Update and scripts! (Patreon)
Content
Hi, everyone! Just a quick update to let you know I am working on a big project related to the impeachment trial and the Republican Party in general. It's going to be at least twice as long as the average 20 minute episode but more likely three times as long. Expect it around the turn of the month. I want to do more big projects going forward. Once I can travel again, I'm planning on filming more episodes on location like I did with No More Presidents.
With that said, here are some scripts to some previous episodes:
BOB'S BURGERS
[Roseanne] A sitcom needs to be relatable, its characters familiar, as a television is a commitment of several years of the audience's life. A sitcom often mirrors the lives of the audience, and because of this, the characters are often members of the lower economic classes – waged or salaried laborers, those performing essential duties while on the low rung on the ladder. [All in the Family] Some sitcoms in which class is featured lean in heavily on the social concerns of the lower classes more than the economic concerns. [King of Queens] And some barely mention either. [Everybody Loves Chris] The series that do reference economic concerns do so at their own risk, as poverty is not inherently comical. [Married...with Children] Married...with Children was the rare sitcom that frequently referenced the family's poverty but often blamed the Bundy family's circumstances on the fact that Al married Peg, on customers making Al's occupation as shoe salesman so painful, and at least in one case, on a curse. [Home Improvement] Home Improvement had the flavor of a working class series but without the economic concerns. Tim fancied himself a “man's man” blue collar hero, bathed in a romanticized laborer's masculinity while maintaining local celebrity status and a house in the suburbs. [The Simpsons] The Simpsons only glibly mention the family's occasional economic concerns, often to the point of parody in which Homer is able to land many different occupations – some of them high-paying – over the course of the series' now infinite run.
[Family Matters] Some working class television series have the relatable family patriarch as a police officer, [Mike and Molly] which muddies the waters of class conflict further. [Sanford and Son] Sitcoms balance relatability with aspiration. Characters need to have enough in common with the audience for them to relate to them [Taxi] but not so much that the audience's stresses and concerns play out with too much familiarity on the television screen. Sitcoms traffic in comedy, and poverty is not funny. [Bob's Burgers] And then there's Bob's Burgers, a long-running television comedy in which virtually everything that happens is seen through the lens of the family's ongoing economic concerns. The series stars Bob Belcher, the owner of Bob's Burgers, an unsuccessful burger restaurant or “slop shop” as the children mockingly declare, Linda, the wife of Bob and unpaid worker at the restaurant, and their children, Tina, Gene and Louise, all three unpaid workers at the restaurant where they work after school. It is unclear exactly how much money Bob makes, the expenses of the Bob's Burgers, the expenses of three children, and the cost of the rent in the apartment above Bob's Burgers, but the series makes it clear in almost all of its 194 episodes that the restaurant is not popular, the family is constantly behind on bills, always late on paying the rent, and unable to provide much for their children. While many comedies shy away from this, Bob's Burgers consistently references the family's poverty.
AUDIO 2
The series actually uses the word “poor” on a regular basis, anathema in sitcoms. In addition to these references, episodes often center around Bob trying to dig his family out of poverty or trapped in situations caused by their poverty. In season one, episode six, Bob takes a second job as a cab driver at night while working in the restaurant during the day. In season one, episode seven, Linda turns their cramped apartment into a bed and breakfast. In season one, episode twelve, Bob laments that his burger restaurant is struggling because he lives in a seafood town that hails the annual Lobster Fest as its biggest event. The series often references movies that have working class economic concerns such as season two, episode one, which recounts the events of The Goonies, or season two, episode two, which recounts the events of Dog Day Afternoon. Bob's efforts to increase traffic to his restaurant often blow up in his face, such as in season two, episode four, in which Bob buys an arcade game that eventually mocks him in his own restaurant. Or in season two, episode five, in which Bob buys the cheapest vehicle possible to supplement his income with a food truck. These are only a few examples and only in the first two of the series' ten seasons so far. In addition, most of the family's rivalries and personal relationships are shaped through class. Tina's primary rival throughout the series is Tammy, a popular girl who transferred to Wagstaff School in season two, episode eight.
Tammy is spoiled and is a bad influence on Tina, but the conflict is more of that of personality than class until season four, episode thirteen, in which Tammy refuses to invite Tina to her elaborate and expensive bot-mitzvah. Louise convinces the party planner to no longer be Tammy's subject, and Tina steps in, takes over the party, and makes it more fun for everyone while Tammy is stuck in a giant representation of her own head towering above the party-goers – the imagery is not subtle. Tammy is, perhaps, not as rich as she believes herself to be, as season six, episode ten reveals that her parents must have lied to her about Wagstaff being a private school when it is, in fact, a public school. Tina's most notable relationship is with Jimmy Junior, the son of Jimmy Pesto, Bob's most immediate economic rival. Jimmy Pesto is the owner of an Italian restaurant across the street. Bob is simple, honest, and poor whereas Jimmy Pesto is flashy, dishonest and successful. Jimmy is not actually Italian but changed his name to fool his customers about the authenticity of his restaurant. Jimmy is not rich, but his restaurant is successful, placing him in the middle class or perhaps even upper middle as a business owner with real paid workers. Jimmy consistently mocks Bob through classist insults about their comparative levels of success and the family's poverty.
AUDIO 3
Bob's Burgers confronts the myth of meritocracy. Many episodes remark on the fact that Bob makes excellent burgers at affordable prices. Season five, episode five shows how much craft Bob puts into his work, competing for the title of best burger. World famous chef Skip Larouche even recommends Bob's Burgers to a magazine called Coasters for a spotlight piece on his food. However, Bob is consistently outclassed by Jimmy Pesto, who uses low quality horse meat, mostly uses frozen food instead of fresh food, and doesn't know nearly as much about food preparation as Bob. Another rival who is shaped through class is Randy, a filmmaker who first threatens to put Bob out of business for serving hamburgers, then rivals Bob with a successful food truck, and is generally a thorn in Bob's side. Randy is a “trust fund kid” and failson of some unexplained fortune. Yet another antagonist shaped through class is Helen, a woman who inherited wealth when her husband passed away under mysterious circumstances. She is introduced in season five, episode nineteen and then reappears in season nine, episode twelve, in which the children compete with her over a missing valuable. Bob does not maintain many friendships, devoting nearly his entire life to his family and his restaurant. However, his best customer, a working class laborer named Teddy, forms a bond with Bob which is only sometimes reciprocated.
Teddy is a self-employed handyman, and Bob is a small business owner with no hired workers, at least none on the books. Bob and Teddy don't have much in common, but this shared lifestyle will always mean Bob will have more in common with Teddy than with, say, Randy. Bob's Burgers frequently portrays the police as either incompetent or actively harmful to the communities they are presumably instructed to protect. In season one, episode five, the police are represented by two officers who pass by the restaurant as it's being robbed, and then fail to go after him when he robs the restaurant again. By season two, these officers are gone, and the face of the police is Sgt. Bosco. In the aforementioned bank robbery hostage episode, Bosco fires on the bank several times, despite the fact that it puts Bob and the other hostages at risk. The robber, Mickey, is not violent, but poor. After Mickey is arrested and eventually released, he becomes a friend of the family and later gains employment at the Wonder Wharf. Again, Bob and Mickey have little in common, but their shared class fosters solidarity. Class shapes every relationship in the series.
AUDIO 4
In addition to this, class shapes the episodes, though some are more overt than others. In season four, episode fifteen, Tina, Gene, Louise and their friend Regular-Sized Rudy are locked in the back of a train for wine connoisseurs. Unwilling to accept their status as second class citizens, they plan to rob the train of its chocolate. In season six, episode eleven, Tina, Gene, Louise, Regular-Sized Rudy and a few of their friends ask to share the bounce castle with the wealthy birthday girl. She rebuffs them, and they seize the bounce castle for themselves. Season seven, episode seventeen revolves around Bob and Linda winning a contest to take part in an elaborate LARP of the show's Downton Abbey proxy. Their roles are assigned at random, and Bob and Linda are given the parts of servants while other guests are given the parts of the wealthy, a nod to being born into one's economic circumstances. Bob is tempted by the wealthy LARP'ers into being a class traitor, but he eventually sides with Linda and her revolt against those who were assigned wealth. Linda learns a valuable lesson. In season nine, episode three, Tina, Gene and Louise join a school extracurricular in which they create a small business selling wooden figures. Tammy, Jocelyn and Jimmy Junior nonchalantly take power and assign themselves the roles of management, doing comparatively little work but gaining far more rewards than labor. Tina initially sides with management until she realizes what this is doing to her siblings and to Regular-Sized Rudy.
When labor recognizes the unfair power dynamics, they fight back, eventually making the small business collectively owned and operated among all workers. These are only a few examples. More than anything else in the series, the class conflict is highlighted most by Mr. Fishoeder, the landlord, and the richest man in town. Rent-seeking is as unjustified as leeching the profits of labor from the workers. Mr. Fishoeder is not just the antagonist of one episode but the primary antagonist of the series – positioning class conflict as an inescapable aspect of every episode of Bob's Burgers regardless of whether or not Mr. Fishoeder appears or not because the Belchers are always living and working in their rented property. A rental property is not simply something someone owns that others want to buy – it is something someone privately owns that the entire community needs to live and that he cannot realistically use or need all on his own. Rent is inherently exploitative. The series humanizes Fishoeder from time to time, but the belief that rent is exploitation is not a personal jab at individual landlords but a condemnation of the practice. Whether or not Fishoeder is a “nice” guy is irrelevant, though the series clearly frames him as, at best, aloof, and at worst, uncaring and conniving. In season one, episode thirteen, Fishoeder shows Bob that the games he owns at Wonder Wharf can almost never be won, allegorical for the promise of wealth to the lower classes that historically is incredibly difficult to attain.
AUDIO 5
Bob's Burgers highlights the exploitation between landlord and tenant in various episodes in which he has the Belchers perform unusual tasks for him in exchange for leniency on their often late rent payments. This is not generous on the part of Fishoeder. If the Belchers can't pay their rent, they are out on the street. It is an ultimatum that the Belchers must agree to, and Fishoeder recognizes that. The Belchers are poor and have no choice but to cooperate, which is the unequal, exploitative relationship between all landlords and their tenants. For example, in season three, episode five, the Belchers pretend to be Fishoeder's family so that he can woo an old flame who is attracted to married men. This is particularly humiliating for Bob, who must pretend to be Fishoeder's personal chef – not to mention he must watch his wife Linda kiss Mr. Fishoeder to make the act more convincing. In season seven, episode seven, Mr. Fishoeder tempts Bob with leniency on his rent if he helps him cheat at a contest. Class conflict is perhaps most overt in season five, episode twenty-one in which Mr. Fishoeder threatens to raise the rent on much of the town. Bob organizes a rent strike and marches to Fishoeder's mansion. Fishoeder does what those with power and wealth always do: divide the working class against itself. He organizes a water balloon fight with the winner receiving several months free rent and the losers suffering through the raised rent. The town briefly goes along with it – basically, capitalism brain.
The idea that instead of organizing to avoid being exploited, focusing on the extremely unlikely chance of becoming the exploiter. In the end, the town recognizes this, organizes against Mr. Fishoeder, and Bob convinces him to keep the rent as is. A small victory. Bob's Burgers has a lot of humanity to it, a lot of talk of the common good, rarely punching down, fairly inclusive, and largely avoids the faux “edginess” that has plagued other animated comedies and has engendered unpleasant fanbases. Faux “edginess” is not bold. Bob's Burgers isbold because it has the audacity to talk about concerns of the poor in a way that does not shy away from that word and does not shy away from who maintains economic disparity. That may or may not be the goal of the series or the intention of the writers – but in an effort to make the series relatable, it has done just that.
VOYAGER
Star Trek: Voyager is the story of a starship flung across the galaxy. Two crews – one the upstanding Starfleet and the other the rebellious Maquis – join together to find their way home. Voyager debuted in January 1995, in the midst of a golden era of the franchise. Star Trek is often divided into “eras” – never officially and more as shorthand for fans. Trek fans consider The Original Series and The Animated Series as the early era of Trek, the original cast movies as its own era, and so forth. If you ask Star Trek fans what the “best era” of Trek was, they will probably say the time between the late 80's through the turn of the century when The Next Generation, Deep Space Nine and Voyager were on the air. They may or may not count Enterprise among its era considering how different it was from the rest. For a long time, The Next Generation and Deep Space Nine were heralded as the best of this era, and with good reason. The Next Generation was iconic, and Deep Space Nine was a kind of precursor to the “peak television” style of writing in which there were season-long arcs – completely unheard of in Star Trek prior to this. Voyager was often considered “lesser Trek” by the nerdy faithful, or even just flat-out bad. My observations about Trek fandom comes from everything from late 90's Trek message boards through modern day facebook fan pages. If your experiences with the fandom are different, that's OK. Our experiences are not universal. This general consensus of Voyager being lesser Trek has been challenged in recent years by new Star Trek fans.
According to Netflix data, Star Trek: Voyager episodes are re-watched more than any other Trek. IMDB user ratings for Star Trek episodes show before Voyager average at 7.466 for The Original Series, 7.400 for The Next Generation, 7.586 for Deep Space Nine, and 7.471 for Voyager. That's approximately the same as TOS and TNG, and just below DS9. I don't think a bunch of numbers can determine some “objective” ranking of quality – that's nonsense – but these numbers do seem to indicate that a lot more people love Star Trek: Voyager than the uber-nerds of the 90's believed or at least indicate that those feelings have broadly changed. A lot of people are re-watching Voyager or watching Voyager for the first time on Netflix, Hulu, Amazon, and CBS All Access and thinking “Is this...good?” I would argue, yes, it is, and before anyone jumps up and says “In your opinion!” like, yeah, I know. My “Actually” titles are facetious, not a declaration of some impossible objectivity. Voyager is just a show I like, and it would be amazing if we could all just chill. Now, with that out of the way, why do I sing the praises of Star Trek: Voyager? It's not my favorite Trek, that's Deep Space Nine. But what is it about thisseries that makes it worth watching? To answer that, we actually need to explore the characters.
[I. HARRY KIM]
AUDIO 2
Eager young space cadet, operations officer and verified snack Harry Kim. In Trek fan circles, Ensign Kim is sometimes seen as a “disappointing” character who never lived up to his potential. Forever trapped in his rank aboard a starship with little room for upward mobility, Kim is a bridge officer and senior staff officer and at the same time forever saddled with a rank that makes everyone look at him as if he is forever falling off the turnip truck. [As you rise through the ranks...] Oh, Captain. Don't toy with him. Kim works best when paired with someone because his personality is otherwise confined to being sincere, officious, and shy, but it is in these relationships where Kim shines brightest. His closest friendship is with Tom Paris right from the beginning. We're introduced to Kim in Quark's Bar in Deep Space Nine. Quark is attempting to sell him some lovely stones that are not worth all that much, and Kim, newly made an ensign says “We were warned about Ferengi at Starfleet Academy.” – racist. Quark is rightly offended, but Paris swoops in with his big, dumb chin and convinces Kim to not buy from Quark, repeating Kim's line about the dangers of Ferengi – racist. From then on, Kim and Paris are inseparable, playing games on the holodeck, courting the Delaney sisters.
The friendship is one of the highlights of the entire series. Season three, episode three, “The Chute” features Paris and Kim unjustly convicted. A “clamp” that functions as a torture device is implanted in both of their heads. The psychological and neurological damage causes them to turn on each other, but Kim eventually regains control and defends Paris until they are able to escape, leading to this touching scene. […] In the early seasons, Kim has a strong friendship with B'Ellana Torres stemming from their shared incarceration by the Ocampa. She calls him “Starfleet.” and he calls her “Maquis.” – nicknames that stick through the early seasons. Kim is the by-the-book Starfleet ensign, and Torres is the hot-tempered Maquis who does things her own way. The duo becomes more of a trio of friends which includes Paris and then Kim becomes more of a third wheel once Paris and Torres get together. Nevertheless, the early interactions between Kim and Torres are great, and their unlikely friendship is one of the strong parts of the first two seasons. Kim's relationship with Seven of Nine starts as a crush, then forms naturally into a friendship based on mutual respect. [“Earth won't be the same without you.”] Episodes that focus solely on Kim are a mixed bag. Season one, episode nine, “Emanations” is arguably Kim's first starring role, but he is such a passive entity in it.
AUDIO 3
Season two, episode five, “Non-Sequitur” is the next time Kim gets his own episode, and it's easily among his best. Kim wakes up in San Francisco with no idea how he got there or what happened to Voyager, and his determination is the first time we get to see Kim get tough. It's also just a compelling story and favorite among the early seasons. Kim does not get another starring episode until season three, episode twenty, “Favorite Son” where he's stranded on a planet of women, and it's not – great?
Harry working best as a companion to other characters might seem like a failing, as if he is not engaging enough to hold an episode on his own, but it could be argued that this aspect of his character actually reveals he's simply a very likable character and watching him play off other characters is Kim being utilized well. He does get major roles in some classic episodes like “Timeless” and “Demon” – where he gets to say this. [Need I remind you, Ensign, that there is no atmosphere more inhospitable to humanoids than a Class Y. No, Tuvok, you needn't remind me.] In season seven, episode eight, “Nightingale” we get to see Kim take a leadership position, which really should have happened earlier in the series, but better late than never. Kim is perpetually embarrassed by his parents, a hopeless romantic, and a loyal friend, all qualities that make him relatable. Also, he toots. He toots real good. Harry Kim for Captain of Voyager in a revived series, please.
[II. CHAKOTAY] Chakotay is the first officer of Voyager, former Maquis rebel, and also just kind of a low-key hunk, right? Sexy in an understated sorta way. [Big strapping man like yourself.] [Is it the tattoo? Because mine's bigger.] In the first two seasons of Voyager, Chakotay is the conscience of the ship. [Time and Again] Always giving sound advice and guidance about respecting local cultures and traditions – not disturbing burial sites and such. His conscience is what made him join the Maquis, resigning from Starfleet under moral objections. Chakotay is an anthropologist at heart, helps the crew through spiritual matters, and in his spare time, he likes to box. He's a well-rounded character with a rich backstory, and it's a real shame that after season three, he takes a backseat to a lot of the cast. But early on, Chakotay had a much larger role. The fans who think that the series did not really start until Seven of Nine seem to forget the Chakotay of season one through three. [Initiations] Chakotay was the main character in the best – perhaps only – really good Kazon episode, in which the commander befriends a Kazon child played by the late Aaron Eisenberg. Chakotay's relationship with Seska is one of the most intriguing parts of the early seasons, beginning as a friendship with a previous romantic backstory to Seska revealing herself as a secret Cardassian to Seska stealing Chakotay's DNA to impregnate herself – OK, that is some weird sci-fi soap opera stuff right there, but it's also hilarious.
AUDIO 4
[Ha ha ha, I stole your junk.] Chakotay has major parts to play in episodes like “Unity” and bizarre fan favorite slash goofy as heck episode “Nemesis” – in which Chakotay is brain-washed into fighting in a conflict against aliens who are clearly just Predators. It's an emotional journey undercut by aliens who look exactly like humans but use synonyms for words we commonly use. [Examples.] Like, I get it, we're seeing indoctrination as Chakotay begins to speak like them, but it's also hard not to laugh. Chakotay and Tuvok have an antagonistic relationship stemming from the fact that Tuvok was a spy posing as a Maquis. Their differing views come to a head in the season three opener in which Tuvok assumes the indigenous people of an alien world are dangerous and cannot be trusted whereas Chakotay tries – successfully – to work with them. The best way to describe Chakotay is that he's just a good dude, and maybe that's not compelling for some people, but I find a character whose traits and actions are defined by his righteousness and decency to be very compelling. It's the same argument that splits people on Superman. Basically, if you don't like Superman, you won't like Chakotay, and if you like Superman, you might like Chakotay. One common complaint about the character is that he is an amalgamation of various Native American tribes and that the consultant for the series was actually a fraud.
It's a genuine drawback to the character, and whether or not Chakotay works as good representation is a matter of some debate among Native Americans Star Trek fans, and I do not feel qualified to offer an opinion. The problem with Chakotay is not Chakotay. When Chakotay is on, he's on. The problem with Chakotay is that there was not enough Chakotay. As the seasons progressed, he became more and more of a supporting character. Compared to other first officers like Will Riker and Kira Nerys, Chakotay does not get a lot of focus. The biggest missed opportunities for Chakotay to break out as a character are probably all the romantic possibilities that the series squandered, the most notable being with Captain Janeway. They had chemistry, their friendship was one of the best relationships in the series. [Now I can't imagine a day without you.] It was teased in a season two episode in which Chakotay and Janeway had to live together on a planet – possibly forever – but nothing came of it. There was also a tease for B'Ellana and Chakotay. One episode confirmed she had feelings for him, but it was never addressed afterward. Poor Chakotay. For him, it will never be pon farr night at the Vulcan night club.
AUDIO 5
[III. KES] Kes is an Ocampan, which means that, like many aliens, she looks exactly like a human except her ears different. Unfortunately, Kes' role in the first season centers around her associations more than herself. She is Neelix's girlfriend. She is The Doctor's friend. Kes doesn't get to do much except be a supporting character at the best of times. By season two, Kes featured in the episode “Elogium” in which Kes needed Neelix to decide very quickly whether or not to be a father due to some sci-fi schenanigans that affected her body. It's a fine episode, but it only reinforced Kes' character as being Neelix's girlfriend. The only ongoing story Kes had in the first two seasons is Neelix being jealous that she was spending time with Tom Paris, and she became more of a prop than a character. Someone for Paris to pine for, someone for Neelix to covet, and someone to exist off-screen while Paris and Neelix sort things out. Kes is not involved in the resolution of the storyline in which she is the conflict. In “Cold Fire” Kes gets some character growth, but after that, it became clear that the writers simply did not know how to write Kes as a character who could be the center of the episode. Unlike the other characters, she is not the head of a department or have any major role on the ship. An episode of The Next Generation starring Commander could simply have him on assignment in a shuttle craft when he encounters danger, but Kes never goes on away missions.
An episode of Deep Space Nine starring Dr. Bashir could start with an unusual medical problem that only he can solve, but Kes is The Doctor's assistant, not the Doctor. An episode centered on Captain Archer could revolve around him making some life or death decision, but Kes is not written to have any kind of authority. Now, the writers could have written her a role that would make her part of the action, but someone made the decision that Kes is a nurse, and that's that. Kes is sweet, kind, compassionate, various other synonyms, and Star Trek fans hate her. Kes hate comes in many flavors. The first is that Trek fans hate the actor's performance, something I have seen many times among the nerds, but they never seem to have any qualms about wooden performances from other Trek actors. The second is that she didn't do anything, but that should be cause for disappointment about lost potential more than hate. The third is that they associate Kes with the pre-Seven of Nine version of Voyager. If Seven of Nine needs a counter-part to always compare them to, it's Kes. Ocampa age quickly, which meant that if Kes would last to season five or six, she would have to wear old woman makeup in every episode. We never got that far. As season three turned to season four, the producers decided either for creative reasons or financial reasons or both, Kes needed to go.
AUDIO 6
She went super-saiyan in season four episode “The Gift” and disappeared forever – until the end of season six when she returned as a villain to destroy Voyager, but then she remembers when she was not filled with hate and learns the true meaning of Christmas, and then she's gone forever again. Kes could have been a lot more than she was, but I will always remember her fondly as a child-woman who ate bugs that one time. [IV. THE EARLY SEASONS] Voyager went through a variety of changes as the series progressed. At the end of the season two, Michael Piller, one of the series' creators, left his role, and Rick Berman and Brannon Braga become even more involved. Character relationships, character emphasis, and even the focus of the series itself changed starting with season three and reached Voyager's “normalcy” by the beginning of season four with the introduction of Seven of Nine. When people think about Voyager, they are more likely to think about this, not this. Voyager in the first two seasons had season long arcs – something that Rick Berman famously despised – and these arcs were gone by season three. The arc is season one is the integration of the Maquis and Starfleet crews into one. Various episodes show the characters initially not getting along, then being given senior staff positions, being instructed by Tuvok.
The arc is season two was about Seska and the Kazon and Chakotay's “donation” to that storyline. Episodes referenced previous episodes and foreshadowed future episodes. It's the basics of peak television in the 21st century but was still new to Star Trek in the 90's. These arcs, these developing relationships made Voyager feel like a home, the crew like a family. Their quarters lived in, their disagreements serious. And then, everything changed. Trek fans today remark on how much better the series became starting with Scorpion, Part I, but when the premise and focus of the series changed, that meant that we would never see what could have been. Kim and Torres stopped being besties. Paris and Torres suddenly had feelings for each other that the series kept insisting began in season one, but there is no real evidence of that or the idea that the writers were setting that up. Seska died in the season three premiere, ending the series' primary antagonist before Voyager was halfway home. Imagine if Q only had Encounter at Farpoint and then two more episodes before pulling the character altogether, not allowing the audience to see his relationship with Picard develop in classic episodes like “Tapestry” and of course the series finale. Imagine if Gul Dukat perished in an explosion in that season three episode of Deep Space Nine when Thomas Riker takes off his sideburns. We would have never seen him in the Dominion or with Ziyal or anything else.
AUDIO 7
Trek fans might scoff at this because Seska was no Dukat, but they didn't really give her a chance to be. She died at the beginning of season three and only returned as a hologram and in a time travel episode in the last season. Voyager switched her out for the Borg Queen as the primary antagonist, a character that might have a more striking aesthetic but without much potential for depth, motivation, and an arc. The Kazon were not much of a threat, but they always seemed more powerful and more cunning with Seska leading them. Season three also largely saw the end of the Vidians, a complex antagonist species that performs unspeakable acts out of desperation to save their culture and their population from a plague. The other notable change in focus after the end of season two is that Maquis are an afterthought. Not the characters – Torres gets a lot of screen time – but the fact that they were Maquis is rarely brought up. They are simply Starfleet officers now. In the crowd-pleasing season three two-parter “Future's End” Chakotay even seems to renounce his former membership in the Maquis. Contrast that with Kira and her days in the Bajoran resistance. In the season three episode “Worst Case Scenario” Tuvok confirms that there are no major disagreements between the Starfleet and Maquis crew members anymore. The premise of the series no longer exists. They are still working toward finding their home, but all of their struggles are external, never internal.
The first three seasons are often dismissed, but there are simply too many good episodes in them, and it's a shame that they are seen with such derision. “Caretaker” is a better pilot than most of what Trek normally gets. Looking at you, Encounter at Farpoint. “Eye of the Needle” is this quiet, desperate story about Voyager trying to convince a Romulan on the other side of a wormhole to help them, and the twist ending is heartbreaking. “State of Flux” with Seska is a fine mystery in which the crew tries to discover who is the spy. “The 37's” is just fun. Voyager finds Amelia Earheart on the other side of the galaxy, and it's played up so sincerely despite the cornball premise. “Projections” really has The Doctor come into this own, as he struggles with his own identity. “Meld” introduces Lon Suder, the best supporting character crew member Voyager gets, and he's played by Brad Dourif. He is a murderer with a redemption arc, and it's very satisfying. It also gives us emotional, creepy Tuvok. [clip] The early seasons also get two of the best Q episodes in all of Trek. The later season Q episode is the worst. “Real Life” with the Doctor's holographic family and “Coda” with Janeway preparing for the afterlife both pack an emotional wallop. I also have strong feelings about “Tuvix” and the ethical conundrum in the episode. My feelings are as follows... [Warning: Memory File Not Found] ...and that's I have to say about Tuvix. The first three seasons, particularly seasons one and two, really are worth re-watching in an era when season-long arcs are more appreciated.
AUDIO 8
[V. TOM PARIS] Tom Paris joins Voyager straight out of prison to hunt down the Maquis. Before that, he was with the Maquis. Before that, he was in a flying accident at Starfleet before covering it up, and before that, he was Nick Locarno. He eventually earns the respect of the Maquis and the respect of Captain Janeway. Opinions on Tom Paris vary so wildly. I have seen Trek fans think of him as a goofy, cringey Space Chandler. I have seen Trek fans think of him as a lovable geek doofus. I have seen people call him the worst and best Voyager character in fairly equal measure. I side with liking Tom Paris – shock, horror. He's a space pirate of privilege who develops as a character throughout the series until he's a dad and a holo-novelist. All that and he gets the best line of all of Star Trek. [“We ate him.”] Paris' biggest weakness is that so few great episodes are those centered solely around him. His starring roles are in “Vis a Vis” which is a basic body swap episode, “Alice” wherein Paris falls in love with a shuttlecraft, and “Threshold” wherein Paris breaks warp 10, becomes a salamander and mates with salamander Janeway. Paris' best central character episode is “Thirty Days”in which he breaks the Prime Directive to save a planet and gets sentenced to the brig and demoted in rank. Hashtag Tom Paris did nothing wrong. Hashtag Free Tom Paris. Paris works best when paired with his eventual wife, like in the famous “I love you” scene from “Day of Honor.”
If Paris gave us one unassailable good, it's the inclusion of Captain Proton. Paris and Kim's holo-adventures are funny and adorable, and they feature Satan's Robot. The best of Captain Proton comes from “Bride of Chaotica” with holodecks gone wrong like they always and Captain Janeway dressing up like this to save everyone. [You're the Queen!] Bride of Chaotica ranks up with “Take Me Out to the Holosuite” and “Trials and Tribble-ations” as the greatest Trek comedy episodes. [“Yes, ma'am. His army of evil.”] Paris may not have too memorable episodes about him, but he does have a lot of memorable moments, like walking down the street in the World War II era France using 20th century lingo, traveling back in time and pretending to be a secret agent to fool Sarah Silverman. It's funny that Tom Paris became the best comic relief character in a series that already came with a pre-packaged designated comic relief character. It's also funny that the pre-packaged comic relief character gets some of the most serious episodes, but I will get to that when I get to that. Paris has father issues. In the episode “Hunters” the crew is preparing to get letters from home for the first time in years. It's an ensemble episode, but Paris is a big part of it. Paris tries not to get his hopes up about hearing from his father, and it's just this very quiet, warm episode that also features the Hirogen. So, what about Tom Paris' wife? [VI. B'ELANNA TORRES]
AUDIO 9
Half human, half Klingon, and the series will constantly remind you about that. B'Elanna Torres is a former Maquis and chief engineer on Voyager. She's characterized by her fiery temper that, again, she blames on being half Klingon. Season one episode “Faces” splits Torres into two women – one human, one Klingon – all the way to season seven episode “Lineage” in which Torres is concerned that her daughter might look like a Klingon. She does get to star in some memorable episodes like “Prototype” in which she befriends an android, and “Dreadnaught” in which she tries to disarm a weapon that she programmed. Torres and Paris fall in love with each other and become a couple very quickly. After nothing in seasons one and two, they suddenly start flirting with each other and coyly antagonizing each other even though they did not have that relationship in years prior. There are references to the crew wondering will they, won't they, but it feels unearned and pays off early in the next season. It's no Niles and Daphne, which started from the beginning of the series and didn't pay off until the end of season seven. Also, while I'm here, there is a lot of crossover between Frasier and Star Trek. Kelsey Grammar is Captain Bateson, but Frasier gets guest stars like Brent Spiner, Patrick Stewart, Robert Picardo, Rene Auberjonois, a cameo by Nana Visitor, and Voyager gets Dan Butler in one episode, so a fine trade-off. Not sure where I'm going with this. Anyway, B'Elanna Torres.
There is an episode of Voyager in which Ensign Vorik is so hornt that he almost dies. “Blood Fever” has Vorik accidentally transmit the pon farr to Torres. For anyone who hasn't watched Star Trek, the pon farr is a chemical imbalance that Vulcans get every seven years that can only be resolved by mating or by ritual combat for some reason. Those two things are nothing alike – usually. How can that happen? Anyway, Torres gotta have it, and Paris is like, not gonna happen, because your judgment is impaired, but then Tuvok is like, no, do it. And then both Vorik and Torres resolve their respective pon farrs by just wailing on each other. It's extremely icky, and since this is the biggest precursor to their relationship, it nearly taints the whole thing. Fortunately, their actual relationship is mostly sweet, they argue, but they're a good pair, and they get married – twice due to some sci-fi hijinks. [Pain sticks. Save that for the honeymoon.] Torres gets some good development over the series, resolving her feelings about her mother and learning to let her walls down so that she can fall in love with Chandler Bing.
[VII. Seven of Nine] Seven of Nine did not “replace” Kes in the way that Dr. Pulaski replaced Dr. Crusher. Seven of Nine did not become an assistant to a holographic doctor and minor character. She became head of astrometrics and arguably the series' star from seasons four through seven. It was more like she was added, very suddenly to boost failing ratings.
AUDIO 10
She became extremely popular and was given a lot of credit for keeping the show afloat. Criticism of Seven of Nine is mostly criticism about how much attention she was given at the expense of other characters. And that's certainly fair. The more the series was about Seven of Nine, the less the series could be about Chakotay, Torres and even Captain Janeway. There are two kinds of Star Trek: Voyager episodes. Episodes the centers around a main character and ensemble episodes in which the entire main cast is working toward solving a problem. In the latter, Seven of Nine began getting more and more screen time compared to the others in the ensemble, and in the former, episodes centered solely around Seven of Nine were a lot more in common that episodes centered solely around Harry Kim. This grew as the series continued. Season four had about four. Season five had about seven. This is a valid complaint, but with all that being said, Seven of Nine is a great character played very well by Jeri Ryan, and she was the star of so many great episodes to think of her as anything but the breakout character of Voyager. “The Scorpion, Part II” obviously, but also “The Raven” when she learns about her parents, “Hope and Fear” when she completes her season arc about humans and Borg. “Drone” when Jeri Ryan says “You are hurting me.” and we all cried? I did, and you did, too.
Seven had great relationships. Captain Janeway, her parental figure, Harry Kim, lost in his perpetual crush that eventually just develops into a friendship, Tuvok, her ally against the emotionals, The Doctor, her mentor, Torres, her frenemy. Remember that time Seven of Nine got rock bottomed by Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson on a martial arts planet run by the Re-Animator? Her aforementioned romance with Chakotay is really the only major low point for her character. Season seven of Star Trek is always a little cursed. The character has serious lasting power, making her one of the few Trek actors to be a main character in two series. Not a supporting character in one and main in another, O'Brien. Although, come to think of it, nearly all of the main cast of The Original Series played their characters as the main cast of The Animated Series. I may have lost the thread. Anyway, Borg. [VIII. BORG] One common complaint among Trek fans who don't like Voyager is that the series ruined the Borg. By “ruined” they usually mean that the Borg were no longer threatening as an antagonist or no longer interesting as a mystery. What once was a species so completely beyond the power of the Federation became a threat on the level of, say, the Romulans – steady, stock antagonists through The Original Series and to a larger extent, The Next Generation. People remember the Borg from The Next Generation as this unstoppable foe – second only to Q – but the Borg were barely in The Next Generation.
AUDIO 11
There's “Q Who?” that acts as a Q episode as much as a Borg episode, the classic “The Best of Both Worlds” two-parter, then “I, Borg” – one of the best Trek episodes – and then the “Descent” two-parter. I would argue that the Borg peaked too soon. After “The Best of Both Worlds” – where do you go? You do a more philosophical episode to humanize them and then you just completely botch it. In “Descent” the Borg were basically a hired goon squad for Lore – Data's evil twin. How does that work, by the way, now that we know the Borg have a Queen? Did the Queen clench her fist at the thought of Lore becoming the local Borg mayor, and she's like, “Give me back my boys!” Star Trek: First Contact better answered the “Where do you go from here?” question following the whole Locutus thing. Time travel. It's ludicrous, and it's great. But after that, it seemed like the Borg really were just another antagonist. The Borg was a top shelf threat right up until the closing credits of First Contact. Voyager didn't have the Scorpion episode until after First Contact. Voyager did not play out the Borg as an antagonist. The TNG series and movie did. It may not have been the best decision to bring back the Borg Queen as the series' new primary antagonist immediately after she got completely wrecked by an old man and new flesh parts Data, but Voyager did not ruin the Borg. They did the only thing left with the antagonist species that can ever be done in Trek. They joined the main cast.
It happened with the Klingons, an antagonist in the Original Series and the main cast of The Next Generation, the Ferengi in the Next Generation getting new life in the main cast of Deep Space Nine. The same happened with the Borg in Voyager. They explored the Borg through Seven of Nine and through Unimatrix Zero. Yes, exploring their culture de-mystified them, but again, after First Contact, they didn't have anywhere else to go. The end result was probably the best character on the series and some a more popular ongoing villain than what Voyager had before: the Kazon. [IX. COMMON COMPLAINTS] Some of the complaints Trek fans have with Voyager tell you a lot about Trek fans. “Why is the number of photon torpedoes so inconsistent?” is an actual, constant whine that has lasted for over twenty years. “Why didn't Voyager take the wormhole in the Gamma Quadrant? It might have saved them a few years off their planned seventy year journey.” Well, allow me to answer these questions with a question. WHO. CARES. They bought or made new torpedoes and they went with the direct space route instead of the wormhole route because wormholes are unstable, and if they traveled for decades to something that might not exist when they get there, they would have wasted half their lives. Also, again, WHO. CARES.
AUDIO 12
[I hope somebody got fired over that blunder.] Minutiae and lore are not plot holes and series-breaking errors. The only Star Trek “canon” I care about the photonic cannon. I do have actual complaints – genuine complaints with Star Trek: Voyager based on what is actually in the series and not how well it adheres to canon or Roddenberry's vision. Voyager did a poor job with its supporting characters. The main cast is very likable and has great chemistry, but the series spent little time on developing supporting, recurring characters, and those that they did were not well-received. Supporting characters in Trek flesh out the world of each series and offer new opportunities for the same characters to emerge and present new challenges. Deep Space Nine had Garak, Nog, Dukat, Weyoun, Winn, and so many more. The Next Generation introduced Q, Guinan, Gowron, Barclay, Lore and more. Voyager, by contrast, reused Q and Barclay, and got rid of Seska, Cullah and Suder in the same episode – the season three premiere. They didn't really do much with Vorik except the aforementioned, extremely gross episode. Afterward, he became a background character like so many nameless ensigns in Star Trek. As the series progressed, various children were introduced – Naomi Wildman and Icheb. Naomi is probably the best child character in all of Star Trek, which is admittedly a low bar, but Icheb is a deeply boring character. I'm sorry, I'm glad his eye got pulled out, I don't care.
Without supporting characters with rich inner lives or memorable personalities, Voyager didn't have that “lived in” feeling to it that, say, Deep Space Nine had, and the series suffered for it. The other complaint is that there were some disastrous episodes. This is true of any Star Trek, but Voyager had some whoppers. “11:59” is often hailed as its worst. Janeway learned that her ancestor was not as important as she once thought, and it played out in a modern day romantic drama. The funny thing is that the scenes on the ship with the crew chatting together about their families were actually really good and had that unmistakable Voyager chemistry. If the episode had been a quiet episode on the ship instead of the story of how someone's car broke down in front of a book store, it might have been salvaged. “Retrospect” feels like the writers were arguing against the Me Too movement twenty years early. Avoid at all costs. “False Profits” is your standard Ferengi episode, meaning obnoxious and painful to watch, proving that only Deep Space Nine seemed capable of writing good Ferengi stories. These episodes along with a few others make for some indefensible stories and moments in Voyager. [X. TUVOK] Hot take: Tuvok is the sassiest Vulcan. [Shall I flog them as well?] Vulcans are always written to be humorless, but Tuvok has such contempt for some characters and such a contentious relationship with the comic relief character that he can't help but be sarcastic – an uncommon trait among his people.
AUDIO 13
I love Tuvok. This is how he dances. Look at him go! Tuvok stars in a lot of Voyager's best episodes. The aforementioned episode “Meld” with Lon Suder is intense and powerful. “Flashback” with Tuvok remembering his time serving under Captain Sulu is not only fan service but actually a compelling story with some funny moments. [You never served me tea.] “Gravity” has Tuvok, Paris and The Doctor stranded on a planet, and Lori Petty falls in love with Tuvok, and it's beautiful. The episode “Innocence” is apparently not well-liked by Trek fans, but Tuvok bonding with children, singing to them and then accompanying them after the episode's twist is revealed really works for me. Tuvok is such a Dad. Tuvok has two major relationships throughout the series: Janeway and Neelix. Tuvok and Janeway are old friends. Their relationship is one of mutual respect but also almost familial comfort. The scene in Endgame between them is so touching and so sad. Trek fans often cite Kirk and Spock or O'Brien and Bashir as the best written friendships in Trek, but Janeway and Tuvok is up there.
And then there's Neelix. [Mr. Vulcan!] Neelix is the comic foil to the serious Tuvok. The relationship actually gets more development than that, though. In the season three episode “Rise” Tuvok and Neelix must work together, and Tuvok's contempt for Neelix is called out and reinforced by a third party onlooker.
“Riddles” from season six is a bit of a mess, as Tuvok has neurological damage that makes him a better friend to Neelix, and honestly, there is too much to unpack here with regards to treating neuroatypical people like children, and I just can't. I can't and won't, moving on. Neelix's last episode is also the resolution of Tuvok's relationship with him, as the wise Vulcan encourages Neelix to save his people, the Talaxians, and admits to Neelix's great variety of skills and leadership qualities. Unlike most of the crew, Tuvok is not given many relationships, but the two that last throughout the series are among Voyager's most memorable. [XI. NEELIX] Neelix is introduced in the pilot as a junk merchant who persuades the Voyager crew to help rescue Kes – unbeknownst to them. Neelix starts off as a kind of con artist with a heart of gold and becomes arguably the most valuable member of the crew. He's the cook, ambassador, morale officer, at time security officer, Neelix can do anything but never so perfectly that he seems “overpowered” – more like a jack of all trades. Neelix was designed to be a comic relief character, but it doesn't take long before the audience realizes that his nervous talking is a side effect of a traumatic life. Neelix's home planet was conquered, his home on the moon annihilated, his sister lost. Neelix has been practically homeless for a long time prior to boarding Voyager.
AUDIO 14
Neelix gets some dark and serious episodes that really allow actor Ethan Phillips to shine. In the episode “Phage” Neelix's organs are harvested by the Vidians, and he asks the Doctor to pull the plug on him. “Jetrel” is not a good episode and has a really problematic resolution in which both the scientist who made the doomsday weapon that destroyed his people and Neelix are portrayed as having a similar level of guilt and responsibility. Nevertheless, it does contain a great performance by Phillips as Neelix. [clip] “Mortal Coil” has Neelix recognize that his religion is false, that there is no afterlife, and that without his faith, his life has no meaning. The episode “Once Upon a Time” is mocked because it's the one with Flotter, but the story is actually extremely serious as Neelix, godfather to Naomi Wildman, struggles with whether or not to tell the young girl that her mother may have been lost on an away mission. [clip] I feel like Star Trek fans have referred to Neelix as a Jar Jar Binks character so many times that it has created a kind of Mandela Effect, misremembering Neelix as a goofy character when he was just as often portrayed as sincere. [...most of all sincere.] Neelix is a great guy and a fine dancer and you know what? Leola root is very nutritious, so shut up about Leola root.
In the first two seasons, Neelix is portrayed as having a character flaw: jealously. This manifested most in his relationship with Kes. However, the series never portrays this character flaw positively, always negatively, and Neelix successfully overcomes it.
Neelix and Kes breaking up is handled rather poorly. Kes breaks up with him while she is under the control of an alien, but the breakup somehow stuck and was never properly explained. I can't defend that and won't try. In the end, Neelix leaves the ship to defend his people from space miners and gets a good send-off. It's a little disappointing that he only gets a cameo in the series finale, but writing him out as the hero of his people made more sense for him. He is the only character who lasts the whole series who had no personal interest in going to Earth. [XII. THE DOCTOR] The Doctor is an emergency medial hologram that, due to the passing of the chief medical officer, takes over responsibilities in sick bay. He begins his life with a terrible bedside manner, but as he becomes more accepted as a real person, that starts to change, particularly in season two episode “Lifesigns” in which he shows a romantic interest in a patient. The Doctor's character growth throughout the series is arguably the best out of the cast that was there from the pilot. The Doctor spends a lot of his time arguing for his own rights, sometimes against the otherwise enlightened Captain Janeway who isn't quite ready to see the Doctor anything more than a tricorder. This contrasts greatly from the relationship between Data and Captain Picard, the latter defending the rights of the former from others in Starfleet, such as in “The Measure of a Man” and “The Offspring.”
AUDIO 15
Janeway, by comparison, plays both supporter of and opposition to The Doctor's rights depending on the situation. It makes the dynamics between them really engaging, even tense, as Janeway holds the keys to his freedom but sometimes stands in his way for reasons of pragmatism. The Doctor stars in some of the best episodes of Voyager. “Message in a Bottle” is behind only “Bride of Chaotica” as Voyager's best comedy episode. The Doctor is sent across the galaxy to deliver a message to Starfleet where he encounters the Mark 2 version of his holographic program. [You're breathing down my neck.] “Living Witness” is easily one of Voyager's best episodes, carried by the Doctor. We are actually seeing a backup file of the Doctor – a duplicate – trying to set the record straight on a planet that traffics in historical misinformation about Voyager. In the end, he leaves for Earth. I did the math on this once, and based on how far in the future this episode takes place and how long a shuttlecraft would take to get back to the Alpha Quadrant, the duplicate Doctor would reach Earth right around the time when the USS Discovery is supposed to get there in season three, and I really want to see that. “Latent Image” is a great mystery episode mixed with a character development episode for The Doctor as he must resolve the fact that he made a decision based on his personal feelings and not his ethical subroutines.
[Author, Author] There are more and more Doctor-centric episodes as the series progresses, partly because the writers must have found him a great character to write for but also because he was a very popular character among Star Trek fans. [Critical Care] The Doctor gets the same criticism as Seven of Nine – too much focus on this character means less focus for other characters – but the audience decided they loved the Doctor. How could they be denied? [XIII. KATHRYN JANEWAY] Captain Kathryn Janeway of the Federation starship Voyager. A scientist, an explorer, and arguably the most controversial character in the series. There are those who love Janeway for her sometimes measured and sometimes forceful approaches to problems and some who have noted that writers trying to write women as “tough” sometimes mistake tough for “mean” and Janeway is sometimes portrayed that way, probably for that reason. Janeway's sometimes erratic behavior is mostly the result of different writers having different takes on her, but the in-universe explanation was delivered by Tuvok in the episode “Night” [Guilt has been her constant companion.] Janeway feels guilty about stranding her crew in the Delta Quadrant. She saved the Ocampa, but her actions not only kept her crew far from home but also indirectly resulted in the demise of many of her crew along the way, including Harry Kim, except they had a spare. It's complicated.
AUDIO 16
With that being said, Janeway under incredible always delivers. In the episode “Scientific Method” her crew was subjected to dangerous medical experiments by aliens, and when one of her crew tragically passed because of this, Janeway was like [This ends now.] and flew Voyager into the sun! The aliens bailed out, but not before one of their ships exploded, presumably vaporizing everyone inside. She can also be fun, though. It depends on who's writing her. [There's coffee in that nebula.] “Counterpoint” is this wild episode in which Janeway trafficked telepathic refugees across alien space and submitted to inspections, like Border Patrol in outer space. She is seduced by the head alien, fooled into thinking he was on her side, but – uh-oh – she tricked him, and it's actually just a very fun episode. Janeway is the star of “Endgame” the series finale. This finale is fine. The bad aspects of the episode are Chakotay and Seven having no chemistry, Neelix only getting a cameo, and the series ending only seconds after Voyager makes it home. Some fans were bothered by that last part, but considering much of the first half of “Endgame” shows what will or at least could happen to the crew following their return anyway, that seems like a minor complaint to me. Future Janeway vs. Present Janeway is compelling because of their differing philosophies, the aforementioned scene with Tuvok is one of the best in the series, and the battle with the Borg mostly...works?
Whether or not the Borg being the final boss of Voyager works for you probably depends on whether or not you liked the Borg in Voyager at all. Anyway, fought a macrovirus, got assimilated, saw the gateway to Hell, still got her crew home. [XIV. CONCLUSION: MORE GOOD THAN BAD] So, why have I been referencing every possible good episode of Voyager and spending so much time on individual characters? Well, because it's related to why I think Voyager is good, actually. In the end, Star Trek: Voyager has more decent-to-good episodes than bad episodes. The good episodes stand out. And the decent episodes, though unremarkable, are populated by likable characters. “Someone to Watch Over Me” may only be a decent episode, but because we care about The Doctor and Seven, seeing him fall in love with her makes the episode engaging. It's a very low stakes episode, but the Doctor is so likable that we want to see him happy, and it's hard watching him fail in the end. The “Flesh and Blood” two-parter is only decent, unspectacular, but it holds attention because of the Doctor and how the crew who felt so close to him react to his betrayal. [Twisted] There are a lot of “only decent” episodes of Voyager, [The Omega Directive] but every decent episode lets us spend time with these characters. The “decent” episodes become more than that. As for the good and even great episodes, I have mentioned a lot of them already, but who can forget Year of Hell?
AUDIO 17
A two-parter with a compelling, complicated antagonist and a kind of micro version of what some people wanted Voyager to be: constantly under threat and barely making it through the quadrant. “Prey” with the Hirogen and Species 8472 was a good one, as was the Hirogen two-parter “The Killing Game.” “Demon” created a second duplicate Voyager, and we got to see them struggle to survive in the heartbreaking episode “Course: Oblivion.” “Relativity” is a fun time travel episode, “Equinox” is Star Trek doing what it does best: pondering morality. “Renaissance Man” is the Doctor at his height, as he evades Tuvok and tries to save the Captain. “The Voyager Conspiracy” is just bonkers but a real crowd favorite. Basically, Seven absorbs too much data and starts to think Voyager being in the Delta Quadrant is either a Starfleet plot or a Maquis plot. “Deadlock” is a great sci-fi premise and a great overall episode. My argument that Voyager is good, actually, is simply that there are too many good episodes. That's it! It's actually not complicated, I just felt that inundating you with classic episodes and moments to make my point. I hope we all learned something. Even some of the “worst” episodes like Threshold are funny. [Pepperoni!] I'm not going to make the argument that Voyager is as good as The Next Generation or Deep Space Nine. That is an uphill battle that I am not prepared to wage. But it's...good? It's pretty good. Justice for Tuvix!
MAGA
I don't know if I have the power to convince fascists to stop being fascists, but I hope I can convince people who are not part of this fascist movement to accept that this is a fascist movement, that we should treat it as a fascist movement, and that avoiding the term “fascism” is unhelpful, even dangerous.
Fascism is an ideology of far-right ultra-nationalism that evokes a mythic past to justify a hierarchy of dominant people in a nation. Said nation is “reborn” under this traditional hierarchy. A fascist movement seeks to establish, legitimize and codify this hierarchy by taking control of political power in the nation – sometimes through force, sometimes through democracy, and sometimes a combination of both. For example, following World War I, Italy's conservative prime minister Giovanni Gioliti formed a coalition with the fascists in hopes of keeping power from the emerging socialists and transforming the fascists into something mainstream and respectable instead of a roving gang. After gaining legitimate power, the fascists marched on Rome, and Benito Mussoulini was declared prime minister, gaining power through illegitimate means. Fascism is an ideology, a movement, but not a form of government. A government can be described as “fascist” the same way a government can be described as, say, “conservative” but “conservatism” is an ideology, not a form of government. A form of government is its shape: monarchy, democracy, aristocracy, and so forth. Fascist regimes do not always share the form of government. For example, both Fascist Italy and Germany were totalitarian states, but only the former was still operating, loosely, within a constitutional monarchy. An ideology can influence the inner workings of the government and sometimes even change the makeup of the government, but it is not a form of government all on its own.
A fascist group is still a fascist group even if it does not currently hold power in government or has not yet changed the structure of government because what makes it a fascist group is its fascist ideology. The fascists in Italy were always fascists even before they took power. An individual or group can espouse an ideology regardless of the ability to personally enforce it. An individual or group can be conservative or liberal or right-libertarian or anarchist or any other ideology regardless of that ideology's current hold on power in the government. This is no less true of fascist ideology. A conservative is still a conservative even if there is a liberal president. With these things in mind, examining fascism as if there is some tangible, well-defined “threshold” in which a regime “achieves fascism” in government would be a mistake. A conservative politician with a conservative base does not cross a “conservative threshold” or “achieve conservatism” once they are elected. They were always conservative. To sum up, and this will be important later, if we accept that fascism is an ideology, then fascists are still fascists regardless of their current grip on power. Fascist movements use different mythic pasts, different scapegoats, but they share other traits. These include traditionalism, the rejection of modernity, hierarchical gender roles, hierarchical in-group and out-group roles, and an obsession with an invented plot against the in-group by the out-group. Italian philosopher Umberto Eco, citing Ludwig Wittgenstein, explained it this way:
AUDIO 2
“The notion of fascism is not unlike Wittgenstein's notion of a game. A game can be either competitive or not, it can require some special skill or none, it can or cannot involve money. Games are different activities that display only some 'family resemblance,' as Wittgenstein put it. Consider the following sequence:
1 2 3 4
abc bcd cde def
Suppose there is a series of political groups in which group one is characterized by the features abc, group two by the features bcd, and so on. Group two is similar to group one since they have two features in common; for the same reasons three is similar to two and four is similar to three. … Fascism became an all-purpose term because one can eliminate from a fascist regime one or more features, and it will still be recognizable as fascist. Take away imperialism from fascism and you still have Franco and Salazar. Take away colonialism and you still have the Balkan fascism of the Ustashes.” There were (and are) a great many fascist movements, some which held power and some which did not, and framing fascism as merely the one or two most well-known examples would be ahistorical and a mistake. Now, with all that understood, the fact that fascism is ultra-nationalism based on a glorification of the past, the fact that fascism is an ideology, not a form of government, the fact fascism is obsessed with traditionalism, hierarchical gender roles, hierarchical in-group and out-group roles, and the fact that one can eliminate from a fascism one or more features, and it will still be recognizably fascist, is MAGA a fascist movement? [I. MAGA]
Well. What is MAGA? MAGA is both a slogan – Make America Great Again – and an ideological movement. Some prefer “Trumpism” as the ideology and MAGA as the movement, and some use the terms interchangeably. For the sake of simplicity, MAGA alone will suffice. Although MAGA has no membership and is more movement than group, its unassailable figurehead is President Donald Trump, who appropriated the phrase from past politicians into something else: right-wing nationalism, preoccupation with a plot, preoccupation with a mythic past, and the formalization of in-groups and out-groups. MAGA as a movement either encompasses or touches upon other related groups and beliefs. QAnon is both a conspiracy theory about a “deep state” effort against Donald Trump and an informal group all its own. The Proud Boys are a men-only, violent far-right gang. Explicitly racist, white nationalist and white supremacist groups, the alt-right and so forth. [Hail Trump, Hail Victory] Much like fascism itself and the game example by Wittgenstein, these groups have some differences in their makeup, ideology and goals, but they all have enough commonalities and a “family resemblance” to be realistically considered to be part of the overall MAGA movement. There is also, undoubtedly, overlap. They all whole-heartedly support Trump. They all “wear the red hat” – sometimes literally but always figuratively.
AUDIO 3
According to Shane Burley, author of Fascism Today, “...these groups can be thought of as concentric circles, movements that are using the same logic as fascism without filling out its entire ideological checklist.” A humiliated nation drawing on a past that does not exist and being promised a return to greatness if they follow a strongman authoritarian is the model of a fascist movement. Trump never explicitly says “when” the United States was “great” – allowing his supporters to draw on a vague past. However, references in his 2016 rallies about his fondness for police brutality against protesters suggests he is referring a time before the end of segregation. The “humiliation” that he claims the nation has felt often came back to Barack Obama. To his predominantly white supporters, the message is clear that they are the victims of the end of segregation, that they are the victims of the first African-American president. This “mythic” past is just that, a fabrication. Segregation was one of many blights on the nation's history, and the president immediately before Obama was widely regarded as one of the worst of all time. The common denominator of these periods is the amount of power in the hands of white America. Labeling politics and political thought under Trump as well as the political movement around Trump as “fascist” causes consternation among political pundits and editorialists – for a variety of reasons.
For one, they don't want to seem alarmist. For another, some are ignorant about what fascism even is, mistakenly believing it only to be only its most extreme incarnation or something that only existed in the first half of the 20thcentury. For another, some are ignorant about the fact that fascist movements form under liberal democracy. “It can't happen here,” is their common refrain, even though this system in this kind of nation is exactly where it commonly happens. And finally, some dismiss MAGA as a fascist movement because they support MAGA, President Trump or the Republican Party, and that term being seen as related to their ideology is something they would choose to avoid. Denial of MAGA and the Trump administration having anything even resembling fascist ideology is self-preservation by conservatives, and yes, outright fascists. No matter what MAGA does, no matter how many fascist symbols they use, no matter how many historically fascist talking points they echo, and no matter how much “us vs. them” fascist rhetoric is uttered by the President of the United States, calling it “fascism” is still forbidden. When red-hat wearing Trump supporters march with people carrying unambiguously fascist flags and regalia, that is still – somehow – notfascist. When Trump calls for refusing to allow a religious group to enter the country, that is still – somehow – notfascist rhetoric. When secret police usher protesters into unmarked vans, this is still – somehow – notreminiscent of how fascists have historically controlled the people.
AUDIO 4
Whenever something occurs that can be described as fascist, the discourse goes thusly: If fascist tactics are successful, MAGA and its defenders claim that such tactics cannot possibly be fascistic if they can co-exist within liberal democracy. If fascist tactics are unsuccessful, MAGA claims that liberal democracy has safeguarded us against fascist tactics and therefore said tactics are not worth worrying about because it's “only fascism if it's successful” – defining fascism by the aforementioned threshold that historically does not exist. The most notable example of this circular argument is President Trump attempting to cancel the election. He has explicitly stated that the election must not take place this year.
Undermining elections and consolidating power are both part of the fascist playbook. Defenders of Trump say that since he is probably unable to do this due to the constitution, any suggestion that this is “fascist” is alarmist. Conversely, if Trump does successfully weaponize the Department of Justice and other departments to cancel the election, those same people will say that he has done so legitimately using the powers of his office and is therefore not fascist. It's a double-speak that allows any action to be defended as “normal” no matter how egregious and no matter its level of success. The existence of structural safeguards to prevent some of the more egregious acts of authoritarianism and common fascist tactics does not change the fact that such tactics have been attempted.
Prevention in the midst of an action does not terminate the existence of the action in the first place. Defeat of fascist tactics also does not change the fact that such tactics were attempted. The Allies winning World War II does not somehow mean that World War II did not happen. In short, using the term “fascism” might be seen as hyperbolic, but at some point, it becomes more absurd to not call it fascism. Too much has happened both inside and outside the White House. Bear in mind that none of this means that everyone who has worn the MAGA hat is a member of a white supremacist organization or that Trump is a day away from extermination camps or anything along those lines. The assertion made here is only that the overall ideology of the MAGA movement and all that touches on that movement can credibly be called fascist, that this label has become more and more credible as the years have gone on, and that the figurehead of said movement employs fascist politics, fascist rhetoric and at times, fascist tactics. It's not a “fascist conspiracy” – nor is it even an elaborate, remarkable plan – it's simply the common result of blunt, uneducated prejudices and values amplified by a strongman who wants to take advantage of them. [II. Racism and Nationalism] Fascism requires the majority to believe themselves the true victims, the true oppressed people, being forced to share power with minorities. To the majority, egalitarianism can feel like oppression. This false “victimization” is accomplished by creating the perception of an in-group and an out-group.
AUDIO 5
“Us vs. them” – emphasizing that the in-group has a right to this country, that the in-group is the creator, the giver, while the out-group has less right or no right to this country, and that they are the takers, the parasites who feed off the creators, the givers. In his very first speech as a presidential candidate, Trump infamously warned his predominantly white supporters of the dangers of Mexicans crossing the border to sexually violate the women of the United States. Apologists for Trump hand wave this as simply being “tough on crime” or some other excuse, ignoring the fact that this is a historically a fascist tactic. According to How Fascism Works by Jason Stanley, “To ensure the right kind of moral panic about these groups, its members are represented as particular kinds of threats to the fascist nation – most important, and most typical, a threat to its purity. Consequently, fascist politics also emphasizes one kind of crime. The basic threat that fascist propaganda uses to raise fear is that members of the targeted group will rape members of the chosen nation, thereby polluting its 'blood.' The threat of mass rape is simultaneously intended as a threat to the patriarchal norms of the fascist state, to the 'manhood' of the nation. The crime of rape is basic to fascist politics because it raises sexual anxiety, and an attendant need for protection of the nation’s manhood by the fascist authority.”
The threat of a non-white, sexually insatiable minority is also something historically used to stoke fear of black Americans preying on white Americans – particularly white women. Because of this, the superficial hierarchy might “American citizens” over “Mexican citizens” but the implied hierarchy based on the rhetoric is white Americans over non-white immigrants. Fascist rhetoric presents the racial majority with the idea that this land is “owed” to them alone and that others exist there only at their discretion. After being elected, Trump invoked “nationalism” in explicit terms. [Nationalism] When nationalism becomes the “ultra-nationalism” inherent in fascism is a matter of debate on degrees, but considering Trump proposed a nearly 2,000 mile, 50 foot wall on the border between the United States and Mexico, claimed that Mexico must pay for the wall, called countries suffering from poverty ****holes, blamed other countries like China for his mistakes, and more, it seems credible to label it something besides the still dangerous but garden variety right-wing nationalism that has long existed among American conservatives. During Trump's campaign, he promised to ban all Muslims from entering the United States. This was widely condemned by anyone who was not part of the MAGA movement and widely applauded by those who were. Apologists for Trump claimed that this was all bluster and that nobody would (or perhaps could) actually do that.
AUDIO 6
One week after his inauguration, Trump signed an executive order banning entry into the United States from seven Muslim-majority countries. Apologists pounced, claiming that Trump had not banned Muslims but merely any foreign national from Muslim-majority countries, but his previous statement that his goal was to ban Muslims specifically strains the credulity of this defense. This ban went back and forth in the courts until the third version of the Muslim ban was upheld in 2018 by the Supreme Court in a close 5 to 4 ruling. The ban and the discourse around it is another example of how those who wish to avoid words like “fascism” paint Trump's actions and his supporters unwavering acceptance. When Trump called for a ban on a religious minority, his detractors rightly cried “fascism” and his supporters claimed that Trump could not enact such a ban. Again, this misunderstands “fascism” as a result and not as an ideology. Then, when Trump enacted the ban, the same supporters shifted what fascism is, that even though the ban went into effect, it was still not fascism because it was enacted within the confines of liberal democracy. By this logic, nothing can ever be fascism if the current institutions endorse it and comply with it. Misidentifying fascism as simply totalitarianism has the intended effect of protecting fascism. In the summer of 2017, a collection of white supremacist and far-right groups, most of which aligned themselves with Trump, marched, rallied, shouted historically fascist slogans, carried fascist banners and flags, and engaged in violence, in one case, fatally.
Following the event, widely called Unite the Right, Trump defended his supporters, called many who marched “very fine people” and blamed those opposed to the fascist rally as having equal blame in the chaos. The resurgence of white supremacist, white supremacist rallies, the acceptability of far-right gangs, are the byproducts of the mainstreaming of fascist rhetoric and fascist politics by Trump. According to the Brookings Institution, “...While some observers have explained Trump’s success as a result of economic anxiety, the data demonstrates that anti-immigrant sentiment, racism, and sexism are much more strongly related to support for Trump. … He did especially well with white people who express sexist views about women and who deny racism exists. … Even more alarmingly, there is a clear correlation between Trump campaign events and incidents of prejudiced violence. FBI data show that since Trump’s election there has been an anomalous spike in hate crimes concentrated in counties where Trump won by larger margins. It was the second-largest uptick in hate crimes in the 25 years for which data are available, second only to the spike after September 11, 2001.”
AUDIO 7
Apologists for Trump and for MAGA at large, knowing that racism and fascism are bedfellows, try to distance the movement from racism by noting that there exists a handful of minorities in important positions within Trump's cabinet and that there was still some small amount of support from racial minorities. However, this is not unusual for a fascist movement. Historically speaking, there are always sell-outs, always turncoats, always people for whom their desire to be accepted by the majority outweighs everything else. The overall makeup of MAGA and their overall fascist ideology cannot be hand waved by the mere existence of outliers. [III. Propaganda, Conspiracy and Fake News] Advancing fascist policy to the people requires the speaker to selectively use terms that are mainstream with the implication of something more extreme. When fascists want to avoid explicitly racial terms but still make a raciststatement, they can use the “suburban” instead of white and “urban” instead of whichever minority is the target. This is only one example of who manipulating language and communication allows fascists to spread extreme rhetoric while still maintaining plausible deniability.
Again, from Jason Stanley, “When propaganda succeeds at twisting ideals against themselves and universities are undermined and condemned as sources of bias, reality itself is cast into doubt. We can’t agree on truth. Fascist politics replaces reasoned debate with fear and anger. When it is successful, its audience is left with a destabilized sense of loss, and a well of mistrust and anger against those who it has been told are responsible for this loss. Fascist politics exchanges reality for the pronouncements of a single individual, or perhaps a political party. Regular and repeated obvious lying is part of the process by which fascist politics destroys the information space. A fascist leader can replace truth with power, ultimately lying without consequence. By replacing the world with a person, fascist politics makes us unable to assess arguments by a common standard.” Trump has created a false reality, and MAGA, writ large, is willing to participate in its maintenance. This false reality operates like this: anything positive said about Trump is “truth-telling” and anything negative said about Trump is “fake news.” Trump co-opted the pre-existing term “fake news” during his campaign, turned it in his favor, and turned it into a response to anything damning about his rhetoric, policies, or personal history. Because of Trump's close relationship with conservative media figures, the term “fake news” propagated and was falsely legitimized by pundits and talking heads.
AUDIO 8
Responding to criticism with the simple phrase “fake news” is a strategy of non-engagement. Rather than discuss the topic or debate the allegations, MAGA dismisses serious, unambiguous misdeeds by Trump by claiming that the misdeeds simply never occurred. If a number of sources report on something Trump did, the sources must be lying. Fake news. If Trump himself said or did something inflammatory on camera, then Trump did not mean it that way. Fake news. We might be able to see it, but the false reality washes it away. It may as well have never happened. Fascist politics cannot hold up to intellectual scrutiny because they are rooted in so many demonstrable lies. A mythic past, a scapegoat enemy, the oppression of the majority, et cetera. Instead of interrogating these lies and judging their veracity, fascists create a new lie on top of the previous lies – a big lie that says that the smaller lies must be true. The big lie is that truth has been manipulated by the opposition to fascism or by the out-group. In this case, Trump's big lie is that anything reported in the media that reflects negatively on him is fake, which allows his smaller lies to be converted to “truth” by MAGA. Believing the big lie is very attractive to people because it means that they know “the real truth” and have seen the world for what it is. The lie is not only attractive, not necessary. They must believe the big lie, because without the big lie on top of the smaller lies, the smaller lies have no protection.
MAGA as a whole would have to concede that their figurehead is actually always lying and that nearly everything said about him was the truth. MAGA's opponents are dumbfounded that so many people can believe quite literally hundreds of thousands of lies, but that is not exactly the case. They only believe one. The big lie. And because it's so attractive and makes them feel so smart, the only lie they need to believe is easily swallowed. In the book Can It Happen Here, Cass R. Sunstein wrote “...if people stop believing in the truth of what they read, they don’t have to think hard about political questions. Instead, they can simply make political decisions based on identity or affiliation with their political allies.”This false reality, this non-belief in truth, has many MAGA devotees searching for their own truth. Enter: QAnon – a far-right conspiracy theory that the Democrats worship the Devil, that Tom Hanks is a child trafficker, that Hollywood actors ingest an imaginary psychedelic liquid harvested from children, that Robert Mueller was actually investigating all of this and not Trump, and that Trump is the only man brave enough to stop it. Every mistake that Trump makes, every misdeed, is part of an elaborate plan to expel the Devil. It's a series of incredible lies upon lies upon lies, but believers are only required to accept one lie: that Q is real. That there is a real individual within the Trump administration delivering this information to the masses and that Q is not just some loser with an account on 4chan.
AUDIO 9
The “big lie” works here, too. When Q makes the odd prediction that turns out to be partially correct, QAnon supporters cite this as evidence that everything else, no matter how absurd, is also correct. When Q frequently makes predictions that turn out to be false, this is merely “fake news” and can be ignored. Criticism emboldens them because they think those criticizing Trump are part of the conspiracy. Criticism therefore does not become evidence against QAnon but evidence of the deep state. Not everyone who identifies with MAGA believes in the Q conspiracy theory or has even heard of it, but everyoneis following a similar pattern. Believing the big lie, and subsequently seeing all criticism as “evidence” of fake news. The false reality of MAGA is so pervasive that QAnon now has high-profile supporters and has recently been endorsed by Trump himself. When confronted with the particulars of the conspiracy theory by a journalist – the Devil, Hollywood, and such – he doubled down. Once again, fascism cannot hold up to scrutiny because it is built on lies, which means greater lies that obscure smaller lies and misdeeds are necessary components in its maintenance. [IV. The Police and the Secret Police] At their best, the modern centralized police force is still an instrument of control that is used as a substitute for meaningful change – armed agents of the state to control the poor instead of support to ease criminogenic conditions.
At their worst, the police force is all those things, plus an instrument of fascism. The police have long served to control dissent against the state. When the head of state is even worse than usual, dissent becomes greater, which requires even greater control. In the midst of protests against the police, Trump vowed to “dominate” the protesters. Trump filled downtown Washington DC with US Marshals, agents from the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the Bureau of Prisons, Marshals, the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, Homeland Security, Customs and Border Protection, Transportation Security Agency, and the Department of Defense. In other words, federal agents, not local police. Without exception, these heavily-armed agents are masked, without badge numbers, without names on their uniforms, without even identification of which department they belong to or who they serve – without any means in which to identify them. For all the inherent problems with local police, they at least display their names and badge numbers, forcing at least some small amount of accountability for officers and their precincts. In the case of this swarm of heavily-armed federal agents, there is not even the appearance of accountability.
AUDIO 10
In the early evening of June 1st, just outside the White House, this swarm of unidentifiable federal agents fired tear gas and rubber pellet grenades to scatter largely peaceful demonstrators. This cleared a path for Trump to walk to St. John’s Church for a brief, three minute photo op. These unidentifiable federal agents also appeared in Portland, San Diego, Las Vegas, New York and other cities. Masked, heavily-armed, unidentified federal agents have been pulling up to protesters and throwing them into unmarked vans. Although some details are still unknown, much of their activities are under the supervision of the Department of Homeland Security, a federal executive department. In other words, due to the enormous power of the executive branch, Trump can call upon this private army and direct it to do almost anything. Apologists for these agents are invariably also apologists for Trump. They say that it is “alarmist” to call them the secret police. However, considering their complete lack of identification, fealty to Trump due to being comprised of federal agents, and tactics including tossing people into unmarked vehicles, it becomes more difficult to avoid calling them the secret police. It becomes a game in which everything “secretive” about what they are doing must be replaced with some other more innocuous word. What else would one call an unidentifiable, secretive entity that serves to control people at the behest of the head of state?
David A. Graham of The Atlantic summarized it this way: “While law enforcement violating civil rights is sadly not new, Trump appears to be trying to do something novel in this country: establishing a force like interior ministries in other countries. … One common tool for an interior ministry is a national police force. That can be a dangerous tool because an armed national police force at the disposal of the central government has a tendency to be misused. A repressive regime that is in danger, or simply faced with protests it finds troublesome, can use the national police to crack down, turning the force into an agency that protects the rulers, rather than one that defends the rule of law. Even in more democratic countries, a national police force can be a threat. In early post-Franco Spain, the Guardia Civil was a hotbed of fascist irredentism. … None of these tasks has much to do with the stated mandates of these agencies or departments – Coast Guard officers aren’t generally trained for riot control – and this is 'homeland security' in only the most general sense. … This is an amateurish way to cobble together a national police force, characteristic of the improvisational authoritarianism of the Trump administration.” A glance at social media during the peak of these incursions saw MAGA-aligned political commentators and random devotees applaud the secret police.
AUDIO 11
No matter how overtly fascist, even to the point of activities that would seem more at home in near-future dystopian fiction than real life, MAGA will deny what is happening, deny its historical similarity to the rise of fascist ideology in other countries, or applaud it as a necessity. The fact that this incredible overreach of executive power is happening to quell Black Lives Matter protesters and allied anti-racist groups should not go unnoticed. A fascist conception of law and order divides people into an in-group and an out-group. The out-group invariably contains the racial minority. The out-group is not only labeled a threat to law and order but a threat to the nation itself, presenting the in-group with an existential threat to themselves and to their cherished homeland. To the in-group, any means used to stop that threat, no matter how egregious, can appear necessary. [V. Conclusion] In spite of everything, there has been no real pushback from MAGA. No pushback from supporters in the media, supporters in the streets, supporters on social media, and worst of all, supporters within these institutions. George Packer of The Atlantic wrote “When Donald Trump came into office, there was a sense that he would be outmatched by the vast government he had just inherited. The new president was impetuous, bottomlessly ignorant, almost chemically inattentive, while the bureaucrats were seasoned, shrewd, protective of themselves and their institutions.
They knew where the levers of power lay and how to use them or prevent the president from doing so. Trump’s White House was chaotic and vicious, unlike anything in American history, but it didn’t really matter as long as 'the adults' were there to wait out the president’s impulses and deflect his worst ideas and discreetly pocket destructive orders lying around on his desk. After three years, the adults have all left the room – saying just about nothing on their way out to alert the country to the peril – while Trump is still there.” In addition to Trump's supporters and his apologists within the far reaches of the MAGA cult, there are above-it-all centrists and satisfied liberals who also dismiss these warnings as “alarmist” and say in unison “It can't happen here.” even as it's happening. They have so much faith in the institutions within liberal democracy even as these institutions are proven time and time again to be easily corruptible. Democracy alone can't save us because our democracy chosethis. Democracy itself opens the door for fascist ideology, not only through corruption. Because anything can “happen here” if roughly half the nation wants it to. There is no pushback against Trump among his own people, which means there is no bottom, no limit to what can be done, and no end to his supporters moving the goal posts to cloud the discourse. They say “This isn't fascism. He's not going to ban a religion from entering the United States,” and then that is basically what has happened.
Liberals say not to worry because the constitution will protect us, but it has not so far! By some estimates, Trump has violated the constitution dozens of times, and nothing has done except an impotent impeachment.
AUDIO 12
And then people say “OK, but it's not fascism, because it's not like he's going to corrupt our institutions and pardon his friends,” and then that's exactlywhat has happened. And then people say “OK, but it's not fascism, because it's not like he's trying to find a way to stay in office past constitutional limits or undermine confidence in the election,” and then that's consistently what has happened. And then people say “OK, but it's not fascism, because it's not like people are getting rounded up by some gestapo style task force,” and so on and so on, ad infinitum. Trump's approval rating might have dipped a little due to the mishandling of the pandemic, but Rasmussen polling shows he still maintains 80% approval among Republicans. That is actually around the lowest it has ever been among Republicans, which means the basement for approval of this movement is still a super-majority of his party. MAGA will never self-reflect and recognize or publicly declare its ideology as fascist. They might not even know why this rhetoric appeals to them – only that it does. As I said in the beginning, I don't intend to convince them to give up their strongman – instead I wish to convince those of us outside their group to stop playing their rhetorical game, accept that their ideology is that of fascism whether they realize it or not, and act accordingly. If we have ever wondered how we would have acted when threatened with an early 20thcentury fascist movement, the answer is however we are acting right now. MAGA does meet most of the touchstones for a fascist movement, as famously outlined by Umberto Eco.
Apologists will always find some other outline, some loophole for why this must not be publicly declared a fascist movement, always purposefully missing the definition of fascist ideology that it need not be identicalto the common perception of fascism in the popular consciousness or meet every commonality, only that it be recognizably fascist and contain the bones of the ideology. People are so afraid to call this what it is for fear of being ostracized as an “alarmist” but those days need to be over.
Every prediction for what a Trump presidency backed by the MAGA movement would look like either came true or ended up being worse than predicted. The “alarmists” were right. People are worried that calling this what it is won't be “helpful” in the discourse, but downplaying what has been happening has not been “helpful” so far. There is no threshold for when fascism officially “happens” – it's an ideology, not a exact structure or a form of government. Any argument that amounts to “Well, this specific thing hasn't happened yet.” is irrelevant. Sell that to someone who has not been paying attention. It is my hope, my sincere hope, that this is the last research essay I will ever write about Donald Trump or the Make America Great Again movement, but that's not up to me. It's up to us.Does all of this end soon, swept away by resistance and conflict like so many other fascist movements, or will fascist ideology be the new normal?