why would the diabolical cabal want to do something positive for women?   If they answer that they don't know, the argument falls apart, and if they answer that the consequences are actually bad and not who is making the decisions, then the veneer of this being about anything other than controlling women's bodies is lifted completely. Describing women having more autonomy over depictions of their bodies as the consequence of a terrible censorship conspiracy exposes what reactionaries really think about women having more autonomy over depictions of their bodies. Congratulations, you played yourself. It's also ludicrous. It shows a complete misunderstanding about institutional power in our society, particularly as it relates to capital. Billionaire-dollar companies are not controlled by media critics on YouTube. The rich have significantly more institutional power than the rest of us. I don't want to give the impression that I'm defending billionaires, only explaining that the power dynamics make some of these arguments faulty.   
 Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk are privatizing space travel like they're Weyland and Yutani respectively, and there's nothing that the people you pejoratively call “social justice warriors” can do about it, let alone the rest of society. So. Let's sum up. The outrage is about control of the depictions of women that reinforce the reactionaries' vision of what they want to be the status quo. It cannot simply be about wanting to see breasts because there is no shortage of breasts and there never will be, and it cannot be about censorship in the abstract as no corporation is being forced or coerced by powers greater than themselves on how to design their women characters. It's a classic culture war. Simply put, the pattern of outrage has its roots in reactionary politics and a mistaken belief in a status quo that only benefits some is beneficial to all. Thanks for listening.   


LATE STAGE DISNEY

 AUDIO 1 So unless you’ve been living under a rock on Mars with your eyes closed and your fingers in your ears you probably already know that from 1989 through 1999, Disney’s animation output is considered the Renaissance. After a lackluster period often called the Dark Ages, Walt Disney Animation Studios got their act together and started creating feature films that were critical and commercial successes again. We generally name eras after the fact once we have better perspective of what it actually accomplished or how good or bad it was. Maybe it’s premature to give the new Disney live action movies a name since Disney has not, but I feel like I need to anyway – otherwise it’s going to sound very clumsy and we just can’t have that. Superficially, the only thing these movies have in common is that they're part of an internal initiative to resurrect old Disney properties. The recent Disney live action movies are mostly remakes but they are also prequels or sequels or a bit of both depending on the movie. Pete's Dragon is a live action remake of another mostly live action movie, and The Lion King is hardly live action at all. So we can’t just call them the “Disney live action remakes” because some don't fit that criteria for one reason or another. If we have to call the good Disney movies from the late 80s and 90s the Renaissance and the bad Disney movies from earlier the Dark Age then I have decided all on my own and with no input from anyone else to call this swath of movies late-stage Disney. The Late Stage Disney live action remakes, sequels and prequels do not technically have an official series name but are very much part of the same marketing initiative. We’ll make it a hashtag. Who can stop me? So, besides the superficial, what do these movies have in common? Well. The late-stage Disney movies contain deeply disingenuous themes and a pale imitation of post-modernism that only jokingly mocks its own canon and deconstructs not to criticize but to defend itself from criticism of its own place in late stage capitalism. [PART 1: Late Stage Capitalism] Late-stage capitalism or late capitalism for kind of short is a stage in which capital becomes so dominant that everything is commodified. Commodification is the transformation of goods, services and ideas into objects of trade. That sounds super basic, but in late-stage capitalism, everything is up for commodification including things that need not be commodified like, say, water and people.   AUDIO 2 An oversimplication of the stages of capitalism – meaning private ownership of the means of production -- is that from around 1700 to 1870, we had a “free competition capitalism” stage in which we saw explosive growth of industrial capital in domestic markets. 1870 through the beginning of World War II was a “monopoly capitalism” stage characterized by neo-imperialism and exploitation of colonies. Late-stage capitalism is where we are today, post-World War II, characterized by growing multinational corporations and mass consumption. This simplification, however, ignores the fact that exploitation of other countries by more powerful countries still happens, and “monopoly” capitalism is still rearing its head. Disney, for example, due to recent purchases of Marvel, Lucasfilm, 20th Century Fox and Hulu now owns significantly more of the market share than the number two and three competitors. Market share represents the percentage of an industry, or a market's total sales, that is earned by a particular company over a specified time period. Market share is calculated by taking the company's sales over the period and dividing it by the total sales of the industry over the same period. This metric is used to give a general idea of the size of a company in relation to its market and its competitors. Disney's recent acquisitions and aggressive moves in the theater industry have given it an approximate 40% of the market share. Detractors would say this is not technically a “monopoly,” but this percentage does give Disney significantly more power in its various endeavors than its competitors. Capitalists defend this as a fair outcome of “competition” in the market, but capitalism inevitable moves toward either monopoly or growth that allows mega-corporations to have greater and greater control over our lives. Late-stage capitalism is also called that because capitalism is not sustainable forever and it’s only a matter of time before humanity is forced into creating a different economic system. Capitalism, through mass media, gives us the impression that there can't be anything but the current economic stage in which we live. Capitalism reinforces itself through media, through consumption, through everything in our daily lives. It hypnotizes us into thinking this is the only way. But if past is prologue, capitalism can't last. AUDIO 3 Before capitalism, there was feudalism, before feudalism, economics were held together through slavery, before that, there was something else, and so forth. Late-stage capitalism has also become the kind of go to catch phrase for explaining absurdities related to capital like Budweiser spending $5 million to advertise how it donated only $100,000 to clean water or how Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos has enough money to theoretically buy every homeless American a house and still have $19.2 billion left over. He definitely will not be doing that. Late-stage capitalism is the end result of capitalism: the final consolidation of power through capital. Late-stage capitalism as a term is also used to describe the bottomless abyss of creative bankruptcy mixed with paradoxical customer loyalty from emerging mega-corporations like Apple or Disney. Disney owns us as customers and can give us any old thing, and so long as it’s Disney, the lines to buy it or see it will wrap around the corner. Enter: late-stage Disney. A series of live action movies that bank on us having heard of the license or product before in order to see it and regardless of quality will almost certainly earn a profit, which will allow Disney to buy more properties and even more of the market share.   Disney owns that Simpson’s reference from a couple minutes ago, please don’t Content ID me, Disney. This will continue until they become the mega-corporation that previously only existed in science fiction but predicted by economists for the better part of a century. And what are we sacrificing ourselves unto the altar of capitalism for? What is so precious that we are enabling monopolies? A bunch of movies that run the gamut of very bad, mostly bad, forgettable, passable and Aladdin. I can’t blame the rise of Disney and late-stage capitalism on these live action movies, of course. Disney is a symptom more than a driving force. This is systemic. Also, even if it were not, Disney's Marvel Cinematic Universe and Star Wars movies are bigger earners. Late Stage live action Disney is simply a better example of late-stage capitalism and a better vision of what life is going to be like unless we can change the world for the better and not the worse following the end of this economic system. You know, bad and flavorless and de-humanizing.    AUDIO 4 [Part 2: I Blame Tim Burton] Like most things in life, this is Tim Burton’s fault. In 2010, Timmy Scissorhands released the live action remake of Alice in Wonderland, a tired slog of an adventure through Burton’s now empty imagination. It was around this time that we all collectively began to realize that Burton was nowhere as subversive as we once thought. His earlier films mocked yuppie culture and pretentious upper class whites but with no real interest in examining the systems that supported said culture. In Pee-Wee's Big Adventure and Beetlejuice, the victims of upper class whites were simply mildly less well-to-do whites, their positions in life widely unquestioned and the damage they do to other characters being the products of personality quirks rather than systemic disparity. Authority figures are just as often endearing as they are dangerous, perhaps more so. Burton's Alice has some of its own trappings. Put a pin in that, we will return to it. Later that year, Disney released The Sorcerer’s Apprentice, extremely loosely based on the only scene from Fantasia that everyone remembers.   There had been Disney live action remakes before, but they were few and far between. Burton's Wonderland spawned not only a sequel but a big push for a series of unrelated but brand-connected movies at least once a year and eventually multiple times a year. This became late-stage Disney, a recycling of old properties rather than risking their stake in the market share with new ideas. Nearly every late stage Disney movie deconstructs previous Disney canon, Disney mythos or even Walt Disney himself and the corporation he founded. Unfortunately for anyone expecting honest introspection and genuine deconstruction of some Disney’s most egregious actions or failures, the late stage Disney movies instead only playfully mock its own shortcomings, becoming less of a critique of itself and more a like a roast: a humorous recognition of shortcomings with the goal of praising rather than critiquing.   AUDIO 5 This sneaks into animated Disney pictures, too. [Moana] But we see this more consistently in regurgitated live action late stage Disney. Did I expect Disney to genuinely critique itself? No. It is not in the interest of capitalists to sincerely criticize capitalism or other hierarchical structures that support capitalism. I’m not surprised, I’m only explaining what Disney is doing and why. [PART 3: What Is Disney Doing and Why?] Disney is “deconstructing” and “modernizing” its mythos by taking the safest possible political position, presenting it as “woke” and deflecting criticism about its role in both the economic and cultural landscapes. It's a charm offensive in the era of growing interest in socialism among young people and growing knowledge of what mega-corporations are actually selling us. Late Stage Disney is fake wokeness, a flimsy attempt at recuperation of radical politics by capitalism. Example: In Burton's Alice in Wonderland, Alice is faced with a system in which choices are made for her and she needs to marry a man. And then she goes to Wonderland where a different system has also made a choice for her. A literal prophecy in Wonderland that puts her in great danger and a deeply uncomfortable social expectation in the normal world. The fact that the system that forces her to take on the Red Queen gives her some armor and a sword doesn't mean she has more choices, only a different choice. It's the most superficial reading of what “feminism” is that has been put to screen in recent years. Beauty and the Beast has a scene in which Belle is teaching a young girl how to read. A townsperson, the living embodiment of the patriarchy, finger-wags at her, even though women's literacy was not uncommon during the time period of the film. Late Stage Beauty and the Beast is perhaps even less “woke” than the animated film because it portrays the ignorant and dangerous townspeople are merely misunderstood and under a spell. This is a gross mischaracterization. The original showed how “othering” and a charismatic leader can lead to de-humanization and violence. Claiming the small, mean-spirited, easily-led townspeople are only misunderstood is a terrible reading of the room in 2017, the year this was released. Essentially, Alice in Wonderland, Beauty and the Beast and other late stage Disney products contain the “safe” version of feminism – first wave feminism, paraphrased by men as “Well, women shouldn't be...property, I guess. They can vote – sometimes.” A feminism that is only as “woke” as the 1920's.   AUDIO 6 Late Stage Disney won't tackle socialist feminism, the recognition that patriarchy and capitalism are interconnected and that unequal hierarchies feed or are supported by other unequal hierarchies. Again, it's not in the interest of capitalists to sincerely criticize hierarchical structures that support capitalism. By giving Belle a scene in which a caricature of a misogynist condemns her for knowing how to read, Disney can pretend that it's deconstructing its previous, more passive women protagonists from the 1930's through the 1950's while actually only advocating for a feminism that was popular prior to the 1930's. Its politics are not even contemporaneous with the era in which it's allegedly deconstructing. Similarly, Late Stage Beauty and the Beast allegedly featured the first “openly gay” Disney character, and you can no doubt sense those scare quotes around “openly” because all that happened was Le Fou danced with a man for two seconds. Le Fou's “gay moment” is so not gay that the scene wasn't even censored in Russia or China, two huge socially conservative markets for Disney. Beauty and the Beast made Disney an extra $14 million from Russian audiences and $85 million from Chinese audiences.   Beauty and the Beast is not “woke” for having a character who is never even confirmed as gay in 2017. Two men dancing together in a film from 2017 is not progressive. Here is a short film of two men dancing together from 1895. Disney capitalized on the minor uproar about its alleged “wokeness” and received a lot of free press for its film. That's it. Disney's defense from criticism that it historically and contemporaneously reinforces status quo gender roles and status quo heteronormativity was to have a movie with gender politics that conform to the feminism of one hundred years ago and sexuality that was depicted in the late 19th century. [PART 4: The Friendly Millionaires and Billionaires] The most notable pro-capitalism message that flows through late-stage Disney is that of the friendly millionaire. Capitalists love telling us that there is a difference between capitalism and greed, but capitalism is a system that explicitly rewards greed and does not reward much of anything else. Disparity between the rich and poor under capitalism is not a bug, it's the system functioning as it was designed to. That's not cynicism, that's just literally what a hierarchical system does. And it's actually getting worse over time.    AUDIO 7  The idea that capitalism, the economic system that dominates the world, makes us all rich or even content and able to pay the bills is a fairy tale worthy of Disney. Speaking of which, let's get back to those friendly millionaires and billionaires. Mary Poppins returns is the story of a family facing sudden economic hardship. The bank is not helping them, they're gonna lose the house, and the children are understandably distraught. Mary Poppins sings a series of songs about the joys of being happy, Jack the Cockney lamplighter dances the blues away, and that is, apparently, the best advice available to privileged people with brief economic concerns that will eventually be handled with minimal trouble. Mary Poppins Returns does not portray the bank – a physical stand-in for the system of capitalism – as the antagonist. No. Only...some people...who work at the bank. The family is visited by two men – one kind and one unkind – who deliver the bad financial news. Then the family encounters a greedy millionaire and a friendly millionaire! The greedy millionaire wants all that money, but the friendly millionaire wins in the end and saves the family! This happens in Christopher Robin as well.  Christopher has an antagonistic relationship with Winslow Jr. – the bad capitalist – but he is saved by Winslow Sr. – the good capitalist. The friendly millionaire. Capitalism isn't the problem, no sir. Only “greedy” capitalists, a few bad apples, not the system. Perish the thought! That is how movies like these frame capitalism: essentially good for everyone and any issues within the system can be explained away by a handful of ne'er-do-wells. Mary Poppins Returns and Christopher Robin individualize hardship under capitalism. One last time: It is not in the interest of capitalists to sincerely criticize capitalism. By framing capitalism this way, Disney skirts around the issue of capitalism itself being the problem. Don't think about it too hard, everyone! Just watch Dick Van Dyke dance on the table! Pay no attention to the capitalism behind the curtain! Watch him dance. WATCH HIM DANCE. [PART 5: Dumbo? More like...Dum...fuck this movie] So, earlier this year, the remake of Dumbo hit the theaters, courtesy of Tim Burton. Ah, we've come full...something, haven't we? Even Dumbo, a movie with clear references to Disneyland, is not an indictment of The Walt Disney Company, Walt Disney himself or capitalism. The film's antagonist, V.A. Vandavere, is not some much a Disney stand-in as a “What if?”    
  AUDIO 8 What if, the movie asks, Walt Disney had NOT been a charming, friendly billionaire? What if good ol' Uncle Walt had been replaced by this P.T. Barnum figure? Dumbo does not condemn Walt Disney. Dumbo replaces Walt Disney with a figure that does not resemble the mythological Walt Disney that the Disney Company has long sold us. This is not Burton lashing out against Disney. If it were, Disney would never release it, and it doesn't fit with Burton's politics. Matthew Dessem of Slate wrote: “The answer is that we’re not meant to reconcile it as much as we’re meant to forgive it. The Vandevere subplot in Dumbo is not a sincere critique of the business practices of the Walt Disney Company—how could it be?—nor does it have anything much to say about art under capitalism, or even Tim Burton’s feelings about his once and future employer. The climactic sequence, in which the recently fired members of DeVito’s circus steal Dumbo and his mother from Vandevere, sort of works as a metaphor for Burton returning to Disney to rescue Frankenweenie and Jack Skellington, except that Burton didn’t steal them back: Disney paid him money to try to make the company more money from ideas it didn’t think it could make any money from back in the 1980s.   The nudges and winks in Dumbo about Disney’s predatory practices are an invitation from filmmaker to audience to share a knowing chuckle over the essential soullessness of the entire enterprise.” That's a good way to describe Disney's self-reflection. Not true deconstruction but only a knowing chuckle. Furthermore, Vandavere's Disneyland-ish theme park is still presented as amazing and fun and a trip that your family should take right now! It's only Vandavere himself that's the problem, and once he's out of the picture, all is well. Because capitalism, the movie tells us, is not the problem. It's never the system. It's always...some individual. Everyone else within the system is good and pure. You know...like Walt Disney! I was joking about this being Tim Burton's fault, to be clear. This is systemic, not individual. The aforementioned explosion of income inequality, repeated cycles of boom and bust and capitalism’s disastrous contributions to climate change has led economists and political scientists to begin to seriously consider how a post-capitalist society would look and function. But it needs to happen sooner rather than later. Climate change is not going to give us a lot of time, and people currently living in extreme poverty don't have fifty years for capitalists to have a “come to Jesus” moment. Don't expect Disney to inspire people to fight capitalism either. They're not “woke” and that word has lost all meaning anyway. I bet the new Lion King doubles down on the original's “watch out for those dirty poors” messaging. [long, gagging sigh] 


SHE-RA

 I'm not going to waste much time pushing back against the reactionaries who dismissed She-Ra and the Princesses of Power sight unseen. If you want to know the real reason why some men declared a teenage character in a children's cartoon “not sexy enough,” you can watch my recent video on reactionary politics and why challenges to the status quo is frightening to those who benefit from said status quo.   
 I don't care about that today. I want to make a more positive video for a change. I just want to talk about why the new She-Ra series on Netflix is good, actually. That's my whole thesis. I don't give a fuck. Let's begin. Quite possibly the worst argument about children's entertainment is “It doesn't have to be good, it's for kids” when describing a bad children's movie or television show. It's extremely callous. You wouldn't say that about food or water or clothes or anything people need or want. If anything, children's entertainment needs to be high quality and teach excellent values because children are even more susceptible to internalizing the values of the media they consume. Media influences the way we view the world because our individual, anecdotal experiences with other people and especially those different from us are limited exclusively to ourselves and our limited interactions, travels, friendships and other relationships. I want to focus on the values that the series teaches children rather than simply talking about how I love all the characters and how I wish Sea Hawk were my best friend. So, what values does She-Ra and the Princesses of Power teach?   
 Children's entertainment is not written by children, it's written by adults, many of whom are parents. That means it's no surprise that children's entertainment often contains themes of making peace with one's parents. Max in A Goofy Movie is deeply concerned that he will one day turn into a father, a man with whom he has almost nothing in common, but the movie makes the case that these two should have an unshakable relationship anyway and that – somehow – the onus might be on Max to make that extra effort in the end even though he is a child. Other entertainment not specifically for children but certainly enjoyed by children, like superhero movies, portray distant parents as people who still – deep down – love their children no matter how abusive they might otherwise be. She-Ra says “no” to all that and instead depicts two separate mother-daughter relationships that teach children the difference between a good parent and a bad parent. Glimmer's mother, Queen Angella, is protective of her daughter, something that bothers Glimmer. But Angella is also willing to give Glimmer responsibilities and allows her a great deal of independence, especially by season two.   
 Queen Angella is a good mother. She is strict when necessary, appropriately concerned and proud of her daughter's accomplishments. Glimmer and her mother don't always get along, but their arguments are common in the give-and-take between mothers and daughters. The relationship shows children that their parents may occasionally get on your nerves, but so long as they ultimately treat you with respect, the relationship may be worth maintaining into adulthood. She-Ra and Catra's adoptive mother of sorts is Shadow Weaver, an abusive parent who shows clear and open favoritism toward one child over another, lies to them both about the world and generally cannot be trusted. By contrasting a good mother-daughter relationship with a bad relationship, the series educates children on whether their parents are just the regular kind of annoying or if they are actually dangerous. Children don't need to be told that their abusive parents really do love them. They need to be told the truth. Season one of She-Ra introduced us to Netossa and Spinerella, an openly same-sex couple that admittedly did not get a lot of screen time. Season two introduced us to Bow's fathers.   
 Bow spent much of the episode concealing the fact that he had joined the resistance against the Evil Horde but finally “came out” to his parents about this aspect of his life, an obvious but heartfelt reference to coming out of the closet. The accusation that characters being gay is too “adult” for children and that characters being straight is not too adult exposes the homophobia of the argument and that of whoever is making the argument – a lingering suspicion about anyone who is not straight somehow being inherently deviant, dirty or dangerous. The canard of “I don't hate gay people, but children shouldn't see anything but straight people...” usually trails off at the end before the speaker can finish their thought about why. Furthermore, someone being gay is not somehow more difficult to explain to children than someone being straight. The idea that children would be “confused” by two dads or two moms in a television show only suggests that whoever is making this argument is purposefully shielding their children from the very existence of anything outside heteronormativity, which can obviously lead to long-lasting ignorance as they grew up. Lying to children by omission is not protecting them from being “confused” – it is, in fact, confusing them about who people really are.
 If you want a more comprehensive explanation about the importance of LGBT representation in media aimed at young people, there are resources in the description, but I would like to think that we're all smart and humane enough to understand the need for providing comfort and reassurance to vulnerable children. The series provides characters for straight youths to better understand and sympathize with queer youths. It also provides comfort for queer youths themselves who want to see themselves represented in media so they can feel less alone. Young gay, bisexual and trans people face certain obstacles that young straight and cisgender people do not. The series offers support and comfort to LGBT youngsters, particularly those who receive no such support and comfort from their parents. So, there's this character in the series called Swift Wind: a talking pegasus who is the most politically radical character in a show in which all good guy characters are fighting in a literal resistance movement. Swift Wind wants to dismantle “unjust hierarchies” which, in case you didn't know, is a very left-anarchist thing to say and do.
 
 Swift Wind, unlike the other characters like Adora, Glimmer and Bow, is not only trying to take down the Horde but is also unsatisfied with the marginal social progress for his own people and is unwilling to simply put his concerns aside in the face of a monarchy that is ostensibly on his side. Children's media is full of evil empires and media that is not explicitly for children but widely enjoyed by children like Star Wars has this common conflict as well. Star Wars doesn't tell us a lot about the explicit politics of the bad guys and the good guys – it only informs us through visual shorthand which real world entities we are meant to associate with the fictional entities of the films. Swift Wind's overt politics still skirt around naming exactly where he is on the political compass, but it still somehow makes more of an effort than Star Wars. She-Ra doesn't have to show Comrade Swift Wind reading The Conquest of Bread, but explaining what he and the princesses hope to accomplish beyond “beating the bad guys” is still far beyond most children's entertainment. So, why does that matter? Well, it's a good thing because...everyone thinks they're the Rebels, right? No matter your political persuasion, everyone thinks they're the Rebels and that their enemies are the Empire.
 A character in a children's television show actually stating that he opposes unjust hierarchies and believes in an egalitarian society – presumably one that doesn't have to be ruled by monarchs one day – is a good way to let children think in terms greater than “bad guy bad” and “good guy good.” Speaking of which, allowing the bad guy characters to have personalities and relationships might help teach children empathy. I really hope that the kids growing up She-Ra and Steven Universe and the like will internalize these good values. Obviously children need a lot more than just the right media to grow up to be good and decent human beings, but it is...a component to who we become. Kids could do a lot worse than She-Ra and the Princesses of Power. 

Comments

No comments found for this post.