October Update and Scripts (Patreon)
Content
It's the spooky season, everyone. You know what that means. Actually, I don't know what it means. There are no parties or trick-or-treating in 2020. However, you will be pleased to know that there is one more horror-related video coming very soon. It should be available tomorrow at the earliest. After that, there will be a slightly longer breaker between episodes than usual. The first episode in November is a big one, and it will require all my attention.
With that out of the way, here are some episode scripts from earlier this year.
MISINFORMATION FOR FUN AND PROFIT
AUDIO 1
The world is currently under quarantine. There are well over two million coronavirus cases and a tremendous amount of deaths. 7% of those confirmed to have been infected with coronavirus have tragically passed away. The United States of America has, by far, the most coronavirus patients, presently well above 800,000 at the time of this recording with total deaths over 40,000. Apologists would say that this is only because of the high population of the United States and nothing else, but if that were true, countries with 4x the population of the US would have 4x the amount of coronavirus cases, but they do not. India has 1.3 billion people whereas the United States has a population of only about 300,000,000. Nevertheless, India has significantly fewer cases than the US. Countries with similar populations to the United States like Indonesia, Pakistan, Nigeria and Brazil all have far fewer cases. It's not even close. The United States contains only about 4% of the total world population but 32% of the world's coronavirus patients. Coronavirus cases are not exclusively relative to population, as other contributing factors are to blame. This leaves the only explanation being that both the Trump administration and the country at large did not handle this well at all. The Trump administration was slow to take action and even now has continued to make both honest mistakes andintentionally dangerous decisions.
After weeks of quarantine, some Americans – most of them white and conservative – have begun to rebel against the quarantine, staging protests and rallies to demand that the United States be “re-opened” so that they can watch sporting events and get haircuts. Some have more legitimate grievances, such as the inability to work, but they have mistakenly blamed this on doctors and experts rather than the government's stinginess with their stimulus checks. Across articles and social media, people have begun to label these people “covidiots” and “Florida morons” – suggesting that this behavior is sign of a failed intelligence test. According to Pew Research, 32% are worried that restrictions won't be lifted quickly enough. And yes, that is not the majority, but if roughly 1 out of 3 Americans are more concerned about staying indoors than people dying, that is a significant number of people misinformed about the danger.To be perfectly clear, what these protesters are doing is dangerous, and they are, put simply, wrong. They are wrong. They should not be doing this, and the United States cannot and should not be “re-opened” before it is safe to do so. However, these protests and rallies are not the result of some people just being “born dumb-dumbs” or “inferior people” – that's some low key eugenics talk. Let's not do that. The opposition to the quarantine, a wedge issue against a technocratic, apolitical safety measure, is the result of misinformation by far more powerful entities than these individual protesters:
AUDIO 2
right-wing politicians, right-wing media and rich capitalists. A wedge issue is a divisive political matter that provides a contrast between two political parties. This has two effects, and both of them are dishonest. First, a wedge manipulates the people into a culture war to galvanize voters so they will show up on election day and vote for the politician who they feel is strongest on the wedge issue. Second, a wedge issue often distracts the people from their real concerns: their place in stratified economic classes. Both parties in the United States protect the system of capitalism. With no intention of providing relief from that system, the two parties need wedge issues to motivate their voters and distract them from the fact that both parties wish to maintain the system that has the most to do with their own oppression. Even matters that need not be politicized – such as the widely understood necessity of social distancing – is made a wedge issue to draw contrast between the parties, placing social distancing within the ideology of the Democrats and opposition to social distancing within the ideology of the Republicans, even though neither have much to do with their respective party platforms. President Trump, from the very beginning of the crisis, held rallies to show contrast between how he sees the coronavirus and how his political opponents see the coronavirus.
He told everyone that Americans are perfectly safe and that he personally had the situation under control and that everyone panicking is only trying to take him down. Right-wing media uncritically parroted his words because they are in the business of giving conservative, predominantly white Americans the news and entertainment they desire: news and entertainment that reinforces what they have been culturally lead to believe for centuries. White conservatives have been passive participants in their own oppression due to a campaign of misinformation and a series of wedge issues designed by politicians and capitalists to distract them from said oppression. In the late 19th century, following the American Civil War, among southern capitalists were white plantation owners. These capitalists feared emerging labor class unity. A unity among the labor class, regardless of race and other factors, is strong enough to collectivize and oppose their own exploitation by capitalists. The plantation owners could not have that and ignited a wedge issue: the idea that poor white workers could not trust newly freed poor black workers due to the latter's resentment of whites in general so soon after the abolition of slavery. White plantation owners, so soon after losing all their free slave labor, did whatever they could to hold on to their position in the economic classes.
AUDIO 3
Thus, white plantation owners built a political coalition with poor white men to overthrow integrated Reconstruction governments throughout the South. Rather than joining forces with the multitude of poor black workers to organize against their own exploitation, poor white workers sided with rich white plantation owners – choosing racism over class solidarity. They believed the misinformation about who their “real” enemy was. One needs to understand the power dynamics of misinformation here. Rich, white plantation owners could campaign, hold rallies, provide literature to those who could read, pay off politicians to side with them, and use their wealth in other ways to help further their cause and their coalition with poor white workers. Poor black workers had no wealth, no political influence. The argument was rigged against them. Poor white workers may have never even heard their argument, and if they did, said argument did not carry as much sway as that of the powerful in society. Obviously, the intersection of race and poverty presented black workers with greater challenges than white workers, but in one respect, they faced an identical challenge with white workers: their exploitation by capitalists. Nevertheless, in a campaign of misinformation vs. a campaign that goes unseen, the misinformation will win every time. Capitalists protect their interests by driving a wedge between workers, making it impossible for them to organize.
Moving on to the 20thcentury, one specific strategy among capitalists and their corporately owned political puppets is a misinformation campaign that re-defined what capitalism is and re-defined what socialism is, thereby creating a culture in which the workers side with capitalism and their own oppression. Capitalism was re-defined in the popular consciousness of the United States simply as the “American way of life” – of hard work and dedication – instead of what it is, an economic system that depends on the vast majority of people being dependent on wage labor, enriching capitalists who privately own the means of production while the poor never see a share of that wealth. Socialism was re-defined as a foreign influence and that adoption of such an ideology was treason. Anything that could potentially cut into the profits of rich capitalists was branded socialism, and since this boogeyman term was conflated with treason, capitalism had the added side-effect of being branded as patriotic. This was not an accident. This was the goal of capitalists – to brand their hoarding of wealth, their stealing of wages, their greed, their exploitation of the workers – all as patriotic and in keeping with the values of the country.
AUDIO 4
Anything that threatened the wealth of capitalists could be labeled socialism, particularly things that were not really socialism but just helpful – leaving no room for actual socialism to be even considered. Capitalists and their bought politicians told poor workers that the threat was not the capitalists who exploited them but foreign socialists. Capitalists were heralded as protecting the American way of life, and workers were given the impression that they had more in common with rich capitalists in the United States than they did with workers in the Soviet Union. This tactic during the 20thcentury was the same used in the late 19thcentury following the American Civil War. Protecting capitalists interests by misinformation, driving a wedge between the workers and creating a false solidarity between the capitalists and their workers while shunning actual class solidarity among the workers themselves. This has continued to this very day. It's why the aforementioned protesters are calling the quarantine socialism or communism. It doesn't make sense until you recognize how words and ideologies are conflated due to misinformation from capitalists. Businesses being closed for safety precautions affects capitalists' ability to earn even more money. Therefore, closing a business is “socialism” in the eyes of conservatives. A quarantine limits movement. Capitalist propaganda and misinformation labels capitalism as freedom. Less freedom under a quarantine?
Therefore, the quarantine is “socialism” in the eyes of conservatives. “Closing” the United States? Well, capitalism and the United States have been propagandized as one in the same. Therefore, “closing” the United States is “socialism” in the eyes of conservatives. Anything that conflicts with the vague concept of the American way of life is socialism, and if socialism is something to be defeated, then capitalism is something to be protected. Conservative protesters are given the impression that they are out there defending the United States of America, defending capitalism from socialism, an ideology that they have mistakenly been lead to believe is what is oppressing them and keeping them poor instead of what is actually oppressing them and keeping them poor: capitalism. Poverty among the many is the inevitable consequence of capitalism. Capitalists and their bought politicians will always find some other reason why the poor and to a lesser extent the middle class are suffering. It can never be the fault of capitalism. So, this century, it must be the fault of immigrants. Immigration then becomes a wedge issue for voters, a way to distract them from the wealth and privilege who are actually in power. Immigrants are not the cause of low wages. Immigrants neither affect low wages or control wages. Capitalists who could easily afford to pay higher wages are why there are low wages.
AUDIO 5
Capitalists have bought politicians who have, in turn, kept the federal minimum wage stagnant for over a decade at $7.25. Politicians can't expose this and certainly can't blame themselves, so the work force is divided through this wedge issue. Immigrants are not keeping wages low. Capitalists are. Who do you think has more power? Billionaires with tons of political connections or people who just arrived in this country last week with nothing but the shirts on their backs? Capitalists and their bought politicians do it once again. They create a false solidarity between poor white, conservative workers and rich white, conservative capitalists against the poor workers from Mexico and other Central American countries. Poor workers from differing countries have far more common class interests than poor workers and rich capitalists from the same country. But poor white, conservative workers don't see it that way. Again, this is not an attack on the intelligence of poor white, conservative workers. They believe this because poor workers from Central America do not have the misinformation apparatus that rich capitalists do. So, poor white workers do not recognize the actual class solidarity between themselves and poor workers from Central America. The names and faces change, but the strategy stays the same throughout the centuries under capitalism.
Protesting the quarantine is the result of centuries of misinformation among socially conservative culture that tells them that right-wing politicians and media have their best interests at heart. It's the result of a coalition of misinformation by arguably the worst president in a history of bad presidents and a media apparatus that knows it's in its economic interest to explore this wedge issue. Modern white, socially conservative, working class people will watch Fox News, watch President Trump's speeches, watch socially conservative pundits and assume that they are being given the truth about coronavirus. That it's not as bad as the Democrats are saying, even though, really, it's not the Democrats who are saying that. It's scientists, doctors and people all over the world. Conservative, white, working class people have been given a steady diet of misinformation, carefully crafted to provide a counter-argument if the workers look elsewhere for real information. President Trump constantly attacks the media during his speeches, giving his base the idea that news media outside of Fox News and other right-wing outlets cannot be trusted. So, when white, conservative, working class people see the numbers from the New York Times or a study in The Guardian or CNN, they will assume that those numbers and studies are the misinformation.
AUDIO 6
They will assume that the only real sources of information about the coronavirus are President Trump and his friends in conservative news media. Mainstream media has its own problems, that's a topic for another day, but repeating information from qualified experts is not one of them. If the Trump administration, conservative news media and others aligned with those two entities say things like “Coronavirus is no worse than the flu,” the bubble that white conservatives live in will not allow them to hear a counter-argument. To be clear, coronavirus is worse than the flu. For one, data suggests that coronavirus is more infectious than the flu. The average patient infected with the flu will spread to 1.3 other people. The average patient with coronavirus will spread it to 2 to 2.5 additional people. The higher number of infections per coronavirus patient may be related to the frequency of what is called pre-symptomatic transmission. This is when people who have been infected are not yet showing symptoms but still could be contagious. In contrast, flu is most contagious in the three or four days after symptoms begin. But that's not all. About 80% of coronavirus cases are mild to moderate. About20% of coronavirus patients are serious enough to get sent to the hospital. That is approximately 10 times more often than the flu. The mortality rate is also higher than the flu.
Protesters counter by ignoring the rate of mortality and focusing on overall numbers, saying the flu has had a tragic end for more people total. Yes. So far, because the flu has existed for a long time whereas the coronavirus is only a few months old. The total numbers are not as important right now as the rate of mortality because that is what is making those numbers skyrocket. Also, there is a vaccine for the flu but not for coronavirus. If someone is worried that their workplace may be hazardous, they can get a flu shot. There is presently no coronavirus shot. Also, with only a limited number of beds in hospitals, and a limited number of hospital staff, people with other injuries and diseases who would otherwise be treated are not going to make it. Based on the rate of infection, rate of mortality and the fact that there is no coronavirus vaccine, maintaining a quarantine to stop potentially hundreds of thousands of preventable deaths is the most sensible option. So, with all of this readily available information, why do conservative protesters believe otherwise? It's not necessarily because they have seen the same information that everyone else has and have come to a less enlightened conclusion. It's because they haven't seen the same information or they don't see the information as true. They have been bombarded with misinformation, and centuries of propaganda telling them who to trust and who not to trust has lead to them to mistakenly believe the misinformation. This misinformation campaign about the coronavirus benefits Trump, conservative news media, and capitalists. For Trump, it creates a wedge issue that galvanizes his base. If he can affect anger among his most solid voting bloc – white, socially conservative working class people – he can make them believe that the Democrats the real problem during this quarantine.
AUDIO 7
That only he can fix the problem. This has been a common refrain for Trump dating back to 2016. The wedge issue alone helps him. He does not care that this will undoubtedly lead to spreading the coronavirus and subsequent tragedies. Conservative media benefits from the wedge issue because it has always relied on contrarianism to draw in viewers. An atmosphere of “we're all in this together” is off-brand and therefore unhelpful to their economic interests. Moreover, acknowledging the mainstream media, scientists, academics, and apolitical government institutions that taxpayers fund are all right this time would seriously damage years and years of their own talking points that have attacked those institutions. Right-wing media has been spreading misinformation for years that these entities are out to get us. That scientists are peddling lies, that the mainstream media is more biased than right-wing media, that our taxes are being wasted on healthcare and other social programs, and that academics are the real “elites” that are keeping us down. Right-wing media simply cannot acknowledge the necessity of these institutions. It would be an acknowledgment that right-wing media was wrong this whole time. Their brand, their profits, all of it depends on being opposed to the institutions that are, at this time, dispensing medical advice and safety guidelines. That means right-wing media, in order to survive, must be opposed to whatever it is these institutions are saying.
The Center for Disease Control says to stay indoors? Well, maybe you should go outdoors instead! Scientists say that the coronavirus has a higher infection and mortality rate than the flu? Well, maybe it is the flu that has a higher infection and mortality rate than the coronavirus! Mainstream media is repeating the talking points of scientists and the CDC? Well, maybe mainstream media is in the pocket of big science! Academics are giving advice? Well, ignore them! They're the “elites” after all. This is something Fox News pundit and definite white supremacist Tucker Carlson harps about all the time. How the “elites” are out to get us. In a way, he's right, but he is purposefully rebranding college-educated literature majors as the “elites” and distracting his predominantly white, socially conservative audience from discovering who the real elites in society are: capitalists. Rich capitalists have more power and influence in society than liberal arts students struggling to make ends meet. It's the old grift. It's not functionally different from the late 19thcentury misinformation campaign against recently freed, poor black laborers. Divide and conquer. Protect capitalism. Create wedge issues and culture wars. Maintain the status quo of stratified economic classes. Politicians are already beginning to reopen non-essential businesses amid the pandemic. What's happening is their rich donors are demanding they do this – in spite of the danger it will cause – so that corporations can rake in more money.
AUDIO 8
The protests give the politicians an excuse to do so, to see which way the wind is blowing. Then when people start getting infected at growing rates, these politicians will find some distraction for their conservative base, letting them off the hook. Politicians may even blame the protesters for asking for an end to the quarantine, even though it's the politicians who are influencing the protesters to ask for an end to the quarantine in the first place. When infections increase, the narrative will be that the protesters are “getting a taste of their own medicine” – shifting blame on the targets of misinformation – but it's the politicians and capitalists who are feeding them this misinformation, influencing them to protest so that those in power can open up businesses without publicly accepting any blame for the consequences. Because that's what they always do. It's the oldest trick in the book, but that also means it's time-tested. Anything to avoid acknowledging that capitalism puts business interests over human lives. It's especially important for capitalists to obfuscate the harm capitalism causes in a time when people are finally starting to recognize this. After all, when right-wing politicians and pundits told people they should sacrifice themselves for the economy, that may have opened some minds about the true cost of capitalism. White, working class conservatives are protesting because they have been the targets of a misinformation campaign about who is really oppressing them. A misinformation campaign that has lasted centuries.
Bear in mind that none of this excuses the behavior of anyone causing genuine harm. We have to protect ourselves from individuals because individuals are the ones who will adopt misinformation into practice in dangerous ways. This is particularly important in this case because some of the people protesting are not simply misinformed but are actively recruiting for dangerous causes. Nobody is congratulating anyone for their ignorance on an issue. It's simply important to recognize where it comes from. It comes from the top. Attorney General Barr is threatening legal action against states that are simply following appropriate safety guidelines. The Republican Lieutenant Governor of Texas, Dan Patrick, outright said “There are more important things than living,” Barr, Trump and the rest want businesses back open to appease their corporate donors and because they care more about the economy than human lives. The protesters may seem like a fringe group, but their wrongheaded beliefs are reinforced for them by the people at the top. Because of this, they think their dangerous beliefs are mainstream and therefore correct. They think “Well, the leader of the free world says everything is fine, so everything must be fine,” not realizing why Trump is making these outrageous claims. Again, none of this excuses their actions, but it does explain their actions.It's not enough to just say “covidiots.” It's critical to recognize entities with more power and influence that are creating these divisions among the workers so that we correct the public record when possible, so that we can can see them for what they are and potentially dismantle them.
STAR TREK GENERATIONS IS GOOD, ACTUALLY
AUDIO 1
On May 23rd, 1994, Star Trek: The Next Generation aired its series finale, All Good Things. The two-part episode featured Captain Jean-Luc Picard operating within three different points in time – the present, the past and the future – all while attempting to solve a conundrum that would wipe out human civilization. Critically and commercially well-received, All Good Things put an end to the television series that pushed the Star Trek franchise beyond its original series and subsequent movies. But that was not the end for the crew of the Enterprise-D. Later that same year, on November 18th, 1994, a little under six months after the series finale, Star Trek: The Next Generation had its first major motion picture: Star Trek: Generations. The movie was marketed on fan service more than being an epic adventure. The fan service in question was the meeting between Captain Picard and Captain James T. Kirk. The tagline on the poster was “Two captains. One destiny.” Paramount wanted Star Trek fans excited about that. According tot he marketing, the movie itself was immaterial, irrelevant. It was the fan service that was the hook. The Next Generation gave us episodes with McCoy, Spock and Scotty, but not Kirk. Now all those nerds on usenet would have something to look forward to besides a lifetime of virginity.
Generations was a box office success, raking in over $118 million dollars worldwide against a $35 million dollar budget. Adjusted for inflation, that was approximately $315 million dollars by today's standards. Critical and fan response, however, was mixed. Critics were evenly divided, and Star Trek fans, who bought tickets on the promise of some big team-up or battle between Picard and Kirk were disappointed to find that the two captains don't share the screen together until 1 hour and 29 minutes into the movie and that Kirk dies twenty minutes later. Trek fans were also furious about what Trek fans often love to gripe about: minutiae. “Why does the bridge look all well lit...like a movie? Why does Captain Picard want children all of the sudden? Why does the emotion chip look slightly bigger in the movie than it did in the series? Why does Captain Picard not care about the Kurlan Naiskos? Didn't anyone bother to think about the Kurlan Naiskos?” For many TNG faithful, Star Trek: Generations was ruined through a combination of expectations based on marketing and the Trek fan's greatest nemesis: obsessing about stuff that doesn't really matter. It has been about twenty-six years since the release of the film. If we can divorce ourselves from those expectations and also divorce ourselves from the baggage of canon, is it...any good? Yeah. It's, you know, it's pretty good.
AUDIO 2
It's not the best sci-fi film. It's not even the best Trek film. It's also not the best sci-fi film that deals with the same themes: mortality, our limited amount of time, and what it means to be human, and how our mortality and limited amount of time defines ashuman. But it's pretty good. It features an incredible, sometimes tragic, sometimes heartwarming performance by Patrick Stewart in his most famous role, a haunting performance by screen legend and perennial antagonist Malcolm McDowell, memorable moments of both comedy and tragedy, the score is lovely, and special effects that hold up to this day. Star Trek: Generations on BluRay in 2020 is still visually impressive. There is a lot of craft and a lot of heart that went into this film, but your mileage may vary depending on your expectations, level of obsession over canon, and sentimentality. Generations is perhaps Star Trek's most sentimental film. Not necessarily its most emotional overall, but arguably its most sentimental. During a promotion ceremony, Captain Picard receives a message from Earth. His brother, Robert, and his nephew, René, previously introduced in the famous TNG episode Family, have tragically passed away in a fire, presumably at the Picard family vineyard.
Picard realizes that with the passing of his nephew and his advancing age, there may be no more Picards, and though the series initially presented the captain as someone with little tolerance for children, by the time of the film, he has softened greatly on the matter. With the sudden and unexpected passing of nephew, the closest he had to a child, Picard realizes he, too, wishes to be a father, but that opportunity may have passed him by. Meanwhile, Data, after failing to understand a social situation, opts to insert an emotions chip to allow him to better understand what it is to be human. The Enterprise rescues an El-Aurian named Dr. Soren, who has been trying to re-enter an energy ribbon to another plane of reality called The Nexus. Within the Nexus, the inhabitants do not age, can presumably live forever and be bend their reality to whatever they want. Soren, whose family were taken by the Borg, has adopted a philosophy that since all life is destined to end, the manner in which one dies or how long one dies is irrelevant. Outside the Nexus, nothing matters, but within the Nexus, time – which he calls a predator – has no meaning. [The predator has no teeth.] So convinced of this, Soren is willing to destroy a star, doomed millions on a nearby, to draw the energy ribbon to him. Picard takes the opposite view, that our impermanence is part of what makes us human, and that within the Nexus, nothing matters because it isn't real.
AUDIO 3
Picard's philosophy is tested once he is drawn into the Nexus himself, as the reality manifests itself as a Christmas morning, surrounded by the children he never had. He resists the temptation to stay in the Nexus, reaffirming his beliefs about humanity, meets Captain Kirk, who long ago was trapped within the Nexus, and convinces him to help him defeat Soren and prevent him from destroying the star. Data has a similar crisis of faith, as the humanity he long sought had begun to overwhelm him, his sudden cowardice causing him to nearly lose his best friend, Geordi LaForge. Geordi forgives him, letting Data know that he could not blame him – because he was only behaving like a human. With their respective feelings on humanity further solidified and their related crises of faith resolved, Data, Picard and the entire crew embark on the next stages of their lives. The Enterprise-D was lost in the conflict, but rather than mourn the loss, Picard takes it in stride, stating that unlike Dr. Soren, he believes that we should not fear change, that time is not a predator but a companion that walks along with us on the journey. As a movie, Generations is structured well, its themes both established and explored, its plot set up and paid off. As a piece of Star Trek, it fits neatly within the overall humanist philosophy of the franchise and optimistic view of the future. So...what is everyone's problem with this movie? It may have something to do with the lens in which one watches the film.
Reviews of Generations that focused on the craft of the film tended to be more positive. Carrie Rickey of the Philadelphia Inquirer noted “...John Alonzo's crystaline cinematography.” Jay Boyar of the Orlando Sentinel called it “...cleanly staged.” Positive reviews also noted the acting, such as Stephen Hunter of The Baltimore Sun, who said “The best thing about 'Star Trek Generations' is [Patrick] Stewart, as Captain Picard, and the way the movie allows this powerfully charismatic Englishman to swagger the center and take command of one of America's most cherished fables.” Even negative reviews, such as that of Jonathan Rosenbaum of the Chicago Reader, noted the impressive special effects: “...the special effects and outer space vistas are more handsome than usual. ”But many negative reviews focused on something besides this – the baggage of this being a Star Trek movie. The expectations, the history of the various characters. No film critic – no human being – is an “objective” reviewer.
AUDIO 4
There is no such thing as an “objective” review. Even a movie review written by an artificial intelligence would have the bias of whoever wrote the program and what that person believed was and was not important in judging a movie. It is in no way a failing, only a fact of human nature. Professional film critics know their reviews are not truly “objective” because they know enough about media studies to know that's not possible. It's just that some film critics prefer not to let their personal biases be too public to protect themselves and their work. The only people who think their criticism is “objective” are amateur critics who wish to preserve their opinions as “correct” under the guise of this false objectivity. Film analysis need not be viewed under this pretense of objectivity anyway. That's where film studies come in, the academic umbrella term that deals in various theoretical approaches to film, judging a film as it relates to other films of its genre or judging a film through the particular lens to view its artistic, cultural, economic, and political implications. Film theory is the set of scholarly approaches within film studies. Judging the movie Thelma & Louise exclusively through its craft might tell us that it's a suspenseful, well-acted film, but judging Thelma & Louise through feminist theory might tell us about the culture that made this movie and why their adventure might be significant when viewed through this lens. Star Trek is often judged in academic papers and books through the lens of its economics due to its depiction of a post-capitalist Earth. Star Trek fans, sometimes, view through favorite franchise not through any of these academic theories or even view the franchise as film critics often do, as a judgment on its craft.
Star Trek fans often view Star Trek – and judge Star Trek – exclusively how it relates to Star Trek. More specifically, to Star Trek “canon.” This is not a behavior unique to Star Trek fans, as judging an entry in a popular franchise based on how well it respects the history of the franchise itself is common among fans of Doctor Who, Star Wars and a myriad of other franchises with interrelated television shows, movies, books and other materials that form a narrative canon. Judgments about the behavior of The Doctor's latest incarnation within this lens focuses less on the acting abilities and more on whether or not this behavior is substantiated by hundreds of episodes spanning half a century. Judgments about Luke Skywalker's behavior and demeanor have nothing to do with Mark Hamill's acting range and everything to do with the fact that when audiences last saw the character, he was a much younger and different character. It might seem obvious, even inevitable that a person would change, grow, even regress over the course of decades, but since there are no canonical films or television series that chart this change for the character, the narrow “canon lens” in which Star Wars fans viewed this progression was no different to them than Luke Skywalker drastically changing his behavior and demeanor between scenes. The canon lens is no less “valid” than viewing a piece of media through any other academic theory.
AUDIO 5
Judging a piece of media as it relates to other media within its “genre” is common enough and not remarkably different than judging a piece of media within its franchise. Also, since it's admittedly all subjective, what's even the problem? The canon lens is problematic more with how it's often applied than how it might work on paper. Fans of a franchise might not use this canon lens as a supplement to judging the craft of a film but rather might use this canon lens in place of judging the craft of a film and with no regard for any other theory of film. Canon becomes everything, everything becomes canon. Fans say “This character would never do that!” after watching that character definitely doing that, because the lens in which they are viewing the media focuses on judging the present media on past media, and past media has the benefit of coming first. So, the past media becomes irrefutable, and any attempt to refute it is heresy to canon. [The Sacred Jedi Texts!] Apologists for judging a piece of media as it relates to its canon compare this to the continuity within a single story, a book, an episode, a movie, et cetera. Without continuity or with too many holes in the plot, the story becomes less compelling, too scattershot. However, there is a difference between the internal continuity of a single story and external, canonical franchise continuity. The former can be largely maintained. The latter, given enough time, cannot. The longer the canon exists and the more entries within the canon, the less likely there can be flawless continuity.
There is a difference between a series of plot holes and missing pieces within a single film and something in an episode of an entry in franchise in the year 2020 that contradicts something in an episode in 1966.
Also, not all complaints about canon are actually violations of canon but instead are only violations of a fan's individual expectations. Luke Skywalker being different in The Last Jedi, for example, does not violate canon. It was just unwelcome for some fans, and that's not the same thing, but many fans have come to mistakenly view their expectations as more “canonical” than something that actually is canonical, like the events of the film.
Star Trek fans are notorious for this kind of thinking, favoring this lens as the proper way to view Star Trek. Among these fans, continued discourse on Generations to this day is a prime example. Canon, not craft. Fan service, not filmmaking. One objection to Generations is that Captain Kirk is not “treated well enough” by the film, as if he were a real person and deserving of a better send-off. Someone who does not exist does not “deserve” anything, so what the fans really mean is that they deserve a Captain Kirk story, and since nobody is “owed” something so frivolous, and there is no formal arrangement between writer Ronald D. Moore and millions of individual Star Trek fans, there is no other way of looking at it other than an unearned entitlement. Everyone is allowed to dislike any piece of media, of course, but feeling and declaring a “betrayal” suggests a belief in an arrangement that never existed.
Part of this objection is that after Kirk dies, Picard buries him on the planet rather than contacting some distant relative to recover the body to bury him on Earth. “Doesn't Starfleet have burial protocol and laws about contacting the next of kin?” Under the canon lens, fans object because it does not comport with what they think Kirk “deserves” or what Picard “would have done” – as if what he “would have done” is what they expect of him based on what they observed in other episodes and cannot be violated. Picard did not bury Kirk on the alien planet because it complied with Starfleet regulations that don't actually exist.
AUDIO 6
Picard buried Kirk for filmmaking reasons. Because the close-up of Kirk's badge, the symbol of his duty, makes sense for us to see. Because in the previous scenes, Picard convinces Kirk to resume his duties despite the latter's desire to remain in the Nexus. Because before they leave the Nexus, Kirk is reminded that he strives to “make a difference.” And he did. And that's why we see the badge. Then we see a rotating shot of Picard by the grave, a gorgeous aesthetic. Film is a visual medium, and a scene with Picard placing a badge on the grave as the world continues to turn around him, as life always goes on, is beautiful. He says nothing, but the visuals tell us everything he's feeling. That's just good filmmaking. It would not be good filmmaking for Picard to contact the Enterprise, ask for Kirk's next of kin and wait in the dirt for a few weeks for someone to pick him up.
Star Trek series following The Original Series no longer present planets made of cardboard. These new, non-cardboard planets do not have to be reconciled with canon. These new, non-cardboard planets are a production matter, a filmmaking matter, and the difference need not be explained within canon. Canon critique of Generations is full of stuff like that. Fans object that Picard suddenly wants to be a father, even though he begins The Next Generation telling Riker that he is not comfortable around children. This is not a plot hole. It's a character arc. Although not necessary to appreciate the plot of the film, the series presents Picard initially as someone with no interest in children but later as someone who can tolerate children, such as in the aforementioned episode Family and another episode called Disaster.
AUDIO 7
Picard is eventually presented as someone who may even want children of his own, as hinted at in the famous episode The Inner Light, in which Picard experiences a kind of sci-fi illusion of being a father. By the time of the movie, Picard has softened on the matter, his mind changed – but it's too late. Frankly, even if Picard didn't change his mind about wanting children until Act I of Generations, that does not make the film “bad” or irreconcilable with canon. It's just the beginning of Picard's story in the movie. The implication that it's bad that Picard now wants different things is the byproduct of believing that consistency and unchanging characters is the mark of good storytelling. That's what seeing something through the canon lens does. It only exists in the minds of Star Trek fans who, instead of watching a movie as a movie, are watching an entry into something with decades of baggage attached to it. Imagine watching Raiders of the Lost Ark. Imagine Indiana Jones mentioning Marion Ravenwood, and fans saying “What? Who is this Marion Ravenwood? This is the first time she's been mentioned! How contrived!” Of course it's the first time she's mentioned. There needs to be a first time a character is mentioned. A first time anything is seen or referenced or made aware to the audience. But in Generations, when Picard acknowledges that recent events have made him reconsider wanting to be a father, fans draw on episodes of the series in which Picard has complicated feelings about children, and denounce this revelation as unacceptable and not in keeping with the character.
Picard outwardly acknowledging that he may want a family for the first time is not remarkably different from a character being introduced. It just feels different because the lens of canon is so narrow that it obscures other interpretations of the scene. Picard has tragically lost his family, and his feelings on family and what he wants have now come into focus. Another problem with how the lens of canon is applied is that the viewer sometimes claims to only be dispensing objective facts about what can be readily proven about previous entries in canon, giving the veneer of some kind of impossible objective analysis, but this ignores the subjectivity of the viewer, that the viewer is judging what they deem important in the first place. The viewer has created a series of principles they personally care about – adherence to canon and various pre-existing entries in the franchise – and has overlayed that on the lens in which they are viewing the piece of media. Canon is only important if you have decided it's important. Canon can just as easily be unimportant to someone else's subjective experience and judgment. Star Trek fans who condemn an entry into its franchise for a lack of “respect” for canon always seem to cite the most meaningless minutiae and often cannot interpret said minutiae outside of the lens of canon. Case in point: the final scene in Generations in which Picard picks up and sets down an artifact.
AUDIO 8
The Kurlan Naiskos is an artifact given to Picard by his archaeologist mentor in an episode of The Next Generation. The canon lens complaint about the scene is that Picard trashes the artifact that the series established meant so much to him, but that is not what happened. There is no crashing sound when Picard gently sets down the artifact. Listen. This is the scene. The crashing sound that Trek fans hear is an example of the Mandela effect. They have heard people endlessly going over this scene with the Kurlan Naiskos and how Picard trashed it so many times that this crashing sound is now part of the movie for them. That is not what happened. Picard picked up the artifact and set it back down without damaging it. It lasts 1 and a half seconds, and Star Trek fans still talk about this scene in forums and facebook groups to this day. Then, they counter with “Well, Picard still should have taken it with him. Didn't you see episode 20 of season six, production number 40276-246?” Ugh. OK, first of all, the fact that Picard does not take it with him does not mean it won't be recovered. Picard doesn't take anything with him but his family album, but he owns other things. They are in the midst of a salvage operation. His personal effects will presumably be collected. The fact that we don't see Riker with his trombone in that scene does not mean he left it on the planet forever.
It only means that in this scene, he didn't collect it. Second, and perhaps more importantly, that's not the point. The point is that Picard picks up this priceless artifact and sets it down because that's not what he's looking for. That's not what's important to him. He's looking for his family album. He picks up the one-of-a-kind, immeasurably valuable artifact and discards for the moment because what matters to him is his family. The family album has more meaning to him, more significance. That's the point of the scene. The one thing Picard needs to know is safe is not an artifact – it's his cherished memories of his family. It's so obvious that that's what the movie is trying to convey based on everything else that has happened in the movie prior to this scene, but because of the blinders of the canon lens, some Star Trek fans are instead focused on a prop that appears for less than two seconds. The movie isn't about this. It's about this. The movie is telling us through visual language what matters to Picard, completing his arc about what matters to him, about what it means to be human. Another bonkers complaint about the scene among Star Trek fans is that the family album is in this room and not in the meeting room where the audience last saw it, but that is not a plot hole. The scene in the meeting room is days prior to the scene at the end of the film. At some point, Picard simply took it back to this room where he keeps some of his personal effects. We don't have to see it happen to understand that it did happen.
AUDIO 9
In the beginning of the film, when Picard leaves the holodeck, we next see him on the bridge. We didn't have to watch him walk down the corridors, go into the turbolift, say “Bridge.” and then see him walk out of the turbolift in order for us to understand how he got there. The same is true of the family album. Someone, presumably Picard, put it back among his belongings. Movies are not designed to behave like closed circuit security camera footage that captures everything that happens from various angles, all played at the same time. They operate through film language, and the narrative flows through that visual language. This could go on forever because Trekkies are very adept at nitpicking and spotting phantom plot holes that either do not exist, like the placement of the album, or do not matter, like the speed of a rocket and the distance between the planet and the star. Once again for the people in the back, watching an entry in a long-running franchise with an eye toward how it relates to previously established canon is not some “wrong” way to watch that entry. It's merely problematic in how it's often applied. If the thing you like about Star Trek is the philosophy, then the movie that affirms its overall humanist message is exactly the right Star Trek movie. If the thing you like about Star Trek is minutiae, then this is the wrong Star Trek movie, as it spends little time dwelling on “Trek-no-babble” and far more on abstract and emotional matters.
Star Trek: Generations is pretty good, though admittedly that is only my subjective opinion and experience based on the standards that I have deemed important and unimportant. Please simply bear in mind that the lens in which you are watching a piece of media and the values you have overlayed on this lens may be completely unimportant – even ludicrous – to others.
MIKE PENCE
AUDIO 1
Who is Mike Pence? Is he the devout Catholic who once told a university classmate he was considering the priesthood? Is he, instead, an evangelical who believes that creed is more important than deeds? Is he a scam artist, or a true believer? Is he unwavering in his principles, or is he a political chameleon who changes depending on his surroundings? Mike Pence never had much difficulty telling others who he was. He would say “I am a Christian, a conservative, and a Republican, in that order.” Does that give his audiences a firm understanding of who he is? “Christian” and “Republican” can be found on hospital forms, a census, the superficiality of information under a yearbook picture. People who know him claim he is “nice” – but that word, usually describing demeanor, tells us little about his beliefs, his morals, his goals. “Nice” may be called into question when one considers the policies that Mike Pence pushes forward, and the company he keeps. If Pence is “nice,” then he's “Indiana nice” – smiling while repressing true intentions. What is his true intention? What is his ultimate goal in life? Pence's mother Nancy once described her son to the Chattanooga Times Free Press: “He's a very kind, thoughtful, very Christian man. What you see is what you get. That's exactly who he is. He has no airs, no pretensions. He's a simple, God-fearing man." A mother's love notwithstanding, “simple” and “no pretensions” are not good descriptors of someone with the highest ambitions and the highest opinion of oneself.
Based on people who once knew him and currently know him, based on everything he has said and done in the public record, based on his ambitions and his professed beliefs, he is a man who believes that God's plan is for Mike Pence to be the President of the United States of America. Whether Pence was lead to this belief in a moment of thoughtful prayer or if he simply always had ambition, an insecurity that needed massaging, and God was simply the excuse to lionize this insecurity, there may be no way to tell. That's a question for a personal psychologist, who Pence would almost certainly never hire. An investigation of his life from an outsider's perspective does seem to paint the picture of someone who bows to authority in hopes of gaining authority himself. When he was a radio show host and television host in Indiana, journalists and onlookers noted the bending-over-backwards manner in which he spoke to more powerful guests, earning not only radio and television advertising dollars but influence among those in authority. When he was a Congressman, he ran for minority House leader and lost, but this was widely understood to be done as a favor to the actual minority leader so that it would look like a contest and not a coronation. Pence threw the fight to gain favor with his superiors. And now, as Vice President, Pence is considered a sycophant by his peers and among people who once mistakenly respected him. But this is all in service to God's plan.
AUDIO 2
“How could I be wrong,” he might think, “if this is what God wants?” Pence wants to be President whether it's God's will or not, and he has slowly positioned himself for that office over the course of his life. [I. Mike Pence the Boy] Michael Richard Pence was born on June 7, 1959, one of six children in a Catholic family. He did not speak until he was three years old. His parents operated a number of gas stations, and he grew up in a comfortable, well-to-do, middle class home. When Pence was seven years old, he walked the runway at the Crump Theatre in Indiana, modeling outfits for the Tempo department store spring fashion show. In middle school, he was a champion in the debate club, giving him the early skills he would need to later obfuscate facts from reporters, often beginning his statements with “Let me be clear,” and then being anything but. As a teenager, Pence's father connected him with a business associate, John Rumple, the head of the local Democratic Party. Pence worked as a youth coordinator for a local Democrat running for judge. Pence would not become a Republican until his mid-20's. In order to give himself a “common man” character to voters, he would later remark on his childhood days as challenging, recollecting being significantly overweight and unpopular, but by the time he was in high school, that turned around. Pictures and records from that time suggest Pence was a good-looking young man and child fashion model from a prominent family in the community.
He told reporters about the cornfield in his backyard to apply that same “common man” characterization, and while the cornfield existed, it did not tell the whole truth. Pence grew up in the city’s newest subdivision, built for Columbus, Indiana's booming manufacturing industry. The Pences may have had corn in their backyard, but they were also a rising business family living in the suburbs. The corn may have been there, but he was no farmer. Pence was both an athlete and class president. He began to tell classmates that he may run for President of the United States one day, the first recorded instance of Pence's ultimate political ambition. When he attended Hanover College, he was a member of the Phi Gamma Delta fraternity. When the associate dean surprised them with a visit, the brothers hid their alcohol and evidence of partying while Pence was chosen to greet him at the door. Instead of covering for his sworn brothers, he ratted them out, perhaps in hopes of gaining the associate dean's favor. He did, as this may have been helpful in Pence gaining employment with the college following graduation. In an interview with The Atlantic, Pence's classmate, Daniel Murphy, said this of the incident: “They really raked us over the coals. ...Somewhere in the midst of all that genuine humility and good feeling, this is a guy who’s got that ambition. Is Mike’s religiosity a way of justifying that ambition to himself?”
AUDIO 3
Pence's conversion from Catholicism to Evangelicalism is shrouded in mystery. Pence is always careful not to reveal too much of himself to the press or else the facade of the “simple” man with “no pretensions” might be torn down, revealing his ambition. Michael D'Antonio and Peter Eisner, authors of The Shadow President: The Truth about Mike Pence, suspected it had something to do with a college trip to a Christian music festival called Ichthus. “At Ichthus, Pence heard conservative Christianity’s answer to pop rock and folk music.… For a young Catholic who had, no doubt, heard some awful guitar masses growing up in the 1960s, the Christian music at Ichthus would have been a revelation of sorts. Evangelical acts of the time played loud and sang with emotion. Many of the musicians poured the drama and struggle of their lives into their lyrics.… Pence was moved by what he heard and saw...” A more cynical but perhaps more realistic interpretation of Pence straddling the line between Catholic and Protestant is that his future constituents were mostly Protestants with Catholics a sizable but still distant second. Pence would sometimes call himself an “Evangelical Catholic,” perhaps to gain support from both denominations. As Catholics are less likely to vote for Republicans than Evangelical Protestants, Pence's religious conversion was also a political conversion, eventually registering as a Republican and running for office. However, his straddling the fence did not initially pay off. [II. Mike Pence the Failure]
Pence graduated from Hanover College in the spring of 1981. He delivered the student address and shared the stage with President Ronald Reagan’s national security adviser, Richard Allen, who delivered the commencement address. In 1985 and 1986, Pence set his sights firmly on politics, working as a protege to William Harvey, who had famously mentored Vice President Dan Quayle.
One might think Pence was on the right track to become a successful politician, but his early political career was full of failures. His first public embarrassment was his doomed 1988 campaign for the House of Representatives, seeking to unseat Democratic Congressman Phil Sharp. When the chairman of the Indiana Republicans selected Pence to run in the Second District, he did not actually live in the district and had to buy a house there to make everything legal. Pence criticized Sharp for taking money from political action committees and vowed never to use them.
AUDIO 4
This was not a principled stance, as his wealthy supporters gave him more than $425,000, roughly the same that Sharp had. Far worse optics than that, Pence repeatedly missed the filing deadline to report this fundraising. When he finally did submit his papers to state and federal officials, they were full of errors. His 1988 campaign was the first sign that Mike Pence was to become the leading anti-abortion politician in the United States. His campaigned to outlaw abortion whereas Congressman Sharp was pro-choice. This would become one of Pence's key issues throughout his career, but in a race doomed to fail against a popular Congressman, with no profile and no record to speak of, Pence did not yet attract enough of the Christian right to help bolster his chances of winning. With his back against the wall, Pence's campaign made their own version of the “Willie Horton” ad, a commercial and a print ad version, both with a razor blade, a rolled-up dollar bill, lines of white powder. Red letters bled over the picture, declaring, “There’s something Phil Sharp isn’t telling you about his record on drugs.” followed by “It’s weak” written in powder. Pence's fear-mongering to suburban families was still not enough, as he was soundly defeated by Sharp come election day. Undaunted, Pence desired a rematch with Sharp in 1990, but if he was going to follow God's path to the presidency, he was going to have to make some deals with the Devil.
Pence put together contacts and supporters – a who's who of the worst of the worst. In the summer of 1989, Pence went to Washington to meet with Lee Atwater, then chairman of the Republican Party and the mind behind the aforementioned Willie Horton ad and the white southern strategy for the party. Famous for racist attack ads. Tim LaHaye, founder of the Council for National Policy and co-author of the infamous Left Behind series of novels. LaHaye was in favor of Dominionism, a policy of changing the United States into an explicitly Christian nation under Christian law. Richard DeVos, a billionaire who funds right-wing candidates and particularly those who oppose marriage equality. He was also appointed by Ronald Reagan to work with the Commission on the HIV Epidemic. Reagan dragged his heels on AIDS, making the appointment of a virulently anti-gay Republican to the commission no real surprise. Pence also cozied up to the Family Research Council, an activist organization that opposes abortion and gay rights. It is listed as a hate group by the Southern Poverty Law Center. And finally, Pence tied himself to the Koch Brothers, who were not motivated by religion but solely by profits. The Koch Brothers funded right-wing think tanks to spread climate change denial and paid Republican politicians to keep their taxes low. With the Kochs and the rest at his side, Pence had put together a dream team of powerful Republicans who could take on Phil Sharpe in the 1990 election.
AUDIO 5
He lost again. Part of his failure came through scandal. Pence created two campaign organizations to accept donations. One was a garden variety political nonprofit. ordinary nonprofit. The other was set up as a business that was able to take out loans and make payments. Reporters found that this “business” made payments on Pence’s personal credit cards, house mortgage, car payments, groceries, and like all American politicians, rounds of golf. When confronted, Pence snapped, saying “I need to make a living!” Pence tried every dirty trick in the book to dig himself out of the scandal and go on the offensive, including an attack ad featuring a man dressed up as a Arab thanking Phil Sharp for his support, but it wasn't enough. Pence, a disgraced, political failure, had no choice but to seek employment elsewhere. [III. Mike Pence the Politician Turned Celebrity Turned Politician] After making connections with the Heritage Foundation other conservative groups, Pence was poised to bring his variety of bland, right-wing Christianity to the people in a new way: media. Mike Pence was offered a broadcasting position at WXIR, a small station owned by the American Bible Radio Group. He soon moved on to a bigger station that gave him a weekly show, and by 1994, The Mike Pence broadcast daily across much of Indiana.
He focused on abortion, teen pregnancy, women in the military, divorce and adultery. Pence's even-tempered, stone-faced grimace of later years had not yet taken shape, as he was a lot more animated on the radio and later television. Pence was particularly incensed by the Disney movie Mulan because it suggested that women could perform the same actions as a man, including armed service. Pence's interpretation of the relationship between men and women comes directly from the Bible. “Ephesians 5:23 - For the husband is the head of the wife, even as Christ is the head of the church: and he is the savior of the body.” Pence had remade himself. After years of claiming that he no longer had any political ambitions, Mike Pence filed his papers in the summer of 1999 to run for Congress once again. Armed with even more right-wing groups, think tanks, Koch brothers money and state-wide notoriety due to his celebrity, he was finally ready to not fail.
AUDIO 6
Again, from The Shadow President: “Candidates generally insist that their political positions and votes are not for sale and that people who fund their campaigns are simply backing the one who already supports their priorities. No one in politics believes this is true, which is why, in 1988 and 1990, Pence made a big deal out of Phil Sharp’s habit of accepting donations from political action committees. Everyone knows that committees and individuals give to gain access and influence. Pence’s first campaigns were funded mainly by businesspeople—many from local industries like Cummins Engine—who had their own interests, but they were harder to discern than the goals of a PAC named for a labor group, a commercial association, or policy priority. Nevertheless, the donors would make their wishes clear, and it would be understood that future support depended on performance. After nearly a decade of making connections as Radio Mike, Pence knew the big players who could give and also connect him to others who would make donations.” Pence's campaign called for abortion to be outlawed, heterosexual couples to be favored over same-sex couples, removal of any funds to AIDS groups that, in his words, “celebrate” homosexuality, and a ban on same-sex marriage across the country, even though at that point, only one state allowed civil unions and not marriage. Pence also called for federal funds to be devoted to groups dedicated to changing the “behavior” of gay people.
Pence had become even more extreme in his time away from politics. Nevertheless, with help from the Koch brothers and other right-wing groups, Mike Pence had finally become a political success. He won the election in 2000, and in January 2001, he was sworn in as a Congressman. Pence supported the disastrous War in Iraq, as virtually all Republicans and many Democrats did, but Pence's key issues were related to his Christianity, particularly his anti-gay policies. Pence voted against the Employment Non-Discrimination Act (ENDA), which would have prohibited discrimination in employment based on sexual orientation or gender identity. He also opposed the repeal of Don't Ask, Don't Tell. Pence had become the superstar of the Christian Right. He finally figured out his place in the world. Espousing right-wing Christian values to gain favor with Christian who believed their way of life was “under attack” – all the while funded by anti-tax, right-libertarian groups to pay lip service to their causes from time to time. Pence was never going to be a Grover Norquist, someone whose focus was entirely on promoting big business interests and shrinking the government so that said businesses could get away with anything.
AUDIO 7
But Pence was still bought by those organizations and business interests, and he would reliably vote in favor of them in between his speeches warning about the encroaching threat of the gays. Pence's star had risen so much So much that he considered running for president in 2012. However, after much consideration, he must have realized that going from Congressman directly to President would have failed. Only one US President had made that jump before. Generally, Presidents who were once Congressman did something in between – Senator, Vice President...or Governor. [IV. Mike Pence the Christian Conservative Superstar] While Pence was campaigning for Governor in 2012, his policies on abortion somehow became even more extreme. One anti-abortion measure would have required that all women undergoing abortion be shown ultrasound images of the embryo or fetus and hear a description of its condition before the procedure. The proposal failed, but Pence used these issues to galvanize his base in the Christian right. It worked, and Pence was elected governor on the strength of his “convictions.” In late 2014 and early 2015, doctors and public officials determined that there had been a sudden rise in drug overdoses along with a rise in HIV infection.
The Center for Disease Control and local officials asked Governor Pence for permission to distribute clean needles to addicts. By law, needles could only be obtained by prescription and otherwise were considered illegal drug paraphernalia. Pence refused, and the outbreak grew and grew, costing the lives and health of many of his constituents. Pence, like many Christian conservatives, considered HIV infection and drug addiction moral failings rather than public health concerns. After months of inaction, Pence claimed he would “pray” on it and eventually relented when public outcry was against him. By that point, however, over 100 new HIV cases had arisen. Pence signaled that he would soon end the new rules allowing needles, so the Indiana legislature overruled him and passed a law making this new permission permanent. In 2015, backed by Pence, conservatives in the Indiana state legislature proposed a new law, the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA). It allowed for the people of Indiana to discriminate against their fellow Hoosiers on religious grounds. RFRA was a thinly-veiled anti-gay law, but the language was so broad that it protected discrimination against anyone, so long as they claimed they were doing so because of their faith. This law was so extreme and so flagrantly unconstitutional that governors in many states enacted travel bans to Indiana, and many businesses and sports organizations refused to do business in the state.
AUDIO 8
Only under this mounting pressure did Pence and the legislature reverse course on RFRA. Pence still had his sights set on the White House – God's plan – and his rising unpopularity could have undone all that. Only a year later, Pence moved on step closer, as he was tapped by Donald Trump to be his running in the 2016 presidential election. Pence helped shore up support from Christian conservatives and evangelicals specifically who had some doubts about the twice-divorced, adulterous, scandalous reality show host. During Trump's Access Hollywood scandal, Pence privately offered to replace Trump on the ticket. The Republican Party, having no mechanism to do that so late in the campaign, stuck with Trump. Pence later denied this attempted coup, but he was not widely believed. Following the election victory, Pence was not only the Vice President-elect but the head of the transition team. That meant it was Pence was decided on most of Trump's cabinet. Pence looked into his rolodex and primarily chose his political cronies and far-right Indiana mainstays to fill up the administration. Pence chose Tom Price, an anti-abortion and anti-medicare politician, to be Secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services. When Price resigned in scandal, he was replaced by Alex Azar, a businessman from Indiana and fellow anti-abortion activist.
Pence chose Betsy DeVos to head the Department of Education. DeVos and her family had long been donors to Pence's campaigns. DeVos has consistently sided against victims of sexual assault on campuses, has spent millions of education privatization schemes, and has virtually no background in education. Jerome Adams, Pence's former Indiana state health commissioner, became the US Surgeon General. Adams had previously defended Pence during his HIV scandal. Dan Coats, Pence’s friend and former US Senator from Indiana, was named Director of National Intelligence. Many of the scandals and frequent turnaround in cabinet positions during the Trump administration are related to Mike Pence's cronyism and choices of unqualified businessmen and conservative activists for the highest offices in the nation. The Vice President has a limited amount of power on paper, but the President can give the Vice President more responsibilities, and President Trump has done that for Pence. In his tenure as Vice President, Mike Pence earned a reputation for being a sycophant and for enabling Trump. Most recently, he was named the head of the effort to combat coronavirus. During this short stint, he refused to wear a mask during his visit to a hospital, refused to self-quarantine after his staffers tested positive, and shortly thereafter, the task force announced it was disbanding, despite no progress being made. [V. Mike Pence ...President?] Ideally, there should no President.
AUDIO 9
The fact that a single person holds so much power and is nearly impervious to being recalled outside of an election only every four years is antithetical to democracy...but that might be a topic for another day. Nevertheless, there is going to be an election this year, and unless the system collapses or is overthrown, there will be one in 2024.Mike Pence believes he was chosen by God to be President of the United States. He will almost certainly run for President in 2024. If Trump is re-elected in 2020, the victory will be shared with Pence, giving him more credibility in 2024. Another way Pence could ascend the presidency is if Trump steps down or dies in office, something that has happened nine previous times in the history of the United States. In total, fourteen vice presidents have become president one way or another. Then vice president George H.W. Bush was elected president. Being vice president may not be a glorious position, but it does have a history of leading to the presidency. If the Trump-Pence ticket loses in 2020, this may hurt Pence's argument for electability and damage his reputation enough that he won't run or at least won't win if he does. He could win, and that might be worst case scenario for the United States of America.
There are a handful of Republican politicians nearly as extreme or slightly more extreme than Mike Pence, but none of them are in any position to make a successful run for the White House. Pence is an extremist, but he is able to smile calmly when espousing his far-right beliefs whereas many extremists are louder, more confrontational, and therefore unpopular outside their base. Pence has a shot, and as this year's Democratic primary has shown, sometimes the well-known Vice President is chosen by the establishment on name recognition alone. Americans sometimes underestimate how much power the President has. This may have something to do with social studies classes that claim that the three branches of the federal government are “co-equal” – but the President has a preposterous, unacceptable amount of power. The President is commander-in-chief, and in the 21stcentury, that power cannot be easily tempered by Congress due to a series of laws passed in 2001 and 2002. The president can choose the heads of every federal department, can influence federal policy in every federal department, can sign far-reaching executive orders that override the legislature, and nothing can be passed in said legislature unless it has so much bipartisan support that it can override a presidential veto. These days, bipartisan support is so rare that this contentiousness has the byproduct of granting the president that much more power due to the veto. No bipartisan support means the veto is absolute. The president is absolute. Now imagine all that concentrated power wielded by a man who believes he was chosen by God to sit in the Oval Office. That everything he believes is right, and that everything he does is divinely ordained. A president Mike Pence is the worst scenario for the United States, and with Joe Biden as the last hope to damage Pence's reputation by beating the Trump-Pence ticket in November, the worst case scenario may yet come to pass.