Troy’s Experiences: Too Big For Me (Patreon)
Content
All characters depicted in this story are 18 years of age or older. Everything portrayed is safe, sane, and consensual.
The Cock I Couldn't Take
Okay. I already know what a lot of you are thinking the second you read that title. A cock that Troy couldn't take? Impossible. I have taken plenty and I usually pride myself on being able to handle whatever gets thrown my way. But this one was different. And no, this isn’t some bad experience story or a warning tale. This is a story about a hookup that still gets me hard every single time I think about it. It didn't end with penetration the way I had pictured. It turned into something even filthier, even hotter, and I walked away smiling like an idiot for days afterward.
Let me introduce you to Charlie.
Charlie was 28, slim build, white glasses that made him look like the kind of guy who spends his days buried in code or books. Total nerd vibe. I’ve come to realize I have a serious weakness for that look. The contrast does something to me every time. He stood five foot nine or five foot ten, basically the same height as me. We started talking through one of those Reddit meetup threads. Back then, I would scroll through them sometimes and message guys who seemed interesting and like they might actually want to hook up. I never posted my own ad though. I always figured that app wasn’t the smartest place to find real action.
Then came one of the worst dry spells of my life. I was horny, frustrated, and tired of not meeting people. One night, I said fuck it and wrote a short post. I kept it light and a little teasing. Something about being in a serious dry spell, how I started off shy but got really into it once I had a nice dick in front of me, and how I was looking to make up for lost time. I hit post, threw my phone onto the bed like it might explode, and tried to forget about it.
My phone lit up all night. Messages from guys in the city, from other places, from obvious weirdos I blocked right away. A few conversations felt okay but nothing clicked. By the end of the night, I was disappointed but not shocked. I figured that was the end of it.
Next morning, I woke up scrolling and noticed something odd in my notifications. Back then Reddit had this glitchy thing where some messages showed up there instead of the usual direct message spot. There it was. A single line from a guy I hadn't seen in my regular inbox.
“You want some dick, eh?”
I smiled and typed back. “Wouldn't mind some.”
He replied fast. “Some?. I'll give you some, alright.”
“Cocky much?,” I sent.
“Not at all. Just like guys who get enthusiastic about dick.”
That made me laugh out loud in my empty room. I wrote back. “Let's just say I’ve been starved for a while and a nice dick would make me smile.”
He dropped his Snapchat username immediately. “Add me. I promise to make you smile.”
How romantic. A man offering to make me smile with his dick. Chivalry really has evolved. I added him before I could overthink it.
We moved over to Snapchat and the conversation turned filthy fast. I told him I didn't believe anyone could actually be that big. He didn't argue. He just started sending proof.And guys, that cock did make me smile. It made my mouth water and my hole twitch just from pictures.
The first picture came through soft. It hung heavy and thick between his legs, longer soft than most guys get when they are hard. The head looked fat even then. I stared at my screen and told him no way. He sent another, this time starting to swell. The shaft thickened, veins becoming more obvious. I asked for more, purely for research. He delivered. A side angle that showed the full length. A top down shot that made the girth look unreal. One with his hand wrapped around the base for scale. His fingers didn’t meet. The head flared out wide and smooth. Heavy balls sat underneath. I kept typing one handed while my own cock strained in my shorts.
He stayed cocky but playful. “You sure you can handle this?”
I sent back a picture of my own hard dick for comparison and told him I was willing to try. He replied with a short video of him stroking it slow, getting fully hard. It looked even bigger than the stills. I was leaking onto my stomach by the time we set a day to meet.
The weekend came and I headed to his place with my stomach doing flips. Part of me was excited. Part of me kept wondering if I had lost my mind. That thing was not fucking normal. I kept picturing it and getting hard on the way over.
He opened the door looking exactly like his pictures. Slim, glasses on, casual shirt and shorts. We talked for a few minutes, the air getting thicker between us. I couldn't stop glancing at his crotch. Even soft there was an obvious bulge. Eventually I couldn't hold the question in anymore.
“Don't people stare at you in the gym when you got that thing flopping around?”
He laughed, low and easy. “They do.”
“What do you do about it?” I asked.
He smiled and his hand slid down slowly, resting right over the bulge. He gave it a little squeeze while I watched. “I let them stare.”
My mouth went dry. My cock started to fill out in my pants.
We moved to the bedroom without saying much else. I dropped to my knees on the floor the second the door closed. He stepped in close and looked down at me through those white glasses. He pushed his shorts down and pulled his cock out.
Seeing it in real life, right in front of my face, hit me differently. The pictures had not prepared me for the biggest dick I’d ever seen. Even semi hard it was massive, long and thick with real weight to it. The head flared wide. Veins ran along the shaft. It hung forward like it knew exactly what it was. I reached up and wrapped my fingers around it. They still didn't meet. It felt hot and heavy in my hand, twitching as blood rushed in.
I leaned forward and took the head into my mouth. My lips stretched wide immediately. I swirled my tongue around the smooth head, tasting clean skin and a hint of salt. It hardened fast on my tongue, growing thicker and longer until I had to pull back just to breathe. Spit already dripped down my chin. I tried again, taking as much as I could. My jaw ached. I managed a few inches before the thickness pressed against the back of my throat and I gagged. He moaned above me, one hand resting gently on my head. I bobbed and stroked what I couldn't fit, twisting my wrist and using all the spit I was producing. He got fully hard in my mouth and it was bigger than any picture had shown. It felt like trying to swallow something my body was not built for. I pulled off gasping, thick strings of spit stretching from my lips to his shiny cockhead.
“You are even bigger up close,” I said, voice already rough but with a grin on my face.
“Told you, I’d make you smile,” he answered with a grin.
I went back down, stubborn and turned on. I relaxed my throat and pushed. It went deeper for a second before my body fought back. Spit poured out around the shaft and ran down onto his balls. He stayed patient, letting me work, but I could feel him throbbing harder every time I choked.
After a while he pulled me up. “Get on the bed. On all fours.”
My heart hammered as I climbed up and got into position, ass high, chest low. I heard the condom tear open, the sound of lube being squeezed out. His hands settled on my hips, steady and warm. The blunt head of his cock pressed against my hole. Even with lube it felt enormous. He pushed slowly, so slowly… the pressure built and built until the head finally popped inside.
“Arghh shit,” I hissed into the sheets, my whole body locking up.
He froze right away, one hand rubbing slow circles on my lower back. “All good?”
“The stretch,” I managed. “It's a lot.”
“Breathe for me. Take your time.”
He gave me a full minute, just holding still while I adjusted. Then he pushed forward again, careful—one inch at a time. It felt like he was opening me up in a way I had never felt before. My hole burned in that deep, overwhelming stretch that sits right on the edge of too much. I moaned and pushed back a little, wanting more even while my body resisted. He got maybe halfway in and stopped. The fullness was intense. He pulled back a fraction and rocked forward again, gentle and testing. Still only halfway. He added more lube, the cool liquid helping ease the friction, and tried once more. Same result. Barely past the thick middle of his shaft. My body kept clenching, refusing to open further. Maybe I was too nervous. Maybe he really was just too big for me that night. Either way it wasn’t happening.
He tried one last time, slow and steady, but I felt my limit hit hard. I turned my head. “I am sorry but I don’t think it’s working.”
He pulled out carefully and I heard the condom come off. When I looked back he was still smiling, no trace of frustration. “Don't be sorry. Your mouth seemed to take my cock really well. You want me to fuck your face instead?”
Relief and fresh heat crashed through me at the same time. I grinned and slid off the bed, dropping straight back to my knees on the floor. “Fuck yeah you can.”
He stepped forward. His cock stood straight out, still rock hard, pointing right at my face and shiny from the lube and my earlier spit. I opened my mouth wide and wrapped my lips around the head. This time I knew what I was in for. I relaxed everything and let him take over.
He started slowly, both hands holding my head, feeding me his cock inch by inch. I took what I could until he hit the back of my throat. He paused, letting me breathe around him, then pushed a little deeper. My throat spasmed and I gagged hard, but I stayed right there. Spit flooded my mouth and poured out around his shaft in thick waves, running down my chin and dripping onto my chest.
“Fuck, that’s it,” he groaned. “Open up for me.”
He pulled back until only the head sat on my tongue, then thrust forward again, deeper. I made a wet gawk sound as he pushed into my throat. He repeated it, finding a steady rhythm. Each thrust went a little further. My eyes watered. Drool ran everywhere, coating his cock and balls, making every movement sound filthy and wet. Glug glug glug. My gagging turned into rhythmic gawk gawk noises that only seemed to spur him on. He moaned low and constant above me.
“Jesus, your throat feels insane around my dick.”
I couldn't speak. My mouth and throat were completely full of Charlie’s dick. I kept my hands behind my back like he had told me earlier and just took it. He used that position, one hand on the back of my head, the other under my chin, controlling the angle and pushing deeper with every thrust. He hit a place I had never felt with anyone else. Past the usual resistance, deeper than I thought possible. It felt like he was fucking straight down into my chest. Every time he bottomed out, my nose pressed into his trimmed pubes and I couldn't breathe for a second. The lack of air made everything sharper and hotter. I would choke, pull back when he let me, then nod hard, eyes wet and pleading for more.
He gave it to me. He held my head steady and thrust harder, burying every thick inch over and over. My throat bulged around him. I could feel the outline of his cock moving inside. Spit poured out in steady streams, soaking his balls and running down my chin. The wet sloppy sounds filled the room. Gawk Gawk Glug Glug I was a complete mess and I loved every filthy second of it.
He changed the angle slightly and suddenly sank even deeper. My face was buried in his crotch with no space left between us. His cock was completely buried in my throat, balls resting heavy against my chin. I held there, fighting the urge to pull away, my throat convulsing and squeezing around him. One second. Five seconds. Ten seconds. I reached up and grabbed his ass with both hands, pulling him even closer if that was possible. His cheeks squeezed under my fingers. His thighs started to shake. His whole body went rigid.
Then he broke.
He groaned loud above me, “Jesus fucking christ, dude,” and I felt it. Hot thick pulses of cum shooting straight down my throat. It came in heavy spurts, flooding me so deep I barely tasted the first few. It just kept coming, spurt after spurt, filling my throat and sliding down. I swallowed around him as best I could, my throat working to take every drop. Some of it backed up into my mouth and mixed with all the spit. I held him there as long as I could, struggling for air but not wanting any of it to end. His cock kept twitching, the last weaker spurts still warm as they slid down.
Finally he pulled out. Slowly. So slowly. Inch after thick inch slid out of my throat and then out of my mouth. The fat head left my lips with a wet sound and long strings of spit and cum stretched between us. His cock was completely soaked, shiny and dripping with my drool and a string of his load, still heavy and half hard. I leaned in without thinking and licked the head clean, sucking the last bits of cum and saliva into my mouth. He shuddered hard above me, breathing like he had run miles.
“Fuck, dude,” he panted. “So what if you couldn't take my dick in your ass. You did one hell of a job with that throat. No one has ever taken me that deep before.”
I stood on shaky legs and he pulled me in for a kiss. It was deep and messy, tasting like both of us. He pushed me back onto the bed and climbed over me. His mouth went straight to my cock. I was so worked up from everything that had happened that it barely took any time at all. His tongue and lips worked me until I was shooting down his throat with a broken moan, my whole body shaking.
Afterward we lay there catching our breath and laughing softly about how the night had gone. He was genuinely sweet about the whole thing. No ego. No disappointment. Just two guys who had figured out a way to make something intense and memorable happen.
So that’s the story, guys. The cock I couldn't take. Not in the way I was expecting, anyway. But it claimed my throat completely and I wouldn’t change a single thing about how the night went. Sometimes the best hookups are the ones that don’t follow the plan you had in your head. They turn into something filthier and more satisfying than you expected. Charlie and that monster between his legs taught me that lesson in the best possible way.
If you made it through this without stopping to take care of yourself, I am honestly impressed. Or maybe you did not. Either way I want to hear what you thought of my experience. Drop it in the comments. Ever had a dick that was almost too much but you found another way to worship it until it gave you everything? I want the details. And if you want more of these real stories from me you know exactly where to come find them.
Thanks for reading, guys. Stay filthy.