Update and scripts! (Patreon)
Content
Summer is upon us, and the world is still quarantined. I hope you are all safe. A lot of big videos I've been planning for a while are coming this summer. I may (or may not) finish my project of Star Trek: Voyager in a few months. It depends on how long I will eventually decide it should be. If you have been following me on Twitter, you will know that I have been going through the entire series again.
With that out of the way, here are some episode scripts.
DO THE OSCARS MATTER?
A few days ago, the nominees for the 92nd annual Academy Awards were released to the public, and the usual hot takes and reasonable criticism were levied against them. Far too white, far too centered on men, too filled with blockbusters instead of better but less seen films. Since the beginning of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, there has always been some criticism of how the Academy chooses which films should be congratulated – or even counted among its numbers. Academy members, thousands of people ranging from visual effects artists to actors, have made some questionable decisions. After years of controversy and screw-ups, maybe people are starting to wonder “Do the Oscars matter?” It's a challenging question to answer because it might mean something different to different people. Do the Oscars matter, compared to other more important issues going on in the world? Well, no, because the Oscars are a series of gold statues given mostly to rich people, but that's not really what is meant by “Do the Oscars matter?” Instead, the question is “Are the Oscars of great significance in the medium of film in determining who and what is the best?” That's a more cumbersome question, but at least it narrows down what everyone is actually asking. Let's try looking at this from a few different perspectives so we can get the most complete picture possible. [I. Qualifications] Among the most notable evidence that the Oscars is not a meritocracy of world film is that its qualifications and criteria immediately disqualify almost every motion picture made in the world every year.
The criteria for what can and cannot be considered for an Academy Award is incredibly stifling, making it next to impossible for anything besides a movie in the English language with big studio backing to qualify. Even the rare independent film that blows up big with both audiences and critics is almost always distributed by a huge studio. At that point, it becomes another part of the Hollywood system. A film that has humble origins but becomes popular is almost always distributed by one of the big Hollywood studios. So, what are these qualifications? The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences has a rulebook – often updated – that tell filmmakers and studios which movies “count” and which movies don't. Some of the rules make perfect sense. For example, one rule states that a feature length film is over 40 minutes. Anything less is a short film. Frankly, calling a 40 minute film “feature-length” is overly generous, but that's where the broad, inclusive nature of the Academy rules ends. The criteria for whether or not your film can even be considered by the Academy is far more complicated, and it covers everything from where you screen your movie to what projector resolution you use. To be considered for an Academy Award, a film must run in Los Angeles county for at least seven consecutive days.
AUDIO 2
That doesn't seem like a big roadblock if the movie in question is a big budget film with pre-release buzz like 1917, but the vast majority of films released across the world every year don't have that luxury. This means independent films and foreign films that can't get a theater to show their movie for a solid week in a tiny corner of the globe are instantly disqualified. The competition for upstart directors all clammoring for a spot at an arthouse theater or a megaplex must be rough. Foreign films especially don't get a lot of theater space in America. Bong Joon-ho remarked upon this recently, calling the Academy Awards a “regional” movie awards ceremony. His most recent film, Parasite, is up for Best Picture, but this is incredibly rare. In order for a foreign film to be nominated for any Academy Award BESIDES Best Foreign Language Film, first, it needs to get picked up by an American distributor, then it needs to get shown in theaters in one specific county in America. But that only means that it is not immediately disqualified. Realistically – it needs to do so well among both film critics and audiences that the Academy voters take notice. It's got to be the next Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon. In the past ten years, the only non-English language films nominated for Best Picture have been Amour in 2012 and the aforementioned Parasite. There is more.
The major motion picture studios are populated by Academy voters and board members, and they have recently tightened qualifications in order to kneecap Netflix. If a film is released through streaming services or video-on-demand first or even simultaneously at the time of its theater release, the movie is disqualified. That's why The Irishman and Marriage Story, two Netflix films nominated for Best Picture this year, had limited theater releases even though Netflix obviously wants these films to be exclusive to their streaming service to drive up subscriptions. So, if the question is “Are the Oscars of great significance in the medium of film in determining who and what is the best?” then the answer based purely on this is only...kind of? Some of the best motion pictures made every year are in the English language or are popular foreign films praised by English-speaking critics, such as Parasite. However, if almost everything is immediately disqualified and almost everything else is not considered, then “kind of” is the most charitable answer to the question. But there is so much more to how the Oscars are chosen... [II. Campaigns] A studio campaign for an Oscar both is and is not similar to a presidential campaign. Both use tremendous amounts of money, both are out to convince those who can vote who they should vote for, both can be deeply dishonest and malicious.
AUDIO 3
But they also differ greatly and not only because the stakes are so much lower for an Oscar. The money to elevate a movie or actor in the eyes of the Academy doesn't come from donors, it comes straight from the coffers of the studio. According to the rules, the studio must only look like it's “celebrating cinema”, must appear almost disinterested in the award itself. That's why “For Your Consideration” is such a popular phrase and not some campaign slogan about why their movie is the best. This is all nonsense, of course. The studio is actively campaigning, it's just being done more quietly. The billboards and ads in trade publications are only the public face. The real campaign is happening more quietly. In the 90's, campaigning for the Academy Awards began to change, and while it might not be entirely fair to blame this is one gross monster, I mean, it is kind of his fault, right? Harvey Weinstein ran what was, for a while, a small production company, and a small production company like Miramax could make a lot of their money after their Oscar nomination. Miramax did everything they could to earn Academy votes. They called voters at their homes, on vacation, set up screenings for *where* they were on vacation, threw parties attended by actors in their movies and invited the press, sometimes straight-up lied to Academy voters. They even set up screenings at motion picture retirement homes for elderly Academy voters – who were on life support but could still vote.
AUDIO 4
Academy voters receive For Your Consideration booklets, DVDs, copies of screenplays, and CDs of soundtracks. Voters are invited to tons of screenings and can only go to so many, ramping up the competitiveness among the studios. Voters are targeted by For Your Consideration ads in industry publications, on social media, ads on billboards, subways, and taxis. Those last few are generally only in New York and Los Angeles. The process usually starts in the fall, after the blitz of film festivals in Venice, Telluride, and Toronto, and ramps up over the next six months leading up to the Oscars. All of this raises awareness of the film and creates the notion among the voters that this movie could win and therefore must be on their must-watch list. Movies that aren't pushed as hard by studios or not at all are not nominated because the voters are never given any reason to believe they could win. The Academy is massive, and though estimates vary, it's at least 7,000 but possibly higher than 8,000. This means that the campaigns reach every voter must be massive, too. Both the actors and directors campaign. Tom Hanks, for example, is said to be involved in campaigning in all of his films, and he can apparently really turn on the charm.
There are endless Q&A's and campaign events and dinners. Academy voters are “judges” but they are not a hopefully unbiased jury. They party with the nominees and spend time on their vacations with them. Winning an Oscar has about as much to do with making a great movie as it does campaigning and convincing others to vote for your movie. So, if the Oscars are about hobnobbing with the right people and earning their vote through parties and advertisements, do the Oscars matter? “Kind of”? Despite the campaigns and the lack of anything resembling integrity, sometimes great performances and great movies are rewarded. Would they have been rewarded without a successful campaign? Probably not because a strong campaign will beat a strong movie, but in a better world, they would have “earned” the award. Sometimes the right movie or right person wins even if the endless campaigns mean they always win them for the “wrong” reasons. But there is still one more perspective on whether or not the Oscars matter.
AUDIO 5
[III. Representation] If the Academy Awards are not a meritocracy in terms of judging films across the world or in terms of judging films based on quality and not campaigning, then what about inclusiveness? Are all films even within the limited scope of the Academy given a fair shake? Ten years ago, a woman won the Academy Award for Best Director for the first time in history. It took Kathryn Bigelow and The Hurt Locker for this to happen. Only five women have ever been nominated for Best Director, and in 2020, women directors were snubbed again. In addition to this, films that could be described as “male-coded” or appealing to male demographics look to be the big nominees. 1917, a movie populated almost exclusively with men for somewhat obvious reasons, The Irishman, taking place in the patriarchal mafia, Ford v. Ferrari, a dad movie set in the world of car racing, and the latest entry by dude-bro messiah Quentin Tarantino. Furthermore, the best picture nominees, with Parasite being the lone exception, are deeply...white. In early 2015, following the popularization of the #OscarsSoWhite hashtag, detractors of the hashtag and movement did what detractors always do when the subject of representation is broached.
They claimed that the cream will always rise to the top, that no actual barriers have ever existed and that choosing a person of color for an acting award or directing award amounts to quotas. The truth is, the Academy Awards have never been a true meritocracy, actual barriers have existed for a long time, and nobody is asking for a person of color to receive an award on that basis but rather to be considered equally. Unequal treatment goes back to the Hayes Code of the 30's, 40's and 50's. While the code was most notable for censoring risque material, the code also forbade miscegenation, a now rarely used word that effectively means the mixing of races. This severely limited roles for people of color all on its own, but it particularly affected women of color. In those days, most leading roles for women were as the romantic partner of the leading man, and miscegenation rules mandated that they either both be white or both be black, and since Hollywood wasn't in the business of heavily promoting black films, the former was almost always the case. If there were no leading roles for women of color, then there were no opportunities for Best Actress in a Leading Role. Although the Hayes Code ended in the mid-20th century, this remained the standard operating procedure for a long time due to Hollywood's now infamous inability to accept change.
AUDIO 6
Times have changed, but the demographics of the Best Picture and Best Director nominees are not radically different. This is not to say that there is some secret, shadowy cabal actively working to keep the Oscars as white and male as possible. Rather, it has to do with the demographics of the voters. To this day, long after the demographics controversy, only 16% of Academy voters are people of color, and only 28% are women. The most charitable explanation for this exclusion is a kind of unconscious bias. Producer Amy Pascal explained it like this: “[Voters think], these kinds of stories are important to me, and these kinds of stories are less important to me. … I do wonder if many thousands of voters, deciding what to watch on their screeners or deciding which ones they go to, might have an unconscious reaction...” Again, even the most charitable explanation for exclusion, an unconscious reaction, still doesn't neatly solve the issue. The Academy does occasionally award Best Picture to a black film about the black experience, but with the exception of Moonlight, there is always some catch. 12 Years a Slave is set in the distant past, and Green Book is set during segregation. Not to mention that it's a white savior film, a black helplessness narrative that was rightly excoriated by black film critics and activists.
Both of these films are...safe. They do not challenge white audiences about their present day attitudes but instead tell white audiences and white Academy voters how far they themselves have come. This is particularly true for aging white Academy voters who remember those days and can applaud themselves and pretend such attitudes are things of the past. Bear in mind, 12 Years a Slave may be “safe” for white audiences, but it's also really good and deserving of the recognition, unlike Green Book, which is not. It's bad. It's a bad movie. In contrast, movies like Sorry to Bother You do not receive Academy award nominations. They are less...safe. Sorry to Bother You is set in modern day and shows white audiences wherein their guilt lies. It's not an “Academy” movie. The intersection between whiteness and dudeness is that even when a movie breaks through, there is usually a catch. Only one best-picture winner over the past decade has had a woman protagonist – The Shape of Water, starring Sally Hawkins but directed by Guillermo del Toro. When a woman director's movie is nominated for Best Picture, there is a good chance, she herself will not be nominated for Best Director, and should such a movie break through, it will almost certainly be a movie about white women.
AUDIO 7
Studios pick their candidates based on “electability” and pour money into them, targeting Academy voters with ads, mailers, screeners, events, and more. Studios engage in a self-fulfilling prophecy. They know that the demographic makeup of the Academy voters, and they cater their campaigns toward those demographics. Then, when we get years of #OscarsSoWhite and only men nominated for best director and bro-movies and so-called “safe picks” instead of something intriguing and new, the studios have plausible deniability.
They didn't choose the best picture nominees. The Academy voters did. But of course, the Academy voters were nudged in those directions by the studios, sent particular screeners, invited to specific events for specific movies and so forth. This is how a movie like Joker, which received mixed reviews, and has the least amount of critical appraisal out of all the best picture nominees, can be the most nominated movie of the year. Least praise, most nominations. Whether you loved Joker or hated it is irrelevant to the point. Joker discourse is over, please spare us your hot take, nobody cares. The point is that any movie that almost half the community of critics gave a thumbs down to getting the most nominations over everything else is an indicator of an effective campaign and not any inherent quality. Academy voting is not a meritocracy – it is a game. Warner Bros put all their eggs in this basket. They went hard on Joker, and it received 11 out of Warner Bros' 12 overall nominations. The 12th was for Kathy Bates' performance in Richard Jewell. Warner Bros clearly did not try to position Just Mercy for that spot, despite being released in the prime December spot for Academy voters and despite an overall better critical reception than either film. You can draw your own conclusions about why, but the studios know the demographics of the Academy voters, and they model their campaigns around electability. [Stats]
AUDIO 8
The Academy members and therefore voters are predominantly people who work in the motion picture industry in Hollywood. Though everyone from costume designers to directors can be members, the actual membership has a disproprotionate amount of actors. If the “goodness” of a movie is judged mainly on the performance by the lead actor, that can be enough to grant it Best Picture status due to the disproportionate amount of actors as Academy voters. So, based on all these biases and weirdly specific demographics and privileges, do the Oscars matter? Kind of?
The Academy Awards still, more often than not, chooses good – albeit sometimes not great – movies. Almost certainly not the best movies even within the stringent and exclusive qualifications and biases, but “best” is subjective enough that “kind of” might be the best answer here too. Honestly, the biggest piece of evidence that the Academy Awards don't matter is how forgettable the best picture movies are. Two years after the statues are handed out, does anyone really remember the nominees? Is anyone out there still stanning hard for...Spotlight? Does anyone still talk about Best Picture winners like Argo or The Artist? Is anyone's favorite movie Best Picture nominees like Philomena or Brooklyn? Did anyone even see Brooklyn? Is there a big fandom for Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close? Are there brainy, academic courses about garden variety biopics like The Imitation Game and The Theory of Everything? Is anyone dying for a sequel to The Big Short? What I'm trying to say is: Movies are great, but the Academy doesn't always pick great movies. The Academy Awards ceremony is a terrible predictor of what will remain important to the medium. The list of nominees is a snapshot of what studios and paid consultants have decided to present on one night of the year and happily throw away the morning after.
BERMAN TREK
In 1964, television writer and producer Gene Roddenberry drafted a script for a science fiction series called Star Trek. The series would be show a space-age starship exploring the galaxy. It would center around Captain Robert April of the USS Yorktown, which was eventually changed to Captain Christopher Pike of the USS Enterprise. After a second pilot was ordered, this was changed once again to Captain James Kirk of the Enterprise. By 1966, Star Trek had debuted, and the world of sci-fi would forever be changed. Roddenberry, like any producer searching for a long-term project, was looking for a hit, but he also had something else in mind. He was angry about the suffering and injustice he saw in the world around him, and like other great television writers like Rod Serling, he saw the medium as a powerful tool to comment on those injustices – and to expose them. To Roddenberry, television was more than just a way to tell stories. He could comment on the civil rights movement, sometimes indirectly by showing an integrated crew working together with few, if any, references to any tension among them, and sometimes directly and overtly such as in “Let That Be Your Last Battlefield.” He could comment on the emerging women's liberation movement by originally having the first officer be a woman, and when that unfortunately had some pushback, he introduced several more women characters on the Enterprise.
The battle between what Roddenberry wanted to do and what less progressive voices were afraid to do became part of Star Trek, and many years later, this battle changed...but before that did, Roddenberry had one more great contribution to Star Trek. [The Next Generation theme] Star Trek: The Next Generation debuted in 1987. It starred a new captain, Jean-Luc Picard, and featured a new Enterprise. It had more women in leading roles, more to say about the modern world, and it was the perfect antidote the cynical, conservative, Ronald Reagan 80's. And then Gene Roddenberry got sick. A lifetime of amphetamines to work through the writing process, a lifetime of recreational drug use and declining health caught up to him. By all accounts, his role on The Next Generation greatly diminished after the end of the first season, and in 1991, the Great Bird of the Galaxy passed away. Roddenberry was not perfect – his detractors will undoubtedly note his alleged affairs and some of his less progressive ideas for characters that were thankfully scrapped – but whatever else Gene Roddenberry was, he was a true believer. He a humanist, and he thought humanity had the potential to create a future like the one in Star Trek. When he passed away, someone else had to take over as head of The Next Generation and the Star Trek franchise in general...and that man was Rick Berman.
AUDIO 2
Over the years, Berman became a controversial figure both among the fans and the various casts and crews of multiple Star Trek series. He was labeled a “misogynist” by beloved Trek actress Terry Farrell, a “raging homophobe” by veteran Trek writer David Gerrold, and a lot worse by Garrett Wang. Berman was not a true believer, once telling the LA Times “I don’t believe the 24th Century is going to be like Gene Roddenberry believed it to be, that people will be free from poverty and greed. But if you’re going to write and produce for ‘Star Trek,’ you’ve got to buy into that.” Of course, nobody knows what the future will bring, but Berman did not simply suspect disagree with Roddenberry's humanist vision. He was enforced it through a series of regressive mandates, refusals of important, conscientious stories and behavior toward the cast and crew that was, by many accounts, absolutely disgraceful. Before, the battle to have Star Trek be Star Trek was that of two sides: Roddenberry with his writers vs. the more cautious, conservative network. Now, the battle was between Rick Berman vs. his writers, his crew and his cast. While Berman was a producer during the time of the creation of new Trek series like the magnificent Deep Space Nine and the criminally underrated Voyager, the evidence of his involvement and where his fingerprints are on each series seem to point to Trek flourishing not because of him, but in spite of him.
The franchise had entered the era...of Berman Trek. [title] Rick Berman taking over Star Trek was academic. In the eyes of Paramount, there were no other options. In the beginning of the Next Generation, according to Berman himself, there were two producers under Roddenberry: Bob Justman, who stayed on only for the first year, and Eddie Milkis, who left due to a disagreement with Roddenberry. Berman was inexperienced at the time, his biggest credit being a producer on a children's show on PBS. Many among the crew found working with him a challenge. Production illustrator Andrew Probert once claimed "When Rick Berman took over the show, half way through the first season, every time we showed him a design concept, his constant response was, 'No, we can't do that, because it reminds me of something that I've seen somewhere' or 'It looks like a shaver' or 'It looks like something I've seen in a furniture store.' The only thing of note that Rick Berman did before Star Trek was a show called The Big Blue Marble, a kid's show. … Rick Berman did not, in that time, and, as far as I can see from what is being produced, does not understand science fiction. My experience with Rick Berman is he does not understand what he's doing..."
AUDIO 3
One immediate impact of Roddenberry's declining health and declining influence on The Next Generation was that some modern ideas for the series were halted. During the run of The Original Series, actor George Takei asked Roddenberry for the inclusion of a gay character. Following the fallout from the interracial kiss, Roddenberry worried that a gay character would spell the end of the series and put the idea on the back burner. Star Trek was canceled shortly thereafter, providing no opportunity to revisit the idea within the series. After a few successful movies with no references to gay crew members, Roddenberry finally decided that the world was ready. At a fan convention in 1986, Roddenberry reportedly said “We should show gay people on board the Enterprise.” This was not only something he said to the fans. He reportedly said the same thing in a staff meeting for The Next Generation. In a 1991 interview with The Humanist, Roddenberry remarked on his evolution on the issue from the 60's to the 80's. “My attitude toward homosexuality has changed. I came to the conclusion that I was wrong. ... I gave the impression of being thoughtless in these areas. I have, over many years, changed my attitude about gay men and women.” Early in the run of The Next Generation, long-time Trek writer David Gerrold wrote a script for an episode called Blood and Fire, an allegory for the HIV crisis of the 80's and 90's.
Roddenberry was initially supportive. In fact, according to Gerrold, the crisis was high on the list of topics Roddenberry himself wanted discussed in the series. Gerrold explained how the script was eventually rejected. “So that the script, somewhere in there I was 'You know what, these two characters, they could be boyfriends.' There were two lines of dialog. 'How long have you two been together?' and 'Since the Academy.' That was it. I go off to a Star Trek cruise and come back to find there has been a cluster****. Rick Berman writes that we can’t do this episode and how we are on at 4PM in some markets and mommies are going to write letters. We get half the staff saying we shouldn’t do it and the other half – those who could recognize a good story – saying 'This is a hell of a script, we got to do this and demonstrate we are the Star Trek that everybody’s been waiting for.'” By that point, Roddenberry's health had deteriorated to the point that his lawyer, Leonard Maizlish, and Rick Berman, were running The Next Generation. While Roddenberry was not completely innocent in this, Gerrold has stated that he blames Berman for the demands for rewrites and eventual rejection of Blood and Fire. According to a separate interview with Salon, Gerrold claimed “A large part of the problem was that Gene’s health was failing. He didn’t have the physical strength he needed — and he was experiencing mental lapses as well.”
AUDIO 4
This was not the only time that the subject of homosexuality was shot down by the producers of The Next Generation. What could have been the first Star Trek episode to explicitly reference homosexuality or even just orientation in general, The Outcast, was watered down considerably. The episode, written by accomplished Trek writer Jeri Taylor, told the story of an androgynous species that had only a minority of its people identify as male or female. Commander Riker becomes romantically involved with a member of the species who identifies strongly as female. Although modern eyes might view this as more akin to an allegory about gender identity, the character's speech as the end clearly identifies this episode as at least intended to be about homosexuality. The episode has...problems. For an episode subtextually about being gay, the romance is heterosexual. To his credit, the actor who played Riker, Jonathan Frakes, was said to have wanted the alien be a man and not a woman and that he be allowed to kiss a man on The Next Generation. Also, a line in the script, presumably spoken by Dr. Crusher, that uses the word “orientation” was forcibly removed.
In the episode The Offspring, Data builds an android daughter called Lal. Data educates her as best he can, but Lal becomes confused when she sees two people kissing. In the script, Guinan was supposed to instruct Lal, saying “When a man a a woman are in love...” and there would be men and women sitting at tables holding hands. Whoopi Goldberg refused and said “When two people are in love.” Cast and crew decided on set that there should be two men or two women holding hands as well, but someone called the producers, and the idea was shut down hard. Defenders of Berman as showrunner as well as the other producers trot out the argument that it was a different time and that gay characters or even references to being gay was forbidden on television even in the early 90's, but that is simply not the case. There was a gay character on The Mary Tyler Moore Show in a 1973 episode called My Brother's Keeper. All in the Family, in 1975, introduced not only had a gay character but a recurring gay character in drag. Cheers had an episode sympathetic to homosexuality in 1983. The Golden Girls, in the 80's and 90's, had multiple episodes with gay characters and references. Roc had a recurring gay character played by none other than Shaft himself, Richard Roundtree.
AUDIO 5
Early 90's sitcoms like Seinfeld, Frasier and Friends had episodes and characters centered around the topic as well. This is also true of dramas like Dynasty, LA Law and lots more. While said sitcoms and dramas were not always entirely sensitive, they still were allowed on the air with little to no fuss. There is no excuse for a series like Star Trek: The Next Generation, which had a progressive legacy to uphold, to not even be as modern as The Mary Tyler Moore Show on this subject. But this was the way of things under showrunner Rick Berman. The buck stopped with him and so did any reference to being gay. Berman's relationship with the women cast members was, at times, adversarial. In an interview, Denise Crosby, who played Tasha Yar, told Trek Core: “Sure, I mean I thought that would be the last day and they came down with a cake and you know… But my favorite thing is when Rick Berman, the producer, came down to the set and the very first thing he did was pull off my communicator from my uniform and said, 'Well, won’t be needing that anymore!' […] You used to just stick [it on with] velcro and it was just like some weird symbolic gesture… I don’t know if he thought I was going to sell it on eBay or you know… I mean they all looked the same – it wasn’t like mine was any special thing – it was just a very strange thing – I’ll never forget that.”
Berman recently lied about this, claiming that Denise Crosby gave her the badge, and Crosby set him straight on Twitter. Years after Crosby left The Next Generation, she petitioned Berman to return to the series as the daughter of Tasha Yar and Lt. Castilo from the alternate timeline. Berman had a different idea, and tweaked it, and had Crosby return as Tasha's daughter but Castilo would not be the father. Instead, Berman's vision was that the daughter, Sela, would be the result of Tasha being effectively being captured and forced to become a concubine to a powerful Romulan. So, because of Berman, the legacy of Tasha Yar is forced, umm, “servitude” – to a Romulan. There is a word for this, but if I say it, this will get demonetized. So...yeah. Gross. Crosby did the episodes, and when she asked to return, Berman denied her for unknown reasons. Marina Sirtis, who played Counselor Deanna Troi, noted that negotiating her contract with Rick Berman and Paramount was a nightmare, once stating “Women are always paid less and the negotiations are always uglier because there is some kind of feeling that we don’t deserve the same money as the boys. It was always ugly. I quit smoking for six years but what got me started again was contract negotiations with Paramount. That is how bad it was.” It apparently got worse during the Next Generation movies:
AUDIO 6
“When I was negotiating for [Star Trek:] Nemesis they literally threatened to fire me and recast Troi, well not actually recast, but they said 'We are going to fire you and hire Jeri Ryan (Seven of Nine from Star Trek Voyager).' And I said 'Well Jeri Ryan won’t do it for that money, that is for sure.'” In fact, Ryan refused, and Sirtis was back in. The women of the Next Generation had very little to do in the movies. Guinan is only in Generations, Crusher is an afterthought in all four movies, and Troi has little to do, except in the aforementioned Nemesis in which, umm. [“It was a violation.”] Iiiiin which she is a victim and nothing more. One actor who left The Next Generation specifically because of the producers, most notably Berman, was Wil Wheaton, who played Wesley Crusher. Wheaton was approached to be in a Milos Forman film, Valmont. This was not only a good opportunity for Wheaton but for Star Trek: The Next Generation. Having one of your actors in an Oscar winner's movie would help build the prestige of the series. Most producers would be happy to work around the actor's schedule because of this, but Rick Berman and Brannon Braga apparently shut it down hard, apparently citing Wheaton being crucial to an upcoming episode. However, when said episode was shot, Wheaton discovered that it had nothing to do with him and that in the edit, he is barely in it.
This is why the Wesley Crusher character was written out. Wheaton couldn't work with Rick Berman as showrunner. When Star Trek: Deep Space Nine debuted, much of the show was run by Ira Stephen Behr after Michael Piller left DS9 after season two to work on Voyager. Behr turned DS9 into something Berman could not understand: a series with consequences. Episodes had consequences for future episodes. New, fresh, exciting ideas could be explored, and by all accounts, Berman hated it. Ronald D. Moore, who wrote episodes for both The Next Generation and Deep Space Nine, once remarked upon the contentious relationship between Behr and Berman. “They were just always conservative. You were always pulling back from something. You were never given a note saying, ‘Go farther. Go wilder. This needs to be more shocking.’ It was always, ‘Pull it back. Be safer.' … I remember one particularly insane argument that (executive producer) Ira (Steven Behr) and Rick had when Nog was injured, and ended up losing a leg. There was this ridiculous extended argument that I was in a room while Ira was on the phone. We had written the draft where he had lost both legs, and Rick was just appalled. ‘We can’t lose the character’s legs!’ And we were like, ‘No, we’ve got to. We’ve got to have somebody who’s injured in this war who’s not just a guest star in the background.’”
AUDIO 7
Much of Deep Space Nine revolved around heightened tensions between the Federation and the Dominion over the course of seasons three, four and five, resulting in full scale war in season six and seven. If Berman had his way, it never would have happened. Behr didn't convince him. Rather, he lied. According to Moore, the only reason the Dominion War happened was because Behr kept it from Berman until it was too late. Much like with The Next Generation, Deep Space Nine was not permitted to be particularly gay. Elim Garak, a plain simple tailor who absolutely was not a Cardassian spy, was supposed to be a one-off character. Actor Andrew Robinson brought the character to life, particularly in his scenes with Dr. Julian Bashir. The writers loved him and decided to keep him around. Sparks flew between Garak and Bashir, they started having meals together, and grew closer and closer. Robinson confessed that this tension and this characterization was intentional on his part. For fans of the pairing, it seemed this could be building to Star Trek's first gay relationship. Yet, after the excellent episode The Wire aired, the two began to have fewer and fewer scenes together, and Garak was romantically paired with a young Cardassian woman named Ziyal. To some viewers, the characters seemed to have just drifted apart, but over the years, the cast and crew of the show have pointed the finger at Rick Berman. Interviews over the years at various cons have brought to light the fact that Berman instructed Deep Space Nine’s writers to stop giving Garak and Bashir scenes together. Andrew Robinson was reportedly told to “tone down” his portrayal. Homosexuality and bisexuality in both The Next Generation and Deep Space Nine were relegated to what can only charitably be called an accidental queerness. For example, in the TNG episode The Host, Dr. Beverly Crusher breaks off her relationship with Odan when he changes host bodies to that of a woman, and in the DS9 episode Rejoined, Jadzia Dax is only attracted to a woman because back when she had a different male body, she and the woman were married, only...she also had a different body. It's Star Trek, it's complicated, but the point is her relationship is a matter of science fiction consequences that immediately go away at the end of the episode. The only other references to anything not straight is in a Mirror Universe episode in which bisexuality is product of a backwards parallel universe. If one were to be forgiving of Rick Berman, he did not have much, if anything, to do with said Mirror Universe episode. Not all problems with Star Trek from that era can be traced back to him. But his fingerprints on the regressive side of Trek from that time are hard to ignore.
AUDIO 8
Fortunately for Deep Space Nine, Ira Stephen Behr had a lot of power and was in charge of the overall flow of the series, but Rick Berman's presence caused a lot of problems, particularly for Terry Farrell, the actress of who played Jadzia Dax. These are Farrell's words from the book The Fifty Year Mission, but I have to substitute certain words with synonyms to avoid demonetization: “The problems with my leaving were with Rick Berman. In my opinion, he’s just very misogynistic. He’d comment on your bra size not being voluptuous. His secretary had a 36C or something like that, and he would say something about 'Well, you’re just, like, flat. Look at Christine over there. She has the perfect [chest].' That’s the kind of conversation he would have in front of you. I had to have fittings... I think it was double-D or something. I went to see a woman who fits bras for women who need mastectomies; I had to have that fitting. And then I had to go into his office. Michael Piller didn’t care about those things, so he wasn’t there when you were having all of these crazy fittings with Rick Berman criticizing your hair or how big your [chest was or wasn't]. That stuff was so intense, especially the first couple of years.”
Contracts for Deep Space Nine were for six seasons, which meant that the main cast had to sign an extension for the seventh and final season. Farrell, whose character was very popular among the fans, wanted to negotiate, but Berman was infamous for not taking women seriously during contract negotiations. See: Marina Sirtis. Farrell continued: “Basically he was trying to bully me into saying yes. He was convinced that my cards were going to fold and I was going to sign up. He had [another] producer come up to me and say, 'If you weren’t here, you know you’d be working at Kmart.' I was, like, 'What the hell are you talking about? I had a career before this. Why the hell would I be working at Kmart? Who are you?' Just to be jerky, he’d call me in my trailer: 'Have you been thinking about it yet? Are you going to sign?' Like, right before I had a scene. It was that kind of thing. Rick Berman said I was hardballing him, and I was, like, 'I’m not. I just want to have a conversation. You’re giving me a take-it-or-leave-it offer and I’m not okay with that.' So I finally did have a conversation with him and asked to cut down my number of episodes or just let me out.” Reportedly, Ira Stephen Behr was kept out of the loop and learned about this after fact. He believes this is because Berman knew he would have had another angry confrontation with him.
AUDIO 9
Whether this constitutes a firing or quitting depends on one's perspective. Nevertheless, Farrell was gone from Deep Space Nine and Dax was “recast” by a younger actress. It's a Trill thing. Contrary to popular belief, Farrell did not leave Deep Space Nine to be on Becker. She had not signed with Becker or even had an offer at the time of her departure. She simply was, as she predicted, able to secure another acting job following Deep Space Nine. It's important to note something: Rick Berman's defenders prefer to think of him as someone who was only trying to keep the lights on and Star Trek continuing. No biases, no misogyny, no homophobia, nothing like that. But stories like his interactions with Terry Farrell and Denise Crosby paint an accurate picture of his motivations and character. By most accounts, Berman despised the style of storytelling in Deep Space Nine. Berman denies this, but it was common wisdom among those who worked with him. Bryan Fuller, a Trek writer and producer, claimed in the aforementioned book The Fifty Year Mission that Berman's mindset was syndication, and that syndication requires everything to be wrapped up by the end of the episode, which is the antithesis of character building. Berman was more at home with a project he apparently felt closer to: Star Trek: Voyager.
Berman was not only in charge of Voyager but was more hands-on with it than Deep Space Nine, even having fair amount of the writing and story credits. So, when we talk about Jeri Ryan's outfit and some other things, we need to have no delusions about who ultimately signed off on them. There was a lot of financial wrangling about rights and having to pay writers for the rights to characters and stories. Ira Stephen Behr remarked “We had done the Maquis on Deep Space Nine because they wanted to set them up for Voyager. We were doing a two-part episode; Michael Piller wrote part one and I wrote part two. Mike, or maybe it was Mike and Rick [Berman], come in and they go, 'Look, Voyager is going to be about the Federation and these guys banding together to get home on this ship... we don’t want there to be any problems, so we’re going to put Jeri Taylor’s name, Rick’s name, and Mike’s name onto the story with you.' And it’s, like, 'What? You think I’m going to f***ing sue you? You think I’m going to try and get money from Voyager because I’m writing this episode?' ... That was f***ing lame. I was p****ed off about that. To me that was, like, 'Okay, you’re basically saying you don’t trust me, or not that you don’t trust me, but that you’re putting your names on it for ownership of something that no one is going to question.' It was not a friendly franchise thing to do.”
AUDIO 10
There was also a belief that the reason that Robert Duncan McNeill ended up playing Tom Paris instead of his Nicholas Lacarno character was that the show would have to pay royalties to the creator of the character. Paris' backstory about what he did that got him expelled from Starfleet is similar to that of Lacarno. Both were involved in pilot errors with fatal results and a coverup. They are not the same character, but their backstories are so similar that the official reason, that being that Lacarno was irredeemable and Paris was not, does not add up. Not when what they did was the roughly the same thing. Rick Berman was more hands-on with Voyager than Deep Space Nine, and it showed. According to Garrett Wang, who played Ensign Harry Kim, Berman told the cast that the human characters were to lack emotions. All acting had to be underplayed and militaristic. This was, apparently, in service of making the alien characters seem more real by contrast. During the first year of shooting, the actors were required to re-shoot scenes due to excessive emotion. If you thought some of the characters on Voyager were a little dry, this was by design. Wang wanted Harry Kim to be promoted from Ensign to show character growth, but Rick Berman and Brannon Braga refused the request. Wang also requested to direct an episode, and Berman denied this request too.
Wang was the first cast member in the history of the franchise to have a request to direct refused. According to Wang, this was because he said in an interview that the show should take more risks, and Berman held on to this grudge. Wang has said of this “I was the first actor in Star Trek history to be denied the chance to direct. The irony of the situation was that, unlike my predecessors, who only wanted to direct for the sake of directing and acquiring their DGA cards, I was the only one who wanted to direct Trek and make it the best it could be, drawing upon my knowledge and experiences as a lifelong fan of science fiction. I truly believe that if I was given the chance, it would have been the best freshman effort by a Trek actor because of my passion for sci-fi. This missed opportunity has haunted me ever since.” Wang was nearly fired from Voyager at the end of the third season to make room for Seven of Nine, but he was kept on – perhaps due to being People Magazine's 50 Most Beautiful People. Instead, Jennifer Lien was let go. While Jeri Ryan's skin-tight suit was designed by Robert Blackman, it was under the direction of Rick Berman and Brannon Braga. Ryan herself confirmed that the producers wanted – no, needed her outfit to have two individual, ermm, cups, and for the outfit to hug the skin.
AUDIO 11
Ryan was forced to wear a painful corset under the catsuit that was so unbearable that she routinely passed out from the pain. Oxygen tanks had to be on stand-by. In an interview, she once lamented that she wished she could have been given the catsuit after production had wrapped so that she could personally burn it. Subsequent costumes included this number which literally underlines her chest for the audience. Star Trek: Voyager was yet another Trek incarnation that came and went without a gay character. Kate Mulgrew, who played Captain Katherine Janeway, reportedly asked Rick Berman on multiple occasions for there to be gay representation on Voyager, but he refused every time. Berman was a producer and not a writer...until Enterprise. His writing credits on the other series were between 2 and 5. But Enterprise? 37. Berman was concerned about the potential for franchise fatigue with Enterprise, and this may have had something to do with how hands-on he was with it. He didn't want the franchise to be ruined. Of course, Berman did not believe in the same correlation of Berman-to-bad that others do. So...he thought he was helping. He was not. Berman and UPN ramped up the, well, most Berman-y qualities.
AUDIO 12
Enterprise needed an excuse to constantly have the crew showing more skin, particularly T'Pol, played by actress Jolene Blalock. So, now, after every away mission, the Enterprise crew had to rub decontamination gel all over themselves. And of course, if they couldn't reach some places, they would rub gel on each other. We even got to see T'Pol's rear end, but only the top part. This was still network television after all. In season three, ratings were dropping, and the producers decided that one of the biggest changes had to be less clothes. Producers insisted that T'Pol have an even more revealing look in season three. Jolene Blalock criticized making T'Pol more risque, stating, "You can’t substitute t*** and a** for good storytelling. You can have both, but you can't substitute one for the other, because the audience is not stupid. You can’t just throw in frivolous, uncharacteristic... well, bull and think it's gonna help the ratings!"
In addition to this step backward for Trek, Enterprise underutilized its only two minority actors in the main cast. Travis Mayweather and Hoshi Sato were frequently sidelined and ignored during the series. This is particularly true of Mayweather, played by Anthony Montgomery, who barely existed.
AUDIO 13
Also, again, no gay representation on the series. Once more unto the breach. Dominic Keeting, the actor who played Malcolm Reed, clearly tried to make his character gay, but the producers would have none of it. Keeting once remarked “I played him so gay ... I mean, it was always rumored that Malcolm was gay, wasn't it? It was that one line of his three-line bio, 'Shy around women,' that just shockwaved across the gay community. … I don't want to say it was dry and they didn't want to take any risks, but there was an element of that." Producers were rumored to be so concerned about Reed being perceived as gay that they forced references to Reed's unshakable straightness. Again, giving credit where it's due: I recently re-watched Enterprise from front to back, and I have a lot more affection for it now than I did during its initial run. Trip is great. T'Pol is great. Shran is the best.
I have faith of the heart, but Enterprise is still the weakest of the four Star Trek shows from this era, and a lot of that must be laid at the feet of the showrunner, executive producer, and for some reason, writer of a lot of the series, Rick Berman. Rick Berman held an office at Paramount until December of 2006. Not long after Enterprise was canceled, Berman stepped aside from the franchise so that someone else could take a crack at it. After three reboot movies of varying quality and box office receipts, Star Trek was given to Bryan Fuller and then to Alex Kurtzman. Star Trek: Discovery finally fulfilled the promise of a gay main character in Star Trek with Lieutenant Commander Paul Stammets, Dr. Hugh Culber and Engineer Jett Reno. Emperor Phillipa Georgiou appears to be pansexual, but that seems to be the norm in the Mirror Universe. I have some issues with the series, but I definitely love gay it is. Frankly, I hope season three is even gayer. And with more Tilly, please. Also, Star Trek: Picard has premiered, and you know what? So far, so good. Whether you love the new shows or hate them, it seems clear that Star Trek needed to be in other hands after so long in the grip of Rick Berman. Star Trek is taking risks again, and since risk was part of its foundation, that makes a lot of sense. Here's to the future.
DOWNTON ABBEY
Weyland-Yutani from the Alien franchise. RDA Corporation from Avatar. Omni Consumer Products from Robocop. Hollywood has a long history of portraying powerful corporate entities as caricatures of real world corporations. Hollywood takes the pulse of the nation and delivers to them an antagonist that they are most likely to despise. The film and television industry does not mind that some vestigial arm of capitalism is portrayed badly. Corporations can profit from anything – even anti-capitalism and other radical ideas. It's called recuperation, the process by which capital intercepts socially and politically radical ideas and images, commodifies them, and safely incorporates them back within mainstream society – in this case, popular media. Nevertheless, the portrayals of the rich are still worth exploring, as these portrayals tell us a lot about the culture that created them. Different from the antagonist being a faceless, nebulous corporation is the antagonist being “the rich” as a class of people. This is nothing new – see: 1989 film Society – but there has been an uptick in the rich as a class of people being the antagonist, a rich family or a rich community. Parasite is a fine example, but in terms of Hollywood films, there were a few released only last year.
Ready or Not tells the story of a young bride who marries into a rich family only to discover that the family has made a dark magical pact and believes that their wealth can only be maintained by sacrificing her, the implication being that the rich do not become rich through virtuous means and only maintain their wealth through more and more irresponsible and dangerous methods over time. Knives Out is the story of a rich, greedy and deeply flawed family whose patriarch has recently passed and the fallout regarding the will. A poor woman who took care of the old man who died is thrust into their lives more completely and finds herself in great danger. The culture of the United States and the ever-growing disparity between the rich and poor make the frequency of the rich as antagonists acceptable or even welcome among the poor or even among the suburban middle class. Different cultures portray the rich differently, and media from the United Kingdom tends to have a different outlook on rich families for somewhat obvious reasons. The UK props up one of the wealthiest families in the world. The Crown, produced by British production company Left Bank Pictures, has frequently been described as propaganda for the royal family.
AUDIO 2
It was created by Peter Morgan, a British writer perhaps most famous for writing The Queen, a movie about how the prime minister was wrong for doubting the royal family and how the real victim of the tragic death of Princess Diana was actually Queen Elizabeth II. I hate this movie. There are numerous other examples of this in the UK, a pattern of lifting up the wealthy and powerful as our social betters. I call this loose sub-genre of drama Aristo-Trash: media that portrays the concentration of wealth as a public good. There is no more famous example of this than the wildly popular British television series and later movie: Downton Abbey. The series takes place in the titular country estate and stars its residents, the aristocratic Crawley family, and the servants who live there. The series itself is largely conservative in its politics, portraying the family as ultimately a force for good in Yorkshire and the fictionalized, idealized relationship between the super rich and the poor as one of family and friendship. The series was created by Julian Fellowes, a Conservative Party peer of the House of Lords. His full name and title is actually Julian Alexander Kitchener-Fellowes, Baron Fellowes of West Stafford. In addition to creating the series, he literally wrote every single episode. There are fifty-two episodes of Downton Abbey, he has the sole writing credit on fifty, and a co-writing credit on two.
He is also the sole writer of the motion picture released last year. This was entirely his baby from front to back, the only voice of the entire run. So, just in case there are any delusions about the political leanings of Downton Abbey, its relationship with the aristocracy, its relationship with capital, its feelings toward the royal family and monarchism, and its intended messages and propaganda, let those misconceptions be washed away now. Every single episode was written by an old Tory who literally must be addressed as Lord Fellowes. Downton Abbey and other aristo-trash put a human face on the rich for the purpose capitalist apologetics and propaganda about how the rich are just like us and therefore would always have our best interests at heart. Downton Abbey is filled with examples of not only capitalism being an unassailable good for society but the Crawleys in particular being essential and righteous. They have flaws on a personal level, such as the squabbling among the sisters and the normal bickering between husband and wife, but every time the topic of economics come up, the Crawleys are shown as absolutely critical to the good of the town and the nation.
AUDIO 3
Income inequality is ignored and replaced with a paternalistic portrayal of the rich taking care of the poor. Downton Abbey takes place in the early 20th century, but its politics are written by the British Conservative Party of the early 21st century. There are reasons for everything the series chooses to display and everything the series chooses to ignore. According to The Equality Trust, the UK has a very high level of income inequality compared to other developed countries. Over the past five years, basically during the run of Downton Abbey, the top 20% of incomes has increased by 4.7%. The rich getting richer. The poorest 20% have seen their income fall by 1.6%. The poor getting poorer. This is not the full extent of the difference between the richest and the rest of society because the top 1% have significantly higher incomes than the rest of the top 20%.
Since 1980, the share of income earned by the top 1% in the UK has generally has rising, peaking at 13% in 2015. This is almost double the corresponding figure for Belgium at 7%, Scandinavian nations like Sweden and Norway at 8% each, Australia at 9% and so forth. This is only the UK, though. It's worse in the US, as most things are. And as for the whole world, the top 1% earn 20% of the total income. Capitalists and their cheerleaders claim that the rich simply have what they “deserve” and the poor simply have what they “deserve” and that the playing field is the same for all. But we know that's not true, as a great deal of wealth is inherited, and even if the rich “deserve” their wealth, that is of small comfort to people struggling to make ends meet, struggling to find shelter, struggling to find work, struggling to find healthcare, struggling to live. Furthermore, income inequality has other negative effects on society, even though people dying really should be enough of a persuasive argument. Income inequality is a threat to democracy because it allows the super rich to have more say in the government than anyone else. In Downton Abbey, the Crawleys are seen hob-knobbing with royalty and Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain. This is portrayed positively and a great honor instead of what it is: the combined efforts of the rich and powerful to consolidate their positions through a marriage of capitalism and the state.
AUDIO 4
Angus Deaton, a British economist and Nobel Prize winner, once said of this: “The political equality that is required by democracy is always under threat from economic inequality, and the more extreme the economic inequality, the greater the threat to democracy. If democracy is compromised, there is a direct loss of well-being because people have good reason to value their ability to participate in political life, and the loss of that ability is instrumental in threatening other harm. The very wealthy have little need for state-provided education or health care… They have even less reason to support health insurance for everyone, or to worry about the low quality of public schools that plagues much of the country. They will oppose any regulation of banks that restricts profits, even if it helps those who cannot cover their mortgages or protects the public against predatory lending, deceptive advertising, or even a repetition of the financial crash. To worry about these consequences of extreme inequality has nothing to do with being envious of the rich and everything to do with the fear that rapidly growing top incomes are a threat to the well-being of everyone else.” In Downton Abbey, the Crawleys are portrayed as charitable, the mere existence of their abbey creating employment for the town and their charitable works being an added benefit. Downton Abbey skillfully clouds the important fact that the super rich, as a class, don't actually give that much and they get back so much from what they give.
Cheerleaders for capitalism note that men like Bill Gates and Jeff Bezos give to charity, but this illusion of generosity fades the moment we start thinking about what the super rich could be contributing. Put it this way: stealing a million dollars from people who desperately need it, and donating a hundred dollars to those same desperate people is not an act of generosity. What else do the super rich get from their philanthropy? For one, tax breaks. They give some so that they can take more. For another, they get control over the public policy-making process. The think tanks, institutions, and organizations the wealthy use to shape and distort our political discourse. They define the bounds of what gets discussed and what gets ignored. Downton Abbey plays up the myth of the benevolent billionaire, that billionaires serve the public good rather than deepen income inequality. We see this play out every time the Crawleys are shown doing something nice for the servants, like a Christmas party or the servants ball in which the super rich dance with the servants. “Why, they sure are lucky,” the audience is meant to say. “What great billionaires they are. Allowing their servants to dance sometimes!” To be clear, this is played completely straight. It's not satire. It's not commentary on income inequality. It's one hundred percent sincere by Julian Alexander Kitchener-Fellowes, Baron Fellowes of West Stafford.
AUDIO 5
Income inequality is not a bug in capitalism, it's a feature. It's the inevitable consequence of capitalism. In order for the super rich to exist, far more people need to have far less income so that they can perform wage labor to support the super rich. That's how it works. Capitalists don't want poverty to be abolished. Poverty is necessary for their continued existence. Capitalists require a socio-economic hierarchy for their fortunes to exist. They are not incentivized to eliminate poverty. They are actually incentivized to maintain poverty. [S06E04] In the middle of season six, after returning from the United States, Tom Branson remarks that his previous disdain for capitalism has been eased a bit. In the US, he claims, workers have more rights and more of a chance of getting ahead in life. Labor laws in the period during Downton Abbey notwithstanding, this is largely untrue today. Perhaps the biggest difference between US employment law and UK employment law is that the US has something called “at will” employment whereas the UK does not. In the US, employers can terminate employment without notice, for almost any reason. There are notable exceptions like on the grounds of pregnancy, race, religion and gender. In the UK, employment law is much more formal, whereby employment is structured through formal, written contracts.
These contracts will detail the conditions under which a UK employee’s contract can be terminated, and employers are not permitted to terminate an employee’s contract for any reason or without notice. In the UK, there is often a requirement for notice prior to termination, and an employer will often need to show cause. Arguably, the UK has more rights for its workers, at least on paper, but here's the problem. Regardless of what it says on paper, the rich will always have more power in any termination – whether it's a legal termination or not. Capitalists like the Crawley family or the creator of Downton Abbey would claim that labor laws provide equal protection for all, but income inequality under capitalism grants different powers and resources to people in different economic classes. The capitalist will be able to afford better lawyers should a lawsuit be filed against them whereas the average worker either will only be able to afford an average lawyer, or the worker will decide that since there is little chance of a victory, the cost of any lawyer isn't worth it. Capitalists bet on these two outcomes when terminating employees. In other words, yes, it is illegal in both the US and UK to terminate an employee for being pregnant, but proving that was the reason for termination requires the employee having a much better lawyer than their boss.
AUDIO 6
Considering the gulf between their incomes, that is not very likely. Laws only provide equal protection in theory, not in practice, due to the inevitable consequence of capitalism: disparate economic classes. Throughout the course of Downton Abbey, a handful of employees are terminated, but the series never portrays these terminations as the fault of the Crawleys – the capitalists. It's always the fault of the servants living in their meager quarters downstairs. In fact, there are a few instances in the series in which the Crawleys are portrayed to be astonishingly forgiving of the improprieties of their servants. For example, in the motion picture, which acts as a series finale, Barrow mouths off to Lord Crawley. Someone mentions in passing that he could be terminated for this, but the idea is quickly dismissed due to the great love and compassion of the capitalists. The implication is that the Crawleys – the capitalists – are always right and incredibly forgiving. Downton Abbey always portrays social progress one of two ways. Social progress, such as with Tom Branson's socialism, is dangerous and something to be outgrown. Or, social progress, such as with Gwen's rise to secretary instead of house servant, is owed entirely to the capitalists. [S06E04] In season one, Gwen, a maid, dreams of leaving Downton Abbey and becoming a secretary. Lady Sybil encourages her. In season six, the character returns, if only for an episode.
By this point, she and her husband promote Hillcroft College, where young women of more modest upbringing can go to better themselves. The family congratulates Gwen for improving her station in life...for a moment. Then, Gwen corrects them. It was not she who should receive any credit, she insists, but Lady Sybil. This obscures years of Gwen’s hard work. Sybil helped a housemaid become a secretary, and then that secretary moved on to local government, and now uses her hard-earned privileges to help other young women. Instead of recognizing Gwen’s achievement and generosity, the episode celebrates this as a win for Sybil – the woman born into wealth. The implication by Lord Fellowes here is that it is the capitalists who are best put in charge of affecting change – what little change they decree as worthy. Socialism is portrayed as a childish fantasy at best and dangerous at worst. Tom Branson begins as a socialist chauffeur in the early seasons and becomes a capitalist by season six. In the interim, his socialism is challenged not only by other characters but by the show itself. Socialism on Downton Abbey exists only to be torn apart, much like how conservatism only exists on The West Wing for its liberal writers to argue against.
AUDIO 7
Branson always confidently assures people of his belief in socialism until someone delivers a newspaper that says “The Soviets have done it again!” and Branson sinks into his chair, defeated. In the motion picture, his character arc is complete when he saves King George V from an assassination attempt, not only making peace with the aristocracy and the wealthy and monarchism...but embracing them. Once Branson isn't a socialist anymore, someone else needed to be target of writer-creator Lord Fellowes.
This was assigned to Daisy, a chef's assistant who eventually starts reading Karl Marx. Daisy is portrayed, throughout the series, as kind-hearted but silly and naive, much in the same way that capitalists think of young socialists. This is the only change that Downton Abbey welcomes. The kind that shields it from examining exploitation by capitalism, exploitation by the ruling class, and exploitation by the state. Downton Abbey pays lip service to progress, but its sympathies always lie with the powerful. In the motion picture finale to Downtown Abbey, the workers – the servants of the abbey – are absolutely thrilled that the King is visiting. They go to great lengths, even committing a few minor crimes, in order to have the honor of serving royalty. And that's Downton Abbey. Apologia for the rich and powerful, sure, but also a message to the poor that they should be grateful just to be in the same room as people higher than them on the socio-economic ladder. They have no greater goal in life than this, no greater honor in life than to serve the King. The movie portrays their service as glorious, their poverty as nothing. All hail Lord Crawley, and God save the King. Once again, every episode was written by Julian Alexander Kitchener-Fellowes, Baron Fellowes of West Stafford, in case you have any doubts about what is going on here.
AUDIO 8
The world would be materially better without people like the Crawleys. The super rich are the greatest obstacle toward solving climate change. The rich have the resources to insulate themselves from environmental impact. The effects of climate change for the poor are matters of life and death — shifting weather, limited water sources, increased competition for resources and the inability to buy new housing following flooding. Remember, concentrating that much wealth leads to control over public policy. Since the rich do not fear climate change like the rest of us do, and since many of them profit directly from the climate change, they are not incentivized to solve it. Some, like those in the energy industry, are actually economically incentivized to worsen climate change. This concentration of wealth – this income inequality – is literally responsible for why the planet has not fully responded to the threat of climate change. Income inequality, particularly on this level, is objectively ruining the world. There are no Crawleys coming to save us. They're not the solution. They're the problem.
RAMBO
Much of the cultural landscape of the United States in the late 70's and 80's was shaped by the catastrophe of US interventionism in Vietnam in the 60's and early 70's. Popular culture in the United States typically portrayed Vietnam differently than it portrayed more victorious conflicts. Hollywood Vietnam films usually remain agnostic as to the underlying causes of the conflict or US justification for intervention, which is different from the more glorious portrayals of the US military. It is an outlier at least in that regard. Films made in the US about Vietnam focused on the consequences and trauma – but in these seemingly critical and skeptical depictions of the conflict, the consequences and trauma were predominantly that of the US military. Their trauma. Their consequences. Not the trauma or consequences thrust on to the Vietnamese. These films, even satirical films, are still from the perspective of American recruits and draftees – not the Vietnamese. These films sometimes portray the effects of this moment in history negatively, but the vast majority of those portrayed as being negatively affected are Americans – the aggressors portrayed as the victims. Nevertheless, relitigation of Vietnam through popular culture is still more critical of the conflict than any other instance of US interventionism. One film series bucked that trend: Rambo, a film series that begins with trauma – albeit exclusively American trauma – and spirals out into a revenge fantasy.
The Rambo trilogy in the 1980's relitigates Vietnam and reframes the greatest failure. In truth, the greatest failure is that this intervention of choice did not need to happen, was built on a lie, and countless people needlessly perished. In Rambo, the greatest failure is only that the United States lost. This is codified in First Blood II: Rambo when the titular character asks the central question of the series and unambiguously positions its politics. [Do we get to win this time?] That is the Rambo series. Restorative “justice” but only for the aggressors of the conflict – the invading Americans. In First Blood, often regarded as the best of the series, John Rambo is harassed by local police, and due to his post-traumatic stress, reacts to their hostility with his own. He escapes, and the police begin to track him in a scenario not unlike Rambo's service in Vietnam. Critics sometimes look at First Blood through rose-colored glasses. This film is not as overtly jingoistic as later films, and Sylvester Stallone's performance, particularly his monologue at the end, paints the picture of a sympathetic veteran who was only doing what he was told. First Blood remains agnostic on the justification for US intervention in Vietnam. What these same critics fail to see is that First Blood does not throw stones at US interventionism. It throws stones at the peace movement.
AUDIO 2
Rambo's monologue at the end brings up a common myth about the peace movement in the US during that time. The myth that returning servicemen were spat upon. This has long been debunked by Jerry Lembcke's book Spitting Image: Myth, Memory and the Legacy of Vietnam. Lembcke, himself a Vietnam veteran, wrote: “If spitting on veterans had occurred all that frequently, surely some veteran or soldier would have called it to the attention of the press at the time. … Indeed, we would imagine that news reporters would have been camping in the lobby of the San Francisco airport, cameras in hand, just waiting for a chance to record the real thing—if, that is, they had any reason to believe that such incidents might occur.” Lembcke's research actually found the opposite: the peace movement was the natural ally to the suffering servicemen who had been drafted into a conflict that never needed to happen. The peace movement did not protest servicemen. They had friends who had been drafted. The peace movement, instead, protested the conflict itself and President Richard Nixon. The “spitting” was an urban legend that had never – not once – been confirmed by a servicemen to had happened directly to them. Only that it happened to “a friend of a friend” somewhere. It's an urban legend, and First Blood helped popularize it. This, combined with the demonizing portrayal of the North Vietnamese in Rambo's flashback, muddies the waters about what First Blood is trying to communicate and who it blames for Rambo's trauma.
Alex Hess of Little White Lies once wrote: “[Rambo's] climactic speech about returning veterans being spat on by 'maggot' hippy protesters at the airport hinted at a conservative heart. And with Ronald Reagan having just been voted into the White House by a landslide, it was the latter that most struck a chord with the American psyche.” The US never should have been involved in Vietnam in the first place. A brief history might be helpful. Vietnam had been colonized by the French since the 19th century. In 1940, Japan invaded Vietnam. To fight to Japanese, political leader Ho Chi Minh formed the Viet Minh, or the League for the Independence of Vietnam. Following Japanese surrender to the Allied Powers in 1945, French-educated Emperor Bao Dai was in charge of Vietnam. The Viet Minh didn't want an emperor, seized Hanoi and declared the Democratic Republic of Vietnam in the North. France backed Emperor Bao Dai because they wanted to one day take back control of Vietnam. They fought, the North won, and French rule and influence finally ended in Vietnam. The two sides signed a treaty in Geneva in 1954 splitting the nation but setting up elections to unify Vietnam in 1956.
AUDIO 3
However, anti-communist Ngo Dinh Diem of the south wasn't having any of that, and Ho Chi Minh remained president of North Vietnam. President Dwight Eisenhower committed the US toward backing South Vietnam, and the CIA meddled in foreign affairs to further the economic influence of the US because that's what the CIA does. Ngo Dinh Diem anti-communist security forces cracked down on alleged Northern sympathizers in the south, arresting roughly 100,000 people, many of whom were brutally interrogated and killed. The CIA helped this happen. By the 1960's, the US had begun helping South Vietnam even more, patrolling along the surrounding ocean. The US and North Vietnam had an incident in the Gulf of Tonkin that, depending on your perspective, was either instigated by the US being there where it didn't belong or due to the actions of the North Vietnamese. Then, after things had settled, the US lied about there being a second attack. This was long-suspected but only recently confirmed by the declassified information and a report by an NSA historian. New documents and tapes revealed there was no second attack on US Navy ships in the Gulf of Tonkin in early August 1964. In fact, the evidence confirms the deliberate attempt by Secretary of Defense McNamara to distort what happened. These falsified records mislead Congress and was the pretext and justification for US putting boots on the ground in Vietnam.
The US had economic interests in having all of Vietnam commit to capitalism. They feared losing influence and that a “domino effect” would occur unless they forced Vietnam to succumb to their economic system. And that's why and how the US intervened in Vietnam. First Blood II: Rambo traffics in a now-disproved conspiracy theory that following the end of US intervention in Vietnam, there were thousands of servicemen captured behind enemy lines and that for years – even decades after – they suffered as POW's. Prior to the Richard Nixon administration, the US armed forces used a different classification for soldiers who could not be accounted for: KIA/BNR. This classification reported the most near certainty that if a serviceman's body could not be found, said serviceman was either a casualty, or in extremely rare cases, only missing. President Nixon needed new propaganda to popularize an unpopular conflict. His administration spun the idea that since servicemen were missing, that meant they were almost certainly prisoners. During the conflict, servicemen were taken prisoner, of course, but by changing the classification to POW/MIA, with POW taking front billing, the implication for the public was obvious. This implication remained in the public consciousness even after US withdrawal and after all prisoners were released.
AUDIO 4
According to Nathan Smith of The Outline: “This transformed the war from a political issue into a humanitarian one, trading public support for sympathy. It didn’t matter why we were there in the first place: our boys were there, and by God, we were going to do anything to get our boys home.” The reality is that following said withdrawal, no US servicemen have ever been confirmed to still be prisoners. Conspiracy theorists claim that roughly 2,000 servicemen are unaccounted for in Vietnam and associated theaters throughout Indochina, but that is not confirmation they remain prisoners. It means they were casualties. In truth, the vast majority of servicemen missing in action during US military operations over the past century were were simply casualties whose bodies could not be recovered or identified. Here are some statistics cited from MIA, or Mythmaking in America by historian H. Bruce Franklin. In nearly all armed conflicts, servicemen are lost without being identified. More than 78,000 fighting the Axis Powers alone. That constitutes approximately 19% of casualties. In Korea, bodies that could not be recovered or identified is a similar 15% of casualties. When POW/MIA conspiracy theorists list the 2,255 unaccounted for servicemen, they claim that must mean that they are imprisoned somewhere in Indochina – somehow even out of reach of sophisticated satellites that can track everyone on the planet.
They see this as a smoking gun, but in reality, that is a considerably smaller 4% of casualties. In all conflicts, servicemen are missing because their bodies could not be recovered or identified. “Missing” does not equal “imprisoned” without evidence, and there simply has been none whatsoever. From the same book: “...years of espionage, interrogation, spy flights, satellite observation, and even raids on suspected sites have produced not one piece of tangible evidence of their existence. This last assertion might infuriate many believers, because they are certain of overwhelming evidence. Some could immediately cite a specific example of 'tangible evidence' – such as the secret Fort Apache photograph – the existence of which can be denied only because an elaborate government conspiracy has been concealing it from the American public. This elaborate government conspiracy, in turn, has become another crucial component of the myth, and arguments about its existence lead in ever widening spirals to broadest significance of the myth itself.” In First Blood Part II, John Rambo and his superior officers discuss the conspiracy theory at length, but when they speak of these mysterious prisoners, they do so matter-of-factly as if it were a foregone conclusion. By the time the film had been made, the conspiracy theory had already permeated throughout the nation due in no small part to the changing classification of POW/MIA and other attempts to change the public image of armed forces.
AUDIO 5
However, in a case of art imitating life and life, in turn, imitating art, this film and others like it helped maintain the conspiracy theory, keeping it alive throughout the 1980's. Not one missing serviceman was ever confirmed to have remained a POW following US withdrawal. After decades of investigation, even cheerleaders for the cause in the US government were eventually resigned to admit that Vietnam returned the POW's, after all. Outside of the occasional disproved hoax, such as with the documentary Unclaimed, the theory has little lifeblood among anyone who has done even a cursory examination of the topic. Yet, the flags still wave, and some of that is almost certainly due to the fictional exploits of John Rambo. In the film, Rambo is released by Colonel Trautman on the condition that he find evidence that POW's are still alive. Rambo is told not to try to rescue them himself, but nobody tells Rambo what to do, so he does it anyway. His superior officer, Murdock, doesn't actually want to pursue a real rescue for political reasons. This feeds into the part of the conspiracy theory that in addition to Vietnam hiding the truth about these secret POW's, the government somehow is too. Except when it's the entity that's pushing this theory in the first place, of course. Then...they are trying to recover the POW's. Except when they're not.
Conspiracy theories without tangible evidence require the theorist to switch theories when one becomes inconvenient but then come back to it when more convenient. First Blood: Part II is a beloved film among conservatives, rewriting Vietnam not as a conflict the maintain US hegemony but as a battle between goodies and baddies, and the baddies were the ones holding the goodies hostage. Rambo III picks up three years after the previous film left off. Rambo is now living in Thailand, and he apparently spent all his time getting swole. Colonel Trautman visits Rambo and gives him a new assignment: help the Mujahideen in Afghanistan fend off the Soviet Union. Much like First Blood: Part II, Rambo III takes some facts from real world politics and cleans them up to make the US look better. Jacob Knight once wrote of this: “First Blood: Part II becomes the quintessential representation of American foreign policy during the Reagan years... Perhaps this is why Rambo III full-on literalized Reagan's ideology, as he takes down a filmic Cold War representation of the Evil Empire.” In First Blood: Part II, the imprisonment is maintained with the help of the Soviet Union, and in Rambo III, the Soviet Union is front and center. Some background may be necessary.
AUDIO 6
In 1947, the Soviet Union began giving large amounts of aid, economic assistance and military hardware to Afghanistan. Russia had a long-standing relationship with Afghanistan dating back to 1919 following the Russian revolution. A military alliance began on a regular basis in 1956 and strengthened throughout the 70's. Also in the 70's, the US, concerned about their loss of influence in the region, began supplying rebels in Afghanistan opposed to Soviet influence. For this reason and others, tension rose. Eventually the Soviet Union took greater control of Afghanistan, effectively an invasion, and the US began even greater efforts toward supplying the rebels – the Mujahideen – with arms. Enter: Rambo III. The film presents US interventionism as the cure for communism. Years later, the US would be the invaders in Afghanistan, making this moment some unfortunate, unintentional foreshadowing. [“Maybe next time.”] Yikes. Rambo III once again tries to relitigate Vietnam while barely referencing it. If the film had any self-awareness, it would recognize that the Soviets invading Afghanistan and the mujahideen fighting back is akin to the US invading Vietnam and the communists fighting back. But Rambo III does not see it that way.
Instead, it frames the Soviets as the Northern Vietnamese, the mujahideen as the Southern Vietnamese and the US and the US – valiantly fighting for the south. Much like in First Blood: Part II, John Rambo allows the US to “win” Vietnam this time – just on different soil. By the end of the second movie, the “prisoners” are brought home, and by the end of the third movie, history is re-written, and the conflict in Vietnam is symbolically won in another country. Gaylyn Studlar and David Desser, in an article from Scraps from the Loft, once wrote: “The pain of history, its delimiting effect on action, is often seen as a political, a cultural, a national liability. Therefore, contemporary history has been the subject of an ideological battle which seeks to rewrite, to rehabilitate, controversial and ambiguous events through the use of symbols. One arena of on-going cultural concern in the United States is our involvement in Vietnam. It seems clear that reconstituting an image —a “memory”—of Vietnam under the impetus of Reaganism appears to fulfill a specific ideological mission. … The right wing films, especially Rambo, most clearly demonstrate the strategy of mythic substitution or displacement... Rambo demonstrates a cultural parallel, a luxuriating in the symptoms of a desperate ideological repression manifested in the inability to speak of or remember the painful past, a cultural hysteria in which violence must substitute for understanding, victimization for responsibility, the personal for the political.”
AUDIO 7
It should be noted that throughout the second and third movie, Rambo's post-traumatic stress disorder has seemingly vanished. Gone is the weary, broken man who fought for his country under false pretenses. Now, Rambo is a one-man slaughter machine. Army recruiters were reported to have put up Rambo posters to encourage young people to enlist. Rambo rewrote military history but also furthered the US military contemporaneously. President Ronald Reagan, in a comment just before he addressed the nation from the Oval Office, was caught on a hot microphone saying “Boy, after seeing ‘Rambo’ last night, I know what to do the next time this happens.” Reagan loved Rambo, referencing it again when promoting his tax plan. “In fact, when I think of all the good people who’ve pleaded with the federal government for years to clean up our tax structure, I am reminded of a recent, very popular movie - and in the spirit of Rambo, let me tell you we’re going to win this time.” We're going to win this time. That's what John Rambo says he wants at the beginning of First Blood: Part II. And that's the Rambo series. The victimization of the US military while taking no responsibility for its victimization of others. The idea that the tragedy of Vietnam was not that it happened but only that the United States lost. A misunderstanding of that moment in history and an attempt to obfuscate and rewrite history.