Update and scripts! (Patreon)
Content
In case you didn't see, the SNL/Neoliberalism video debuted a few days ago. I have so much planned for the rest of the year and next year, but there won't be a Patreon goal to get there. I'm just gonna do it. I'm gonna do all the things. All the time. That's the plan.
Some bonus material about summer movies is coming soon for patrons at the behind-the-scenes video tier.
With those updates out of the way, here are the recent episode scripts.
THE COOL POPE
AUDIO 1
Hey, duuudes. Have you heard about the new, cool Pope? Oh, yeah! For the past several years, the Cool Pope has been telling everyone that space aliens might visit Earth and might be baptized Catholic. And that maybe even those naughty atheists could have a shot at going to Heaven! Oh, that Pope Francis. You gotta love him, I mean, unless you're one of the people still affected by the child abuse scandals that he allegedly covered up or if you have any wits about you and noticed that this is only a charm offensive that distracts from the continuation of deeply socially conservative Church doctrine that affects 1.2 billion people worldwide. Oh, Francis. What a cool Pope. [title] The Vatican is waging a charm offensive on the world, spreading misinformation and carefully cultivating an identity for Pope Francis that is an absolute fabrication. The media is more than happy to play along because the Pope being cool is a better story than “business as usual at the Vatican.” Nobody is “surprised” that the Roman Catholic Church is deeply conservative or that the current Pope is deeply conservative. That has been standard operating procedure for centuries.
The problem is that through this charm offensive, some have swallowed a completely different, false narrative – and it's exactly what the Vatican wanted. A charm offensive is propaganda about the small, inconsequential positives of an organization or state to distract the media and the people from the negatives. A charm offensive is also announcements of small, inconsequential concessions or reforms designed to distract the media and the people from the fact that no meaningful reforms are forthcoming. A charm offensive uses inclusive language while maintaining exclusive policy. Let's back up a bit. Men who wish to be protected by institutional power often choose lives in which the power of men, the authority of their words and their position are unquestioned. For example, men with anger issues, racist attitudes and the desire to feel powerful sometimes flock to law enforcement, a system that allows them that outlet and will almost certainly protect them should they be accused of misdeeds. A system that protects their authority figures over the people who the authority figures themselves are meant to protect – meaning civilians – is appealing to people who wish to feel powerful.
AUDIO 2
Similarly, the Catholic Church provides cover for men with a system in which institutional power is granted exclusively to men combined with the unquestioned authority of God. A system that historically protects the misdeeds of powerful men is a safe haven for men seeking to commit these acts with impunity. In the early 16th century, Dutch scholar and weird, half-smiler Erasmus noted that the faithful “often fall into the hands of priests who, under the pretense of confession, commit acts which are not fit to be mentioned.” The suspicion that priests abused their congregations – particularly young women – was common in the late Middle Ages. During the Reformation, this talking point was common among Protestant critics of the Catholic Church. It may have come across like propaganda at the time – very Fox News “all my enemies are pedophiles” – but the truth is, in cities of that time, confession was among the few acceptable occasions for respectable women to meet unsupervised with men outside their families. These confidential encounters gave the opportunity for abuse, and due to the unquestioned authority of the Church, the abusers could easily be protected.
This directly lead to the invention of the confessional – including a partition between the priest and confessor which disallowed improper touching. The confessional was not an invention for privacy, it was an invention to help the image of the Church during a time in which rumors began to spread about abuse. If you have ever been in a confessional, you are basically in an enclosure that has the same function as a chastity belt. In modern times, we were reintroduced to Church abuses through reports in the mid-1980's and have continued to this day. Movies like Spotlight show brave reporters taking down a ring of priestly pedophiles, but this only individualizes the problem. It's systemic, not a matter of a few bad apples. Men feel safe becoming priests or feel safe after they become priests, and this empowers them to act on their worst impulses. There is research that suggests that Catholic priests, as a whole, do not abuse children at a rate that is remarkably higher than average, but even if that is completely accurate, priests still have more protection than the average person. The problem isn't just numbers and rates of abuse – the problem is institutional power and protection. And this protection allows the abuse to continue rather than be stopped the way it otherwise could among the secular population.
AUDIO 3
The Vatican even admits this, as the vast majority of priests and bishops who the Church itself determined were sexual abusers were allowed to remain in the priesthood. They were NOT defrocked, meaning removed from their status as priests. Instead, the vast majority were given lesser sanctions and continued to be priests, protected by the Church. These statistics were revealed during the papacy of Pope Francis. Global membership in the Church has held steady for decades, but that is primarily due to growth in Africa making up for massive declines roughly everywhere else. So, what to do? In 2013, Pope Benedict stepped down, publicly for health concerns. Although it's now 2019, and he's still kicking around, so whatever. A new Pope was chosen and took the name Francis. The Vatican needed to whitewash the history of the Church and restore their public image.
Thus the charm offensive began. Pope Francis began showing compassion towards aliens – a group marginalized for far too long! He used slightly less inflammatory language about the LGBT community, even though he still disapproved of homosexuality. Put a pin in that. More on that later. The media was so willing to believe in this propaganda due to the traffic it could draw to their news outlets. News media functions through the framework of capitalism in which the highest consideration related to a story is that of competition. The increasingly competitive market has had some troubling side effects. News media sometimes posts mistranslations of Pope Francis that present him saying something more progressive and/or inflammatory than he actually said or post “urban legends” as fact, such as the one about Pope Francis disguising himself as a common priest, sneaking out of the Vatican and feeding the poor at night. This turned out to be completely false. Even the Vatican denied this one. Pope Francis apologized for “past” misdeeds by the Church but continued a system that made such misdeeds possible in the future. Remember, part of a charm offensive is using the right words – new language -- but continuing the same policies and systems. Not long ago, Carlo Maria Vigano, the former senior Vatican diplomat to the United States, claimed that Pope Francis knew for years that Cardinal Theodore McCarrick was a sexual abuser.
AUDIO 4
Pope Francis did nothing for years. The problem with abuse in the Catholic Church goes beyond altar boys. Nuns have recently come forward with their own stories of abuse. Jason Horowitz of The New York Times said of this: “Many members of the church, experts said, suffer from a medieval mind-set and consider the priests who commit abuse against nuns to be the victims of seductive temptresses. Since the victims in these cases are adults, the experts say, there is also a reflexive tendency to blame them. The reductive public image of the nun as existing to serve the priest and to pray quietly also undercuts those who speak up.” Recently, the Pope clarified rules surrounding reporting sexual abuse, but “reporting” is not necessarily the biggest problem. A bigger problem is that of the thousands of priests who abuse children, by the Vatican's own admission, most are NOT defrocked and removed from the Church. Some are, but most are not. Another way to put this is that they're protected by the Church. This has not changed under the papacy of Pope Francis. The Vatican recently admitted that the number of priests worldwide has been in decline. The Vatican is afraid of losing power on the world stage and losing the ability to maintain their churches.
Thus, the Vatican merely admonishes most of the sexual abusers and keeps them in the priesthood rather than risk losing ground to other Christian denominations and other religions. Maintaining the power of the Catholic Church takes priority over the safety of children. Despite his empty apologies, Pope Francis has tried his damndest to project the source of the problem to other factors, recently blaming the Devil himself for these abuses. He has also tried to blame homosexuality, as the Catholic Church often does. [Part 2] Many assume that homosexual men are the cause of the clergy sexual abuse problem in the Catholic Church. While it's true that most victims of clergy abuse are boys, research informs us that these abusers were “situational generalists” victimizing whoever they had access to and trust with. When priests historically had access to young women, the young women were abused, and now with more regular access to boys due to altar servers and such, the abuse has shifted. Sexual orientation is not a risk factor for child sexual victimization. Homosexual men are, by definition, sexually interested in other men, not young children.
AUDIO 5
Blaming homosexuality for clergy abuse in the Catholic Church is not supported by clinical or research data. Pope Francis' language related to the LGBT community is the perfect distillation of how a charm offensive uses inclusive language while maintaining exclusive policies. He once said “They are children of God, they have a right to a family, and such. . .That does not mean I approve of homosexual acts, far from it.” Francis saying gay people are “God's children” is a hollow statement, as Catholics believe we are all God's children. It's standard “hate the sin, not the sinner” line that Catholics and Christians of other denominations use to mask their disapproval and condemnation of homosexuality with a phony, insincere sympathy. Pope Francis, both when he was a Cardinal and now as Pope, opposes same-sex marriage. He not only opposes it through his church but has signaled it should be opposed through governments. He signaled support for government officials like Kim Davis who refused to process marriage licenses for same-sex couples. He blames gay men for his own scandals. He approved a Vatican document on the priesthood which includes a ban on gay men from seminaries and ordination.
Pope Francis' thoughts on transgender people are even more damning, once saying “Let’s think of the nuclear arms, of the possibility to annihilate in a few instants a very high number of human beings. … Let’s think also of genetic manipulation, of the manipulation of life, or of the gender theory, that does not recognize the order of creation.” Even if we might be taking the Pope out of context here, he has more explicitly condemned what he calls “gender theory” as “ideological colonization” and erases transgender identities. On this issue, Pope Francis is basically Catholic Ben Shapiro. Pope Francis says things like “Who am I to judge?” and goes right ahead and judges anyway. You know what? Maybe Catholic Ben Shapiro is too forgiving. Pope Francis is more like everyone's conservative uncle at Thanksgiving who says he has “nothing against gay people” but doesn't believe they should have quite the same rights, doesn't want them in his orbit, doesn't understand what he's talking about and is woefully behind the times. The difference is that the worst your uncle can do is get drunk and say the wrong thing whereas Pope Francis has the ear of over a billion loyal followers. The fact that the press is marveling over how the Pope doesn't explicitly and more openly hate gay people tells us nothing positive about the Pope and only illustrates our rock bottom expectations of the Catholic church.
AUDIO 6
If anything, Pope Francis is even more conservative than your conservative uncle. At least your conservative uncle might stay neutral on whether or not he “approves” of homosexuality. Pope Francis has explicitly stated he disapproves of homosexuality as recently as this year. He's not evolving on the subject. If anything, he's regressing now that he has won over the press and solidified his phony image as the tolerant Pope, the “cool” Pope. Again, Pope Francis uses inclusive language – “God's children” but exclusive policy – disapproving of homosexuality, condemning same-sex marriage, endorsing discrimination when it suits the Catholic Church, and erasing transgender identities. Pope Francis saying that Uganda should not execute gay people should not be seen as a sign that he's a “progressive” Pope. Nobody but the most extreme far right will publicly advocate for the execution of gay people in 2019. The bar is so low for the Catholic Church that Pope Francis can pay lip service to the LGBT community and be seen as an inspiring figure in the media. He has explicitly stated that the is a “conservative” who believes “it is an incongruity to speak of homosexual marriage.” He once went even further, saying “Today there is a world war to destroy marriage.
Today there are ideological colonisations which destroy, not with weapons, but with ideas. Therefore, there is a need to defend ourselves from ideological colonisations.” Defenders of Pope Francis on these issues and other issues often compare his papacy to previous papacies to show that the Catholic Church is making progress, but Pope Francis is NOT somehow remarkably better on these issues than previous Popes. He and the modern Vatican are simply better at the public relations game than they were before. This is out of necessity due to the Church being under fire in recent decades. The language has changed, but the policies, stances and scandals have largely remained the same. [PART 3] The Vatican's charm offensive has programmed these defensive responses. Let's get into some deprogramming and talk about the issues where the media and even politicians claim Pope Francis is somehow a progressive Pope. Donald Trump has been the target of some of Pope Francis' rhetoric, particularly as it relates to the proposed border wall. In the US, our two-party system sometimes fools us into believing in binary political camps or that every statement or belief is partisan. “If Pope Francis criticizes Trump,” some believe, “then he must be part of the left.”
AUDIO 7
Well, no. World leaders of wildly varying political beliefs denounce Trump all the time. From far-right leaders to centrists and neoliberals, Trump is unpopular across the globe. Not only by heads of state and heads of government but by the average citizen, particularly in Europe. It's not a “progressive” stance to criticize a Republican president. In most ways, Pope Francis is as conservative as the man he criticizes. Pope Francis doesn't believe in capital punishment, but this is extremely common in most of the developed world, and it's even becoming common in America, even among conservatives. The other so-called “progressive” stance of Pope Francis is his recognition of climate change, but man-made climate change is settled science virtually everywhere else in the developed world. America has a higher-than-average number of climate change deniers. In other countries, Pope Francis' declaration that man-made climate change is real is like saying the sky is blue. In America, it's seen as partisan or “leftist” as if by simply stating well-understood scientific consensus, Pope Francis is now a far left anarcho-communist. The Vatican's charm offensive works particularly well in America because many garden variety, moderate political positions in some countries are considered radical or leftist in America.
Pope Francis doesn't hang out in the Vatican reading Murray Bookchin and Noam Chomsky. The truth is Pope Francis' politics are made up of boiler plate conservative ideals and some far-right ideals. He, like Popes before him, is adamantly anti-choice. He has no recognition for reproductive rights. He is against legalization of any drugs. He is opposed to the ordination of women. These are the same positions as the previous Pope. You know, the one that had the public image of Emperor Palpatine. Their policies were more similar than they were different, but image – perception – is everything in a charm offensive. Again, it's fascinating that the bar for a pope is so low that taking a handful of positions that are NOT far right is considered radical. The Pope is not only a religious figure – he always wades into politics and this influences the political stances of 1.2 billion Catholics who see the Pope as God's messenger on Earth. The Pope's popularity dropped following the public being reintroduced to the various sex scandals. Pope Francis was polling much higher two years ago than he is now, but that only means we can expect a new wave of propaganda any time now. His public image is an invention of the Vatican and popularized by the media. He's not the cool Pope. He's the new Pope, same as the old Pope.
80's AND 90'S ACTION MOVIES
AUDIO 1
[clip] [I: What is Queer Theory?] Disclaimer: Not everyone will like the use of the term “queer” in this video because it's a reclaimed slur that was previously offensive, but “queer theory” is the academic term and the one that will be used in academic discourse and in this video. Queer theory is a framework for examining movies that removes the “default” gaze of a film – generally masculine heterosexuality – and instead inserts a different lens, in this case a queer lens, in which to view the film from that perspective. This lens can be used to study queer culture, queer relationships, and queer identities. It is NOT a framework to discover which movies are “gay” and which movies are “straight” but more of a framework to discover how sexuality in our culture influences all media.
It can also be used to study how film portrays queer characters and can even be used when there is an absence of queer characters because that may also tell us something about what a culture believes is “appropriate” for a particular piece of media, in this case, 80's and 90's action movies. The point of examining a film through a lens is NOT to uncover a hidden agenda of the director or to discover what the film is secretly “about” – the point is to see a film as the product of the culture that created it. The point of examining a film specifically through a queer lens is to examine the ways in which we think about relationships, sexuality and how pervading ideas like heteronormativity influence media and how that media influences us. Most action movies do not contain explicitly queer text, meaning queer characters or relationships, but said action movies can still be examined as a reflection of a culture's attitudes towards relationships, particularly homosocial relationships. Furthermore, if accidental queer subtext is perceived in a film by a large number of people, it's worth examining why and what people consider “gay” when something is not explicitly gay.
AUDIO 2
Queer theory also examines queer characters as punchlines. 80's and 90's action movies are largely devoid of sympathetic openly gay heroes, and if your reaction to that is “Well, of course they were!” then ha-ha, you have fallen into my trap, because if something is a given in society or a cultural default, then examining why is necessary. In 80's and 90's action movies, queer characters will almost certainly be either antagonists or throwaway characters intended to be the butt of a joke. This has gotten a little better, but the fact that we are about 20 movies deep into the Marvel Cinematic Universe – the biggest action franchise of the 21st century – without a queer lead character tells us how little progress has been made in this particular area.
Queer characters in action movies today are far less likely to be the butts of homophobic jokes but are only marginally more likely to be main characters. My focus on the 80's and 90's today is not to say “Look how far we've come” but more like “Look how not far we've come.” The biggest action films of the 80's and 90's were mostly American productions, and American attitudes towards homosexuals throughout the 80's and at least the first half of the 90's was influenced heavily by the AIDS crisis. The spread of AIDS predominantly among gay men created an atmosphere and attitude about said gay men a combination of sympathy mixed with fear. This cultural influence can be seen in movies in which gay male characters and queer coded characters were not always monsters but were always “the other.” A people “apart” from the default people of the film: almost entirely straight men. Due to the masculine genre conventions, action movies were (and are) dominated by men throughout the cast and especially in the starring roles. Since 80's and 90's action movies are almost exclusively centered on men, queer readings of 80's and 90's action movies are also almost exclusively centered on men. Don't blame me. I didn't cast these movies. So, what are some of the ways that these movies address and avoid homosexuality? Well...
AUDIO 3
[II: No Homo] In the 1991 action movie Showdown in Little Tokyo, two police officers must take down the Iron Claw Yakuza Clan. Chris Kenner, played by chemical engineer, model and former bodyguard to Grace Jones, Dolph Lundgren? Damn, Dolph, what the f***? Sorry, Dolph Lundgren plays Chris Kenner, an American raised in Japan, and Brandon Lee plays Johnny Murata, a Japanese-American who knows nothing about Japanese culture outside of martial arts. Throughout the movie, Chris, the white, blonde-haired, blue-eyed hunk explains Japanese culture to Bruce Lee's Chinese-American son. One might say it was a different time, but we are apparently still doing this s***. Showdown in Little Tokyo features a lot of scantily-clad men, some in a bath house, as well as this exchange. Brandon Lee is absolutely stunned and impressed by Lundgren's package. He admires it, he wants it, who knows? The scene is played for comedy, but it also obviously contains a whiff of homoeroticism. Lest you think either star is gay, the film goes out of its way to dissuade you of such a notion.
Earlier in the film, Johnny Murata and Chris Kenner visit a social club in which naked women are decorated with sushi. Murata loses his composure and is extremely hornt. Kenner even beds a woman right before the big “hey, I kinda like your big penis” line. This provides cover for both characters and, frankly, both actors from accusations of being gay. A “no homo” turned up to 11. Action movies from this era often feature this disavowal, this reassurance to the audience that they're not watching anything gay and therefore not participating in anything gay. The disavowal makes no mention or indication that the male stars of the film might simply be bisexual or pansexual. Their activities in which they perform heteronormativity are enough for the film and for the audience to plant them firmly in the straight category. Heteronormativity is the belief or pervading idea that heterosexuality, based on a concept of binary gender, is the norm or the default sexual orientation due to it being majority. Heteronormativity assumes that sexual relations are most fitting between people of the opposite sex.
AUDIO 4
A heteronormative view of sexuality aligns biological sex with an unwavering gender binary and gender roles. Sex and gender are different but often not to heteronormatists. Heteronormativity is such a pervading idea in so many cultures that one need not have even heard the word or have ever stated such a belief to have bought into it. That's why when men are paired with women in action movies or other movies, the filmmakers are not necessarily doing so due to an edict from an executive producer or studio head to make certain there is a scene that confirms the character's heterosexuality. Rather, the “default” nature of the pervading idea of heteronormativity makes pairing the male lead with the female lead the default idea when writing the story and the default consideration when establishing who the male lead is. Sometimes filmmakers are intentionally “no homo”ing their film, and sometimes it's unintentional due to heteronormativity's pervasiveness, but the end result is the same regardless of intention. Strictly speaking, there are two ways in which action movies of the 80's and 90's perform this disavowal: by showing their male stars to be aggressively straight or explicitly homophobic.
The male lead need not be the one who says anything homophobic, but so long as the homophobia is communicated to the audience, the disavowal locks in. Let's look at a couple examples, both involving Arnold Schwarzeneggar films. In the 1985 film Commando, Schwarzeneggar plays a retired soldier named John Matrix. He raises a daughter alone with no sign of a mother or heterosexual companion. His daughter, played by Baby Alyssa Milano, is kidnapped, and it's up to Matrix to find her. The principle antagonist is this Freddy Mercury lookin' guy wearing this loose crochet vest or yarn mail armor. Matrix befriends a woman, Cindy, but there is absolutely no indication that either character is interested in one another. Cindy even sees Matrix barely wearing a stitch of clothing, and she's never like “Wow, can't wait to see more” or anything, it's all business, and Matrix is 100% not interested. Matrix also tells another one of his obstacles that he “eats Green Berets for breakfast.”
AUDIO 5
When Matrix and principle antagonist Bennett finally hook up, Matrix says "Put a knife in me, look me in the eye, see what's going on in there when you turn it. Let the girl go. It's between you and me. Don't deprive yourself of some pleasure. Come on. Let's party." Then, Bennett says he's going to shoot Matrix between the balls, and Matrix throws a big phallus into Bennett and says he should “blow off” some steam. The credits roll, and we are played out by a song called “We Fight for Love.” Commando is, uh, let me check my notes here, HELLA GAY, but nobody ever talks about that, and it's partly due to the disavowal. Within the first few minutes of the film, Matrix mocks 80's musician Boy George, calling him “Girl George” and “subversive” a word commonly used among authoritarian states to denounce anything against the state's status quo. This strong disavowal is coded in the language of the Cold War as well as authoritarian powers. Predator is a 1987 film in which a rescue team is tricked into a mission by a dishonest former colleague and are subsequently hunted by an alien hunter, the titular predator.
Dutch, played by Schwarzeneggar, and Dillion, played by Carl Weathers, smoke phallic objects and embrace for the manliest of squeezes. The rest of the movie is basically a group of muscly dudes avoided someone on the hunt for men, a being who the ostensibly straight men consider alien. There is only one woman in the entire film, who is mostly silent and none of the men profess any interest in her. Also, this happens. [drink] When Blain dies, Mac takes it especially hard and hesitates as he tells Dutch that Blain was his “friend.” Mac laments Blain's death as if they were lovers. Yet, it is through Blain that Predator performs its disavowal. Early in the film, during a helicopter ride in which Little Richard is playing on the radio, Blain performs heterosexuality by calling everyone else on the team the infamous homophobic slur and then referring to himself as a sexual Tyrannosaurus. Through these disavowals, filmmakers of the 80's and 90's could have it both way: action movies packed with men and their homosocial relationships dripping with sexual tension AND a defense that guards against any accusation of homosexuality against their films or against the mostly straight audiences that enjoy them.
AUDIO 6
[III: Male Gaze and Male Gays] Male gaze is the act of depicting both women and the world at large, in the visual arts from a masculine, heterosexual perspective that presents and represents women through that lens, often as sexual objects for the pleasure of the presumed heterosexual male viewer. This amorphous “dude” audience of movies is seen as a kind of “default” viewer. Even though women are statistically more likely to see a movie than men, the vast majority of movies are directed by men and therefore fall into this default, this presentation of women and the world from heterosexual men. We have consequently been conditioned to see what the camera sees as “male” and “heterosexual” by default. That's not to say that lesbians, bisexual women and pansexual women will get nothing out of a gaze that focuses on attractive women, but the objectification of these women could dilute that desire with a sense of their own objectification. Regardless of who is actually watching the movie, the male gaze forces the audience to identify with the perspective of a straight man. This is especially true for action movies, a genre that people generally associate with men both as audience and as the stars. 80's and 90's action movies do show a great deal of powerful male bodies, but the gaze of these films usually show these bodies as aspirational rather than as overtly sexual – or as often naked – as women's bodies.
And that brings us to...The Danger Zone. Top Gun is a 1986 film in which Maverick, played by Tom Cruise, participates in a series of war games while struggling with his own past and his budding heterosexual relationship. Top Gun is famously depicted in the film discourse as a covertly gay film. These two men talk about their briefing giving themselves hard-ons, an authority figure shouting that he wants some butts, the way Iceman, played by Val Kilmer looks at Maverick and so forth. There is definitely something there, regardless of intent. Although, for a famously gay 80's, it's also aggressively straight, as the entire Navy serenades one woman, and she somehow goes for it. What's fascinating about the gay discourse on this movie is how the volleyball scene – set to the tune of “Playing with the Boys” – is interpreted as explicitly gay. Why is a scene of men playing volleyball seen as gay and homoerotic whereas women in a similar state of undress are NOT seen as lesbians or serving a lesbian audience? It all has to do with the aforementioned male gaze. If men are decided to be the default for who is watching the movie and the default of the camera, then these men are therefore performing for other men.
AUDIO 7
We also don't see this from the perspective of anyone watching the volleyball game. The camera is the only perspective. Because of the male gaze of a default masculine audience, the assumption is that even though we don't see any characters looking at these men in the movie, it is men who are looking at them. The male gaze designates these men as for other men in the audience. If everyone is for the men, then these men are also for the men. The presumed masculine audience. Let's contrast with a different example: the 1991 film Terminator 2: Judgment Day. In this iconic scene, the Terminator enters a biker bar – fully nude. He shows far more skin than anyone in the Top Gun scene, but nobody calls out this scene for being “gay” or mocks it for that reason. Why is this? Well, two reasons. One is that the Terminator – though without an explicit sexuality – performs a violent aggression towards the bikers that is coded as straight.
Homophobia, heteronormativity, and ignorance about homosexuality mistakenly conflate traditional male attributes like aggression with heterosexuality. But there's another reason, and it has to do with the framing of the scene. The camera in the Top Gun scene is not the perspective of any one character. It's “our” perspective – the audience's perspective that we have been conditioned to believe is masculine. The camera in the Terminator 2 scene is the point-of-view of the Terminator. Everyone is looking at us – we are the Terminator's POV. We're not looking at the naked man. The naked man...is us. Everyone is looking at us, and every time we see a woman in this scene, the woman is either lusting at the naked man – meaning us – or is impressed with our masculinity and our masculine naked body. By switching the perspectives, the scene from Terminator 2, though even more nude than the Top Gun scene, becomes a scene in which heterosexuals are comfortable watching and find exciting and iconic.
AUDIO 8
[IV: Why Can't We Be (Hetero) Friends?] In the 1988 film Die Hard, John McClane, played by Bruce Willis, and Al Powell played by Reginald Vel Johnson, form a bond over walkie talkies. McClane was in the wrong place at the wrong time when Hans Gruber, played by the late Alan Rickman, took hostages in hopes of emptying the vault at the Nakitomi Plaza. It is through these interactions that McClane stays grounded and connected to the outside world while he is trapped in the plaza, fighting for his life and bleeding from his feet. Powell even tells McClane he loves him. The bond between McClane and Powell becomes even closer as Powell saves McClane's life in the final moments of the film. There is nothing overtly homosexual about their friendship, but it is homosocial, meaning the interactions and friendships between those of the same sex. The popular view of men is that they are unemotional and impersonal, but men obviously form friendships and participate in larger friendship groups. Men do not only connect with each other through competition but through genuine friendship. Male solidarity even plays a role in the maintenance of men's power, as it works to exclude women.
Some men are criticized by their male friends should they begin to spend more time with a girlfriend than with the group, and this jealousy shows both the closeness of the group and its exclusion of women. Due to this, they must therefore manage to connect with each other personally and emotionally. Homosocial friendships among men in many cultures are often performed indirectly largely due to living in a heterosexist atmosphere. Many men rely on indirect speech, and stances, such as playful insults, boasts, and other competitive linguistic forms to create homosociality. In 80's and 90's action movies, bonds between men, even when the bonds are very strong, are portrayed as homosocial, not homosexual, but can be perceived as homosexual if speech and stances between the two men are more direct and vulnerable, not indirect and guarded as in many male friendships. The point is that what we perceive as “gay” in an action movie is sometimes subtext, sometimes influenced by the culture that created it, but sometimes only a consequence of what we consider to be the boundaries that men in homosocial relationships build between them.
AUDIO 9
If two straight men in real life become close and one tells the other man something intimate or makes himself vulnerable, the other straight man might accuse him, perhaps only jokingly, of being “gay” because closeness between straight men often requires an indirectness in order for straight men to not have their sexuality questioned. In action movies, homosocial friendships between ostensibly straight men require closeness because film is often an exaggeration of real life and showcases intense circumstances that require trust and bonding between characters. Action movies, due to the life-or-death circumstances, inevitably show two ostensibly straight men becoming closer. This can lead an audience to have the same reaction as the example with the two straight friends in real life: an accusation of homosexuality simply due to being vulnerable with one another or telling each other they value each other's friendship. Hollywood's pattern of almost always casting men in the starring roles of action movies and the disparity in the ratio between men and women characters in movies – particularly action movies – creates a homosocial atmosphere to film and to the relationships between characters.
This creates an uncomfortable paradox in applying a queer lens to an action movie that features close homosocial relationships. We see some of these relationships as “gay” due to their closeness, but we may only see closeness as “gay” due to homophobia among men and the subsequent indirectness of their friendship. To put it more simply, we only think a man telling his platonic male friend he loves him as “gay” in the first place because homophobia and heteronormativity tell us that men don't or shouldn't talk to other men that way or else be labeled as weak, effeminate or gay. The 1988 film Bloodsport is only occasionally referenced as “gay” because two men are vulnerable enough with each other for one to say he cares about the other. That's not to say that we can't apply a queer reading of the film – of course we can – but the reading here is that men who express even the slightest affection for one another due to duress or extreme circumstances can still be labeled as gay by a homophobic society. There has obviously been some gains in explicit queer representation in media – it would be dishonest to claim otherwise – but in action movies, queer characters among the main cast are still mostly invisible. This makes queer readings of action movies through that lens and queer coding a lot more common than actual, openly queer characters in action movies. The biggest excuse is that it wouldn't play well in China. This argument does not sterilize the excuse as a mere financial decision divorced from politics but instead only exposes homophobia internationally. Oh well. I guess we'll always have Point Break. [sighs]
CHINESE PROPAGANDA
AUDIO 1
Let's get the disclaimer and some terminology out of the way: Nobody needs to say “But what about AMERICA?” to me. Half of my videos are about America, including American propaganda. Criticism of the People's Republic of China does not mean elevating a state somewhere else. This is not a zero sum game. Furthermore, China will be referred to as the People's Republic of China or PRC for short to distinguish itself from simply the land in general, culture in general or the citizens in general. If you say “China is in the wrong,” this may be misinterpreted as a reference to the Chinese citizens or China as an abstract. “The PRC is in the wrong.” hopefully will communicate that it's a reference to the state. Let's begin. Western propaganda and Chinese propaganda both posit that the People's Republic of China practices socialism. From the western perspective, this propaganda is meant to demonize the PRC, and from the Chinese perspective, this is meant to distance itself from capitalism and the west. In reality, the PRC does not practice socialism nor has it achieved communism. Socialism is the ownership of the means of production by the community and the workers.
The PRC practices state capitalism, which is ownership of the the means of production by the state. State profits are retained by its enterprises rather than being equitably distributed. Conflation of the two terms and ideologies is both western propaganda, meaning the remnants of the Cold War, and Chinese state propaganda. Its ruling political party is called the Communist Party of China, but declaring oneself communist while practicing state capitalism is more branding than ideology. North Korea – officially called the Democratic People's Republic of Korea – is not democratic nor is it controlled by the people simply because it gives itself that name. In general, socialists don't see the PRC as the goal. Admittedly, some leftists defend the PRC due to its opposition to the western version of capitalism and the western version of imperialism, but the PRC's own state capitalism and modern imperialism is not somehow cleaner simply because it's in competition with America or because it uses the aesthetic of a revolution for its authoritarianism.
AUDIO 2
One Chinese industry controlled by the state is proving highly lucrative: the motion picture industry. China Film Group Corporation is the largest state-owned film enterprise in the country. It's effectively a state monopoly in terms of imported films and the largest distributor of domestic films in the country. There are private film studios, and they're flourishing. Remember, the PRC is not actually socialist despite its protestations. Nevertheless, all film studios – state-owned or private – must abide by the same censorship laws and state-sponsored propaganda. The word propaganda can mean a great number of things – historically, it was a somewhat neutral term -- but as a pejorative and with the qualifier “state-sponsored,” propaganda is exaggerated or manipulative information and media that serves the state. The word propaganda as the pejorative will be used throughout this video, not “propaganda” as the neutral term that people generally do not use. State propaganda dwarfs any other form of propaganda qualitatively and quantitatively, mostly due to budget.
The Walt Disney Company has slowly gaining an unheard of percentage of their share, and their total assets were estimated last year at 98 billion dollars. Probably a bit more now. Comparatively, the People's Republic of China spent 3.7 TRILLION dollars in 2017 alone. Obviously not all of either entity's budget went toward propaganda – what Disney would instead call marketing – but the contrast between the two numbers of a major corporation and a powerful nation show there is hardly any meaningful similarity whatsoever. The PRC has greater reach than Disney even though it is relatively inexperienced in the film industry. In November 2016, China passed a film law banning content deemed harmful to the “dignity, honor and interests” of the PRC, but that was always standard operating procedure. In the US, film studios are incentivized to make films that support the US and especially the US military. The military frequently sponsors major motion pictures, and many other films are given tax breaks for their cooperation. Taxpayer dollars subsidize pro-war movies and those subsidies are withheld from anti-war movies. The constitution does not allow the US to block an anti-war movie from being made.
AUDIO 3
But by making pro-war movies the financial path of least resistance, studios have little to no interest in anything that does not glorify the US military. In the PRC, this is perhaps even worse, as the law simply blocks anything critical of the state – military or otherwise – or blacklists Chinese filmmakers who circumvent their censors. The end result is roughly the same, though. In the PRC, all imported films must be pre-approved by the State Administration of Press, Publication, Radio, Film, and Television and are subject to censorship. The SAPPRFT does not work alone. It works in concert with other state organizations that oversee content related to film. A spy thriller is shown to censors in the Ministry of State Security. If it features students, censors in the Ministry of Education will have to look at it, and so forth. The 2016 hit film Deadpool, for instance, was rejected for being too violent. The PRC also exports films to English-speaking countries in hopes of both making money and spreading propaganda. The most obvious example is the 2016 film The Great Wall. And that brings us to Wolf Warrior. In the first film, Leng Feng is sent to a Chinese Special Forces unit, the titular wolf warriors.
In the sequel, he must save an unnamed African country. When watching state propaganda, particularly if it's related to the military, ask yourself: “Who are the good guys? Who are the bad guys? Who is the audience? What is being presented? What is being concealed? Why was this made?” Let's look at some examples of how the Wolf Warrior movies portrays the military, the police and the PRC's foreign interests. [THE POLICE] At the beginning of the first Wolf Warrior film, the military and the police have combined forces for the incredible task of just...arresting a group of drug dealers. The police are extremely violent, and their opposition, the drug dealers, are portrayed as faceless monsters. The PRC actually has laws on their books that allow them to execute not only murderers but drug traffickers, among many other lesser criminals. The authorities undertake random drug testing on foreign nationals including on entry to the country. If you test positive, you can be prosecuted you regardless of where or when you consumed drugs. Police raids on homes also occur; if drugs are found in your property, penalties can be extremely severe.
AUDIO 4
In the film, Leng is practically a superhero – leaping around and crushing those dirty drug dealers. What else do they deserve but death, eh Wolf Warrior? With some of the strictest drug laws in the world, it's no wonder that the film series begins with a joint effort by the police and military to eradicate a drug organization as if it were an enemy nation at war with the PRC. Most developed nations have a firm separation between the police and the military. Though both are entities which help monopolize violence for the state, most nations limit the powers of the police in terms of their firearms and the scope of their jurisdiction. Not so in the PRC, as the Chinese People's Armed Police Force is actually a paramilitary organization and exists on the national level. There are over two million officers in China. Whereas in the US, we rightly protest the oversized military spending, in the PRC, their spending on police can actually sometimes outweigh their military spending. These budget increases are not due to a ramp-up in murder or other major crimes but due to political unrest in Tibet, western China and trouble brought about by unemployed workers and other problems associated with the economic crisis.
As we see in Hong Kong right now, the Chinese People's Armed Police Force exists not only to solve crimes but to quell any political unrest or opposition to the ruling party. That's NOT to say this doesn't happen in other nations, but it definitely happens in China. [ETHNO-NATIONALISM AND CHINESE SUPERIORTY] In Wolf Warrior, scientists discover a virus pushed by pharmaceutical companies that targets Chinese DNA. Ethnic Chinese would be wiped out. Imagine this plot point in a movie from a majority white nation. If the plot was about non-white people trying to kill the white race, red flags would be seen that this is a white nationalist picture portraying white people as “under attack” and facing “white genocide.” We would rightly call this alarmist and racist based on what we know about the rise of white ethnonationalism in recent years. That is what Wolf Warrior is doing; portraying the Chinese people as very strong but also under attack by an insidious enemy, in this case, the west. Xi Jinping recently stressed the duty of overseas Chinese to contribute to the realization of his Chinese Dream. The PRC is now displaying the warning signs of an emerging ethnonationalist power, by reaching out to a massive diaspora to realize its own political goals.
AUDIO 5
Currently, roughly 60 million ethnic Chinese live aboard, and 80 percent of them have no Chinese nationality. The term “race traitors” has become increasingly common in state-run media to describe activists and protesters. In Wolf Warrior, this cool guy who doesn't look at explosions tells his western mercenary friends not to underestimate the Chinese. Most of the antagonists in the Wolf Warrior series are not Chinese citizens but foreigners. This is not uncommon for action movies – foreign threats tap into the audience's xenophobia in any country – but there is something more, well, suspicious when it happens so overtly and when it happens due to a film being under the control by the state. Poor Frank Grillo. A willing participant in propaganda against his own country. [THE UNITED NATIONS] In Wolf Warrior 2, the film goes out of its way to mention that the PRC is a permanent member of the United Nations Security Council. It's awkwardly shoe-horned into the dialogue, just like a lot of the propaganda lines in both movies.
In Wolf Warrior 2, the People's Liberation Army waits patiently for the UN to give clearance to perform a military operation. The film portrays the PRC as having a relationship with the UN built on a kind of mutual respect. In the real world, the PRC's relationship with the UN is more complicated and contentious. Experts are warning that China is quietly working to weaken the United Nations’ commitment to human rights. If it succeeds, the international human rights system could become even less capable of protecting victims and holding individual states accountable. During the most recent UN Human Rights Council session, the PRC deflected criticism of its arbitrary detention of more than a million Uighurs and other Muslims in Xinjiang. These prisoners have been detained in “re-education camps.” Delegates from the PRC also disrupted a discussion on Hong Kong. Prior to the administration of President Xi Jingping, the PRC tried to downplay its human rights violations. Their new strategy is to simply deflect criticism and change the subject to their own national sovereignty. According to Human Rights Watch, the PRC threatened other UN members to give positive reviews of its human rights or else suffer severe economic consequences.
AUDIO 6
The Human Rights Council's decrees are generally non-binding by law, but the Security Council, mentioned in Wolf Warrior 2, has more binding resolutions. While all member states try to control the conversation in the UN for their interests, the PRC is notable among Security Council members for blocking otherwise universally agreed-upon resolutions. For example, North Korea has been violating the terms of its sanctions, and when frequently brought up by other members of the Security Council, the PRC blocks the resolution to condemn this violation. The reason is because the PRC is a key supplier of petroleum to North Korea. Keeping its economic interests with the rogue nation intact is more important to the PRC than North Korea breaking the rules and becoming more dangerous to the region. The only state that sided with the PRC in this case with Russia, which has its own petroleum interests with North Korea. [AFRICA] In Wolf Warrior 2, Leng must save an unnamed African nation from rebels and assorted ne'er-do-wells. There are a lot of scenes with Chinese characters saying how China and Africa are friends, how important Africa is to the Chinese people and how Africans trust China.
Leng must save the African people from both the rebels and this American who is interfering with the PRC “saving” Africa. So, what's that all about? The African nation in Wolf Warrior 2 does not have a name and only references the African continent as a whole because the PRC has economic interests throughout the continent. Panos Mourdoukatas of Forbes explained “The reason Chinese corporations are in Africa is simple; to exploit the people and take their resources. It’s the same thing European colonists did during mercantile times, except worse. The Chinese corporations are trying to turn Africa into another Chinese continent. They are squeezing Africa for everything it is worth.”
AUDIO 7
Supporters of Chinese industries taking over Africa make the same claim as the previous more violent colonialism: that it will ultimately benefit the native people. However, the numbers tell a different story. While Africa accounts for about 30 per cent of the world's reserves of hydrocarbons and minerals, its share of global manufacturing stood in 2011 exactly where it stood in 2000: at 1 percent. Again, there is no sharing of the wealth or worker ownership. The PRC is not actually socialist. It's as capitalist as they come. The PRC is performing what is commonly known as a “debt trap.” The loans are seen as too good to be true for a reason. Many of these loans are for ventures that are not expected to be profitable. The PRC knows this. When the ventures fail to meet the terms of the loan, the PRC will be able to take control of the projects altogether, effectively taking over the continent through shady business practices rather than force. The PRC did did this to Sri Lanka following their civil war. This tactic has been used by nations throughout history, but the PRC's ambition – an entire continent – goes beyond garden variety debt-trap diplomacy. The PRC is effectively colonizing Africa.
That's not to say there have been no benefits to the PRC's involvement in Africa, as I am certain that apologists will declare, but that's not the point. The point is the propaganda that says that the PRC's involvement in Africa is entirely beneficial and that there are no downsides. Propaganda works in absolutes. There is no state propaganda that says “Well, this is complicated and a bit of a mixed bag when you think about it.” No. Wolf Warrior 2 is the PRC saying “Hey, we always have Africa's best interests at heart!” This scene shows Leng and his new acquaintance talking about the colonialism enacted by other nations – particularly European nations in Africa – but brushes past what the PRC is actually doing in Africa. [blank] So, what else? Oh, let's talk about porn. In Wolf Warrior 2, a young boy is admonished for selling pornography. The PRC has banned pornography on the Internet. It's illegal and a punishable offense. In Wolf Warrior 1, they talk of terrorism, but “terrorism” to the police in the PRC is anything that is contrary to the wishes of the state. God, I've gone this whole video without even once referencing these terrible CG wolves. Look at them! LOOK AT THEM! WHAT?! [laughs] Alright, so, what have we learned here today? Not that “Chinese = Bad” because that's...reductive and childish. But I hope that by examining propaganda films from another nation we can more readily spot it when our own nations peddle it. And if you are a Chinese citizen, uhh, sorry? The PRC is lying to you about some stuff. All nations do, really, but not all nations have as much control over their media as the People's Republic of China.
SPIDER-MAN
AUDIO 1
Earlier this month, news broke that Disney and Sony were no longer going to collaborate on Spider-Man movies. Negotiations had been shut down, and bit by bit, it became less of a rumor and more of a confirmation by the studios and the stars of the movies. In 1999, Sony purchased the movie rights to Spider-Man from Marvel. The deal gave Sony exclusive film rights to the Spider-Man universe, meaning not only Peter Parker but related characters like Aunt May, Venom, Doctor Octopus, et cetera. Marvel retained merchandise rights to the characters and could continue to feature them in comic books and cartoon series. Sony distributed Sam Raimi's beloved Spider-Man trilogy and less fondly remembered Marc Webb helmed Amazing Spider-Man films. This deal continued after Disney purchased Marvel lock, stock and barrel in 2009. With the success of the Marvel Cinematic Universe and the weak box office returns of The Amazing Spider-Man 2, Sony and Disney arranged for Spider-Man to join the MCU for a five-picture run. Sony would produce two Spider-Man movies that would feature unrelated MCU characters as well as have Marvel Entertainment honcho Kevin Feige as one of the executive producers.
That deal has concluded, as Spider-Man had appeared in Captain America: Civil War, Spider-Man: Homecoming, Avengers: Infinity War, Avengers: Endgame and finally Spider-Man: Far From Home. The details of the previous deal are under lock and key, with some sources claiming that Disney received either 5% of the first-day or total gross for Sony's Spider-Man movies while others report that each company kept all the revenue from the films it was responsible for producing. Sony produced the solo Spider-Man films, and Disney produced Civil War and the Avengers movies. Both sides benefited and lost nothing. During re-negotiation for the next deal following the end of the five-picture arrangement, Disney reportedly proposed receiving a larger share of the profits from any future Spider-Man solo movies, as much as 50%. In exchange, they would pay half the production costs. This sounds fair at a glance until you compare production costs to the box office for these movies. Spider-Man: Far From Home cost $160 million to make, and its worldwide box office was over $1 billion. Assuming the next Spider-Man solo movie costs a similar amount and makes a similar profit, Disney is asking to pay Sony $80 million so it can take $500 million from Sony's potential profit.
AUDIO 2
Even if these numbers are a little off and don't take the marketing budget into account, that is an extremely bad deal for Sony, financially speaking. Disney has become so powerful in recent years that it's possible they thought Sony (or anyone for that matter) would be desperate to continue to do business with them. Nevertheless, fans of the Spider-Man films broadly sided with Disney over this divorce, insisting that Spider-Man was doomed now that Disney would no longer be associated with the character. Bear in mind that Disney did not create the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Iron Man and The Incredible Hulk were released in 2008. Disney didn't make the MCU. They bought the MCU by purchasing Marvel a year later in 2009. At some point, when fandom of a brand and company becomes a matter of faithfulness and anything lost from that brand or company becomes a matter of treason, it is no longer fandom: it's corporate loyalty.
Stanning for a corporation is the very height of bootlicking, a deferential bowing to either amorphous corporate entities that, in spite of what the Supreme Court says, are not actually people, or to millionaire corporate executives who absolutely do not care about us. Sony is not “the little guy” in this split between itself from Disney. It's a massive corporation. It's only small by comparison and certainly no less innocent. However, Sony should not be seen as the “bad guy” either, especially considering the incredible arrogance of Disney to demand Sony lose half the box office to its most successful property. This is particularly galling considering how successful Sony has been without its association to Disney. 2018's Venom went on to gross more than $850 million at the box office, and Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse beat Disney at the Academy Awards. While Disney played a role in shaping Spider-Man, all recent Spider-Man pictures, Homecoming, Far From Home, Into the Spider-Verse and Venom if you count it as a Spider-Man movie, were produced in-house by Sony Pictures.
AUDIO 3
I'm not too interested in cheer-leading a corporation, but objectively speaking, Sony made a smart move by refusing to cede more control of its most valuable movie property. But try telling that to corporate loyalists, some of whom are demanding Disney buy Sony to gain exclusive movie rights to the character, and some of whom are apparently ready to storm Sony offices to demand Spider-Man be reintegrated into their precious MCU. Here's some a hot take for these loyalists: the only reason Disney is squabbling over the movie rights to Spider-Man is because Disney completely f***ed up copyright law, which itself was already f***ed up and worked far more in favor of corporations over labor. Creating, inventing or naming something is making intellectual property. If a pharmaceutical company comes up with a formula for a new pill, the intellectual property is not the physical pill but the formula one uses to create it. The pill is an intellectual property asset. The product of the intellectual property, the idea. In superhero terms, a physical Spider-Man comic book is property, but the idea that Stan Lee and Steve Ditko had when creating Spider-Man is intellectual property. Spider-Man is owned – now across different media –through a variety of intellectual property rights. A copyright shields artistic expression against copying by others. Another form of intellectual property rights is contractual rights, meaning licensing the right to use someone else’s invention. That's how Sony gained the film rights to Spider-Man in 1999. Marvel sold them exclusive film rights via contract, but Marvel – now Disney – still retains rights to Spider-Man in its original form: comic books. In an economic system which depends on disparity between economic classes, the copyright system will – more often than not – benefit those with more capital and resources. Those who can hire the best lawyers, those who can drag something out in court without the risk of going bankrupt due to mounting legal bills. That's why the copyright system, even though it can be utilized by anyone, benefits corporations more than it benefits individual artists and inventors.
AUDIO 4
Intellectual property law has existed for centuries, but it began to change in the United States during the 20th century. Disney has long fought to ensure that the copyright license to Mickey Mouse continues for as long as possible. In 1998, Disney lobbied to overhaul the copyright the copyright system to retroactively extend everything created between 1923 and 1977 to a staggering 95-year term. They were successful, so much in fact that the law is sometimes pejoratively called the Mickey Mouse Law. Due to this, Mickey Mouse, at least as depicted in Steamboat Willie, is safely protected under Disney until 2023. Everyone involved in the creation of the Steamboat Willie cartoon short is dead, and the assumption that the Disney company should be the owner of Mickey Mouse for all time tells us a lot about how we have been fooled into viewing corporations as people. It tells us a lot about the commodification of even intangible things, like ideas. As for Spider-Man, the webslinger won't become public domain until 2057. If Disney hadn't lobbied politicians to extend copyright, Spider-Man would have entered public domain on January 1st 2019. This year. Disney would have been free to make as many Spider-Man movies as it desired.
The news that Spider-Man would no longer be able to interact with characters that are the intellectual property of Disney created a lot of misinformation on social media when it broke, most notably the idea that this meant that the Tom Holland version of Spider-Man was about to be snapped out of existence. This is untrue. The movies Captain America: Civil War, Avengers: Infinity War and Avengers: Endgame are the property of Disney, but Spider-Man: Homecoming and Spider-Man: Far From Home are the property of Sony. Holland and Sony have both confirmed that he is under contract for more movies and that there is no reason for a reboot. The story will continue, presumably where it left off in Far from Home. This misinformation is the likely result of the aforementioned corporate loyalty for Disney, the idea that if Disney no longer has access to Spider-Man, then Spider-Man may as well cease to exist. Sony still owns the movie rights to Spider-Man. Peter Parker in the MCU was an arrangement, not a handover or buy-out. Sony would have no interest in rebooting Spider-Man with such a proven winner on its hands, particularly after so many other potential franchises among its intellectual properties failed to catch fire.
AUDIO 5
The only appreciable difference between what would have been the next solo Spider-Man movie and what is going to be the next solo Spider-Man movie is that it can't reference or feature characters that are the intellectual property of Disney, but that does not actually kneecap the film. Iron Man can no longer be part of the Spider-Man movies as the property of Disney, but that character was killed off in Avengers: Endgame. He couldn't feature anyway. The only noticeable difference between what would have been the next Spider-Man movie and what will be the next Spider-Man movie in terms of rights and intellectual property is Happy Hogan. Happy is a character owned wholly by Disney, which means unless some new deal is brokered, he will not making an appearance in the next solo Spider-Man movie. That's it. In terms of characters, Happy will be the only noticeable change, and though the flirtations between Happy and Aunt May probably got a few laughs from the audience, it probably would not be controversial to say that nobody bought a ticket for either movie to see Happy Hogan. Even when with the Avengers, Spider-Man forged no meaningful relationships with any characters besides Iron Man, who, once again, is now dead. Spider-Man lifts out of the MCU better than almost any other major character. This does not require very much screenwriting surgery at all. Another complaint among Disney's corporate loyalists is that it was somehow Disney itself that made the Homecoming and Far From Home as good as they were.
AUDIO 6
This is a mischaracterization of the process that went into the creation of both of these movies. Homecoming and Far From Home are not Disney movies, they are Sony movies. Sony did not hand over the creation of the solo Spider-Man movies to Disney and simply reaped all the reward. That would not make good financial sense for Disney. Kevin Feige of Marvel Entertainment was one of the executive producers of both films, but the other executive producer was Amy Pascal, former chairperson of the Motion Pictures Group of Sony Pictures Entertainment and Co-Chair of SPE in general, including Sony Pictures Television. Her other recent producer credits include the Academy Award winning Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse and the Best Picture Academy Award nominee The Post, directed by Steven Spielberg. In fact, Pascal Pictures, founded and owned by Pascal herself, was one of the three production houses credited with creating Homecoming and Far From Home; the other two being Columbia Pictures, which is a subsidiary of Sony, and of course Marvel Studios, under Disney. Homecoming and Far From Home were also financed in-house by Sony, not Disney.
Homecoming and Far From Home were written by a series of hired gun screenwriters, and since Sony fronted the bill for both movies, the screenwriters were under the employ of Sony, not Disney. Both pictures were directed by Jon Watts, who until then never had any major dealings with either Sony or Disney. Characterizing Homecoming and Far From Home as Disney movies is incredibly disingenuous. There has never been a Disney Spider-Man movie. The premise of the argument that Disney is best suited to control Spider-Man has never been proven. The popular perception of Disney as a monolith in the industry leads to the assumption that Disney was responsible for Homecoming and Far From Home, even though that is demonstrably untrue.
AUDIO 7
Furthermore, over-estimating Disney's control over Homecoming and Far From Home shows a misunderstanding about how common it is for a motion picture's primary producer and distributor contracting help from other production houses, splitting distribution domestic and worldwide distribution, et cetera. Corporate loyalists tend to lionize Kevin Feige as this supreme being who is solely responsible or at least chiefly responsible for why the Marvel Studios movies are “good.” and if that is true, then that is the only reason that Homecoming and Far From Home were “good.” There are two problems with this line of thinking. One is that filmmaking is a collaborative process and that motion pictures are the result of the labor of a great many people. Frequently in film discourse, the director is deified as the sole motivator of a film, which itself is problematic, but it's telling about the growing influence of corporate loyalty in our society that the director has been supplanted as the perceived creative head of the film in the popular consciousness of movie-goers. Corporate loyalists are more likely to give credit to an amorphous brand or to a producer, a position that is historically more of a corporate overseer; an arranger of finances.
Kevin Feige undoubtedly had a major hand in making the MCU what it is today due to his position within Marvel Studios, but the shift from giving far greater credit to a producer than to writers, directors and other creatives working the industry is both telling of our shifting priorities and arguably a mischaracterization of the primary reasons why movies end up being, well, good. Kevin Feige is not primarily responsible for the MCU movies being “good” – he is primarily responsible for the MCU movies being “uniform” – containing the same style, cohesiveness and even the same camera equipment used for each movie. That's not to downplay his involvement, which has been quite an undertaking, but that is a more realistic credit to Feige's actual mark left on the MCU. The other problem with the line of thinking that lays credit solely at the feet of Kevin Feige for the MCU movies being any good is the presumption that these movies are, in fact, good in the first place. Obviously a lot of this is subjective, but It might be more accurate to say that the MCU movies are successful rather than exceptional.
AUDIO 8
They are serviceable action movies, with a handful of entries that rise above that median or are so grand in scale that they become, at least, very satisfying. The MCU is an achievement in organization more than filmmaking, which is another reason why an executive producer is given more credit than the accomplished creative heads who helmed its most popular entries. Long story short, not much is lost by Sony and Disney having a falling out over profit sharing. Spider-Man starring Tom Holland will continue, and Sony is perfectly capable of hiring successful directors and writers for the next sequel. In fact, word is they want Jon Watts back for the third installment. He may be back. The only thing truly lost from the Disney/Sony divorce is that Spider-Man can no longer have awkward small-talk with Doctor Strange in a fifth Avengers movie that has not even been announced yet. At the risk of being dismissive, so what? Disney's intellectual property within its shared universe is so vast that losing one character among hundreds will not diminish it. Disney recently acquired 20th Century Fox, which gives them the film rights to the Fantastic Four, the X-Men and all related characters like Deadpool.
They have an absurdly large library of characters from which to choose. The counter-argument that “Disney should have everything” is effectively cheer-leading a monopoly. A “gotta collect 'em all” mentality that is extremely concerning both from Disney and its audience. Disney's huge gains in the box office market share, television market and streaming market should give pause to even the most enthusiastic of corporate loyalists. Disney now owns somewhere between 35 to 40 percent of the market share, which even at the low estimate is more than twice as much as number two. Sometimes this level of market control or merger is rejected by United States Department of Justice, but both rejections and allowances are often politically-motivated.
AUDIO 9
The Trump administration had no problem with Fox selling its movie and television intellectual property to Disney because Fox head honcho Rupert Murdoch is a personal friend to Trump. The Disney-Fox deal is considered a “horizontal merger” because both Disney and 20th Century Fox were in the same business: making movies and television show as entertainment. The Department of Justice usually considers this a serious antitrust concern, but in this case and with this President, it happened painlessly and without interference by the government. The Fox acquisition has resulted in thousands of layoffs and cut Fox's upcoming film schedule roughly in half. This means fewer jobs and fewer movies for the consumer. When Disney loyalists shout from the rooftops that the Fantastic Four are free at least, free at last, it rings hollow when compared to the staggering loss of employment and loss of options at the box office. Disney does not technically have a “monopoly,” but it is growing ever closer to that designation.
When a private industry has more of the market, they can charge more to the consumer, which is exactly what happened following the AT&T-Time Warner merger. It's the same reason your hotdog at the sports stadium or your popcorn at a movie theater or your chimichanga at Disney World costs so much – because they can. Because there is no other option once you're inside. Under a monopoly, the industry can do and charge whatever it wants. A merger of this magnitude is not good for the consumer, and certainly not good for the workers. If the Fox workers even have jobs under the new reign of Disney, they now have fewer options in their industry should Disney mistreat them or not pay them as well as they should. [Iron Man] That's capitalism, baby. An economic system that inevitably builds towards incredible private ownership that bestows obscene power in very few people at the top. With great power, comes great price gouging. Sony is no angel either, as previously mentioned, but Disney losing even the tiniest bit of power in its industry is not a bad thing and no amount of awkward Doctor Strange scenes will ever be more important than keeping an emerging monopoly in check.
FRANK GRIMES
AUDIO 1
“Homer's Enemy” is the twenty-third episode of the eighth season of The Simpsons. Frank Grimes, a man who suffered tragedy after tragedy in his life but never stopped working hard, is hired by Mr. Burns to work in the Springfield nuclear power plant. Frank encounters Homer Simpson, a far less serious and far less professional worker. Frank discovers that Homer, in spite of his disinterest in his work, lives a much more comfortable life than Frank. “Homer's Enemy” was written by John Swartzwelder, an arch-conservative American libertarian and notorious, paranoid recluse, which means it should come as no surprise when Frank exclaims “You're what's wrong with America, Simpson. You coast through life and you leech off decent, hard-working people like me.” Whether Sqartzwelder's politics influenced the episode consciously or unconsciously, my commentary would be the same. Frank represents – not conservatives but a idealized, fantasy of who conservatives are in the minds of the very same conservatives: the decent, hard-working people. The salt of the Earth. Those who value backbreaking labor as a virtue. Those who turn their nose up at the social safety net because it somehow devalues their true god: work.
Homer represents something else. He represents what conservatives blame for some of the failures in capitalism: laziness. Not making enough money? Simply get a second job, like Frank Grimes. He mentions that he works a night job at a foundry. Still not making enough to get by, even with two jobs? Well, that's a “you problem” to conservatives. To them, not a failure of the system. To them, it's not necessarily even something with which we should sympathize. If you aren't making enough money under capitalism, then you must be lazy. If you are living on the street, then you must be lazy. Why not at least live in a dangerous, overcrowded, poorly maintained homeless shelter? American liberals may be less inclined to agree with these statements, but American liberals believe in capitalism too, which means they are doomed to see conservative workers as the enemy rather than the economic system that is responsible for all this hardship in the first place. If someone suffers under capitalism but performs all the tasks that capitalism demands of him, well, maybe that's the fault of the Homer Simpsons of the world who “leech” off hard-working people.
AUDIO 2
Nothing like a scapegoat to distract from the real enemy of labor. [It's also standard procedure to blame a scapegoat or sacrificial lamb.] Mr. Burns barely factors into the episode except as a kind of neutral party, an oblivious and even harmless entity that doesn't care one way or the other. Burns is brought to tears by Frank's life story and hires him but also chews him out over something that wasn't his fault. Past experience shows that he thinks nothing of Homer but gives him an award anyway. In a bit of writing ingenuity, “Homer's Enemy” frames Homer Simpson as wrong but the protagonist and Frank Grimes as right but the antagonist. Burns is an invisible hand of the market, and the conflict is only between Homer and Frank. Mr. Burns is framed as a disinterested party who has his ups and downs with both characters. If “Homer's Enemy” were more honest, Frank Grimes would not be so correct and Homer Simpson would not be so incorrect, but it is honest in ways it did not intend to be. Workers are pitted against each other by their employers – focusing on competition between one another rather than competition against their employers. An illusion of combativeness between workers as if the workers are what's preventing other workers from earning better pay.
Burns' exclusion from the conflict of the episode is representative of how conservative capitalists see the angst of workers; as being caused by other, lazier workers. Unjust systems generally require a scapegoat. “Homer's Enemy” portrays Mr. Burns as having no strong feelings about the feud or even awareness of the feud, but if the episode were more honest, Mr. Burns would be the one intentionally manipulating the feud instead of passively pushing Frank over the edge at the end by rewarding Homer first prize in the model power plant contest. The extremely conservative writer of this episode naturally blames the wrong person and wrong institution for Frank's misery. And since Frank is his avatar – so does the Frank character. Frank believes in the “cult of work” – a belief system that props up capitalism not as a necessary evil that some liberals view it but as a good unto itself, as something both godly and necessary to the rule of law. And if that is true, then poverty is the sole result of laziness and lack of personal responsibility. The working poor – many of whom are conservative – continue to buy into this in spite of it being opposed to their best interests. This is because this cult of work has brainwashed them into believing one of two things. First, that their hard work will be rewarded. [Futurama]
AUDIO 3
The second is that even if they don't raise themselves out of poverty, the hard work itself is its own reward. That way, the cult of work can never be wrong. This is what rich capitalists want them to think so that they can profit off the labor of the working poor and middle class. Over the centuries, hardline legal measures have been taken against the poor – a reaction to massive population shifts caused by the enclosure of the commons in England and how land was affected across Europe, particularly in France. Outlawing idleness and the poorhouses physically forced people from serfdom into wage-labor. The cult of work is partly the result of the Protestant work ethic – meaning work in and of itself being godly, making idleness a sin – and the desire among the poor to advance in life so much that they believe that the rich will give them a slice of the good life if they work hard enough. This delusion forces them to see the rich as their saviors and other workers as their competition and enemy. In the episode, Homer is the embodiment of the sin of sloth, a caricature of those who conservatives believe “leech” off the hard-working people.
In reality, the working poor, unemployed and under-employed are not “sinful” so much as they are suffering under an economic system in which disparity is a feature, not a bug. There have been mild attempts at reform over the years but little interest in replacing this economic system outright. Welfare as we know it began in America in 1935 as part of Franklin Roosevelt's Social Security Act. Decried as socialism and as antithetical to the cult of work in America, what the Social Security Act actually did was help struggling families. For example, it granted aid to dependent children who had lost an income-producing father. By the 1970's, welfare had become a lifeline for single mothers, giving conservatives even more ammunition against it. A single mother defies the cherished social norm of the nuclear family and the reliance on husbands as sole caregivers. For these socially conservative reasons and many others, conservative and neoliberal politicians sought to end welfare as we knew it. Bill Clinton ran on this during his campaign. “When I ran for president four years ago, I pledged to end welfare as we know it.”
AUDIO 4
The Clinton welfare-to-work program ushered single mothers and others off their support. Some greatly suffered because of this, and those could find jobs often found them lacking – retail jobs and cashier positions that couldn't possibly provide for themselves and their numerous children. Low wage jobs provide little room for upward mobility, and since wages have been largely stagnant since the Clinton years, these low wage jobs aren't getting better. The buying power for those pushed off welfare by the welfare-to-work program is now lower than it was. Cuts to welfare are pushed by conservative politicians, applauded by conservative voters and accepted by neoliberal politicians who want to seem sympathetic but also follow a doctrine of capitalism. Food stamps, housing and health care outlays are up, but welfare checks have shrunk so much that the very poorest single-parent families received 35 percent less than they did before welfare-to-work began. What's more, there's another major problem for welfare recipients right now: significantly reduced funding for job placement and training. Conservatives get into government, dismantle programs and then use the now dismantled programs as evidence that they don't work.
Men like the fictional Frank Grimes and their real world counterparts would ignore this. He would call struggling mothers “welfare queens” and see any failures of the system as the result of the Homer Simpsons of the world. Again, unjust systems and policies require a scapegoat. Frank tells his opposite that if Homer had lived in any other country, he would have starved to death long ago, and the episode treats this as fact in spite of the reality that most developed countries have far better social safety nets than the US. Other scapegoats include policies, institutions and people who actually benefit the work force so that rich capitalists can avoid detection as the true problem. Sometimes rich capitalists can even benefit from these policies, institutions and people – such as when immigration is blamed for low wages, unemployment and the proliferation of the sin of laziness. In truth, immigrants are 30 percent more likely to start a business in the US than non-immigrants, and 18 percent of all small business owners in the United States are immigrants. Small businesses owned by immigrants employ millions of people and generate more than $776 billion annually. Immigrants are also more likely to create their own jobs. 7.5 percent of the foreign born are self-employed compared to 6.6 percent among the native-born.
AUDIO 5
Deep down, rich capitalists love immigrants because of the cheap labor they can provide and because immigrants have started 25 percent of public U.S. companies that were backed by venture capitalists. This list includes Google, eBay, Yahoo!, Sun Microsystems, and Intel. But capitalists and their puppet politicians need the workers to blame themselves – to blame other workers – which makes scapegoats so prevalent. [I knew it was immigrants.] Another way rich capitalists get workers to blame each other is through propaganda against unions. Workers are subjected to what union organizers like to call a captive audience meeting. Employers hold these anti-union meetings once they have caught wind of an organizing campaign. New workers sit through anti-union orientation videos and presentations, which give misleading stats about the negatives of unionizing. The biggest “negative” of unionizing is that the employer will fire the employee, but that is not a negative of unionizing. It is the product of not having a union in the first place. Capitalist propaganda has made unions the enemy of the worker even though it has historically been the worker's greatest ally. It is not a coincidence that wages have stagnated at roughly the rate of the decrease in union influence in the US. The Simpsons had an earlier episode in which Homer becomes a union representative, but talk of unions on the series has faded along with the presence of unions in the real world.
Anti-union propaganda is so strong that many non-union workers see unionizing as a negative, not realizing that they are siding with rich capitalists who don't have their best interests at heart. Frank Grimes' parents abandoned him as a child, suggesting that he spent the rest of his youth in poverty. In addition to the episode, and by extension Frank, misunderstanding other workers as the cause of Frank's ennui, Frank also fails to realize that his position in life is not dictated by how hard he works but the conditions in which he was born. Karl Alexander is a Johns Hopkins sociologist who followed nearly 800 people from poor neighborhoods in Baltimore since they started first grade in 1982. Of the nearly 800 school kids he followed for 30 years, those who got a better start—because their parents were working, had more income or because of being a two-person household—tended to stay better off, while the more disadvantaged stayed poor. Out of the original 800 public school children he started with, only 33 moved from low-income birth family to a high-income bracket by the time they neared the age of 30. This preserves privilege across generations.
AUDIO 6
Only 4 percent of the low-income kids he met in 1982 had college degrees when he interviewed them at age 28, whereas 45 percent of the kids from higher-income backgrounds did. Of course, these statistics also intersect with racial discrimination. Among men who drop out of high school, the employment differences between white and black men are staggering. At age 22, 89 percent of the white subjects who’d dropped of high school were given jobs anyway, compared with only 40 percent of the black dropouts. Believers in the cult of work would claim that some born into poverty fight their way up to middle class and in some extremely rare cases even wealth, but that does not change the fact that it is much more difficult and much less likely with fewer resources. Low-income children caught up in their parents’ economic struggles experience the impact through unmet needs, low-quality schools, and unstable circumstances. In “Homer's Enemy” Frank definitely had unmet needs, home-schooled himself and obviously had unstable circumstances.
But when Frank laments that he lives in a small apartment between two bowling alleys and Homer lives in a house, he blames Homer's laziness for his own misfortune rather than a system that disadvantaged Frank from an early age. Struggling workers like Frank are given a pat on the head by rich capitalists because their added labor will always benefit the income of said rich capitalists more, and because of this, struggling workers might see these capitalists as their benefactors or even aspirational. The cult of work is at play here. So long as the workers don't complain about the unequal arrangement, these workers are a net positive for their employers. If the workers do complain, capitalists will make excuses that deflect criticism towards themselves. Things like “If you wanted a higher paying job, you should have taken a higher paying job. That's a you problem.” But this ignores the aforementioned statistics about the challenges in attaining these jobs for those born into poverty, not to mention the the limited amount of higher paying jobs that sometimes require workers to take on more than one occupation at a time. Rich capitalists are – more often than not – born into far better circumstances than the poor, have far greater advantages, have far more privileges, resources and stability.
AUDIO 7
But they can't or won't see it that way and instead blame the victims of capitalism rather than the beneficiaries of capitalism. The US props up an “American Dream” of getting rich from nothing but the sweat off your back and a garage for your amazing invention. It is codified in the very culture of the nation. It is a religion, a cult far stronger and more prevalent than any other belief system, and it is just as supernatural. “It's a you problem” individualizes systemic problems because individuals are easier to see and therefore blame. Frank blames Homer because he is his exact opposite and because he can see him and shout at him and look at their disparate lives and tell him that he's what's wrong with the US. And no, the conservative libertarian writer obviously did not intend an anti-capitalist message, but like many conservatives who notice income inequality but blame it on the wrong people, he was close an epiphany but could not quite make the right connection. When Frank Grimes discovers that Homer Simpson, who doesn't work particularly hard, has a much better life than himself, he could have had a realization that the meritocracy that “personal responsibility” conservatives and work cultists talk about was a sham, but that is never broached in the episode. For an instant, Frank sees the world for what it is but takes the wrong lesson from it.
What it gets wrong is how the myth of meritocracy within this cult of work benefits the rich far more than it would benefit a working class family because the rich – upon confronted with their obscene wealth hoarding can always claim that they “earned” their millions and billions. Nobody earns a billion dollars, they steal it from the labor of those who have no choice but to take low-wage jobs in a system that previous billionaires maintained for new billionaires. US television sitcoms are filled with working class families and humor centered around their working class problems, but said sitcoms generally don't question economic injustice and capitalism as a system and sometimes also could be fairly right-wing. Al Bundy never blamed his position in life on the fact that his employer doesn't pay him enough. He blamed his position in life on women, most notably his wife, his neighbor and the women customers at his place of employment. He complained far more about the customers than about management, directing his unhappiness with his life at bystanders and other working class people rather than those who actually control him. Simpsons fans sometimes take issue with this episode because it portrays Homer as a foil of a man who had a hard life – he is a monster who elicits laughs at Frank's funeral – but that is how capitalists frame anyone who works for a living or wants to work for a living but doesn't buy into the cult of work: lazy, worthless and ignorant. We are the butt of the joke. The ranting of Frank Grimes isn't directed only at Homer Simpson but at us, anyone who is skeptical of capitalism, skeptical of meritocracy, disinterested in shifting blame to our fellow workers. We've existed under capitalism for centuries now, and we should all know who the real enemy is.
CHRISTIAN HORROR
AUDIO 1
In the 1968 horror film Dracula Has Risen From the Grave, two men attempt to stake Dracula through the heart and perform a ritual that will end his reign of terror. Unfortunately, the staking proves ineffective when the two men – an atheist and a priest with no faith – do not have the conviction to perform a prayer and vanquish the vampire. It is only through faith that Dracula can be defeated, at least until the next movie. This goes unquestioned in Dracula Has Risen From the Grave as well as supernatural horror in general. The enemy of evil is faith, and the accomplice of evil is doubt or godlessness. [PART 1: CHRISTIAN BY DEFAULT] Supernatural horror is a film genre that includes fantastic elements such as ghosts and demons. Supernatural horror can also contain elements of religion. The United States is predominantly Christian in religious ideology. This is also true of the United Kingdom, Canada and other western nations that both make and export horror films. Consequently, supernatural horror made in the west is either understood to be existing within Christian ideology implicitly or existing within Christian ideology explicitly through Christian imagery. This does not mean that a horror movie made in the United States can't take imagery from other faiths, but the dominant ideology makes Christianity a “default” for supernatural horror that deals with the afterlife, spirits, demons, devils and the power of faith to overcome the antagonist.
Supernatural horror from western origins being Christian by default is the product of dominant ideology. Horror often draws upon supernatural beings, and if Christianity is the dominant form of supernaturalism in a culture, said horror will also draw upon Christianity even if the intent is not to create an inherently religious narrative. Unless contradicted in the text, references to God in supernatural horror is understand by a Christian audience as the Christian God by default, references to the afterlife understood by a Christian audience as the Christian afterlife, etc. Most Christian films are not part of the horror genre. Christian exploitation films like the God's Not Dead trilogy or anything dealing with the Rapture, more often than not have an Evangelical Protestant flavor. Supernatural horror films, however, are more likely to be unmistakably Catholic. Roman Catholicism is steeped in ancient, sometimes foreboding imagery and has a powerful, hierarchical system that is naturally intimidating. There aren't too many horror films in which a family's Presbyterian or Lutheran roots are integral to the plot. Horror with Christian themes is likely to either be of the Catholic denomination or without any specific Christian denomination. Supernatural horror films generally position the church or faith or God as the savior that can assist the potential victims overcome the monster, the demon, the ghost or the devil.
AUDIO 2
Characters in the film who are opposed to the supernatural entity often actively seek out the help of the church or use Christian icons or prayers to defeat the antagonist. If supernatural horror movies don't seem explicitly Christian, that is because Christianity being a norm and the dominant ideology in a culture can give it a kind of cultural invisibility. We are accustomed to it so much that it's the background radiation of any discussion or narrative dealing with supernatural elements in a majority Christian nation. Not all horror will serve as a puff piece for Christianity, of course. See: The Mist or many other films adapted from a Stephen King novel. However, supernatural horror made in western nations generally goes the Jesus route. According to Hauntings and Poltergeists: Multidisciplinary Perspectives, widespread and frequent repetition of similar stories with similar characters and similar results can have an impact on the social consensus or individual conviction. When movies feature ghosts, demons and other supernatural elements, they can't help but comment on belief, the afterlife, doubt and finally rejection of that doubt and renewed faith. If we understand Hollywood supernatural horror movies to be Christian by default, then that faith being renewed is Christianity.
If media repeats these narratives endlessly, it reinforces the pre-existing worldview about Christianity or even changes and strengthens that worldview. James Houran wrote in the aforementioned book: “The concept of media power suggests that the images audiences consume are infected by a dominant ideology. In an era in which knowledge of an experience substitutes for experience itself, moving image media can have a powerful influence on what audiences think they know.” Most writers and directors of supernatural horror are not intending to proselytize but instead use the cultural currency to reach Christian audiences. However, some writers and directors believe in the source material, they believe in what messages they are conveying to the audience. In an interview with the Christian Post about The Conjuring 2, writer Chad Hills said “Conjuring 2 is a story told through the eyes of believers, whose strongest weapon is their faith in God. Our films allows believers and nonbelievers to travel their journey with them, and in some ways, maybe affect someone who is on the edge of faith, and give them the strength they need.”
AUDIO 3
Whether intentional or not, supernatural horror conveys meaning to the audience. So, what do supernatural horror movies within the reach of Christianity tell us? [PART 2: Follow Jesus...or Else!] The Conjuring and its related movies are based on the life work of two scam artists: Ed and Lorraine Warren. The films portray the Warrens as actual demon hunters rather than frauds. Though, whether the real life Warrens believed their own fantasies or not is irrelevant to the consequences. In the first Conjuring movie, Ed and Lorraine are summoned to a haunted house. They conclude that the house itself needs an exorcism, contact the Catholic Church, but when the priest does not arrive in time, the Warrens dispel the entity themselves. The movie traffics in reactionary right-wing politics: women as vessels of evil, and secular society putting the world in great danger. The Warrens' career focus was educating their followers that no longer believing in the Devil is what gives him his power and that disbelief and modern thinking will doom us all. The film ends with this weaponized message to the audience: “The devil exists. God exists. And for us, as people, our very destiny as people hinges on which we decide to follow.”
When supernatural horror movies falsely claim to be based on true events, they re-frame the historical persecution of women and marginalized people who were labeled witches. Under this revision, this warning that witches and dark magic are real, the victims of witch trials are portrayed as having gotten what they deserved. Under this revision, those who the church mistakenly believes have been tempted by the Devil into a life of sin actually are what the church says they are. Under this revision, our actions are guided by spirits, our misdeeds are the work of demons, and the Harry Potter books might actually be dangerous. Historically, when people get paranoid about some menace that they can't actually see – whether it's ghosts, demons, secret communists or secret terrorists – they are most likely to target the most vulnerable people. The Conjuring 2 continues its message. Lorraine is able to defeat the demon Valak by remembering something she wrote in her Bible. The Nun traffics in even more Catholic imagery. Lest you think the film is anti-Catholic because the nun is the antagonist, the film makes it abundantly clear that the demon in the film is not a nun but merely appears as a nun to remain undetected in the cloistered religious order.
AUDIO 4
The film begins with a Latin phrase “God ends here” to describe the demon's resting place, features a young man using a crucifix for self-defense and most prominently features a group of nuns as the best weapon against the demon. The same actor who played Ed Warren starred in another demonologist supernatural horror film series: Insidious. The conceit of this film series is the same, that demons are out to possess us and that only those of strong convictions can stop them. Although, the Insidious film series has no pretensions about being derived from “true” stories. Some supernatural horror films go one step further with their “true story” declarations. Rather than claim to be based on actual events, the horror movie is based on Biblical prophecy or at least the screenwriter's interpretation of Biblical prophecy. That way, even though the story in The Omen is merely a work of fiction, the predominantly Christian audience can believe that something like this could or even will happen due to it being in the Bible. The Omen and many other supernatural horror films that quote the Bible are actually misquoting the Bible quite a bit or at least twisting it to have even more sinister implications – something that better suits a horror film.
Horror movies can be critical of faith – such as The Sacrament – but the conceit of supernatural horror specifically is that the supernatural exists. This makes supernatural horror movies that are critical of Christianity, such as Carrie, still exist in a world and with a worldview that is familiar to Christianity, comforting to Christianity. Some supernatural horror movies, such as Frailty, give us a setup that makes the audience believe they are watching something critical of religious zealotry, only to be told that supernatural forces were in play the whole time. [PART 3: Have the Heard the Word of Not Jesus?] Supernatural horror movies made in the west depict non-Christian religions with suspicion or sometimes outright panic. In The Exorcist, Father Merrin learns of Pazuzu. In Ancient Mesopotamian religion, Pazuzu was the king of the demons of the wind. In the film, Pazuzu possesses the body of a Christian girl, Reagan. Pazuzu is not only a demon but a foreign demon from a foreign religion. The fact that it predates Christianity is a threat to the Church and to the audience of the film.
AUDIO 5
Pazuzu must be destroyed, and he must be destroyed by the Catholic Church. Rejected by the Church. Movies like The Serpent and the Rainbow depict Vudu as inherently dangerous and frightening. In truth, Vudu is a series of different but interrelated religions which originated in West Africa and became popular in the Caribbean. Supernatural horror's most common target is the Church of Satan, depicting them as murderers and a cabal that exists only for human sacrifice. The Church of Satan is actually far less sensational and does not teach belief in the Devil. Wicca, meaning modern pagan witchcraft, is perhaps the second most frequent antagonist. Horror movies about witches make no differentiation between Wicca and diabolical, fantasy black magic, and this purposeful obfuscation has undoubtedly lead to some ignorance. Often, devil worship and witchcraft are conflated or at least joined together as if one serves the other. Midsommar features a superficially pleasant but dangerous cult. Hereditary features a fanatical cult that worships Paimon. The director of both Midsommar and Hereditary is not a Christian, but his films still traffic in the “otherness” and villainy of unorthodox religions.
The Wicker Man depicts a group of pagan fanatics who plan a human sacrifice, but this film is a little more complicated in its messaging about religious zealotry in general. The protagonist, a deeply conservative Christian, is also the subject of criticism by the film, and some interpret the narrative as burning away old conservative ideas. However, most horror films with Christian elements have no such nuance. According to Christian Horror: On the Compatibility of a Biblical Worldview and the Horror Genre, horror movies require “...an ultimate good to frame evil. Horror is horrific precisely because it is a perversion of something good, pure, normal, right, and/or true. ... Horror intersects with religion because they both appeal to a supernatural view of the world and grapple with existential questions about life, being, and nature.” The problem is that supernatural horror made in western nations by default frame Christianity as “normal” and “true” and subsequently frame any other religion or a lack of religion as abnormal and false. These movies don't only frame life as a battle between good and evil but as a battle between the Christian God and anything that might be opposed to the Christian God.
AUDIO 6
[PART 4: The Skeptic] A supernatural horror film almost always has a skeptic, a character who exists in the movie to be proven wrong. Usually, the skeptic will conduct a series of tests to determine what exactly is the real underlying problem. If the skeptic is investigating a demonic possession, those tests will probably be psychological. If the skeptic is investigating what they believe to be a staged hoax, those tests might be interrogations of the characters who claim their home is haunted or that their children have consorted with the devil. In The Exorcist, Reagan is put through a battery of medical tests, x-rays, scans of her brain and so forth to determine why her behavior has suddenly changed. The doctors give reasonable explanations, but naturally, with this being an exorcism film, they are building towards these notions being disproved and a real demon emerging later in the movie. The doctors, the scientists, these “great, modern thinkers” can't solve the problem – only the Catholic Church can. He is proven wrong. In Ghost Stories, the protagonist is the skeptic. He is proven wrong. In The Last Exorcism, the skeptics are an entire film crew trying to expose a hoax. They are proven wrong, too.
The identity of the skeptic changes from movie to movie, but one fact remained constant over the past few decades in supernatural horror produced in the west: the skeptic is almost always proven wrong. For all talk among right-wing pundits about secular Hollywood corrupting the God-fearing masses, Hollywood is the most ardent defender of the supernatural and therefore Christianity by default. Hollywood consistently tells its audiences that the skeptic is the fool, that modernity and science cloud our perceptions about what is true. This is not necessarily for reasons of intentional propaganda. Hollywood is not run by the Pope, thank God. Christianity is the default faith of the characters of the film due to dominant ideology and demographics, and supernatural horror rejects skeptical interpretations more often out of necessity than as propaganda – the movie might not be as exciting if the ghost or demon or devil were revealed to be a harmless prank. Nevertheless, the end result of reinforcing dominant ideology remains. For reasons of keeping the movie engaging, the only way the supernatural event can be revealed as false is if the revelation is as engaging as the presumed supernatural event.
AUDIO 7
For example, in the 1990 film Whispers, a character at first believed to be some demonic figure returned from the dead is shown to be the twin brother of the deceased. The skeptic in the film was proven right. These outcomes are rare and have become even more rare as the years go on. But it wasn't always like this. Skepticism was not always portrayed as so one-sided. A classic Hollywood story – no longer commonly used – was that a haunting or other supernatural event was revealed to be a hoax or misunderstanding. And that the characters' skepticism was justified. In these films, belief in ghosts is not only a mistake but detrimental to the well-being of the protagonist. In some of the earlier films, someone might be frightened to death by a “ghost” that is revealed not to be a ghost at all. If was often the job of the heroic skeptic to uncover the truth. In the 1938 film Religious Racketeers, a skeptic tries to expose fake mediums. The turning point may have been The Exorcist, a film that is not only Christian by default but features a Catholic priest who has lost his faith and must vanquish not only the demon Pazuzu but his own doubts about the existence of God. The demon may be the antagonist, but his character arc and development doesn't center around saving a child but regaining his faith.
In The Exorcist, faith is the key to defeating Pazuzu. Skepticism actually hinders the investigation – it is not only unhelpful but puts Reagan in greater risk by not performing the exorcism. The film was incredibly popular and to this day continues to spawn pretenders to its throne. Atheism as an obstacle to victory is a recurring theme in supernatural horror movies. In From Dusk Til Dawn, Jacob Fuller is a former pastor who abandoned his faith following the death of his wife. Jacob is needed to make holy weapons to fight vampires. The template was created, the repetition and formula was set, and now every supernatural horror movie requires someone to disbelieve the supernatural, be proven wrong and often even have that change in worldview be central to both character development and the victory over the demonic antagonist. Sometimes the supernatural horror movie can be more nuanced than “skepticism = bad” but sometimes, yes, the underlying message is, well, skepticism = bad. It is an affirmation of the religious audience. An atheist can't kill Dracula. Only we – the believers – can kill Dracula. Amen.
MASTERS OF THE UNIVERSE
AUDIO 1
In Masters of the Universe, Skeletor has conquered Castle Grayskull and declared himself ruler of Eternia. He learns that He-Man and his comrades have a cosmic key that can save the Sorceress and put a stop to Skeletor's plans to become a golden god. Skeletor says “I must possess all or I possess nothing.” Skeletor's victory is all that matters. He has no plans after said victory. He simply wants...to win. Later on, the Sorceress breaks down who and what Skeletor really is. “Men who crave power look back on the mistakes they've made in their lives, pile them all together and call it destiny.” After Skeletor has captured He-Man, he taunts him while also becoming introspective, saying “Tell me about the loneliness of good, He-Man. Is it equal to the loneliness of evil?” In an interview, Frank Langella said he added this line himself. Skeletor's goal of becoming master of the universe is fruitless and not only because he loses in the end, sequel-baiting another story that never came. Skeletor's goal of ruling Eternia is fruitless because of how isolating it is and because his quest to sit on the throne of Grayskull, open the Great Eye and become a god has an end point.
There is a finality to it. When your end goal in life is to seek great power but not to use that power toward some other end, the victory is empty. When someone achieves some executive position, it might come as a great relief because they are no longer as susceptible to financial ruin or anxiety about paying the bills. But Skeletor, prior to taking the throne of Grayskull, clearly does not live in anything resembling poverty if he has an army at his disposal. When someone achieves some higher office, they can do it for as long as it is satisfying and then retire early to write an autobiography or do high-paying speaking engagements. Skeletor can never retire following an armed coup. Skeletor shouts that the universe is power, which means he sees power not as a means to an end but as an end in and of itself. This means that Skeletor doesn't plan to do anything in particular with this newfound power. He can rule Eternia, but what does that mean to a man like Skeletor? Draft infrastructure bills? Summon Evil-Lyn and Beast Man to propose new healthcare reform laws? Skeletor doesn't seem like the kind of man who has any interest in ruling Eternia in the sense of sustaining and caring for Eternia.
AUDIO 2
His boldest actions will probably be rounding up rebels. In the beginning of the film, his first decree is that anyone who doesn't pledge themselves to him will be destroyed. He makes no other decrees to the people of Eternia throughout the film. He has no plan after he takes over Eternia and ascends to godhood. In other words, maintaining his rule will be his only focus. Dictators and power-hungry politicians – the “great men” that the Sorceress references – want power simply so they can claim to be powerful. They treat that power not like a responsibility but more like a sports championship. A champion doesn't do anything with his power except declare themselves the best in the instant they receive it and then spend the rest of the time defending their title. To Skeletor and the “great men,” that is what ruling Eternia is. A championship that he sought, one with which he has no interest in doing anything else but defend, in his case, from rebellions. The throne of Grayskull will make him grow more and more isolated from everyone around him – the loneliness of evil.
Skeletor has contempt for everyone around him. His first words in the film are demanding a report from Evil-Lyn, but he speaks to her as if she were an animal. He says “Report, Evil-Lyn. Speak!” like one talks to a dog. He incinerates another minion, shouts orders and commands an army of completely faceless soldiers. He thinks nothing of them – but he keeps them around. He could rule from afar and barely interact with her underlings, but he chooses to sit on the throne and have his servants and assassins come to him. He's...lonely. Loneliness is referenced several times in the film. Skeletor requires distractions to keep himself from recognizing this in himself. Skeletor only tells this to He-Man, the person Skeletor sees as his opposite. But Skeletor also wonders if He-Man, though his opposite, is as lonely as he is, if the responsibility of being the hero of Eternia is as isolating as the burden of being the villain of Eternia. Skeletor desperately wants He-Man to be as lonely as he is, to justify his own loneliness. He-Man, however, is not isolated. He obviously has strong bonds with Teela and Man-at-Arms and very easily becomes friends with two people from Earth.
AUDIO 3
This fact would undoubtedly drive Skeletor into an even greater depression. If he had not been defeated at the end of the narrative, this would have only gotten worse for Skeletor once he ascends to godhood. He will be even more isolated from the people around as the commoners and even his evil henchmen can't possibly comprehend him. Relationships are built on a mutual trust, and if Skeletor has no more equals as he triumphantly announces during his “I am a god” speech, he will grow ever lonelier and subsequently fall even further into despair. Someone with too much time alone and time to contemplate their own existence can often fall into a kind of existential ennui. Philosopher Blaise Pascal once remarked “All of humanity's problems stem from man's inability to sit quietly in a room alone.” Relationships are a defense that keeps these thoughts away from us because if we are not alone, we don't have to spend as much time in our own heads contemplating the meaninglessness of our lives. Skeletor has no one close to him. Evil-Lyn and his minions abandon him in his time of need near the end of the film.
His loneliness is only going to get worse if he defeats He-Man, arguably the most important relationship he has. Pascal said that one alternative to despair is to turn to God, but now that Skeletor is God, he is now the only person in existence for whom that is not an option – isolating him further. Skeletor conquering Castle Grayskull, becoming a golden deity and ruling over Eternia has an inherent, unavoidable problem for him: what now? What is he supposed to do with his life now that he has nothing left to do? If the goal one chooses for themselves to give their life meaning has a specific end point, then anything Skeletor does following his ascension is even more meaningless to him that the actions he took to distract himself from his loneliness and his inconsequential existence. Shortly after his decree, he looks at the halls of Grayskull and says that he has waited so long for this moment, but...then the moment is over. He wanted nothing EXCEPT his victory, and now that he has his victory, he wants NOTHING and is NOTHING.
SNL
AUDIO 1
Liberalism, as a political ideology, is based on liberty and equality before the law. Historically, those in favor of liberalism had exceptions on who could receive this liberty and equality, just not as many exceptions as those to their political right. One integral component to liberalism is capitalism – an economic system in which the means of production are privately owned. “Classical liberal” philosophers stated that since liberalism is all about freedom, then the market must be “free” as well, even if that market makes others less free. This seems to be a contradiction because of the social ills that capitalism causes like economic disparity, poverty and, I don't know, the literal destruction of our environment that will cause our planet to be either inhospitable or even uninhabitable by human beings. And it is a contradiction of sorts, but the contradiction fluctuates here and there over the course of history. If liberalism were a numbered list of what it is, capitalism would not always be the number one priority among all liberals. But capitalism is prioritized under the predominant form of liberalism in the modern day: neoliberalism. And if you stick with me throughout the video, I will be happy to explain further through the time-honored tradition of using a well-known, mainstream example to make this easier to understand and a heck of a lot more palatable than reading the works of David Harvey and other critics of neoliberalism.
I am referring, of course, to Saturday Night Live. [title] Before we get to SNL, we have to understand some basic definitions. You can't build a house without a foundation. I promise this part will only take a few minutes. In the United States, “liberalism” has a noticeably different meaning than in much of the developed world. In the US, a “liberal” is anyone who is to the left of conservatives. And since conservatives in the US are particularly far-right compared to much of the developed world, a “liberal” is actually closer to a centrist in terms of social issues and center-right in terms of economic issues, at least by the standards of other developed nations. A US “liberal” politician or voter may consider themselves on the opposite end of the political spectrum than a conservative, but a more objective placement of liberals in the US by global standards is somewhere in the center and perhaps even to the right. In Canada, the Liberal Party is well-known as the centrist party with the Conservative Party to its political right and the New Democratic Party to its political left. In the United Kingdom, the Liberal Democrats are the centrist party with the Conservative Party to its right and Labour to its left.
AUDIO 2
In much of the world, “liberalism” is understood as centrist, which means in the US, the only two parties that hold any real power are either conservative – the Republican Party – or centrist – the Democratic Party. “Liberalism” and “Conservatism” are ideologies. An ideology is a system of ideas that form the basis of a political belief or policy. All ideologies state facts but then use those facts to come to different conclusions and to perform different actions. Example: black Americans outnumber white Americans among the prison population. A left-wing examination of this fact would note that black Americans are far more likely to be convicted of the exact same crime as a white American. Also that generational wealth and other factors have unfairly lead to black Americans being more impoverished than white Americans which can sometimes lead to crime. Also, black Americans are policed more heavily than white Americans, racism is a factor in policing, and that the prison pipeline is the product of privatization of prisons. These factors would lead to the conclusion that systemic racism has a hand in this discrepancy in prison populations, capitalism has a hand in the exploding prison population in general, and that steps should be taken to drastically change the criminal justice system.
Conversely, a fascist would look at the prison population and have that fact reinforce their belief in white supremacy and the genetic inferiority of some people. Same fact, different conclusions based on their ideologies. Liberalism, as an ideology, is opposed to The Left because The Left opposes capitalism or is skeptical of the benefits of capitalism. “The Left” does not contain liberals. It contains socialists and other leftists. Whether socialists want to count democratic socialists and social democrats among their numbers is another topic altogether, but suffice it to say, the left rejects what liberalism has predominantly become – neoliberalism. Neoliberalism has a variety of definitions and people argue over what exactly it means, but the best and simplest definition is that it is the ideology that capitalism is an overall good and that social progress, historically a liberal ideal, is best achieved through capitalism. In fact, neoliberalism as an ideology prioritizes capitalism. Neoliberalism does not take far right social positions like arch-conservatives and fascists, but it still prioritizes capitalism over the public good. It frames capitalism as serving the public good through itself in a kind of circular logic. A politician does not even have to be a liberal in order to further the ideology of neoliberalism. See: Ronald Reagan.
AUDIO 3
Naturally, capitalism inequitably benefits very few people over the vast majority of the world, but neoliberalism posits that the good of the corporation is to the benefit of all, regardless of evidence to the contrary. Previous versions of liberalism imagined society to be divided into distinct public and private spheres. The public sphere was the under the rule of the state, and its role – at least on paper – was to ensure the legal rights and freedoms of citizens through rule of law. The private sphere included the economy. Politics took shape around the line between public and private, a kind of struggle over where to draw the line. Within liberalism, politics was a question of how to define and uses and limits of the state within capitalism. Neoliberalism erases the line between public and private and to create a society based on private market competition – capitalism. Neoliberalism adjusts the horizons of the struggle between public and private. The state does not go away but is instead reconstructed toward the new end of expanding private markets. Under neoliberalism, social progress occurs but only incrementally because it can only be allowed if it's profitable. There is a reason why every US corporation has begun taking advantage of pride month.
A corporation is not a person no matter what the Supreme Court says. So, a corporation did not have a come to Jesus moment as it relates to treating the LGBT community with respect. Rather, the people within the corporation crunched the numbers and concluded that courting the LGBT community is now more profitable than not courting the LGBT community. That's not to say that Oreo tweeting support for gay people is somehow a “bad thing.” It's promising and telling about our society that this is no longer corporate suicide. However, it is an example of how our sluggish, incremental social progress happens under neoliberalism and how social progress can only be achieved when economically convenient. This also means that if the status quo is economically convenient, then it must be maintained. Under neoliberalism, privatization of public works and de-regulation are both permissible if they are profitable. Now, in fairness, some neoliberal politicians are in favor of more safety regulations and less privatization than the far-right, but that is only incrementally better than the worse alternative rather than an actual public good.
AUDIO 4
Also, while it is undoubtedly better that important safety regulations exist than not exist, these regulations also exist to reinforce the idea of capitalism among the populace as a public good, to draw contrast between themselves as the erroneous “good capitalists” and divert attention from the ills of capitalism as a system. Now, Saturday Night Live...remember Saturday Night Live? This is an essay about Saturday Night Live. [coughs] SNL is a late-night variety show with comedy sketches and musical acts. It was created by Lorne Michaels who was the primary show runner from 1975 to 1980. He returned around 1985 and has been its show runner and executive producer ever since. It airs on NBC, and its production company is Broadway Video, owned by Michaels himself. If you listen to Donald Trump, you might mistake SNL for a far-left television series with performers taking revolutionary or at least firm stance against the status quo. But the truth is Broadway Video is a business, and much like neoliberalism as an ideology, SNL is only as progressive or left-leaning as a business will allow – not very. SNL pays lip service to progressive causes while maintaining enough of the status quo to not alienate conservatives – either as voters or viewers.
This means that SNL will never directly challenge capitalism and will often mine humor from conservative or even reactionary talking points if it suits the show. The primary consideration under neoliberalism is capitalism, and the primary consideration under capitalism is competition against other competing entities for a greater share of the market with the end goal of monopoly. Thus, the primary consideration for SNL is whether or not this show, idea, host or opinion will draw ratings and earn more advertising money. Liberals might argue that this means SNL has no ideology, but “I'm apolitical” is itself a political stance and usually a rather telling one. Neoliberalism has become such a “default” that it has become ideologically invisible. Much in the same way that I know how to drive a car but don't know the names for all the parts or how to fix it, one can perform under neoliberalism without even knowing the definition of the word or the larger systems in which we are all participating. Neoliberalism pushes back against social progress that is deemed unprofitable, not yet profitable or too radical, and pushes back against economic progress that grants granter power to the people and less power to corporations.
AUDIO 5
Let's look at some of the ways that SNL does these two things, the ways that SNL reinforces a neoliberal ideology among its audience. In 2015, Larry David guest starred and played Bernie Sanders, and the takeaway from the sketch was this: [So far left, it could never be elected.] Neoliberal media doesn't hold up a big banner and say “We love capitalism” but instead engages with topics related to capitalism uncritically. In 2018, Steve Carell guest hosted and played Amazon founder Jeff Bezos in a sketch meant to lift up Bezos and poke fun at Donald Trump. Prior to the sketch, Bezos dominated the headlines after Amazon announced it would open up headquarters in Queens, New York and Crystal City, Virginia. New Yorkers protested the move, as a similar Amazon HQ in Seattle helped drive up rent prices for locals and exacerbate income equality. Another concern was that all of the money the city was giving to Amazon amounted to “corporate welfare” and could be better used for public services and people in need. Not to mention the fact that Amazon is owned by the wealthiest businessman in the world and does not require this corporate welfare to continue his business and the fact that Amazon is a viciously anti-union corporation that has been consistently criticized for the way it treats its workers.
The SNL sketch completely ignored this, glossed over New Yorkers' concerns and focused on presenting the image of the “good capitalist” over Trump, the bad capitalist. When the deal between New York and Amazon fell through, Colin Jost remarked that regardless of what anyone thought of Amazon, this deal would have created jobs. Yes, but investing the money into new jobs instead of Jeff Bezos' pockets would do that, too, COLIN. SNL will, far more often than not, reinforce the status quo of capitalism and the profit motive. SNL is no stranger to reactionary social positions as well, like when Colin Jost blamed the Trump victory on there being more than two genders. No, COLIN. Trump won because of voter suppression, a less than exciting opponent, a massive media push to shine a spotlight on Trump including your own show, COLIN, and an electoral system that can allow someone who received the vast majority of votes to still “lose” to a less popular candidate. It is not the fault of people who are now just beginning to be treated like human beings, COLIN. I get that it's a joke, but it's also transphobic, COLIN.
AUDIO 6
This is actually something that SNL does all the time. It reinforces a neoliberal status quo, not a left-wing or even a progressive position. There are frequent examples of dismissing “identity politics” and intersectionality. [Here are some examples]. SNL traffics in homophobia so long as that homophobia is directed at someone they don't like. Of course, the homophobia will not affect the person they don't like, they are far too powerful, so the homophobia will actually affect the most vulnerable people. SNL makes Trump and Vladimir Putin out to be secret lovers. The false idea that all or most homophobes are gay lays the blame of homophobia on LGBT people. It is blaming a group of people for their own subjugation. Under this false idea, the only people discriminating against “the gays” are “the gays” – it shifts the blame to the victims of homophobia and discrimination rather than the perpetrators of homophobia and discrimination. These are only a few examples from the most recent season. This has been going on for decades. But SNL has done something far worse and an even clearer example of neoliberalism – profit as priority over all else.
On November 7, 2015 – roughly a year before election day – Donald Trump hosted Saturday Night Live. The decision to allow Trump to host was met with incredible criticism from the left and from garden variety liberals. This was following Trump's fear-mongering remarks about Mexicans coming into the country to rape and murder us but before his fear-mongering remarks about calling for a “total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States.” It is not unusual for politicians to appear on SNL. Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, Rudy Giuliani, Sarah Palin and countless others have appeared for cameos and one-off sketches. However, it is unusual for politicians to host the show. John McCain has done it twice in 2002 and 2008, Jesse Jackson did it once in 1984 during his presidential campaign, and that's about it. There are over 800 episodes of SNL, and those few are about the only examples. Trump hosted SNL before during the run of The Apprentice, but this was long before his campaign. SNL undoubtedly believed that the controversy would draw ratings, and they were correct in that assumption. Neoliberalism prioritizes earnings and maintaining capitalism above all other concerns.
AUDIO 7
That means that genuine concerns about Trump's appearance further legitimizing a racist demagogue to the American public and concerns about helping a campaign that would make this man leader of the free world went ignored in favor of a short-term ratings boost. The Trump host episode in 2015 was easily one of the worst that SNL ever presented. Trump could not act, which meant that nearly all his sketches navigating their way around this by having him almost always face directly into the camera so he could surreptitiously read the cue cards. Worse than that, the sketches that featured Trump could only be mildly critical of him. Trump famously eschews any real criticism. His Comedy Central Roast years prior was apparently knee-capped by orders to stay away from certain sensitive subjects. Without a doubt, some writers and performers were uncomfortable with both the decision to allow him to host and the decision to make light of his failings rather than sincerely criticize him, but as in all cases, the workers and management are defined by unbalanced power dynamics. Kate McKinnon is not as powerful as Lorne Michaels. Let's go through all of the segments that featured Trump.
The monologue started off with Trump congratulating himself on his wealth and, for some reason, his looks, then transitioned into mocking Rosie O'Donnell and doubling-down in his statements about her looks. Then we had a series of unfunny Trump impersonations, interrupted by SNL completely dismissing criticism against their show. Larry David played a malcontent in the audience, completely taking the wind out of the protest by mocking it. Next was a sketch about Trump as President, a dark portent of things to come, that made light criticism against Trump's outrageous and dogwhistle racist claims of making America great again. They made a joke about the ludicrous idea of Omarosa becoming part of the Trump administration a couple years prior to Trump actually doing that. Ivanka Trump, the real one, made an appearance and received NO applause whatsoever for her unannounced guest spot. Again, the joke is supposed to be that Trump has his daughter have influence in his administration, and then two years later, he literally did that. This sketch is even worse in retrospect. Ivanka said her lines, and the room grew ten degrees colder.
AUDIO 8
Hey, you know how Donald Trump is a terrible racist whose very words have incited violence against Hispanic immigrants? Well, that's just another border wall joke for SNL. Isn't it funny? Our host is a racist monster with blood on his hands! The next sketch is the various SNL cast members learning about Trump's mean tweets about them. The same platform that has seen Donald Trump radicalize his followers. Then they made light of Trump's “birtherism” – a racist campaign against the United States' first African-American president. None of this is actually mocking Trump. It's a roast – poking gentle fun for the purpose of praising someone rather than sincerely deriding them. The rest was part embarrassing and part vile. The episode did a lot to humanize Trump to the American public. All his worst features, his racism, his sexism, his insensitivity, his bad policies – the gravity of what he wanted to say and do to the country was taken out. Criticism against him was deflated. Once it's a joke, it's not serious anymore. That's not to say that SNL was solely responsible for getting Donald Trump elected. That would be ridiculous...but his guest host spot was symptomatic of neoliberal media that saw Trump not as a genuine threat but as a ratings winner.
Donald Trump was given significantly more media coverage than any of his Republican opponents in the primary. By some estimates, he was given $2 billion worth of free advertising by the news media. Trump was ratings, and that was all that mattered. Every rally, every speech, every slip-up, every tweet was given an unbalanced amount of attention by the media. Donald Trump was a celebrity, one who said inflammatory things that, in a better world, would have made the media dismiss him and focus on more serious candidates. But we don't live in a better world. We live in a neoliberal world. We live in a world in which it's OK for SNL to give this man an hour and a half to promote his campaign for president. We live in a world in which Jimmy Fallon can have a completely friendly, charitable interview with a racist demogogue because it meant ratings. We live in a world where the media will spotlight anyone who might cause a stir and create ratings. Donald Trump did not get elected because of pronouns, COLIN. He got elected because it was profitable to give him that much attention and to treat him like a serious politician.
AUDIO 9
He got elected because of neoliberalism. [blank] One charge against SNL by the Republican Party and Donald Trump specifically is that the late night program has a radical leftist agenda for consistently mocking Trump himself even after he helped them pull in strong ratings for his guest host spot. The unceasing mockery and open opposition by the cast toward Donald Trump might seem unusual to some, but this does not a leftist agenda make. Mockery of Trump on SNL is not the result of far-left politics but of neoliberalism, as was mockery of previous presidents. The mockery is performed across both parties because of the economic incentive to do so, a neoliberal concern. The President of the United States is always the most famous figure in the country. Lampooning famous figures draws in viewers more than lampooning barely known figures due to recognition and familiarity. Remember, the primary consideration for SNL is whether or not this will draw ratings and earn more advertising money – not whether or not it will help someone get elected or removed from office.
In the late 80's and early 90's, Dana Carvey performed an exaggerated impersonation of then president George H.W. Bush. His hand gestures and clownish facial expressions did not resemble Bush, but this caricature of Bush became what many thought of when they thought of Bush. This sketch is about the early days of the Gulf War, and while there is a whiff of anti-imperialist leftism in the sketch when Carvey references the failure of Vietnam, it's never explored. Carvey quickly pivots to his Bush catchphrase – “wouldn't be prudent” – and then goes on a comical tirade about receiving Christmas gifts from other countries to help support the war. The real George H.W. Bush ran a racist campaign to become president, committed a horrific war crimes, refused to cooperate with the Iran-Contra special counsel, continued Reagan's policy of allowing AIDS to continue unchecked and ramped up the racist war on drugs. SNL's portrayal of Bush Sr, however, made him a lovably goofy figure. His portrayal was endearing, so much so that the subject of this mockery made an appearance on SNL that received wide acclaim. It's not in the financial interest of SNL to bring up Bush's war crimes. It's not as easy to get a cheap laugh from that.
AUDIO 10
Bill Clinton was portrayed by Phil Hartman and later Darrel Hammond throughout the Clinton administration. The real Bill Clinton helped bring about mass incarceration of people of color in America. SNL's portrayal of Clinton was that of a horny doofus. The primary consideration was not to get Clinton impeached. It was to make money off of Clinton's embarrassing scandal but not rock the boat too hard in such a way that would alienate viewers. Left-wing concerns about Clinton's neoliberalism and racist endorsement of the 1994 federal crime bill were ignored and instead replaced with only playful mockery of Clinton as merely an amorous trouble-maker that men could relate to. The impersonation of Barack Obama is not remembered as fondly or even as well because there isn't much that's inherently funny about him. However, Obama's portrayal on SNL does highlight the difference between the political right's criticism of this president and the left's criticism.
The right's criticism of Obama was full of lies, that he was foreign born or that Obamacare would install “death panels” in place of doctors. The right's cheap shots were usually about inconsequential things like Grey Poupon and the color of his suits. Criticism of Obama from the right was laughable and that became the only funny thing about Obama for SNL. Criticism from the left, that Obama further escalated the war on terror which has resulted in untold civilian casualties, was ignored. Obama's bog standard neoliberalism was ignored because it would mean SNL turning the mirror against itself. SNL has always poked fun at politicians, and while the mockery of Donald Trump is both more frequent and pointed, this has less to do with an emboldened radical leftist agenda by Lorne Michaels of all people and more to do with the fact that there is significantly more material for the neoliberal SNL machine with which to craft and perform said mockery. Ratings for SNL have increased during the Trump administration in no small part due to the comical portrayal of Trump, which means those with financial interests in SNL have no objections to a Trump presidency.
AUDIO 11
The George H.W. Bush impersonation by Dana Carvey had to reach cartoonish exaggeration in order to make fun of a plain-spoken, unenthusiastic President who was more immune to gaffes – whereas the impersonation of Trump requires little, if any embellishment. Many Trump sketches are mere verbatim recitations of the Donald's own words in new context. None of these impersonations do much, if anything, to hurt the president. If anything, they humanize the president or turn him into such a cartoon character that he no longer seems threatening. Pop culture portrayals of sitting presidents and other politicians have an affect on how the public at large sees that figure. Take Sarah Palin, for instance, a politician whose career will forever be connected to her impersonation by Tina Fey on SNL. Fey later recognized that this humanized Palin, softened her image and made her arch-conservative politics less threatening instead of more threatening. Fey even addressed this in an episode of 30 Rock in which Tracy Morgan's character makes the Republican more electable.
SNL's inclusion of Donald Trump as a frequently recurring character may do more to both humanize and normalize the president, portraying him as just another in a long line of presidential impersonations, thereby legitimizing him to the audience. Admittedly, the options here are few. They could choose not to address the elephant in the room for four to eight years, but that could have its own problems. The third option could be to openly portray Trump as a monster and not as comic relief. The sketches could still be funny, but the humor could be darker and more pointed. This has probably never been considered. SNL goes to great lengths to avoid anything resembling real satire. The idea that Alec Baldwin's now famous impersonation of Donald Trump hurts the Trump presidency is not backed up by the history of how SNL's impersonations generally soften the image of politicians or the history of how SNL chooses its targets – whoever happens to be in the White House. Trump as a recurring character on SNL is OK'ed by Lorne Michaels for the same reason he wanted Trump as the guest host: because the primary consideration centers around capitalism. Any other consequences are secondary or even ignored.
AUDIO 12
Once again, based on some of the sketches, many of the SNL writers and cast probably legitimately dislike Trump, but that doesn't make SNL a left-wing show. It just means the SNL writers represent most of America, based on all available polling. Trump is objectively unpopular. SNL isn't going hard on Trump because Lorne Michaels thinks it's in the nation's best interest. Michaels donates to the Republican Party and has previously stated that Republicans can “take a joke” better than Democrats. Trump and SNL benefit from one another. SNL benefited from the ratings of the Trump host episode and the increased ratings during its Trump impersonation era. Trump benefited from how SNL normalized and legitimized him during the host episode and because it now allows Trump a talking point every Saturday night or Sunday morning; that he is under attack by the “liberal media” and “Hollywood” – two common refrains that galvanize his base and want to protect him. SNL makes self-satisfied liberals laugh harmlessly at Trump and makes conservatives want to defend “dear leader” even more.
Lorne Michaels might even hope that Trump gets re-elected, as it would allow the highly-rated Trump sketches to continue. Baldwin claims that he's done playing Trump – we'll see about that – but even if someone else takes on the role, SNL and Trump will both still benefit from the mockery on the late night show. It's a symbiotic relationship. Now, having heard all this, some might respond by saying “Well, of course the state and corporations put profits before everything else. You're not telling me anything I don't already know.” OK, but remember when I said that different ideologies use the same facts to come to separate conclusions and solutions? Both the state and corporations work together under the philosophy of neoliberalism to put the profit motive before every other consideration – regardless of the consequences. Do you think it should be that way or do you think it should not be that way? The point is not that it's happening. The point is...shouldn't we oppose it? And how? I certainly don't have all the answers. Neoliberalism is now a global hegemony – a dominant idea and system, and it's going to take a lot to fix the world. We can start by at least recognizing it when it's right in front of us – by supporting movements, direct action and even politicians who are skeptical of neoliberalism – by engaging with this ideology critically instead of uncritically – and by dismissing this hegemony as “natural” when it is most certainly unnatural and allowing ourselves to believe in the potential for a better world.