Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

All characters depicted in this story are fictional and 18 years of age or older. Everything portrayed is safe, sane, and consensual.

The balcony was quiet at this hour. The kind of quiet that only existed before the city fully woke up. I sat with my legs pulled up on the chair, journal open on my knee, and a half finished cup of coffee cooling beside me. The water below moved in slow silver lines. Somewhere further out a fishing boat cut a thin white trail across the surface.

Matteo was still asleep. Jessica’s door had stayed closed all morning. For once the apartment felt like it belonged only to the two of us.

I turned the page and kept writing.

Journal Entry #142Three weeks. It still didn't feel real. Three weeks of waking up next to the same man I used to watch from across the office and pretend not to. Three weeks of hearing that Sicilian accent say my name in the dark. Three weeks of watching him pull a shirt over those arms and somehow still looking surprised every time I stared.

The same man’s body I used to stare at from a distance when we were just friends was now the body I got to touch. The broad shoulders. The thick muscular arms that flexed when he reached for anything. The solid chest and the way his stomach tightened under my hands. Back then I used to look away too fast, scared someone would notice how long I had been watching. Now I didn’t have to look away at all.

I smiled a little while I wrote it down. It felt strange to put those thoughts on paper now that I was allowed to have them out loud.

Behind me the sliding door opened with a soft scrape.

I didn’t turn around. I already knew the sound of his bare feet on the tile.

Matteo’s hands settled on my shoulders a second later. Warm. Heavy. He leaned down and pressed a slow kiss to the side of my neck, right under my ear.

“Writing about me again?” he asked, voice still rough from sleep.

I closed the journal without rushing and set it on the small table beside the coffee.

“Maybe.”

He made a quiet sound of amusement and moved around the chair so he could sit on the low ledge in front of me. His curls were flattened on one side. He was wearing only a pair of soft grey shorts and nothing else. The early light caught on the lines of his chest and stomach.

“Let me read it,” he said, reaching half heartedly for the journal.

I pulled it further out of reach. “Absolutely not.”

“Why not? I am the main character.”

“You are a supporting character at best,” I said, and he laughed, low and warm.

He rested his forearms on my knees and looked up at me. For a moment neither of us said anything. The city was starting to make soft morning noises below us. A scooter. Someone calling out from a balcony further down the street.

“I like seeing you out here,” Matteo said eventually. “Writing. Looking all thoughtful.”

“I am always thoughtful.”

“You are always overthinking,” he corrected, and then softened it by sliding his hands higher up my thighs. “But I like that too.”

I set the coffee down and reached out to push a curl off his forehead. He leaned into the touch the way he always did now, like he had decided he was allowed to want it.

“Come back to bed,” he said.

“I’ve been awake for an hour.”

“Then come sit with me on the bed and look at me while I pretend to sleep.”

I laughed under my breath. “You are ridiculous.”

“And you are still sitting out here instead of kissing me.”

He said it lightly, but there was something open in his face when he looked at me. Something that still caught me off guard some mornings. Like he was still getting used to the fact that he could ask for things like this out loud.

I stood up, journal in one hand, and let him pull me inside by the wrist. We didn’t make it all the way back to the bed. He stopped me just inside the living room and kissed me against the wall, slow and unhurried, one hand sliding under the back of my shirt. The apartment was still quiet. Jessica’s door stayed closed.

For a few minutes it was only that. The two of us, the early light, and the feeling that we still had time before the day started asking things of us.

We didn’t have time.

By Wednesday the small things had started to pile up.

Jessica left the living room light on all night so that it spilled under Matteo’s door. She moved Matteo’s laptop charger from the kitchen counter to a drawer without saying anything. She made coffee for herself and left the machine empty. None of it was big enough to fight about on its own. Together it felt like sandpaper.

At the office Matteo kept finding reasons to stand too close. In the elevator on Thursday he backed me into the corner the second the doors closed and kissed me like we hadn’t seen each other in days. My hands ended up under his jacket. His mouth tasted like the espresso he had stolen from my desk ten minutes earlier.

“If someone sees us,” I murmured against his mouth, “HR is going to throw me out.”

Matteo smiled and bit my lower lip gently. “Then I will quit in protest. Very dramatic. Very Italian.”

“You’d last three days without a paycheck.”

“I would last three days and then come find you so you could take care of me.”

I shoved at his chest, laughing, and he caught my wrists and kissed me again until the elevator slowed on our floor. We stepped apart just in time. The doors opened on two people from accounting. Matteo’s hand stayed low on my back the entire walk to our desks.

That night the condoms were gone.

Not just the ones from the last few days. The entire stock Matteo had bought two weeks earlier. The big box he had brought home looking very proud of himself, the one he had dropped on the bed and said would last us at least a month if we were careful (which we weren’t). Now the box sat open and completely empty in the nightstand drawer.

Matteo stood in front of it with his hands on his hips, staring down like the empty cardboard had personally insulted him. I was sitting on the edge of the bed pulling off my socks.

“She took them,” he said.

“You don’t know that.”

“There were four left this morning. Now there are none. The box is still here. Only the condoms are missing.” He turned to look at me. “She took them, Adrian.”

I stayed quiet for a second. The irritation in his voice was sharper than usual. Not playful. Not the light annoyance he used when Jessica left dishes in the sink. This was hotter.

“Okay,” I said carefully. “So we’ll buy more tomorrow.”

“That’s not the point.”

“I know.”

He ran a hand through his hair and let out a short breath. “I am getting tired of this. Every day something small. Every day she finds a new way to remind us she is still here.”

I stood up and walked over to him. Resting my hands on his waist, I waited until he looked at me.

“Then stop letting her control the mood of the whole apartment,” I said.

Matteo frowned. “What does that mean?”

“It means if she wants to play games with us, we can play too.” I nodded toward the living room. “We don’t have to hide in here every time we want to touch each other. This is your place as much as it is hers. Maybe more.”

He stared at me for a long moment. Some of the heat in his expression shifted into something else. Interest. A little surprise.

“You want to make out on the couch while she is home,” he said slowly.

“I want her to understand that taking the condoms doesn’t stop anything. If she is going to be petty, she can sit with the consequences.”

Matteo’s mouth curved, not quite a smile. “You are more ruthless than you look.”

“I’ve been patient,” I said. “I am done being patient about this part.”

He kissed me once, hard, and then took my hand.

Jessica was on the far end of the new couch with her laptop open when we walked into the living room. She glanced up, took in the fact that Matteo was only in sweatpants and I was still in the shirt I had worn to the office, and looked back at her screen without comment.

Matteo sat down in the middle of the couch. I sat beside him, closer than necessary. For a minute nothing happened. The television was on low. Some drama with too much yelling. Jessica typed something.

Then Matteo turned his head and kissed me.

It started soft. Almost polite. His hand came up to the side of my neck, thumb brushing under my jaw. I kissed him back the same way, slow and unhurried, like we had all the time in the world and no audience.

Jessica’s typing slowed.

Matteo deepened the kiss. His other hand settled on my thigh, high enough that his fingers pressed into the inseam of my pants. I made a quiet sound against his mouth and felt him smile. He pulled me closer until I was half in his lap, one of my knees between his legs.

The laptop closed with a soft click.

Matteo did not stop. He kissed down to my jaw, then lower, mouth open against the side of my neck while his hand slid higher. I tipped my head back and let him, fingers curling into the fabric of his sweatpants. The sound of the television felt very far away.

“You two are unbelievable,” Jessica said.

Matteo lifted his head just enough to look at her over my shoulder. His voice was calm.

“You took the condoms. We are adapting.”

“I didn’t take anything.”

“Sure.”

He went back to kissing my neck. I laughed under my breath and turned his face so I could kiss him properly again. My hand slipped inside his sweatpants and wrapped around his cock. He made a low, broken sound against my mouth.

“Aaah… Adrian…”

He pulled me fully into his lap so I was straddling him. The position left very little to the imagination.

Jessica stood up.

For a second I thought she was going to argue again. Instead she walked to her bedroom, disappeared for less than a minute, and came back out holding a single condom between two fingers. She dropped it on the television console without looking at either of us.

“There,” she said. “Happy?”

Matteo’s hands tightened on my hips. I felt the shift in him, the way his body went still. Before he could say whatever sharp thing was forming, I spoke first.

“Thank you,” I said evenly. “That was very mature.”

Jessica’s jaw flexed. She looked at me for a long second, something complicated moving behind her eyes, and then she turned and went back into her room. The door shut harder than necessary.

Silence settled over the living room.

Matteo let out a slow breath and dropped his forehead against my collarbone.

“I wanted to say something worse,” he muttered.

“I know.” I ran my fingers through his hair. “That’s why I spoke first.”

He was quiet for a moment. Then he lifted his head and looked at me.

“You are good at this,” he said.

“At what?”

“At stopping me from making things uglier than they need to be.”

I kissed the corner of his mouth. “Someone has to be the calm one. You are very pretty when you are angry… and even hotter when you start speaking Italian.”

He huffed a small laugh and pulled me down so I was lying fully on top of him on the couch. My thighs settled on either side of his hips. The position left almost nothing between us. I could feel how hard he already was through the soft fabric of his sweatpants, thick and pressing right up against me. Matteo’s hands slid down my back and settled on my ass, gripping firmly as he rolled his hips up once, slow and deliberate.

“You like the accent that much?” he asked, voice low.

I kept my expression neutral even as heat moved through me. “It’s fine. Average. Nothing special.”

Matteo smiled like he didn’t believe a word of it. He leaned up and spoke right against my ear, the Italian coming out soft and filthy.

“Mentitore. Ti sento indurire contro di me ogni volta che parlo così.”

Liar. I can feel you hardening against me every time I speak like that.

I bit the inside of my cheek and refused to give him the reaction he wanted. His hands squeezed harder on my ass as he rolled his hips up again, grinding against me with more intent this time. The friction made my breath catch despite myself.

“Still nothing special?” he murmured, switching back to English with a smirk.

“Completely ordinary,” I said, even though my voice had gone a little rough.

Matteo laughed quietly and kissed the side of my neck. “Liar. Your cock just twitched.”

The condom stayed on the television console, untouched. Neither of us moved to take it yet.

Matteo tipped his head back against the couch cushion and looked up at me, eyes dark and playful.

“We could still use it right here,” he said. “Fuck on the couch. Leave the door open. In case Jess wants a better view.”

I kissed him once, slowly, then pulled back and gave him a flat look.

“Don't be an asshole now, Matteo.”

I pushed myself up and off his lap. My legs felt a little unsteady. I walked over to the console, picked up the condom packet, and turned it over between my fingers without opening it.

“You coming,” I asked, glancing back at him, “or should I take this and go back to my place so you can finish arguing with your roommate alone?”

Matteo sat up fast. The lazy playfulness dropped from his face, replaced by something hotter and more focused. He stood in one smooth movement and crossed the space between us. When he reached me he didn’t take the condom. Instead he stepped in close, one hand sliding around to squeeze my ass hard through the office pants I was still wearing.

“You aren’t going anywhere,” he said, voice low and rough against my ear. “Not when you are already this hard from listening to me speak Italian, and not when these pants have been driving me crazy since the office. Turn around and walk to the bedroom, Cole. I am not done with you.”

I held his gaze for a second longer, then turned and started walking toward the hallway. Matteo walked right behind me, hand still squeezing my ass, guiding me forward.

The condom stayed in my hand.

Jessica’s door remained closed.

And for once, neither of us cared if she heard what came next.

────────────────Playing Boyfriends 💋 | Season 2, Episode 5: What She Took

Files

Comments

robert moore

Every word is perfect between them.. Jessica does not stand a chance against them

Stuart

Nice one guys, fight petty with petty. Love it 😁.

Josh

I like these games. Jessica, you’re going down sweetheart. I’m sorry but these two men can play a lot harder than you can. Obviously, since an entire box of condoms is gone like it was never even there. 😜

Lil g

Why condoms? Get tested and go raw. I’m sure Jessica would go nuts. Have them leave the test results out “accidentally.”😂But I do love a petty fight, watching with my popcorn.

StoriesByTroy

Choosing not to use condoms and deciding to have raw sex is going to be a significant milestone in their relationship. Right now, they're still in the early stages, so they use condoms. And I absolutely love the test results idea! I'm definitely going to use that if and when they decide they're ready to stop using condoms. Don't mind me making a note of this for a future episode. 😉

LovingLife

Oh I love this playful dynamic

Boomer

lets get it done then, this condom thing is a ruse!

Jeff M

Given how petty Jessica is being I wouldn't put it past her to put a pin hole in the condom. Though it's not like Adrian is going to get pregnant 😂

StoriesByTroy

Hahahaha. That's just evil xD. Would have worked really well if this was a story about a straight couple.

J

Damn that was hot from the beginning, I love that Jessica thinks she is going to win and the boys prove she will lose

Devin

I don’t understand the condoms? I can’t imagine Italy not having a clinic to test. What would be better than using the condom is to tape it to Jessica’s door with a note: “Jess, thanks for returning one of our four condoms. But you made us think about it and we are so sure of our relationship and our future, we have decided we don’t need them. So we will return the one to you as you’re obviously fucking someone and need them.”

Marcus Eddington

I’ve read just about all of your stories … but this one makes me not want to read anything else since the first season… it’s like they are living real breathing humans and I’m the nosey neighbor watching thur my window…. You really outdid yourself with this story ….. I’m almost afraid any after this won’t measure up!!!! I absolutely love your content !!!!

Frank

I love this banter between the three of them, especially with Adrian and Matteo...love is really in the air!!