Update and scripts! (Patreon)
Content
Hi, everyone. Welcome to 2020 on Renegade Cut. You may have noticed that my last three videos have been on lighter topics than usual. Favorite Movies, a TV series I like, and the Oscars. Writing and researching about how messed up the world it is really takes an emotional toll, and I needed a few weeks to not hate everything. Well, that's over, and you can expect super serious stuff in the coming week. Hurraaaay.
Anyway, here are some scripts to some episodes from late last year:
BAD SUPERMAN
Superhero movies are not great at postmodern deconstruction. Postmodernism is a movement in art and criticism characterized by mistrust of previous traditions and styles. Postmodern deconstruction aims to pick apart the piece of art – its themes, its style, its message – and discover greater truth beneath the surface. In visual storytelling, postmodern deconstruction generally deconstructs either the genre itself or the themes that are common to the genre as a means of criticizing either genre or themes. The superhero genre or sub-genre, contains a great number of commonalities that cross over among intellectual properties and the stories that populate their fictional universes. Sometimes these commonalities are lampooned or remarked upon thoughtfully within the narrative. One commonality among superhero comics is that when a superhero dies, they will almost return one day. They will either be resurrected within the narrative or their death will be retconned altogether. This has become so common and comic book fans have become so aware of this inevitability – this knee-capping of consequences – that it is sometimes addressed within the narrative in a way that could be described as postmodern.
In Secret Avengers #15, released in July 2011, ordinary people are envious of a superhero because their deaths are often not permanent, but Black Widow says that this gives them different consequences: not knowing whether or not to mourn. Never knowing if this is “for real” this time. In Catwoman: Secret Files and Origins #1 from November 2002, in which Catwoman and Holly talk about resurrections in comics with one of them taking the “pro” side and the other the “con” side, not-so-subtly referencing the fact that Holly was retconned back into existence for this run of Catwoman. This is genre deconstruction – an examination of whether or not a commonality in the genre is worthwhile or a net good. Now, deconstruction of themes is different. Common themes across superhero comics and movies include the nature of heroism, duty, sacrifice and authority. Sometimes these messages about what it means to hero are implicit, such as Spider-Man learning to use his powers for good over the course of a story, and sometimes they are explicit. “With great power comes great responsibility.” A postmodern deconstruction of the common themes of superhero narratives might pose questions:
AUDIO 2
“Should someone have all this power without oversight? Is it heroic to break the law to potentially save others? Is it noble to kill people in the service of potentially allowing others to live? Why do audiences find these actions appealing, and what does it say about our beliefs related to justice that they do?” Postmodern deconstruction of themes looks more like...Watchmen. Released in 1986 and 1987, Watchmen added new “weight” to the aforementioned common superhero comic themes. Watchmen posited that some heroes may not be heroic, that duty to mankind might be corrupted, that sacrifice is not always noble and that authority is to be questioned, not obeyed. Postmodern deconstruction of superheroes became more popular but was still largely relegated to stories outside of the mainstream books, such as the out-of-continuity The Dark Knight Returns and The Authority, which was segregated into the Wildstorm line of comic books. Some postmodern superheroes stories were thoughtful, whereas some others were...The Boys. Fast forward to the modern era of superhero media: the explosion of superhero movies in the 21st century.
Mainstream superhero movies did not deconstruct the themes of superhero narratives – they reinforced them. Any flaws that a superhero might have were not related to deconstructing previous themes and traditions associated with superhero narratives. They were simply part of the superhero's traditional character arc. Iron Man was selfish and concerned only with money and fame, and then he grew as a person – kind of – by the end of the narrative. The film does not question Iron Man's actions during his character arc, though. His violation of airspace and borders as well as his extra-legal executions of human beings are portrayed as heroic. Cool guys don't look at explosions. This is a character arc, not self-reflection. In Captain America: Civil War, when the Avengers are eventually called out for their behavior, this calling out does not deconstruct the aforementioned themes but instead frames this admonishment as mostly wrong and coming from the mouths of the antagonists of the film. Civil War does not question Captain America's heroism or sense of duty or sacrifice – it reinforces it. The authority questioned in the film is not Captain America himself but anyone who gets in his way.
AUDIO 3
These movies do not question the themes of superhero narratives but instead reshape the themes to fit neatly into these movies. Actual deconstruction of superhero narratives within recent films has been a mixed bag, at best. Kick-Ass is a pastiche of references to other superhero films – a kind of loving genre deconstruction – but has nothing to say about what the audience considers heroism or what the audience should think about authority. Deadpool breaks the fourth wall and speaks directly to the audience, but his commentary is also on the superhero genre and not a deconstruction of why audiences might find the violence superheroes employ against “bad guys” to be appealing. The film adaptation of Watchmen lightens some of the weight of the narrative but turning the schlubby middle-aged crime-fighters with delusions of grandeur into hyper-competent, incredibly buff and sexy superheroes who perform impossibly graceful and cool kung-fu in slow-motion. The film adaptation retains a lot of Alan Moore's ideas – as much of it is shot-for-shot and directly adapted dialogue from the comic book – but the visual storytelling somewhat alters how the audience is meant to interact with the narrative and feel about Watchmen's thematic deconstruction of superheroics.
Mainstream superhero movies – even those with pretensions of being postmodern – need to walk a careful line. They need to pose serious questions but never answer them because the answers are not satisfying to an audience that just came to see Iron Man punch-catapault a man fifty feet into the air, undoubtedly murdering him. Perhaps the best opportunity to do this was also squandered completely. Earlier this year, the film Brightburn was released, a thinly-veiled Superman horror movie without explicitly using said intellectual property.
AUDIO 4
The opportunity to say something meaningful about those themes was there. The opportunity to ask the aforementioned questions was there. This is a postmodern superhero film – rated R – with no DC or Marvel intellectual property to satisfy and coddle. Low budget, which means low stakes for the studio. Counter-programming release during the summer movie season for anyone who doesn't want to see the new blockbuster but might be down for the never-fail genre of horror. Written by Brian and Mark Gunn, produced by James Gunn who is apparently bullet-proof, and directed by a man named David Yerovsky, a filmmaker with no reputation whosoever and therefore nothing to lose. And even with all of these pieces in place, they made a completely surface-level postmodern Superman movie with base, uninteresting observations and with nothing to say about heroism, authority or any of that. Now, someone is already angrily writing a comment to the effect of “Why do movies have to try to SAY something?” Well, maybe they don't have to try, but if you make a horror movie that uses the imagery and iconography of a long-established, beloved figure, we can't help but think that there must be a reason for that.
A reason beyond trading on this mythology to get people to watch your movie. This is the plot of Brightburn: it's the plot of Superman except instead of learning about his origins and resolving to do good and save the world, he learns about his origins and resolves to do evil and conquer the world. It's mere inversion. It's a transgression – contrarianism for the sake of being contrarian. More than that, “What if Superman but bad?” isn't even a fresh enough concept to be all that transgressive. It's a bog standard horror movie with a sprinkling of Superman dust on top of it to get people interested. And it worked. I went and saw it on the merits of it potentially being actually transgressive and/or a proper thematic deconstruction, and what I got was a modestly entertaining by-the-numbers horror. There's a blink-and-you'll-miss-it moment in which you can make out some words on a young girl's laptop, and some of it is a Nietzsche quote – ha, ha “ubermensch” Superman, get it? – but this is never explored. It's an Easter egg, not bread crumbs leading to a point. Worse still, if Brightburn does have a message, that message is the psuedoscience of biological determinism – the discredited idea that your behavior is either exclusively or almost exclusively dictated by your genes and your ethnic background.
AUDIO 5
It's used by racists to try to justify their place in the world as above other groups. It's the somewhat more modern form of phrenology but still deeply outdated and ignores everything we have come to know about people through sociology. Brandon, the Superman stand-in, is a well-adjusted young boy with caring parents and good values when suddenly his biology asserts itself. He can't escape his nature, his biology. I would say this is unintentional except there is a scene early in the film in which Brandon notes the differences between bees and wasps to his teacher, telling her that one is more aggressive by nature than the other. So, Brightburn does have a point, and though the Gunn siblings certainly do not mean it the same way that white supremacists do, it's still roughly the same point made by men like Stefan Molyeneux. We're not bees, everyone. That shouldn't be a controversial statement. We are animals, but we are not ONLY animals. I can understand people being bored with deconstruction by now, but I suspect that has less to do with the concept of self-reflection and to do with the fact that so much of it is transgression for the sake of transgression. Faux edgy nonsense.
“What if the thing you think is good...is actually BAD?!” That's not clever unless you have a greater point about why. Obviously most superhero movies need not be deconstructions of their own mythos. My favorite superhero movie is Superman – the least transgressive superhero movie ever. But when a movie tells you through its iconography that it might have something to say about an existing property, genre or set of themes and then absolutely does not, it's terribly disappointing. Anyway...bad Superman. Look how bad he is. Look! Down in the gutter! It's a bird, it's a plane, it's a piece of sh*t little kid. No, I'm not going to watch The Boys. So, just don't ask. I don't care.
RONALD REAGAN - AMERICAN SLASHER
The late 60's and early 70's were a time of rebellion and change – of a counter-culture that shunned traditional values and obstinate patriotism in favor of anti-imperialism. Hippies espoused free love, and activists criticized the principles of the United States of America. But time wore on. “The 60's were over, and people were once again ready to feel bad about themselves.” Cultures change, even counter-cultures change, and all of the sudden, it was like nobody wanted to join The Weather Underground anymore! Counter-cultures often have a cultural response, a reactionary movement that hopes to turn back the clock to the aforementioned traditional values. A combination of the rise of the religious right and the ascension of a certain president imposed these values on the nation, and with the hippies and activists all grown up and selling out, not enough people objected or even cared anymore. “Luckily, by then it was the 80's, and no one noticed.” It was morning in America again. So. Let's talk about slasher movies. Watching slasher movies, at least the most famous entries from the 80's, is like watching the horror version of what the 80's were like under the Ronald Reagan administration.
“You have to ask yourself: Who was the most towering, charismatic figure of the 1980's? And you could say Ronald Reagan or you could say Freddy Krueger. They both essentially pursued the same policy – that they were going to, through their actions, visit the sins of the father upon the children.” If pop culture is influenced by the culture that creates it and shaped by the time it's created, then there may be no greater pop culture reflection of the 1980's zeitgeist and 1980's social politics than Friday the 13th. Jason Voorhees and his mother before him felt like Ronald and Nancy Reagan, respectively. They were not directly inspired by them, of course, but the rampage of Jason mimicked the id of the Republican Party in the 1980's. “In the 1980's, at the height of the success of these movies, there were multiple cases made that he was the modern Reagan-era killer because he was making those kids who didn't 'just say no' or having pre-marital sex pay. It's like, watch out young people, be careful what you do or Jason's gonna come for you.” Whatever else Friday the 13th and all 80's slashers might be, they are very telling artifacts about the values, politics and culture of the time. They are culture...and counter-culture. “Do a lot of coke and vote for Ronald Reagan.” [I. Drugs]
AUDIO 2
Early in the first Friday the 13th movie, the teenagers meet a motorcycle cop. His name is Officer Dorf. That's his name! He's there to warn the teenagers that crazy Ralph is on the loose, but he also takes the opportunity to interrogate and harass them for suspected drug use. This sets the tone for the rest of the Friday the 13th film series. The victims smoke weed in Part III and do cocaine in Part V. In the 1980's, Nancy Reagan became the public face of the war on drugs. Her “Just Say No” campaign was hollow and empty and did not address the actual reasons for the drug epidemic or real solutions like treatment over punishment or decriminalization. The “war on drugs” actually began earlier during the Nixon administration but the modern form began under Ronald Reagan. Aggressive policing has led to the mass incarceration epidemic, which itself has fueled private prisons. Private prisons then have the money to lobby politicians for greater power, and those politicians then have no incentive to actually curtail the drug problem because the private prisons want more drug offenders, not less. Countless thousands of young, non-violent drug users are filling American prisons, where they then learn how to become violent criminals instead of what they were before: people who needed help.
The strict prohibitions on drugs have created economic incentives that make combating drug producers and distributors extremely difficult. The high black-market price for illegal drugs has generated huge profits for the groups that produce and sell them. That income is then invested in buying state-of-the-art weapons, hiring gangs to defend their trade, paying off public officials and making designer drugs that are easily available to children, to get them addicted. Measures that could have a meaningful impact are ignored, partly for the aforementioned money-in-politics reason but also because swaying public opinion toward solutions that are less about punishment and more about results is challenging in a nation that still holds puritan beliefs. Solutions like decriminalizing marijuana and decriminalizing small-scale possession of drugs were not options back in the 1980's, and though public opinion and gently swung toward the former, the war on drugs and the private prison pipeline are still in full effect today.
AUDIO 3
So, remember that escalation of drug use from the first few Friday the 13th movies to the cocaine in Part V? Well, this isn't just an escalation of Jason's body count getting higher and therefore the “sins” of the victims getting stronger. It's also history. Iran-Contra is the term used to reference the scandal involving the Reagan administration illegally selling weapons to Iran to fund the Contra terrorists in Nicaragua, but this treasonous scandal is even worse than it seems on the surface. The Reagan administration also helped fund the Contras with revenue from crack cocaine. Reagan and the CIA conspired with the Contras to smuggle cocaine from South America into the US. The administration shielded the smugglers from investigation. Reagan had Oliver North funnel the proceeds to the Contra army in Nicaragua. US flight crews smuggled both arms and cocaine on their return flights. Some hangars used to dock the airplanes were owned by the CIA and National Security Council, and some were operated by Oliver North himself. After the cocaine was smuggled into the US, it would then be sold to a drug distributors. The distributors would then convert the cocaine into crack and distribute it to street-level dealers.
The actions by the CIA and Reagan Administration are credited with sparking the crack epidemic by flooding the drug market with an unprecedented amount of high-quality cocaine at a low cost. The Reagan administration's own war on drugs was escalated due to the rise in drug crime, which itself was the responsibility of the Reagan administration to begin with! It's the political equivalent of “Stop hitting yourself! Stop hitting yourself!” So, in Friday the 13th: A New Beginning, when Bob and his girlfriend are doing cocaine and murdered by the impostor Jason, we get a clear look into both the secret and public drug policies of the Reagan administration. Remember: the killer in the Friday the 13th movies is judging the victims much in the same way that the Reagan administration did. The reason Bob has cocaine in the first place is probably because of Ronald Reagan, and he is then punished for getting high on cocaine by the killer – who is himself a supernatural and fictional stand-in for Reagan. Bob being punished by Reagan for doing drugs that he could only get because of Reagan is similar to the real world hypocrisy of the war on drugs.
AUDIO 4
By Friday the 13th: Part VIII: Jason Takes Manhattan, drug use is even more prevalent, but much like the Reagan administration, the drug users are portrayed as the “bad” people and the character who abstains is the good girl who followed Nancy Reagan's advice. If drug use and drug abstinence are moralized, then we don't have to sympathize with those who are addicted. We don't have to consider any solutions besides locking them up and making matters worse – both for them and for society at large. When doing drugs is framed as a moral failing and not an addiction that needs treatment, then we don't have to care. Speaking of moralizing... [II. Sex] Special effects guru Tom Savini said it best: “Sex, die. You have sex, you die. That's the premise. That's the underlying theme going through the Friday the 13th movies.” In the first film, Pamela Voorhees blames teenage camp counselors for what she believed she was the death of her son, Jason. The real culprit, however, was sex. The counselors were too busy having sex to notice Jason was drowning. [“They weren't paying attention. They were making love while that young boy drowned.”] The first kill in the film, during a set-up decades prior, is a teenage girl who had the audacity to have sex with her boyfriend.
Mrs. Voorhees goes on a murder rampage at the beginning of the 80's when the film was released. All these teenagers, hanging around, having sex, being young. Hey. F*** them, right? Mrs. Voorhees is the “concerned mother” of the 1980's, the Nancy Reagan. A reactionary force that wants to bring back traditional values that were “lost” in decades prior. A reactionary movement is a socio-political backlash against changing values or social norms. The free love of previous decades had to be stopped, and it was up to the conservative forces of the 1980's to put a stop all this. “What's interesting about the Friday the 13th movies is that if you watch those films, down to a film, Jason is compared with nature. In every one of the Friday the 13th films, there's a storm coming when he's coming. At the same time. So, is Jason actually an avenging force of God? Is he nature? Is nature angry, or is God angry with these teens for smoking weed or occasionally doing cocaine or having pre-marital sex? It's really interesting that the forces of the Moral Majority and the religious right had such an objection to these films because they were essentially depicting an Old Testament world. You behave badly, and you will be killed. Vice precedes slice and dice.”
AUDIO 5
What would eventually be known as the Christian right was solidified in the presidential race of 1980, the same year as the first Friday the 13th movie. A pivot in evangelical politics changed the relationship between religion and government. All three candidates in 1980, Democratic president Jimmy Carter, independent Republican John Anderson and Ronald Reagan described themselves as born-again Christians. Jerry Falwell supported Anita Bryant’s 1977 anti-gay-rights crusade, and Pat Robertson got involved with the Washington for Jesus rally of April 1980. During the 1980 campaign, Ronald Reagan and the evangelical conservatives engaged in a very public courting ritual. Moral Majority executive director Robert Billings signed on as a Reagan campaign adviser, and the 1980 Republican Convention was controlled largely by Moral Majority supporters in Alaska Republican organization. Congressman Guy Vander Jagt of Michigan, an evangelical conservative, delivered the keynote address. Reagan, during his acceptance speech, asked the party for a moment of silent prayer. The Christian Right had found a friend in their new president. The Christian Right's activism against “promiscuity” was a reactionary movement against the more permissive 1960's.
The broadening of sexual rights arising from Roe v. Wade gave them a banner issue. The Moral Majority pushed to ban sex education programs in public schools if the programs did not require parental consent. The group also opposed sex education programs “which reject Judeo-Christian rules” or which hint at “liberal sex education.” Following discovery of the first AIDS cases in 1981, it quickly became clear a national health crisis was developing. That is, it became clear among the medical community but not among the political right. AIDS became a tool in conservative politics and the Christian Right specifically to target gay men. Falwell said “AIDS is the wrath of God upon homosexuals.” Reagan's own communications director, Pat Buchanan said that AIDS is “nature's revenge on gay men.” Researchers and healthcare professionals demanded funding, but the response from the Reagan administration was largely that of indifference. On April 23, 1984, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention announced 4,177 reported cases in America and 1,807 deaths.
AUDIO 6
Writing in the Washington Post in late 1985, Representative Henry Waxman wrote: "It is surprising that the president could remain silent as 6,000 Americans died, that he could fail to acknowledge the epidemic's existence. Perhaps his staff felt he had to, since many of his New Right supporters have raised money by campaigning against homosexuals." Years later, Reagan finally addressed the issue of AIDS while president. His remarks came May 31, 1987 near the end of his second term. It was not only too late but too little – advocating abstinence instead of safe sex. Statistically speaking, safe sex education fares better than abstinence education, but the moralizing of sex requires punishment – not solutions. Friday the 13th's sex = bad and virginity = good binary had no room for the idea of safe sex. In Part V, someone mentions a condom, but it's...a joke? Once again, the moralization of something personal and private turns it into a stigma and something easily demonized and ignored. If sex is a “moral failing” then we don't have to help anyone who contracts a sexually transmitted disease. If sex is a “moral failing” then a pregnant teen has done something shameful. If sex is a “moral failing” then they...get what they deserve. In the 80's, sex became “scary” again instead of liberating.
[III] Friday the 13th Part V: A New Beginning features a grown-up Tommy Jarvis suffering from a mental illness and with minimal assistance. Rather than getting the care he needs, he's part of some rag-tag group of at-risk misfits. One of the first major legislative actions Reagan undertook as president was to repeal mental health reforms and slash federal funding for mental health care by 30 percent. As his presidency progressed, the Reagan administration basically threw people out of their mental health hospitals. During his presidency, approximately 40,000 beds were eliminated. In 1988, with his presidency dying down, the National Institute of Mental Health estimated that as many as 300,000 mental patients with chronic mental illness were homeless. Tommy's fate in Friday the 13th Part V is not too dissimilar to what it might have been in the real world. One criticism of the Friday the 13th movies is that most of the characters barely have personalities. In the first movie, they don't have any motivations or backstories. By the third, we get a handful of personalities, and by the fourth, we get Tommy Jarvis – the closest the film series has to a protagonist. He appears in IV, V and VI – played by three different actors.
AUDIO 7
In Part VII, we get Tina, one of the better characters throughout the series and a challenge for Jason. Also, Demon is great because his name is Demon, but these are few and far between. Many slasher movies in the 80's were like this. Not a lot of emphasis on a character's motivation outside of surviving the serial killer or undead monster. For the most part, nearly all the victims are are interchangeable. They are...disposable. That's how the Reagan administration saw a lot of people. These are not victims with hopes and dreams. These are...statistics. Because of this, audiences sometimes identified more with Jason or other slashers because they were the only recurring characters. If you ask the average person who is the main character of A Nightmare on Elm Street, they are more likely to say Freddy Krueger than Nancy Thompson – even though Nancy has a lot more depth than the average slasher movie character. But if you ask the average person who is the main character of Scream, they will probably think of Neve Campbell's character Sydney, if they don't immediately remember the character's name. Something happened to slasher movies in the late 80's and early 90's. Slasher movie series that began in the late 80's and 90's sometimes had a recurring protagonist.
Child's Play 1, 2 and 3 all feature Andy. Wes Craven's New Nightmare brought back Nancy, kind of. It became her story and not the story of a monster. One aspect of the Scream movies that sometimes goes unnoticed is this inversion of protagonist. In the Friday the 13th movies and A Nightmare on Elm Street movies, the star is the killer, and the victims change in each sequel. In the Scream movies, the star is the would-be victim, and it's the killer who changes in each sequel. By the 90's, this aspect of slasher movies was a joke. It might be a coincidence that the end of the Reagan era was also the end of disposable people in slasher movies...but it does seem to fit a little too neatly to be ignored, right? There were a lot of “panics” in the 1980's – ranging from the Satanic panic, an explosion of homophobia, continued panic during the waning days of the Cold War about communism, a panic about crime and drugs that was often racialized – and it's not hard to notice that these panics tend to come from the political right. It's no wonder slasher movies were so popular in the 80's. Conservatives, Ronald Reagan chiefest among them, always made us think there was a...boogeyman out to get us.
GEORGE W. BUSH
On March 2nd, 2017, former President George W. Bush appeared on The Ellen DeGeneres Show, hosted by the eponymous comedian. Bush laughed at himself and his inability to properly wear a poncho two months prior at the inauguration of President Donald Trump. Bush's “Aw, shucks” humility and TV dad persona seemingly clashed with the vulgar, mean-spirited bravado and rhetoric of the man at the center of said inauguration. For years, Bush had largely remained out of the public spotlight – for a time, the most notable aspect of his ex-presidency has been his life as an artist. His disastrous administration, long thought to be among the worst in the history of the United States, precipitated this isolation. Even when future presidential hopeful Jeb Bush spoke of George during the Republican National Convention, he could only reference the catastrophic presidency in patronizing terms. [MUSIC 2] Bush's administration presided over some of the worst disasters and lapses in judgment in history...but as years went on, two presidents later, Bush being kept out of the spotlight to paint and do little else gave the nation a kind of collective amnesia. Maybe with how fast everything moves today, and with news cycles that last only hours, holding on to the anger or even memory of the results of an election almost 20 years ago became too much for some people.
But more than that, more than the natural flow of time and new dangers replacing old ones, there has been an unmistakable media campaign to rehabilitate the image of George W. Bush. He has been seen cavorting with Barack and Michelle Obama, on friendly terms with the Clintons, and now a certified friend of a popular, clean comedian and reigning queen of daytime network television. Her recent play-date with Bush caused a bit of a stir, prompting criticism of this rehabilitation and DeGeneres' role in it. Put a pin in that. It'll come back around later. The attempt at rehabilitating both the image and presidency of George W. Bush has a lot of consequences, even as we are now two presidents removed from his administration. [1. Individualizing Removes Systemic Concerns] First, if we rehabilitate Bush, then the electorate can continue under the delusion that there are no systemic problems that have lead us to where we are today. The only “bad thing” is the “bad man” currently in the White House, and once he is gone, everything will be back to “normal” and “normal” is good. Donald Trump is easily one of the worst presidents of all time, but he may have a ways to go before he has as much blood on his hands as Bush – so far.
AUDIO 2
See, George W. Bush was better at “being president” than Trump, in the sense that Bush spoke like a human being and not like an angry, thin-skinned monster. Bush went through the rituals and mock public shaming and such that the President is expected to perform. President Trump, in terms of personality, is not presidential, but that alone doesn't make him automatically worse than Bush. History will have to take a “wait and see” approach following Trump's tenure as president. [2. Normalization of War Crimes] Second, when white liberals talk up George W. Bush as a glowing alternative to Trump, they normalize what he did. They normalize the wars, the civilian deaths, the poor response to Hurricane Katrina, the anti-LGBT legislation and so much more. If Bush is “normal” and is rehabilitated in the era of Trump, Republicans can wash their hands of Trump once he's gone and push the false narrative that Bush is a “real” Republican whereas Trump was an impostor. [3. Empowers Republicans] Another problem with rehabilitating the image and administration of George W. Bush is that is grants the Republicans another major figure to help the party. Remember, Bush has been mostly out of the spotlight until fairly recently. He campaigned a bit for his brother's doomed presidential bid, an act that many speculated could hurt more than help.
But with the resurrected Bush, the Republicans could now have a living, breathing Republican standard to endorse and help future Republican candidates. All the other former presidents are Democrats. The Republican Party has not been able to utilize either Bush as an individual or reference the Bush presidency as a positive. If he is rehabilitated, they can then use the memory of the Bush administration to strengthen their party. Before, the Bush administration was a black mark on their history, even among many conservatives. If the Bush administration is seen in a new light, the black mark goes away, and the administration can then be used as evidence of the “goodness” of the Republican Party. Such a rehabilitation and re-writing of history would strengthen whichever Republican is nominated for the presidency after Trump. The country doesn't have to look back, reflect and learn from past mistakes if those mistakes are white-washed and its perpetrators rehabilitated into harmless old grandpas who simply have “differences in political opinion” with their friends. Re-framing disgust with the George W. Bush administration as a “difference of opinion” is not only a transparent attempt at re-writing history and rehabilitation but also extremely insulting to the victims of said administration.
AUDIO 3
This is more than having friends and family who registered to vote under a different party. That's just life. This is different. This has consequences. Your friend who votes differently from yourself is probably not a war criminal. Bush is. So. Let's talk about that. [MUSIC 3] [II. War Crimes] Following the attacks of September 11th, 2001, the Bush administration demanded the Taliban in Afghanistan turn over Osama bin Laden, who was believed to be in hiding somewhere in the nation. After some international back and forth over the legality of threatening war over a matter of mere extradition, the administration asked Congress to pass The Authorization for Use of Military Force Against Terrorists, a resolution that allowed the US military to attack Afghanistan. Authorization to go to war, however, is not authorization to commit war crimes, at least not officially. Nevertheless, the amount of war crimes committed under the direct authorization of or indirect actions of the George W. Bush administration is staggering even by the standards set by previous presidents. Vice President Dick Cheney, Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld, and others in the Bush administration believed that international law placed unrealistic restrictions on the need for the United States to defend itself. On September 11, 2001, Bush is quoted by former head of the National Security Counter-Terrorism Group Richard Clarke as saying, “I don’t care what the international lawyers say. We are going to kick some ass.”
At this juncture, the Bush administration committed itself to war crimes. On January 25, 2002, as prisoners were being sent from Afghanistan to Guantanamo, Counsel to the President Alberto Gonzales issued a memorandum agreeing with Justice Department officials that the Geneva Conventions, which were signed in good faith, were now “quaint” and “outmoded,” and could be ignored by the United States. In the opinion of Jack Goldsmith, who later headed the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel, the January 25 memo constituted a “conspiracy to commit a war crime.” Chiefest among Bush's war crimes were the intentional targeting of civilians during war, authorization of torture and allowance of prisoner abuse such as in the cases of Abu Ghairab and Gauntanamo Bay. The specifics are grisly. As it relates to torture, in 2002, Donald Rumsfeld approved new rules to allow some forms of torture to be used against prisoners, including waterboarding which could result in hypothermia, forced stress positions and more. However, what was allowed in theory was expanded in practice. In 2004, images from the Abu Ghraib prison proved the US military was engaging in both physical torture and in some cases sexual abuse.
AUDIO 4
Congress, in response to the Abu Ghraib scandal, passed the Detainee Treatment Act of 2005, banning torture by the military but not the CIA. However, Bush’s signing statement indicated that he might authorize a violation of the law whenever he wanted. In terms of bombings, the numbers are massive, and in terms of civilians killed, the numbers are terrifying. All estimates of Iraq War casualties are disputed for varying political reasons, but even the low estimate at 200,000 people is an incredible loss of life. That is more than 70 9/11's. High estimates reach somewhere around 600,000 people, which is well over 200 9/11's. The George W. Bush administration caused a death toll of the equivalent of over 200 times the amount of Americans we lost on 9/11 – in one country alone. This is particularly tragic when said country had nothing to do with 9/11. Among other countries, the death toll grows higher. [MUSIC 4] I've discussed this at length in a previous video, but this bears repeating or at least summarizing. Contrary to popular belief that civilian casualties are marginal and unintended, Brown University's Cost of War project has proven that civilian casualties in the War on Terror outnumber military casualties. More civilians die in war than the people who either chose to fight or are conscripted to fight.
In addition to those killed by direct acts of violence, the number of indirect deaths – those resulting from disease, displacement and loss of critical infrastructure – is believed to be several times higher, running well into the millions. The Bush administration and its lawyers tried so hard to make their war crimes somehow not war crimes. Here are some examples. The Bush administration declared that the Geneva Conventions were inapplicable. It asserted that because those detained were not in uniform and this alone meant they were somehow not covered by the Third Geneva Convention. But the document confers no such immunity from coverage.
AUDIO 5
Article 3 states that all those no longer taking an active part in hostilities, including those captured or surrendered in war are initially protected. Next, the Bush administration claimed an exemption because terrorists, both individually and collectively, have not ratified the Geneva Conventions and thus cannot claim protection. However, there is no reciprocity requirement. According to Article 2, all signatories to the Conventions are unilaterally bound by the provisions. Finally, Bush’s lawyers argued that Article 5 of the Fourth Geneva Convention had a loophole, namely that provisions were inapplicable “while the armed conflict continues.” However, the Conventions state that the exception is only intended to be “applied in individual cases of an exceptional nature.” Instead, the US military under the direction of the Bush administration indiscriminately rounded up thousands in Afghanistan and later Iraq. Some were not even screened for months. On September 6, 2006, Bush asked Congress to amend the War Crimes Act of 1996 in order to decriminalize their actions -- retroactively. Among the war crimes that he thereby implicitly admitted authorizing in the past were disappearances, extrajudicial imprisonment, torture, transporting prisoners between countries, and denying the International Committee of the Red Cross access to prisoners.
On the same day, Bush ordered that fourteen people detained in secret prisons be flown to Guantanamo for trial. He thereby admitted that he had been supporting American gulags overseas. Furthermore, one could argue that the entirety of the Iraq War constituted a war crime due to the illegality of the conflict in general. The United Nations Charter, which legally binds all nations, prohibits the use of armed force except in very limited conditions of self-defense, which were in this case inapplicable. Without UN Security Council authorization, a good argument could be made that the US invasion of Iraq was unlawful. [MUSIC 5] [III. Power Protects Power] So. How did the US legal system respond to the war crimes and human rights abuses? Mostly with pronouncements but no action. In 2004, in Rasul v Bush and Hamdi v Rumsfeld, the court ruled that those held in a US prison, including Guantanamo, had the right to contest their detentions by filing a writ of habeas corpus.
AUDIO 6
In 2006, the Supreme Court ruled in Hamdan v Rumsfeld that Donald Rumsfeld, then Secretary of Defense, had violated Article 3 of all four Geneva Conventions of 1949. The offense was refusing to allow a prisoner under the custody of the US military to be tried in a regularly constituted court. By doing this, the justices by implication identified George W. Bush—the author of the executive order of November 13, 2001, which established the unconstitutional court—as himself a war criminal. But here's the thing. Neither Bush nor Rumsfeld was on trial in either case, since the role of the Supreme Court was, as usual, to clarify principles to be applied at the trial court level. Also, nearly every other war crime was broadly ignored, and no such trials have ever taken place. In June 2008, Congressman Dennis Kucinich of Ohio introduced a comprehensive House Resolution to impeach President George W. Bush. It went nowhere. Formally accusing the President of war crimes never gains much traction. Michael Haas, a political scientist and author of the most comprehensive book on the subject of Bush's war crimes, once wrote:
“Hundreds of years of human rights progress are in serious jeopardy as long as governmental war criminals live blissfully in the knowledge that they will never be accountable for their crimes. Insofar as decision makers feel free to violate well-established norms of proper conduct, terrorists have been emboldened and have easily attracted volunteers. The surreal symbiosis between war criminals in Washington and terrorists around the world makes everyone less secure.” With that in mind, where are these war criminals? Near the end of his tenure as vice president, Dick Cheney was awarded an honorary doctorate of public service by Brigham Young University, where he delivered the commencement address. Following his term as VP, he became an author, political commentator and regularly hosts fundraisers for the Republican Party. He had a heart transplant in 2012, and at age 78, lives a relatively comfortable life of wealth and continued influence. Donald Rumsfeld, Secretary of Defense and overseer of prisoner abuse, faced no serious consequences. In 2011, he released a memoir to rehabilitate his image, and in the same year was awarded the "Defender of the Constitution Award" at CPAC in Washington, DC.
AUDIO 7
Former president George W. Bush paints, jokes and shares candy with more popular public figures. The painfully predictable reaction from the right and from coddling liberals has been defending the actions of George W. Bush by invoking Barack Obama. “If Bush is a war criminal, then you have to call Obama a war criminal,” they sarcastically and smugly exclaim. They are so close to the point, and they never seem to realize it. They draw right up to the border of an epiphany about US imperialism that exists and is propagated irrespective of administration and then race away from that epiphany as fast as their legs can carry them. [COLOR] Ah-ha! You thought this was a video about trashing a Republican president and a moderately funny but very successful comedian but is actually about US hegemony on the world stage and war crimes in general! [MUSIC 6] But seriously, the Obama administration is responsible for broadening the so-called war on terror, not ending it as he once claimed, and the civilian deaths under his watchful eye were staggering. The difference between the foreign policies of Bush and Obama are a matter of scale and a schoolyard argument of “Who started it?” Bush was definitely a worse president than Obama, but this is only a matter of degrees.
Canonizing Obama a saint obscures his record on drone strikes and a foreign policy that was predominantly in service of US economic interests. What's more, it's so very common. US citizens, media and government accept US global hegemony as status quo. This has been this way for a long time but was solidified in modern times during the George W. Bush administration. It's “normal” for the US to commit its forces toward wars for economic interests, and since it's “normal,” any difference between candidates on this subject is marginal or a matter of degrees. When something is normalized, when it becomes status quo, it's no longer a concern but an accepted truth. The wars and the war crimes are now status quo. A recent Ipsos/FiveThirtyEight poll shows that even though the US is committed to multiple wars, Democratic primary voters surveyed before the September debate show that issues related to the military are second to last among their concerns, clocking in at 0.3%. Even if we combined that with the “foreign affairs” listing, which actually may only be about trade and not war, it would still be less than 2% whether we look at the numbers before or after the debate.
AUDIO 8
The historically less hawkish party is now approximately as hawkish as the Republicans. There is no debate over whether or not we should be “over there” especially considering most US citizens can't name how many countries we are currently bombing or have boots on the ground or which countries they are. These numbers change, but as of last year, it was seven: Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Yemen, Somalia, Libya, and Niger. These is only the operations that we know about. This comes from the unclassified portion of the White House's “Report on the Legal and Policy Frameworks Guiding the United States’ Military Force and Related National Security Operations.” Classified operations may stretch the US military further. All these operations in all these countries may not have been explicitly endorsed by Congress, as both tradition and the law require, but they are also still considered “legal” by the US due to the aforementioned Authorization of Military Forces. The AUMF contains no geographic limitation on where authorized force may be employed, and its wording of “associated” groups is interpreted as a blank check against almost anyone. In other words, the AUMF used by the George W. Bush administration is actually an authorization to wage war on whichever country that commander-in-chief and future commanders-in-chief see fit.
Not just the initial targets like it was sold to the public. In addition to more recent and major operations in the aforementioned countries, the AUMF has also been invoked to perform some military operations in the Philippines, Georgia, Djibouti, Kenya, Ethiopia, Eritrea and Somalia. This spans three presidencies. The reason it's more “socially accepted” and “forgivable” for a celebrity to hang out with Obama is because we are willing to accept a little ignorance among a citizenry that might not know much about our current wars. The state no longer debates whether or not we should be bombing and drone striking civilians, which means the media no longer debates this, which means the citizens no longer debate this. Attacks on Obama from the right were full of lies – lies about the aims of his healthcare plan, lies about his religion. If the right ever criticized his wars, it was only that he didn't go far enough. His own party had no incentive to criticize their president on the wars either. That means that if neither major party is criticizing imperialism, then it's not news. If it's not news, it's not well-known. It's believable that Obama's celebrity friends don't know about his expansion of war authority under the AUMF.
AUDIO 9
[MUSIC 7] It's not, however, believable that Bush's celebrity friends don't know what he was up to during his administration because the AUMF was brand new. The War on Terror was all we talked about during his administration. Not because people were outraged – the Democratic candidate who opposed him in 2004 didn't want to call off the wars, he only campaigned on being better at war. It was all we talked about because it was still new, which meant it was still profitable for news organizations to have stories about it every night, and it had the byproduct of informing the electorate. It's not as profitable to talk about Niger and Yemen in 2019. News organizations prioritize profitable topics. Climate change is arguably the most serious crisis facing humanity, but it's not the number one topic in news. This is because climate change news is ratings poison. Chris Hayes of MSNBC recently stated that climate change doesn't pull ratings, and that's why it's not a bigger story. If it's not a bigger story, people don't think of it as urgent. If viewers don't care about civilian deaths across seven countries, then it won't be reported on, which means there is no opportunity to care, which then means that politicians don't have to campaign for or against it anymore. [IV: CONCLUSION]
Ellen Degeneres definitely knows what Bush did during his administration because it was all over the news at the time. DeGeneres made a speech following the backlash about the importance of being kind. Two problems: first, rehabilitating Bush has consequences that go beyond someone's anecdotal experiences with him. And second, being “kind” to everyone is impossible because being “kind” to some people is inherently “unkind” to others. Being kind to a war criminal is being unkind to his victims, to the families of his victims. Being friends with an oppressor is cruel to the oppressed. Making excuses for the oppressor is cruel to the oppressed – not to mention the consequences to the future this could have by taking part in this rehabilitation. Once again for the people in the back: this is not about you having friends and family who registered to vote under a different party. Your friend or sibling who votes differently from yourself probably did not order bombs dropped on children. Bush did. Nobody is saying you can't be friends with someone whose party registration is different. That's a private matter whereas this is very much happening in public, including but not limited to doubling down on national television to the applause of a studio audience.
AUDIO 10
Bush's celebrity friends are far too rich to be materially affected by his policies and continued legacy. This is common among the economic elites. Once you become rich, solidarity among the wealthy often becomes more important than any other concerns. It is a kinship that goes beyond race, sexual orientation or politics. It's why the super rich have come out in full support of defending Bush and his celebrity friends. How soon following the Trump administration will he be rehabilitated by the media and his powerful friends? Unthinkable? So was the rehabilitation of Bush only ten years ago. The rich are unconcerned, reducing indefensible actions to “differences of opinion.” This obscures the fact that the objection is the content of said opinion, not the existence of opinion. If everything is only difference of opinion, indistinguishable in content and quality, no matter how harmful, then everything is permissible, and that is dangerous. In fact, some are economically invested in these rehabilitations, regardless of consequences. It's why Sean Spicer was compared with Nazi propagandist Joseph Goebbels while he served Trump but is now Dancing with the Stars. Those with power and influence have white-washed Bush's history and have laid the groundwork for history to repeat itself.
HOW TO SURVIVE YOUR OFFICE JOB
Hello, new worker! Congratulations on being hired! Before you begin your career at this particular corporation, you need to learn some keys facts and helpful tips about being an office worker. In fact, this orientation may help you in any line of work. What brought you here today? Well, you had a choice: wage labor or starving to death. There is no real choice, which makes our current economic system compulsory and your new position at this company the best of a bad situation called capitalism. One day, when most of the world is ready for a revolution, that may change, but since that appears to be a long ways off, you need to prepare yourself for your career and how best to interact with your employer. Everything your employer does is in service of controlling you. Even if they don't think of it that way, that is what's happening all the time. If your employer is a manager and not an owner, they still have an implicit mandate from said owner to control you. Example: Ever wonder why big corporations are against universal healthcare even though it costs those corporations to pay for your employee healthcare? It's because that's a bargaining chip they have to make you continue to work there for whatever they choose to pay you. It's all about control. Surviving your job is about escaping that control.
To that end, here are some tips that you might find useful. [S05E03] Tip #1: Seeing Through Your Employer's Bull. In order to maintain control over you, sometimes your employer may gently or not-so-gently remind you about a concept called time theft, something they invented that definitely does not actually exist. Employers sometimes describe time theft with examples like incorrectly clocking in, but really, time theft, to them, is the act of you doing anything besides labor for their shift. Keep in mind that shifts can last from eight hours to twelve hours – or perhaps more. Taking a minute to break or briefly checking your phone for messages from your family are unacceptable to your employer because that time could have been spent serving said employer. The truth is that working non-stop without breaks or time to stretch your legs is extremely dangerous both psychologically and physically. You are a human being and not a machine, and as such, you require moments of rest and relaxation – even in the workplace – in fact, especially in the workplace. [S01E04] Never taking a moment to go to the water cooler or talk to a nearby co-worker in the next cubicle – day in and day out over the course of years – can cause psychological harm. Employers call it “time theft” because it places the responsibility on you and frames the act of being a human being as a moral failing.
AUDIO 2
The blame is on you for daring to call your loved ones about something important or simply to tell them they are loved. In truth, “time theft” does not make sense – for multiple reasons. First, if you are able to complete your tasks in their work day while also behaving like a human being and having a snack, then nothing has been taken from the employer. Time theft, as a concept, is particularly strange if your occupation does not depend on deadlines and instead is done through a per-customer basis. Meet Jim. He spends some time talking to his wife at work, but since he's one of the top salesmen and having this psychological outlet helps his productivity and morale, his employer should not care. See, employers institute time theft rules and reminders because what they really want is for the workers to work harder than they have to – harder than they are paid to work. More hours than they are paid to work. More time than they are paid to work. By framing the act of talking to a co-worker to alleviate some of the mounting stress of the work day as “time theft,” employers can both guilt and punish their workers for not working what is essentially overtime for no added pay. Here is a quote from a employer's guide from a software website trying to sell employers on the idea that time theft is real:
“To eliminate time theft, it is essential to create a work environment with the resources to monitor and prevent it. Investing in the right software will take care of many of the administrative issues that contribute to letting time theft slide by.” By “resources to monitor and prevent” and “investing in the right software,” this f**king narc is actually saying that you taking a smoke break or five minutes too long on your lunch is all the justification they need to spy on you. This includes cameras and spy software in office computers to monitor you as if you were a prisoner – an Orwellian nightmare that has become so commonplace that its normalcy has lead to complacency about fighting back against this. Employers don't institute time theft policies and punishments out of a moral responsibility. Employers do this to squeeze as much labor – often free labor – out of their employees as they legally can. If an employer demands that a worker perform their labor more and/or harder than they are paid to do so, that labor is therefore free. It is actually the employer who is the thief. This is called wage theft, which is actually a thing. Workers are those who sell their labor to employers for a set amount of time in exchange for wages. A fraction of the value of what the workers produce comes back to them in the form of a wage. The rest is kept, or stolen, by the owners of the corporation, who generally do no productive labor themselves. They can get away with this because under capitalism, this sort of theft is both perfectly legal and encouraged. Illegal forms of wage theft include failure to pay overtime or failure to pay minimum wage, but these laws are often circumvented with little to no consequences by corporations. If you are wondering which is worse – time theft or wage theft – it can be solved by reminding yourself who has significantly more power.
AUDIO 3
Enforcing an atmosphere in which “time theft” is somehow a thing, workers will become even more stressed about their work. You could mistreat your own psychological well-being and actually become less productive – the opposite of the intention of time theft enforcement. To combat this, develop a friendship with someone in your workplace. Someone who can cover for you if you're stuck in an elevator or in traffic. Employers hate it if you have a friend at work. Having a friend at work also means you have someone who can alert you if your employer is making their rounds like a beat cop and hoping to dock your pay for glancing at your phone in case your sick child needs to text you. Solidarity is everything. [S02E09] Tip #2: Stay Off the Grid. Your employer is tracking you at all times. It will never be enough for them that you do your job. What they really want is for you to do more than you are paid to do so they can wring free labor out of you like a wet washcloth. Take precautions. Don't use your corporate email address.
If your employer insists on you using it and expects to see you using it, only use it to communicate directly with your employer to give them that impression. If you want to communicate with your co-workers or loved ones while at work, use your private email address but NEVER on your office computer. They can and will track that with email surveillance. Use your own phone, and just in case, never use the corporate WiFi. Use your network. Communicating with your co-workers privately is necessary to safeguard yourself from any unfair practices from your employer. If you're being monitored, you aren't able to do this, and your employer knows this. That's why the email surveillance software is there to begin with. Any area in which your employer does not have control over you is unacceptable to them, so it's best to try to get around this. Employers will tell you that computers are company property and that their surveillance is well within their rights because they own the computers. Then, in the same breath, they will tell you not to email your co-workers on your phones to avoid their surveillance even though the phones are YOUR property. It isn't about use or misuse of company property. It's about control.
AUDIO 4
Tip #3: Learn Your Employer's Behavior. While every employer follows some of the same tactics, each employer has a different way of tricking you into performing free labor for them. If your employer tells you that they have a “development opportunity” for you, that translates into an added project that is not part of your work schedule nor is it one of your duties. Your employer is hoping to trick you into performing a new task that is not a requirement of your job to squeeze more labor out of you. Respond by saying that performing this task will take away time and effort from your current tasks. If your employer insists, remind them that your current tasks will suffer and that you cannot be held responsible if this happens under orders from the employer. If the employer then responds that you must do this new task in addition to your current tasks at the same level of efficiency, remind them that this will cause you to have to work overtime and for extra pay. If they double down and deny you that pay, tell your employer that you will have to speak to payroll and [S02E16] whoever is higher up than your employer on the corporate ladder. Unless your employer is the sole owner of the company, there will always be someone higher up.
That doesn't mean that someone higher up will be sympathetic to you – heavens no! It only means that whoever is higher up will believe your immediate supervisor is losing control, and they love control. So, your immediate supervisor doesn't want you to make that call. Employers will try to convince you that you are a “professional” and therefore expected to put in longer hours. Even if you're just punching the keyboard, your employer will pretend that the work is extremely important. If you are a salaried worker and you took the job under the impression that you would work 40 hours a week, your employer trying to get you to work an extra 20 hours a week is like increasing their staff by 50% without costing the corporation a penny. Tip #4: Always Look for Something Better. [The Return] Employers want to keep you in a state of fear of losing your job. When they try to make you work longer hours for no added pay or harder for no added pay, they are hoping that you won't quit your job for something better. Employers will remind workers of the “bad economy” which always exists in the minds of employers regardless of which year we're in. For that reason, always look at other job opportunities comparable to your own. That way, should your employer tell you that you wouldn't want to lose your job because it's “hard out there,” you can respond by having a pre-made list of jobs to which you qualify and could easily apply.
AUDIO 5
Your employer needs you more than you need your employer. Your employer is stuck where they are and is answerable to corporate if you have a loss in labor. You do not answer to corporate if you no longer work there. When you quit, your responsibilities are over. When your employer watches you quit, their responsibilities have only begun, and they know this. Tip #5: Get That Bread. After working for your employer and accepting their indignities for a few years, you are entitled to an increase in pay. Employers generally have the power to do this but will try to avoid it at all costs. They would rather keep as much of the yearly salary increase for themselves. Employers will pretend their hands are tied and cite vague rules like “salary guidelines” or “pressure from corporate” avoid this. An employer will try to be good cop and place the blame on a bad cop, probably someone above them in the corporate ladder who almost never makes an appearance at the workplace and is therefore unable to confirm this. Here's an idea. Actually ask for specifics. Do so politely at first under the guise of your professionalism. You want to understand the situation more clearly so that you can be a more productive worker, after all!
Human Resources might be able to help, but most likely they will be useless. HR does not work for you. HR works for corporate. HR exists to protect the corporation from lawsuits and other problems associated with employees. HR is actually not on your side. Tip #6: Cover Your Butt. This is a quick one but every important. Document everything that protects yourself. Documenting your successes is useful for when your employer insists you have not been doing your job. It's also useful when asking for a raise or a promotion. Try to build strong relationships with those inside and outside your department so that if your employer comes down on you hard for something that isn't your fault, your have both the documentation and backup to fight this accusation. Tip #7: Beware bootlickers. Now, some middle managers may sympathize with your station due to earning a comparable wage, but some people of a similar economic class as yourself will choose to have no real solidarity with you and instead serve higher authorities. Meet Dwight. He informs his immediate superior, Michael, about any suspected infractions by his co-workers. [S03E03] He also routinely sides with Michael over his co-workers and sometimes even goes over Michael's head to speak to corporate.
AUDIO 6
Unfortunately, Dwight is no anomaly. He's part of a pattern of behavior common to the workplace. These bootlickers are called...class traitors: members of the working class who directly or indirectly work against their own class interests. [S02E20] The most notable example is the police, who make a middle class wage at best but serve the interests of capitalism by controlling the poor. [S08E09] You don't have to feel bad for standing up to them just because they're not rich since they serve the ruling class more than they serve you. Class traitors often have ambitions beyond their station, and rather than pulling everyone together to make a better life for the exploited workers, class traitors seek to be the ones in charge of the exploitation. Tip #8: Avoid Manipulation. An important thing to remember is that the corporation does not care about you. The corporation did not hire you as a favor. Hiring you is an agreement, an exchange of labor for pay. The corporation did not do you a favor by hiring you, it simply wanted to exploit your labor. Some employers don't want you to realize this. A manipulative employer will constantly remind you of how they helped you in the past by hiring you. Again, that's not what happened.
They wanted you to perform labor for the corporation, and you were willing to do so. It was an exchange. That's all that happened. On occasion, your hiring may have had something to do with a friend going out on a limb for you. But nine times out of ten, your hiring was impersonal and had to do with the corporation wanting the most productive worker for the least amount of pay. If your employer ever tries to guilt you into doing something you don't have to do, remind them of this fact. They will undoubtedly call you “ungrateful” – pushing the guilt further – to which you can reply that the employer is ungrateful for your already hard work if they are pushing you to commit to more work than you were hired to do. Employers don't want you to think of it that way. They only want you to think of the relationship between employer and employee as that of a parent and child respectively. If your employer ever talks to you like a parent, remind them that this is not a family but a workplace. You were hired to do a job. If your employer wants you to do a new job only tangentially related to your current one, then the employer must, in effect, hire you again for this new occupation, and in the hiring process, there must be talk of compensation.
AUDIO 7
Employers want you to be dependent on them – not independent – as a matter of control. They don't want you to be richer than they are because that would mean losing said control. The corporation wants you to be of a low economic class to better control you. Tip #9: Discuss Comparative Pay. There is a good chance that some of your co-workers who perform the same job as yourself and started at a similar time make more money than you. This is because compensation is not equal across the board. Don't blame them, though. You are paid only as much as your employer believes they can get away with paying you. If you work a minimum wage job, chances are everyone else makes the same, but if you work anywhere else, there is probably some disparity based on how much hardball one worker played compared to another and sometimes other factors like gender, cronyism and more. Employers don't want you to discuss your wages with other workers because then you might ask to be paid the same as someone else in your department. Corporations and society at large propagate the idea that discussing your wages is vulgar and in bad taste, and maybe among strangers that's true, but among co-workers, there is solidarity in discussing comparative wages.
If wages are secret, employers can get away with paying some people less than what they deserve. They do this to save money for themselves. Finally, Tip #10: Join a Union. If your occupation has a union, join it. If your occupation or workplace does not have a union, speak to union leaders in your area about forming one. During orientation, there is a good chance that your employer will either play anti-union propaganda for you or subtly suggest in conversation about why a union would be bad for you. In truth, a union is incredibly good for your bargaining power and safety. The only reason a union might be “bad” for you is that if your employer catches wind of you starting a union, they will fire you. A union is only “bad” because of your employer punishing you for even considering being in one. Actually being in one is very helpful. Employers don't push anti-union propaganda to protect you. They push anti-union propaganda to protect themselves. Union workers generally enjoy better wages than non-union workers because unions can negotiate these wages. Remember literally every unfair practice by your employer said earlier? Those can be mitigated with collective bargaining. A union takes away some of the control from the employer, and at the risk of being repetitive, that's what this is all about: control. Well, worker, that about wraps it up. We hope you're ready for an exciting new career and lifestyle in which you are willing to question the authority of someone who just happened to have started working at the company earlier than yourself. Good luck to you, and as always, death to capitalism.
THE PROBLEM WITH RICK AND MORTY
Media does not force us to do things. Nobody plays Doom and is transformed from a choir boy to a school shooter. Media does, however, inform and reinforce our worldview. Here's a quick exercise. Close your eyes and imagine a French person. If you've never been to France, you probably imagined either a French celebrity – someone you saw either in popular media or news media, like a politician – or you thought of a French caricature from a cartoon. A beret, a baguette. See, our opinions, beliefs and conceptions of an entire people are based more on the media we have consumed about them. This can also be true of, you know, everything else. And that's OK. Media can be our window into 99% of the world with which we do not interact, but if that is true, then what media says – what it communicates – is therefore important and not something to be dismissed as “It's only a TV show.” So, what does Rick and Morty communicate? Oh, a lot of things. Ideas about existentialism, the role of science, the role of religion, lots of stuff. It also, perhaps unintentionally, seems to communicate...something else. Rick Sanchez is a genius super-scientist and mass murderer. He's also the series protagonist, along with his grandson Morty. This wouldn't be a problem if Rick were framed as someone who is proven wrong or whose cruelty leads him to constant failure.
But in nearly every episode, Rick...wins. He saves the day and/or Morty. Narrative framing tells us with whom the audience is meant to sympathize and the messages the media is communicating or even endorsing. Let's use the most basic example. In Return of the Jedi, Emperor Palpatine is framed – both in narrative and in visuals – as the bad guy. He tempts Luke Skywalker, our protagonist, in the same way the Devil tempts human beings. He promises Luke incredible power if only he could give into the dark side. Luke is tempted, but when he sees what he is becoming, he casts down his light saber, admonishes Palpatine and tells the stand-in for the Devil that he has lost. In response, Palpatine opts to murder Luke. The point is, Palpatine is unambiguously framed as wrong and Luke is unambiguously framed as right. Even visually, Palpatine is cloaked in darkness and sits atop a throne. See, in Rick and Morty, Rick might perform some of the same misdeeds as Palpatine, but he is framed as right.
AUDIO 2
Not a goody-goody like Luke Skywalker, of course, but as someone who is both intellectually correct and even in his moral debates with Morty, Rick is often framed as morally correct, too. More than that, he is framed as “cool” – Rick is easily the most popular character in the series. In addition to being cool, he's also...cruel. Rick is cruel and intelligent, and several times over the course of the series, these two qualities are conflated, as if cruelty is a sign of intelligence. That is the problem with Rick and Morty. The idea that cruelty and intelligence go hand in hand. The idea that being cruel is a sign of intelligence and that being cruel is somehow “right” can be highly attractive to cruel people. Sometimes people who are cruel see their attitude as a sign of their intelligence, and if they believe that is true, then they can believe they are “right” and that their cruelty is “right.” Everyone has encountered someone who has cloaked their cruel words and misdeeds as “Hey...I'm just being honest!” Through the text of the series – not the intention, but the text – Rick and Morty can reinforce this attractive idea for some people. One should not have to explain what the thesis is NOT right after saying what the thesis is, but since fandom defensiveness has ran rampant of late, please allow this brief aside to firmly state what is NOT the thesis. It's not that Rick and Morty isn't funny. It's not that Rick and Morty is bad. It's not that Rick and Morty can't engage in rated R humor. It's not to condemn literally everyone who watches a television series as toxic.
While one could certainly argue that some of the fanbase is toxic, the problem with Rick and Morty is contained within the text of the series. Reaction to the series may be toxic, but that isn't the origin of the problem. The origin of the problem with Rick and Morty lies within Rick and Morty – within the text of the series. Leveling an accusation against the fandom as a whole is unhelpful. That lets the series off the hook and makes the reason that some in the fandom admire Rick seem inexplicable. It's actually a totally knowable thing with evidence littered throughout the series. It's not inexplicable. Now, you may be thinking “I watch Rick and Morty, and I don't think Rick is right or cool.” Yeah, that's good. That's good for you. But your experiences are not universal, they are anecdotal, and learning the outlook of one person tells us nothing of a pattern and little about what is being communicated by the piece of media. Any protestations of “Well, we're not SUPPOSED to agree with Rick!” are invalidated by the framing of Rick. He is the funniest, coolest character in the series, and more importantly, he is almost always proven right by the end of the episode. “That's the point!” is not an argument if the point is continuously obscured by the very text of the series.
AUDIO 3
So, these are...a lot of ideas and a lot of...words and literary jargon. Let's go through them in more detail – one by one. [PART I: The Text of the Series] In literary criticism, the “text” or “main text” is information content of a particular piece of writing. The "text" of a work is the arrangement of words and events. This has come to be used as shorthand and jargon in media criticism in general, including film and television. In more layman's terms, the text of Rick and Morty is, in essence, what happens within the series – what is inarguably occurring in the events of the series. In the pilot, Rick takes Morty on an adventure. It can't be argued that this did not happen. It's right there...in the “text” of the series. Remember that. If Justin Roiland, Dan Harmon and other people who work on the show were to claim that even though we didn't see it happen, there were, say, an underground factory of super-intelligent graboids from the movie Tremors living beneath that planet, that would NOT be the “text” of the pilot episode. Instead, it would be “paratext” – which is other material supplied by the author, often material that is never published but merely fleshed out by the author's own interpretation of events. Obvious example: In the Harry Potter books, Dumbledore is the headmaster of Hogwarts, a wizarding school.
That is the text. The fact that Dumbledore is gay is never mentioned in the books. Author J.K. Rowling merely said so well after the fact, which means that Dumbledore's sexuality is “paratext” and not “text.” So, what is the text of Rick and Morty, and how does the text of the show – meaning the unambiguous events that we can all see – frame Rick Sanchez as right? How does the series continuously show Rick to be correct and communicate this to the audience? Well, let's do a Rick-by-Rick examination of nearly every episode. In Season 1, Episode 1, Rick outsmarts interstellar TSA and his family. Early in the episode, Rick makes the series' first reference to what it thinks of “smart people.” In Season 1, Episode 2, amid some casual Islamaphobia, Rick outsmarts a dream demon, Morty's teacher and a race of super-intelligent canines. Summer references intelligence again, this time directly correlating it with cruelty. In Season 1, Episode 3, amid multiple r*pe jokes, Rick saves Morty and company from a Jurassic Park parody. In Season 1, Episode 4, Rick saves Morty and outsmarts a species of intergalactic scam artists. In Season 1, Episode 5, Morty's kindness is portrayed as naivete, another overt reference to kindness being unintelligent or wrong, and Rick's cynicism and cruel intelligence portrayed as correct.
AUDIO 4
After all, it is through this cynicism that Rick is able to save Morty and murder a sex offender. Also, more r*pe jokes. In Season 1, Episode 6, more r*pe jokes and casual Islamaphobia. This is one of the few episodes in which Rick is incorrect, but he still saves the day, at least for himself and Morty. In Season 1, Episode 7, Rick dismisses gender politics and reinforces the false notion that “Women have it better than men” because of their sexual allure. This is what you get with a writing room without women for the first two seasons. In Season 1, Episode 8, there is no conflict for Rick, but his “it doesn't matter” philosophy saves the day. “It doesn't matter.” as an expression of existential nihilism as theory and not praxis is one thing. “It doesn't matter” as praxis and justification for misdeeds, however, is not a great way to go through life. There is a difference between theory and praxis, and Rick puts “It doesn't matter” into effect in every episode. In fact, within the text of the episode, Rick is right. Rick's philosophy is used by Morty to help his family. The series therefore frames “it doesn't matter” as correct. In Season 1, Episode 9, Rick tries to justify why he should be able to say a slur for a group of marginalized people because the slur wasn't always thought of as a slur by people outside said group.
It's basically the “I want to say the n-word” argument framed as logical. So, yikes. The episode frames Rick as correct, and Morty's response reinforces this. So, it's another “mean is smart” moment for the series. Also in the episode, Rick wins, of course, proving he is smarter and better than the Devil himself. In Season 1, Episode 10, we get another example of good being dumb and mean being smart. In the end, Rick is proven right over all the other Ricks. In Season 1, Episode 11, Rick stops time to save the day. Also, more r*pe...stuff. In Season 2, Episode 1, even more r*pe stuff – Jesus Christ, what the f**k? – some tired, misogynist reference to men being incapable of being friends with women, and then Rick saves the day. In Season 2, Episode 2, the good-natured Morty is proven wrong by Rick. See, Morty isn't just framed as unintelligent. He's framed as “good.” He's also framed as wrong. Rick is framed as intelligent and cruel...but right. Is everyone getting it? Are...are we all getting it? Great. This is also true of Jerry. His insecurity about his lack of intelligence makes him a burden for the entire family. [sighs] I could go on. And I will! In Season 2, Episode 3, we get a lot of “New Atheism” stuff that is littered throughout the series and a moment of Rick's “man pain.”
AUDIO 5
Several times throughout the series, Rick is shown to be in pain, but this does not make an argument against Rick being right. Rather, it is a typical portrayal of “man pain” and how being right and smart is a burden. Season 2, Episode 4...is actually really funny and probably my favorite episode. In Season 2, Episode 5, there's more New Atheism junk. Morty puts his trust in Rick alone and that saves the world. In Season 2, Episode 6, Rick enslaves a world and wins. In Season 2, Episode 7, more man pain and mild self-reflection with zero interest in changing. In Season 2, Episode 8, instead of the series reflecting on how it's perceived, it doubles down. This is common for a television series. It crosses a line, and rather than reflecting and addressing this within the text of a new episode, it instead tells the audience to f**k off. Sometimes, a series will take the high road. BoJack Horseman famously acknowledged how an audience empathizing too much with BoJack could be dangerous. This isn't a throwaway line either. It's an entire season-long arc – but we'll get to that later. In Season 2, Episode 9, Rick and Morty debate morality.
Morty's good-natured attitude gets them in trouble, and Rick saves the day with mech suits. In Season 2, Episode 10, Rick says this: [] We really didn't have to wait until the finale of season two for the series' mission statement because it was scattered throughout the first two seasons. Once again, for the people in the back, Rick is almost never portrayed as wrong. People who mistakenly believe themselves geniuses because of how cruel and insensitive they are will latch onto this phrase instead of see it as a wrong-headed comedy line because they actually believe that and because the series consistently reinforces this. At the end of the episode, Rick allows himself to be captured, showing that only Rick can defeat Rick. In Season 3, Episode 1, Rick's apparent selflessness in the previous episode is undermined, and he single-handedly destroys the galactic government. Season 3, Episode 2 reinforces the “nothing matters” philosophy. Season 3, Episode 3 is the infamous Pickle Rick story that actually touches on some of Rick's flaws. Pretty good, right? I'm glad they actually hired some women writers. Then in Season 3, Episode 4, the jerk talks about how “triggered” he is, and Rick's concept of morality or immorality is proven right.
AUDIO 6
In Season 3, Episode 5, Rick knows what's best for Jerry, who is typical of the mostly good-natured but mostly “unintelligent” character. The rest of the season is simply more of the same “smart people” and “nothing matters” malarkey that stained all three seasons of an otherwise pretty funny television series. That is the text of the show. [PART 2: OK, So What?] Now someone might argue that the series doesn't “mean it that way” – referring to the writing staff here – but whether the writers “mean it that way” or not, that text of the series is the text of the series, and it is unambiguous that Rick is presented as correct in nearly every episode. The truth is, being mean is not a sign of intelligence. It generally signifies only itself. If anything, it may be an indicator of a lack of “emotional intelligence,” which is extremely important in dealing with basic human interaction and therefore navigating your way through life. Being mean doesn't make you smart or vice versa. It just makes you...mean. In fact, attaching one's cruelty to one's intelligence to prove oneself correct and therefore not cruel is a logical fallacy. It's sometimes called the fallacy of special pleading. It's when someone uses harsh, unfavorable language to describe the actions of others, and uses favorable language to describe the same or similar actions done by themselves.
The most common example would be someone who says they are “just being honest” when they says things that hurt people – as if it would have been impossible not to say or do something cruel -- but refer to someone who hurts them as rude or tactless or wrong. To the person performing the fallacy of special pleading, they are a special case because they're so allegedly smart and their cruelty isn't true cruelty, it's only an expression of that alleged intelligence. There is a movement right now, and it can be summed up in a few words: “Facts don't care about your feelings.” It's a movement of people defined by their insensitivity and cruelty who justify said cruelty by their own false perception of their intelligence. They say things like “facts don't care about your feelings” but when presented with facts that contradict their prejudices, the actual facts are dismissed. Because their movement isn't actually about facts. The “facts” that they spew are easily and constantly debunked. This means the movement is not about a separation of facts from feelings but actually an incorrect conflation of cruelty with intelligence – an intelligence that does not actually exist – which means it's really only about cruelty under the guise of intelligence.
AUDIO 7
Let's pretend Rick and Morty is satire and that every writer and both showrunners explicitly intended for Rick to be wrong and the target of mockery – even though the text of the series explicitly shows us the opposite. But let's pretend. If it were satire, Rick and Morty fails at satire because satire requires clarity of who or what is the target or else it will be mistaken for what it intends to criticize. Let's take a look at quite possibly the most unambiguous comedy satire on television. It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia is a comedy in which Dennis, Mac, Dee, Charlie and Frank – five Philadelphia residents of varying degrees of mean-spirited ignorance, concoct hair-brained schemes and display said mean-spirited ignorance. It was created with the intention of lampooning and satirizing shallow people. What makes It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia special is that it is fairly consistent in how it frames the actions of the group of friends – collectively called The Gang. They are framed...as wrong. Always. Whereas Rick almost always wins, almost always is proven right, and is almost always displayed as cool, The Gang is framed the opposite way. They almost always lose, almost always are proven wrong and are typically displayed as uncool, losers, racists and fools.
The Gang are therefore not aspirational. Undoubtedly, some people misunderstand this, even though it is the most unambiguous satire imaginable, but the text of the series clearly illustrates the wrongheadedness of The Gang at every turn and in nearly every episode. That's not to say Always Sunny hasn't made mistakes – because it has, and I don't care to defend obvious mistakes – but by and large, Always Sunny knows what it's doing, is not subtle about what it's doing, and hopefully the vast majority of the audience will recognize that. If The Gang is always wrong, then the Gang's misogyny is wrong. If the Gang is always wrong, then their insensitivity is always wrong. If the Gang is always wrong, then their actions are wrong and not to be admired. The problem with Rick always being right is that when he says and does deeply problematic things, it has the byproduct of coding those things as also right to the audience. If Rick is always right, then his misogyny is right. If Rick is always right, then his insensitivity is right. If Rick is always right, then his actions are right and are to be admired. Framing matters. It's why Season 3, Episode 3 shows Rick at his most vulnerable, but the main thing people remember from that episode is PICKLE RICK.
AUDIO 8
It's why Rick can finally be called out in at least one episode, but what people chose to do with that episode is paint Pickle Rick on a bomb. Let's look at another series starring a cynical alcoholic – BoJack Horseman – and do some compare and contrast. When Rick does something unconscionable, it's portrayed as funny. When BoJack does something unconscionable, it's portrayed as wrong. When Rick is responsible for the demise of an entire planet, it's funny. When BoJack takes too many pills and strangles a woman, it's hideous and serious and results in him going to rehab. Complex characters are great, you know, if they're done right. The tone of Rick and Morty is very different from the tone of BoJack Horseman, and the manner in which the two series confront the morality and immorality of their protagonists are completely opposite and therefore communicate completely different messages to their respective audiences. Saying “Maybe it's satire!” in response to problematic content is not helpful when something is easily identifiable as sincere. At worst, it's a roast – jokes directed at a person or idea that do more to praise the person or idea and hand wave the faults instead of outright condemn.
Satire criticizes. Satire condemns. Satire is opposed to something – it is not ultimately sympathetic to it. Rick occasionally slipping up is not enough to be condemnation. Satire requires intent, a target and explicit criticism or condemnation. Rick and Morty cannot claim satire as defense if it consistently portrays Rick as correct. I've said this in a previous video, but it bears repeating: the phrase “Maybe it's satire!” in response to problematic content in media is almost always in bad faith, a hand grenade thrown into the conversation with the intent of scattering the interlocutors in hopes of never having to think critically about said problematic content in media they enjoy. We can be braver than that if we choose to be. We can also choose to be more honest than that. Once again, nobody says you have to stop watching a series you enjoy. Rick and Morty can be pretty funny, but it seems reasonable to suggest that we definitely need to start being honest about what it's communicating, regardless of whether or not it's intentional. Because if we ignore it, then it can become invisible and therefore harder to notice when it affects us or people we know. When the content, the philosophy and the movement...become normalized. [But maybe it normalizes it.] Yeah. I can agree with that.