Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi, everyone. I hope you all had a safe summer. I'm working on a few large projects. The first, which is about global capitalism, will debut next month. The second, which is about the presidency and the concentration of power in the head of state, will debut in November. There will be regular-sized videos between them, but those are the big projects right now. I hope they will be worth the time and effort.

With that aside, here are some scripts from earlier this year.

THE EMPTY ARENA

 AUDIO 1
 Professional wrestling is a performance art in which two individuals work together to give the appearance of an athletic contest to a live audience. The contests contain variations, such as a tag team match in which two or more wrestlers compete against two or more other wrestlers, modified stipulations such as a reward for victory or a change in the rules, as well as a change in venue, such as a contest taking place somewhere besides the ring. Prior to the contest, sometimes the wrestlers will perform a narrative which gives the wrestlers motivation for why they are participating. If this “angle” occurs in a professional wrestling company that has weekly television, the narrative could take place over the course of several weeks or even several months. Wrestlers take classical theatrical roles as protagonist and antagonist – “babyface” and “heel” respectively – to provoke the appropriate cheers or boos from the audience. Example: Popular wrestling babyface “Stone Cold” Steve Austin is tragically struck by a vehicle, and the identity of the driver is unknown. Over the course of several weeks, World Wrestling Entertainment commissioner Mick Foley investigates the crime because nearly all matters taking place in professional wrestling narratives are handled internally. Otherwise, every surprise attack that takes place outside the confines of a wrestling match would be a matter for law enforcement. Commissioner Foley eventually reveals it was babyface wrestler Rikishi would struck Austin.   
 This effectively changed Rikishi's alignment from babyface to heel in front a live audience, leading to a showdown between the two. Due to the popularity of the angle, it is furthered by implicating heel wrestler Triple H as the mastermind behind the attempted vehicular homicide, prompting another match. Throughout the angle, due to the clear instances of right and wrong, the audience cheers for the babyface, Austin, and boos the heels, Rikishi and Triple H. They have a series of matches, all of which are designed to illicit specific reactions from the live audience during specific points or “spots” in the match. These narratives and these matches play out every week, and every week, a combination of the writers and the wrestlers prepare their narratives, matches, monologues (called “promos”), and other aspects of professional wrestling around attempting to persuade the live audience to react a certain way so that their actions are applauded and therefore universally understood by the audience watching from home. Who is babyface? “Stone Cold” Steve Austin. We know this because the narrative, promos, and matches are manipulated in such a way that the live audience cheers for him, immediately instructing the audience watching at home who is the good guy, even if that home audience has never seen Steve Austin before. Sometimes the live audience reaction does not go the way it was intended.
 AUDIO 2
 When Rikishi revealed his role in the attack, he gave the audience his motivation: he wanted to protect The Rock's place as a main event wrestler due to WWE's history of favoring white wrestlers. This was meant to be a heel turn, but some people in the audience agreed with Rikishi's statements, as the fictionalized motivation brushed up against reality. WWE course-corrected and had The Rock refute Rikishi's claims in later weekly episodes, which aligned future live audiences against Rikishi and put all the pieces where they were planned to be. Playing to the live audience and working the audience is everything in professional wrestling. Unlike traditional theater in which the separation between the drama and the audience is a thin, invisible wall, the separation between pro wrestling and the audience looks a lot different. The pro wrestling audience, instead, surrounds the ring. The audience works with the wrestlers to create the show. The audience also works with each other to enhance the show, such as leading chants of the wrestlers' names or catch-phrases. It's hard to imagine professional wrestling without the audience. What would that even look like? What would change? We got the answer to the question a few weeks ago, as social distancing suggestions and legal requirements prompted immediate changes to televised wrestling programs. New Japan Pro Wrestling shut down entirely. The American independent wrestling scene slowly faded out and waited for a return to normalcy.   
 Weekly professional wrestling in the United States, programs put on by top wrestling companies World Wrestling Entertainment and All-Elite Wrestling, experimented in shows with no audience. Empty arenas. This is not the first time a wrestling match has taken place with no live audience. For example, aforementioned wrestlers The Rock and Mick Foley, then going by the name Mankind, once battled in an empty arena match in 1999. Furthermore, some rare matches are more theatrical and highly-staged than others, such as Randy Orton vs. Bray Wyatt in the House of Horrors match in 2017 that was filmed like a movie and without a live audience. But a weekly show with all matches in front of empty chairs? This was unprecedented. There was too much money on the line, too many contractual obligations with their respective television partners. Pro wrestling follows the old theater adage: the show must go on. But even if it were safe to continue wrestling during this crisis, and it very well may not be, should it even continue, considering how much of wrestling is built around the live audience? [Removed Completely] Professional wrestling, both the angles that lead up to the matches and matches themselves have long been formatted to play to a live audience. The live audience can occasionally detract from the festivities, but far from often than that, the audience contributes to them.   
 AUDIO 3
 In fact, some things that wrestlers do are not only enhanced by the live audience but are dependent upon them. They simply could not happen and cannot work with the audience. One aspect of professional wrestling, particularly professional wrestling promos, is the “call and response” nature. When the aforementioned “Stone Cold” Steve Austin would conduct his promos and hype his upcoming match for the audience, he would ask them to participate. A typical Steve Austin promo would involve him asking the audience “If you [insert relevant actions here] – and then inserts something like “want to see me do this particular action” or “agree with what I'm saying” and the follows it with his call to action: “gimme a hell yeah.” to which the audience will invariably respond “hell yeah.” Another call and response, a far simpler one, in fact, is when Austin would say “What?” to the crowd, to which they would respond with the same word. In doing this, Austin connects himself with the live audience, cementing his status as babyface or fan favorite. The live audience sees themselves in Austin and this familiarity breeds popularity and acceptance. This call and response is not relegated to Austin, as it is common among most major wrestlers throughout history. [“If you're not down with that, we got two words for ya.”] A variation on the call and response is for the audience to recite the catch-phrase simultaneously with the wrestler instead of waiting for the pause to make their response.
 In both cases, the call and response and the sing-along variation, the live audience is absolutely necessary.  On the March 16th episode of Monday Night Raw, broadcast from WWE's empty performance center, they played up the fact that there was nobody there to respond to his call. [“Gimme a hell yeah.”] Without the live audience, wrestlers perform their promos under a different set of rules, but due to their complete unfamiliarity with these rules, wrestlers who have performed promos to empty arenas sometimes seem a little bit lost due to the lack of immediate feedback and the inability to feed off the reaction. As for the match themselves, certain key factors in matches do not exist without a live audience. Wrestlers and the live audience generally have a symbiotic relationship to helps the match. Some of this is invisible, but some of it is obvious. One example is that a wrestler will perform various actions designed with the intention of causing the crowd to react and make the match seem exciting, epic and important. One common way is for the babyface to rhythmically stomp on the canvas or clap their hands in hopes of provoking the audience to do the same.
 AUDIO 4
 As part of the narrative, this is the wrestler trying to garner support either for themselves or for the wrestler's tag team partner, currently in peril, and in need of a boost in morale. As part of this show, this is actually the wrestler trying to get the live audience excited either because the match isn't exciting enough on its own or as a signal to the audience that the match is about to have a shift in power, with the babyface turning the tide and suddenly gaining the upper hand. This connects the live audience with what's happening in the ring. It gives the audience the impression that they are participating rather than being passive onlookers. That way, should the babyface prevail, that is also their victory. In this match, on the March 13th episode of Smackdown, Nikki Cross instinctively stomps her boot on the canvas to provoke the audience and connect them with her partner, Alexa Bliss, currently being trapped by the other tag team. Cross undoubtedly learned to do this a long time ago, and it's a difficult thing to just remove from a wrestler's repertoire, even though it serves no real purpose in an empty arena. On the March 24th episode of AEW Dark, comedy wrestler Colt Cabana performed the classic babyface clap to an empty arena before realizing there was no reason to do this. He may have done this on purpose as a joke.
 One of the most famous ways a babyface wrestler can make their comeback is by “hulking up” named after Hulk Hogan, who would suddenly feed off the crowd support to gain superhuman strength. In doing this, the live audience could feel as if they were responsible for Hogan's many victories. In addition to these flourishes to garner live audience support, there are also specific wrestling moves that require audience participation or always illicit a particular audience reaction. For example, sometimes a babyface will corner a heel wrestler and climb the turnbuckle and throw a series of punches. The punches are counted by the crowd, usually to the count of ten. It's only a series of ineffectual punches, but because of the audience participation, it's a big favorite among crowds. Without the crowd, ten punches in a row form a fairly boring spot in the match. When a wrestler performs a chop to the chest of another wrestler, the audience instinctively says “woo” – a reference to “The Nature Boy” Ric Flair and his famous chops. Without an audience, nobody is wooing, the Flair chop is just any slap across the chest. One way that wrestlers establish the babyface-heel dynamic is by dueling in a flurry of repeated moves, most commonly punches.
 AUDIO 5
 The wrestlers strike one another, and when the babyface connects, the audience quickly cheers, and when the heel connects, the audience quickly boos. This is repeated until either the babyface gets the upper hand, resulting in an explosion of greater cheers, or the heel gains the upper hand, temporarily deflating the audience and making them want the babyface to make a comeback that much more. Occasionally, the audience will react to the babyface and heel in an unplanned way, such as cheering the heel or booing the babyface. In this match from 2015 between babyface John Cena and heel Kevin Owens, it is Cena who is booed and Owens who is cheered during their dueling punches. Listen: [clip] Recognizing this “wrong” reaction and hoping to maintain their alignments, they quickly stop their duel of punches, and Cena launches himself at Owens to move on. Without the live audience, this might have gone differently. The symbiotic relationship between professional wrestlers and the live audience is helpful to the wrestlers because it lets them know what's working, what's not working, how quickly or how slowly they should proceed. In fact, matches are formatted with reactions in mind, and without the live audiences, the format is exposed in ways that that can be detrimental to the action. Let's use a different and more accessible medium to better explain for people who have never watched professional wrestling.
 A traditional situation comedy will use a laugh track in the space immediately after a joke, and a modern situation comedy will not. However, the existence or non-existence is related to the format in which the jokes are written for the respective shows. A sitcom with a laugh track and therefore artificial breaks in the narrative generally only allow for jokes to be structured with a lead-in, punch line and then the canned laughter. The laugh track makes it impossible for jokes to have rapid succession or an immediate comeback by another character. Singular jokes, which require long leads-in. A sitcom without a laugh track allows more freedom to tell jokes in rapid succession or have immediate comebacks by other characters, but they also require more jokes to be written due, as there is no canned laughter filling up any dead space following a joke. In short, a sitcom having or not having a laugh track cannot be the same show except with or without canned laughter. The very format must be different because the timing, spacing of jokes and the requirement of lead-ins to the joke are different. A sitcom without a laugh track is not just a traditional sitcom with the canned laughter mysteriously missing. It's designed from the ground up to be formatted and structured differently.
 AUDIO 6
 Wrestlers in an empty arena performing the match exactly as they would with a packed arena is like a traditional laugh track sitcom with the laugh track removed instead of a sitcom designed from the ground up without a laugh track. Note the difference. Without a live audience, the very format of wrestling must change, and much like a sitcom without a laugh track, it must move at a faster pace. Imagine watching a wrestler perform this basic move. Listen to the crowd. Although nothing exciting is happening, the heel holding on to the babyface, wearing him down, is enough to get the crowd pumped up. They are cheering this man who is, in the story of the match, desperately trying to make a comeback, and in reality, is resting. This is a rest hold. Wrestlers can't sprint for 20 to 30 minutes. Professional wrestling is exhausting. Professional football player Lawrence Taylor made a Wrestlemania appearance years ago, and though the match only lasted eleven minutes, he went on to say that it was more exhausting than anything he did in his football career. Wrestling is exhausting, and the ring is not a trampoline. It's made of wood and metal, and wrestlers land back, neck or sometimes head first on it many times throughout the course of one match.
 Wrestlers need to rest or else the match will suffer. So, the heel slaps on a chinlock or something. It generally needs to be the heel. The audience is willing to watch a chinlock or headlock for a while if they think their chants and cheers and cries will help provoke the babyface to make his comeback and escape the hold. If the babyface slaps on a rest hold, they the dynamics change. The audience is not conditioned to cheer for the heel to make his comeback, and since all the babyface is doing is applying a hold while not moving, there is nothing to excite the audience. If anything, he's upsetting the audience hoping for more action. So. A rest hold in front of a live audience, applied correctly and at the right time, can excite the live audience, which in turn excites the television audience. It's infectious. All that needs to happen is a smattering of people in the live audience chanting or cheering for it to spread across the arena. But without a live audience, there can be no transmission of this excitement. They are relying on each individual watching on their televisions to be excited by the least exciting part of the match. A chinlock or headlock now looks like what it really is: a rest hold. Even matches with few or no rest holds still have spots in which they're resting nonetheless. Such as immediately following a failed pinning attempt or after one wrestler is knocked down. But while the fallen wrestler rests, the standing wrestler has been conditioned to use this time to rile up the crowd.
 AUDIO 7
 If there is no crowd to rile up, the wrestler still standing will have to do something else to pass the time while the fallen wrestler catches his breath. Perhaps argue with the referee, but that's something usually reserved for heels. Without a live audience, a lot of what wrestlers do is exposed. Wrestlers communicate with one another during the match to prepare for moves, to remind them of what is meant to come next, and to warn them about any potential danger. Over the roar of the crowd, this is usually drowned out, except for loud and consistent talkers like John Cena. Without the live audience is drown out the communication, wrestlers can either opt not to do this anymore, resulting in potential problems, or just do it anyway and hope that the television audience does not mind seeing the curtain pulled back. Without the live audience, everything becomes awkward. Empty. Listen to bits and pieces from this empty arena match. The only way to push their matches into territory where they can never feel awkward is if they are constantly attacking, never resting, never slowly building the match to a crescendo. Wrestling cannot work the same way in an empty arena.   
 This is Hulk Hogan vs. The Rock from Wrestlemania 18, often stylized as Wrestlemania X8. In the angle leading up the match, The Rock was firmly positioned as the babyface, and Hulk Hogan was firmly positioned as the heel. He returned to WWE after a long stint in WCW as a main event heel and one of the leader of the massive heel faction, the nWo. And The Rock was...The Rock. The most electrifying man in sports entertainment and one of the most universally beloved babyfaces in the world. Yet, when it was time for this epic, first-time encounter between the two titans, this dream match once thought impossible, the crowd was so excited that they eschewed their role as designated cheer section for the babyface and began cheering both men. The Rock even received a fair amount of boos. The ovation and the electricity in the air even before the match began gave us this iconic moment in which Hogan and The Rock, realizing what was happening in the crowd and what was about to happen between them, turned from side to side to listen to the live audience and to savor the moment. It was unexpected, and it was amazing.   
 AUDIO 8
 That can't happen...here. Wrestlemania 36 is scheduled to take place soon, and due to what's happening in the world, it can only be done in an empty arena. Vince McMahon, against the wishes of many people within the company, decided to go ahead with it instead of postponing the event. Several major stars in the company like Roman Reigns have opted not to participate due to health concerns. WWE and AEW have both tried to roll with the punches due to the obligations. AEW, knowing that matches are not the same without an audience, elected to have a lot of their wrestlers act as audience members during one episode of their weekly show. In the following episode, they opted not to do this, perhaps out of concern that the number of people at ringside began to skirt up against violating the social distancing recommendations.   
 AEW also tried to make lemonade out of their lemons by performing special effects in the empty seats that they otherwise could not do if there had been a live audience. Nevertheless, their weekly show has suffered. WWE's weekly shows have suffered even more because WWE is simply not as likely to try new things as AEW is. Vince McMahon is set in his ways whereas Cody Rhodes and the Young Bucks are more open to try new things. In spite of this, all of them – meaning WWE management and AEW management – are going to need to make a decision about the health and safety of their performers soon. Empty arena matches are better than no matches...until you take the health risks into account. Nobody needs to tell me there is money on the line, I know, but this can't continue. And to be honest, holding on to their weekly shows to produce empty arena matches is only maintaining something that does not really work anyway.   


COMEDY AGES POORLY

 AUDIO 1
 In the 1994 comedy film Ace Ventura: Pet Detective, the titular character discovers that Lieutenant Lois Einhorne had gender confirmation surgery and that she was previously known as Ray Finkle, a disgraced Miami Dolphins kicker. As Ventura previously had some brief romantic contact with Einhorne, he becomes disgusted with himself that he kissed a trans woman. At the climax of the film, Ventura exposes Einhorne – both her role in the missing Dolphins mascot and her personal history – by stripping away her clothes and pointing out that she had not yet had bottom surgery. This information alone is enough to both disgust and terrify all the hardened police officers. The film does not nail down the terminology well, and though Einhorne is referred to as a man and not a trans woman, the scene is nonetheless transphobic. Such transphobia still exists in popular media today, although most blockbuster films in 2020 would probably not be as overt or center so much of the comedy of the film around mocking a trans woman, partially due to changing values and partially due to fear of backlash. When critics and audiences say that comedy ages poorly, scenes as these immediately come to mind. The idea being that comedy ages poorly due to the progression of society. However, this is only one way in which comedy movies age so rapidly. It's simply the most obvious.
 The concept of comedy aging poorly is not new, as it is well-understood among comedians and comedy writers that it does, in fact, consistently happen but not always well-understood why. Who better than I to answer this question – someone who has never been funny, not even once, by accident. But what I lack in humor, I make up for in the twin abilities of reliably charting data and coming to reasonable conclusions, my two sexiest qualities. Join me (won't you?) as I ruin everything because I had nothing better to do this week. I will limit these observations to movies only as far back as the early 80's, within my own lifetime or “Quantum Leap rules.” In the 1994 comedy movie Dumb and Dumber, Harry and Lloyd are accidentally responsible for the death of their criminal companion. They feed him peppers, not realizing that he has a condition that would make this fatal. Upon his death, Lloyd looks up at the diner and says “Check, please.” This is an example of an overused line in a comedy movie: jokes, quips and sight gags that were contemporaneously fresh but have since been used and reused too many times since and date the jokes retroactively. This may have garnered laughs in 1994, but now that “check, please” has been used so many times in other films since the release of this Dumb and Dumber, revisiting this film can't illicit the same response.   
 AUDIO 2
 In fact, one could argue that by the time Dumb and Dumber made this joke, it was already overused. It was done in So I Married an Axe Murderer a year prior in 1993, Robin Hood: Men in Tights in the same year, and many times before this, including twice in the 1987 film Spaceballs. There are a number of other instances of this one joke, and worst of all, there is little variation to it. The same joke, told differently or told with some kind of twist can mix it up, but “check please” happens with such regularity and such consistently that it is amazing that it lasted as long as it did. In 2020, audiences will rarely hear “check please” as a comedy line because comedians and writers have wisely moved on. This is not simply a matter of “cringe” or consensus that this is now a hack line. Laughing is involuntary, and as a formula, it relies on surprise. An overused joke can no longer surprise any us. The same joke told to someone who has never heard it will illicit a laugh. Here's a joke. A stranger sees an eunuch walking down the road alongside a woman. The stranger asks the eunuch “Is she your wife?” and the eunuch tells the stranger that eunuchs don't have wives. So, the stranger says “Oh, so she's daughter!” If you have never heard this joke before, you may have laughed or at least smiled, but this joke is literally ancient. It's from “Love of Laughter” -- the oldest surviving collection of jokes, dating back to roughly the 4th century.
 The actual age of the joke is not relevant to whether or not it's funny. Instead, it's more like...how many miles the joke has on it for you personally that determines its wear and tear. Whether or not it has been overused in a culture and whether or not the surprise is gone. “Check please” – the joke itself – was never “bad.” It's only been used and reused so many times that it has gained a kind of cultural normalcy – a neutrality – something that is not surprising and therefore not funny anymore. The joke, on its own and in a vacuum separated from this overuse, is funny and follows a basic theory about humor, that being humor often involves the realization of incongruity –  a mismatch – between a concept and a situation. “Check please” works as a joke because of the incongruity of concept and situation. The concept is that saying “check, please” in a restaurant is a neutral ending to the dinner and is precipitated only by the meal being complete and with no other contributing factors. The situation is that there is a contributing factor this time, usually a ludicrous one such as in the case of the restaurant scene in Dumb and Dumber. The neutrality of the statement combined with the ludicrousness of what happened immediately prior is the realization of incongruity and why it's funny. It's why people laugh, even if they are not charting why, over-examining it and further ruining it, like I am, right now.    
  AUDIO 3  
 Humor as surprise is both the reason why the joke initially worked, the surprise of the incongruity, and the reason the joke no longer works in a culture that has heard it before – the lack of surprise due to overuse. The same can be said of “That's gotta hurt” and other myriad of other overused comedy lines. “Check please” is two words of dialogue and can therefore age quickly, but sometimes entire concepts and situations are repeated enough to age quickly. An example of a comedy concept and situation combination that aged quickly throughout 90's comedies is the novelty of hip hop being performed by someone who is not expected to be a hip hop artist or enthusiast. Concept: hip hop music. Situation: not someone who resembles Tupac Shakur. Hip hop music in the 90's was still a fresh phenomenon and was only recently entering the consciousness of white suburbia and therefore white suburban theaters. Robin Hood: Men in Tights featured a hip hop group that breaks from their incredibly basic rhymes to sing something more at home at a renaissance festival. The Wedding Singer from 1998 had an elderly white woman performing Rapper's Delight. Both Austin Powers: The Spy Who Shagged Me and Austin Powers: Goldmember featured Dr. Evil performing hip hop. Not only is this concept and situation combination overused by today's standards, it could be argued that it was old by Goldmember, released in 2002.  
 The novelty of hip hop had worn off, and the music genre had simply become mainstream years prior. The entirety of this recurring joke is that the audience was not expecting the character to be interested in the genre of music. No other genre was used to this effect so frequently in 90's comedies. Speaking of Austin Powers, the trilogy of films is painful to watch in 2020, but part of the reason why is not actually its own fault. It suffers from an inverse of the overuse problem. Instead of utilizing overused jokes within the movie, Austin Powers is uncomfortable to watch due to the overuse of jokes specific to Austin Powers outside of the movie – either through mocking parody or sincere appreciation. Most notable, this comes in the form of Powers' many catch-phrases. [Yeah, baby.] Powers' catch-phrases briefly became part of the language for a few years during the craze, much in the way that “d'oh” from The Simpsons is now said even without thinking of that particular reference or the origins of the word. “D'oh” can be used casually. Unlike d'oh, the Austin Powers catch-phrases were too specific to the trilogy to have the same lasting power and cannot be said as casually. By the time the third movie premiered, the jokes and catch-phrases being repeated outside the movie became stale, resulting in the final movie not having the same impact. As a culture, we overused the catch-phrases rather than too many movies overusing them. There were only three, after all.  
  AUDIO 4  
 Similarly, this happened to Borat, a very successful comedy from 2006 that has retroactively been ruined due to both parody and sincere admiration. The only comedy gained from saying a Borat catch-phrase so many years after its debut is comedy about how unfunny and stale the catch-phrases have become. It's not the fault of the film that it was so popular and so quotable. Nevertheless, Borat is now hard to watch for reasons that exist primarily outside the film. Reference humor operates under the same formula as most other comedy, the incongruity here being a reference to something familiar in an unfamiliar context, such as James van Der Beek climbing into the window of the wrong set while the theme from Dawson's Creek plays. One problem with reference humor is when the incongruity is paper thin, such as characters from Scary Movie simply repeating the “wassup” Budweiser commercial verbatim. There is almost no incongruity if the parody is nigh indistinguishable from the original. Another problem with reference is how poorly it ages. A commercial, for example, is usually not something revisited for future generations the way classic movies always stay in the popular consciousness or how television shows get rebooted for new audiences. Scary Movie is intended for young adult audiences in the year 2000, but young adults in the year 2020 will either not understand the reference, or if they do, will probably cringe about a gag that their parents already found stale.  
  So, are all comedy movies doomed to age poorly? Not necessarily. There are ways to future-proof a comedy, at least to some extent. Trends in comedy change, and those are impossible to predict, but there are some steps that can be taken. For one, referencing whatever is popular in the same year as the release of the comedy should be avoided. For another, if a joke in Movie B been used before in Movie A, using it in Movie B will help propagate it to some unrelated Movie C, causing Movie B to age poorly and not even hold the distinction of being the first. And finally, in terms of humor that mocks a marginalized group that was socially unprotected during the time of the comedy's release, maybe just don't mock a marginalized group even if society has not yet caught up. Historically, this realignment in values and eventual protection of the marginalized group is inevitable. People sometimes say “You know, the only minority we can mock these days is [blank].” and then they proceed to do that, not realizing that this is temporary. Maybe try being ahead of the curve instead of desperately trying to mock marginalized people while you can still “get away” with it, just a thought. All movie genres age due to advancements in special effects, changing styles of acting and such, but for all the reasons mentioned here, comedy may have the most hurdles. But it can be better, it can work. It just requires a little added care.     

DISCO ELYSIUM

 AUDIO 1
 “What kind of cop are you?” This is the tagline to the 2019 computer roleplaying game Disco Elysium. From the outset, the player controls a police detective awakening from a days-long bender. Because of his hard-living or some other unseen force, the detective has amnesia – everything from his personal identity to his knowledge of the world has been erased save for some rudimentary knowledge like how to walk, talk and be horrified at the unceasing nightmare of existence, you know, normal stuff. The detective, revealed to be named Harry, is in town because he has been tasked with solving a murder. He is only aware of this because his assigned partner from another police district, Kim Kitsuragi, tells him so and acts as a sounding board and encyclopedia throughout the gameplay. Because of Harry's tabula rasa status, he can be instilled with any number of personality traits, beliefs and political ideologies. The game keeps track of these decisions, these new thoughts and ideas. Harry is a mess, total garbage, at least once referring to himself as a “Hobocop.” I felt sorry for Harry, and in my first run through the game, I tried to have him make good choices so that he could both solve the murder and become a better man. Because of this, by the end of the game, the mystery was solved, he had impressed Kim, and he was a full-blown communist.   
 All very good things. My initial run of Disco Elysium, hereafter called the communist run, transformed Harry from a blank slate to someone who questioned the very authority bestowed upon him, concluding that hierarchical systems are oppressive and that power does not justify itself. Though the game had no such designation, Harry resembled a left-anarchist by the end. He consistently called into question the authority of the police, sometimes thoughtfully and sometimes through slogans like “**** the police!” What kind of “cop” I am, is one that is skeptical of the overall goodness of the police, particularly as agents of capitalism and the supremacy of the majority. Police have far too much authority over our lives, and the motives of those who control the laws and consequently law enforcement are suspect. I put the game down once it reached its rather abrupt ending...and a few weeks later, I came back to it. Disco Elysium is an excellent game – one of a kind – and the diversity of options and choices makes for a new game during every playthrough. “What if,” I thought “I gave Harry the opposite of my politics and values this time?” What if my cop behaved...like a cop? What if Harry embodied all the trappings of modern law enforcement? I did that. And by the end, he was a fascist and an enthusiastic bootlicker of capitalists. This is how it happened...and why all hobocops are *.
 AUDIO 2
 [I. The Basics] In the beginning of my fascist run, Harry woke up on the floor, drunk, tired and without a memory. Of course, that's the way the game always starts. My choices began to affect him later. In Disco Elysium, the outcomes of all choices are determine by dice rolls. I failed two extremely difficult checks, dressed Harry and had him leave his hotel room. Harry met Klassje, a woman staying at the hotel, although they had met before in the fog of his pre-amnesia life. She addressed him as “officer.” In my communist run, upon learning this, I made Harry incredulous learning this, but trying to make Harry behave more like every encounter with the police I've had, I made Harry say “I'm a policeman! And don't you forget it!” As we'll see throughout both the game and this video, police officers have institutional support that allow them to conduct themselves aggressively or however they want so long as it's within the line of duty. Since Harry is here on assignment, as we'll soon learn, almost nothing he says or does will result in failing the game. When I say that Harry has “institution support,” it means that his actions are broadly endorsed by both society and those who have the greatest power within society. When a police officer does something “wrong,” much of the public will leap to their defense, shouting down any opposition with platitudes and dog whistles like “law and order” more than fleshed-out, reasonable arguments.
 The people believe in the overall goodness of the police due to propaganda and rhetoric by those with the power to spread said propaganda and rhetoric. This makes public outcry about police wrongdoing tempered by a society that sees police going over the line as an inevitability of the occupation and a means justified by its ends. Those with power in society, the wealthy and the politicians, endorse the police because they protect private property and the state respectively – their two interests. Everything I had Harry say to Klassje was pointed and aggressive. I made an extremely difficult skill check and tried to have Harry coerce Klassje into an intimate act. There were no consequences for this inappropriate action in the game and few consequences in the real world. For example, the New York City Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB) — the independent New York City agency that investigates civilian complaints of misconduct by NYPD officers — for decades automatically referred police sexual misconduct complaints to the NYPD for internal examination. In other words, police misconduct is investigated by the entity that allegedly performed the misconduct. All misconduct by the police, so long as the misconduct happens in the line of duty, is handled internally, and with the aforementioned public trust of police due to propaganda and rhetoric by those in power, there is rarely any real pressure for misconduct to lead to firing and charges pressed against the police officer.  
  AUDIO 3  
  Anyone who has ever interacted with a police officer understands this lopsided power dynamic. When police officers engage in sexual misconduct, they are taking advantage of this imbalance, whether they know it or not. A police officer even asking for a victim's phone number has significantly more power in the interaction, as the victim saying no could negatively affect her case. Harry's attempt to sleep with Klassje here utilizes this imbalance of power dynamics. Harry has been on duty ever since arriving in Martinaise. He is there to investigate a murder. That means all his flirtations and exploits since arriving have been under the authority of a police officer and not simply a man who likes to party and listen to disco. Not all police misconduct is sexual, but all police misconduct operates under an imbalance of power. Internal investigations into misconduct may be done by a different department than the one that employs the offending officer, as different cities and countries perform internal affairs differently. However, police everywhere either belong to a fraternal order or are instilled with enough camaraderie that the wheels of justice move very slowly, if at all, for victims of police misconduct – sexual or otherwise. After Klassje made her escape, I had Harry bang on the door over and over again, punching it, being aggressive and vulgar.  
  There are no legal consequences for Harry if he does this. To sum up, police are granted enormous authority by those in power, and their authority can very easily be abused with far fewer consequences than those of civilians. It's a kind of cycle of power. Those with wealth and influence make the people believe the police are on their side, which protects the police, who in turn abuse their power in service of protecting those with wealth and influence. More on all these topics later and in far greater detail. For now, back to the game. I decided to make Harry a smoker because I wanted him to make nothing but bad decisions. Afterward, I had him walk downstairs to begin his day. Harry flexed his newfound authority with Garte, the cafeteria manager, and found his assigned partner, Kim Kitsuragi. Kim told Harry that they work in different precincts but they are to work together on the case. So, where does all this authority come from? When and where did this cycle of power begin? How did it spread? And how does it function to control people, most notably, the poor? Not in the fictional world of Disco Elysium but...the real world.       AUDIO 1
 [II. The Origins of Modern Policing] Some form of law enforcement has existed for roughly as long as communal society has existed. Their duties, level of power, centralization, dynamics, and what systems they serve vary over time. The word “constable,” for example, is derived from comes stabuli, meaning “head of the stables” or “count of the stables” and has existed since the 9th century. Law enforcement varied from place to place across the globe. Rural law enforcement in England was conducted by “shire reeves” who were both tax collectors and soldiers. There is where the word “sheriff” is derived. However, a centralized police force is a fairly recent invention. Policing in the United States had its origins in policing from England. The “watch” system in the American colonies was composed of volunteers whose duties were mainly that of warning the town to impending danger. Boston, for example, created a night watch in 1636. New York followed decades later in 1658, and Philadelphia in 1700. The night watch was kind of a law enforcement agency, but it was primarily used by people trying to evade military service or as punishment. In addition, there were constables, but law enforcement was only one of their duties. They were also surveyed land and verified the accuracy of weights and measures.   
 They weren't so much “cops” as they were officials with a lot of barely-related jobs to do. It wasn't until the 1830's that a centralized police force was created in northern cities in the United States. As explained by Dr. Gary Potter of Eastern Kentucky University: “These 'modern police' organizations shared similar characteristics: (1) they were publicly supported and bureaucratic in form; (2) police officers were full-time employees, not community volunteers or case-by-case fee retainers; (3) departments had permanent and fixed rules and procedures, and employment as a police officers was continuous; (4) police departments were accountable to a central governmental authority.” In the southern United States, the origins of the police were different. In 1704, the first “slave patrols” were formed. Again, from Dr. Potter: “Slave patrols had three primary functions: (1) to chase down, apprehend, and return to their owners, runaway slaves; (2) to provide a form of organized terror to deter slave revolts; and, (3) to maintain a form of discipline for slave-workers who were subject to summary justice, outside of the law, if they violated any plantation rules.”  
  AUDIO 2  
 Not all modern policing has its origins in slave patrols, but some of it definitely does. Modern policing in other countries had different origins but followed similar paths. Centralized, modern policing had its origins in Europe but was adopted across the world. Without going over every single nation's evolution into a modern, centralized power force, suffice it to say, in the 19th century, the world moved law enforcement in this direction. So, about the world in the 19th century necessitated the development of centralized police forces? Cities were growing, sure, and there are anecdotal accounts of increasing “vice” in urban environments, but evidence of an actual crime wave is severely lacking.  
 If policing exists to correct “disorder” then we have to understand who is defining these terms. In the cities of 19th century United States, for example, “disorder” was defined by capitalists. Capitalists needed a method in which to ensure the control of their work force – laborers. In short, modern policing began as a means of opposing emerging unions and workers' rights, protecting property, controlling people as property, and protecting the state from unrest by the people. In other words, the police exist to control the poor. The police exist because of capitalism. In Disco Elysium, Kim Kitsuragi exists as the straight-laced police officer who believes in his cause. The topic of the police as a force to control the poor and protect property comes up when Harry asks him what the police even are, but Kim rejects this as “cynical” because that is his function and role in the game. During my communist run, Harry rejected Kim's naivete masked as altruism and frequently questioned his own role as police officer.    
  AUDIO 3  
  In my fascist run, Harry rejected Kim's altruism only because he wanted to go in the opposite direction. He wanted to control the poor. He worked for the wealthy elite all while shouting “I am the law!” In spite of Kim's protestations that the police do not exist for such purpose, he never actually tries to prevent Harry from doing any of this, seeing it as in service of his police work. By acknowledging it as police work, Kim is tacitly admitting that serving the interests of the wealthy and controlling the poor is, in fact, police work. It's not a coincidence that modern policing rose in power parallel to the rise of capitalism. From the 12th to 15th century, European medieval feudal society was based on a series of regionally based, largely self-supporting economic systems. This was called feudalism: a political and economic system where a landowner granted land to a vassal in exchange for homage and military service. Each self-supported region was a kind of mini-economy where peasants were forced to work the land for a feudal lord in exchange for the right to build shelter on, and work a small strip of land. Although they were allowed to cultivate this strip of land, they had to give up a portion of their produce to the lord. If they could afford to keep animals on it, they had to hand over some of the gains from that as well.    
 The feudal system began to break down in the beginning of the 16th century. Increased foreign trade led to the emergence of a new class of merchant capitalist. These new merchants managed to hoard wealth by purchasing foreign goods cheaply and selling them for huge profits to the European aristocracy. This led to many European countries growing rich from taxes and establishing colonies. Once a country established a colony, it imposed a trading monopoly, often by force, by banning foreign merchants and ships. The Solidarity Federation explained it thusly: “For example, the riches of Spanish colonies in the Americas could only be exported to Spain, where they were traded on to other European countries at a tremendous mark up, enriching both Spanish merchants and the Spanish state. The race for new colonies inevitably led to conflict. England, being a relative latecomer to the international trade race, found that many of the prime sources of wealth had already been snapped up, so it embarked on nearly three centuries of war to establish its own colonial empire.
 AUDIO 4
 In simplest terms, capitalism is the private ownership of the means of production. The means of production are both the facilities and resources for producing goods. For example, the factory and the resources in the factory that makes whatever it is the factory makes. Capitalism operates through “wage labor” – a worker sells their labor for a wage that is far less than what the owner – or capitalist – earns from that labor. A worker under capitalism makes dozens of loaves of bread to be able to afford only only one loaf of bread. This is why opponents of capitalism often call wage labor “wage slavery” or remark that the relationship between worker and capitalist under capitalism is not too dissimilar from the relationship between serf and lord under feudalism. Under capitalism, as the wealthy elite grow richer and richer, but the workers do not. Instead, the wealthy elite – or simply “capitalists” – hire more workers at roughly the same wages, put some of the capitalists' earnings back into production, grow richer still, and repeat the process. By doing this, the capitalists continue to accumulate wealth while the workers – the poor and middle class – do not accumulate wealth. This is called “exploitation” – but under capitalism, this is not only tolerated but encouraged. The domination of capital over labor are not the result of any violation of property rights. Exploitation is not the result of cheating capitalism but the result at adhering to capitalism. Exploitation is baked into the economic system.  
 It is the logic of capitalism itself. Capitalism does not lift many people out of poverty. In fact, capitalism relies on poverty to exist. In order for rich capitalists to rich, they require a much greater number of poor people to perform wage labor for their industry. Poverty is not a bug in the system, it's a feature. It's an unavoidable component of capitalism. Private property and personal property are different. Personal property is your television set, your trash can, your shampoo, all things a single personal would reasonably use on their own. When I open up Harry's inventory in Disco Elysium, his items are his personal property. Private ownership, however, is ownership of something that a single person could not realistically use on their own and something the entire community needs and depends on. Joyce works for The Wild Pines Group, a huge corporation controlling 22 cargo terminals and employing 72,000 wage laborers. Martinaise depends on The Wild Pines Corporation, but under capitalism, it is privately owned, not collectively or publicly owned, and people are forced to perform wage labor for Wild Pines to live. This is not some invention of an alternate timeline sci-fi computer game. That is how capitalism works. Personal property is a given under any economic system. When the world became industrialized, capitalists required even more laborers, and eventually laborers wisely began to organize, and capitalists tried to organize society around greater control of laborers and greater protection of their private property. A centralized police ensured the control of the work force. Private property is something enforced through capitalism, specifically its armed enforcers: the police.   
 AUDIO 1
 [1 - 36:36] After another brief conversation with Garte, I had Harry go outside and begin the investigation. As this was my second playthrough, I knew more about what to do this time and immediately found the body, a hanged man tied to a tree. [IV. Police Brutality and the Monopoly of Violence] In my communist run, Harry's starting stats were more geared toward empathy, but in this run, Harry had enough endurance to make a still unlikely check to approach the body without throwing up. The yard with the body was also home to Cuno and his adoptive sister of sorts, Cunoesse. [1 – 52:50] Cuno is a foul-mouthed child with a love of amphetamines and meaningless conflict. He's twelve years old. [1 – 56:55] During my communist run, after a couple days, I managed to make an Empathy check, allowing for Harry and Cuno to get along better. Cuno has had a hard life. His impoverished father turned to alcoholism and such to dull the pain of living in poverty under capitalism, and Cuno himself took after his father. That was the communist run, though. [1 – 54:55] Playing as a more natural enforcer of capitalism in which the poor are to be controlled, Harry punched Cuno for getting out of line. [1:08:00] As for Cunoesse, a ten year old girl, for the crime of interfering with police business and getting under Harry's skin... [clip] Harry can perform a lot of underhanded and illegal actions throughout the game, and the game can continue.   
 Successfully making the legendary roll and taking out Cunoesse is one of the only actions that immediately stops the game, simply because it might be difficult to sympathize with Harry after that or even with Kim for allowing the investigation to continue undeterred after watching his partner take the life an unarmed child. A state is an entity that lays claim to a monopoly on the legitimate use of violence within a given territory. On a day to day basis, the police are given access to that violence. If violence is a commodity, then the police hold a monopoly on that resource and do not allow it to be shared. The police are permitted to use violence against the people whereas the people are not permitted to use violence against the police to protect themselves – and if this power dynamic is violated, then the people are met with greater violence by the police. Because of this monopoly, the police are given an incredible amount of leeway to use violence to meet their goals or even use violence in a manner that does not meet their goals so long as that violence is employed while on duty, presumably protecting the community. Due to this understood monopoly of violence, propaganda that portrays the police as ultimate good, and outright fear of the police, the population generally does not confront the police – with violence or even passive resistance – despite the fact that the people outnumber the police.   
 AUDIO 2
 Apologists for the police will note that while the police shooting unarmed or surrendering people is tragic, it does not justify militant protests of the police, temporary takeovers of the streets by activists, or riots that happened in response to these shootings. However, this ignores the power dynamics at play. If the police have all the power, the monopoly of violence, what other option do the people have? A peaceful, quiet, candlelight vigil that draws no attention and functions more as a community funeral than an accusation against the police? In Disco Elysium, Harry and Kim encounter anti-police graffiti and lone resistance to the police. [3 – 26:00] Cindy the Skull passively resists the police, but nothing she does hinders the investigation. Harry and Kim have so much power that any mild resistance to the police bounces off them impotently. Only more active resistance to their efforts prove effective. The people of Baltimore protest and even riot over a long history of police brutality that finally went too far, and the talking heads sit in their comfortable studios and lament the loss of what they really care about: property. Won't somebody think of the property damage? Whatever happened to...civility? [close up on Tucker Carlson] Demands for civility function primarily to stifle the protests and grievances of those currently facing real harm, in this case, the most common victims of police brutality: poor people and racial minorities.   
 Calls for “civility” are a smokescreen to allow those in power to continue this brutality. Such “civility” – a neutrality of both speech and action – is more useful to those currently enjoying the fruits of the status quo than it is useful to those hoping to affect change or bring attention to their oppression. And those calling for “civility” know this. It is a tactic to suppress protest and to falsely claim that “both sides” share equal blame for an unequal relationship. Apologists will move the goal posts after hearing this and counter with cold pragmatism. Does active resistance do any good in bringing attention to police brutality? Does it result in arrests and convictions of police officers? To answer that, we can look at the case of Oscar Grant. In 2009, police boarded a Bay Area Rapid Transit train to respond to a call about a fight. They detained several young men, most of them African-American. Among these young men was Oscar Grant. Once Grant was lying face down and handcuffed, a police officer named Johannes Mehserle fatally shot Grant in the back. The murder was recorded on video from multiple angles, as several witnesses filmed it with their phone cameras. They did their cameras from the police and posted the recordings on the Internet. Shortly thereafter, demonstrations were organized, which then escalated into riots. Police responded with tear gas and more than a hundred arrests.
 AUDIO 3
 A full year later, Mehserle was tried and convicted – not of murder but of “involuntary manslaughter.” He was found not guilty of murder and voluntary manslaughter. The police can never be labeled murderers. The general consensus at the time was that the only reason Mehserle was even arrested was because the people rioted. The riot and the threat of future riots convinced the state to charge Mehserle. The riots caused significant property damage and added expenses to the city for weeks of added police protection. To the state, Mehserle's greatest crime was not shooting an unarmed black man. It was costing the city money. The police exist to protect property, and only if a police officer threatens property can that officer be truly in error. Kristian Williams, author of Our Enemies in Blue: Power and Police in America, once wrote: “The battles that ensue do not only concern particular injustices, but also represent deep disputes about the rights of the public and the limits of state power. On the one side, the police and the government try desperately to maintain control, to preserve their authority. And on the other, oppressed people struggle to assert their humanity.   
 Such riots represent, among other things, the attempt of the community to define for itself what will count as police brutality and where the limit of authority falls. It is in these conflicts, not in the courts, that our rights are established.” When the police are recorded brutalizing someone through an excessive use of force or a shooting that is disproportional to the threat, the media tends to individualize the incident and question the actions of the individual police officer, or far more likely, the actions of the victim and what lead up to the brutality. Statistics and data compiled for many, many years instead show a pattern of violence, a pattern of forgiveness for the police regardless of their crimes, and a pattern of condemnation for the victims of police violence. The police, no matter what they do, are forgiven because they presumably serve a public good, but the victims of police violence, often vilified in the media as “no angels,” presumably do not serve a public good and are therefore more expendable than the police. In the United States in 2019, the police killed 1,099 people. 24% of those killed were black despite being only 13% of the US population. Black people are roughly three times more likely to be killed during encounters with the police, despite being roughly 1 and a half times more likely to be unarmed during these encounters. Apologists for the police will say that the police are only responding to violent crime, and that's just “where the police are.”   
 AUDIO 4
 However, statistics consistently show that levels of violent crime in US cities do not determine rates of police violence. It is demonstrably untrue that police violence is simply an unavoidable result of a comparable violent crime rate. These are only statistics in the United States, and while many Americans mistakenly believe that police violence and police militarization is a uniquely American problem, there is a lot of data that disproves this. Put a pin in that. [2 – 1:40] After Harry's interactions with Cuno and Cunoesse, he and Kim examined the body and continued their investigation. [8:40] Harry and Kim had to search a dumpster but didn't have the key. I had Harry question the cafeteria manager. Garte gave up the keys rather quickly, which meant there was no reason for Harry to continue questioning him...but I had him do it anyway. After Harry made his way through this district full of poverty and crime, he found Joyce, the representative of Wild Pines.    
  Criminogenic conditions are the causes of crime, such as poverty leading to theft. Early policing faced three compelling questions. Solving criminogenic conditions requires measures that capitalists would label “socialism” and are therefore not pursued by the state because rich capitalists have significant influence in the state. Capitalists don't want criminogenic conditions resolved because in order to help more people, the capitalists would have their taxes raised. Also, capitalists would no longer have an impoverished citizenry that is reliant on the capitalists and can provide cheap labor.    
  Resolving criminogenic socio-economic conditions would result in far greater peace and order than the police could ever create, but capitalists prefer the police to maintain “order” because it maintains the “order” that allows them to continue getting wealthier rather than an actual order that would help the most people. To put it more simply, police enforcement advantages the wealthy and disadvantages the poor. Solutions to criminogenic conditions would help the poor, but cut into the profits of the wealthy. Since the wealthy make the rules, the state focuses on police enforcement instead of solutions to criminogenic conditions. Wild Pines could solve poverty in Martinaise. But they won't. Wild Pines wants enough of the population of Martinaise to be poor so that the poor relies on Wild Pines. That is how capitalism functions. Thus, the police function as the armed enforcers of capitalism.   
  
  AUDIO 1  
 Over the course of the investigation, Harry has opportunities to lie to and intimidate witnesses and suspects. If the laws in Martinaise are similar to the United States, some of this is legal, and some of it is not, but nearly all of it will have no consequences. [V. Dirty Cop Stuff Is Still Cop Stuff] Remember Garte, the cafeteria manager? When Harry insists on seeing the kitchen, I had him pretend he has a search warrant. Police require a warrant to search property in many cases, and if the officer lies to gain entrance, any evidence the police officer finds will probably be suppressed in court. Again, probably, but not necessarily. Rather than simply lying about a search warrant, which is something the courts can check, police lie in other ways that are impossible to prove unless there is a recording. [3 – 2:44:30] For example, police can enter a residence if they believe an emergency is occurring inside. Of course, the police could simply lie about believing there is an emergency. Furthermore, consent may be considered invalid if officers mislead the person about who or what they’re investigating, but if the officers simply fail to tell a suspect that an inspection could lead to criminal charges, consent will be valid. However, one needs to consider the power dynamics in both instances. The officers could always lie about the emergency or lie about consent.    
 In either case, due to the authority the police have in society, they will almost certainly be believed over the person who was arrested. This is because society has been lead to believe that whatever the police are doing is in the public interest – in their interest. Even if cops get their hands dirty, it's OK, but dirty cop stuff is still cop stuff. [3 – 2:42:00] Harry is, according to the text of the game, “well versed in threatening legalese that implies criminal liability but has no meaning whatsoever.” This is another way police officers can do what they want. They probably know the letter of the law more than the average civilian and can lie about almost anything. In addition to lying about the law, police officers know that the law itself allows them to lie. The law will always favor law enforcement over suspects. These are some examples from the United States, but similar laws exist elsewhere. Oregon v. Matthiason established that the police are allowed to lie about fingerprints. People v. Jones established that the police can lie about DNA. Maryland v. King established that the police are allowed to lie to obtain your DNA. People v. Mays and People v. Smith established that the police can lie to you about polygraph tests. People v. Dominick established the police can lie to you about having witnesses. People v. Sims established that the police can lie about recording conversations. For example, they can say they are turning the recording device off to have an off-the-record chat with you but not actually do that.    
  AUDIO 2  
  People v. Steger established that the police can lie to you about what will happen to your friends if you don't confess. There are some exceptions to this. People v. Jablonski even established that there are ways that the police can deny you a lawyer even after you have requested one multiple times. This is all in service of gaining a confession –  even a phony confession. In fact, police can lie about that too. Frazier v. Cupp established that the police can lie about someone else confessing to the suspect's involvement in a crime. People v. Gurule established that the police can pretend that they have enough evidence to put that suspect away for a long time and that confessing is their best way to avoid a lengthy jail sentence. Apologists for the police would no doubt say “Well, if the suspect is innocent, why shouldn't the police be allowed to lie to them?” To that I say, first, please get that boot out of your mouth. Second, false confessions happen with a high degree of regularity. This is because police can trap a suspect with so many lies about what is in their best interest that the suspect may mistakenly believe that confessing to a minor crime is better than what will happen if the suspect does not cooperate. The public at large supports the police in these lies and confessions, presuming an innocence on the part of the police and guilt on the part of the suspect.    
 Presumption of innocence on the part of the police is a big part of why suspects believe their lies about reduced sentences and phony witnesses in the first place. In short, the police are legally allowed to lie to the people about nearly anything, and in the case of illegal lies, they are given the presumption of innocence should that come up in court. Not long ago, a police officer, Amber Guyger, was arrested and convicted of entering the wrong home and killing the owner, Botham Jean. It's not unusual for a police officer to kill someone, but it is unusual for a police officer to be arrested and convicted for it. What was the difference between this and, say, the strangulation and death of Eric Garner by Officer Daniel Pantaleo? In the case of Officer Guyger, she was not performing her duties as a police officer during the killing. She was off-duty and coming home. The fact that Guyger is a police officer was incidental. Society found it acceptable for her to be punished for killing Botham Jean. In the case of the death of Eric Garner, Daniel Pantaleo was on duty when he needlessly strangled an unarmed man to death. Society found it unacceptable for him to be punished because even though he was in the wrong, he was on duty when it happened. The police can get away with almost anything so long as they do it while wearing their uniform. Because if it happens on duty, then they were only doing “cop stuff.”    
  AUDIO 3  
  If a civilian wrongfully kills an unarmed person without a particularly good reason, they are charged for that crime, and statistically speaking, they will probably be convicted if it goes to trial. If a police officer wrongfully kills an unarmed person without a particularly good reason, society grants them a reason: they did it in the line of duty. A police officer only needs to say that they felt “threatened” to get away with it. They have enough institutional support and public support for this to be deemed acceptable. “We have to protect our boys in blue,” some people will say. Excuses will be made, and if none are immediately obvious, excuses will be invented. Anything to hand-wave the actions of the police as “necessary” for our safety. [3 – 2:45:20] Throughout Disco Elysium, no matter what Harry does, Kim will always look the other way. Here, Harry breaks into an apartment without permission. Kim acknowledges what is happening but barely raises an eyebrow. Earlier, when Harry took a swing at Cuno, Kim did nothing. Earlier still, when Harry tries to aggressively force a confession out of Garte, Kim reluctantly takes Harry's side...but he still does it. Kim is a firm believer in the necessity of the police. He mentions this several times. Kim himself will not do much that one might consider “dirty” but he allows Harry to do whatever he wants.    
  Within the context of the game, Kim can't impede Harry's progress because that would be impeding the player's progress. Although, this function of the game mirrors how much a police officer can get away with and how much other police officers, even if they don't agree with the actions of the dirty cop, will be willing to look the other way. Later in the game, Harry meets a union boss who wants him to intimidate someone. This is obviously well outside the investigation, but because the union boss could help with the investigation if Harry does this, Kim turns a blind eye to it. He will even participate because everywhere Harry goes, Kim follows. [3 2:41:00] Only in the rarest of circumstances, like when Harry considers kicking down an old woman's door, will Kim put his foot down. For the most part, however, Harry can do almost anything with few, if any, legal consequences. Because everything he does in the game is happening while he's on duty, and that's good enough for his partner.     
 
 AUDIO 1
 At a critical moment in the game, Harry and Kim encounter a standoff between a group of mercenaries and the Hardie Boys, the enforcers of a local union. During my communist run, I had Harry try to reason with both sides of the conflict and to ease tensions. He was not successful, but due to some solid rolls and better decisions, both he and Kim made it through alive and continued the case together. During my fascist run, I had Harry be more aggressive, immediately threatening both sides of the conflict. As a communist, Harry's rhetoric skills were much higher, but as a fascist, the odds of settling the dispute with words were similar to the odds of violently escalating the situation in Harry's favor. [VI. Arming the Police Against Us] In the real world, when in a potentially dangerous situation, police officers know that even though they may not need to draw their firearm, doing so is very tempting. It might get the civilian killed, even if the civilian doesn't need to be killed at all, but at least the police officer will feel safer. Trying to behave like a human being is marginally less effective for a police officer than outright killing whoever is in their way if the officer's only goal is their own safety.
 Police officers are generally trained to de-escalate a situation. However, killing a civilian with their firearm is still safer for themselves than not killing a civilian with their firearm, and many police officers, given the opportunity and hardware, will do that. Americans are sometimes under the false impression that their police carrying firearms is unique due to the prevalence of firearms among citizens and because news media and popular culture often compare US law enforcement usage of firearms to UK law enforcement and their usual lack of firearms. However, police across the world generally carry firearms, giving them incredible and lethal power over the citizenry. In Spain, the National Police own over 38,000 firearms, the Local Police own over 37,000, and the Guardia Civil own over 65,000. This arms roughly 83% of total Spanish officers if the weapons were evenly distributed. In Italy, both the Polizia, under the Ministry of the Interior, and the Carabinieri, the military police under the Ministry of Defense, routinely carry Beretta 9 caliber semi-automatic pistols. In France, the National Police, which is responsible for urban areas, and the Gendarmerie, which is responsible for rural areas, equip all their officers with a Sig-Sauer SP 2022 pistols.  
  AUDIO 2  
 Police routinely carry firearms in Australia, Japan, Russia, China, India, Pakistan, Brazil, Sweden and almost everywhere else in the world. Very few countries in the world severely restrict law enforcement access to firearms for public safety. Firearms carried by the police in the Republic of Ireland are extremely rare. Police in Norway do have access to firearms, but the manner in which they can use them is severely limited. Norwegian police officers don't carry firearms while on patrol duties, but they do have a firearm locked in their patrol cars. However, they may only arm themselves with permission from the chief of police. In Iceland, the police generally do not carry firearms except for the special operations team. Although, even among the rare countries with generally unarmed law enforcement, there have been moves in recent years to give them greater access to firearms. New Zealand has unarmed police officers.  
 But in recent years, the New Zealand Police Association has made several requests for a revision of the force’s weapons policy with a proposal to include arming officers. In the United Kingdom, the vast majority of law enforcement does not carry firearms, but there has been a notable militarization of law enforcement in recent years. In Disco Elysium, there are only a handful of instances in which Harry can draw his weapon on a civilian and even fewer in which he can actually fire it at a civilian. This is not a game with a normal combat system. The standoff between the mercenaries and the Hardie Boys is one of those instances. Will Harry shoot first and ask questions later? How threatened does he need to be in order for the deaths of the mercenaries to be justifiable? Policies and statistics vary from country to country. In a Supreme Court ruling in 2018, the majority of justices concluded that if an officer feels threatened in any way, even if the officer has no reasonable expectation of feeling threatened, the officer is virtually always justified.     
  AUDIO 3  
  In Sacramento, California, not long ago, police opened fire on Stephon Clark. Two officers, dispatched to investigate a report that someone was breaking car windows, saw Clark in his grandmother's backyard. One officer shouted “gun,” and fired 20 rounds of bullets, eight of which hit Clark. There was no gun. It was a cell phone. A recording proved that Clark showed his hands as asked, and an independent autopsy showed that six of the eight shots that struck Clark were in his back. The two officers muted the audio on their body cams as they discussed what had happened with each other and plotted their coverup. Still alive for up to ten minutes, Clark was left to die as the officers did not move to help him. These are only two, high-profile examples. The amount of police shootings and killing vary across the world. In Mexico in 2017, police killed 371 people. In the Congo in 2018, the number is 389.

AUDIO 4  
 In South Africa, 436. In Bangladesh in 2018, 466. In Pakistan in 2017, 495. In the Philippines in 2017, 3,451. In Brazil in 2018, 6,160. Increasing militarization of the police and police shootings in general is a global problem. [3 – 4:30] In Disco Elysium, Harry learns about himself and discovers that he has killed three people while on duty. Kim does not react to this negatively, insisting that this is common for police officers and that Harry might even be one of the good ones because his tally is so “low” compared to others. Kim never even inquires about the circumstances of Harry's shootings because Kim is of the mind that Harry must have had a good reason for drawing his weapon. His belief in this has everything to do with Harry being a police officer and therefore trustworthy in his eyes, despite overwhelming evidence leading up to this reveal that Harry is not trustworthy. In the real world, these shootings are allowed to happen without much pushback due to a combination of police intimidation, propaganda and complicity among more conservative citizens. When a police officer shoots someone, even if they didn't have to, much of the public will defend them, shouting down any opposition with empty arguments that always find fault with the victim and not the police officer who escalated the situation.    
  After all, it was done in the line of duty: “cop stuff” remember? In the case of Stephon Clark, enough people will say “Well, a cell phone could be mistaken for a firearm,” as if the police officer's mistake was somehow the fault of the victim. Enough people will say “He was no angel,” digging into his past, searching for any justification or any reason to hand-wave the incident so that the police are not at fault. Police officers can be caught on camera shooting children holding toys and still not be found at fault by much of the population. When citizens rightly protest police shootings, enough people will say “Oh, they'll call the police if they're in trouble,” as if that's the point. As if we have to accept thousands of police shootings in order to protect our car stereos.    
  AUDIO 5  
  Back to my fascist run and the standoff, I increased Harry's odds of making an unprovoked shot but still failed the check. Tried again and made the improbable check. Harry escalated the problem, and as he was unable to dodge a bullet, he was shot. A failed authority check later, and Kim was shot by the mercenaries. In my communist run, Kim helped patch Harry up and continued the investigation. In my fascist run, Kim is removed from the game – presumably alive for the time being in a hospital – but is never seen again.    
  Again, Harry shot first. He was not responding to a shooting. Nevertheless, apologists for the police use real world incidents like this as evidence. They will say “Well, what about police officers who are shot and killed?” Out of fairness, this should be acknowledged. According to Officer Down, in 2019, 48 police officers in the United States were shot and killed in the line of duty through intentional gunfire by suspects. This is undoubtedly heartbreaking for the families of these officers, but this is also a very small number compared to the amount of people in the United States shot and killed by police officers. The police fatally shot 1,099 people in 2019. 1,099 to 48. Apologists would try to boost these numbers by adding other on-duty deaths unrelated to suspects like training accidents and heart attacks, but even with all that added to the totals, it still would not be close to the 1,099 people who the people killed in 2019 in the United States. And again, that's only the US. Any loss of life is tragic to their families, and police officers do encounter danger, but based on these extremely lopsided numbers, it's not the police who are in the most danger. It's everyone else.  
  Many people are not willing to believe that the police are at fault when someone is shot, even if the victim is innocent and unarmed, because doing so forces them to acknowledge that the police are not there for their protection – and that can be terrifying.    
  AUDIO 1  
  So...what can we do about this? [VII. Limited Reforms] Throughout the game, Harry is called a “pig” by various people around Martinaise, and his feelings about that are dictated by the player. In my communist run, Harry came to identify with those who would call him a pig and disassociate with the police entirely. In my fascist run, obviously, he was way more into his violent authority. The letters ACAB sometimes confuse people who don't have much interest in police reform or police abolition – not only because they can't imagine a society functioning any other way but because the “all cops” part makes the statement seem to target individual cops. It does not. Whether or not an individual police officer is a “good” or “bad” person is not relevant. Mistrust of the police, the political movement of police abolition, and the letters ACAB themselves have nothing whatsoever to do with individual police officers and everything to do with the system with which these officers participate and prop up. Disco Elysium asks “What kind of cop are you?” and allows you to make lots of choices for Harry. However, the game never allows you to not be a cop at all. The narrative is about a police investigation. The only way to not be a cop in Disco Elysium is to not play Disco Elysium. Communist Harry might be a better human being than fascist Harry, but any Harry is a cop. Put it this way. A “bad” cop might get a perverse, racist thrill out of harassing minorities, and a “good” cop might not.    
  But that same “good” cop must still enforce laws that disproportionately punish minorities. A “bad” cop might come from an affluent background and despise the poor, and a “good” cop might not, but the “good” cop is still enforcing laws that favor the rich and control the poor. Bad cop, good cop, they are both part of the same bad institution. Whether or not it's a “good thing” for “good” cops to be part of the force to balance out the “bad” cops is irrelevant because while there are varying degrees of bad behavior among individual officers, the system of policing itself – meaning enforcing capitalism and controlling the poor – is inherently damaging. During police training, individuals are not told that they are there to serve capital and to prevent the working class from organizing...but it is what the police end up doing anyway. It's not a secret conspiracy. It's just the result of the existence of the police, what the laws instruct the police to predominantly serve, and the role of the police within our current economic system. Apologists for the police sometimes bring up the fact that any profession comes with it some risk that one's actions indirectly benefit a bad system, but there are two problems with this. First, again, the opposition is to the system of modern policing, not some individual's microscopic contribution to it. Second, even if we were to take the individual approach, there is no comparison to a police officer who disagrees with some aspects of modern policing and, say, a Walmart greeter who disagrees with the owners of Walmart. The Walmart greeter might indirectly – in some five degrees of Kevin Bacon kind of way – assist capitalists in some marginal, barely visible manner, but that ignores the fact that it is unavoidable to participate in capitalism while capitalism exists.  
  AUDIO 2  
  We have no choice but to indirectly assist capitalists and participate in capitalism to pay rent and buy food for the same reason that a convict in a private prison must indirectly and begrudgingly make money for the owners of said prison. So long as capitalism is the economic system under which we all live, we cannot opt out of having a profession under capitalism. On the other hand, a police officer does more than simply have a profession, like we all do. A police officer far more directly enforces the law in service of the marriage of state and capitalism. A police officer can take away the freedom and even the life of a civilian with little to no consequences for themselves. A Walmart greeter cannot do that. Also, while it is true that we must have a profession, there is nothing that forces us to have this profession. Saying “there is no ethical consumption under capitalism” does not dismiss the existence of the police – nor does it excuse those who choose to directly participate in modern policing. Having a job? No choice. Having this job in particular? A choice. Now, how much personal responsibility one applies to an individual police officer for choosing their profession is a matter of some debate, but since the problem is the system and not any one individual, it is not particularly relevant to this conversation. In short, the problem is not Harry or Kim or your real world police officer relative who you swear on a stack of Bibles is a nice guy.    
 The problem is the institution to which police officers are employed and serve. The police abolition movement does not seek a society without law or law enforcement. It only seeks to replace the current, modern, centralized system of policing and/or employ radical changes to that system. There are two categories of change related to the police. The first category is limited change that can happen within our current economic system and current centralized police that could theoretically happen right now if there were enough public support. The second category is massive change that would be far more effective but probably won't happen overnight. So, we should probably advocate for both because everything that could minimize harm is worth doing. First category first: reforms that might help, at least a little. Police officers in many parts of the world do not through extensive training. In the United States, for example, prospective officers train for an average of nineteen weeks before being given a lethal weapon and told to patrol the city looking for bad guys. It takes four years of university as well as a series of qualifying classes to become a kindergarten teacher. It takes seven years to become a surgeon. It takes only a few months to become responsible for the incredible authority to take away the freedom or life of a civilian in a society that presumes that authority is almost never wrong. Police training lasts about as long as one semester of university.    
  AUDIO 3
 Imagine passing one course, Psychology 101, and being given a doctorate and a private practice at the end of the semester. For the police, that's the gap between training and utilizing that training. Rutgers University sociology professor Paul Hirshfield once said of this: “If you only have 19 weeks of training, you’re going to spend those on the most essential things. Unfortunately, in the United States, it’s about what you need to defend yourself. How you’re going to avoid getting hurt. If you have three years, you can also learn how to protect people, how to avoid these situations from arising in the first place. It fosters a whole different orientation and culture in law enforcement.” If police officers are dedicating their entire careers – their entire working lives – to the force, they should at least receive proper training, and most of that training should be about protecting others, not protecting themselves, as that gives them the impression that their lives are more important than civilians and that drawing a weapon at the slightest provocation is considered acceptable if it's in the service of self-protection. In Disco Elysium, there are at least two instances in which Harry must act as a negotiator and mental health expert. Ruby, a suspect, threatens to kill herself, and another civilian, nicknamed 'The Pigs,' is having a mental health emergency. Yet, it is up to Harry to prevent any harm, despite the fact that he is not a mental health expert.   
 He himself is having a week-long mental health emergency. The police are given a broad directive to maintain “order” in their community, and because of this, they are called to quell any disturbances. When the police respond to someone acting erratic, they don't know what to say or what to do. They're not doctors. They're police. The police are not called to put out fires. The fire department is called. Why are the police dispatched to handle mental health emergencies? Mental health emergencies should not be handled by the police. A separate, unaffiliated institution should be responsible for handling mental health emergencies. Why are the police called when a homeless person is sleeping on a bench or loitering? Why not dispatch someone who works at a homeless shelter or someone who is there to help the homeless person? Shooing away the homeless does not benefit the homeless. It benefits more fortunate people who have decided that they don't want to look at homeless people so much that they will call the police just to avoid making eye contact with them. Nobody is demanding working class people house complete strangers in their already occupied studio apartments, but there is an abundance of empty housing that goes unused, owned by the rich. A society that doesn't even have proper, safe shelters and other forms of care for the homeless is failing at being a society. The state gives the police the job of shooing away the homeless instead of funding a system to take care of the homeless.   
 AUDIO 4
 The police being responsible for dealing with the homeless gives the community the impression that if the homeless are a “police matter,” then the homeless are inherently dangerous. The blame is shifted on to the victims of society and not the structure of society itself that makes such victims. The police don't shoo away homeless people because they have evidence that this individual homeless person is dangerous. If they did, that homeless person would be arrested in light of that evidence. The police are directed to disperse homeless people from public places because the rich make the laws, and the rich don't have any use for people with no money, and the homeless are an “eyesore” for people with money. The police are given many tasks which have little to do with law enforcement and everything to do with maintaining commerce in a community. If the job can be done by someone who is not a cop, then a cop should not be called. For all the reasons mentioned in the earlier section, police should be de-militarized and gradually disarmed. Apologists for the police would say that police need to be armed in a country with a potentially armed population, but in Iceland, where there are an estimated 90,000 guns in a population of 323,000, the police are unarmed and the country has one of the lowest global crime rates in the world. Even if that were not true, the police as an institution has consistently proven itself irresponsible as an armed force. We don't give this many chances to violent offenders.   
 There is no reason to keep giving more and more chances for the police to one day be responsible with firearms. Police accountability departments and internal affairs should be handled exclusively by civilians – not the police themselves. The conflict of interest is obvious. There are countless other potential reforms to the police, and the feasibility should at least be investigated. In addition to reforms to the police as an institution, criminogenic laws and circumstances should be reformed. The destitute and the homeless can easily be housed in the thousands upon thousands of empty homes and buildings if the state actually wanted to do that. Marijuana and ownership of small quantities of drugs should be decriminalized, and the drug problem should be treated predominantly as a health matter and not a legal matter. Private prisons should be abolished, as they incentivize legislation that fills them up. The criminal justice system should be completely reformed, and mandatory minimums should be abolished. These reforms would give the police significantly less authority over our lives. Toward the end of Disco Elysium, Harry and his partner – either Kim or Cuno – set off for a nearby island to confront the murderer and close the case. Spoilers. I guess.   
 AUDIO 1
 [VIII. Conclusion] I had Harry confront Iosef, a communist who had seen his dreams fade with the victory of capitalism. During my communist run, Harry tried to get along with him, but he rejected Harry. The police are a tool of capitalism, and a communist cop is still a cop. During my fascist run, every nonsensical fascist slogan Harry said resulted in him losing morale. It took several tries and a few deaths to get to a conclusion. There are several problems with mere reforms to the police. One problem is that the police are incredibly resistant to reforms. Adding body cameras to police officers sounded like a helpful reform until we realized that police officers can – and do – put their hand over their camera or just turn off either the video or audio when convenient. Another problem is that reforms can simply be rolled back under a new administration or new representatives. The concept of police reform suggests that the police as agents of capitalism is some flaw in the system when in reality, this is the system functioning as it was intended. Capitalists wanted there to be a centralized police force who protected their interests, and that's what happened. We should advocate for anything that even has a chance of protecting civilians from the police, but we also need to recognize that the police maintaining their current level of unquestioned authority will abuse that authority and that the police under capitalism are always going to be the enforcers of capitalism.   
 For example, added training would undoubtedly help, but calls for training as a cure-all ignore certain facts. Eric Garner did not die because the police officer accidentally used the wrong hold. He died because the police officer casually disregarded his plea that he could not breathe. Police are told time and time again that they are invincible to public scrutiny, above the law and superior to those they are harassing. Worse still, they are told that the people they are harassing for suspicion of petty crimes are in need of this harassment. It's “broken windows” policing, meaning targeting low-level infractions and relatively harmless vice with aggressive, intensive and violent enforcement. According to Alex S. Vitale, author of The End of Policing, “Broken-windows policing is at root a deeply conservative attempt to shift the burden of responsibility for declining living conditions onto the poor themselves and to argue that the solution to all social ills is increasingly aggressive, invasive, and restrictive forms of policing that involve more arrests, more harassment, and ultimately more violence. As inequality continues to increase, so will homelessness and public disorder, and as long as people continue to embrace the use of police to manage disorder, we will see a continual increase in the scope of police power and authority at the expense of human and civil rights.” Broken-windows policing is more philosophy than policy and is therefore difficult to root out.   
 AUDIO 2
 Other reforms like special prosecutors and civilian accountability departments still face major hurdles to doing their job due to a lack of cooperation from the police. In short, there are limits to reform due to the incredible power that the police are given. That means the only way to circumvent this is by taking away much of their power -- replacing the modern police with something else. This is only a radical proposal if one mistakenly believes that the modern, centralized police is an institution that has always existed. It has not. The police as we know it is a relatively recent invention. Demanding a replacement in law enforcement and community safety is no more radical than the last major replacement in law enforcement and community safety in the 1830's. The only difference is that it was the wealthy – the capitalists – who demanded this change to serve their interests whereas now, it is the people who demand a change to serve our interests. Incremental reform can only take us so far, and at some point, we need to have the political will to make another radical change. What would the replacement for the police look like? How would it function? Police abolitionists have proposed several alternatives, as there is no singular consensus. One alternative is for most activities that do not need to be handled by the police be separated into professional departments that are specifically trained to solve problems those problems without harsh punishment, such as the aforementioned mental health professionals handling mental health emergencies. Drug enforcement can be abolished and transferred to a department that would treat drug problems as a public health matter and not a punitive matter that statistically is not be solved by jail sentences.    
  AUDIO 3  
 What remains of the police would be highly trained detectives for major crimes like homicide and rotating community patrols for everything else, populated with temporary members so as to remove any above-the-law privileges that officers believe they have. It should go without saying that this new law enforcement would not be armed. This would resolve some of the issues related to the police as an authoritarian force while still maintaining community safety. Some combination of these alternatives might make the most sense. What we would call this does not really matter. If it makes people comfortable, we can still call them “the police.” But they would be functionally so different that a rebranding might be in order, just as law enforcement prior to the police were “the watch” and before that something else, and so forth. Would it work? There is no crystal ball, but we do know that the current system of policing does not work, which means alternatives must be explored. The biggest threat to the people and the biggest influence on police power is that the wealthy control the politicians, and the politicians control the law. The only way to resolve that is for people to be unable to hoard the vast majority of the wealth on the planet. The wealthy create greater and greater disparity and income inequality. If wealth creates influence, then the wealthy have more and more influence in the law, then everyone else has less and less influence in the law.   
 That means the law will always favor the wealthy and maintain the wealthy over everyone else – unless there is no more income inequality. Unless there is no more...capitalism. Again, from Alex S. Vitale: “We must break these intertwined systems of oppression. Every time we look to the police and prisons to solve our problems, we reinforce these processes. We cannot demand that the police get rid of those 'annoying' homeless people in the park or the 'threatening' young people on the corner and simultaneously call for affordable housing and youth jobs, because the state is only offering the former and will deny us the latter every time. Yes, communities deserve protection from crime and even disorder, but we must always demand those without reliance on the coercion, violence, and humiliation that undergird our criminal justice system. The state may try to solve those problems through police power, but we should not encourage or reward such short-sighted, counterproductive, and unjust approaches. We should demand safety and security—but not at the hands of the police. In the end, they rarely provide either.” At the end of Disco Elysium, Harry and the suspect talk about the capitalists taking over and the dream of a better world only being a memory. They had their chance, and they blew it. But that does not mean that we won't get another chance to change the world. Economic systems are replaced by new economic systems over the course of history. I don't have a three-step plan to overthrow capitalism, I'm an educator, not an organizer, but I do know enough about history to see that there is going to be an opportunity to make that radical change. The police can't be the enforcers of capitalism if there is no capitalism anymore.    
  Hi, everyone. If you want to learn more, the sources are cited in the description. Many of the sources were always quoted in the video, particularly The End of Policing by Alex S. Vitale, Our Enemies in Blue by Kristian Williams, The History of Policing in the United States by Dr. Gary Potter, and The Origins of Capitalism by the Brighton Solidarity Federation.  
 


Comments

No comments found for this post.