Rival Rugby Captains 🏉 | 04 (Patreon)
Content
All characters depicted in this story are fictional and 18 years of age or older. Everything portrayed is safe, sane, and consensual.
04 - Prove It, Captain
(Mason Hale’s POV)
I stepped inside Jax Rivera’s apartment and closed the door behind me. This is really fucked up. I’m walking into the apartment of the team captain who beat my team three times in a row. Mason Hale, captain of Northridge University’s rugby side, standing in the home of Jax Rivera from Southgate College. We had been rivals since that first brutal match years ago, knocking heads on the pitch with late hits and trash talk that never quite stayed on the field. Every season the tension between us grew heavier, stares lasting too long, until weeks ago in the sauna, it had finally snapped into something we couldn’t ignore.
This cocky asshole probably wants to boast about being the alpha tonight. That smirk he gave me across the pitch after winning said everything. He’s probably going to fuck me, make me lose control like before.
The apartment was surprisingly clean for someone as arrogant as Jax. Everything in its place, no mess, just a couple of framed team photos on the wall and a rug that actually looked expensive. I kicked off my shoes by the door without thinking. I wasn’t about to give him any reason to bitch about dirt on the carpet later.
I looked around, taking it all in. “Fucking hell, Jax. I didn’t know you had rich parents.” The place was neat as hell, modern and minimal. My eyes landed on one of the photos — Jax celebrating a win, that same cocky grin on his face. I laughed under my breath. What a cocky bastard. Full of himself, narc as hell.
I walked slowly down the short hallway, heart hammering against my ribs. The anticipation was already building, thick and electric. Every step made my cock twitch harder in my trousers. I had spent the entire drive over picturing him sprawled on the bed with that thick cock out, ready to take control the way he always did. The memory of how he had swallowed me weeks ago, proving that thickness could overtake a long dick like mine, kept flashing through my head.
“You're jerking off in there already?” I called out, voice rougher than I meant it to be.
Jax’s voice drifted from down the hall, low and amused. “Something like that.”
I reached the open bedroom door and pushed it wider.
To my surprise, Jax was completely naked on the bed, on all fours, back arched and ass presented toward me. His black hair was still damp. He looked over his shoulder, that signature smirk on his face, eyes dark and steady.
I froze in the doorway. My cock throbbed so hard it almost hurt. I had spent the whole drive imagining him taking me apart again. This was the last thing I expected. But fuck, this man looked good. My hand moved on its own, sliding down to palm the bulge in my trousers. I rubbed once, slowly, and let out a short laugh. “What do we have here, Captain?”
Jax stayed exactly where he was, knees spread, back dipped, black hair falling into his eyes as he looked back. “You keep losing those matches, so I thought I’d give you a reason to keep showing up.”
I let out a shaky breath that was half a laugh. “You’re out of your fucking mind, Rivera.”
Jax’s smirk widened. “Maybe. But you’re still standing there with your dick trying to punch through your trousers, so who’s really the crazy one here?”
I stepped forward slowly. This is fucking unbelievable. Jax’s ass was muscular and round, perfect and presented like an offering. My eyes traced the curve of it, the way his back dipped, the strong lines of his thighs.
Jax smiled over his shoulder. “I know. I’ve got an ass that could make most guys forget their own names.”
I reached out and ran one hand slowly down the curve of his back for the first time. The skin was warm and smooth under my palm. Jax pushed back into the touch like he was daring me to keep going. I stepped even closer, and my bulge brushed right between his ass cheeks through my trousers.
Jax let out a low sound. “Yeah, that’s what I’m talking about, Mase.”
I laughed and pulled back just enough to grab the hem of my shirt. I pulled it off in one motion and tossed it aside. “I’m not complaining, but what the fuck is this?”
Jax looked back at me, eyes dropping to my chest then lower. “Well, our little length versus thickness debate got me thinking. If you were right all along about that long dick of yours…”
My hand moved to my waistband. I shoved my trousers and underwear down in one go. My cock sprang free, seven and a half inches, big and already rock hard, curving slightly upward. The sight of it made my dick twitch even harder in the open air.
Jax’s voice came out lower. “And looking at that… I think you might be right after all.”
I stepped forward completely naked now, my cock heavy between my legs. I reached down and ran my hand over the head once, spreading the precum that had already beaded there. “You sure thickness doesn’t beat length?”
Jax laughed low, the sound rough. “I’m about to find out, aren’t I? Go on, captain. Prove it to me otherwise.”
I moved in closer. My hand slid lower, fingers brushing between his cheeks. Jax made a quiet, hungry sound that went straight to my dick.
“Fuck,” I breathed.
“Yeah,” Jax said, looking back again. “That’s the idea. You gonna keep staring or are you gonna put your big dick to use?”
I smiled and lined my cock up against his pink hole. I spread him open with one hand and pushed the tip in with one slow, deliberate push. Jax’s breath hitched hard. I did it again, slower this time, teasing the head against him, feeling the way his thighs tensed and his muscles fluttered. The neat, cocky captain of Southgate College was on all fours in front of me, and I was the one making him make those sounds. The power of it hit me hard and hot in the chest.
Jax’s voice came out tighter. “That’s it… fuck, Mason. You’re actually good at this when you stop overthinking.”
I pulled back just enough to answer, voice rough. “Shut up and let me get it all the way in.”
Jax laughed, the sound breathless. “Fuck yeah.”
I pushed more inches in slowly, watching the way his body took me. “Is that it or you got more room in there?”
Jax pushed back against me with a low groan. I chuckled and thrust the rest of the way in one smooth, hard push instead of dragging it out. Jax moaned loud, his back arching deeper.
“Want more?” I asked, gripping his hips.
Jax laughed and pushed his ass back harder until it was flush against my body. “Yeah. If you’ve got more.”
“Fuck, you’re tight,” I muttered, holding still for a second, one hand gripping his hip, the other braced on his lower back.
Jax looked back over his shoulder, eyes half-lidded but still smirking. “That’s because nobody’s been fucking me like this. Now fuck me, captain. Show me what three straight losses bought you.”
I started to thrust — slow at first, then deeper, harder. Every time Jax moaned or pushed back against me, something hot and possessive unfurled in my chest. This was the same arrogant rival who had been beating me for years, and now he was taking every inch of my cock and still finding ways to talk shit.
“Harder,” Jax gritted out. “You want to win so bad? Then fuck me like you mean it.”
I snapped my hips forward. The sound was a sharp thwack as skin met skin. Jax groaned loudly. “That’s it… fuck, Hale. Maybe length does have its uses after all.”
I thrust again, harder this time, the slap of my hips against his ass loud in the quiet room. ThwackThwackJax pushed back to meet every stroke, his muscular ass rippling with the force. I reached around and wrapped my hand around his thick cock. It was rock hard, precum leaking steadily from the tip. I stroked him in time with my thrusts.
“Still think thickness is everything?” I asked, voice rough.
Jax laughed, the sound breaking into a moan when I thrust deep. “I don’t know. I just didn’t want your hole to suffer with my thickness.”
I thrust hard, the wet sound of skin on skin filling the room. Jax laughed again, breathless. “Yeah, fuck yeah, bro. That’s it.”
I kept fucking him, driving into him with steady, deep strokes. Jax’s cock throbbed in my hand. His breathing grew ragged. I could feel him getting close, the way his body tightened around me.
He came all of a sudden, thick ropes spilling over my fist and onto the bed. I kept thrusting through it, the bounce of his ass and the ripple of muscle under my hands pushing me higher.
“Looks like the captain lost the jerk off contest this time,” I said, voice tight, still fucking him hard.
Jax stayed cocky even while coming down. “Or maybe tonight’s win got me excited.”
My palm was filled with his cum. I pulled my hand back and my cock out, and looked down at the mess. “The match I lost on purpose?” I rubbed his cum over his hole, then pushed my cock back inside in one smooth thrust. The wet heat of his cum mixed with the tight grip of his body around me made my head spin. The squelching sound every time I thrust was filthy and perfect.
Jax laughed, the sound was rough. “Fuck, I knew it.”
“Yeah, whatever,” I said, thrusting harder now, the wet sound of his cum around my cock driving me crazy. “I prefer this win over a rugby match.”
I fucked him through the mess, the slick heat making every stroke smoother and dirtier. Jax pushed back against me, moaning, still half-hard. I kept going, chasing my own release, the sound of my cock sliding through his cum filling the room. After a few more hard thrusts I came hard, flooding his hole, groaning low as I emptied inside him.
I pulled out slowly, watching my cum leak from him. I gave his ass a sharp spank. Jax rolled over onto his back, exhausted, breathing hard, that cocky smirk still on his face even now.
I stood there for a moment, my cock shiny and softening slowly, breathing hard as I looked down at him. Jax lay naked on the bed, his own cock softening against his stomach, hair messy, skin flushed.
“Not bad for a guy who kept losing on purpose,” Jax said, voice low and amused.
I huffed a laugh, still catching my breath. “You’re still an arrogant prick.”
“Yeah,” Jax answered, voice low. “But you like it.”
He looked up at me, eyes half-lidded. “You wanna stay?”
I started pulling my underwear back up. “I’m not sure if you can handle another round.”
Jax laughed a little, the sound tired but still cocky. “Well, next time you lose, I might be able to handle a second round too… Or I might not. Depends on how well you fuck.”
My chest tightened. I knew I should say something cocky back. Instead I started pulling my shirt on. “And what if I win?”
Jax’s smirk returned, lazy and filthy. “Then maybe I show you how a thick dick feels inside your hole.”
I chuckled, half a laugh, and finished dressing. “We’ll see about that.”
I was already thinking about the next match. Whether I should finally win it… or lose it again. The rivalry had become something else entirely, something addictive and dangerous, and I knew I was already hooked.
I walked out of the bedroom without another word, leaving Jax on the bed behind me. The apartment door clicked shut softly as I stepped into the hallway.
Outside, the night air felt cool against my skin. I headed to my car, mind racing with possibilities. The thought of facing Jax on the pitch again, knowing what could happen after, sent a fresh wave of heat through me. I didn’t know if I’d win or lose next time, but one thing was certain — this wasn’t over. Not by a long shot.
________________________________Rival Rugby Captains 🏉 | 05