Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

All characters depicted in this story are fictional and 18 years of age or older. Everything portrayed is safe, sane, and consensual.

This chapter is written from Adrian’s point of view.Adrian Cole’s POVI should have told him.

That was the first thought I had sitting on the edge of my own bed, in my own apartment, in a quiet that didn’t have Matteo in it. I hadn’t slept. There was no point pretending I would. Not after the kitchen counter. Not after the couch at two in the morning. My head kept going back to whatever happened. Nicolás in underwear. The cup in his hand. The exact second I knew who he was and still turned the morning into a performance instead of a sentence.

I should have said it then.

This is NicolĂĄs. We used to be together. He asked me to go to Madrid. I said no.

I should have said it before Jessica walked in wearing his shirt. Before Matteo came looking for morning snuggles. Before pastries and borrowed shorts and a blowjob I used like an apology I was too much of a coward to speak.

I rubbed both hands over my face and stayed there in the half dark, already dressed in the clothes I had come home in, already late for a night that had refused to end.

That part was on me. Not on Matteo. He had every right to take the pillow and leave the room. Something in his life had taught him that silence in a shared house wasn’t a small thing. I had felt that in the way he looked at me when he said it wasn’t that he didn’t trust me. He never finished the sentence. He didn’t have to. I had put my hand on an old bruise without knowing the shape of it.

I got up and started getting ready for work.

The apartment felt too clean. Too mine. No Vespa helmet by the door. No second coffee cup in the sink. I pulled on a shirt and watched myself do the ordinary things I usually did after Matteo had already texted that he was downstairs. He picked me up most days. I didn’t drive much in this city. I liked the excuse of his body in front of me on the bike, my arms around his waist, the smell of him in the morning air. Today that would have been selfish. I had told him I would give him space. Making him cross Palermo to collect me would have turned the sentence into decoration.

I picked up my phone.

I’ll see you at the office. I’ll drive.

The reply came faster than I expected.

Grazie.

Just that. No baby. No bello. No little joke to make the morning smaller. Thanks.

I locked the screen and stood there until the quiet in the room got loud again. Then I took my keys and left for the office.

─────────He came in twenty minutes after I did.

I heard him before I saw him.

His voice was at the far end of the floor, low, saying good morning to someone by the printer. I was already at my desk with a file open I wasn’t reading. I looked up before I could stop myself.

Matteo in work clothes was still Matteo. White shirt fitted across the chest and arms. Dark trousers. The walk that made people get out of the way without him asking. His curls were messy, like he hadn’t really bothered styling his hair. Then I saw his face properly and the rest of it fell away. He hadn’t slept. Not really. The couch. Nicolás leaving. Dawn in an apartment that had stopped feeling like his. I felt the guilt rise so fast I had to put my hand on the desk to stay in the chair.

He saw me.

I smiled.

He smiled too.

It was real. It was careful. It travelled the length of the office and still died before it became a reason to stand up. I stayed where I was. Space meant space, even when the man I wanted was twenty feet away and looking at me like he hadn’t decided whether coming closer would help or split the day open.

He went to his desk. He sat. He turned on his screen. The office did what offices do. Phones. Keyboards. Someone was laughing too loudly by the kitchen. I worked the way you work when your mind is in another room. Every few minutes I looked up and found the line of his shoulder, the way he rubbed the back of his neck, the fact that he had not rolled his sleeves yet. I wanted to walk over and put my mouth against that neck and tell him I was sorry until the word ran out of meaning. I didn’t.

Near 1:00pm, I stood up because sitting had started to feel like hiding.

He was bent over a printout, pen tapping once against the margin. I stopped beside his chair and waited until he looked up.

“Lunch?” I asked.

Matteo’s eyes moved over my face, then down to the files, then back. He nodded.

“Yeah.”

We walked to the cafeteria without touching. The building was full of other people’s noise. Our silence sat in the middle of it like a third person. He held the door. I muttered thanks. We took a table by the window that we had used a dozen times when the days were easy. Trays. Water. Food I wasn’t going to taste.

For a while we just ate.

It should have been unbearable. It was not, quite. We were still boyfriends. I could feel it in the way he sat angled toward me, in the way his knee came close to mine under the table and stayed there, in the way he didn’t look around the room to see who was watching. He was civil. He was slightly out of reach. That combination hurt more than if he had refused to come.

I set my fork down.

“I’m sorry, Matteo.”

He kept eating, but his eyes lifted.

“I need you to know that I care about you. Only you. I would never hurt you on purpose. You matter to me more than anything I left unsaid in that apartment.”

He chewed, swallowed, and looked at me for a long second like he was checking the words for cracks. Then he reached across the table and put his hand over mine.

The cafeteria kept being a cafeteria. A tray dropped somewhere behind us. Two women at the next table argued about a deadline. His palm was warm and dry and familiar. I turned my hand over so I could hold him back. We sat there in all that noise with our fingers locked on the cheap table and it felt like the first honest thing I had been allowed to have since he walked out of the bedroom with a pillow.

“Just give me some time, Adrian,” he said.

He squeezed once and took his hand away.

I nodded.

“Okay.”

We finished lunch. We threw the rubbish. We walked back upstairs and split at the corridor like colleagues who happened to know the taste of each other’s mouths. The rest of Monday passed in emails and a meeting I contributed two sentences to. Every time I thought about going to his desk I saw his hand leaving mine and stayed put.

At the end of the day, I saw him first.

He was in the lobby by the lifts, phone in his hand, bag over his shoulder. The doors opened. People moved in. He waited, then stepped forward. There was space for me if I walked faster. I didn’t. I stopped by the noticeboard and pretended to read something until the doors closed on him.

If I had got in that lift I would have touched him. I knew it the way I knew my own name. The closed box. The smell of his cologne after a long day. The chance to put my forehead against his and ruin the word space in thirty seconds. He had asked for time. The least I could do was not steal the ride down.

I took the next one alone and drove home to an apartment that didn’t know what to do with me.

─────────Tuesday began with coffee I hadn’t asked for.

I was answering an email when a paper cup appeared beside my keyboard. Matteo’s hand. Matteo’s body close enough that I caught the soap he used. I looked up. He gave me a small smile, the real one, the one that used to come with a kiss stolen behind a door.

“You look like you forgot,” he said.

“I did.”

He tapped the lid once with two fingers, already stepping back.

“Drink it before it goes cold.”

Then he was gone, walking toward his own desk like the kindness had a time limit. I wrapped both hands around the cup and sat there longer than I needed to. It was made the way I liked it. Of course it was. He had been paying attention for months. The fact that he still was should have been comforting. It was. It also made the distance look deliberate instead of cruel, which was almost worse.

We ate in the same part of the cafeteria that day and not at the same table. He sat with two people from his team. I sat with a sandwich I dismantled and didn’t finish. Our eyes met once over someone else’s shoulder. He didn’t look away first. I did, because if I kept looking I was going to get up and sit down next to him in front of the whole floor.

In the elevator that afternoon there were four other people. We stood on opposite sides of the same metal box and watched the numbers fall. His bag brushed my knee when the lift jolted. He murmured sorry. I said it was fine. The doors opened on the ground floor and the moment that could have become a sentence walked out into the lobby and died.

Tuesday night the first text came.

Nicolas: I didn’t want to ruin things with your boyfriend. I’m sorry.

I sat on my sofa with the phone face up on my thigh and stared at it until the screen dimmed. NicolĂĄs. Polite. Careful. A little late. I unlocked the phone. I locked it again. Answering him would have felt like opening a door I had just spent 24 hours trying to keep shut. I put the phone on the table and left the message where it was.

─────────Wednesday Matteo brought a cookie.

It was wrapped in a napkin from the cafĂ© downstairs, the kind with the too sweet chocolate that he always claimed he didn’t like and then finished off my plate. He set it next to my mouse, let his fingers rest on the back of my chair for half a second, and kept walking.

“Matteo,” I said.

He glanced back.

“Later,” he said, not unkindly. “I’ve got a call.”

Later didn’t come. We ended up in the same status meeting instead, passing a document between us like we had not been in each other’s mouths three nights ago. He was good at work when he wanted to be. Focused. Precise. I watched his mouth move around a sentence about timelines and thought about the way that same mouth had gone slack on the kitchen counter. I looked down at my notes and wrote nothing useful.

Another text arrived that afternoon, while I was standing at the printer.

Nicolas: I broke up with Jessica.

I read it twice. The printer spat pages I had already forgotten I needed. Around me the office kept making ordinary sounds. I walked back to my desk with the paper and the message both in my hands and sat down hard.

He had left her.

Or she had left him. The sentence didn’t say. It didn’t matter as much as the fact of it sitting in my pocket while Matteo sat thirty feet away, tired and civil and still bringing me food like care was a language he could use when words were too much. I didn’t reply. I wouldn’t start a private conversation with Nicolás while Matteo was taking time. That was how I had got us here in the first place. A thing said in the wrong room. A thing not said in the right one.

By the time we signed off on Wednesday, the week had turned into a bruise I kept pressing. Coffee. Cookie. A hand across a table. Grazie. Later. I was still his. He was still mine. Neither of us had found the sentence that made the nights easier.I lasted about an hour in my own apartment before I couldn’t keep it in.

The quiet was the problem. No Vespa downstairs. No second plate in the sink. No Matteo on the other end of a look I was allowed to follow. I sat on the sofa with my phone in my hand and hated the feeling of being full of words and having nowhere safe to put them. I couldn’t go back to his place and ask the couch to make room. I couldn’t text Nicolás without turning the week into another secret. I couldn’t send Matteo one more apology and pretend that counted as talking.

There was one other person in Palermo.

Not someone from the office. Not someone who would need the whole story explained from the first fake date. The only other person in this city I trusted with the worst version of me. The one who had seen me smiling through breakups. The one who had watched me fall into Matteo in real time and still told me the truth when I didn’t want it.

I sat up.

Chiara Bellini.

I looked at her name long enough for the week to settle into a single next step. Then I reached for my car keys.

The apartment stayed dark behind me when I left. I locked the door, took the stairs, and sat in the car for a moment with both hands on the wheel before I started the engine. Palermo was quieter than it had been on the drive home from work. That helped. I needed the city to stop asking things of me for twenty minutes.

I drove to Chiara’s the way I used to when everything else in my life had gone sideways and she was the only person who already knew the map. Not to ask her to fix Matteo. Not to talk myself into being the victim. Just to sit in a room that had seen the best of me and the worst of me and tell the week out loud before it turned into another thing I carried alone.────────────────

Playing Boyfriends 💋 | Season 2, Episode 17: The Matteo Thing

Author’s Note

I mentioned this in the community chat last weekend, but for anyone who missed it: Season 2 is planned all the way to the end.

I am really happy with how the later episodes turned out. You are going to like where this goes.

There will be 29 episodes, and then a longer epilogue that closes the series. (So a total of 30 episodes). I know things feel heavy right now. I want you to know that these two love each other. The fight is not “you cheated on me.” It is old, unfinished things from both of their pasts finding a way into the room. Hold on. Enjoy the angst. What comes after is worth it.

I cannot wait to show you the second half of the story.

Thank you for reading.

Files

Comments

Stuart

Oh I would want all the juicy details from Nicolas đŸ€­ but Adrian is right to keep that door firmly closed. We’re all invested in these two and it’s not fun seeing them at odds but it sounds like the ending will be worth going through all the drama.

Executive.Kub

The thought that Jessica read the journal continues to bring up the question
 did she bring Nicolas home - knowingly
 to see if she could put a wedge into Mateo and Adrian’s relationship?

StoriesByTroy

I haven't answered that question in the story. I think it's quite obvious that she did :)

CJ

I really like that they’re giving each other space without completely ignoring each other. Matteo’s gestures with the coffee and cookie were sweet. And smart move on Adrian to not respond to Nicolas. Don’t really know Nicolas but I’m also very glad he got away from Jessica, smart man. Looking forward to Adrian and Chiara hanging out. It’s good that he has someone else he can turn to. I’m curious if Matteo will come clean about the journal once they start to reconcile or if someone else will drop that bomb for him. I’m hoping he fesses up to it but we’ll see.

J

I actually really enjoyed this chapter because they finally talked it wasn’t much spoken but a lot of unspoken and it proves they are still a couple in love. I look forward to the following chapters.

StoriesByTroy

You guys will like Chiara. She has very little presence in the story but does a great job of being a good friend :)

FR

Not really convinced about the way Matteo is handling this. Sure he is entitled to space but you can’t ask for honesty without being honest in return. Lying by omission is still lying. He’s not really protecting Adrian by doing this so curious to see how this is handled.

StoriesByTroy

I think that’s exactly what makes this situation more complicated. There are old wounds here that are influencing why Matteo is reacting the way he is. If you remember the night he saw Adrian with Nic, Matteo himself said, “It’s not that I don’t trust you, Adrian. It’s just
” And that “just” is where a lot of the hurt comes from. There’s more underneath his reaction than simply what happened in the moment. I’m curious to see how you feel about it once everything comes to light. 😉

StoriesByTroy

I’m so glad you enjoyed this one! Sometimes what they don’t say says more than what they actually say. They’re still very much in love, even when things are messy between them, and I really wanted that to come through in this chapter. Thank you for reading and sticking with them! đŸ„č

FR

I get that but relationships are helped by two way conversations and honesty with themselves and each other. Adrian will likely understand and could help Matteo process and resolve trauma too if Matteo lets him in. But we’ll see:)

J

It came through loud and clear at least for me

ACFDuck

The first illustration, of Adrian with his hands to his face, is devastating! The two references to the two of them “knowing the taste of the other’s mouth” tells me that Adrian has imprinted Mateo into his life and soul, Mateo is his foundation. The trick is in how the two of them allow themselves back together, not just in spirit but in fact

Courtney Stancle

We all know she planned this on purpose with the intent to cause issues in Matteo and Adrian relationship but Adrian not telling Matteo as soon as he found out is what actually caused the problem. Can’t wait to see what eventually happens to Jessica
.

Courtney Stancle

The fact that Adrian has not blocked his ex or set any boundaries after all this blew up means Adrian has some unresolved issues with his ex he needs to address. Not necessarily by talking to Nic but by actually acknowledging and addressing it with himself.